This video surprised me, I expected the usual from the last 2, Nancy comes back, she teams up with some other villain, someone gets kidnapped, there's a chase, Nancy dies again, and a vehicle goes Kaboom, but this was something different and unexpected, kudos to Logan for breaking the mold
Absolutely phenomenal. Well done to Logan and the crew, this video was spectacular. I'm genuinely surprised about the dark themes they've used to built up all of the characters here. I get they aren't for everyone but its stuff like this that really makes stories memorable and great.
THIS…. this proves to me that Logan can still dish out quality, if he put the time and effort into it! This is probably one of my new favorite SML videos ever, and the last time a video has ever achieved that was before 2020 💀
Yeah, Nate Fleming tried to use it as a sympathy card to attack Marvin even though he's gotten Marvin beat up, arrested, locked out of his own house, attacked by sharks, and caused him to have to go through plastic surgery.
Right with you, I only watch modern videos every now and then and typically it’ll just be ones that people who’ve already watched it are actually bearable to watch. But I watched 20th Birthday without knowing anything hoping it would be better than last year and I loved it
this has to be an 11 out of 10 for me. dare i say one of the greatest sml movies of all time. i'm an absolute sucker for dark/psychological horror sml. hell, it felt like a nitroplus visual novel at times from how dark it was. i have a love-hate relationship with jeffy but this video made me respect him as a character a lot more. jeffy protecting feebee from his mom and cj was also super heartwarming.
@@bwmpii_yt like yea I know he’s a critic but he goes overboard with the whining and complaining I’ve seen him complain over the ones majority of people like
It clears up why Jacques didn’t want anything to do with Jeffy even after faking his death. Still don’t agree with that decision of bringing him back but at least this video somewhat makes up for it
10/10! So much better than 18th and 19th birthday 100%. Logan cooked up some SERIOUS Jeffy lore. I actually felt bad for Jeffy and Feebee. It explains so much about Jeffy’s personality because Nancy gave him a tragic childhood. And why Jacques Pierre François wanted nothing to do with Jeffy. Hopefully it gives everyone character development. This is hands down the BEST video of August.
Now I at first thought this was gonna be ANOTHER Nancy somehow returns, but I was surprised it turns out to be a flashback expansion on Jeffry’s prior life. I didn’t know what to think initially but I ended up liking how it expanded Jeffry’s attitude and why he’s physically strong despite his character cause he’s defensive by instinct. I guessed how Jaque got her pregnant by the only way he would, and I liked the ending giving Jeffy another piece of closure. So for another big Jeffy birthday, it’s probably my favorite one in a while. 8/10, but I hope we can go back to more laid back Jeffy birthdays.
The best SML video I've seen in a VERY long time. I never thought Logan would ever put out a video or a storyline in general that would ever make me like Jeffy, let alone feel sorry for him, but God damn he did it! Easily a 9/10 video, the only reason I'm docking a point is because I kinda thought the first scene with Jeffy opening presents was a bit dumb and dull. Aside from that though, absolutely amazing and Logan cooked up some great lore here.
10/10 BY FAR my favorite Jeffy birthday video (yes, I enjoyed it more than 18th). This video gave both Jeffy and Feebee a very detailed and well-made backstory. The segments with it were really entertaining to watch and were honestly both sympathetic towards Jeffy and Feebee and really funny in fucked-up ways. CJ was also a very enjoyable new character, and I loved the reveal of him being Mr. Winkle's brother, that shit was hella clever. Let's not forget the ending where Jeffy ties that mf to a monster truck to avenge Feebee, which was fucking badass. The fact that they WRECKED A HOUSE for that scene just made it all the more epic. Mario, Rosalina and BTG were also pretty good here. Overall, this was fucking fantastic and it's currently my favorite video of the year. Great job, Logan. Great job indeed
The Feebee and CJ part was way darker than Mario being raped by Bubbles (the season 1 version) and that was (in my opinion) the darkest thing in SML to date well until now
First, 10 out of 10, I’m not Joking or Pulling anyone’s Limbs here, this might be the Best of the Jeffy’s Birthday Specials and it has elements to Jeffy’s Parents, Hell this is the Type of Video Logan hasn’t Properly Done in Years with Moments that are Emotional, Dark, Twisted, and Depressing and I didn’t had hope for this as I didn’t thought there was any story Left for Jeffy but I was Wrong, No Wonder Jacques hates Jeffy as he’s literally a reminder to what Nancy has done to him just to be Rich that it makes sense why he did this Art Scheme not made out of Love, Lust, or even Pressure, it was all about Greed(Plus I find it crazy how the Day Jeffy was Conceived was almost close to the Date of my Birth), it also makes Sense on Feebee being Jeffy’s Half Brother as Nancy is literally a Female Dog on the Streets and that her Gene Pool is the reason why her Children are “Complex” other than the Unstable Food, Alcohol, and Cigarettes she does on her Daily Diet and Neutrians, CJ is a Interesting Addition to say the least although things went Sour when it was revealed what he did to Feebee and the shocking part is that he’s a Winkle, especially David’s Brother, honestly that Gene Pool is worse than Nancy which made the Monster Truck Scene so Satisfying in the End especially since I got Omni-Man and Homelander Vibes from their Train and Plane Fatalities, although while the Characters were Good and the Crew did a Fantastic Job on the Acting and Logan once again proved that he’s best when it comes to Editing Scenes, Brooklyn was kinda Fine and Kinda Filler that I would have given this Video a Lower Score and part of me wanted Feebee to return as someone Permanent in SML as it would bring New Life for SML, heck LBM made a Good Point as Nancy didn’t know about the Will Jacques made as she did Abandoned Jeffy and an Another Retcon of she giving Birth to him on a Portap0ttie but the Video was so well made and paced this is probably the Best Video of the Year so Far.
Ngl it is better than the last two birthday vids. It’s impressive. Minus the filler with Brooklyn Guy because he just kinda ruins the mood each time they cutaway from the flashback. Also the missed opportunity to make Jeffy a changed character, and the ending abruptly ends (not the monster truck scene, that’s cool). Not a bad video, at least I can give credit to Logan for trying something impressive. But overall I do not mean to be mood killer here but after watching the video I think it is impressive but then I realized it’s SML because this is the same channel that made the last video full of rape jokes from Cody and here’s the latest video which is a huge whiplash. I don’t have high expectations from the channel since they will continue to upload more mediocre slop anyways with just a few diamond in the rough videos. Overall the video it’s impressive, that’s the credit I can give to Logan. Yeah it is dark way dark which I think UA-cam will age restricted this video.
Well Jeffys Parents used child abuse (another sensitive topic) to build onto Jeffy when they also had gags like Bowser and Junior's entire dynamic. In the end, I believe its his channel and humor. They are definitely allowed to change their approach depending on the story and message they want to tell.
@@Scholing223its not like in modern SML terms since nowadays they treat most of the sensitive topics as jokes. This video is literally a whiplash when seeing the previous video.
I wasn’t mad at the Brooklyn guy stuff, I thought it would be worse but it was more on purpose to break that much tension since they don’t wanna get too serious
Brother wat lmao? The Brooklyn segments aren’t filler (please stop spamming this word on every video) his birthday mixed with jeffys is a ongoing plot set up in every birthday video, and he’s literally called to help jeffy out after hearing the backstory’s, Jeffy changing as character while it would be cool would feel rlly forced and 100% wouldn’t get addressed again, and just bc 1 context resets rape comedic doesn’t mean another context can’t go in depth and be emotional . I promise you’re not getting a video of this quality again there’s no reason to try and find negative points just enjoy the video lol.
6:45 that's what happened when my former girlfriend drugged me an abused me and tricked me into her having a kid (Don't asked me how it happened too many painful memories)
I haven’t finished this reaction, but I’d argue that this was one of the best SML videos of all time. It sucks, knowing that he’s probably gonna say it’s “decent enough I guess” and give it a 2 out of 10 just because it’s modern SML or whatever.
There’s even a deleted video that shows the way Nancy makes money. She records certain types of videos. It was probably deleted because it was too comedic and messed with the tone.
Sml has had pretty grotesque gore and stuff before but this was WAYYY darker compared to that. Secret Door has nothing on this. It's like how the difference between normal horror and dark fantasy is that in dark fantasy all the terrible things are just part of your everyday life. 8.5 or even 9/10 video
Secret Door was pretty underwhelming when you put all the details together after watching. Would’ve liked it better if other characters appeared other than the typical Mario, Rosalina, and Jeffy dynamic and the whole brother reveal was lame in my opinion. This video though, it was freaking amazing. I don’t even watch modern SML very much but I went in just hoping it would be better than last years birthday video and it exceeded all expectations. Hopefully Logan can put out more quality videos after this
Wow, this video was actually pretty good. I was expecting it to be the same as the last 2 birthday videos, but this one wasn't too bad. I wasn't expecting the video to be this dark and depressing. I actually felt bad for Jeffy and Feebee. It also showcases how much of a great brother Jeffy was to Feebee. Especially when he got his revenge on CJ twice. As of right now it's one of my favorite SML videos of the year.
This video was really dark in And sad but yet I feel like it’s one of the best reading and executed episodes of this month let alone this year feels like the only episode Logan actually cared about in the Laurel was pretty nice to Aldo pretty dark overall I would say it’s about 8.5/10 for modern SML standards.
This actually might be the only Jeffy Birthday special that I liked. Pretty much explains the backstory. Although I don’t like Jeffy, there are occasions that I actually feel bad for him, example includes Jeffy Parents. I say a solid 8/10 because Brooklyn Guy kinda ruined the cake. Although I may not like him, there is one thing he actually does, has a good heart for others. As in his backstory he actually cares for his sister when she was being abused. Very detailed backstory and actually explains a lot of Jeffy’s childhood and Feebee’s childhood. Very creative and very descent.
Despite the series is currently on a critical slump, this episode was a big surprise I didn't saw coming. In a way, this is the channel's puss in boots 2 where nobody would expect it would be this dark and almost intense in quite a long while!!! Everyone made sure to get it right
Logan can make good content still from this video he just needs to show more interest and take his time with his videos and then every video can be a masterpiece if he did that and I wish that sometimes he would make dark videos like this
This is some weird deep and disturbing lore building, but oddly the rare diamond in the rough from Logan. Just watch next video is buy the jeffy yootooz! Also just watch Mr. Winkle being an officer never mentioned again.
This was a actually great vid for a few reasons #1: its surprising dark which i like cus sml never does vids like that #2: they made me sympathize with Jacque more cus he never wanted a kid #3: the fact they made feebee a s€x toy is shockingly dark and unexpected And #4 the ending where jeffy kills cj and crashes through the house was amazing Definitely the best vid of the month
I don’t get how some people hated this, sure it wasn’t some crazy truck explosion thing and just some added lore, but was still good nonetheless, they’re probably saving all that for his 21st birthday.
Wow they did it, they fucking did it. Let me just say this is probably my favorite SML video. Not my favorite SML Video from the “puppet era” not my favorite Jeffy video but my favorite SML video EVER. I love a good dark story, especially one that “humanizes” so to speak a charector. There were parts of this that made my jaw drop even, especially that one part. Now it’s not perfect but it may be getting a 9-9.5 out of me.
I expected this to just be some dumb "Nancy comes back and is a ghost or something now" but holy hell this was dark. Most of the stuff in this video has been portrayed in SML movies before but never in such a dark light.
Ngl even though I still don’t like jeffy and I can’t really say I sympathize with him after everything he done And I definitely wasn’t really looking forward to this video This was still a great video And probably the best SML video in recent years
When Feebee was first introduced, I thought she was just a terrible gender bent version of Jeffy. She's only appeared in three videos, and with each video, her character gets more and more tragic. Like it's bad enough, she died at a very young age, but she was also a victim of sexual assault. Jesus Christ let's hope Feebee is in a better place because fucking hell...
As good as the video was, I have to admit at times the dark parts felt a bit forced, and I'm not sure if the actors are experienced enough with more serious scenes. The video definitely did a good job making Jeffy a likable protagonist though, even if just for this video.
The next video quality went so down for summer school part 3 which is the finale was nothing but a bunch of stupid jokes and filler. At least it put me to sleep.
This video was decent just sucks that Brooklyn Guy had to be selfish and take over the video near the end. I get it was his birthday too but he doesn’t need to act like an a$$hole
Man I HOPE UA-cam doesn’t pull this bc for once Logan isn’t even making “dark humor.” So much as he is telling a serious backstory and making sure u know the shit that happened to jeffy is serious trauma, only poking fun at it for comedic relief not for hehe giggles, like some of his other haha hang myself jokes. Not that I have a problem with that kinda dark humor, but this story takes itself surprisingly seriously and I think pulling this off yt is story censorship of what kinda stories we can tell WAY more than it is UA-cam saying “don’t make fun of xyz” cuz he’s not, Jerry’s backstory is treated with respect not humor. NOW if this happens to get age restricted that would honestly be fair bc this is really damn dark and for a young kid to accidentally watch this would be a bit alarming especially since Logan put up no warning before hand which HE REALLY SHOULD HAVE THIS TIME, not just for kids but anyone sensitive to this kinda content, but I hope if that does happen Logan still keeps the video up. And IF it does get pulled, DAB QUICK, reupload it to sml reuploaded!
yeah this video was pretty good overall and I didnt thin they wee going to go that dark with it especially with CJ and how its potrayed since its ussally Its potrayed for Comedy helped by the fact Mr.winkle is stopped before he does anything ussually.
I see you got high reaction dabhdude, though keep in mind it won't be high rank trilogy, especially when you remember both Jeffy's 18th, 19th, and 20th, will have a bad aftermath, and it will be expectations of defunct of mixed, so yeah, let's see if you dabhdude and supermwrionic will do a collab.
Try to make me sympathize with Jeffy all you want SML, but I’ll never do it. We all know how this works. SML will do a sad story for Jeffy, but next episode he’s gonna revert back to his selfish, obnoxious, egotistical self just like every character. Now, kids have seen jokes that involved child abuse, sexual assault, rape, basically mature level stuff.
That’s why you keep your expectations low with SML especially nowadays. Don’t like modern SML much or Jeffy but this was a masterpiece. And to be fair, wouldn’t be shocked if kids had saw some of that stuff before this video came out considering how they’re almost always on the internet
@@DDDiego I admit, this video is somewhat good. As for the second thing, basically some parents are just being too lazy to raise their kids right and let tablets, smartphones, and the internet to do the parenting for them.
Logan forgot, typical. And also forgot that Jeffy got his name written on his shirt in Jeffy’s Parents yet he already has it in this video. His likely excuse? “He had another yellow shirt with his name on it when he was younger.”
This video surprised me, I expected the usual from the last 2, Nancy comes back, she teams up with some other villain, someone gets kidnapped, there's a chase, Nancy dies again, and a vehicle goes Kaboom, but this was something different and unexpected, kudos to Logan for breaking the mold
Same
Thank God this wasn’t a rehash the last one was so repetitive
This is the most sympathetic I’ve felt for Jeffy since Jeffy’s Parents or Jeffy’s Sister Returns.
Maybe we were too hard on Phoebe, she saw everything
@@danielgudinojuarez6729 Her name is pronounced like that
This video was just DARK, like holy cow the last video I remember going this level of insane was the secret door
The secret door was way more dark
@@Cloverthexoolno it wasn’t two people literally got r*ped in this video
@@Cloverthexool I think the secret for was just shock value while this actually adds to the story and sheds light on how they were raised
@@Cloverthexool Objectively not true
For me, before this, it was Junior's 8th birthday
Absolutely phenomenal. Well done to Logan and the crew, this video was spectacular.
I'm genuinely surprised about the dark themes they've used to built up all of the characters here. I get they aren't for everyone but its stuff like this that really makes stories memorable and great.
9/10 The tonal whiplash made the video a bit jarring at times, but it was a fantastic way to fully reveal Jeffy’s backstory.
THIS…. this proves to me that Logan can still dish out quality, if he put the time and effort into it! This is probably one of my new favorite SML videos ever, and the last time a video has ever achieved that was before 2020 💀
Absolutely
It may have been another "sympathy for Jeffy" video, but I really liked it. It was dark, twisted, and destructive
Yeah, Nate Fleming tried to use it as a sympathy card to attack Marvin even though he's gotten Marvin beat up, arrested, locked out of his own house, attacked by sharks, and caused him to have to go through plastic surgery.
and actually humanizes Jeffy a bit with how he seemed to genuienly care about feebee.
@@XavierDonaldCaliburdudes always been a meat rider for jeffy
@@XavierDonaldCalibur Are all the SML videos with the Nintendo plushies still canon?
@@XavierDonaldCaliburI don’t even bother with his videos, stopped watching him a long time ago he’s annoying
I hate modern sml, jeffy, and birthday specials, yet this managed to be one of my favorite videos they’ve ever made
Agreed
Right with you, I only watch modern videos every now and then and typically it’ll just be ones that people who’ve already watched it are actually bearable to watch. But I watched 20th Birthday without knowing anything hoping it would be better than last year and I loved it
wow you hate everything
@@WelchGuyy’all are nostalgia blinded as fuck
@@lamontharper6653 What it actually had a good story
this has to be an 11 out of 10 for me. dare i say one of the greatest sml movies of all time. i'm an absolute sucker for dark/psychological horror sml. hell, it felt like a nitroplus visual novel at times from how dark it was. i have a love-hate relationship with jeffy but this video made me respect him as a character a lot more.
jeffy protecting feebee from his mom and cj was also super heartwarming.
It really is a top 5 video oat
Dab going through character development he actually didn’t complain the whole video and liked it congrats your taking a big step
Love to see it
@@thearachnid7779 Frfr
Tbh it's probably cus this vid is the best modern Sml has been in a long while
@@bwmpii_yt like yea I know he’s a critic but he goes overboard with the whining and complaining I’ve seen him complain over the ones majority of people like
this was actually one of the best sml movies i’ve ever seen and even though jeffy can be an ass sometimes, he really does have a good heart
It clears up why Jacques didn’t want anything to do with Jeffy even after faking his death. Still don’t agree with that decision of bringing him back but at least this video somewhat makes up for it
Oh yea this video was good 9/10 i actually really like how they didn't actually make nancy come back and just showed jeffys back story
Holy crap this is was good. Dude when they wanna be storytellers, they really know how to knock it out of the park.
10/10!
So much better than 18th and 19th birthday 100%. Logan cooked up some SERIOUS Jeffy lore. I actually felt bad for Jeffy and Feebee. It explains so much about Jeffy’s personality because Nancy gave him a tragic childhood. And why Jacques Pierre François wanted nothing to do with Jeffy. Hopefully it gives everyone character development. This is hands down the BEST video of August.
And the best video of the puppet era
If they ever do more flashbacks I think they should have Goodman Cop or Goodman Doctor again, would be nostalgic
Now I at first thought this was gonna be ANOTHER Nancy somehow returns, but I was surprised it turns out to be a flashback expansion on Jeffry’s prior life. I didn’t know what to think initially but I ended up liking how it expanded Jeffry’s attitude and why he’s physically strong despite his character cause he’s defensive by instinct. I guessed how Jaque got her pregnant by the only way he would, and I liked the ending giving Jeffy another piece of closure. So for another big Jeffy birthday, it’s probably my favorite one in a while. 8/10, but I hope we can go back to more laid back Jeffy birthdays.
Next year is 21 so hopefully it will be a fun birthday video where Jeffy just gets drunk or gambles
The best SML video I've seen in a VERY long time. I never thought Logan would ever put out a video or a storyline in general that would ever make me like Jeffy, let alone feel sorry for him, but God damn he did it!
Easily a 9/10 video, the only reason I'm docking a point is because I kinda thought the first scene with Jeffy opening presents was a bit dumb and dull. Aside from that though, absolutely amazing and Logan cooked up some great lore here.
We are definitely seeing jeffy vs mr.winkle in the afterschool series cause jeffy did just kill his brother
though I kinda doubt it sine sml has very loose contunity though though especially with How Jeffy doesent seem to remember mr.winkle at all.
@@jadenbryant9283he was wearing a hat and none of the other kids remember him either
@@storm7603 yeah but junior and Cody and Joeseph tend to recoginize him.
SML needs to do more emotional stuff like this
this video singlehandedly carried august without question ez 10/10
this maybe the most Depressing and DARKEST SML Video ever
there is so much backstory and lore in this video and it's good
Makes me wonder how GameCubeDude would've reacted to this. His Jeffy's Parents reaction would not match it.
10/10 BY FAR my favorite Jeffy birthday video (yes, I enjoyed it more than 18th). This video gave both Jeffy and Feebee a very detailed and well-made backstory. The segments with it were really entertaining to watch and were honestly both sympathetic towards Jeffy and Feebee and really funny in fucked-up ways. CJ was also a very enjoyable new character, and I loved the reveal of him being Mr. Winkle's brother, that shit was hella clever. Let's not forget the ending where Jeffy ties that mf to a monster truck to avenge Feebee, which was fucking badass. The fact that they WRECKED A HOUSE for that scene just made it all the more epic. Mario, Rosalina and BTG were also pretty good here.
Overall, this was fucking fantastic and it's currently my favorite video of the year. Great job, Logan. Great job indeed
The Sonic Origins? More like The Jeffy Origins
You know the vids dark when Dab starts rooting for Jeffy
The Feebee and CJ part was way darker than Mario being raped by Bubbles (the season 1 version) and that was (in my opinion) the darkest thing in SML to date well until now
Either that or Jr’s whole Military School stent. But at the time it was when people hated Jr.
Feebee: Why mommy Why 😭
Jeffy: it’s ok Mr giraffe feebee will be back soon😥
Bro that broke my heart💔
The scene were jeffy crashes through the house is really funny to me.
I almost pissed myself seeing that giraffe because I literally had that same toy as a baby.
how did that make you feel?
First, 10 out of 10, I’m not Joking or Pulling anyone’s Limbs here, this might be the Best of the Jeffy’s Birthday Specials and it has elements to Jeffy’s Parents, Hell this is the Type of Video Logan hasn’t Properly Done in Years with Moments that are Emotional, Dark, Twisted, and Depressing and I didn’t had hope for this as I didn’t thought there was any story Left for Jeffy but I was Wrong, No Wonder Jacques hates Jeffy as he’s literally a reminder to what Nancy has done to him just to be Rich that it makes sense why he did this Art Scheme not made out of Love, Lust, or even Pressure, it was all about Greed(Plus I find it crazy how the Day Jeffy was Conceived was almost close to the Date of my Birth), it also makes Sense on Feebee being Jeffy’s Half Brother as Nancy is literally a Female Dog on the Streets and that her Gene Pool is the reason why her Children are “Complex” other than the Unstable Food, Alcohol, and Cigarettes she does on her Daily Diet and Neutrians, CJ is a Interesting Addition to say the least although things went Sour when it was revealed what he did to Feebee and the shocking part is that he’s a Winkle, especially David’s Brother, honestly that Gene Pool is worse than Nancy which made the Monster Truck Scene so Satisfying in the End especially since I got Omni-Man and Homelander Vibes from their Train and Plane Fatalities, although while the Characters were Good and the Crew did a Fantastic Job on the Acting and Logan once again proved that he’s best when it comes to Editing Scenes, Brooklyn was kinda Fine and Kinda Filler that I would have given this Video a Lower Score and part of me wanted Feebee to return as someone Permanent in SML as it would bring New Life for SML, heck LBM made a Good Point as Nancy didn’t know about the Will Jacques made as she did Abandoned Jeffy and an Another Retcon of she giving Birth to him on a Portap0ttie but the Video was so well made and paced this is probably the Best Video of the Year so Far.
Dude fuckin wrote an essay
@@jeremyreyes1817 Yeah and?
@@jessicaruizcollazo2372”Yeah and? 🤓”
@@TedRocketLeague Hilarious
Dude wrote a whole book 💀
Can’t wait for him to hate it and give it a -1/10
Edit: nvm he enjoyed it
@@andrezest character development
@@CaptainSoySauce69Love to see it
Still gave it a 8/10. Like atleast give it a 9.5
@@coastercloudyhe said that at the LEAST it was an 8/10, meaning that he would be willing to give it a higher mark. 🤓
Ngl it is better than the last two birthday vids. It’s impressive. Minus the filler with Brooklyn Guy because he just kinda ruins the mood each time they cutaway from the flashback. Also the missed opportunity to make Jeffy a changed character, and the ending abruptly ends (not the monster truck scene, that’s cool).
Not a bad video, at least I can give credit to Logan for trying something impressive.
But overall I do not mean to be mood killer here but after watching the video I think it is impressive but then I realized it’s SML because this is the same channel that made the last video full of rape jokes from Cody and here’s the latest video which is a huge whiplash.
I don’t have high expectations from the channel since they will continue to upload more mediocre slop anyways with just a few diamond in the rough videos.
Overall the video it’s impressive, that’s the credit I can give to Logan. Yeah it is dark way dark which I think UA-cam will age restricted this video.
Well Jeffys Parents used child abuse (another sensitive topic) to build onto Jeffy when they also had gags like Bowser and Junior's entire dynamic.
In the end, I believe its his channel and humor. They are definitely allowed to change their approach depending on the story and message they want to tell.
@@Scholing223its not like in modern SML terms since nowadays they treat most of the sensitive topics as jokes. This video is literally a whiplash when seeing the previous video.
I wasn’t mad at the Brooklyn guy stuff, I thought it would be worse but it was more on purpose to break that much tension since they don’t wanna get too serious
@@Volonidyeah I get what they go for but also Brooklyn Guy tends to act like a jerk when people didn’t celebrate his birthday.
Brother wat lmao? The Brooklyn segments aren’t filler (please stop spamming this word on every video) his birthday mixed with jeffys is a ongoing plot set up in every birthday video, and he’s literally called to help jeffy out after hearing the backstory’s, Jeffy changing as character while it would be cool would feel rlly forced and 100% wouldn’t get addressed again, and just bc 1 context resets rape comedic doesn’t mean another context can’t go in depth and be emotional . I promise you’re not getting a video of this quality again there’s no reason to try and find negative points just enjoy the video lol.
6:45 that's what happened when my former girlfriend drugged me an abused me and tricked me into her having a kid (Don't asked me how it happened too many painful memories)
ooh yikes sorry that happened man
Damn I'm so sorry that happened to you
Best Jeffy Birthday Video Ever 10 out of 10
I haven’t finished this reaction, but I’d argue that this was one of the best SML videos of all time. It sucks, knowing that he’s probably gonna say it’s “decent enough I guess” and give it a 2 out of 10 just because it’s modern SML or whatever.
Damn Nic made his reaction before you did
Well at least it was better then Jeffy's 19th birthday when it was a rehash of Jeffy's 18th birthday
There’s even a deleted video that shows the way Nancy makes money. She records certain types of videos. It was probably deleted because it was too comedic and messed with the tone.
Was it released
Logan actually can make something good when he isn't stupid
Sml has had pretty grotesque gore and stuff before but this was WAYYY darker compared to that. Secret Door has nothing on this. It's like how the difference between normal horror and dark fantasy is that in dark fantasy all the terrible things are just part of your everyday life. 8.5 or even 9/10 video
Secret Door was pretty underwhelming when you put all the details together after watching. Would’ve liked it better if other characters appeared other than the typical Mario, Rosalina, and Jeffy dynamic and the whole brother reveal was lame in my opinion. This video though, it was freaking amazing. I don’t even watch modern SML very much but I went in just hoping it would be better than last years birthday video and it exceeded all expectations. Hopefully Logan can put out more quality videos after this
4:16 I thought the same thing lol
Wow, this video was actually pretty good. I was expecting it to be the same as the last 2 birthday videos, but this one wasn't too bad. I wasn't expecting the video to be this dark and depressing. I actually felt bad for Jeffy and Feebee. It also showcases how much of a great brother Jeffy was to Feebee. Especially when he got his revenge on CJ twice. As of right now it's one of my favorite SML videos of the year.
This video was really dark in And sad but yet I feel like it’s one of the best reading and executed episodes of this month let alone this year feels like the only episode Logan actually cared about in the Laurel was pretty nice to Aldo pretty dark overall I would say it’s about 8.5/10 for modern SML standards.
Seems like the deus-ex-machina fairy for Jeffy Birthday videos was shot dead. On a more serious note, well done, Logan. 8/10
This was Amazing
cant wait to watch him say “its decent” (i was wrong)
This actually might be the only Jeffy Birthday special that I liked. Pretty much explains the backstory. Although I don’t like Jeffy, there are occasions that I actually feel bad for him, example includes Jeffy Parents. I say a solid 8/10 because Brooklyn Guy kinda ruined the cake. Although I may not like him, there is one thing he actually does, has a good heart for others. As in his backstory he actually cares for his sister when she was being abused. Very detailed backstory and actually explains a lot of Jeffy’s childhood and Feebee’s childhood. Very creative and very descent.
Despite the series is currently on a critical slump, this episode was a big surprise I didn't saw coming. In a way, this is the channel's puss in boots 2 where nobody would expect it would be this dark and almost intense in quite a long while!!! Everyone made sure to get it right
Not gonna lie, this was amazing. I love this video for it’s dark and sad story. The only negative is the new FeeBee puppet. 9/10
LOGAN COOKED!!!🔥🔥🔥
6:35 am i the only one that noticed jacques arm is ripped open?
why didnt the timecode shit work
This was dark even for SML but it was so good. First 10/10 in awhile.
damn this video had BALLS! lol.
Logan can make good content still from this video he just needs to show more interest and take his time with his videos and then every video can be a masterpiece if he did that and I wish that sometimes he would make dark videos like this
I honestly thought this woould be bad but it turned out to be interesting and pretty decent
Same here
This is some weird deep and disturbing lore building, but oddly the rare diamond in the rough from Logan. Just watch next video is buy the jeffy yootooz!
Also just watch Mr. Winkle being an officer never mentioned again.
Who knows if we’ll see Mr Winkle ever mention his brother in any other videos, he likely won’t
Finally, the critics finally liked a Jeffy video😂
See kids, taking your time, and thinking out your episodes creates cinema.
I think this SML movie was pretty good.
This was a actually great vid for a few reasons
#1: its surprising dark which i like cus sml never does vids like that
#2: they made me sympathize with Jacque more cus he never wanted a kid
#3: the fact they made feebee a s€x toy is shockingly dark and unexpected
And #4 the ending where jeffy kills cj and crashes through the house was amazing
Definitely the best vid of the month
I don’t get how some people hated this, sure it wasn’t some crazy truck explosion thing and just some added lore, but was still good nonetheless, they’re probably saving all that for his 21st birthday.
Wow they did it, they fucking did it. Let me just say this is probably my favorite SML video. Not my favorite SML Video from the “puppet era” not my favorite Jeffy video but my favorite SML video EVER. I love a good dark story, especially one that “humanizes” so to speak a charector. There were parts of this that made my jaw drop even, especially that one part. Now it’s not perfect but it may be getting a 9-9.5 out of me.
Ngl this was a 9 out of 10 for me
I expected this to just be some dumb "Nancy comes back and is a ghost or something now" but holy hell this was dark. Most of the stuff in this video has been portrayed in SML movies before but never in such a dark light.
This felt like Unmortricken from rick and morty being Unapologetic Backstory with no reason or shame that brings lose plots together.
Now that’s how you deal with your trauma!
Ngl even though I still don’t like jeffy and I can’t really say I sympathize with him after everything he done
And I definitely wasn’t really looking forward to this video
This was still a great video
And probably the best SML video in recent years
i'm glad the nancy stuff was just flashbacks because i was really scared they were gonna bring feebee back
I guess the goal of this was to make the mother look as horrible as possible and yeah they did a pretty good damn job of that lol.
25:27 - Monster Jam wishes yo
When Feebee was first introduced, I thought she was just a terrible gender bent version of Jeffy. She's only appeared in three videos, and with each video, her character gets more and more tragic. Like it's bad enough, she died at a very young age, but she was also a victim of sexual assault. Jesus Christ let's hope Feebee is in a better place because fucking hell...
As good as the video was, I have to admit at times the dark parts felt a bit forced, and I'm not sure if the actors are experienced enough with more serious scenes.
The video definitely did a good job making Jeffy a likable protagonist though, even if just for this video.
The next video quality went so down for summer school part 3 which is the finale was nothing but a bunch of stupid jokes and filler. At least it put me to sleep.
This video was decent just sucks that Brooklyn Guy had to be selfish and take over the video near the end. I get it was his birthday too but he doesn’t need to act like an a$$hole
FAX!!!
100% agree.
Fr
BTG is the main reason why I’m giving this video a 9/10. If he toned it down a bit with his antics then it would’ve been a perfect score
19:14 Still funny till this day, sorry chat. 😂
This is honestly the best SML Movie of the year
Agreed
Man I HOPE UA-cam doesn’t pull this bc for once Logan isn’t even making “dark humor.” So much as he is telling a serious backstory and making sure u know the shit that happened to jeffy is serious trauma, only poking fun at it for comedic relief not for hehe giggles, like some of his other haha hang myself jokes.
Not that I have a problem with that kinda dark humor, but this story takes itself surprisingly seriously and I think pulling this off yt is story censorship of what kinda stories we can tell WAY more than it is UA-cam saying “don’t make fun of xyz” cuz he’s not, Jerry’s backstory is treated with respect not humor.
NOW if this happens to get age restricted that would honestly be fair bc this is really damn dark and for a young kid to accidentally watch this would be a bit alarming especially since Logan put up no warning before hand which HE REALLY SHOULD HAVE THIS TIME, not just for kids but anyone sensitive to this kinda content, but I hope if that does happen Logan still keeps the video up.
And IF it does get pulled, DAB QUICK, reupload it to sml reuploaded!
The scene where Jeffy is separated from feebee made me cry
Bro's reaction in every sml video gets on my nerves 💀🤷🏻♂️
Good to know Logan can make amazing video's if he.. you know actually gave a shit.
7:10 he is not ready 😭
yeah this video was pretty good overall and I didnt thin they wee going to go that dark with it especially with CJ and how its potrayed since its ussally Its potrayed for Comedy helped by the fact Mr.winkle is stopped before he does anything ussually.
I see you got high reaction dabhdude, though keep in mind it won't be high rank trilogy, especially when you remember both Jeffy's 18th, 19th, and 20th, will have a bad aftermath, and it will be expectations of defunct of mixed, so yeah, let's see if you dabhdude and supermwrionic will do a collab.
Try to make me sympathize with Jeffy all you want SML, but I’ll never do it. We all know how this works. SML will do a sad story for Jeffy, but next episode he’s gonna revert back to his selfish, obnoxious, egotistical self just like every character.
Now, kids have seen jokes that involved child abuse, sexual assault, rape, basically mature level stuff.
That’s why you keep your expectations low with SML especially nowadays. Don’t like modern SML much or Jeffy but this was a masterpiece. And to be fair, wouldn’t be shocked if kids had saw some of that stuff before this video came out considering how they’re almost always on the internet
@@DDDiego I admit, this video is somewhat good. As for the second thing, basically some parents are just being too lazy to raise their kids right and let tablets, smartphones, and the internet to do the parenting for them.
*YES! WE'RE GOING TO THE CRACKHOUSE!!*
An actually great video
Honestly I’d say this was good, just, good, take a guess what lowered it
The cutting back to Brooklyn guy, rose and Marvin and Brooklyn complaining about Marvin not remembering his birthday?
@@gavin5724Oh my, how did you know?
HE BETTER NOT SAY ITS DECENT
He better not have an opinion!!! 😡
@@moved8416 No because this dude genuinely has shit opinions
Ok if you’re gonna act like this tell that to all the other comments saying it was decent
@@bestworstyoutuber Because you disagree with it?
@@moved8416 yes damn this dude makes good points but still why the hell are you in all the comments dissing dab like damn
Coming next year
Jeffy 21
CJ COMES BACK TO LIFE OH NO
I don’t know how anybody can take Jeffy seriously
2:03 yes it’s flour and or sugar
say what you want about jeffy, but he is probably the sml character with the most tragic backstory
well next year will be jeffy 21th birtday
it will be biggest video ever i think
19:02 Well I'd remembered Jeffy's Sister that got run over by a Truck that is most messed up Shit I've ever seen in SML
18:50 pretty much explains Why Jeffy HATES GreenBeans
I mean Jeffy said right after it was a lie
Who knows, they may pull a Rick and Morty on us. I'm counting this as canon for now
@@mediamuncher69 They literally said right after that it wasn’t true. Jeffy admitted it was just him not liking green beans
Erm actually Nancy gave birth to jeffy in a porta potty🤓🤓🤓
Logan forgot, typical. And also forgot that Jeffy got his name written on his shirt in Jeffy’s Parents yet he already has it in this video. His likely excuse? “He had another yellow shirt with his name on it when he was younger.”
LateHdude is back
The dude ain’t a robot cut him some slack
@@moved8416 alright fine
For once Dab enjoy a Jeffy video
He likes to dab
good