And here i have been really enjoying the past one, and you go and make another great version. Thank's a bunch for all your hard work at making these awesome songs Gav! I wouldn't say this is better but its different and they both work wonders in different ways and are a joy to listen to. Keep up the good work man, all the effort you put in can certainly be seen, and your love for it really shines through.. So far i haven't heard a single song i don't like from you, and i hope you keep doing this for a long time.
Even though I already liked the first version you've improved it again. And btw somehow I really love that intro. I don't know why but I think the footage really fits to the music. Great work, as always!
I wonder if the double entendre of "Shadow of the ash" is intentional. It refers, clearly, to literal ash, but also possibly to Ash(pronounced Osh), meaning One in the Black Speech of Mordor, translating to "Shadow of the One", as in the One Ring, which seems appropriate.
I love these alternate songs you seem to be doing now, with wake the white wolf and this. Its such a simple change but changes the whole feeling of the song. Both are great, thanks for caring so much about the opinions of your fans. You are reinforcing so much how you are my favourite musician. Keep up the amazing work man :)
ALL HAIL TALOS STORMCROWN!! COME AT ME YE DAMN ELVEN BASTARDS WITH UR ALDMERI DOMINION AND SUMMONED DAEDRA!! I'LL JUST FUS RO DAH ALL OF U BACK INTO OBLIVION WHERE U BELONG!!
As a metalhead I can't deny that I like this version better. Awesome that you listened to your fans' request and made this! (constructive criticism or not)
miracleofsound OMG Gavin-sempai noticed me *faints* I like the sofer one to because it transmites that me vs everyone vibe the game has but this version is awesome to.
Gavin, I want to deeply thank you for the amazing music you put out there. I've actually never liked metal but you've definitely changed my tastes in it ever since I heard you! It's always so wonderful to hear another music piece from you. I too aspire to become a music artist and this is one genre of music I have added to my list. Thanks for everything man. I'm definitely going to support you and your career.
I don't know how I managed to not see this until now. This is even more badass! I always felt that the vocals were a bit too soft compared to the heavy guitar and such. This is my new favorite song of yours. It was All As One until now.
I honestly love how the lyrics in this are both resonant and dissonant all at once. It depicts beautifully the duality of the main protagonist(s), as I feel that they are both separate, but overlap some.
The second half of the song was amazing in this version. However I think the softer approach in the first half of the original song sounded better than the first half of this version. I still love this song because it is very fun to sing along to. Thanks for looking out for us! I'm always spreading awareness of your work my friends so that they can enjoy this too. :)
I find these vocals FANTASTIC, particularly around 2 minutes- the way you just SPIT the words out is impressive, and really fits with Talion's hatred of Uruks.
Just like with Wake the White Wolf, I really like both versions equally. I'm glad you made another, I just can't decide which one I like more though. This one feels more powerful, but the other felt more... Lord of the Rings-y. Or something. Either way, great job on the both of them!
This song went from fucking awesome to pure, unadulterated BADASS. Nice job dude! can't wait for the next one, ever thought of making a Devil May Cry song? for the classics I mean.
In the original video you can hear the improvements of your singing pretty well, but in this version, that is combined with your abilities with layers, which, even to a humble peasent like me, makes the song noticebly better!
Thank you very much for your amazing work, Gav. I personally love both versions, each having its own atmosphere. I can't believe some people are complaining about you actually listening to your fans. I guess there are always party-poopers out there, so please don't get discouraged and keep creating your incredible music! I can't wait for your next masterpiece!
Jeez, never thought I'd see someone on UA-cam who does what their fans want. Even though I hate metal, I think I like this one more, just because it fits the song more imo. It's good to see that you actually care. Keep making great songs!
I've been listening to this on repeat all day, and I must say I've kind of zoned it out while I'm working, but I always get brought back in near the chorus. Thing is though, since my mind is busy and I'm working, I hear "pumpkin brains" instead of broken blade. : D
Had Shadow of the Ash hard vocal running on my ipod on my desk and walked into my office with Mamacita by Super Junior playing on my phone - great combo! Love your work, Gav! Relisten to tons of it!
I couldn't hear it before when I played it on my iPad, but now I've played it on the computer I can really tell the difference between the alternate vocals and the original.
I just started this and went to work. Then I realised, I kinda hear 2 Gav's. Became really happy when I realised I hadn't opened 2 vids at once. Was this one! :D Awesome!
Man, I love this version! So much fun, reminds me kind of Sabaton or Manowar like music, but with video games. Awesome. I wish you would do more of these kind of aggressive songs. :)
Gavin, please cater to my every whim. The beginning was too intense, like metal's supposed to be melodic, like a lullaby. Also your singing would have been a lot better if you had just found the holy grail and sung into it to create more resonance in your voice. Your incompetency is so conspicuous to me because I have released a hundred songs in three years, unlike you, like duh. (I hope my sarcasm is obvious) Honestly, though, I was really impressed my this. I'm not even that much of a metal fan, but I was surprised by how much I liked this version. It's a different perspective on an awesome song. LOVED it! :)
miracleofsound Well I'm glad that I could offer some alleviation from the invalid complaints running rampant through the comments section. "I liked the softer version better, so I'm going to complain about how much this one sucked even though I could just listen to the other version because logic"- every querulous commenter ever. Stay sane out there :D
Gav, I love both versions. The music in general is great. Listening to both sets of vocals form a choral perspective I like the first one's vowel sounds. As a fan of music I cannot pass judgement on which one is better. Both are great the way they are. This one does have a badass metal feel to it, which is pretty fucking great. The original Shadow Of The Ash had a great haunting sense to it. Keep up the fantastic work.
Now I have to decide which one I like best so I can buy it! So much pressure, I like things about each individually! I guess I could buy both... no, I must pick! It means I get to listen to these songs over and over, and I'm fine with that
Dude, you are really talented, I am happy to see real artists like you sharing their originals with the rest of us,you covered almost all my favorite games I am sharing your songs to my friends and I hope to see more songs. keep going, we love your songs. RESPECT
Great job Gavin, all of your work is. I'm a writer and listening to your music (all of it) Inspires me to write more ideas and continue writing. I can't express how much I love your work, keep up the epic work man.
I loved the first version of this song, and I played the whole game with it, so my ear is a little too tuned to that one, but I like this one too (especially the little Wrath quote with that 'I see you'. Don't know why but I always liked branding Uruks and gaining intelligence for that added feeling of angry vengeance you got with the Wrath shouting at their terrified faces XD) It's kinda like the first version was a little more 'Talion oriented' while this one reminds me much more of both Talion and Celebrimbor during a battle (kinda like when you parry a double attack and they both are here for a second with a thunder sound). I don't know if this make sense to anyone else, through XD
From what I understand, you like this version because instead of it focusing solely on Talion, this version emphasizes the duality of Talion and Celebrimbor. In-game, the line between them is blurred as each one aids the other, Talion in the physical realm providing martial and physical prowess and Celebrimbor in the realm of wraiths providing magic, knowledge, and an imbued body. Not only do they need each other, but slowly the lines between both their minds blur as the two become one like Anders (insert Dragon Age 2 dig here).
I think you almost have the point. While the chorus of the original showed a little of both Talion and Celebrimbor, this certainly shows more of Celebrimbor's aggressiveness in trying to find the answer to his history and his binding to the living realm as a wraith. I would agree that this feels more like the both of them, showing how they are truly intertwined, however I feel the original suits the most of the game better. I couldn't decide a favourite of the two either.
Hey Gavin, thanks so much for all these songs man, they are trully something special, I can't get enough of them, you probably get these kinds of messages alot, but I just had to express it on a comment :P
I can only hope if there's ever another 'Brutal Legend' They open up to artists like Gav; Imagine hearing something like this while power-sliding while an explosion engulfs the demons around you.
much like with "Wake the white wolf" the original song was great, but this version is just so much more powerful and awesome! you really know how to do metal!
Honestly it's a great display of character that you can listen to your fans and flex with their suggestions. I will be honest, I wasn't really taken by the first version. but this one hits home, the vocals and music mesh really well. thanks so much !! ^_^
amazing, if a day they make a SoM series or anime or something that needs a intro, u may sell it from 0:00 to 1:45, it's really perfect for that! good work
As requested by you guys, because I love you here's a version with a more aggressive, metal-like vocal. Enjoy
love this version, the vocals work a lot better with the lyrics and music.
any chance of a rocking tribute to Sunset Overdrive in the future?
And here i have been really enjoying the past one, and you go and make another great version. Thank's a bunch for all your hard work at making these awesome songs Gav! I wouldn't say this is better but its different and they both work wonders in different ways and are a joy to listen to. Keep up the good work man, all the effort you put in can certainly be seen, and your love for it really shines through.. So far i haven't heard a single song i don't like from you, and i hope you keep doing this for a long time.
Even though I already liked the first version you've improved it again. And btw somehow I really love that intro. I don't know why but I think the footage really fits to the music. Great work, as always!
While you here, I want to ask you something: any plans on Bordelands The Pre-Sequel game? 'Cause it's really fun and intersting game
You did good... you did good.
I wonder if the double entendre of "Shadow of the ash" is intentional. It refers, clearly, to literal ash, but also possibly to Ash(pronounced Osh), meaning One in the Black Speech of Mordor, translating to "Shadow of the One", as in the One Ring, which seems appropriate.
vidkidjoe Yeah, I realized this as I was listening one night. I just hope it's intentional.
Tirigad how does anyone remember something like that? And knowing Tolkein it's probably a whole language.
@@SorowFame Tolkien built his world around his languages. He was a linguist after all.
good connection either way.
@@SorowFame It is a language!
"Through rubble, rock and stone
The ashes are my home"
I know you didn't intend it but it reminds me of The Red Mountain in Morrowind.
"Through t' rock, rubble and stone
Your bones are my throne"
"The whispers of the Dreamer,
They seep into my soul."
The Sleeper Awakes 🌋
This is what this song needed.
This soft version ain't bad, not in the slightest, but this is AMAZING.
soft version is Talion's sorrow.
metal version is Celebrimbor's rage
That's a good reforging of already good elven METAL!!!
PUNTALITY (get it? ;-)
check out the first version, you'll see the original ;)
Yea, i saw it :-D
i`d say mithril
Tonar Silverwolf ...you got the joke, right?...
I loved the original version but now I can't go back! Great improvement. Miracle of Sound is my main source of music.
same here amigo
I love these alternate songs you seem to be doing now, with wake the white wolf and this. Its such a simple change but changes the whole feeling of the song. Both are great, thanks for caring so much about the opinions of your fans. You are reinforcing so much how you are my favourite musician. Keep up the amazing work man :)
Admiral thrawn! Reporting for duty Sir!
This song was so... artistically done.
YES,I really felt like the first version lacked aggression.This fixed the issue,keep on filling my phone library Gav,cheers to another masterpiece.
I like how you could pretty much take these vocals and change the music around a bit to make it a tribute to the Dunmer from the Elder Scrolls.
Holy crap you blew my mind
+Jacob whydoesmylastnamematter LONG LIVE
V
I
V
E
C
ALL HAIL TALOS STORMCROWN!! COME AT ME YE DAMN ELVEN BASTARDS WITH UR ALDMERI DOMINION AND SUMMONED DAEDRA!! I'LL JUST FUS RO DAH ALL OF U BACK INTO OBLIVION WHERE U BELONG!!
Neeeeerrrd
...huh.
How coincidental. I'll be sure to play this while crafting ultimate armor
As a metalhead I can't deny that I like this version better. Awesome that you listened to your fans' request and made this! (constructive criticism or not)
I love both versions.. The harder version goes so well with the video it makes it look even more epic!
Its kind of diffrent, i like it also. But i like the softer version a bit more XD But as always, a beautifull Song. I love you
Yeah same here. This one sounds great but I like the other version a bit more.
That's perfectly ok, I like the softer one too. It's not going anywhere so people can still enjoy both, one or the other :)
miracleofsound Either way very well put together good work!
miracleofsound OMG Gavin-sempai noticed me *faints*
I like the sofer one to because it transmites that me vs everyone vibe the game has but this version is awesome to.
It takes mithril to make metal this strong
I used to think Fires Far and YOI DIED were the greatest creations ever, I WAS WRONG. MY GOD I LOVE THIS. THANK YOU.
this is by far my favourite MoS song out there
Mythril's sheen and Elf-shot shimmers, justice runs in Uruk-blood rivers.
Old post, I know, but if I'm pronouncing "uruk" correctly then it breaks the rhythm; I would say "black-blood rivers" instead.
I was already in love with the first song. But you made a version that I love even more. I can't wait for Level 5, for so many songs! :D
Gavin, I want to deeply thank you for the amazing music you put out there. I've actually never liked metal but you've definitely changed my tastes in it ever since I heard you! It's always so wonderful to hear another music piece from you. I too aspire to become a music artist and this is one genre of music I have added to my list. Thanks for everything man. I'm definitely going to support you and your career.
just wait until the song about doom 2016
... Im getting a Metal Overload in here, Gav.
AND IT FEELS SO GOOOOOOD!!! :D
I like to think of the original as the song for Shadow of Mordor, and this one is for Shadow of War the sequel.
I don't know how I managed to not see this until now. This is even more badass! I always felt that the vocals were a bit too soft compared to the heavy guitar and such. This is my new favorite song of yours. It was All As One until now.
+Lewis Toroian Ha One.
I honestly love how the lyrics in this are both resonant and dissonant all at once. It depicts beautifully the duality of the main protagonist(s), as I feel that they are both separate, but overlap some.
The second half of the song was amazing in this version. However I think the softer approach in the first half of the original song sounded better than the first half of this version. I still love this song because it is very fun to sing along to. Thanks for looking out for us! I'm always spreading awareness of your work my friends so that they can enjoy this too. :)
A final rebuild of the two together :P?
Maybe that could be a challenge for us to do as a cover xD (With all appropriate links present in description of course)
I find these vocals FANTASTIC, particularly around 2 minutes- the way you just SPIT the words out is impressive, and really fits with Talion's hatred of Uruks.
I like both versions very much. Depens on my mood which is better, really. So good job, man.
Omg, Gavin, I love that you added a glimpse of Call of Home after the chorus.
OMG , the original masterpiece has been just improved. I have no words *.*
Just like with Wake the White Wolf, I really like both versions equally. I'm glad you made another, I just can't decide which one I like more though. This one feels more powerful, but the other felt more... Lord of the Rings-y. Or something. Either way, great job on the both of them!
That instrumental though
Yeaaaaaahhhhhhh!
I was not one of those who asked for this version. But DAMN it is AWESOME! Thank you to everyone who requested it.
This song went from fucking awesome to pure, unadulterated BADASS. Nice job dude! can't wait for the next one, ever thought of making a Devil May Cry song? for the classics I mean.
In the original video you can hear the improvements of your singing pretty well, but in this version, that is combined with your abilities with layers, which, even to a humble peasent like me, makes the song noticebly better!
This is the perfect version.
The first was great and somehow you managed to make it even better, I salute you MOS.
Thank you very much for your amazing work, Gav. I personally love both versions, each having its own atmosphere. I can't believe some people are complaining about you actually listening to your fans. I guess there are always party-poopers out there, so please don't get discouraged and keep creating your incredible music! I can't wait for your next masterpiece!
I really like the call back to 'Call of Home' in the chorus.
As a Metaller and fan of your work, I appreciate these more metal variations of already pretty great songs. Thanks, Gavin!
Thank you for taking the time and making the effort to make this video.
The first version was already amazing, but this is just badass.
Thank you :)
Jeez, never thought I'd see someone on UA-cam who does what their fans want. Even though I hate metal, I think I like this one more, just because it fits the song more imo. It's good to see that you actually care. Keep making great songs!
Perfect job!
I didn't even imagine that this masterpiece could be so much better!
Thank you!
I've been listening to this on repeat all day, and I must say I've kind of zoned it out while I'm working, but I always get brought back in near the chorus. Thing is though, since my mind is busy and I'm working, I hear "pumpkin brains" instead of broken blade. : D
Had Shadow of the Ash hard vocal running on my ipod on my desk and walked into my office with Mamacita by Super Junior playing on my phone - great combo! Love your work, Gav! Relisten to tons of it!
This is one of my favorites.
I couldn't hear it before when I played it on my iPad, but now I've played it on the computer I can really tell the difference between the alternate vocals and the original.
I love this version!!. I hope if you made one for Shadow of War, made a version like this, it´s amazing , keep with the excelent work
The one thing I was worried about in this version was that the chorus would be completely different. I am glad to say that this is not the case. :)
"The Bright Lord" song please! PLEASE!
I don't think he'll make an entire song based on DLC (Which is kinda BS, if you ask me or Dan Bull. And a lot of other people.).
Shuckle He did one for Burial at Sea
Nate Hesford .. Shit. I didn't think of that... Alright. I lose.
You must be gifted in making great music.
I love your take on the Misty Mountain riff!
Wowowow I love this one so much more than the original. I didn't think that was possible. Damn!
cant tell what version is more epic
hm...
OK lets just say they are both masterpieces of music - awesome job !!!
I just started this and went to work. Then I realised, I kinda hear 2 Gav's. Became really happy when I realised I hadn't opened 2 vids at once. Was this one! :D Awesome!
When you decide to write it, you make some of the best heavy mithril around. Keep it up, Gav.
I'll keep saying it. You sir. Are a Bard! Fit to compose fire KINGS!!
This is amazing, I loved the old one, and I find this one to be ear-gasmic.
1000% loving this one. This honestly might be my new favorite of yours, gets the blood flowing!
Oh my gosh this song is soooooo good my friend keptmtrying to get me to listen to it and i cant belive i didnt till just now
Man, I love this version! So much fun, reminds me kind of Sabaton or Manowar like music, but with video games. Awesome. I wish you would do more of these kind of aggressive songs. :)
Gavin, please cater to my every whim. The beginning was too intense, like metal's supposed to be melodic, like a lullaby. Also your singing would have been a lot better if you had just found the holy grail and sung into it to create more resonance in your voice. Your incompetency is so conspicuous to me because I have released a hundred songs in three years, unlike you, like duh. (I hope my sarcasm is obvious) Honestly, though, I was really impressed my this. I'm not even that much of a metal fan, but I was surprised by how much I liked this version. It's a different perspective on an awesome song. LOVED it! :)
haha, that was fun to read :D
miracleofsound Well I'm glad that I could offer some alleviation from the invalid complaints running rampant through the comments section. "I liked the softer version better, so I'm going to complain about how much this one sucked even though I could just listen to the other version because logic"- every querulous commenter ever. Stay sane out there :D
Daniel Kline Haha that's why I mentioned I was being sarcastic. Otherwise it would just be FUCK Y..oh sorry. :D
Jennifer Alt *clap, clap*
+Jennifer Alt I actually thought you were serious, lol.
Gav, I love both versions. The music in general is great. Listening to both sets of vocals form a choral perspective I like the first one's vowel sounds. As a fan of music I cannot pass judgement on which one is better. Both are great the way they are. This one does have a badass metal feel to it, which is pretty fucking great. The original Shadow Of The Ash had a great haunting sense to it. Keep up the fantastic work.
Now I have to decide which one I like best so I can buy it! So much pressure, I like things about each individually! I guess I could buy both... no, I must pick! It means I get to listen to these songs over and over, and I'm fine with that
Dude, you are really talented, I am happy to see real artists like you sharing their originals with the rest of us,you
covered almost all my favorite games I am sharing your songs to my friends and I hope to see more songs.
keep going, we love your songs.
RESPECT
I just played both version side by side (just to see how it would sound) Love them both.
Keep up the awesome work man.
man i love your music sooo much!This song gave me goosebumps like so many others.Keep up the fantastic work!
This is SOOOOOOO AWESOME! Great job, Gav! I love it!
This song is amazing for the opening guitar solo alone.
Great job Gavin, all of your work is. I'm a writer and listening to your music (all of it) Inspires me to write more ideas and continue writing. I can't express how much I love your work, keep up the epic work man.
I loved the first version of this song, and I played the whole game with it, so my ear is a little too tuned to that one, but I like this one too (especially the little Wrath quote with that 'I see you'. Don't know why but I always liked branding Uruks and gaining intelligence for that added feeling of angry vengeance you got with the Wrath shouting at their terrified faces XD)
It's kinda like the first version was a little more 'Talion oriented' while this one reminds me much more of both Talion and Celebrimbor during a battle (kinda like when you parry a double attack and they both are here for a second with a thunder sound). I don't know if this make sense to anyone else, through XD
From what I understand, you like this version because instead of it focusing solely on Talion, this version emphasizes the duality of Talion and Celebrimbor. In-game, the line between them is blurred as each one aids the other, Talion in the physical realm providing martial and physical prowess and Celebrimbor in the realm of wraiths providing magic, knowledge, and an imbued body. Not only do they need each other, but slowly the lines between both their minds blur as the two become one like Anders (insert Dragon Age 2 dig here).
I think you almost have the point. While the chorus of the original showed a little of both Talion and Celebrimbor, this certainly shows more of Celebrimbor's aggressiveness in trying to find the answer to his history and his binding to the living realm as a wraith. I would agree that this feels more like the both of them, showing how they are truly intertwined, however I feel the original suits the most of the game better. I couldn't decide a favourite of the two either.
+DevilEliChan I see THIS version as more suited to the actual combat while the original suits the storyline itself.
Awesome as always. I really like both versions with a small preferance to this version.
Metal and middle earth. Nothing better
I love your metal stuff a LOT. Please do more.
I can't tell whats better. THis version, or the original.
Hey Gavin, thanks so much for all these songs man, they are trully something special, I can't get enough of them, you probably get these kinds of messages alot, but I just had to express it on a comment :P
Nice!
But I really liked that clank at the beginning. It really set the tone for the rest of the song.
I have been listening to to 3:01 part to 3:40 for about an hour. I fell in love with the damn song and it feels weird :D
I think these vocals fit a bit better :) Helps compliment the aggressive sound of the song ^_^ Great job! Keep going! :)
You can't please everyone, but I'm glad you tried! I like both versions :)
Are you sure this is different?
They both kick ass, so i can't tell
I can only hope if there's ever another 'Brutal Legend' They open up to artists like Gav; Imagine hearing something like this while power-sliding while an explosion engulfs the demons around you.
much like with "Wake the white wolf" the original song was great, but this version is just so much more powerful and awesome! you really know how to do metal!
Chorus in this song is so god damn great and epic. BROKEN BLADE REVENGE IS CALLING
Loved the original version now this is 110% better in every way. Keep up the good work Gav :)
Seriously man I love all your stuff!
Definitely a great improvement Gavin. Fantastic job with this one, as with all of your songs.
Honestly it's a great display of character that you can listen to your fans and flex with their suggestions.
I will be honest, I wasn't really taken by the first version.
but this one hits home, the vocals and music mesh really well.
thanks so much !!
^_^
I am speechless.... again
Yeah okay you've have outdone yourself on this one, new favourite.
Love it!!! Awesome songs with awesome lyrics. Keep em coming miracleofsound :D
Amazing as always.
amazing, if a day they make a SoM series or anime or something that needs a intro, u may sell it from 0:00 to 1:45, it's really perfect for that! good work
HOLY SHIZ THIS IS AWESOME! Keep up the good work and stay cool!
Really mighty soundtrack, and epic video with it! +++
Oh hell yeah, sounds amazing!!!
Great this version.
Love it! Amazing job, Gav ^^
3:03 is amazing
Very good alternate version, Same with The Witcher one. I guess I always prefer a more heavy rock sound :) Good job.
All of your songs completely fit the very game it's in. Like its originally from the game. 😋👏🏻
Awesome