if happens to me all the time when my piano teacher gvies me something and keeps pushing me to my limits and i keep pushing harder, so he plays it 1000 times better than me and it gets me even more excited because i want to reach what he can do and i know i won't stop till i reach it.
For those who say he wasn't born deaf. Of course he wasn't born deaf, but he got to make the best composition in human history so far and the years to come, the 9th symphony when he was pretty much deaf. Do you know the level of music understanding one must have to be able to do that?Do you know the level one must have to make a symphony out his head by only creating notes without sound? Beethoven is, and will always be, the greatest music composer of all time. I could only think about Bach to come close to him in terms of music perfection and understanding of music and its rules. In fact, I consider Bach to be one most influential musicians of all times, whose "rules" are present in the music we listen now. But Beethoven was able to reach out and touch the heavens of music and composing when he created the greatest score of all time (I mentioned it above) The 9th Symphony.
@@Trooman20 _Unfortunately, I didn't have a stable position at court. I was only paid so much, and me being me, I had to buy myself new attires and jackets, and on top of that, Constanze had to go to the spa to care for herself, and raising a child between that is also a very difficult thing to do. Screw the emperor and his notions anyways!_
@The Joker but moonlight sonata 3rd movement is more advanced and I've hit my friend with this one while he was playing fur elise I said "may i" and I played it my friend was in total shock he said teach me so I'm teaching him right now
he's a genius not only for how he composed his music,but how it makes your heart shake and feel his feelings,absolute scream of emotions,i'm addicted to this
Beethoven was angry at her and he showed it through his playing. She understood this, which explains her reaction. When he starts playing she’s in awe by his talent but quickly realizes the music is about her. It’s around 1:35 when she starts to understand this. It’s obvious she’s able to understand feelings through music and you can see that through out his playing. She wants to interrupt and say something. It was really good acting on behalf of the actors.
How can she know? That is how Beethoven was like 24/7. That is how Beethoven played and composed. There is no way she could have known in real life in that way.
@Liam Nicholson in my opinion Chopin's ballade 1 in G minor op. 23 is the greatest piece ever written and i don't feel the same way while listening any others. But this would not make him better than anyone. And you are right that everyone has their pleasure but calling him overrated is disrespectful. If someone love something that you dont you should respect that. Chopin has too many popular and great pieces just like Beethofen.
@@hannahquintua my version included Freya getting brutally murdered, Morgana and Merlin falling in love (so it hurts more when she slowly turns evil and dies) (also because I ship them for some reason....), A sequel where Merlin goes through both World Wars, the birth of Beethoven, Mozart, Bach, Liszt, Chopin etc... The birth of Jazz and Rock.... And Merlin suffering because he's immortal and has to watch more of his loved ones die....
The fact that this man lives many century agos ad his music still lives on and is still amongst the most powerful pieces on a piano in term of colors an emotions is just incredible.
@Daniel Johnson that ain't passion man. This is the type of feeling brought about by heartbreak . I think this was the best way he could tell her "you hurt me" through his music. Not like he was gonna write lyrics about it feel me? I'm pretty sure this piece was brought about pain by his beloved.
@@IRex-wm9pd I agree with insanity though. Most heartbreaks or intense feeling for one often drives one insane. Beethoven was lucky (or more so WE are lucky) that he had such talent to put all his emotions into music.
@Daniel Johnson if you meant raw passion like less so loving and more so resentment or hurtful. Then yes. But I really don't think this piece can be in the same realm as most pieces . This is piece is a primal scream .
2:59 I like how he expresses his feelings throughout the piece. At this moment there is a feeling of rationality and perhaps some forgiveness when he plays. The girls picks up on this and looks like she wants to reach out to him and make up, maybe apologize and try to work out their relationship. But then he finishes the piece aggressively signaling that he won't forgive her and that it is over. Truly a fantastic scene.
I got the impression that as his letter noted that she was above his ‘class’, the counterpoint was just how much more nuanced and elegant and violent his music was, and he was enfolded in it while she was on the outside looking in.
That part is pretty easy though... Just practice arpeggios first, and then practice the ascending chords but without arpeggiating them, and then practice synchronizing the left hand with the right. Start slow and work up to speed, but not too slow. That's unnecessary I think.
descriptions such as hard or easy are relative. for liszt anything wouldve been easy e.g. what about a random person that's just started playing the piano? thanks for the advice anyhow
She: "Obviously he is without rank or position, i mean what would my future be?" Beethoven: I am what i am and i owe myself for this. There are princes and there will be thousands of them but there´s only one Beethoven.
I did say that yes. Ironically, this commoner also became one of the wealthiest composers in history. Wish I could say the same for my colleagues Mozart or Bach. They were my idols.
So...I believe 1st mov. was before He met Her, feel so empty... 2nd mov. was when He met Her...so light, full of joy.. 3rd mov. was when He at last realized that they weren't meant to be together...confusing, angry, and ecstasy all rolled into one..yet so beautifully convey through his music.. This music is trully piece of miracle...
Actually i read, that he indeed composed the 1st movement for one girl, to teach her piano - slow , easy and wonderful. She got better by his teaching, so he evolved it to the 2nd movement... more challenging, but still playable. It was at that moment, when the woman told him , that she is in love with another man, who is a much ''better man'' than Beethoven. Beethoven than composed is 3rd movement - with a mindset of : ''Oh yeah ? Is he ? You will never meet a man, who can play this piece !''
The first movement is like a funeral march in its motif, this is Beethoven's burial of his love, his hearing, his former life. The second part as an image of his love - which, despite everything, remained for him a model of beauty and purity. The third part is an aversion to the hustle and bustle of life, which, despite everything, continues to move forward. With this part, Beethoven rejects suicide, which he often wrote about in his letters, especially with the aggravation of deafness.
This is my favorite interpretation, which is funny because it has commentary on part of it, is on a forte piano, is shortened and performed by a little known pianist. And yet the ferocity it has makes me just love it. Superb
And this year are we celebrating that it's 250 years since Beethoven was born! A great composer in piano sonatas to symphonies and more..! I will always love his deeply and emotional work - that will give me strength in times of sorrow and melancholy.
von Ditters i read that it's because she didnt know the song was supposed to be that fast so shes realising its about her... but its because the movement sounds so angry
After hearing such an outstanding rendition from this magnificent pianist, my conclusion is: no woman could hold Beethoven's heart. For Beethoven's heart belonged to his one and ONLY true love...his music. Bravo Maestro Bravo!
Beethoven, to me, is an inspiring reminder that we are held prisoners by our senses. He does not need to hear, nor see, nor smell, nor taste, nor touch. He already experiences these joys through the heart. I believe that's why his music lives and not just "sounds." If we focus our attention on our heart, we will hear more, see more, and enjoy life at such a higher, deeper level. Then, we all will be able to write sonatas with our brother Beethoven.
Well many asian pianist will scream at you that the tempo is of here and that only technique counts .Classic has become only a sad replication of itself only few can even beginn tp match the fire of the creator himself Betthoven
Peter, technique, while an important elemental asset enabling competent "communication" of what one feels, is less vital than one's "feeling," itself. The "fire" you cite is forever captured in Beethoven's score, awaiting anyone who can allow themselves the freedom to go back in time to that stormy night when he suffered the pains of realizing his life would likely be without the love he yearned for. Watching those silvery clouds hide the moon only to have the moon explode each time between, like his heart fighting to never surrender to the dark of hopelessness. Feel that pain and this masterpiece will allow you to release it.
Dom, while I don't know what has gotten into you, I do say your biliousness works to scuttle what could be civil conversation. Technique is important but it is not the soul of music to which I am referring.
The most amazing thing about Beethoven is that his career should have been over when his hearing started to go because at a the time most of a musician's income came from teaching and live performing, which one needed to hear and react to. It is a myth that composers made money by being privately, divinely inspired in their study.
i could imagine the fear he felt when finding out he was losing his hearing, i couldn’t imagine having to compose whilst being deaf not to mention people still not enjoying the music and his actual genius
this is an overwrought last movement to our ear but would be EXACTLY the way it would have sounded to some Beethoven contemporary --- ferocious, wild, brutal. really effective scene
2:16 "My hearing hasn't improved, in fact, I think it may be getting worse, and the lady I told you about, is *not of my class, so marriage is out of the question*
Her:”A deaf musician. Can you imagine that? What would our future be like?” Then she try’s playing weak sauce keys. Beethoven plays movement. Him:”So I realized she’s not my type. Besides my REAL love is music.”
THis is a VERY good scene. I like how she really tries hard to follow him with a little amusement. Then she lost track and as he speeds up more and more she feels embarrassed. Maybe partly, because she doubted his genius and maybe of her own inability to being EVER able to reach his level. It seems like she tries to avoid the situation and want to escape, because it she is totally outclassed by him... as a "deaf musician, can you imagine that?!"
She rejects him underestimating him -> he responds proving his genius -> she feels reflected like an odious person and blame him for that (bravo...) -> she didn't pass the heart exam for him, goodbye
His mind is unfathomable The emotions , excitement , praise and admiration created by a great composer like Beethoven transcend the conflicts between nations , racial differences and the times
Just try to imagine being there when he first performed this….all your life you’ve just been listening to Bach, Vivaldi, Mozart, and then you hear this.
PS: That is a wonderful arrangement, starting with the "B" section on violin and delaying the "A" section until later on the piano. It gives more prominence to that wonderful, seductive, lyrical B melody. Where did you get that? Is it a common interpretation now? Just wonderful!
What is truly amazing is that he was deaf when he wrote symphony #6. It’s hard to imagine the delicate movements in that peace without being able to hear them. Mozart and Beethoven suffered greatly. Still, they’re music was heavenly. They were a gift to mankind from God.
May god keep making people like Beethoven, a mastermind with absolutely fantastic passion in what he does, Beethoven will live on with his music forever , Beethoven is undeniably the best composer of all time.
oh my gods - i have never heard that played so incredibly and beautifully. and the actor who IS Beethoven only adds to the emotional dynamic. he is perfect and simply gorgeous. i already feel so distraught that he’s going deaf. what an incredibly beautiful soul he had. thank you so very much. . . 🌷🎹🌷
I like how they bookend the relationship with her saying "bravo", as that is also what she says in the scene when she first sees him play. The first is uttered in excitement; the last in resentment.
A musically talented angel departed heaven for a brief moment in history and was bestowed to us earthlings as a gift-a priceless musical gift. Such was Ludwig Van Beethoven. Bravo maestro. Bravo indeed.
The most famous movement of this 14th sonata is of course the first, but I can honestly say the 3rd movement is the most metal, hard core musical thing ever composed
Although it's a scene from a movie. However, the third movement of the Moonlight Sonata played by the alive Beethoven truly touches my heart. There is frustration with his love and endless anguish about music. He was a great musician, but at the same time he was a man of endless agony. So his music feels empathy for humans likes me.
I almost never understand classical music and just listen to some pieces sometimes I liked in the anime your lie in april. I have heard this song before but NEVER EVER in my life I felt the music so much that my heart started shaking and there were tears in my eyes and I could sense his emotions. I have never experienced this. WOW!
Those artists lead very sad lives, exploted by their parents, travling all over Europe in the worst conditions, and Beethoven always had trouble getting work because people couldn't pay him! I think he would be blown away today if he knew how much we love his music and what a genius he was!
this piece has more beauty than can be described in human terms. ive yet to see with my eyes something to compare it to. 300 years has passed and has yet to be matched. bravo Beethoven. you fucking absolute Legend!
For very old people of the past who were born during the times of the baroque (1720) this piece must have been an absolute shocker when it came out! xD
Imagine young musicians who've heard only the measured plinking of court music ... and then you hear THIS - tearing through and ravaging mercilessly your soul, tearing through centuries of sound with a storm of diamonds and liberating music to what was barely imaginable before it.
Este video es una pequeñísima parte de la excelente miniserie de la BBC "El genio de Beethoven", a mi juicio la mejor biografía fílmica producida hasta hoy sobre este músico colosal.
This is one of the most astonishing music ever conceived and one of the pinnacles of the human being. It leaves me speechless every time I hear it, no matter how many times I did.
Ba'zi bir kasb egalari uchun eshitmay qolish, Kar bo'lish kasbiga unchalik ta'sir qilmasligi mumkin lekin musiqachi uchun bu katta fojea. Betxoven shunday bo'lsada musiqani sevdi.. shunday holatda ham asarlar yaratdi. Betxovenni kuylariday hayajonli, og'riqli musiqa yo'q, baribir uning kuylari boshqacha... Oy sonatasi esa, Mening musiqam, Eng sevimli musiqam.. Qalbim og'riganda ham, quvonganimda ham shu kuyni chalaman. Menga juda ham yoqadi....
There was no place for a woman in Beethoven's life, there was only music and everytime he had to choose, he decided for music... and most of the world was and is thanking god that is was like that. He made a couple of the most magnificient gifts to culture and art of all time, many of the greatest pieces of musical artwork are from him. Music for the ages! Words from the funeral speech for Beethoven: There he stands among the giants, unassailable for all time!
Anyone else notice the contrast in how she says “Bravo” here and earlier in the doc? I’ve watched the full documentary 3 times (in a couple years) and watched clips like this several times, but only now noticed.
@@slimessiful Valentina isnt the pianist to listen to beethov, I dont want to seem haughty or smth, just an advice, i Heard Valentina at Prague in a concert, it's just.. Not the level she should have for an international pianist, I can advice you some one if you want.
I remembered see that first time many years ago and I almost cried. Now I see it again and I almost cried again. I managed to keep myself not to become ridiculous thinking that humanity will not see a man like him again. At least in my days.
@UCEBWVuTrXBLJIA56F-2_JYg You stupid or what? I never said anything bad about Beethoven. I just said this particular movement isn't melodic and that doesn't mean that it's bad.
![5 Pieces by Hans Zimmer \\ Iconic Soundtracks \\ Relaxing Piano [20min]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Os47nMrjw_Y/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine you trying to play piano and a deaf guy comes and says "may I," and plays it 900 times better than you
He wasn't deaf when he composed this and played this...
Corvo he was almost deaf but he was hidding it
R Ga hiding*
if happens to me all the time when my piano teacher gvies me something and keeps pushing me to my limits and i keep pushing harder, so he plays it 1000 times better than me and it gets me even more excited because i want to reach what he can do and i know i won't stop till i reach it.
Ludwig was going deaf at the time but was hiding it
"A deaf musician. Can you imagine that?"
Turned out to be one of the best in the history of humanity.
Oscar Conroy he wasnt born deaf ,he lost most of his hearing a few years before his death.
Because He's the reencarnation of Jesus.
I'm a brain death survivor professional musician, can you belive that?
Probably the best.
For those who say he wasn't born deaf.
Of course he wasn't born deaf, but he got to make the best composition in human history so far and the years to come, the 9th symphony when he was pretty much deaf. Do you know the level of music understanding one must have to be able to do that?Do you know the level one must have to make a symphony out his head by only creating notes without sound?
Beethoven is, and will always be, the greatest music composer of all time. I could only think about Bach to come close to him in terms of music perfection and understanding of music and its rules. In fact, I consider Bach to be one most influential musicians of all times, whose "rules" are present in the music we listen now. But Beethoven was able to reach out and touch the heavens of music and composing when he created the greatest score of all time (I mentioned it above)
The 9th Symphony.
*I can honestly say, what a genius.*
Ah yes mozart finaly said a comploment for beethoven
Wow
@@brirhieverything171 *i do expect to get a compliment in return..?*
The rest is just the same, isn't it?
@@chamestb6632 *indeed!*
@@Trooman20 _Unfortunately, I didn't have a stable position at court. I was only paid so much, and me being me, I had to buy myself new attires and jackets, and on top of that, Constanze had to go to the spa to care for herself, and raising a child between that is also a very difficult thing to do. Screw the emperor and his notions anyways!_
what a lucky piano
So many likes no replies
NBunyeon Nathan at least he has one.
Not a lucky piano the piano always has to handle the fingering of Beethoven
very lucky)))
That piano needed a cigarette after that.
Imagine that your friend is playing Für Elise and you hit them with this
Tim Stockelberg yea I had that chance of doing that, feels great
I did that
You’ll feel like a king believe me
Both pieces are masterpieces and shall not ve underestimated. Thats not what Beethoven would want
@The Joker but moonlight sonata 3rd movement is more advanced and I've hit my friend with this one while he was playing fur elise I said "may i" and I played it my friend was in total shock he said teach me so I'm teaching him right now
he's a genius not only for how he composed his music,but how it makes your heart shake and feel his feelings,absolute scream of emotions,i'm addicted to this
he's not only angry, he's frustrated and cruel enough to make even the most stupid person in the planet to understand his feelings.
Beethoven was angry at her and he showed it through his playing. She understood this, which explains her reaction. When he starts playing she’s in awe by his talent but quickly realizes the music is about her. It’s around 1:35 when she starts to understand this. It’s obvious she’s able to understand feelings through music and you can see that through out his playing. She wants to interrupt and say something. It was really good acting on behalf of the actors.
Juan Salas dude you opened my third eyehole
Why dis only got three likes?
Why is he angry against her?
Yeah you can tell by his expression and the way he is playing. its like he is raging on the piano.
How can she know? That is how Beethoven was like 24/7. That is how Beethoven played and composed. There is no way she could have known in real life in that way.
Girl: Rejects beethoven
Beethoven : Wait!
*Plays moonlight sonata 3rd mvmnt
Girl: Wet
Beethoven: Rejects girl.
Girl*
@@larskonijnendijk2640
*gurl
@@jaqenhghar5794 gerl
"Marriage is out of the question" he says.
"I'm busy with my music" he says.
@@rarufu2368 He busy to practice have no time to marriage dat gurl
I like how she realizes he wrote it out of anger toward her utter shittiness.
Take that Chopin
Lmao
@Liam Nicholson unacceptable ! Compering composers are not cool. They are so uniq in their way.
@Liam Nicholson in my opinion Chopin's ballade 1 in G minor op. 23 is the greatest piece ever written and i don't feel the same way while listening any others. But this would not make him better than anyone. And you are right that everyone has their pleasure but calling him overrated is disrespectful. If someone love something that you dont you should respect that. Chopin has too many popular and great pieces just like Beethofen.
Lmao
Liam Nicholson again you still compared composers. Chopin’s style is completely different from Beethoven. Personally, I think both equally amazing!!
“I really am far too busy with my music.” Savage
"let me guess... He's married?"
"*Nods* to his work"
@@twinendymion947
HEY IVE SEEN YOU BEFORE!
@@hannahquintua oh yes, from Dark Fur Elise... Was telling you my version of Merlin... Which was way sadder than the original one....
@@hannahquintua my version included Freya getting brutally murdered, Morgana and Merlin falling in love (so it hurts more when she slowly turns evil and dies) (also because I ship them for some reason....), A sequel where Merlin goes through both World Wars, the birth of Beethoven, Mozart, Bach, Liszt, Chopin etc... The birth of Jazz and Rock.... And Merlin suffering because he's immortal and has to watch more of his loved ones die....
@@twinendymion947
Ahh are you ok?!
The fact that this man lives many century agos ad his music still lives on and is still amongst the most powerful pieces on a piano in term of colors an emotions is just incredible.
For me Beethoven was the biggest composer ever lived.
Many? More like a couple.
How two is many?
@@PygmalionFaciebat
Handel was definitely bigger than Beethoven. Handel just loved food more.
@@kylebrogmus8847😂😂
The actress did a wonderful job in making us hate her so much
Yes, Alice Eve is awesome.
@@tinyrobot9989 Bro do you know what is the movie
@@trailerscompany9706 its not a movie..its just a documentary...I think its name"genius of beethoven"
😂😂😂
@Billy Boffin and the floor is made out of floor
Definitely the best version. If anything it should be played at this speed all the time. Captures what the piece is supposed to represent. Pure rage.
@Daniel Johnson and intensity.
Vengeance
@Daniel Johnson that ain't passion man. This is the type of feeling brought about by heartbreak . I think this was the best way he could tell her "you hurt me" through his music. Not like he was gonna write lyrics about it feel me? I'm pretty sure this piece was brought about pain by his beloved.
@@IRex-wm9pd I agree with insanity though. Most heartbreaks or intense feeling for one often drives one insane. Beethoven was lucky (or more so WE are lucky) that he had such talent to put all his emotions into music.
@Daniel Johnson if you meant raw passion like less so loving and more so resentment or hurtful. Then yes. But I really don't think this piece can be in the same realm as most pieces . This is piece is a primal scream .
2:59 I like how he expresses his feelings throughout the piece. At this moment there is a feeling of rationality and perhaps some forgiveness when he plays. The girls picks up on this and looks like she wants to reach out to him and make up, maybe apologize and try to work out their relationship. But then he finishes the piece aggressively signaling that he won't forgive her and that it is over.
Truly a fantastic scene.
I got the impression that as his letter noted that she was above his ‘class’, the counterpoint was just how much more nuanced and elegant and violent his music was, and he was enfolded in it while she was on the outside looking in.
0:41 me practicing 3rd mvt
1:15 looking at people playing it on youtube
FeelsBadMan
That part is pretty easy though... Just practice arpeggios first, and then practice the ascending chords but without arpeggiating them, and then practice synchronizing the left hand with the right. Start slow and work up to speed, but not too slow. That's unnecessary I think.
descriptions such as hard or easy are relative. for liszt anything wouldve been easy e.g. what about a random person that's just started playing the piano? thanks for the advice anyhow
You read in my mind
0:41 thats me trying to play fast everyday
It's easy if you practice this everyday and you have to do this
She: "Obviously he is without rank or position, i mean what would my future be?"
Beethoven: I am what i am and i owe myself for this. There are princes and there will be thousands of them but there´s only one Beethoven.
oh I know this quote
Then, now, and forever!!
I did say that yes. Ironically, this commoner also became one of the wealthiest composers in history. Wish I could say the same for my colleagues Mozart or Bach. They were my idols.
👌
savage
So...I believe
1st mov. was before He met Her, feel so empty...
2nd mov. was when He met Her...so light, full of joy..
3rd mov. was when He at last realized that they weren't meant to be together...confusing, angry, and ecstasy all rolled into one..yet so beautifully convey through his music..
This music is trully piece of miracle...
Actually i read, that he indeed composed the 1st movement for one girl, to teach her piano - slow , easy and wonderful.
She got better by his teaching, so he evolved it to the 2nd movement... more challenging, but still playable.
It was at that moment, when the woman told him , that she is in love with another man, who is a much ''better man'' than Beethoven.
Beethoven than composed is 3rd movement - with a mindset of : ''Oh yeah ? Is he ? You will never meet a man, who can play this piece !''
@@PygmalionFaciebat i thought this story was for song fur Elise
I think 3rd is after he realized what a shallow, horrible piece of shit human being she was, despite her looks.
The first movement is like a funeral march in its motif, this is Beethoven's burial of his love, his hearing, his former life. The second part as an image of his love - which, despite everything, remained for him a model of beauty and purity. The third part is an aversion to the hustle and bustle of life, which, despite everything, continues to move forward. With this part, Beethoven rejects suicide, which he often wrote about in his letters, especially with the aggravation of deafness.
Это музыка о смерти
Mozart: Everythings just the same isnt it?
Beethoven: What?
Mozart: EVERYTHINGS THE SAME
Beethoven:WHHAATTT
😂
🤣
Ok deaf jokes are funny but Beethoven was a God
No. Beethoven is really good.
Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart Beethoven was one of the best
This is my favorite interpretation, which is funny because it has commentary on part of it, is on a forte piano, is shortened and performed by a little known pianist. And yet the ferocity it has makes me just love it. Superb
who played this
Yes what pianist was it!?
It was actually the actor playing this?
Il Dio no it was a classical pianist
You again
And this year are we celebrating that it's 250 years since Beethoven was born! A great composer in piano sonatas to symphonies and more..! I will always love his deeply and emotional work - that will give me strength in times of sorrow and melancholy.
1:53 slide to the left
2:00 slide to the right
2:05 bye have a great time
😂😂
lol at 2:05 she looks like she's questioning her own existence
She is wondering how a man can be so extraordinarily talented.
I think she's more realizing how unsexy he's becoming.
she always looks like that
von Ditters how?
von Ditters i read that it's because she didnt know the song was supposed to be that fast so shes realising its about her... but its because the movement sounds so angry
After hearing such an outstanding rendition from this magnificent pianist, my conclusion is: no woman could hold Beethoven's heart. For Beethoven's heart belonged to his one and ONLY true love...his music. Bravo Maestro Bravo!
Beethoven, to me, is an inspiring reminder that we are held prisoners by our senses. He does not need to hear, nor see, nor smell, nor taste, nor touch. He already experiences these joys through the heart. I believe that's why his music lives and not just "sounds." If we focus our attention on our heart, we will hear more, see more, and enjoy life at such a higher, deeper level. Then, we all will be able to write sonatas with our brother Beethoven.
Well many asian pianist will scream at you that the tempo is of here and that only technique counts .Classic has become only a sad replication of itself only few can even beginn tp match the fire of the creator himself Betthoven
Peter, technique, while an important elemental asset enabling competent "communication" of what one feels, is less vital than one's "feeling," itself. The "fire" you cite is forever captured in Beethoven's score, awaiting anyone who can allow themselves the freedom to go back in time to that stormy night when he suffered the pains of realizing his life would likely be without the love he yearned for. Watching those silvery clouds hide the moon only to have the moon explode each time between, like his heart fighting to never surrender to the dark of hopelessness. Feel that pain and this masterpiece will allow you to release it.
@@carlorachel it's total bs that "technique" isn't as important as "feel" because playing something with feel always requires technique
Dom, while I don't know what has gotten into you, I do say your biliousness works to scuttle what could be civil conversation. Technique is important but it is not the soul of music to which I am referring.
@@carlorachel maybe he's had a bad day, but still your right, kind of sad to see people talking to each other in an uncivilized manner
you can feel his wrath on the freaking piano
fuk ye bro
The most amazing thing about Beethoven is that his career should have been over when his hearing started to go because at a the time most of a musician's income came from teaching and live performing, which one needed to hear and react to. It is a myth that composers made money by being privately, divinely inspired in their study.
Just realized that 2:43 is what Chopin added in his Fantaisie-Impromptu
Very observant. Correct.
Similar, but Chopin was his own unique musician!!
Fryderyk Franciszek Chopin HAHAHAHAHA
@@jta2 finally! Someone in this thread knows the truth! It’s even in the same key C#m
Nice observation
i could imagine the fear he felt when finding out he was losing his hearing, i couldn’t imagine having to compose whilst being deaf not to mention people still not enjoying the music and his actual genius
The best sounding/played version of this movement anywhere on UA-cam is from this scene lol.
Not even remotely. My personal favourite is Lisitsa's recording, which has video to boot, but there's also a recording by Lugansky which is superb.
SalmonVelvet I agree, others don't have the same fire
I urge you to search Glenn Gould's rendition..
I do not agree. Piano sounds far from perfect, and it sounds a bit too hurried for me
Arrau is the best one.
this is an overwrought last movement to our ear but would be EXACTLY the way it would have sounded to some Beethoven contemporary --- ferocious, wild, brutal. really effective scene
2:16
"My hearing hasn't improved, in fact, I think it may be getting worse, and the lady I told you about, is *not of my class, so marriage is out of the question*
Yeah, he’s way out of her league.
Her:”A deaf musician. Can you imagine that? What would our future be like?”
Then she try’s playing weak sauce keys.
Beethoven plays movement.
Him:”So I realized she’s not my type. Besides my REAL love is music.”
exploding the boundaries of instrumental capabilities and of musical frame. GENIUS
Imagine the power of hearing that live played by Beethoven for his first performance. Amazing
I love the speed and aggression in this version, is there a full version like this one anywhere?
check out the recording by ronald brautigam, it was used in the show
@@peeyansh Thx alot, loved it!
@@peeyansh what show is this?
@@neilcaezar306 i think it’s called the genius of beethoven
@@peeyansh thanks
2:59 I literally got chills
SAME
@@sakkijarvenpolkka2090 same yo…. Jeez
2:26 just hits your soul
2:34 the most chad thing he ever said
Ive watched this like 100 times now and i still get goosebumps everytime
"The lady I told you about is not of my class so marriage is out of the question" my FAVORITE PART
She still plays it ten times better then I even could 😂
That piano needs a cigarette after that
Lol - best comment yet!!!
Pianos tremble, violins quake, and cellos quiver when I enter the room.
reference to the famous movie "1900"?
Or maybe the piano needs one.
Absolute madness
INDEED
THis is a VERY good scene. I like how she really tries hard to follow him with a little amusement. Then she lost track and as he speeds up more and more she feels embarrassed. Maybe partly, because she doubted his genius and maybe of her own inability to being EVER able to reach his level. It seems like she tries to avoid the situation and want to escape, because it she is totally outclassed by him... as a "deaf musician, can you imagine that?!"
It's not that deep lil bro
Wish every pianist played it furiously like this
She rejects him underestimating him -> he responds proving his genius -> she feels reflected like an odious person and blame him for that (bravo...) -> she didn't pass the heart exam for him, goodbye
His mind is unfathomable
The emotions , excitement , praise and admiration created by a great composer like Beethoven transcend the conflicts between nations , racial differences and the times
Beethoven: Rages on the piano.
Girl: Imma head out.
Just try to imagine being there when he first performed this….all your life you’ve just been listening to Bach, Vivaldi, Mozart, and then you hear this.
PS: That is a wonderful arrangement, starting with the "B" section on violin and delaying the "A" section until later on the piano. It gives more prominence to that wonderful, seductive, lyrical B melody. Where did you get that? Is it a common interpretation now? Just wonderful!
What is truly amazing is that he was deaf when he wrote symphony #6. It’s hard to imagine the delicate movements in that peace without being able to hear them. Mozart and Beethoven suffered greatly. Still, they’re music was heavenly. They were a gift to mankind from God.
May god keep making people like Beethoven, a mastermind with absolutely fantastic passion in what he does, Beethoven will live on with his music forever , Beethoven is undeniably the best composer of all time.
He’s the best pianist in the whole world
"What would my future be..." - a wife of one of the top three greatest classical composers of all time.
And in any case I am far to busy with my Music . The whole world is thankful that he was too busy Beethoven will live forever through this music .
I love this piece and I think he is the best Beethoven who I saw in films :)
oh my gods - i have never heard that played so incredibly and beautifully. and the actor who IS Beethoven only adds to the emotional dynamic. he is perfect and simply gorgeous. i already feel so distraught that he’s going deaf. what an incredibly beautiful soul he had. thank you so very much. . . 🌷🎹🌷
1+ compliment for the actor
Beethoven went down in history because he played the piano with passion and intensity!
Mozart saying this? Lol
@@kr3mico335yeah, mozart was playing with passion and intensity too.
she can imagine those fingers making her faint
my dirty mind: ( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
I like how they bookend the relationship with her saying "bravo", as that is also what she says in the scene when she first sees him play. The first is uttered in excitement; the last in resentment.
The actor is the greatest one who has acted beethoven
This is a good portrayal I really think he played this with much anger and relief
A musically talented angel departed heaven for a brief moment in history and was bestowed to us earthlings as a gift-a priceless musical gift. Such was Ludwig Van Beethoven. Bravo maestro. Bravo indeed.
She really is not of his class.
She b lookin' up!!
The most famous movement of this 14th sonata is of course the first, but I can honestly say the 3rd movement is the most metal, hard core musical thing ever composed
Although it's a scene from a movie.
However, the third movement of the Moonlight Sonata played by the alive Beethoven truly touches my heart.
There is frustration with his love and endless anguish about music.
He was a great musician, but at the same time he was a man of endless agony.
So his music feels empathy for humans likes me.
I almost never understand classical music and just listen to some pieces sometimes I liked in the anime your lie in april. I have heard this song before but NEVER EVER in my life I felt the music so much that my heart started shaking and there were tears in my eyes and I could sense his emotions. I have never experienced this. WOW!
Have you listened to chopin's ballade no 1 in G minor (zimmerman's preformance) it was in the anime too.
Watch out for spoilers obviously
Those artists lead very sad lives, exploted by their parents, travling all over Europe in the worst conditions, and Beethoven always had trouble getting work because people couldn't pay him! I think he would be blown away today if he knew how much we love his music and what a genius he was!
0:46
lol that sounded like when I first tried to learn it
I can almost play that part at full speed now
Hawlucha the Hawk me too :3
Its been a month update us!
i can play almost half the song now
ahhahahah before/after
It’s been another month, how much can u play
this piece has more beauty than can be described in human terms. ive yet to see with my eyes something to compare it to.
300 years has passed and has yet to be matched. bravo Beethoven. you fucking absolute Legend!
For very old people of the past who were born during the times of the baroque (1720) this piece must have been an absolute shocker when it came out! xD
Wow. That nothing woman might have had the ninth symphony dedicated to her and her name would live for as long as civilization exists.
TBF he dedicated this sonata to her.
Imagine young musicians who've heard only the measured plinking of court music ... and then you hear THIS - tearing through and ravaging mercilessly your soul, tearing through centuries of sound with a storm of diamonds and liberating music to what was barely imaginable before it.
now that’s crazy talent, i just couldn’t imagine being able to play music like this,
Este video es una pequeñísima parte de la excelente miniserie de la BBC "El genio de Beethoven", a mi juicio la mejor biografía fílmica producida hasta hoy sobre este músico colosal.
Brooo, una pregunta. ¿Sabes dónde lo puedo ver completo?
This is one of the most astonishing music ever conceived and one of the pinnacles of the human being. It leaves me speechless every time I hear it, no matter how many times I did.
Ay dios, Beethoven fácilmente me conmueve, emociona y excita en todos los sentidos.
3:08 That's insanely well Played!
Her: well it’s uhh...
Beethoven: hold my beer 🍺.... actually nevermind, I can hold it *Moonlight Sonata Mvt. 3 blasts*
The Girl: You.
Beethoven: A 5 months old Asian baby.
Guys i didn't stole it i see this comment after commenting ok?
Not ok as well as your english
This is my favorite one of Beethoven I always listen to this ♡
He totally owned her!
REKT!
Like a mother freaken BOSS
Blkchevy98 lmao I really hope ur being ironic
lil slav boi not with that pic and name lol
Coming from the person with that picture
Even I could own her, and I play much less well than Beethoven.
That Piano needs a doctor after Beethoven abused him
Lol!!!
I actually thoght you where ging ging
Ban i did not wanna get the broom chain saw dynamite
I ONLY GOT 1 B I TELL YA
I like the playing of 2:45 leading to the pauses of 2:52 and 2:55... I feel that's how Beethoven would have played it
1:15 lovely, just lovely. The man, the legend, the myth, BEETHOVEN
Bravo indeed! I get to become immortal through my music but you? Dead, gone and forgotten in mere years. Pffft!!
Actually, not quite, she gets to be the punchline in a movie 250 years later....
Ba'zi bir kasb egalari uchun eshitmay qolish, Kar bo'lish kasbiga unchalik ta'sir qilmasligi mumkin lekin musiqachi uchun bu katta fojea.
Betxoven shunday bo'lsada musiqani sevdi.. shunday holatda ham asarlar yaratdi. Betxovenni kuylariday hayajonli, og'riqli musiqa yo'q, baribir uning kuylari boshqacha...
Oy sonatasi esa, Mening musiqam,
Eng sevimli musiqam..
Qalbim og'riganda ham, quvonganimda ham shu kuyni chalaman.
Menga juda ham yoqadi....
Anyone else imagine themselves playing all these masterpieces and impressing everyone?
Seems like it’s just you then mate.
@@Codreanu110 lmao
1:31 the moment she knew what was beethoven capable of doing with his fingers
What? Anything dark? 😂
There was no place for a woman in Beethoven's life, there was only music and everytime he had to choose, he decided for music... and most of the world was and is thanking god that is was like that. He made a couple of the most magnificient gifts to culture and art of all time, many of the greatest pieces of musical artwork are from him. Music for the ages!
Words from the funeral speech for Beethoven: There he stands among the giants, unassailable for all time!
This is my favorite from Beethoven
Beethoven. The GOAT 🐐🥰
Anyone else notice the contrast in how she says “Bravo” here and earlier in the doc? I’ve watched the full documentary 3 times (in a couple years) and watched clips like this several times, but only now noticed.
Love You Beethoven sir .
you become a proffessional pianist when you perform this movement correctly
This movement is quite easy for a pianist
Trust me u need far more than thzt to be a professional pianist
Warai-San I know, but playing it correctly, like Valentina, that's the challenge
@@slimessiful Damn.. Valentina isnt a bad pianist, but we just cant say that she plays it correctly..
@@slimessiful Valentina isnt the pianist to listen to beethov, I dont want to seem haughty or smth, just an advice, i Heard Valentina at Prague in a concert, it's just.. Not the level she should have for an international pianist, I can advice you some one if you want.
She is just incredibly beautiful.
I love this sonata 🌹
Yes.... Even after checking out other sonatas, this sonata is still my no. 1 favorite
I like it when she plays slow. You can hear the notes of the moonlight intro, just backwards :D
I remembered see that first time many years ago and I almost cried. Now I see it again and I almost cried again. I managed to keep myself not to become ridiculous thinking that humanity will not see a man like him again. At least in my days.
1:24 he’s literally clawing at the piano
This version of how its played is the sexiest and most elegant
Its like he's making love to the melody .
What melody? It is just some arpeggios and smashing the chords.
@@DanielFahimi 1:47 What do you call this?
Daniel Fahimi sir, do u have stupid
@@30VUU Well u have stupid. There is very few melody.
@UCEBWVuTrXBLJIA56F-2_JYg You stupid or what? I never said anything bad about Beethoven. I just said this particular movement isn't melodic and that doesn't mean that it's bad.