One of the saddest theories I’ve heard and my personal hand canon is that Mace Windu was planning on making Anakin a Jedi master after his duel with Palpatine having finally come to trust Skywalker
It seemed like Mace Windu was at first hesitant of Anakin, I assume it reminded him of his younger self, but it seemed like he was becoming more and more interested in him, easier to see in the Clone Wars. I think he was trying to test and distance Anakin from the situation, knowing his how close he was to Palpatine.
He should've pretended to trust Anakin more at least smh in this case honesty was not a virtue
He shouldn't have tried to kill Palpatine right in front of Anakin though. That was the last straw that broke Vader, seeing how meaningless the code actually was to his supposed master and wiser teacher.
Yeah that’s what would have happened the Anikan would have gotten all the answers he was looking for
What if Kenobi took Anakin to Dooku to be trained, forming a new order of force users. Instead of Dooku turning to the dark side.
I feel like this is one step off of reality, because I truly believe Windu was acting more as a harsh father than a jealous or angered rival. I believe that Anakins final test was spying on Palpatine, whether anything came of it or not, because it would show Anakin was willing to put aside his personal relationships and emotions for the sake of his brothers in the Jedi order. Anakin was so close to his perfect life in that office, but his blade struck the wrong person.
In the ROTS novel it's revealed that the only reason Anakin really cared about being promoted to Jedi Master was that one of the perks was being granted access to the 'Forbidden' Jedi Archives, including any archives pertaining to Force Healing...
Force Healing is something that requures one to have the affinity for it.
I'm not sure if that applies to healing bleedee crystals though
Well, yeah. He wanted information on how to save padme. That's why he had to side with palpatine because he felt he had no other option.
I'm blown away. Seriously the best one you've done mate. You should be proud of this. Love the fact you've finally added abeloth into this. An idea would be what if abeloth escaped at the birth of anakin and took him under her wing?
@@PentePatrolStarWars Imagine Sidious saying to him "ANAKIN SKYWALKER YOU'RE TRAINING IS COMPLETE
Wow! You took the story beyond the initial premise. Really felt like a natural progression of Anakin’s Story. Seems like the next “What If” is going to be great btw. This really shows the Tragedy of Anakin Skywalker in a different way.
there is a reaosn why i never want to watch epsoide 3. it is trgedy and makes me sad
This was a really good one. Cool seeing non-common antagonists like this. Would be cool to see a what if that brings in uncommon stuff from legends like the Mnggal-Mnggal, the Yuuzhan Vong, or the Rakata into the story.
Great idea! What if Ahsoka turned Anakin back to the light on Malachor in Twilight of the apprentice?
Conversely could do the same thing with vader v kenobi duel in the latest series
@@harmannbhasin9170 Ahsoka and Anakin were much closer than he was with Obi-Wan.
@@Goblinhandler just gonna point out that they are pretty close too. He cared very deeply about them both and it's hard to tell who is closer
What if Asoka saved Steela Gerera?
What if Obi trained Anakin one on one with Satines help?
What if the Jedi rid the Galaxy of Slavery after Aayla was found?
What if every Jedi was required to Learn and Teach Force Heal?
What if Satine was Anakins Mother?
What if Sabine kept the Darksaber to Lead Mandalore?
Mace Windu: You are on this council, and we Grant you the Rank of Master
Anikan: What? This is Acceptable. It's FAIR! I can BE on the council, and BE a Master.
Mace Windu: Take a SEAT, Master Skywalker.
I wonder if Samuel L. Jackson felt a shiver when you wrote "Master" Skywalker
Abeloth would be indeed a tough enemy to defeat. And I believe that you're right about the fact that only Anakin can defeat her (hell, not even a black hole could do that). Anyways, it's a very interesting story and especially the villain here was surprising and had me hold my breath for a couple of minutes!
What if Jango Fett Didn't die? as much as I love your stories you seem to concentrate on the more mainline characters I think it would be fun to follow the story of someone who isn't force sensitive and see his impact on the clone wars and beyond
The Null and Alpha class ARCs would follow Jango either as mercenaries or taking over Mandalore. Neither group of clones was particularly loyal to the republic so if they defected it wouldn’t be too surprising.
This has to be one of my favorite what if’s so far! Despite losing his student, and his masters, Anakin truly did have a happy ending at the end. This brings joy to my heart! Also 14th attempt at what if Aniken and Galen were rivals and train together!
This is crazy seeing the progression of your story telling. Your channel has also grown so quickly. Keep it up with the stories my man.
Here are some What If Ideas you may find of interest:
- What if the Grand Inquisitor survived the events of Rebels
- What if Ashoka confronted Vader soon after Order 66
- What if Han Solo had force potential
- What if Anakin/Padme had Triplets (Based on the confusion fans had of Yodas "no, there is another" line. Maybe Han is the 3rd, or perhaps Galen Marek)
- What if The Force Unleashed was canon/What if Starkiller was an Inquisitor
- What if Chewbacca had Force Potential/was a Jedi
- What if Han paid off his Debt to Jabba before A New Hope
What if Anakin and padme joined the CIS on Geonosis
What if Reven was pulled into the future by the force to teach Anakin
What if the lord of hunger teached Anakin
The moment I realized you brought Abeloth into a story with prequel characters, I damn near got chills.
you should do one "what if Mace died at the start of the Clone Wars?" - think about it, his rudness to Anakin and Ahsoka would be gone, Yoda would have faced Palpatine with the 4 masters and would have won, someone else would have gone to the Wookies. .........
Had a random thought about "what if there was a Mandalorian trained by the Jedi, but because Mandalorian reasons they never stay with the order" and it got me thinking about how they'd integrate their jetpacks and flamethrowers into their lightsaber fighting style. Now I know theres the whole Visla story with the Darksaber, bit I'm talking a Mandalorian Jedi who doesn't really stick with the Order.
Probably integrate form 4 with mando jetpack maneuverability and their arsenal of weapons on top of that.
I have some What ifs that I think you find interesting and fun to write about and hope you like these What ifs
1.What if Eeth Koth trained Anakin Skywalker
2.What if Cin Drallig trained Anakin Skywalker
3.What if Anakin Skywalker and Serra Keto fallen in love
4.What if Anakin Skywalker was raised by Sharad hett and the Tusken Raiders
"Anakin cried out with a monstrous "NOOOOOOOO!"" Love your writing and Delivery!!
Shatterpoint, yes! I'd love a deep lore video on that, cause I've only ever seen it given love twice, once in Clone Wars and once in the *old* Clone Wars, that was on Cartoon Network, though the latter is not directly pointed out. But it is speculated that Mace was able to destroy super battle droids with his bare fists by utilizing the shatterpoint ability to see where their weakest points were.
It would have been more interesting if the Council revealed that they were not granting him the role of Master because they knew he was "secretly" married and he should be grateful that they were not expelling him from the Jedi Order outright.
Honestly this is one of your best ones and love the twist you had for this very unique.
The grand inquisitor saying "hElLo" right at the beginning made me burst into a fit of giggles 🤣
Ahhh! Master-ful!
I have a request for December:
What if Ahsoka, ANAKIN, & OBI-WAN went to Mandalore?
this was so sad but so good, I like how you kept the story going after the end of the cloners
This hands down has to be one of my favorite what if’s I’ve ever listened to. I’ve always thought about the possibility of those two fighting at this full potentials and you didn’t disappoint. While listening, I got the feeling Abeloth was going to be in this and was so hyped when The Mother’s name was dropped. Keep up the awesome work man, cannot wait for What if Revan trained Anakin!
You don’t ever kill Ahsoka
What if a brief glitch in a clone’s inhibitor chip caused him to murder Palpatine when his guard was down, and completely forget what he just did. Security footage shows a figure in phase 2 clone armour committing the murder, but no identifying markings, just a clone.
EMOKIN?!? AS A MASTER?!?
YOU MUST BE JOKING
in all seriousness, this is a great concept, and you executed it perfectly. You have come on leaps and bounds. Well done PPSW!
WoW, I’m proud on you man. You Did a great job
See how much can change when people say or do something differently, folks.
First off this was a great what if (as always)!
I know that you're doing only what ifs at the moment, but is there a possibility that you release a video on your own star wars saga, like essentially "rewriting" the movies to your own desire or tell your version of what happened after episode 6. As I and many others think, that Disney did a terrible job at making episodes 7-9. I also do believe that a creative mind of your scale could easily handle this task alot better.
I wish you all the best for the Future!
Keep it going my man!
I intend on it... knowing how in depth I do these stories I won't be doing it until after around 100k subs so that it'll reach a larger group of you :)
What if earth was in the Star Wars universe
What if anakin was a foundling of the true mandalorians
What if Luke became a foundling
What if anakin was revans reincarnation or descendent
What if shmi was a former Jedi either exiled or left the order
What if barriss and ahsoka fell in love
What if the crew of the ebon hawk appeared during the clone wars
What if bail was able save the young Jedi from the clones on the landing platform
The Aliens from ET are in the Senate in the prequels, so by all intents and purposes, Earth is in the star wars universe.
The intro to every star wars film says "a long time ago in a galaxy far far away" so i think earth is in
@@oogieboogie5541 if it is it's probably the unknown regions and that's probably why I was never discovered is so deep in unknown reasons that no one could track it
This was absolutely awsome I don’t think anyone has ever made a battle between the two most powerful beings in all of Star Wars Abeloth the Mother vs The Chosen One Anakin Skywalker This is something I’ve wanted to see for so so long and man I so wanna see it animated some day.
Listening to this is just heartbreaking. Wow dude. you... such impressive work!
I really like this what if, but the only thing I’d change is Ahsoka not being killed. I’d have her meditating out in the field, she’d feel a disturbance and is a little too late in trying to save Luke and Leia, and finds Padme hiding in fear
I had to come back and we listen to this one is very good I wish it was longer keep up the good work and I hope for a part 2 and may the force be with you
What if Anakin fell in love with Dutchess Satine and what if Anakin had battle meditation and shatterpoint
This is a very interesting video more so than your other ones to an extent. You mentioned the mother. I remember seeing her in the feet of the Jedi books. She was an enemy far vaster in deadlier than both the Jedi and Sith.
Also, I can’t wait for the what is Revan trained Anakin video. Revan is my all-time favorite Star Wars character.
Hopefully I win a lightsaber this time. I just need to know what I need to do in order to be on the wheel. If I win, I want Revan’s purple saber
Also, I love what you did with the story. This was very compelling and a very interesting change to what if Aniken was granted the rank of master.
Also, I have a very interesting what if story for you. At least I think it’s a good one. What if Revan was the chosen one?
She has been called by many names. The servant, the Mother, but what she is most known by, is Abeloth. She is possibly the greatest evil in any galaxy. She returned during Luke Skywalker’s time as Grandmaster. But even HE couldn’t defeat her, he had to once again lock her away. Waiting for the day, that she would once again return.
As soon as they said revenge would be hers I immediately knew they were referring to Abeloth. Then I got chills because I knew more people would die
Man, you do such an amazing job at telling a story. I think this is one of your best works yet!
This storyline needs to be made into a movie. It’s already light years ahead of anything that Disney had come up with.
Another amazing story you have made, my personal favourite videos are about anakin before he became Vader (Vader in the suit not when he’s Vader just before order 66). Keep up the great work :)
Love your what if videos man keep it up I am looking forward to this one!
Actually Kit Fisto was the youngest Master on the council at the time. Not Mace Windu, who was 53
What If Crosshair didn’t execute Order 66 💯🌟🌟🌟🔥🔥!
This what if is just clean bro like I didn’t know it would be this smooth and amazing 10/10 bro 100%, just wow
What if Anakin had visions of order 66 instead of padme dying of childbirth?
What if Anakin went undercover instead of Obi-Wan?
What if tup was taken to the jedi temple instead of getting the atomic brain scan?
What if shmi skywalker had a child with Clegg lars?
You have improved greatly I'm going to subscribe I told you Anakin's power would be massive once you become a Jedi master the only thing I can see with this though is that ob1 and Yoda should have became for skills but I'm finally going to subscribe I love this ending
Also the council didn't suspect Chancellor Palpatine was the Sith until Anakin brings that knowledge to Mace.
This right here was well done.
That was a twist, but like a akin prob i got angry in a way I couldn’t describe, knowing what it’s like to lose somebody close. But may God bless your work, one of the best ones you’ve made. (More emotional too.)
What if instead of Palpatine executing Order 66, it was the Senate that voted to execute the order?
So by that, I mean having events happen in a way where the public *really* comes to hate the Jedi. And they pressure their senators into getting rid of them, so they vote to execute the order instead of Palpatine. Which could lead to some interesting events if, say, it was just before Anakin is even asked to spy on the chancellor.
He would use the Jedi's Mind trick to get them to initiate it. Most of them at that point were weak-willed.
I just wanna say I found you early on in your yt channel. And youre videos are some of the best of the starwars theorys/fanfics. what about what if anakin never had attachments? What if Palpatine "groomed" a different jedi. Find out next time on ppsw.
What if Anakin found and awoken an ancient Je'daii Ranger frozen in carbonite amongst the junk at Watto's a year before episode 1?
This is so utterly beautiful bravo lord Pente patrol bravo you sir are a great storyteller
Idk why but when you kill somebody that shit be hitting different 🤣🤣🤣 but when you kept saying the mother I knew it was abeloth that was the best way to use her great story
Palps plan would collapse because Anakin would have no incentive to turn to the darkisde
man that was a sad but epic twist! i really enjoyed this one!
I'm gonna be honest as I can still see this is as two ways as one he trusts the jedi or the other is him eradicating the jedi and still joining the sith
I enjoyed this what if. Very original and well done, thanks for the entertainment.
Man some of these are tear jerkers
My dream what if would be seeing Anakin go god mode on the clones as they marched through the temple. Disney should create this!
What if the Jedi had a legitimate reason for the "no connections or relations" rule?
Thought experiment: From what we have known every child born from a force sensitive individual's relationship has also been shown to be force sensitive, both in cannon and non-cannon (Examples include Luke, Leia Skywalker, Ray Palatine, Ben Solo, Galen Marek)
So what if the Jedi's "no connections" rule was to limit the number of force sensitives being born, regulating them to natural born/ Random force sensitive births.
It’s been a while since I’ve heard a SW theory… but once I saw the title I knew I had to see this😂
We grant you the rank of master but you are not on this council
I love it this is the ending we all would have wanted to see if not for the original story.
Jeasus I’m so excited for what If Revan trained Anakin!
I just got an idea!!! What if dooku didn't leave the jedi order AND became anakin's master instead of obi wan, i imagine the reason would be "qui gon believed in the boy, maybe he is worth something afterall", obi wan would be upset but less so because its his master"s master that now trains anakin, dooku might even allow kenobi to help with anakin's training, would sidious be destroyed? Would the jedi purge happen? Would the sepratists still exist? Likely but anyway, If dooku survives till the battle of yabin, would dooku being a jedi prevent the death star from destroying alderaan due to the events of the past? So many possible endings! Ill try to post this on all your videos(if i remember to, my memory is the worst) maybe one day you'll take the idea and make it a reality :)
Great job, can wait for Revan.
All Hail Lord Revan!
Good old "What if Mace Windu wasn't an asshole".
holy shit you write so many stories so fast.
What if Grogu's cuteness prevents Ben Solo from falling into darkness?
What if Anakin helped his clones kill Prong Krell?
What if Anakin never got mad at not become a master
love this bro
What if ARC Trooper Alpha-17 were in Star wars cannon 🤔 😳 👀
Can you please do
What If Dooku took Anakin and Obi Wan under his wing after Qui Gons death ?
Honestly one of my favourite videos
I saw a ad about being a "Master" When I clicked this vid
Make what if Anakin Skywalker tripled his power instead of doubled it what if Jedi Master pong krell never turned to the dark side
You don't need to train a Padawan to knighthood to become a master. There are a few masters that never had Padawan and knights that have trained padawans to knighthood.
A fine addition to my collection
Always love to see stuff on abeloth
Please make a part 2. I absolutely loved it.
In the swarm war, where do we find Jacen in the beginning? He went to every force user group to learn a wider view of the force. Those force user groups need to flock to Anakin when he goes Gray. PLO Koon will join him, Tyrannus will renounce his name and join as well. Palps and Mace are both angry the extremes are being ignored.
Zonamma Sekot becomes the new Jedi home? Taking on the Death Star in battle!
"How could an ordinary man know about the Sith?" Probably from the freaking Holonet, or a history book if he's old fashioned, they waged war on republic for thousands upon thousands of years, and left be behind droves of trinkets and knowledge, of freaking course that information would be apl over the place, you just had to look, and Palpy isn't some ordinary man, he's the most powerful man in the Galaxy, if he got curious about some Sith story, he just had to snap his fingers to get it.
If Ahsoka had not left the Jedi Order she would have been made Jedi Knight. She wouldn't be a Padawan anymore. It was high time for the next level. Ahsoka might've been the same age as Obi-Wan was during his fight with Darth Maul back on Naboo.
i got an ideas for you for the future
What if Eeth Kot trained Anakin Skywalker (remember that he was one of the only who suport the idea to train Anakin in the force
What if The Hero of Tython move to the future after killing Vititate and train Anakin
What if The Bad Batch go to the Citadel with Obi wan, Rex, Cody, Fives and Echo? How affect that Mission in History.
Literally crying rn
Subscribe and Share!
Become a Patreon: www.patreon.com/ppsw
Community Discord: discord.gg/RdBUUrKRJT
Twitch Account: www.twitch.tv/pentepatrol
GIVEAWAY: docs.google.com/document/d/1a2CTXrrrMCkU6RLpl-dDx2-v_f3R5HYpHqzwLj90qcY/edit?usp=sharing
Still asking for a mandalorian anakin
What if Ashoka was in the Siege of Mandalore with Obi-Wan and Anakin?
What if Bo-Katan Kryze was a stronger and better fighter than Maul and Pre Visla combined, thus defeating Maul and/or Sabine Wren in combat for leadership of Mandalore and/or the Darksaber?
Can I get a shout out pls
Avaloth: kills obiwan and yoda
Anakin: so you have chosen, death.