RARE FAILURE! Short Circuit? Misfire Evap | Chevy Silverado 5.3 P0300 P0455

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 6 вер 2024
  • Check out my Merchandise Store Below the video for Men's and Women's Apparel, MUGS and Stickers! rainmanraysrep...
    Support the channel on Patreon check out the bio: / rainmanraysrepairs
    Patreon is a "Tip Jar" I don't post much there, daily YT uploads is all that I can manage right now
    Must have for any toolbox!
    Bahco "Frustrated" Pliers AWESOME tool! amzn.to/3IfDeOa
    Brake Caliper Compressor: amzn.to/3gQBuiB
    GearWrench Hose Clamp Pliers: amzn.to/33YCVJ3
    Helping Hands Soldering Assistant: amzn.to/3GqnG9U
    My Camera Gear:
    Gopro Hero 8 amzn.to/3mPnpFA
    Gopro Hero 9 amzn.to/3EKDcM1
    Hero 8 Dual Charger amzn.to/3EId84c
    Flexible Camera Mount amzn.to/3Jywrk5
    As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. #commissionsearned.
    Also, I personally use or have used the products featured in my links and only recommended them if I feel they are of good quality.
    “All the videos, songs, images, and graphics used in the video belong to their respective owners and I or this channel does not claim any right over them.
    Copyright Disclaimer under section 107 of the Copyright Act of 1976, allowance is made for “fair use” for purposes such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, education and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing.”

КОМЕНТАРІ • 770

  • @PhuCatMan1
    @PhuCatMan1 2 роки тому +171

    I've spun wrenches on and off over the past 60 years and here I am, 75, snowed in, and I find your channel. I've been watching every day and I have to say I really enjoy your work, your fine attitude, your skills and integrity! My wife cannot for the life of her get why I can sit and watch you work for hours. It takes me back to a better time. Best of luck to you!!!

    • @dans_Learning_Curve
      @dans_Learning_Curve 2 роки тому +10

      Unless our wives work with us on our projects, there isn't any way they'd understand!
      I too enjoy every video and have learned to work more methodically!
      I do 97.3% of our own work on our vehicles. My newest vehicle is a 2003 Subaru Forester just nearing 200,000 miles. Just replaced the head gaskets because I got tired of smelling oil burning on the exhaust!

    • @Blalack77
      @Blalack77 2 роки тому +7

      That kind of reminds me of my grandpa, my dad and his 3 brothers. It's just my dad and his oldest brother left now and my dad will be 60 next year. My grandpa collected cars for most of his life and worked on them as a hobby and my dad and uncles all grew up fiddling with them. He still had hundreds of cars still up there when he passed (it was extremely sad when he started to give up working on them - he quit playing guitar around the same time - too shaky and weak for both) - but the cars ranged from maybe the early 30's to the mid 70's - my dad inherited them all. The auto mechanic gene about halfway skipped me (my dad and I have about equal patience levels so even though we'd watch and help him, he's the "I'll do it myself" type and can't stand to just watch someone else work - plus I was scared to death to dig into a car and mess it up - even though he could have easily fixed it - I did get a 64 1/2 Mustang from my grandpa and that's where I learned what I _do_ know) - but I'm pretty mechanically inclined in pretty much everything else and I could get a vehicle going but it's like my dad is a brain surgeon and I'm just trained in first aid. Sorry for such a long comment but anything about cars/mechanic work, guitars, semi trucks, logging or farming and I immediately think about my dad, my grandpa and my family. And my grandpa just passed back in September so that wound is barely scabbed over. He definitely had a young man's heart and mind in an old man's body.

    • @leifnilsen6107
      @leifnilsen6107 2 роки тому +1

      I agree

  • @jimclifford1241
    @jimclifford1241 2 роки тому +196

    Being a fan of both you and Eric O., I appreciate the occasional, respectful shout out to SMA. You both do it right ... and I appreciate that!

    • @sveinfarstad3897
      @sveinfarstad3897 2 роки тому +2

      Hello, like your name, when i was a little kid, i sang a song of Buz Clifford all the time. Baby sitti'n boogie.

    • @hillbilly8391
      @hillbilly8391 2 роки тому +3

      I second this opinion!! :-)

    • @brucetucker1833
      @brucetucker1833 2 роки тому +3

      I also agree with that

    • @dans_Learning_Curve
      @dans_Learning_Curve 2 роки тому +5

      Absolutely!
      Eric O. has earned a place in the diagnostic Hall of Fame!

    • @ehsnils
      @ehsnils 2 роки тому +2

      Add Diagnose Dan to the bunch of good car diagnostic UA-camrs.

  • @steveschwab922
    @steveschwab922 2 роки тому +96

    Well done Ray! Most of us would have fired parts cannons at the misfires and the EVAP purge solenoid. But we would have been disappointed. You sir are a master troubleshooter!

  • @rileypittmon
    @rileypittmon 2 роки тому +91

    the troubleshooting skills of this man are exceptional

    • @nightmarecivic
      @nightmarecivic 2 роки тому +2

      Has nothing on south man auto though

    • @Nina-rg8es
      @Nina-rg8es Рік тому

      Exceptionally poor, total incompetency.

  • @ggariepy
    @ggariepy 2 роки тому +45

    I've been DIY working on cars for 40 years. This is like a master class in diagnostics. Well done!

  • @jamiepatterson1214
    @jamiepatterson1214 2 роки тому +24

    Replacing parts isn't the gem of auto repair work. It's the ability to troubleshoot the problem and replace the correct part(s).
    Troubleshooting should be the main focus in teaching auto repair.

    • @johnangelico667
      @johnangelico667 2 роки тому

      To adapt Douglas Adams, author of Dirk Gently's Holistic Detective Agency:
      "Replacement of engine part: $2"
      "Knowledge of which part to replace (including saving the human race, sacrifice of one Schrodinger's cat, consumption of 4 cups of tea) $1998" 🙂

  • @angrybill
    @angrybill 2 роки тому +56

    I am impressed with your knowledge. I don't know how many years you have been working on cars or what educational opportunities you have availed yourself of. That said, it seems to me that your knowledge is incredibly diverse, covering so many different cars. Very impressive. I am a 79 year old man who started his mechanical career back around 1958 or so by opening up a flat head ford and doing some simple fixing. I have done a lot of car repair and I am impressed with your knowledge. Well done!

    • @juanawashington9940
      @juanawashington9940 2 роки тому +6

      When they started putting computers in cars, that's when they lost me

    • @martinaudet7687
      @martinaudet7687 2 роки тому +3

      @@juanawashington9940 That's why the scan tool has become the mechanic's best friend. if used well, it makes even today's repairs so much more straightforward.

    • @johncraig406
      @johncraig406 Рік тому

      @@martinaudet7687 I had just bought a 3rd new scan tool, INNOVA 5610 which is a great tool..... then I bought an '02 Ford 7.3L diesel Excursion, and find that it does not read every thing that it should ..... darn it. needs a special protocol for Ford diesel engines

  • @fawdyy1613
    @fawdyy1613 2 роки тому +25

    Hey Rainman my name is Brandon, im a young student in Missouri and im in a auto-mechanics class. Your videos are really inspiring and show me what its like to be in the shop and also give great tips i have watched a lot of your videos and there actually humorous i just want to thank you for the great content and keep up the great work!

    • @mikejacob3536
      @mikejacob3536 2 роки тому +2

      Learn well, Grasshopper. You carry the torch for the next generation!

    • @badgerfool1980
      @badgerfool1980 2 роки тому +4

      Let's go Brandon!

    • @fawdyy1613
      @fawdyy1613 2 роки тому +1

      @@mikejacob3536 ill make sure i do my absolute best! for a junior in high school a lot is headed my way!

    • @mikejacob3536
      @mikejacob3536 2 роки тому +1

      @@fawdyy1613 as someone on the other end of the career path, I can only encourage you to keep doing the next right thing.

  • @terrywilfong4780
    @terrywilfong4780 2 роки тому +29

    You have an amazing amount of patience to deal with that kind of service

    • @torchit007
      @torchit007 2 роки тому

      Their looking for Chevy Malibu steering wheels in Detroit...on Ebay

  • @thequickbrownfox7289
    @thequickbrownfox7289 2 роки тому +46

    As I get older I miss the days when you didn't need a computer in your car/truck.

    • @michaelvangundy226
      @michaelvangundy226 2 роки тому +2

      I can buy a small battery operated computer that can talk using satellites in orbit for a few hundred. But one to talk to my truck is a couple thousand and the wiring diagram is extra. What a rip off.

    • @beans4gas
      @beans4gas 2 роки тому +8

      You mean with a carb?
      And gasoline, no ethanol, where the truck could sit for 20+ years and you just toss in a new battery and it fires right up.

    • @StormsparkPegasus
      @StormsparkPegasus 2 роки тому +3

      @@michaelvangundy226 It's because most car manufacturers are using 20+ year outdated technology for their car computers, even today. This is also why the chip shortage is such a big deal. Because the semiconductor companies can't deal with manufacturing 20+ year old parts (which require a different process) when they are so behind on MODERN parts. Plus keeping production lines for such old hardware is expensive. (Consequently this is also why Tesla is not affected by the chip shortage nearly as much, because they use modern stuff.)

    • @stevewhite3424
      @stevewhite3424 2 роки тому

      @@StormsparkPegasus What you say is indeed true, however Tesla is going to find that theit new design Chips are going obsolete faster than ever. One example I can see rearing its ugly head in the not too distant future is the displays used on Tesla's will almost certainly go obsolete in the next 3 to 6 Years, especially if your Tesla is already 3 years old.

    • @rickchowsr2532
      @rickchowsr2532 2 роки тому +1

      Boycott electric cars

  • @brianbanks3044
    @brianbanks3044 2 роки тому +24

    and people wonder why some of these issues are so difficult to figure out....just because you have a scan tool , it doesn't pinpoint the exact problem....that's why when an auto parts store scans your codes, they end up selling you 6 parts when it may only be one or two.....this stuff is like surgery on an electrical level....if only people knew

    • @brettwalkom948
      @brettwalkom948 2 роки тому

      The scan tools is like a multimeter.. It's just another tool in your toolbox.. And like most tools you need to know how to use it

  • @dannylinc6247
    @dannylinc6247 2 роки тому +12

    Gotta love Mr wizards magic box.
    Service bulletins.
    And experience with pinpoint testing.
    That's what makes Ray so effective is his tenacity with seeing how it can go wrong and checking it that way too.
    It's a joy to watch and it's well edited.
    We may not get that kind of instant gratification on our own cars at shops because the boring reality has been delightfully edited out.
    Thanks Ray.
    You show things I didn't get to do with my Fluke meter.
    It would have been nice, back In the day, to even get authorized for the first hour of diagnosis according to state guidelines.
    Things took longer and they would try to speculate. The real right testing would occur, but after the guess was tried.
    Manuals were problematic also.
    You're lucky.
    Count your blessings, my friend. You show real qualities that are to be aspired to.

  • @markusallport1276
    @markusallport1276 2 роки тому +15

    sweet! If I recall, you went through this with them once before about a year ago, where the service never called you back and you had to call them again the next day. It seem they are not very assistive to your needs as a paid service. "Click!"

  • @IanTheRabbit
    @IanTheRabbit 2 роки тому +2

    21:02 who noticed the Chevy had a German plate in the front
    Oh and I think electric avenue is a good background song

    • @Blurky82
      @Blurky82 2 роки тому +1

      Parking ze auto and poppening ze hood applies for this car👌

  • @lambertsland
    @lambertsland 2 роки тому +15

    Amazing! You work efficiently while recording--edit and put out videos daily--have a family (I believe)--watch other mechanics' videos--and read comments too. "I'll have what your having" (quote from an old movie)

  • @IR-nq4qv
    @IR-nq4qv 2 роки тому +8

    Diagnostics is not listed among my favorite time waster videos but for some reason I watched and enjoyed this one in its entirety, it must due to Ray's charm and down to earth slant that keeps me captivated.
    Diagnostics complete, I like this channel
    Powering down... "Bee--Youuuuu!

  • @thehoneybadger8089
    @thehoneybadger8089 2 роки тому +1

    So glad I live in southern Arizona. It would take 100 years for a vehicle in Arizona to turn into a rustbucket like 10 year old vehicles in Florida. Of course, the plastic parts on vehicles here are pretty well shot in 20 years from the intense UV light.

    • @fastsvtt
      @fastsvtt 2 роки тому

      Florida vehicles dont rust lol

    • @chrisfreemesser5707
      @chrisfreemesser5707 2 роки тому

      @@fastsvtt They do if they're near the coast where the salty air from the ocean gets to them

    • @chrisfreemesser5707
      @chrisfreemesser5707 2 роки тому

      Or 5 years here in New York :(

  • @Blalack77
    @Blalack77 2 роки тому +1

    Damn.. There's nothing quite like the feeling of fixing something - everything from a cellphone to a computer to vehicles to heavy equipment to a house and everything in between. And it adds to the feeling whenever whatever you're fixing would be totally shot without a fix.

  • @AntonioClaudioMichael
    @AntonioClaudioMichael Рік тому +2

    Very good diag proving the Ecm Failed and fried the vent solenoid by hooking the un programed ecm back up to see if regular functions work before programming and showing the ground side switches off the ecm @Rainman Ray's Repairs

  • @seanlevoy9446
    @seanlevoy9446 2 роки тому +1

    I have a 2000 Silverado and replaced the ECM about 4 months ago. I ordered it online and gave them my VIN. It showed up a few days later already programmed. All I had to do is do a key relearn which is done with the truck, no computer. Works great.

  • @deanmoberg445
    @deanmoberg445 2 роки тому +8

    I know I have posted before how much I appreciate you be a diagnostichian! Love that you check and confirm failure of components rather than the " parts cannon" good job Ray.

  • @diggerman7022
    @diggerman7022 2 роки тому +15

    11:38 They aren't always identical there's quite a few parts for my K2500 where the AC and GM part numbers are significantly different. Maybe they've changed that in the past 22 years but since they still sell OEM parts from that era they keep the two line label. Great video!

  • @tstuart7333
    @tstuart7333 2 роки тому +19

    Rainman I'm just so glad to be here and glad to hear that you are once again are glad to be here. I think we are all glad to be here. We are all sitting comfortable wait patiently on you called us all together to learn a little, laugh a little and hopeful getting a taste of yourself talking nicely to the parts and tools.

    • @kirara2516
      @kirara2516 2 роки тому +1

      And calling out Gravity for its mischief. Lol.

  • @brianohara5696
    @brianohara5696 2 роки тому +4

    Eric O and his family are a pleasure to watch !!!

  • @scallums
    @scallums 2 роки тому +5

    If the system is actually sealed ..... if you command purge and seal the fuel tank pressure sensor will show an increase in vacuum and will stall the engine....the engine vacuum will fight against the fuel pump and starve the engine of fuel... Quick and easy verification test. Heat up the evap vent tube and it will come right off, while it is still warm you can shove it directly on the new vent...

    • @randallstewart8487
      @randallstewart8487 2 роки тому +1

      I was thinking a little heat would bring it off without cutting too,I have a purge valve I am going to do this with on a BMW!

  • @paulpierce4818
    @paulpierce4818 2 роки тому +1

    Heavy Duty, Over the Road Trucking going computerized on their engines made me retire after 35 years. I couldn't keep up with technology. I could rebuild and repair anything our company had. Until computers failed me in old school trouble shooting. I miss it. And your knowledge fascinates me. So may times I want to reach out and smack you for not doing something so simple on hardware issues.

  • @gusman412
    @gusman412 2 роки тому +2

    Being a Master tech ( currently retired ) all I can say is great job with diag. and repair procedure ! I always said COVER YOUR ASS. Andyou did down to perfection !

  • @spelunkerd
    @spelunkerd 2 роки тому +6

    The volume of your uploads is amazing, especially considering your video quality.

  • @FlyEaglesFly19111
    @FlyEaglesFly19111 2 роки тому +1

    Who says mechanics aren't skilled labor. Well Ray you are sir skilled labor. You are a certainly a craftsman of your trade. Stay safe and be well bud.

  • @donw3912
    @donw3912 2 роки тому +2

    The gal on the other end and confirming VIN...I would think she would be able to see the year make and model. As for diagnosing..whoever taught you about automotive electronics and how thing work together in harmony did a fabulous job. I bet that purge solenoid wasnt a cheap part either...taken out by the ECM. A great video as always Ray!!

  • @martinnaylor5461
    @martinnaylor5461 2 роки тому +6

    Trouble shooting par excellence Ray. You are the man, never taking what is read as gospel.
    Most people would be ripping out fuel injectors etc to fix problems.But you with your vast experience know to look elsewhere first.excellent first class 👍.
    Oh,that reminds me to remind you to have a great day 🇬🇷😃👍

  • @toddgiambruno
    @toddgiambruno 2 роки тому +6

    Thank you Ray for your integrity and accurate diagnosis. I am a big fan of SMA also. Are you at liberty to say what other technicians on You Tube you value and appreciate? Anyone else in New York State that I could utilize?

  • @austinv183
    @austinv183 2 роки тому +8

    This episode reminded me of dealing with verizons completely incompetent remote network engineers when installing cellular internet backups. Every single time, the unit that they were supposed to preconfigure arrives totally unconfigured, and when you finally get them on the phone and remoted in after a godam hour, they can't even log in to the thing, just sit there guessing passwords for an hour refusing to escalate, when if they woul've just given me credentials i could've had the thing installed in 30 minutes.

  • @philippedamours7433
    @philippedamours7433 2 роки тому +4

    I find myself talking back to you, alone, in front of my screen and I feel good about it. Love your content man, keep it up ! You make me learn new things everyday !

  • @shawnmcdonald1706
    @shawnmcdonald1706 2 роки тому +6

    Well done on being patient with the programmer and the fixes

  • @realeyesrealizereallies6828
    @realeyesrealizereallies6828 2 роки тому +7

    Wow, those people at GM are rough....Nice job, that one was also educational....Very nice....

  • @thegavinhorn1191
    @thegavinhorn1191 2 роки тому +1

    RAY!!!! Thank you so so much. I am 16 and I have been trying to find out why my dads 03 express van was having this problem. I couldn't find it anywhere. It has been having this problem ever since I replaced the crankshaft position sensor. This helped me so much Ray. Thank you!!

  • @williamball5747
    @williamball5747 2 роки тому +1

    watching you i have learned a lot. i am 63 and know now i am dumb with these new fangled cars.

  • @mikeball2949
    @mikeball2949 2 роки тому +1

    Hi Ray. I want to applaud you for being honest and respectful. You are to vehicles like Mike Holmes is to houses. Thank you

  • @dans_Learning_Curve
    @dans_Learning_Curve 2 роки тому +4

    Thank you for testing the ground wire for a short to ground! I was hoping for this test before you condemned the ECU.

  • @hansjansen7047
    @hansjansen7047 2 роки тому

    Got my own ID. I used my wife's before. I didn't realize that changing an ECM was so complicated. BIG THANK YOU

  • @kris856
    @kris856 2 роки тому +10

    This was really interesting to watch - your way of working as well as the troubleshooting skills are worth every dime and every second of watching

  • @golf25radioman
    @golf25radioman Рік тому

    I learned something today! It's a good day! I didn't know that the ECM in a vehicle had to go through that to be replaced. Thanks for taking us through that procedure. And, as always, your excellent diagnostic procedures...a pleasure to watch.

  • @JimmyMakingitwork
    @JimmyMakingitwork 2 роки тому +7

    Only Fords require 2 keys from what I've seen. :)
    Nice work as usual Ray. I'll bet the solenoid shorted and took out the driver, but I suppose the order of failure isn't really of important. What matters is it's fixed.

    • @BigLisaFan
      @BigLisaFan 2 роки тому +1

      My 1996 Chevy and 1976 MG both require 2 keys.

    • @johnfranklin5277
      @johnfranklin5277 2 роки тому

      They are talking about 2 ignition keys.

  • @ToddAdams1234
    @ToddAdams1234 2 роки тому +3

    Ray, heater hose isn’t sufficient for that repair. It’s not fuel or fuel-fume resistant. There’s actually a form of fuel line made by Gates Rubber Co. that is. You could probably get away with using some silicone hose for that.
    I worked in the parts store industry for 30yr. I know what I know “REEE”!

    • @edbernard4289
      @edbernard4289 2 роки тому +1

      Your not supposed to use garden hose as a heater hose but I've seen it done and lasted for years without failure....

    • @richzahnle8198
      @richzahnle8198 2 роки тому

      The TSB states to install 5/8 heater hose and route it to an area above the transmission (not re-connect it like Ray did)

    • @ToddAdams1234
      @ToddAdams1234 2 роки тому

      Heater hose will NOT hold up! Nowhere near as long as fuel line. I’ve seen it MANY times over my 30yrs in the auto parts parts business. I don’t care what ANY TSB says, don’t use heater hose where any petroleum (liquid or fumes) go through it! I’ll argue with whoever came up with that TSB until they realize the fault that they are causing!

  • @jeffboyer8214
    @jeffboyer8214 2 роки тому +1

    Paint works well 😌 lol.
    That's exactly how I would fix e vap system done it many times.
    The programming ppl seem to be God on this video 📹.
    Lack of rot is making me want to move lol . 😆
    Be safe and have a great day.

  • @stevebrown4985
    @stevebrown4985 Рік тому

    I like it that you're so honest !!!

  • @davidnaish6804
    @davidnaish6804 2 роки тому +1

    Looking at what has to be done for diagnosis now a days, I'm glad I got off the bench years ago.
    Give me points & condensers anyday. Great work Ray!

  • @juanawashington9940
    @juanawashington9940 2 роки тому

    Everyone should have a mechanic like Ray...the motoring world would be a much happier place

  • @colbiecolbie6979
    @colbiecolbie6979 2 роки тому

    Impressed me with that diagnosis/repair.

  • @GUIRADE95
    @GUIRADE95 2 роки тому

    Hi there, same here I been working in our cars since early 80s. This all by wire vehicle's are something else. I do all mechanic and electronics in any car, have all this fancy gadgets as well. Just gotta keep up and going. Kind regards from Bogota Colombia South America.

  • @pzoe3808
    @pzoe3808 2 роки тому

    Been a tech since 1981 nice videos to see what is going on now. Thanks

  • @yowekemos2549
    @yowekemos2549 2 роки тому

    It's obvious Ray has a next level intelligence with car diagnosis and repair or maintenance. It's a natural gift. No amount of education or experience can put anyone to this level.
    Maybe talking to the camera is massively improving his skills level.🤣
    It's amazing how you are knowledgeable in both mechanical and electrical diagnostic techniques and maintenance.
    Well done Ray. 👏
    If you had your own automotive shop, you will become a J- OF ALL TRADES.

  • @kenc2257
    @kenc2257 2 роки тому +2

    Programming/reprogramming ECMs is such an interesting process. It's like you've used 2 very different skill sets. [and it 'solved'/resolved the misfire issues]

    • @GReaper
      @GReaper 2 роки тому

      Ignition is handled a similar fashion. The ECM maintains ground on the coil (iirc) and disconnects the ground to cause a spark to fire across the plug. The fried ground circuit was probably preventing the ECM from being able to disconnect the ignition grounds properly, or could have been preventing the ECM from grounding the injectors to fire. (The ECM uses ground instead of the +12v line to control a lot of stuff.) Either way, the result was the same. And the failed evap valve was the clue to find the culprit of it all. Ray actually made it a point to make sure the ECM was bad, which is great.

  • @tomtke7351
    @tomtke7351 2 роки тому +1

    in my industry they were plagued with damaged pins when seating connectors. As such, they REQUIRED an inhouse certification called mate/demate. It was a frequent retraining lasting 4 hours. One simple and essential element was: visually inspect both connector halves before mating. I still do this for any of my electronics.... Cars too!!

    • @blackwolfnews1722
      @blackwolfnews1722 2 роки тому

      Awe! You help couples who have a hard time trying to make babies! What a noble profession! And that you can translate that to automotive issues...wow!

  • @IMelkor42
    @IMelkor42 Рік тому

    The new ECU will be programmed from factory with the correct firmware, so that's why it's able to communicate and function out of the box.
    I think what needs copying over are the specific calibration values for that particular car.

  • @dougwood6685
    @dougwood6685 2 роки тому

    You are the very best at explaining and diagnosing vehicle problems

  • @aaronthrowa
    @aaronthrowa 2 роки тому

    Wow.... extensive process. Things have changed since the 80s

  • @Autokey_Security_Services
    @Autokey_Security_Services 2 роки тому

    When you check purge you also need to command it to seal and make sure it's not pulling vacuum when commanded off ...

  • @craigsparton
    @craigsparton 2 роки тому +1

    28:25 "The engine will race to redline, then initialize a fuel cutoff, and at that moment it has learned the relationship between the crankshaft and camshaft". Nope, that isn't what it's doing. The misfire monitor closely watches the crankshaft speed during a firing event. It expects the crankshaft to speed up by a certain amount, and if that doesn't happen it knows that cylinder didn't fire. This is very precise, and any internal variance in speed due to engine balance or any other factor must accounted for to prevent false misfire codes.. When you snap the throttle to RPM cutout, the ECM records these speed variances as the engine decelerates, during fuel cutoff so there's are no firing events altering the speed of the crankshaft. This gives it a "pure" signal to compare with and know the true RPM change of each cylinder during firing events. It is not measuring the variance of the camshaft sensor or even considering its input during this relearn procedure.
    14:05 "I speculate that the ECM failed first, and continued to energize that solenoid until it burned out". Very unlikely. The driver transistor for the vent solenoid is certainly shorted inside the PCM, and in the overwhelming majority of cases these transistors fail because the component they control is shorted, causing too much current to flow through the transistor. The typical failure mode of these transistor is shorting across all terminals, which is why you saw a direct short to ground. One might wonder why these transistors don't have better protection against overcurrent, and that is a very good question indeed.
    (edit) Speaking of the misfire monitor, what about those stored misfires? Of the two codes that was easily the most important one, but I never heard you mention that code P0300 again. I guarantee you the vent solenoid being shorted didn't cause that.

  • @garethswaffs
    @garethswaffs 2 роки тому +4

    As an Avid Eric O fan, I appreciate the name drop, both your channels are a great learning tool, thanks!

  • @TSKseattle
    @TSKseattle 2 роки тому

    As an old shade tree mechanic, one of the things watching this channel has amazed me is that although I know that codes are stored to tell you what's happened, I didn't know that with the right scan tool you could activate/deactivate subsystems all over the car.
    Having to call and make an appointment to install a new computer is startling.
    There is still a lot of basic wrench turning that goes on, but wow, I'm never attempting to work on a modern car except to change the oil or maybe do brakes.

  • @eddieparent6132
    @eddieparent6132 2 роки тому +1

    I really like your channel, you are a gentleman and a scholar. I hope some day I could shake your hand, Your a very knowledgeable person.

  • @danburch9989
    @danburch9989 2 роки тому

    All the complexities of cars today and the equipment to troubleshoot and maintain them along with the training required is no wonder it costs tons of money for relatively simple repairs. The days of the shade tree mechanic are fading fast. Back when I was a kid in the last century, a car with 50k miles on it was considereed old. Now it's not unusual to get 150k+ miles and still be a young car.

  • @Maples01
    @Maples01 2 роки тому

    Dad's 2000 Chevy 4x4 with the 5.3 keeps popping the EVAP code, he brings it to me to get me to clear the code and he goes on his way, happy the lights out for another week or so.

  • @DrShock
    @DrShock 2 роки тому +3

    My first reaction to that RAP (remote assisted programming) tool experience was when do you ask for a refund and send it back! I presume it's the lesser of evils working in a shop that takes all makes as yours does tho, as otherwise you'd have to have dozens of different programming tools. I prefer complete control of the job end to end, so I'm glad I only focus on GM brand module programming to do it myself seeing that _remote_ experience you had there. ;-)
    BTW, those ACDelco and GM part numbers are not always the same. They are the same for parts only GM sells from the dealer, but anything ACDelco also sells retail will have their own unique ACD number in that field.

  • @rayshutsa6690
    @rayshutsa6690 2 роки тому

    This is another great diagnosis and repair. Everyone have a great day.

  • @PapaKellogs
    @PapaKellogs 2 роки тому

    I have a truck just like that plagued with evap issues, will definitely share this vid with my mechanic... Lol j/k that's me! Last resort paying for ecm. Thanks for the info on the bulletin about the hoses, I was afraid to pull it off and breaking/cracking them. Love your vids btw! Side note I have 160k miles on my 4wd Z71 ext cab so far

  • @sethgibbons80
    @sethgibbons80 2 роки тому

    Glad to see I’m not the only one that doesn’t like straight cuts!

  • @Starchface
    @Starchface 2 роки тому

    I swear that person you first talked to is the same one months ago. She flaked out on you that time as well, leaving you waiting around after hours, and on a Friday as I remember. Absolutely brilliant customer service.

  • @dc3mech1
    @dc3mech1 2 роки тому +1

    You and Eric O are the bomb! So fun to watch y'alls vids.

  • @angrydogvw8067
    @angrydogvw8067 2 роки тому

    Very interesting, I'm learning things....didn't know how that all worked but it does make sense.

  • @codyluka8355
    @codyluka8355 2 роки тому

    I've been chasing misfires and purge valve codes for a while now. I have thrown a few parts at it...tune up, distributor, fuel pump (it was getting noisy anyway). I never thought of the ECM! That might be the ticket. It's a 2005 GMC Safari van. The codes are the dreaded P0300 and the Evap vaccum leak. The purge valve works as I hear it clicking, but I may still have a leak.

  • @KenMagee
    @KenMagee 2 роки тому +6

    Damn, a 2004 with 51k miles. That's crazy!

    • @321CatboxWA
      @321CatboxWA 2 роки тому

      I have a 04 2500hd with 51,800 10yold tires too .

  • @mph5896
    @mph5896 2 роки тому +2

    That programming thing, Ugg. To bad your shop doesn't have a cardaq and laptop to do their own programming. Guess that takes skilled technicians to perform though.

  • @loveofchrist5808
    @loveofchrist5808 2 роки тому

    Everything you did today is beyond my reach I was taught back in the 70s about automobiles and now that automobiles have all these computers and all these sensors to be quite honest Ray this crap scares the 💩out of me. Ray can you recommend a school or somewhere I can teach myself that information? God bless your boss you’re the man✝️✝️✝️

  • @mwalker9401
    @mwalker9401 2 роки тому

    That joint might be fine, but heater hose isn't made for hydrocarbon resistance. Gasoline vapors will pass through it and soften it. That should be PCV/Emissions hose, or fuel/oil hose.

  • @ianwheat1577
    @ianwheat1577 2 роки тому +2

    Surely plug in and go should be on the ecm all that mess about these electronics are a pain

    • @chrisfreemesser5707
      @chrisfreemesser5707 2 роки тому +1

      It's entirely possible for them to design these systems so modules don't need to be programmed, but if they did that (a) they would lose the revenue stream from requiring programming, and (b) there would be rampant theft/resale of the modules. It's kind of a no-win situation I guess

  • @ReneSchickbauer
    @ReneSchickbauer 2 роки тому

    For stuff controlled by a MOSFET ("high power transistor"), stick in a 1 Megaohm resistor parallel to your DMM wires. Some MOSFETs (and Diodes for that matter) tend to leak a very small amount of current that can build of a charge on the switched side. From the point of any equipment that uses power, the circuit is OFF, but when no load is connected a DMM can read "ON".
    For this reason, i'm usually including a 1 meg resistor across all MOSFETs on my circuit boards (at least those that might not have a load connected at all times).
    It's not a problem in the case of this video, just trying to help avoiding possibly time consuming wrong diagnosis.

  • @ZerotheWanderer
    @ZerotheWanderer 2 роки тому

    As someone who has dealt with delivering and stocking auto parts for the last 2+ years, the listing of specific part numbers for different brands just helps the source person(s) be less confused. Having line codes shown would be beneficial but that would be a per-retailer basis and not a producer basis, as everyone's line code system is different.

  • @bobbarron6969
    @bobbarron6969 2 роки тому

    I watch only two auto repair channels - yours and Eric O's. I know how to spin wrenches, but you guys are master classes in diagnostics.

  • @michaelcook184
    @michaelcook184 2 роки тому +1

    That is quite the procedure what a pain

  • @ronnydowdy7432
    @ronnydowdy7432 2 роки тому

    I like how you troubleshoot different things to make sure you get a true repair. Great show

  • @jamesvanzijl4348
    @jamesvanzijl4348 2 роки тому

    Here is South Africa , the 5 piont summit V8 engines are giant size !
    Over here 3L v6 engibes and 4 L v6 engines are the powerfull units. Ford South Africa has the 2.2 Litre straght 4 here , but I must say for the size , tge performance is very very goid.
    Alsolight on diesel fuel !

  • @knutsmilden6353
    @knutsmilden6353 2 роки тому

    I realy like the way that you work, and trouble shoot everything. Your vids are enjoyable

  • @marksmallman4572
    @marksmallman4572 2 роки тому +1

    You and Eric should meet up for a beer, might be a long drive, for you both.. enjoy both of your channels very much.

  • @spelunkerd
    @spelunkerd 2 роки тому +6

    Using a multimeter in resistance mode can be confusing and misleading when there is active power from other connected devices going through a line. Even in voltage drop mode, using voltage drop across an open connector when ground is switched off may be confusing because of ghost voltage and unknown downstream variables. An incandescent test light bypasses many of those issues, it speaks to the question of line resistance on both sides, and it does so in a more trustworthy ten second screening test. Eric and Paul aren't luddites, they use a tool from the past, worth $18, for a reason.

    • @michael931
      @michael931 2 роки тому +1

      Yes. Test light. $3.99 at HF.

    • @spelunkerd
      @spelunkerd 2 роки тому

      @@michael931 Only thing is, it needs to be incandescent, an LED test light doesn't draw enough current. OTC sell a good one.

  • @ericcardinal4788
    @ericcardinal4788 2 роки тому +5

    I wonder what those ECM modules cost now. I replaced one in 1988/1989. Even back then they ran around 400-500 per.

    • @trshorte
      @trshorte 2 роки тому +2

      Using the same part number as in the video, Rockauto has it for $176.79 plus a $100.00 core charge

    • @captinbeyond
      @captinbeyond 2 роки тому

      I'm a bit puzzled at why the ECm was bad with such low mileage ....and also wonder how long it was throwing the EVAP code? If the ecm was keeping the purge vent solenoid from open all the time, shouldn't that have thrown a code?

  • @zalmaflash
    @zalmaflash Рік тому

    I learned on a flathead 1950 Ford. All I had to know was "righty tighty lefty loosey". Times change.

  • @michaelfairchild
    @michaelfairchild 2 роки тому

    10:11 "Push it..." Classic from Scar Face.

  • @TimSpaw1leg
    @TimSpaw1leg 2 роки тому +3

    I need to get one of those scanners.. I'm still using my ear with an old broom stick to find clicks, dings and misfires..

    • @mikeboring2172
      @mikeboring2172 2 роки тому

      And it works, doesn't it?

    • @TimSpaw1leg
      @TimSpaw1leg 2 роки тому +1

      @@mikeboring2172 yes it does.. haha..

  • @lechatbotte.
    @lechatbotte. 2 роки тому +1

    No rrrreeeesss here. What a pain all this emissions crap is. Glad to see your excellent work.

  • @craven3190
    @craven3190 2 роки тому

    This was a cool video. Never seen an ECM replaced and programmed.

  • @adamskiharvey3684
    @adamskiharvey3684 2 роки тому

    As an owner of a 142k mile CLK230 W208, I had a confusing problem. The problem was that it dropped a random cylinder, but run beautiful with no overheating issues, no loss of compression and no leaks. In other words it shut fuel and spark off to any 1 of the 4 cylinders. It would run like a cylinder gasket leak. This is a protection if a misfire was detected.
    Originally I thought it to be a duff plug, so installed with new plugs and coil packs. This, however did not fix the issue.
    I scanned for DTCs to find a multitude of parameters well outside the factory parameters and codes.
    Now, one has to point one small, but important detail out. I filled my fuel tank with E10 fuel. From this point on the misfire began. But I did not believe it to be the fuel.
    I could of gone through all the other fixes, but would of got expensive. Realising that E10 may not well on the older cars, I had to drain and refill with E5 99 Ron fuel. It the car runs sweet again and parameters are now within its factory parameters.
    The moral to this story, don't use the nasty E10 fuel on older vehicles with a bit of milage on it.

  • @DaleB809
    @DaleB809 2 роки тому

    Nit very honest people in this business. Most would just load the parts cannon and have at er. Great video

  • @drivewaygarage1561
    @drivewaygarage1561 2 роки тому

    Nice of you to mention Eric from South main auto, he is a great mechanic

  • @MrDrytone
    @MrDrytone 2 роки тому

    I use a load to test triac inputs , meters always show volts on triacs , test filament lamps work well to see if triac on or off.

  • @george8873
    @george8873 2 роки тому +2

    2004 with only 51k miles is pretty rare in my experience. Must not drive it every day or sticks around town with it.

  • @keithfork8663
    @keithfork8663 2 роки тому

    Eric O and Ray.....the best.

  • @29auto30
    @29auto30 2 роки тому

    Thanks! Now I am going to be singing “electric Avenue”. All day long. 😂😂