TLDR; Edifier S351DB is way better than Logitech Z623 especially when you hear them in person. Long answer - I owned Z623 for over 3 years then got S351DB. I’ve tested the two extensively, listened to 300-500 hours of music on the S351DB and some movies/series. S351DB is better in every aspects. Highs mids and lows are all on a different level from Z623. It sounds much cleaner with tighter bass response. Short description of these is they sound clean, tight, and accurate. There’s lot of detail to sounds especially when listening to rock or metal I can hear more instruments, the vocals sound insanely clear the best I’ve heard in my life so far it sounds as if the singer is in front of you. The bass sounds clean and really tight fast response whereas the z623 is muddy and boomy. Z623’s bass response is also sloppy relatively speaking. After using both the speakers side by side for 2 months I’ve finally sold my Z623. I even got my audiophile friend to listen to both for hours. He’s a pure audiophile who’s sound system setup costs over $50,000 I don’t need to say anything more hahaha and even he confirmed that there’s no comparison between the two S351DB is the clear winner. I will say this tho, initially you might not like S351DB. After listening to z623 for 3 years my ears were accustomed to its sound signature. After very thorough comparisons I noticed now that it (z623) would boost bass in all sorts of music and audio. It’s like Samsung’s AMOLED displays from back in the days which would boost and saturate colours, similarly the z623 does that too with bass. If you decide to get the S351DB it’d be really tempting to bump up the bass slider but don’t give into that temptation. The sound is really balanced out of the box and sounds like they way intended by the creator. Another thing, S351DB is louder. I compared both at 50% volume and Z623 seemed to be louder that 50% volume of S351DB. But at 40% volume and above the z623’s sound starts getting distorted. It gets really distorted over 60% volume and becomes unusable whereas The S351 is clean all the way through.
The Edifier sounds better all round. I have been using the Z623 for 3 years now, just ordered the Edifier S351DB to upgrade. I will give another update once my Edifier S351DB gets delivered in 2 weeks. (Hopefully I won't forget)
wouldnt really consider the edifier's satellites. That set is more like a bookshelf speaker with an added sub. the size of the speakers would not be convenient or neat for a desktop setup. If size was of no concern, there are better choices.
I love the bass of the logitech but I feel that those satellites lack more acoustic level, however the edifier sounds good but it sounds too acoustic. I would like to try with more music rhythms.
certification means absolutely nothing, it's easy to buy if you have money... and even if it's possible, it means, at most, for humming during movies, but it's useless when it comes to the purity of reproduced music
I have the Edifier and my friend has the Logitech and these are not even in the same league. The Klipsch Promedia or Bose Companion 50 would be a more worthy opponent for the S351 but I think it beats even those overall.
Mano, o z623 consome até 125W de energia elétrica e tem certificação THX. Não existe nada melhor, a não ser que seja customizado, tipo um JBL A100P, que só ele como subwoofer console 205W de energia elétrica. Estou atualmente buscando algo melhor que o Z623 e realmente pensei em comprar outro Z625 e usar o dois juntos. Mas preferi investir tudo num JBL A100P + Edifier R1700BTs. Aí sim acredito que conseguirei superar o meu Z623. Tenho ele há 10 anos e quero dar ele de presente pra minha sala kkkkkkkkk
Ciao, pensi che lo z623 vada bene collegato ad una tastiera musicale workstation, parlo ad uso casalingo, ho meglio una coppia monitor tipo m audio bx4. Grazie
logitech ha un basso più presente che parte da 30hz , invece edifier parte da 40 hz . entrambi tagliano a circa 130hz . Ma attenzione perché logitec ha una forte carenza intorno ai 140 - 250 hz . Quindi edifier rimane una scelta migliore!
Porém o z623 consome até 125W de energia elétrica. É extremamente potente, podendo atingir 115db nos graves entre 20hz e 150hz. O satélites são com agudos afinados à certificação THX. Definitivamente são um conjunto 2.1 feito para adultos, porém quem compram são gamers hahahahaha. Felizes os gamers que têm ele. Seja o Z623 ou Z625.
@@TuTaRR1eu tinha uma z623 deu problema e ninguém conseguiu consertar ela, daí tá guardada, agora eu tenho um logitech z625, o único “problema” que vejo é não ter bluetooth, coloquei um adaptador nela, mas não prestou, o som perde mta qualidade até os graves ficam ruins! Agora tô de olho nessa edifier! Eu comprei a z625 no Paraguai paguei 135 dólares, ficou uns 690 reais final do ano de 2023, uma pena elas não ter bluetooth, a logitech tinha q lançar um modelo novo com bt e controle remoto conexões atuais!
its also in a different SIZE league. duh. size does limit audio performance no matter how you want to swing the math. Would be weird if the Audioengine 2+ sounds BETTER than the 5+ ?
@@JerNYCJer The problem with logitech is that they dont offer anything decent, just regular computer speakers that are nowhere near to hi-fi standards.
I got thise speakers for like 8 months and useing every day on pc with optic cable and bluetooth with phone never head speakers with this quality sound and i was replaceing my Logitech Z5500 and it was my best choice since than it got doubled the price in my country .. i never heard before about edifier only when they released the Edifier R1280T and Edifier R1280DB a cheap less than 100 euro system but gives lessons for speakers in 500 euro range .
@@AbsoluteFidelity Can’t tell you exactly I am not an expert but you know you feel the difference between the two this one have that really high quality maybe that is what peoples call fidelity I’m using it on a high end pc and sometimes as bluetooth speaker and just works great .. never hade an issue with it...
@@Xabiroo bass wise, which one would you choose? I know that mids and treble definitely go to the Edifier. What about bass? Which goes deeper, which has more slam?
@@Xabiroo You mean you use an optic cable to connect with your PC directly? I thought optics only available on TVs. How can I also use the optic with my Macbook, any ideas? Do I have to buy some sort of an adapter from an optic (on the speaker) to a USB-C on my Macbook? Is that the way to set up? My new M1 Macbook Air will arrive in a few days.
@@klaaskay2685 I dont know if you use a 3rd device like some kind of converter what quality you will get , if i would use a macbook i would connect with bluetooth and thats what you will do also 😂😉
Ciao spero che tu possa aiutarmi, io ho acquistato Logitech Z623 THX Sistema di Altoparlanti 2.1 con Subwoofer, e vorrei connetterlo al mio TV smat lg 4k ovviamente non a l'ingresso jack ho provato a connettere il Extremella Convertitore da RCA a HDMI ( i 2 spinotti bianco e rosso dietro il Subwoofer. E HDMI dietro il TV poi non riesco a configurarlo . Grazie
@@lucasalvatore28 i smart TV LG di ultima generazione non c'è l'anno. Ma. Ho. Già risolto. Con AMANKA Digitale ad Analogico Convertitore Adattatore Audio Uscita 3.5mm da Coaxial Toslink Ottico SPDIF Digitale ad Analogico Grazie per il tempismo della tua risposta. Ti auguro buona giornata
VÝKON/KVALITA/VELIKOST a hlavne CENA!!! Logitech Z-5500 nema absolutni konkurenci. Srovnavejte stejne drahe reproduktory. ua-cam.com/video/c21mmTRRkds/v-deo.htmlsi=WSsqAcZT9Kd8Y1dg
@Сибиряк пока юзаю свен стрим мега р и свен роял р2 , обе хорошие , тож ищу себе 2.1, мне понравился логитеч Z синема ,или едифер 530, или 360 , в живую не слушал , только в наушниках интернет , люблю детальный и сочный барханный бас
@@zeroblue09 one thing is noise, and another thing is sound. if you want a lot of bass, buy a vacuum cleaner and run it. here we are talking about the quality of reproduced music, and boom cink is not music but noise.
It does have a soundstage. Literally the best thing Z623 has going for it is soundstage. The soundstage is even slightly better than Klipsch Promedia 2.1's (I have both and hear both regularly) but Logitech only shines in movies, gaming and limited range of music that favors a V profile signature. Klipsch and Edifiers shine at literally everything you throw at it so logi is definitely inferior. Yeah, no mids means no clarity, you're right and that's a deal breaker for most as mids are the bones of sound but from what I hear, the edifier blows both logi and Klipsch out the water
Edifier is warmer and transparent in vocals and bass, lower in freq and louder
TLDR; Edifier S351DB is way better than Logitech Z623 especially when you hear them in person.
Long answer -
I owned Z623 for over 3 years then got S351DB. I’ve tested the two extensively, listened to 300-500 hours of music on the S351DB and some movies/series.
S351DB is better in every aspects. Highs mids and lows are all on a different level from Z623. It sounds much cleaner with tighter bass response. Short description of these is they sound clean, tight, and accurate. There’s lot of detail to sounds especially when listening to rock or metal I can hear more instruments, the vocals sound insanely clear the best I’ve heard in my life so far it sounds as if the singer is in front of you. The bass sounds clean and really tight fast response whereas the z623 is muddy and boomy. Z623’s bass response is also sloppy relatively speaking.
After using both the speakers side by side for 2 months I’ve finally sold my Z623.
I even got my audiophile friend to listen to both for hours. He’s a pure audiophile who’s sound system setup costs over $50,000 I don’t need to say anything more hahaha and even he confirmed that there’s no comparison between the two S351DB is the clear winner.
I will say this tho, initially you might not like S351DB. After listening to z623 for 3 years my ears were accustomed to its sound signature. After very thorough comparisons I noticed now that it (z623) would boost bass in all sorts of music and audio. It’s like Samsung’s AMOLED displays from back in the days which would boost and saturate colours, similarly the z623 does that too with bass.
If you decide to get the S351DB it’d be really tempting to bump up the bass slider but don’t give into that temptation. The sound is really balanced out of the box and sounds like they way intended by the creator.
Another thing, S351DB is louder. I compared both at 50% volume and Z623 seemed to be louder that 50% volume of S351DB. But at 40% volume and above the z623’s sound starts getting distorted. It gets really distorted over 60% volume and becomes unusable whereas The S351 is clean all the way through.
no logitech is better in every way
brand fan boy hahahah
@@ercanylmaz967
The Edifier sounds better all round. I have been using the Z623 for 3 years now, just ordered the Edifier S351DB to upgrade. I will give another update once my Edifier S351DB gets delivered in 2 weeks. (Hopefully I won't forget)
Hopefully 😅
@@sw1samir give and update here once you got it.
Yes how's the s351db's?
@@n54e82 I have bought one 5 days ago and I love it
Bro how is it? I'm basshead and want upgrade from Logitech Z623.
I need Logitech woofer and Edifier satellite combination :-)
wouldnt really consider the edifier's satellites. That set is more like a bookshelf speaker with an added sub. the size of the speakers would not be convenient or neat for a desktop setup. If size was of no concern, there are better choices.
@@JerNYCJer what are those better choices ?
I love the bass of the logitech but I feel that those satellites lack more acoustic level, however the edifier sounds good but it sounds too acoustic. I would like to try with more music rhythms.
How do pornographic movies play on this audio system?
What is the first music you played?
Thank for your vidieo
The treble sounds synthetic on the S351DB comnpared to the Logitech which presents a more natural sound in my opinion.
Claro, o Z623 tem certificação THX. Tudo soa de acordo com o que o produtor da fonte do áudio quis que você ouvisse!
certification means absolutely nothing, it's easy to buy if you have money... and even if it's possible, it means, at most, for humming during movies, but it's useless when it comes to the purity of reproduced music
Definitely Edifier.
Uploaded this year but using windows 7. What the
I have the Edifier and my friend has the Logitech and these are not even in the same league. The Klipsch Promedia or Bose Companion 50 would be a more worthy opponent for the S351 but I think it beats even those overall.
Mano, o z623 consome até 125W de energia elétrica e tem certificação THX. Não existe nada melhor, a não ser que seja customizado, tipo um JBL A100P, que só ele como subwoofer console 205W de energia elétrica.
Estou atualmente buscando algo melhor que o Z623 e realmente pensei em comprar outro Z625 e usar o dois juntos. Mas preferi investir tudo num JBL A100P + Edifier R1700BTs. Aí sim acredito que conseguirei superar o meu Z623. Tenho ele há 10 anos e quero dar ele de presente pra minha sala kkkkkkkkk
Who the hell compares super market sound system to edifier anyway?
fanatics of bass and musical style like boom bac bang :D
no logitech is better in every way
@@ercanylmaz967logitech ma silnejsi bass, to je jasny. A halvne polovicni cenu 😂😂😂😂
Ciao, pensi che lo z623 vada bene collegato ad una tastiera musicale workstation, parlo ad uso casalingo, ho meglio una coppia monitor tipo m audio bx4. Grazie
ti sconsiglio.il.623 , i medi sono soffocati troppo
Which one have good bass ?
logitech ha un basso più presente che parte da 30hz , invece edifier parte da 40 hz . entrambi tagliano a circa 130hz . Ma attenzione perché logitec ha una forte carenza intorno ai 140 - 250 hz . Quindi edifier rimane una scelta migliore!
351 is deeper bass better bottom end
Z623 is King of bass bro i have it and frequency responde is 35 hz to 20 khz
@@berjonibro3564 where did you buy the Logitech z623
@@gaming3git136 if u don't like logitech go to edifier to quality sound for bass is nothing edifier
Os dois parecem com boa qualidade de som fiel nos graves, médios e agudos
Porém o z623 consome até 125W de energia elétrica. É extremamente potente, podendo atingir 115db nos graves entre 20hz e 150hz. O satélites são com agudos afinados à certificação THX. Definitivamente são um conjunto 2.1 feito para adultos, porém quem compram são gamers hahahahaha. Felizes os gamers que têm ele. Seja o Z623 ou Z625.
@@TuTaRR1I think the edifiers are better gamers would be more happier with those😊
@@TuTaRR1eu tinha uma z623 deu problema e ninguém conseguiu consertar ela, daí tá guardada, agora eu tenho um logitech z625, o único “problema” que vejo é não ter bluetooth, coloquei um adaptador nela, mas não prestou, o som perde mta qualidade até os graves ficam ruins!
Agora tô de olho nessa edifier!
Eu comprei a z625 no Paraguai paguei 135 dólares, ficou uns 690 reais final do ano de 2023, uma pena elas não ter bluetooth, a logitech tinha q lançar um modelo novo com bt e controle remoto conexões atuais!
Klipsch promedia 2.1 vs s350db
Yeah, I was wondering why the 1 was there. I was thinking maybe there was a model I hadn't heard about. Maybe it's a regional thing.
@@brucelivingston2220 nah it’s a newer version, black with a better remote. That’s about it.
Edifier is in a different league.
its also in a different SIZE league. duh. size does limit audio performance no matter how you want to swing the math. Would be weird if the Audioengine 2+ sounds BETTER than the 5+ ?
@@JerNYCJer The problem with logitech is that they dont offer anything decent, just regular computer speakers that are nowhere near to hi-fi standards.
no logitech is better in every way
What is the first song ?
Please compare Logitech z623 vs edifier t5
I got thise speakers for like 8 months and useing every day on pc with optic cable and bluetooth with phone never head speakers with this quality sound and i was replaceing my Logitech Z5500 and it was my best choice since than it got doubled the price in my country .. i never heard before about edifier only when they released the Edifier R1280T and Edifier R1280DB a cheap less than 100 euro system but gives lessons for speakers in 500 euro range .
The S351's bass is better than the the z5500?? Deeper?
@@AbsoluteFidelity Can’t tell you exactly I am not an expert but you know you feel the difference between the two this one have that really high quality maybe that is what peoples call fidelity I’m using it on a high end pc and sometimes as bluetooth speaker and just works great .. never hade an issue with it...
@@Xabiroo bass wise, which one would you choose? I know that mids and treble definitely go to the Edifier. What about bass? Which goes deeper, which has more slam?
@@Xabiroo You mean you use an optic cable to connect with your PC directly? I thought optics only available on TVs. How can I also use the optic with my Macbook, any ideas? Do I have to buy some sort of an adapter from an optic (on the speaker) to a USB-C on my Macbook? Is that the way to set up? My new M1 Macbook Air will arrive in a few days.
@@klaaskay2685 I dont know if you use a 3rd device like some kind of converter what quality you will get , if i would use a macbook i would connect with bluetooth and thats what you will do also 😂😉
Ciao spero che tu possa aiutarmi, io ho acquistato Logitech Z623 THX Sistema di Altoparlanti 2.1 con Subwoofer, e vorrei connetterlo al mio TV smat lg 4k ovviamente non a l'ingresso jack ho provato a connettere il Extremella Convertitore da RCA a HDMI ( i 2 spinotti bianco e rosso dietro il Subwoofer. E HDMI dietro il TV poi non riesco a configurarlo . Grazie
ma non puoi con l.hdmi far uscire l.audio dalla tv, non è possibile...
proprio sicuro che tale tv non ha un uscita jack per le cuffie?
@@lucasalvatore28 i smart TV LG di ultima generazione non c'è l'anno. Ma. Ho. Già risolto. Con
AMANKA Digitale ad Analogico Convertitore Adattatore Audio Uscita 3.5mm da Coaxial Toslink Ottico SPDIF Digitale ad Analogico
Grazie per il tempismo della tua risposta. Ti auguro buona giornata
VÝKON/KVALITA/VELIKOST a hlavne CENA!!! Logitech Z-5500 nema absolutni konkurenci.
Srovnavejte stejne drahe reproduktory.
ua-cam.com/video/c21mmTRRkds/v-deo.htmlsi=WSsqAcZT9Kd8Y1dg
edifire win
How do pornographic movies play on this audio system?
no logitech is better in every way
и что лучше в звуке ?
@@Fitd47ci мне по звуку
@@Fitd47ci только у эдиков большой косяк с писком)
@Сибиряк пока юзаю свен стрим мега р и свен роял р2 , обе хорошие , тож ищу себе 2.1, мне понравился логитеч Z синема ,или едифер 530, или 360 , в живую не слушал , только в наушниках интернет , люблю детальный и сочный барханный бас
@Сибиряк а ты что юзаешь?
@Сибиряк тож были 5.1 продал все
edifier !!! ... rip logi
no logitech is better in every way
Ciao il Logitech non ha il bluetooth vero?
ciao no
@@lucasalvatore28 io sono indeciso...io lo comprerei per ascoltare musica..quale consiglieresti?
@@paolo5861 ascoltare musica e magari suonarla pure? tutta la vita EDIFIER
@@paolo5861 logitech ha i bassi pompati , e ha carenza dei toni medio bassi sui 2 satelliti... purtroppo si percepisce e la qualità scende...
Edifier
good edi
ua-cam.com/video/ILoOor9MSco/v-deo.htmlsi=X9ZgXIGN0QK8MCjT
Edifier Vam muze polibit prdel.
Navic Edifier taky bral komponenty od TangBand jako Logitech.
351 win
yes i'm think too
I don't know, the edifiers are too acoustic, the bass is lost, and the logitech has more bass and they lack more acoustic
@@zeroblue09 Probably possible to get more reverb on 351 through settings. No way to know for sure on this kind of youtube comparison
@@zeroblue09 one thing is noise, and another thing is sound. if you want a lot of bass, buy a vacuum cleaner and run it. here we are talking about the quality of reproduced music, and boom cink is not music but noise.
I can hear no difference
You're surprised, it's YT.
edifier is like a wearing a 250ohms headphone
Logitech is so dull...
How do pornographic movies play on this audio system?
Bass only is NOT music. Logitech is garbage only for gaming and yeeeaaaa bassss 🤢🤢🤮🤮. No clarity, no soundstage whatsoever. Bye
that's exactly what I'm trying to explain in the comment that music is not just bass from 40 to 120hz. and the remaining 19000hz is what? vacuum?
It does have a soundstage. Literally the best thing Z623 has going for it is soundstage. The soundstage is even slightly better than Klipsch Promedia 2.1's (I have both and hear both regularly) but Logitech only shines in movies, gaming and limited range of music that favors a V profile signature. Klipsch and Edifiers shine at literally everything you throw at it so logi is definitely inferior. Yeah, no mids means no clarity, you're right and that's a deal breaker for most as mids are the bones of sound but from what I hear, the edifier blows both logi and Klipsch out the water
How do pornographic movies play on this audio system?
no logitech is better in every way