Hyunjin was actually on time (exactly like the track) For me he also sounded the same as he usually do, it’s just that he is trying a different tone in his voice 🥰
@lemonssssssss4 well that's a personal preference, doesnt have anything to do with the person's capabilities. He was perfectly on time and did his part as he was directed
Actually hyunjin didn't miss the beat, listen to the studio version again, he's right on time. Also I personally think hyunjin sound the same, but I love your honesty because that's what makes you genuine, thank you for your reaction!!
So many comments about Hyunjin but I ll say it as well) He sounds absolutely perfect and on time) I listen to this song like 5 times a day , the only thing that is different is the music arrangement! Being Hyunjin biased I follow his singing carefully , and he improved so much overall
I also listen to this song all the time 😂 I was questioning everything when he said it was off LOL And I also thought Hyunjin’s singing actually sounded better this time? Idk I liked it a lot!
@@nickel8026 haha i get it , but honestly i dont say it coz he is my bias , im the first one to notice when he is off) I have a music background so i can differentiate it well, and here, he sounds amazing
@@elinak1009 ah that’s awesome I wish I had a music background! And I can agree, I’ve thought he was off a couple times before but thought it was great here!
This song is really beautiful, Changbin wrote it, everyone made it beautiful, i loved it and Hyunjin did it in a timely manner, maybe what confused you was the arrangement they used for first take, but everything was fine, greetings and thanks for continuing to react to the guys♡
Seo Changbin! - the rapper who wrote a song that makes a singer want to sing it. . Changbin's vocal was so hevenly and beautiful! And Seungmin voice is so strong!
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. That being said; I think I.N's voice suits the Japanese language really well, and maybe that's the reason why he's shining in this album like the maknae on top star he is. And he's obviously maturing, getting more sure of himself, and working hard on his vocals.
In the studio version that part where you thought Hyunjin was late it's actually delayed like that on the track. You think it's gunna come and it doesn't until the next beat just like he sung it. The end of that phrase is supposed to end as the chorus came in, so he was perfectly on time. He did well in this I thought.
Hyunjin wasn't late at all actually. That's where he is supposed to sing. His line is supposed to stop right as the beat starts again. That's how it was arranged.
Binnie writes the best heartbreak/love songs ❤️ like Ex or Sorry, I love you! But Teddy I have to agree with the comments, Hyunjin respected the original time and tone of the song 🤔
Hyunjin sounds perfect here.. I love how hyunjin has power to use his voice acc to the vibe of the song like he sounds honey laced in some songs, in hot songs he uses his raspy and lazy tone and he can go deep too
Hyunjin was on time and it's exactly as the studio version lol I've only heard this kind of delay after the "drop" in a Spanish-speaking indie band, so it was fascinating for me, cuz it made it so familiar and nostalgic 👌 Also, I think you're not that familiar with their soft side hahaha you should check more if you want, so you can get used to their soft vocals hahaha
Its funny but Hyunjin surprised me this time, he did it very very well and I love how he managed his voice. But what I like from you Teddy is that you're genuine, you don't hesitate to say your impressions and thoughts, that's why we all love you ;)
I dont think Hyunjin's voice sounds different than normal. In the beginning he sounds very quiet tho, to me it seems like he is nervous. The last part he sings is done beautifully and towards the end of the sentence he sings a little more nasally. He hasnt really had a note at that height that wasnt sung in headvoice so its his first time we hear his mixed voice I believe. You dont hear that a lot, if ever, from him. At least thats what it sounds like to me. And the prechorus part with IN, like you said, the instrumental sounds very loud compared to their voices. They couldve mixed it a bit better in my opinion. But I love the video nontheless. :)
I've been a stay for almost 2 years and i do think Hyunjin sounded a little different than usual! But he sang beautifully! And yeah I agree the instrumental was a little too loud.
Unfortunately, the mixing is set prior to their recording, as is the instrumentals volume. That's the one of the rules of the first take, there is absolutely no post production... So, whoever set the mixers (specially for Hyunjin) didn't set it correctly. I know it's not the members that get to do that, with kpop groups it never is. It's the stage team who goes over it all with them during sound check, and asks them what all needs to be done. So yeah, sadly the team setting the mixers and choosing the volume of the backing tack messed this up a bit for all of them. And of course, Hyunjin singing in a mixed voice is new to him and considering he's still developing his vocals, i didn't expect perfect. I'm more upset about the backing track volume. You should never have to fight the backing track. And here, because their headphones are working like in-ears, they likely aren't even aware of the issue until afterwards or at the very least... near the end. So they wouldn't have even known they needed to make themselves louder. It's times like this when the artist really depends on the studio staff to get things right on their end, or else the end result is flawed. They know the vocal volume and projection that the song SHOULD require, but in this situation, there is a good chance they were none the wiser about the volume error until it was too late.
Hyun sounded just fine to me? That's the vocal tone for this song and perhaps that's what's throwing some people off. He was indeed on beat and all of SKZ did great :) The mix is quite loud this time and they should've turned it down a bit if anything.
hyunjin was on time, it was exactly like how the audio version. it sounded tricky, yes, but he was perfectly on time. his voice as well was progressing, thus he sounded just like he usually does, and better! i suggest, maybe you can listen to the audio track more then listen to the first take one after that. thank you, anyway, for trying to point it out ☺👍🏼
Hyunjin sounded perfect actually surprising this time on first take and so on time didn’t miss a beat though the music arrangement is different! Or at least you’d think he’s improvising or trying a different sound of him instead of saying he’s missing a beat, I guess you know how professional he is to miss a beat and BTW you’re the only one who said such a thing not even vocal coaches said that, which tells a lot I think
My opinion on Hyunjin's performance here was that when he sang at first, it definitely did sound different than the original(originals kinda softer), but it wasn't a bad difference imo. I also think that he was perfectly on time with the drop(and i think he might've also been counting it, too). And yes, after Teddy commented on hyunjin in this performance, I went back and forth comparing this and the studio version
Thank you. This is an amazing song. Hyunjin sounded good. Because this is a first take. it wont be exactly as the audio version. But he was on time. Changbin ending verse sounded more off to me than Hyunjin. At least they got all the lyrics this time, not like Bang Chan who missed ABC part of EFG line in Case 143 first take. LOL Here is what is listed on the official song. Composer, Lyricist: CHANGBIN (3RACHA), Lyricist: SUNNY BOY, Arranger, Composer: BANGCHAN (3RACHA), Arranger, Composer: Versachoi
Thank you so much i thought the same 👌Teddy disappointed me actually i didn’t expect this way to express his opinion it was disrespectful towards Hwang Hyunjin
I agree with you that Binnie sounds amazing and smooth here! i`m so glad they did a slower song in first take ( after case 143) so all of them could show off their vocals
Ohhh!! Loved this song! Loved hearing I.N pop off, loved the Seungmin harmonize with Lee Know. Loved Hyunjin’s tone too! Very “miss you” loved the softer voice he does on those songs. Oh and chan’s extra trill too! Let’s gooooo skz! I’m in a professional orchestra and I wanna say I didn’t hear any lateness, but whew I do prefer the original composition to be honest. But dang one take has always been a bop! Go off skz! :))
I noticed Hyunjin’s lack of energy in the Relay Dance they released for The Sound. The other members were clearly trying to support him. Hugs for Hyunjin.
It must be incredibly intimidating to do first takes, but for professionals it’s a good exercise. I personally thought Hyunjin sounded great, was different but not off. Professional choice. I am glad you showed concern for him and how you heard it. It’s fun interacting and getting all kinds of opinions. Thanks for sharing😊
Spontaneous reactions are not supposed to be all 🤩🥰🥳💓💞💯. Good and bad are both welcome! Hyunjin's voice is really interesting, because in the group his live voice differs the most from recordings. We have Chan, I.N, Seungmin and Han who all sound -the same- in a professional mix and live, we have Changbin and Felix who's emotive powers are always shining through live, we have Lee Know who you'll never know how he'll surprise us. But Hyunjin's voice often go either higher or lower than recordings and his flow differs a bit. Produced his voice sound more generic to me while singing, live he has interesting and captivating qualities. Thank you for your reaction!
For me, I noticed in the studio version there is a pause before hyunjin's line so he was on time. It is a good reaction video 👏 keep on reacting to skz contents ♥️. I would like for you to react to 'Ta' and 'phobia'.
I didn't notice anything wrong, but I'm not a music connoisseur. However, I did notice when they were warming up that Hyunjin grabbed his throat. Maybe he did notice something. He seemed a bit quiet and serious before they started.
The way Hyunjin sounded in this is just how he sounds when he sings live. Now don’t come at me bc I don’t wanna sound rude but I feel like Hyunjin just doesn’t sing as well live as som of the other members do and that’s okay. He's a rapper and dancer, not a vocalist. He sounds really good in studio versions but when it comes to actually singing/rapping live he just doesn’t do it as well as the other members. There are some members who are really good at singing live and they sound almost if not exactly the same as they do in their studio versions (Especially Han, Changbin and Seungmin). Now ppl are welcome to fight me on this but imo it’s just a known fact that the most stable and consistent members when it comes to singing/performing live are the three people I mentioned. Now Hyunjin isn’t bad, he just sounds very different from the studio versions and that’s okay to admit. I'm baboracha biased (Han, Lee Know and Hyunjin) and even I can admit that. However he definitely wasn’t off beat in this, he started when he was supposed to.
Would also like to add that Hyunjin focuses more on his dancing than his live vocals when they perform live which is understandable bc he's mainly a dancer after all. And when he does stand still and raps like he does in the First Takes it sounds rly good, it’s just the singing that’s a but off I guess, bc it sounds so different from the recorded/studio version.
I commend & appreciate you stating your opinion. A lot of times, if you aren't expressing blind adoration for an idol, you are labeled a hater. We can have opinions and express them respectfully, just like you did. And I actually agree with you. His parts felt a bit rough. But no one can be perfect all of the time, not even Stray Kids who, in my opinion, are about as close to perfect as you can get.
Chan had a cold a couple of weeks ago at the Aus concerts. Innie and hyunjin sound like they caught it too. (This was filmed a few days after Aus tour).
Anyone who has been watching long enough knows that you’re a true fan of Stray Kids and that you have zero ill intentions towards the boys. I think on top of what you’ve already mentioned here in the comments such as passers-by and maybe younger fans who don’t know how to be objective, it seems that people become especially triggered when anything perceived as ‘negative’ is said about Hyunjin - I imagine this is due to the fact he has been the target of so much undeserved hate over the years and it looks like trolls have been piping up again recently, such as his Instagram posts being spammed with hate comments .. so this might explain some of the knee-jerk reaction you’ve had here. In any case (143 .. sorry I had to 😅), appreciate the reaction as always, keep doing what your doing Teddy 🤟🏻
What some of us have to understand is that being a fan doesn't mean you have to like everything your favs release, neither does it mean you can't speak your mind about that feelings, facts or opinions. I also thought Hyunjin didn't sound so great here, and that's okay.
i agree hyunjin sounds different than usual, ( if you enjoy that or don’t, is personal) but he was not out of time or off beat throughout the performance which did confuse me a little when teddy was commenting on his vocals
Es increíble lo mucho que me emociono cuando subes video reaccionando a stray kids. Changbin me a impresionado mucho con su vocal, mejoró mucho. Su voz suena muy angelical, lo amo. Thanks for uploading the video.
not sure why people in the comments seem mad- yes he was on time but i can see why u thought he wasnt and i agree he sounds different than usual but i think its meant to be that way. easy mistake tbh no biggie. keep the skz reactions coming i love them! still wanna see u react to 'ta' dance practice video!
It’s just a few casual passers-by that are deciding to pipe up 🙄😂 I think you’re right bough I think it’s the change in backing track that threw me off!
I think if a person making 3 mistakes in a row, probably it wasn't mistake at all. Probably some thing that done in purpose. In 3 years I follow SKZ, I found that Hyunjin has various ways of rapping and singing. I got used to it, and never matter if he made sudden change of style. Have a nice 'stay' day, every one.
No cuz I had to play it on the same time as song they released to hear if I heard the difference but he did it excactly as in the one they released. all of them did.
I ADMIRE YOUR SINCERITY, I NOTICED THAT HYUNJIN DID NOT LEAVE TIME BUT I PERSONALLY LIKED HYUNJIN AND CHANGBIN NEEDS MORE SINGING PARTS HE HAS A BEAUTIFUL VOICE ❣️
I thought first hj part is little bit weird too. So I checked more than 3 times and I figured out he changed his volume on purpose. But 2nd part(drop) was on the beat, he did great.
Living for Teddy’s petty replies to the haters. It was an honest mistake and I can kind of see what you’re saying about his voice but I think he still sounds great and he’s just trying something knew. Which is totally fine. And our boy Binnie wrote this masterpiece!!! I think it was really sweet the whole group was complimenting the song so much. They’re the best. Thank you so much Teddy!
I just hate how this video has had more comments than usual because people are quicker to point out a problem than they are to support the channel 🫠 I think tbh it’s the change of backing track that threw me off haha. He still sounds off but like you say that’s probably because he’s trying something new! 🫶
@@TeddyGreyOS I totally agree! People love to jump on stuff. I get wanting to defend the boys, but we have to be realistic too. Hope you have a great day friend!!
I agree with you...your honesty is very refreshing...Could be that Hyunjin was a lil nervous, or didnt have time to warm up his voice properly..and that's okay...he's already an excellent dancer, rapper and has amazing stage presence and more...I know he will continue to work on his vocals just like the kids will work on areas they want to improve....keep giving HONEST reactions pleaseeeeee
i really like this album and Replay.. the tracks remind me of their older releases (2020 and before), so it feels like old SKZ before Maniac and Maxident.. just received my Sound album yesterday from Japan!
For me Hyunjin's parts sound a bit odd because of the way he enunciates the words, for japanese speakers this prolonged singing style makes the words sound a bit off, but overall he still did well melodically
What's up Teddy!!! Seeing the fuss in the comments makes me chuckle a little 🤭 I really like your sharp ear for music but most of all I'm glad you keep your own opinions regarding music and express them without limitation. I'M HERE FOR IT The arrangements of the track also threw me off and I think that's why it sounded weird, later in the song Felix did the same thing and it sounded a bit off as well, so I assume it's due to the change in the song. What ever it is i enjoyed it.
Мне нравится, как звучит здесь голос Хёнджина. Да, он звучит иначе чем обычно, но как будто теплее и интимнее, что ли. Это может нравиться или не нравиться, может быть не привычным, но и только. Другой вопрос, что Хёнджин всегда становится мишенью для придирок, упрёков и даже обвинений, ему со стопроцентной вероятностью прилетит за мелкие косяки, которых обычно не замечают у других мемберов или прощают им, а когда зацепиться совсем не за что, ему их просто придумают. Откуда, вы думаете, вырос перфекционизм Хёнджина и его максимальная требовательность к себе? К нему цепляются даже если он безупречен, так что он привык не обращать внимания и просто доводить до совершенства все, что делает. Иногда мне кажется, что ум и чувства некоторых людей просто не в состоянии справиться, сталкиваясь людьми, подобными Хёнджину, они слишком хороши, ненормально хороши, и это то ли пугает, то ли раздражает, заставляя выискивать и придумывать им несуществующие недостатки или даже пороки. Конечно, Хёнджин не идеален, но он ВЫГЛЯДИТ идеальным. Даже когда действительно ошибается, хехе. Думаю, не стоит мешать людям пытаться "приземлить" в собственном сознании таких людей как Хёнджин, пока это не выходит за рамки. Иногда лучше дать им счастливо пребывать в собственном убеждении в том, что они наконец нашли недостатки у того, кто одним своим существованием подвергает их картину мира риску слегка пострадать.
I know I am late to the comments here, but I have just seen this reaction, Teddy I love you, I am obsessed with your reactions now, but I watched and listened, and watched and listened again, and I thought Hyunjin sounded great! I know you know your stuff, and music encapsulates who you are, but I just couldn't disagree with you more about him here. I listened with headphones, without, and I still thought he sounded great. Idk... But still, you're the man!
you’re a brave man for pointing out vocal flaws teddy 😂 personally i feel this is consistent with how hyunjin has always sounded live with maybe a bit more scratchiness than usual. the one area I feel like he needs more practice in (and it’s not his fault or anything, just that skz don’t perform ballads live as much) is in modulating his volume to add more texture esp when it’s a softer song and it’s a live performance - it’s all in the breathing!
Hyunjin was on time, but he changed his voice, more like ... Nasal voice (?) I think 🤔 Even though this version isn't bad, but I prefer his voice in the original version
I have loved watching you become a stay. You're one of my favorite reactors. I really want to see you react to Yuuri either Betelgeuse or Dried Flower on First Take. It isn't rap but his voice, I just can't stop listening to him. So much emotion. He is from Japan.
I believe that Hyunjin missed 1 sec of drop because later the same part Felix did ideal. ❤I agree Hyunjin is on my bias list i love him but he felt tired a bit or maybe worried as it’s a hard song to perform. In song itself he did such a great job.
dude, I know you said it with no ill intentions, but just listen to the studio and this one side by side.... hyunjin (like all the other members) is literally on the exact time, so your comments seem a little too harsh for them to be just a feeling you got, that it's not actually correct (the timing part).
Я не поленилась проверить по секундомеру, сравнив First Take со студийной версией с альбома, и Хёнджин вступил абсолютно вовремя. Не поняла наезда, короче. Тедди решил поднять активность на канале? 😂
Apparently not everyone shares your love for honesty as this positive comment was quite far down, meaning it’s been disliked lmao. Apparently some can only enjoy an opinion if it mirrors their own 🙄😴 I appreciate your words and of course my criticism never comes from a negative place!
@@TeddyGreyOS I chock it up to life experience and coping skills. It's not negative to comment on something you observed. People need to get a grip. The world isn't ending because of your opinion. It's not like you can't love them anymore because of it. Goodness, those the people who get their panties in a twist because we say something they don't like might need to learn how to take criticism. I know how much you appreciate Stray Kids and it pains me when fans get stupid like this. Keep doing what you're doing!
Hyunjin was definitely on time but I share the same sentiment that he wasn't at his best. I think he was trying something different with his dynamics and maybe he's not very used to it yet so it came a bit off? Hyunjin also has a tendency to eat his words when rapping (yknow the lazy rap i dunno how to call it) and I can tell that he's using that tonal quality and placement in his singing here. It's just that it isn't so well suited for this type of song. Always appreciate your honesty teddy! One of the reasons why I enjoy watching your content Angry comments with no meaningful argument can f off btw
Something about the mix on this performance does feel wonky. A lot of the vocals seem to get buried here and there. The second time Chan came in was much lower than the first time.
Oh I understand your comment on hyunjins part. It’s because of the arrangement in my opinion. I need to double check the part because I don’t hear anything off there😂
Hyunjin was actually on time (exactly like the track) For me he also sounded the same as he usually do, it’s just that he is trying a different tone in his voice 🥰
Yeah... Hyunjin's part comes in on a "simmer" delay. Let's the change sink in and then hit with the vocal. 😊
For me he sounded even better than normal in vocal perspective.
@@Slantishka Yes!
right that's what i think too
@lemonssssssss4 well that's a personal preference, doesnt have anything to do with the person's capabilities. He was perfectly on time and did his part as he was directed
Actually hyunjin didn't miss the beat, listen to the studio version again, he's right on time. Also I personally think hyunjin sound the same, but I love your honesty because that's what makes you genuine, thank you for your reaction!!
Right and I feel the same way💓
So many comments about Hyunjin but I ll say it as well) He sounds absolutely perfect and on time) I listen to this song like 5 times a day , the only thing that is different is the music arrangement! Being Hyunjin biased I follow his singing carefully , and he improved so much overall
I also listen to this song all the time 😂 I was questioning everything when he said it was off LOL
And I also thought Hyunjin’s singing actually sounded better this time? Idk I liked it a lot!
@@nickel8026 haha i get it , but honestly i dont say it coz he is my bias , im the first one to notice when he is off) I have a music background so i can differentiate it well, and here, he sounds amazing
@@elinak1009 ah that’s awesome I wish I had a music background! And I can agree, I’ve thought he was off a couple times before but thought it was great here!
🥰
@@nickel8026 Foreals I was like my dude did u forget how the sound went😩🤣🤡 Justice for Hyunjinnie
Actually Hyunjin was right on. I didn't think anything was wrong so went back and listened to studio version and he was perfect.
There is no wrong with Hyunjin he sounds so beautiful and soft may be Tedy who had a bad day tho 😁that he couldn’t recoknize Hyunjin’s vocals well 😅
This song is really beautiful, Changbin wrote it, everyone made it beautiful, i loved it and Hyunjin did it in a timely manner, maybe what confused you was the arrangement they used for first take, but everything was fine, greetings and thanks for continuing to react to the guys♡
Seo Changbin! - the rapper who wrote a song that makes a singer want to sing it. . Changbin's vocal was so hevenly and beautiful! And Seungmin voice is so strong!
Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. That being said; I think I.N's voice suits the Japanese language really well, and maybe that's the reason why he's shining in this album like the maknae on top star he is. And he's obviously maturing, getting more sure of himself, and working hard on his vocals.
I think so too! He’s sounded amazing and crisp throughout this whole album above all else!
In the studio version that part where you thought Hyunjin was late it's actually delayed like that on the track. You think it's gunna come and it doesn't until the next beat just like he sung it. The end of that phrase is supposed to end as the chorus came in, so he was perfectly on time. He did well in this I thought.
Hyunjin wasn't late at all actually. That's where he is supposed to sing. His line is supposed to stop right as the beat starts again. That's how it was arranged.
I believe Changbin is the main writer for Lost Me, stays correct me if I'm wrong
You are right👌 its changbin
Yassss, it's Changbin.
Like everyone already said Hyunjin did it exactly like on the track so it's not late at all just them playing with the music and vocals as always
Binnie writes the best heartbreak/love songs ❤️ like Ex or Sorry, I love you!
But Teddy I have to agree with the comments, Hyunjin respected the original time and tone of the song 🤔
Hyunjin sounds perfect here.. I love how hyunjin has power to use his voice acc to the vibe of the song like he sounds honey laced in some songs, in hot songs he uses his raspy and lazy tone and he can go deep too
Hyunjin was on time and it's exactly as the studio version lol I've only heard this kind of delay after the "drop" in a Spanish-speaking indie band, so it was fascinating for me, cuz it made it so familiar and nostalgic 👌
Also, I think you're not that familiar with their soft side hahaha you should check more if you want, so you can get used to their soft vocals hahaha
Its funny but Hyunjin surprised me this time, he did it very very well and I love how he managed his voice.
But what I like from you Teddy is that you're genuine, you don't hesitate to say your impressions and thoughts, that's why we all love you ;)
Everything was actually time. I felt that this was actually one of their best performances
I dont think Hyunjin's voice sounds different than normal. In the beginning he sounds very quiet tho, to me it seems like he is nervous. The last part he sings is done beautifully and towards the end of the sentence he sings a little more nasally. He hasnt really had a note at that height that wasnt sung in headvoice so its his first time we hear his mixed voice I believe. You dont hear that a lot, if ever, from him. At least thats what it sounds like to me. And the prechorus part with IN, like you said, the instrumental sounds very loud compared to their voices. They couldve mixed it a bit better in my opinion. But I love the video nontheless. :)
Backing track definitely off .
I do think hyunjin sounded normal too and music was louder than their voices
I've been a stay for almost 2 years and i do think Hyunjin sounded a little different than usual! But he sang beautifully! And yeah I agree the instrumental was a little too loud.
Unfortunately, the mixing is set prior to their recording, as is the instrumentals volume. That's the one of the rules of the first take, there is absolutely no post production... So, whoever set the mixers (specially for Hyunjin) didn't set it correctly.
I know it's not the members that get to do that, with kpop groups it never is. It's the stage team who goes over it all with them during sound check, and asks them what all needs to be done. So yeah, sadly the team setting the mixers and choosing the volume of the backing tack messed this up a bit for all of them. And of course, Hyunjin singing in a mixed voice is new to him and considering he's still developing his vocals, i didn't expect perfect.
I'm more upset about the backing track volume. You should never have to fight the backing track. And here, because their headphones are working like in-ears, they likely aren't even aware of the issue until afterwards or at the very least... near the end. So they wouldn't have even known they needed to make themselves louder.
It's times like this when the artist really depends on the studio staff to get things right on their end, or else the end result is flawed. They know the vocal volume and projection that the song SHOULD require, but in this situation, there is a good chance they were none the wiser about the volume error until it was too late.
IMO Hyunjin did So well this time, i was surprised By his singing voice, He did exactly the same from the record ❤
hyunjin is supposed to sound like that💕 :) he is EXACTLY on point, it is supposed to be that little late sounding... on purpose. it's right on cue ! ✨
CHANGBIN is one of the most talented rappers I've ever come across, he's an all rounder. What a talented young man 🥰💜💜💜
hyunjin is exactly on time like the song is
Hyun sounded just fine to me? That's the vocal tone for this song and perhaps that's what's throwing some people off. He was indeed on beat and all of SKZ did great :) The mix is quite loud this time and they should've turned it down a bit if anything.
hyunjin was on time, it was exactly like how the audio version. it sounded tricky, yes, but he was perfectly on time. his voice as well was progressing, thus he sounded just like he usually does, and better! i suggest, maybe you can listen to the audio track more then listen to the first take one after that.
thank you, anyway, for trying to point it out ☺👍🏼
you really should listen to the track again Teddy. Its spot on for Hyunjin
they all sounded great, but my fave was Seungmin Harmonizing with Lee Know :)
Hyunjin sounded perfect actually surprising this time on first take and so on time didn’t miss a beat though the music arrangement is different! Or at least you’d think he’s improvising or trying a different sound of him instead of saying he’s missing a beat, I guess you know how professional he is to miss a beat
and BTW you’re the only one who said such a thing not even vocal coaches said that, which tells a lot I think
Nope he's not late. I was actually waiting for that part coz I was thinking it would be hard to time it. But he did well.
My opinion on Hyunjin's performance here was that when he sang at first, it definitely did sound different than the original(originals kinda softer), but it wasn't a bad difference imo. I also think that he was perfectly on time with the drop(and i think he might've also been counting it, too). And yes, after Teddy commented on hyunjin in this performance, I went back and forth comparing this and the studio version
I rewatched it 3 times in a row after First Take released it. SOoooo good!
Go watch the original on First Take’s feed. Let’s show them how much we adore SKZ performances.
Hyunjin was fine are you good bro 😂
😂😂i am wondering too
Thank you. This is an amazing song. Hyunjin sounded good. Because this is a first take. it wont be exactly as the audio version. But he was on time. Changbin ending verse sounded more off to me than Hyunjin. At least they got all the lyrics this time, not like Bang Chan who missed ABC part of EFG line in Case 143 first take. LOL
Here is what is listed on the official song.
Composer, Lyricist: CHANGBIN (3RACHA), Lyricist: SUNNY BOY, Arranger, Composer: BANGCHAN (3RACHA), Arranger, Composer: Versachoi
Thank you so much i thought the same 👌Teddy disappointed me actually i didn’t expect this way to express his opinion it was disrespectful towards Hwang Hyunjin
I agree with you that Binnie sounds amazing and smooth here! i`m so glad they did a slower song in first take ( after case 143) so all of them could show off their vocals
Ohhh!! Loved this song! Loved hearing I.N pop off, loved the Seungmin harmonize with Lee Know. Loved Hyunjin’s tone too! Very “miss you” loved the softer voice he does on those songs.
Oh and chan’s extra trill too! Let’s gooooo skz!
I’m in a professional orchestra and I wanna say I didn’t hear any lateness, but whew I do prefer the original composition to be honest. But dang one take has always been a bop!
Go off skz! :))
Omg they arranged so good in chorus part Lee Know' voice and this sound fall beautifully into my ears tho
Ahhhhhh I LOVE IT!!!!!!!!
I noticed Hyunjin’s lack of energy in the Relay Dance they released for The Sound. The other members were clearly trying to support him. Hugs for Hyunjin.
It must be incredibly intimidating to do first takes, but for professionals it’s a good exercise. I personally thought Hyunjin sounded great, was different but not off. Professional choice. I am glad you showed concern for him and how you heard it. It’s fun interacting and getting all kinds of opinions. Thanks for sharing😊
You should check out 'cause I like you' by changbin and Felix
Spontaneous reactions are not supposed to be all 🤩🥰🥳💓💞💯. Good and bad are both welcome!
Hyunjin's voice is really interesting, because in the group his live voice differs the most from recordings. We have Chan, I.N, Seungmin and Han who all sound -the same- in a professional mix and live, we have Changbin and Felix who's emotive powers are always shining through live, we have Lee Know who you'll never know how he'll surprise us. But Hyunjin's voice often go either higher or lower than recordings and his flow differs a bit. Produced his voice sound more generic to me while singing, live he has interesting and captivating qualities.
Thank you for your reaction!
For me, I noticed in the studio version there is a pause before hyunjin's line so he was on time. It is a good reaction video 👏 keep on reacting to skz contents ♥️. I would like for you to react to 'Ta' and 'phobia'.
Let's fall in love to StrayKids!!bro...
hyunjins line before the chorus was on time! :) it probs just sound different cos its a slightly different track! no hate tho. love ur reactions
I didn't notice anything wrong, but I'm not a music connoisseur. However, I did notice when they were warming up that Hyunjin grabbed his throat. Maybe he did notice something. He seemed a bit quiet and serious before they started.
The way Hyunjin sounded in this is just how he sounds when he sings live. Now don’t come at me bc I don’t wanna sound rude but I feel like Hyunjin just doesn’t sing as well live as som of the other members do and that’s okay. He's a rapper and dancer, not a vocalist. He sounds really good in studio versions but when it comes to actually singing/rapping live he just doesn’t do it as well as the other members. There are some members who are really good at singing live and they sound almost if not exactly the same as they do in their studio versions (Especially Han, Changbin and Seungmin). Now ppl are welcome to fight me on this but imo it’s just a known fact that the most stable and consistent members when it comes to singing/performing live are the three people I mentioned. Now Hyunjin isn’t bad, he just sounds very different from the studio versions and that’s okay to admit. I'm baboracha biased (Han, Lee Know and Hyunjin) and even I can admit that. However he definitely wasn’t off beat in this, he started when he was supposed to.
Would also like to add that Hyunjin focuses more on his dancing than his live vocals when they perform live which is understandable bc he's mainly a dancer after all. And when he does stand still and raps like he does in the First Takes it sounds rly good, it’s just the singing that’s a but off I guess, bc it sounds so different from the recorded/studio version.
I commend & appreciate you stating your opinion. A lot of times, if you aren't expressing blind adoration for an idol, you are labeled a hater. We can have opinions and express them respectfully, just like you did. And I actually agree with you. His parts felt a bit rough. But no one can be perfect all of the time, not even Stray Kids who, in my opinion, are about as close to perfect as you can get.
I'm so glad that the guys chose this song to First take❤❤❤❤❤ thanx for your reaction
Chan had a cold a couple of weeks ago at the Aus concerts. Innie and hyunjin sound like they caught it too. (This was filmed a few days after Aus tour).
I’m glad it’s not just me hearing that 🫠😂
Anyone who has been watching long enough knows that you’re a true fan of Stray Kids and that you have zero ill intentions towards the boys.
I think on top of what you’ve already mentioned here in the comments such as passers-by and maybe younger fans who don’t know how to be objective, it seems that people become especially triggered when anything perceived as ‘negative’ is said about Hyunjin - I imagine this is due to the fact he has been the target of so much undeserved hate over the years and it looks like trolls have been piping up again recently, such as his Instagram posts being spammed with hate comments .. so this might explain some of the knee-jerk reaction you’ve had here.
In any case (143 .. sorry I had to 😅), appreciate the reaction as always, keep doing what your doing Teddy 🤟🏻
I just hope those hyunjin haters won't use this to attack him later 😢
What some of us have to understand is that being a fan doesn't mean you have to like everything your favs release, neither does it mean you can't speak your mind about that feelings, facts or opinions. I also thought Hyunjin didn't sound so great here, and that's okay.
Ikr
I agree. The boys are great, but Hyunjin's voice was slightly weird in this one, which is fine, it happens to everyone.
for me Hyunjin also sounds weird..
strongly agree
i agree hyunjin sounds different than usual, ( if you enjoy that or don’t, is personal) but he was not out of time or off beat throughout the performance which did confuse me a little when teddy was commenting on his vocals
Es increíble lo mucho que me emociono cuando subes video reaccionando a stray kids.
Changbin me a impresionado mucho con su vocal, mejoró mucho. Su voz suena muy angelical, lo amo.
Thanks for uploading the video.
not sure why people in the comments seem mad- yes he was on time but i can see why u thought he wasnt and i agree he sounds different than usual but i think its meant to be that way. easy mistake tbh no biggie. keep the skz reactions coming i love them! still wanna see u react to 'ta' dance practice video!
It’s just a few casual passers-by that are deciding to pipe up 🙄😂 I think you’re right bough I think it’s the change in backing track that threw me off!
I think if a person making 3 mistakes in a row, probably it wasn't mistake at all. Probably some thing that done in purpose. In 3 years I follow SKZ, I found that Hyunjin has various ways of rapping and singing. I got used to it, and never matter if he made sudden change of style. Have a nice 'stay' day, every one.
No cuz I had to play it on the same time as song they released to hear if I heard the difference but he did it excactly as in the one they released. all of them did.
I ADMIRE YOUR SINCERITY, I NOTICED THAT HYUNJIN DID NOT LEAVE TIME BUT I PERSONALLY LIKED HYUNJIN AND CHANGBIN NEEDS MORE SINGING PARTS HE HAS A BEAUTIFUL VOICE ❣️
I thought first hj part is little bit weird too. So I checked more than 3 times and I figured out he changed his volume on purpose. But 2nd part(drop) was on the beat, he did great.
Living for Teddy’s petty replies to the haters. It was an honest mistake and I can kind of see what you’re saying about his voice but I think he still sounds great and he’s just trying something knew. Which is totally fine. And our boy Binnie wrote this masterpiece!!! I think it was really sweet the whole group was complimenting the song so much. They’re the best. Thank you so much Teddy!
I just hate how this video has had more comments than usual because people are quicker to point out a problem than they are to support the channel 🫠 I think tbh it’s the change of backing track that threw me off haha. He still sounds off but like you say that’s probably because he’s trying something new! 🫶
what haters we’re just pointing out that HYUNJIN didn’t miss the timing bfr
@@TeddyGreyOS I totally agree! People love to jump on stuff. I get wanting to defend the boys, but we have to be realistic too. Hope you have a great day friend!!
@@urstepmom686 but some can have opinion that he did sounds off, i dont have to like every release and i can point out whats wrong
@@TACOSSAYRAWR I wasn’t talking about that I said the timing wasn’t off
Teddy… you’re slowly becoming delusional and I love that for you
Such a good 1st take!
Some people are not ready for this conversation tho, i really love your transparency as a fan, keep going teddy
What conversation? /gen
I agree with you...your honesty is very refreshing...Could be that Hyunjin was a lil nervous, or didnt have time to warm up his voice properly..and that's okay...he's already an excellent dancer, rapper and has amazing stage presence and more...I know he will continue to work on his vocals just like the kids will work on areas they want to improve....keep giving HONEST reactions pleaseeeeee
Hyunjin was on time.
i really like this album and Replay.. the tracks remind me of their older releases (2020 and before), so it feels like old SKZ before Maniac and Maxident.. just received my Sound album yesterday from Japan!
Thanks for another great reaction!
Hyunjin was on time he did like the original track and he sound like usual but if you don't like it , it ok
For me Hyunjin's parts sound a bit odd because of the way he enunciates the words, for japanese speakers this prolonged singing style makes the words sound a bit off, but overall he still did well melodically
What's up Teddy!!! Seeing the fuss in the comments makes me chuckle a little 🤭 I really like your sharp ear for music but most of all I'm glad you keep your own opinions regarding music and express them without limitation. I'M HERE FOR IT
The arrangements of the track also threw me off and I think that's why it sounded weird, later in the song Felix did the same thing and it sounded a bit off as well, so I assume it's due to the change in the song. What ever it is i enjoyed it.
Thanks for the fast reaction!! 🎉 I adore your responses to SKZ.
Keep talking to the photos- we do it too 😂
And yes- Seungmin is both sweet and funny. This song obviously is special to him.
I played CD and live same time, actually Hyunjin did not miss
Мне нравится, как звучит здесь голос Хёнджина. Да, он звучит иначе чем обычно, но как будто теплее и интимнее, что ли. Это может нравиться или не нравиться, может быть не привычным, но и только.
Другой вопрос, что Хёнджин всегда становится мишенью для придирок, упрёков и даже обвинений, ему со стопроцентной вероятностью прилетит за мелкие косяки, которых обычно не замечают у других мемберов или прощают им, а когда зацепиться совсем не за что, ему их просто придумают. Откуда, вы думаете, вырос перфекционизм Хёнджина и его максимальная требовательность к себе? К нему цепляются даже если он безупречен, так что он привык не обращать внимания и просто доводить до совершенства все, что делает.
Иногда мне кажется, что ум и чувства некоторых людей просто не в состоянии справиться, сталкиваясь людьми, подобными Хёнджину, они слишком хороши, ненормально хороши, и это то ли пугает, то ли раздражает, заставляя выискивать и придумывать им несуществующие недостатки или даже пороки. Конечно, Хёнджин не идеален, но он ВЫГЛЯДИТ идеальным. Даже когда действительно ошибается, хехе.
Думаю, не стоит мешать людям пытаться "приземлить" в собственном сознании таких людей как Хёнджин, пока это не выходит за рамки. Иногда лучше дать им счастливо пребывать в собственном убеждении в том, что они наконец нашли недостатки у того, кто одним своим существованием подвергает их картину мира риску слегка пострадать.
sorry, changbin himself praised hyunjin's singing very well. try to listen and understand the lyrics not just the song
You should still react to Changbin on masked singer... He did really well ❤️
Hyunjin
Seungmin
In
Felix
Han
chan
lee know
And changbinnnnnn 🥰🔥
Me encantan tus opiniones sinceras
Lee Know voice is sweet ,your japanese is very good.
I know I am late to the comments here, but I have just seen this reaction, Teddy I love you, I am obsessed with your reactions now, but I watched and listened, and watched and listened again, and I thought Hyunjin sounded great! I know you know your stuff, and music encapsulates who you are, but I just couldn't disagree with you more about him here. I listened with headphones, without, and I still thought he sounded great. Idk... But still, you're the man!
you’re a brave man for pointing out vocal flaws teddy 😂 personally i feel this is consistent with how hyunjin has always sounded live with maybe a bit more scratchiness than usual. the one area I feel like he needs more practice in (and it’s not his fault or anything, just that skz don’t perform ballads live as much) is in modulating his volume to add more texture esp when it’s a softer song and it’s a live performance - it’s all in the breathing!
+ it’s something I think I.N has worked so hard on too, and the improvement has been noticeable!
Thanks to reaction of stray kids music can i request can react the stray kids mv get cool please
Lee know's voice ♥️😭
Hyunjin was on time, but he changed his voice, more like ... Nasal voice (?) I think 🤔
Even though this version isn't bad, but I prefer his voice in the original version
I have loved watching you become a stay. You're one of my favorite reactors. I really want to see you react to Yuuri either Betelgeuse or Dried Flower on First Take. It isn't rap but his voice, I just can't stop listening to him. So much emotion. He is from Japan.
I believe that Hyunjin missed 1 sec of drop because later the same part Felix did ideal. ❤I agree Hyunjin is on my bias list i love him but he felt tired a bit or maybe worried as it’s a hard song to perform. In song itself he did such a great job.
he didn't miss it as all, listen to the track on spotify or where you listen to music and he will do it exactly like that
Omg ur skin looks sooo goood
dude, I know you said it with no ill intentions, but just listen to the studio and this one side by side.... hyunjin (like all the other members) is literally on the exact time, so your comments seem a little too harsh for them to be just a feeling you got, that it's not actually correct (the timing part).
Not me trying to ditch a meeting at work to have watched this live 🫠 #Priorities #Fail #FOMO
Я не поленилась проверить по секундомеру, сравнив First Take со студийной версией с альбома, и Хёнджин вступил абсолютно вовремя. Не поняла наезда, короче. Тедди решил поднять активность на канале? 😂
I love how you love this group. You are brutally honest with the intention of trying to make them better. It's awesome.
I love this track!
Apparently not everyone shares your love for honesty as this positive comment was quite far down, meaning it’s been disliked lmao. Apparently some can only enjoy an opinion if it mirrors their own 🙄😴 I appreciate your words and of course my criticism never comes from a negative place!
@@TeddyGreyOS I chock it up to life experience and coping skills. It's not negative to comment on something you observed. People need to get a grip. The world isn't ending because of your opinion. It's not like you can't love them anymore because of it.
Goodness, those the people who get their panties in a twist because we say something they don't like might need to learn how to take criticism.
I know how much you appreciate Stray Kids and it pains me when fans get stupid like this. Keep doing what you're doing!
Can you do wow by Lee know Felix and Hyunjin?
changbin is absolutely attractive
Hyunjin was definitely on time but I share the same sentiment that he wasn't at his best. I think he was trying something different with his dynamics and maybe he's not very used to it yet so it came a bit off? Hyunjin also has a tendency to eat his words when rapping (yknow the lazy rap i dunno how to call it) and I can tell that he's using that tonal quality and placement in his singing here. It's just that it isn't so well suited for this type of song.
Always appreciate your honesty teddy! One of the reasons why I enjoy watching your content
Angry comments with no meaningful argument can f off btw
I really enjoyed your honest reaction. Don't listen to the haters. We (Stay) always love you and your channel ❤️
Hyunjin voice is só cute but your japanese haver accent,is cute.
2:39 teddy's in his delulu era
TEDDY, LOVE ALL YOUR REACTIONS
PLEASE REACT TO DRAGON THREE BY 3RACHA
Something about the mix on this performance does feel wonky. A lot of the vocals seem to get buried here and there. The second time Chan came in was much lower than the first time.
Hi, everyone 👋
Hi 👋
@@nargesdellavarian1155 hi, Narges
Hi
hi
TEDDY TEDDY TEDDY! I beg you, please react to ‘Phobia’ by Stray Kids.
💗🔥
I feel like the mix on this is a little too loud but they did a great job!
Oh I understand your comment on hyunjins part. It’s because of the arrangement in my opinion. I need to double check the part because I don’t hear anything off there😂
Actually it's just the same as in the actual version