Watch our final episode of "Reporting for Duty," and meet the Air Force veterans turning our nation's heroes into music stars: ua-cam.com/video/fSZovLyrsvA/v-deo.html You can watch the entire 14-part series here: www.aarp.org/reportingforduty AARP is honored to fight for issues that are important to nearly 4 million AARP members who have served in America’s military and their families. Veterans have given their all for this country, and they deserve supportive services to help them live their best lives.
When you see an old Vet walking with a limp, or shuffling along out of breathe or overweight, remember that these men at one time were more badass than most people will ever be.
I agree, I was in the Army and I've been a full time firefighter for 19 years. I've been tested, and I know I could hang, but it is hard to see an old veteran falling apart.
Approach them, and simply say "Thank you, sir" They'll understand. Unless you can see on their hat that they were enlisted men- don't call them sir, if that's the case. They'll probably reply with "Don't call me sir- I work for a living."
Karl Marlantes suffered from severe PTSD when he came back from Vietnam. He underwent treatment and now has the coping mechanisms to counteract his disorder.
This is the only thing that gives me hope in humanity. That deep down, most people do not want to commit violence upon others and will feel a serious grief if they do. Hopefully our species can find peace in the future. Those who are eager to commit violence need to be disposed of.
@@justinriley8651 Justin, for your sake, I hope that you never have to know what it is like to lose comrades around you in battle, that you never understand the meaning of "survivor's guilt", and that your wife and sons and daughters, nor anyone else close to you, ever has to rely on you in a time of violent crisis.
@@donna30044 my kids would be wise to rely on me during a time of crisis. the wife can do what she wants. I dont know where you were going with your comment you dont know me . find some other comment you dont like or understand and teach it a lesson.
I had the honor of meeting Karl Marlantes at a book signing. I was wearing a Marine Corps windbreaker and when he signed the book he brushed his hand across the Marines logo over my heart and said, “Semper Fi Marine”. I’ll never forget it.
Two of my team died on their last patrol. Only days left for them in country. Well they did go home. Been long time since 1966, but I still carry that fowl place in my heart...
I feel like the metals are not here to remind me what I did, or to make me feel guilty for surviving when my friends didn't. I feel like they are here to remind me who my friends were. And I try to live my life for them in a way. It's all we can do.
My great uncle fought in Burma, in world war two, he hated that jungle, and despised the Japanese for the rest of his life... He never talked about it to me. Only that the jungle was a dreadful place for man or beast.. and he'd been both.
Strange how i always hear that the last days of duty are also the most feared among the buddies. A sober veteran told me once that the last day/s guys getting out, have a habit of having their minds focused on getting back home and planning what to do. "Not being on one's toes are the deadliest mistake"
The older I get, the more I realize just how young these kids in battle were. When you're 18 you think you're a man. An adult. ...NOPE. They're just kids..
You are so right! I was drafted at age 18 into the infantry. Did 3 tours in the Middle East and the Balkans. Thought I am a man. Nope, I was a boy on an adventure trip. 30 years later as a father of two girls I am happy they have no interest in the military. (I am not US)
I remember back in 1982 reading how three 17 year old British paratroopers were killed storming an Argentine machine gun nest. I was 16 at the time and still in school. Children fighting in wars is a terrible thing.
America should have walked away. I don't blame the soldiers who signed up to go, but I spit on the memory of every politician who had a hand in starting this war.
I never knew till the end of my dad's life (U.S. Army, WWII, Battle of the Bulge, Ardennes Forest) that he felt the same way. He said he lost the best friends he ever had, and he didn't know why they died and he survived. I understood at last why he was sad and withdrawn all those years. So sorry for your struggles. I hope some day you can find peace.
Live for those who didn't. Don't compound the loss by adding to it. Those who survived need to live well in order to honor those who didn't. There's is no reason for you to feel guilty.
Forrest Luce We as Americans will never forgot your service and dedication to our country. I am 17 and planning on joining the marines, I’ve wanted to ever since I was born. I may serve, and I may not, but one thing is for sure, I and many others will never forget what you and the veterans of our great country have given to us all. Thank you.
I read your book, “Matterhorn” a few years ago by accident. I had been to the mountain named Matterhorn previously and saw your big on a table at a used book sale. I thought your book had something to do with the Alps. I started the book and could not put it down. One of the greatest books I have ever read. I gave it to my twenty something son and he said it was the best book he has read. Well done soldier and author. Thank you.
My older brother is a Vietnam vet. I remember the pain my dad felt when He went. He made it back but to this Day as far as I know has only spoken about it to my Father.
What honor ???? No honor in killing innocent people ! And the Vietnamese people diddent invite you to their country, the predator is you, and not the innocent Vietnamese !
Thank you for your service .I am a war child. Vietnam war was a cold blood. My American father was an GI and my Vietanmese mother was a Maillady in Longbinh and Saigon. I lost both of my parents during of the war (Tet)
Thuy Swanberg thanks for your reply. I've been trying to wrap my head around the whole situation and I'm still so intrigued. There are so many factors to consider. I mean, the war that ended the lives of your parents was also responsible for the creation of your life. That's got to be the the ultimate example of a paradox, or something. The bottom line I guess depends on you and your view on life. Are you a happy person? Do you enjoy life? I hope you are and I hope your parents didn't suffer and are somewhere together and happy too. my wife n I met in the first gulf war. Our kids are a byproduct of that war.
A huge THANK YOU to my fellow Marine, Karl Marlantes, for his gallant service in the Vietnam War. I was a peacetime Marine ('79-'83) and never had to face combat, or war. Karl and Charles Thomas were the Marines who were held up to us as heroes and who we should strive to emulate and honor, during our training. They will always be my heroes and walk a little taller, in my eyes and heart. Thank you, also, Mr. Marlantes, for sharing your story with us. Your courage and sacrifice, and that of your fellow Marines, is an inspiration to us all. Semper Fi, brother. Always.
Theodorej1960 I applaud you, you can always stand proud, you willingly and honorably served your country, it doesn't matter one bit that you never had to face combat or war and again, Thank You for your service. Military Assistance Command Advisory Team 8 2nd Area Logistical Command 2nd Corps Qui Nhon, June67 to June68.
I was also a marine the same time you were, discharged in May '83. I also feel the same as you regarding Vietnam veterans, heroes, all of them! Semper Fi
I worked as a case manager with Vets for a couple of years with the VA too, so many stories that most of the population never hear or understand. I met some of the most inspiring people of my life in the VA and the vets I worked with. Im truly thankful to have been able to be associated with those individuals and the VA too.
Mr. Marlantes, I have seen you many times in documentaries about Vietnam and since I have the equivalent to a PhD in the subject of the war, having studied it for 40 years, I think you are the most articulate, sincere and devoted former Marine platoon commander I have listened to. Sir, you will be met in Heaven by your platoon for a final muster. Their reverence for you must have been a true honor to have been a witness to. Semper Fi, sir!
What heaven? The Bible's heaven?? Because if that is so, nobody of his platoon will be waiting for him in heaven, unless they had Jesus in their hearts.
Sir, Thank you for sharing your life with us while in Vietnam. My father served with the 1st INF DIV in 65 while in Vietnam and also served in the Korean War. I served with the 1st MarDiv during the Gulf War of 1990-1991. I Salute you and all other’s like you. Semper Fidelis. CWO3 JKK. 1972-1994.
Semper Fi brother, I left everything in my life to take off to the Marines in 2006, was worth it... hardest most rewarding life changing experience I ever faced. I'll never be able to surpass it, ever. God bless the United States Marine Corps.
Great moral character. The Marines and the nation were blessed to have him. He was in a bar surrounded by women and his conscience took over. They don't make men like that anymore.
I hope we learned many lessons, no one feels like a hero, they feel like a survivor, even the guy they called "hero". There are scars for life but I hope many did find peace in living and living for those who left so young. Survivor's guilt is an ugly thing but so is any guilt. Let it go. Let it be. Stick with the present and when it shows back up, get it out/talk it out and release. The problem was they held it in. It destroys you more you have to release it all and make peace with it.
Having read "Matterhorn" a couple of times, it really shows just how much the novel is based on his experiences... Even what he said in this short video is portrayed really well in the book. I don't know how to explain it, but it truly hits in a special way. Would definitely recommend reading it some time, it is by far the best book I have ever read. Thank you, Mr. Marlantes for sharing your experiences with the world in such a way. btw, sorry if I made some poor translations.
I could never imagine what these men were faced with; the sheer amount of the human experience packed into a couple of years just as they’re starting their lives. That’s a young age to be carrying those kinds of burdens. I’ve been fortunate enough to be part of developing a mental health practice that conducts first responder and veteran, group therapy sessions with an emphasis on PTSD. We only contract therapists that have formerly served in the military and/or been first responders in the past to work with these men and women. It’s so important to our clients that the people we ask them to trust in understand their experiences and can appreciate the importance and impact it’s had on their lives. I feel honored to help in some small way, and just getting to know and befriend these men and women has made a huge impression on my life. Thank you all for the sacrifices you’ve made-you deserve the best this country has to give.
I have just finished Karl's book Matterhorn. I have read many many books but I feel that Matterhorn is possibly the most intense, raw, honest and downright emotional piece of literature I have ever read. So many times I could have sobbed.. God bless all those souls from both sides, alive or passed who had to endure that and all conflicts.
Countries call to take misery to other people thousands of miles away from your homeland? You answered you politicians calls while they drank the best whisky, young men were dying.
@@anner.5347 Well said. But I should say that I don't mind it if someone was against the war as a conscientious objector( like Muhammad Ali, Bill Clinton, Bruce Springsteen, Cheech Marin, John Lithgow, etc) or if they simply didn't believe in it and didn't support it. I feel like that's a very different thing from being a coward and being better off with other people going.
I have read his book “what it is like to go to war” and tbh it is a very good book written by him and I would totally recommend everybody to read it it’s definitely worth it
Thank you for sharing your ❤️,God bless you my friend. I too am a British army vet. This is the life of loyalty and love for our brothers in combat,I send you my peace and love. We stand together. 🌹❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️🌹 Pastor Martyn. Infantry, British army.
Ian Jarrett,. I served with the British royal Air Force in a NATO support unit nearly 40 years ago, with lots of great English Airmen,. Yes and ladies also in the British services. There were other nations that were part of our unit also. Always miss England, and some of my forefathers came from there in the 1600s in the Devon area.
Sir I know where you are coming from. You did what Marines do, improvise, adapt, overcome. And keep doing it till the threat is no longer there. Semper Fi
God Bless you for your Service! I was a PenPal to many of you from my Hometown Racine Wisconsin... I've just turned 61 on April 13th. God Speed your Store of Blessings to the forefront of His Lists!
Mary Stachowiak- I was a Marine in Vietnam and received letters from pen pals. I had one that wrote to me from Greeley Colorado. You ladies don't realize the comfort it was for us to hear from a complete stranger from the States. Telling us about yourselves and things back home, though I was from the deep South, she, Colorado. Her name was Cheryl and was 24 and I was 19. We quit writing when I came home and I have often wondered where she is today. We did appreciate those letters and thanks a million for them.
Mary, thanks for doing your part. Letters like that meant a lot to a LOT of guys. I was lucky enough to have a girl friend (now my wife) who wrote me almost every day I was over there. By the way, I live in Baileys Harbor, Door County, Wisconsin.
I’ve been on a spree these past couple days watching Vietnam veteran videos. My grandpa was a vet with the 101st during nam, and he recently passed a couple days ago so I’m just trying to still get a feel of him you know
Even if you disagree politically, we as a nation have a duty to honor our veterans and fallen warriors,. Because without them, our freedom would be nothing but a distant memory.
My father served - tunnel rat - we never spoke of his 3 tours - I am proud of his service and i believe you did the best you could- it appears you where cut from the same bolts of cloth
IMO Karl Marlantes is one exceptional human being. I watched several videos dealing with his books and experiences in Vietnam and he's one top notch speaker.
He is a MARINE First ! Semper Fi til I die ! Cpl. Steve eaton,HMM165,CH53CC,RVN/RNVN. 1972/73. Proudly served 1970 to 76. Please pray this holiday season for ALL U.S. men & woman in service ALL over the world. Regards, SCE.
It's really interesting the way he talks. I just finished reading Matterhorn (which I highly recommend you read) and his voice really comes through in the book. For example, the reverence he gives to radio operators comes through in the book, or the love that exists between people who have shared combat. This guy is amazing.
I remember sitting on the bench in the Quad at midnight at the College where CS Lewis taught. It was so quiet. My friend Doug B was an SF medic at 21 years old. He couldn't save a kid who was bleeding out "he was like swiss cheese I couldn't stop it." He felt a duty to serve our country. Virtues of a generation and at great cost must never be forgotten. Thanks Karl.
not for nothing , but there is not enough said for the families that are broken for our, and everyones liberty, thank you to all the families that sacrificed and endured the price for freedom. thank you boys and girls for all that you gave!! we love you
Thank you for giving me another piece of a family story and for living to tell it. My brother was one of the pilots that flew you all back and forth. He took me to the O Club one Friday night so he could get drunk enough to tell the flight students and pilots his "funny" stories about getting all the people on two helicopters back alive. I knew that he valued the life of every man on those two ships and did what he had to for them to live including flying an overloaded, wounded helicopter that they later told him could not fly. He agreed because there was no longer a reason to work that hard to fly it. Again, thank you for doing your very best in a bad situation and for coming home to tell the stories of those who can no longer tell what they gave for us.
2 tours as a CAS pilot in support of those ground Marines and Helo pilots. Did all I could to keep the VC off their backs when I could. I consider myself to be very fortunate to make it home but still feel guilty about not being able to do more to support my fellow Marines. Got shot at but never hit as some of buddies were. I’ve never, and never will, regretted my serving in Nam and would do so again if called upon. Semper Fidelis to all Marines who answered the call as did this Marine.
@@skyhawk61 glad you made it back. My brother got a distinguished flying cross in Vietnam so I've heard some stories. My grandson is the youngest Marine in the family. I was always happy when they took the civilians off the gates in Corpus Christi. The Marines had orders so they had nothing to prove and were usually very nice.
It really makes you feel for those young grunts - never had a chance to experience life and its joys. And they did it all so that we could enjoy our own lives. We need to remember that - every day of our free lives.
I was a 2531 MOS, Vietnam Era Veteran, USMC. Something people don’t always realize is that Marines, because that’s what I know, has a Camaraderie. That means that although you fight amongst yourself, You Love those Guys, each and every one! To loose one is pretty devastating. This story brings much back. My heart hurts for this Lieutenant! Any Man in that situation make the best decision, based on what he knows, At that Instant! I’d Love to communicate with this Man! Tell him, GOD’s grace and Love supersede’s all. And that means “All”. Semper Fi
Knew nothing about Vietnam really. Just sat through the PBS documentary and got an eye opener and respect for the soldiers... Thank you for your service..sad story.
This guy is a damn modest man but a true hero ....In a single year long active tour of duty in Vietnam as a rifle platoon leader and later as Executive Officer in the Charlie Company of the1st Battalion,4th Marine Regiment,3rd Marine Division from october 1968 to october 1969 he was awarded Navy Cross which is the us navy and marines second highest decoration awarded for valor in combat.....Apart from Navy Cross he also got a Bronze Star for valor ,2 Navy Commendation medal for valor, 2 purple Hearts and 10 Air Medals.
War is hell and I salute all veterans of all the wars for their bravery love for country and fortheir willingness to put their lives on the line so that we may live free and safe!!,..
This is what I typically was around while a grunt in the Marine Corps. The best and brightest leaders I've ever seen. I'm old know but being a Marine grunt was without doubt the best part of my life. Later in his life Ted Williams felt the same way about being a Marine pilot. I wish I was 17 again so I could run down to recruiting office and enlist again.
God Bless you sir. It was an immoral war not because our cause was not noble, but because the people at the top that escalated the conflict in 1964 had no intentions of winning it, a dastardly thing. It was a noble thing you did to volunteer to go because in an advancing civilization a soldier is to follow the commands of his superiors and his oath as an officer. How many 10s of 1000s of Marines have followed orders to take a hill they knew they could not take and died without resentment fighting to the death like your wonderful radioman and friend who is in heaven with Jesus smiling down at you right now. Well done. You were an inspiration on many levels.
They DID intend to win it. Unfortunately for them, the Soviet-supplied air defence systems proved to be too much for them...and the Vietnamese fought them to a 1:1 ratio in the air. Invading the North proved impossible so they got bogged down in a war of attrition in the South...which they ultimately lost.
Watch our final episode of "Reporting for Duty," and meet the Air Force veterans turning our nation's heroes into music stars: ua-cam.com/video/fSZovLyrsvA/v-deo.html
You can watch the entire 14-part series here: www.aarp.org/reportingforduty
AARP is honored to fight for issues that are important to nearly 4 million AARP members who have served in America’s military and their families. Veterans have given their all for this country, and they deserve supportive services to help them live their best lives.
When you see an old Vet walking with a limp, or shuffling along out of breathe or overweight, remember that these men at one time were more badass than most people will ever be.
You could do what they did if circumstances forced it... probably.
I agree, I was in the Army and I've been a full time firefighter for 19 years. I've been tested, and I know I could hang, but it is hard to see an old veteran falling apart.
Yep...call me old shrapnel ass..... Vietnam 1968
I like people who don't lose limbs during war time. You gotta be quicker than that.
Approach them, and simply say "Thank you, sir" They'll understand. Unless you can see on their hat that they were enlisted men- don't call them sir, if that's the case. They'll probably reply with "Don't call me sir- I work for a living."
I was a young paratrooper with the 82nd, Airborne. Drank for over 30 years. Finally put it down 20 years ago.
hows your liver?
Thanks for your service and I'm glad to hear you've got a handle on the alcohol abuse.
Never forget.
Karl Marlantes suffered from severe PTSD when he came back from Vietnam. He underwent treatment and now has the coping mechanisms to counteract his disorder.
82 Luft
Congratulations
Make no mistake, he carries that with him every day. Every. day.
It always seems to come back. Sometimes after awhile. Mostly kept down in your toes.
This is the only thing that gives me hope in humanity. That deep down, most people do not want to commit violence upon others and will feel a serious grief if they do. Hopefully our species can find peace in the future. Those who are eager to commit violence need to be disposed of.
as well he should. consequences for all actions, he is alive had a family lived life the other young man died think about it ! truth
@@justinriley8651
Justin, for your sake, I hope that you never have to know what it is like to lose comrades around you in battle, that you never understand the meaning of "survivor's guilt", and that your wife and sons and daughters, nor anyone else close to you, ever has to rely on you in a time of violent crisis.
@@donna30044 my kids would be wise to rely on me during a time of crisis. the wife can do what she wants. I dont know where you were going with your comment you dont know me . find some other comment you dont like or understand and teach it a lesson.
I had the honor of meeting Karl Marlantes at a book signing. I was wearing a Marine Corps windbreaker and when he signed the book he brushed his hand across the Marines logo over my heart and said, “Semper Fi Marine”. I’ll never forget it.
I've got his book Matterhorn. Haven't read it yet but I'm sure it'll prove to be a compelling read. Lt Marlantes, I salute you, sir!
@@enterthebruce91thanks for telling me about his book. I bought it years ago and have never read it. I will now. Semper Fi!!
Karl is the very best America has to offer; his integrity, bravery, honor and accomplishments put him in a class of his own.
ZootyZoFo you expressed just what I was thinking. A great man . I hope he finds some peace.
You got that right
Von Musklaus
Why did we lose the Vietnam War?
Well, the Vietnamese had something to do with it.
Well said
but he killed inoccent peoples of vietnam
Two of my team died on their last patrol. Only days left for them in country. Well they did go home. Been long time since 1966, but I still carry that fowl place in my heart...
I feel like the metals are not here to remind me what I did, or to make me feel guilty for surviving when my friends didn't. I feel like they are here to remind me who my friends were. And I try to live my life for them in a way. It's all we can do.
Old Dog
DONT MEAN NOTHIN BROTHER.
My great uncle fought in Burma, in world war two, he hated that jungle, and despised the Japanese for the rest of his life... He never talked about it to me. Only that the jungle was a dreadful place for man or beast.. and he'd been both.
Old Dog foul
Strange how i always hear that the last days of duty are also the most feared among the buddies. A sober veteran told me once that the last day/s guys getting out, have a habit of having their minds focused on getting back home and planning what to do. "Not being on one's toes are the deadliest mistake"
I’m a US History teacher in FL, will definitely share this video with my students. Thank you for sharing your story..🇺🇸
rick urea what was their reaction ?
wow, i have never seen a teacher's comment on youtube :v
rick urea. Also check out Sgt Kregg “Hero” Jorgenson. He has written Books.
Share th USS LIberty too, oh but wait!
Lol, nice profile pic teacher.
The older I get, the more I realize just how young these kids in battle were. When you're 18 you think you're a man. An adult. ...NOPE. They're just kids..
You are so right! I was drafted at age 18 into the infantry. Did 3 tours in the Middle East and the Balkans. Thought I am a man. Nope, I was a boy on an adventure trip. 30 years later as a father of two girls I am happy they have no interest in the military. (I am not US)
The average age of a Vietnam soldier was 22.
@@iamchillydogg no, it was 19.7 years old.
There is so much truth to your statement
I remember back in 1982 reading how three 17 year old British paratroopers were killed storming an Argentine machine gun nest. I was 16 at the time and still in school. Children fighting in wars is a terrible thing.
Someone who could have just walked away but didn't. A good man.
America should have walked away. I don't blame the soldiers who signed up to go, but I spit on the memory of every politician who had a hand in starting this war.
Articulate, intelligent, honest, emotional. A wonderful man.
Survivors guilt is my main struggle as far as making it through my life and this story helped. Every bit counts.
Forrest Luce hang in there man, you went through hell and back
We aren’t holding anything against you.
I never knew till the end of my dad's life (U.S. Army, WWII, Battle of the Bulge, Ardennes Forest) that he felt the same way. He said he lost the best friends he ever had, and he didn't know why they died and he survived. I understood at last why he was sad and withdrawn all those years. So sorry for your struggles. I hope some day you can find peace.
Live for those who didn't. Don't compound the loss by adding to it. Those who survived need to live well in order to honor those who didn't. There's is no reason for you to feel guilty.
Forrest Luce We as Americans will never forgot your service and dedication to our country. I am 17 and planning on joining the marines, I’ve wanted to ever since I was born. I may serve, and I may not, but one thing is for sure, I and many others will never forget what you and the veterans of our great country have given to us all. Thank you.
My Neighbor was KIA.........1969..........USMC...........18 years old.................RIP............Buddy,,,,,,,,,,,,,
@agent viper sounds like a fougasse mine
18...
So sorry
What a class act. We need more leaders like this man.
We have them. They’re called Marines.
Big Bill O'Reilly damn right! You think he’s the only good shot?!?! Marines are badasses whether u like it or not
Big Bill O'Reilly like trump? The one who dodge the draft 5x?
Always tell a vietnam vet "welcome home"
I read your book, “Matterhorn” a few years ago by accident. I had been to the mountain named Matterhorn previously and saw your big on a table at a used book sale. I thought your book had something to do with the Alps. I started the book and could not put it down. One of the greatest books I have ever read. I gave it to my twenty something son and he said it was the best book he has read. Well done soldier and author. Thank you.
My older brother is a Vietnam vet. I remember the pain my dad felt when He went. He made it back but to this Day as far as I know has only spoken about it to my Father.
All vietnam vets deserve the highest honor for what they went through
What honor ????
No honor in killing innocent people !
And the Vietnamese people diddent invite you to their country, the predator is you, and not the innocent Vietnamese !
@@zioslayerslayer1562 government's fault they were there, the soldiers are heroes
@@alexthomas2067 No they're survivors not heroes. But I agree it's government's fault.
@@robertisham5279 Not heroes?
Thanks Karl. I served in Vietnam with the Australian army in 68, read one of your books.
Thank you for your service .I am a war child. Vietnam war was a cold blood. My American father was an GI and my Vietanmese mother was a Maillady in Longbinh and Saigon. I lost both of my parents during of the war (Tet)
Thuy Swanberg where were you raised? By whom?
I have relatives with the same situation they were raised by grandparents usually
I was born in Saigon and I was raised by adopted mother in South Haugiang.....
Thuy Swanberg god bless you .
Thuy Swanberg thanks for your reply. I've been trying to wrap my head around the whole situation and I'm still so intrigued. There are so many factors to consider. I mean, the war that ended the lives of your parents was also responsible for the creation of your life. That's got to be the the ultimate example of a paradox, or something. The bottom line I guess depends on you and your view on life. Are you a happy person? Do you enjoy life? I hope you are and I hope your parents didn't suffer and are somewhere together and happy too. my wife n I met in the first gulf war. Our kids are a byproduct of that war.
A huge THANK YOU to my fellow Marine, Karl Marlantes, for his gallant service in the Vietnam War. I was a peacetime Marine ('79-'83) and never had to face combat, or war. Karl and Charles Thomas were the Marines who were held up to us as heroes and who we should strive to emulate and honor, during our training. They will always be my heroes and walk a little taller, in my eyes and heart. Thank you, also, Mr. Marlantes, for sharing your story with us. Your courage and sacrifice, and that of your fellow Marines, is an inspiration to us all. Semper Fi, brother. Always.
Theodorej1960 Hey Theodore...you served. Your family is proud and you should be, too.
Theodorej1960 I applaud you, you can always stand proud, you willingly and honorably served your country, it doesn't matter one bit that you never had to face combat or war and again, Thank You for your service.
Military Assistance Command
Advisory Team 8
2nd Area Logistical Command
2nd Corps
Qui Nhon, June67 to June68.
I was also a marine the same time you were, discharged in May '83. I also feel the same as you regarding Vietnam veterans, heroes, all of them! Semper Fi
I worked as a case manager with Vets for a couple of years with the VA too, so many stories that most of the population never hear or understand. I met some of the most inspiring people of my life in the VA and the vets I worked with. Im truly thankful to have been able to be associated with those individuals and the VA too.
Welcome home Marine! My heart goes out to all the young men who didn’t make it back to the world, both physically and mentally.
I came here to salute to all veterans served in all wars
Mr. Marlantes, I have seen you many times in documentaries about Vietnam and since I have the equivalent to a PhD in the subject of the war, having studied it for 40 years, I think you are the most articulate, sincere and devoted former Marine platoon commander I have listened to. Sir, you will be met in Heaven by your platoon for a final muster. Their reverence for you must have been a true honor to have been a witness to. Semper Fi, sir!
yeah he is also in Ken burns documentary about the vietnam war which is very good.
Karl Marlantis,I,d follow you anywhere hope you and your family are well, former Jarhead,79-86semper Fi!
Semper Fi, Sir, 3/5 RVN 68-69!
What heaven? The Bible's heaven?? Because if that is so, nobody of his platoon will be waiting for him in heaven, unless they had Jesus in their hearts.
so, watching YT videos make you a PhD in the subject? Same as flat earthers, their 'research' is watching YT videos XD.
We all still cry over our loss. Vet 59-65. Remember some Good Friends.
Sir, Thank you for sharing your life with us while in Vietnam. My father served with the 1st INF DIV in 65 while in Vietnam and also served in the Korean War. I served with the 1st MarDiv during the Gulf War of 1990-1991. I Salute you and all other’s like you. Semper Fidelis. CWO3 JKK. 1972-1994.
Semper Fi brother, I left everything in my life to take off to the Marines in 2006, was worth it... hardest most rewarding life changing experience I ever faced. I'll never be able to surpass it, ever. God bless the United States Marine Corps.
How many deployments did you end up doing?
@@26michaeluk 5
@@usmcsemperfidelis5405 Jesus, I only did 3 and it destroyed my body. Glad you made it back.
@@26michaeluk Very true... it aged me as well. Now leading a normal life... I appreciate it more now than ever.
@@usmcsemperfidelis5405 so true and well said.
Great moral character. The Marines and the nation were blessed to have him. He was in a bar surrounded by women and his conscience took over. They don't make men like that anymore.
all you guys rock America's finest people
@Von Musklaus only girls write lol. Pussgut. We're passive-aggressive, too, aren't we? Only a coward would make comments like yours.
@@davisworth5114 If you are such a gung ho potential war hero, I want to see you volunteer and sign up for service, going overseas or to Afghanistan.
I hope we learned many lessons, no one feels like a hero, they feel like a survivor, even the guy they called "hero". There are scars for life but I hope many did find peace in living and living for those who left so young. Survivor's guilt is an ugly thing but so is any guilt. Let it go. Let it be. Stick with the present and when it shows back up, get it out/talk it out and release. The problem was they held it in. It destroys you more you have to release it all and make peace with it.
Very well done by an obviously intelligent man who didn't have to serve.. but did.
Quote: The war never ends for those that survive.
His book Matterhorn is a MASTERPIECE!
Best book ever written about combat
From a fellow vet, thank you for your service Sir.
Nobody loves a soldier, TILL the enemy is at the gate . Salute you fella 🇨🇦 expat 🇬🇧
The enemy are inside the gates now, oy vey!
Derek lone wolf ......🇨🇦Argyles....1964-1969. Once an Argyle, always an Argyle.
Having read "Matterhorn" a couple of times, it really shows just how much the novel is based on his experiences... Even what he said in this short video is portrayed really well in the book. I don't know how to explain it, but it truly hits in a special way. Would definitely recommend reading it some time, it is by far the best book I have ever read. Thank you, Mr. Marlantes for sharing your experiences with the world in such a way.
btw, sorry if I made some poor translations.
It's a phenomenal piece of literature
It was brilliant. I will read it again at some point.
I could never imagine what these men were faced with; the sheer amount of the human experience packed into a couple of years just as they’re starting their lives. That’s a young age to be carrying those kinds of burdens. I’ve been fortunate enough to be part of developing a mental health practice that conducts first responder and veteran, group therapy sessions with an emphasis on PTSD. We only contract therapists that have formerly served in the military and/or been first responders in the past to work with these men and women. It’s so important to our clients that the people we ask them to trust in understand their experiences and can appreciate the importance and impact it’s had on their lives. I feel honored to help in some small way, and just getting to know and befriend these men and women has made a huge impression on my life. Thank you all for the sacrifices you’ve made-you deserve the best this country has to give.
God bless you Merlantes for your bravery and sense of service and obligation to your country!
"Only the dead have seen the end of war." - General Douglas MacArthur
Nope, not plato
@@guillermo7298 oops, you´re right! It was General Douglas MacArthur.
No Sir that a old Greek philosopher who said that
you saw that playing call of duty
“Thou shall not believe everything you read on the Internet “
-Abraham Lincoln
(from Brazil) Mr. Marlantes God bless you sir and your braves camerades ! Thank's for your sacrifice and noble service sir !!
Thank you for your service Karl, you are an outstanding role model and a true hero.
I wish I could shake that man’s hand and tell him thank you. Best wishes and respect from Canada
I have just finished Karl's book Matterhorn. I have read many many books but I feel that Matterhorn is possibly the most intense, raw, honest and downright emotional piece of literature I have ever read. So many times I could have sobbed.. God bless all those souls from both sides, alive or passed who had to endure that and all conflicts.
You've got it. Also read "What's it's like to go to war". Not fiction but gives you something of a back story.
You've got it. Also read "What's it's like to go to war". Not fiction but gives you something of a back story.
Thank you Karl for protecting us. CWO4, USN, Ret, 73-95.
God Bless all the young men who answered their country's call.
They were not cowards for damn sure, something we have an overabundance of today including especially blowhard hot-air politicians.
Countries call to take misery to other people thousands of miles away from your homeland?
You answered you politicians calls while they drank the best whisky, young men were dying.
@@bendike Finally someone who gets it.
@@anner.5347 Well said. But I should say that I don't mind it if someone was against the war as a conscientious objector( like Muhammad Ali, Bill Clinton, Bruce Springsteen, Cheech Marin, John Lithgow, etc) or if they simply didn't believe in it and didn't support it. I feel like that's a very different thing from being a coward and being better off with other people going.
Thank you thank you for your service God bless you… And those that did not make it back by their souls rest in peace🙏💐
Freedom comes with a
Price, the blood of our Warriors.
I have read his book “what it is like to go to war” and tbh it is a very good book written by him and I would totally recommend everybody to read it it’s definitely worth it
Thank you for sharing your ❤️,God bless you my friend. I too am a British army vet. This is the life of loyalty and love for our brothers in combat,I send you my peace and love. We stand together.
🌹❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏❤️🌹
Pastor Martyn. Infantry, British army.
Just finished his book "Matterhorn", it's quite a masterpiece!
Anyone who read it, can feel how much of that he has gone through in reality.
I am English but I respect this man greatly for his service and command.
Ian Jarrett,. I served with the British royal Air Force in a NATO support unit nearly 40 years ago, with lots of great English Airmen,. Yes and ladies also in the British services. There were other nations that were part of our unit also. Always miss England, and some of my forefathers came from there in the 1600s in the Devon area.
Service for what?
Hold your head high sir.....you are a hero! GOD bless you
b1untrama the country.
b1untrama go back to Africa
Sir I know where you are coming from. You did what Marines do, improvise, adapt, overcome. And keep doing it till the threat is no longer there. Semper Fi
You Sir geets the five finger salute! You just told me what I needed to hear and you were in Vietnam. God bless you!
God Bless you for your Service! I was a PenPal to many of you from my Hometown Racine Wisconsin... I've just turned 61 on April 13th. God Speed your Store of Blessings to the forefront of His Lists!
Mary Stachowiak nobody wanted yoi fuckers as penpals yo
Mary Stachowiak- I was a Marine in Vietnam and received letters from pen pals. I had one that wrote to me from Greeley Colorado. You ladies don't realize the comfort it was for us to hear from a complete stranger from the States. Telling us about yourselves and things back home, though I was from the deep South, she, Colorado. Her name was Cheryl and was 24 and I was 19. We quit writing when I came home and I have often wondered where she is today. We did appreciate those letters and thanks a million for them.
Mary, thanks for doing your part. Letters like that meant a lot to a LOT of guys. I was lucky enough to have a girl friend (now my wife) who wrote me almost every day I was over there. By the way, I live in Baileys Harbor, Door County, Wisconsin.
I’ve been on a spree these past couple days watching Vietnam veteran videos. My grandpa was a vet with the 101st during nam, and he recently passed a couple days ago so I’m just trying to still get a feel of him you know
I'm sure you are very proud, son.
Why when there gone u realize how you should of listen 👂
@@joegagnon2268 you realize you should have asked more questions.
@@bigMzurythefantatic ah the stoic kind of sorry have a great day
@@joegagnon2268 all good joe. You too bud.
Live you're life the best you can so that sacrifice was not in vain and never FORGET
Very smart guy plus high moral/ethical values, integrity and courage. American backbone.
I wanna say thank you to all Of our military veterans for what they've done to make our lifes Better
Thank you for your service. You were all heros in my book, and you are never forgotten. Disabled Combat Veteran Vietnam Hue & Khe Sanh
Thank you for your service Karl, and for being truly one of our finest. Rest in peace Charles Thomas.
Rest In Peace
Charles Thomas.
A good officer is one who listens to those around him.
Even if you disagree politically, we as a nation have a duty to honor our veterans and fallen warriors,. Because without them, our freedom would be nothing but a distant memory.
@Gary Williams Your words are well put.
He has a forever feeling about loosing a friend that civilian politician never have.
Salute to the heroes of the great USA 👍
My father served - tunnel rat - we never spoke of his 3 tours - I am proud of his service and i believe you did the best you could- it appears you where cut from the same bolts of cloth
Yankee Inmissouri ... I do not know how people could do that job.
Damn, he served as a tunnel rat and lived?
+1000 respect
thomas 19, with the heart of a lion
respect from germany
I salute you sir. From a former soldier to a former marine. Thank you for your service. Sfc Escalera 121st/FA. Iraq 07 - 08
A Man of principles and courage. Superb. Good luck to all.
IMO Karl Marlantes is one exceptional human being. I watched several videos dealing with his books and experiences in Vietnam and he's one top notch speaker.
Very touching story. Very brave men. Hands down. You'll never see r be forgotten 💔
Welcome home, Brother. May God bless you.
He is a MARINE First ! Semper Fi til I die ! Cpl. Steve eaton,HMM165,CH53CC,RVN/RNVN. 1972/73. Proudly served 1970 to 76. Please pray this holiday season for ALL U.S. men & woman in service ALL over the world. Regards, SCE.
It's really interesting the way he talks. I just finished reading Matterhorn (which I highly recommend you read) and his voice really comes through in the book. For example, the reverence he gives to radio operators comes through in the book, or the love that exists between people who have shared combat. This guy is amazing.
Yea the way he tried to talk was like he was telling himself that it’s ok and we all make mistakes
The end of inocence... so many young men lost it in so many wars. I thank you for your service.
Bless this man
I remember sitting on the bench in the Quad at midnight at the College where CS Lewis taught. It was so quiet. My friend Doug B was an SF medic at 21 years old. He couldn't save a kid who was bleeding out "he was like swiss cheese I couldn't stop it." He felt a duty to serve our country. Virtues of a generation and at great cost must never be forgotten. Thanks Karl.
Welcome home. Thank you Marine.
not for nothing , but there is not enough said for the families that are broken for our, and everyones liberty, thank you to all the families that sacrificed and endured the price for freedom. thank you boys and girls for all that you gave!! we love you
Thank you for giving me another piece of a family story and for living to tell it. My brother was one of the pilots that flew you all back and forth. He took me to the O Club one Friday night so he could get drunk enough to tell the flight students and pilots his "funny" stories about getting all the people on two helicopters back alive. I knew that he valued the life of every man on those two ships and did what he had to for them to live including flying an overloaded, wounded helicopter that they later told him could not fly. He agreed because there was no longer a reason to work that hard to fly it. Again, thank you for doing your very best in a bad situation and for coming home to tell the stories of those who can no longer tell what they gave for us.
Susan Mazzanti .
2 tours as a CAS pilot in support of those ground Marines and Helo pilots. Did all I could to keep the VC off their backs when I could. I consider myself to be very fortunate to make it home but still feel guilty about not being able to do more to support my fellow Marines. Got shot at but never hit as some of buddies were. I’ve never, and never will, regretted my serving in Nam and would do so again if called upon. Semper Fidelis to all Marines who answered the call as did this Marine.
@@skyhawk61 glad you made it back. My brother got a distinguished flying cross in Vietnam so I've heard some stories. My grandson is the youngest Marine in the family. I was always happy when they took the civilians off the gates in Corpus Christi. The Marines had orders so they had nothing to prove and were usually very nice.
As a US Marine combat experienced Vietnam veteran, I can tell you that Marlantes walked the walk and talked the talk. Ooo-Rah!!!
It really makes you feel for those young grunts - never had a chance to experience life and its joys. And they did it all so that we could enjoy our own lives. We need to remember that - every day of our free lives.
I have respect for all Vets no matter what war all of them did something that i can't physically or emotionally do
Your a hero sir.
Semper Fi sir. Love you very much and I'm glad you came home.
God Bless all who served and those serving now!
One of the most amazing touching stories of all time. Thank you for your service good sir!
I was a 2531 MOS, Vietnam Era Veteran, USMC. Something people don’t always realize is that Marines, because that’s what I know, has a Camaraderie. That means that although you fight amongst yourself, You Love those Guys, each and every one! To loose one is pretty devastating. This story brings much back. My heart hurts for this Lieutenant! Any Man in that situation make the best decision, based on what he knows, At that Instant!
I’d Love to communicate with this Man! Tell him, GOD’s grace and Love supersede’s all. And that means “All”.
Semper Fi
Knew nothing about Vietnam really. Just sat through the PBS documentary and got an eye opener and respect for the soldiers... Thank you for your service..sad story.
what a hero. god bless him and all those who served !
Karl's books are terrific. I highly recommend them.
This guy is a damn modest man but a true hero ....In a single year long active tour of duty in Vietnam as a rifle platoon leader and later as Executive Officer in the Charlie Company of the1st Battalion,4th Marine Regiment,3rd Marine Division from october 1968 to october 1969 he was awarded Navy Cross which is the us navy and marines second highest decoration awarded for valor in combat.....Apart from Navy Cross he also got a Bronze Star for valor ,2 Navy Commendation medal for valor, 2 purple Hearts and 10 Air Medals.
War is hell and I salute all veterans of all the wars for their bravery love for country and fortheir willingness to put their lives on the line so that we may live free and safe!!,..
Semper Fi Marine. Chi Lai Sept ‘66 Oct ‘67. Welcome home.
This is what I typically was around while a grunt in the Marine Corps. The best and brightest leaders I've ever seen. I'm old know but being a Marine grunt was without doubt the best
part of my life. Later in his life Ted Williams felt the same way about being a Marine pilot. I wish I was 17 again so I could run down to recruiting office and enlist again.
Welcome Home Marine! U.S Army 1965-67. Your country called and you answered..
Thank you all for your service 🙏 🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸🇺🇸
God Bless you sir. It was an immoral war not because our cause was not noble, but because the people at the top that escalated the conflict in 1964 had no intentions of winning it, a dastardly thing. It was a noble thing you did to volunteer to go because in an advancing civilization a soldier is to follow the commands of his superiors and his oath as an officer. How many 10s of 1000s of Marines have followed orders to take a hill they knew they could not take and died without resentment fighting to the death like your wonderful radioman and friend who is in heaven with Jesus smiling down at you right now. Well done. You were an inspiration on many levels.
@B M America always does the right thing we are told
They DID intend to win it. Unfortunately for them, the Soviet-supplied air defence systems proved to be too much for them...and the Vietnamese fought them to a 1:1 ratio in the air. Invading the North proved impossible so they got bogged down in a war of attrition in the South...which they ultimately lost.
Sir. Your books finally got me to the VA. I fought going for forty some years. USMC RVN 67/68 Thank You Sir
Welcome home Brother. "Semper Fi!"
God Bless you, Karl. The weight you carry is enormous. You are a great example for the rest of us.
I would like to thank AARP for telling these soldiers and sailors stories.