Try watching it while you work in criminal justice and know the classification code like the back of your hand. I think there are fewer characters that aren't felons than those that are. The only St. is probably Emily's dad.
@@dem0litionsss it was confirmed that he didn't know her age because she lied. You saying he did know is just your headcanon theory. Your headcanon theory is what doesn't matter.
I disagree with Aria's worst thing. I think Aria's worst thing is destroying Emily and Alison's nursery. Yes, the way she treated Hanna was awful. However, the fact that she was willing to destroy the bedroom of two of her best friend's future children all to protect her abuser from facing the consequences of his actions, is just absolutely disgusting.
I think it’s a tie!! She literally yelled at Hanna in rage over an actual traumatic situation.. friends especially should stick together and believe each other when it comes to things like these. I can barely ever forgive Aria when she lashes outs at her “friends” 😩
I actually think this is furthest thing from the worst of Alison. Remember she was only 13 at the time, and the entire incident was an accident - a prank gone wrong. The outcome was tragic but realistically it shouldn’t define her. The blame which was placed on Toby only landed him in juvie for a year or less. 🤷♀️
@@roses7400 When Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too. A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response. Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟. That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her. That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
In the books (spoilers) Toby was an abuser and “alison” was trying to help her and accidentally blinded her. But in the show version I agree since it doesn’t correlate with Toby’s charafter
and used his juice to fertilize Emily and alisons baby ? how when she was in the mirror with the baby and she said she knew he would have nice eyes and male beautiful babies . that was spine chilling
Tampering with Ian’s corpse, attempting to murder Alison, actually bludgeoning Bethany, accidentally killing Charlotte and then dressing and cleaning her body to stage it, in a way that would incriminate Spencer. These have to be her most heinous actions imo.
4:39 also because she felt like if he didn’t sleep with her, that meant he wasn’t attracted to her. and considering her history with food/her body, she felt like she had to get that validation from him
hanna's worst thing being just regular teenage angst (not defending it, but definitely keeping in mind that she is a 15/16 year old girl who just wanted her boyfriend to want her) while everyone else is literally murder, kidnapping, assault, etc. sends me
@@LucyDudgeon23 she's my favourite too! top 3 being hanna, spencer and mona (she COUNTS okay!). the way it got worse as it goes down my list lol but i'm just gay
Remember when she listened to aria gush about her date with Ezra knowing she had gifted the tickets to Ella to expose it all.... Or when she told aria not to tell the cops about her groomer..... She wasn't an angel either
The worst thing Mary did was the fully premeditated murder of her twin sister, then she was involved with Rollins’ plot to steal Alison’s money. She knew what Alex was doing and gave no pushback. ❤love her tho slay
@@jasonmoukala8909 that’s Mary’s story, but no evidence is shown to support it - personally I don’t think she’s a reliable narrator! Mirroring Spencer and Alex’s narrative, I believe Mary always resented Jessica for having the life that Mary felt robbed of. Shorty after Jessica’s death, Mary literally dressed as Jessica to watch Spencer, just like how later Alex impersonated Spencer. We know this was not the first time Mary impersonated Jessica, since that was what led to the conception of Spencer and Alex in the first place. To me, Mary’s character is similar to Mona’s - both highly intelligent, secretive and vengeful.
If I remember correctly, Caleb didn’t actually fall in love with Miranda or left Hanna for her, she went missing and he just went looking for her, so I don’t think it was that bad as he was trying to save someone’s life ? For me, the Spaleb thing is definitely the worst thing he did, like how can you date your first love’s best friend ?!! I don’t know what the writers did to Caleb but his character just annoyed me towards the end. They ruined so many people, it’s so sad Also I totally agree that male traumas definitely don’t get talked about enough! Like,Toby was assaulted multiple times by different people and Peter is forced to have children with his assaulter (though he should have kept his legs closed 😭)
ian’s overall character is the worst thing he’s done 😭 terrrrribllleeeee maaan…the underage stuff i mentioned is just the dust on top of the many layers of him honestly!!
nahh no way dating your friends high school boyfriend after she was already engaged to another man is worse than kidnapping and defacing someone’s grave. while its still not great, definitely not worse than
i think the worst thing ashley’s done was being sesually active with hanna around the house, specially with wilden. i know she did it to protect her daughter and although i love her, i think doing it with hanna there seeing and hearing it was f up. also hooking up with jason was weird as hell, he’s so much younger and she saw him grow up
I would agree HOWEVER 1) Ashley didn’t know that Hanna was up that late. 2) Wilden used his position as a police officer to blackmail and coerce Ashley. He essentially R worded her.
Well, you need to follow the timeline of when Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too. A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response. Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟. That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her. That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
Didn't Emily kill two people? She killed Lyndon James and she was the reason Noel Kahn died. (And before someone replies to this like "no she didn't kill Noel", let me just remind you that she punched him so hard that he fell on an axe and was beheaded. 💀) Sure, it was self-defence both times but killing a man not once but twice is arguably worse than framing someone for murder. 😬
lyndon was actually pure self defence though? he shot caleb and was about to kill her too, as well as him being maya’s stalker and killer ! and the noel ones is also kinda the same…he bought the axe to kill them, she had no pure intention to go out of her way to kill him
This is such an interesting concept/video. my thoughts to add on, sorry its a bit of an essay haha: even though Noel was a POS Hanna abducting him and hurting him is probably the worst thing shes ever done imo haha. Emily I would say killing that guy- it was self-defence, but it is still murder, so i would class it as worse than almost planting evidence?? Toby didn't watch the girls, Ali made that up. Moana is such a hard one for picking one worst thing like she was such a menace lmao we love her but she hit hannah with a car, killed multiple people and tortured the girls like how do we chose just one?!🤣🤣 Melissa also killed someone but to be fair I agree with your point as her killing bethany wasnt purposeful. i dont understand how she can say she buried her to protect spencer and then not protect spencer any other time like she literally bullies her and victim blames her and forces her abuser to live in her garden like pick a side! Ashley ran Wilden over which could arguably be worse than stealing money? however he totally deserved it & survived... and she also paid (most of) the money back to the old dead lady so... she basically is not too bad compared to others Caleb basically started seeing hanna to spy on her for Jenna which is super shady, or cheating on Spencer with hanna. considering everyone else does felonies he really isnt that bad ey!
Alison did not make up. Her suspicions about Toby. You need to follow the timeline of when Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too. A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response. Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟. That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her. That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
@@sarickacampbell2642 I think she did make it up; it is never confirmed that she actually saw him creeping, and they heavily imply it was a lie or heavily exaggerated within the show, plus she lied as much as she breathed air. She didn’t know Jenna was SA’ing Toby until she went to do the stink bomb, hence her shocked expression when she looked inside, and her comments in the argument after. So take that out of your comment- still a “depraved pervert”, for simply being a loner? As she didn’t know who he was “sleeping with” Their argument was him saying he wasn’t peeping and then her blackmailing him, using his trauma against him. How kind! Ali not “intending” to blind Jenna isn’t all too relevant imo, it is still the worst thing she has ever done. i.e you don’t mean to kill someone, but you still did- you didn’t mean to blind them, but you did. the outcome is criminal regardless. She then didn’t even apologise she double and tripled down on it by threatening her multiple times. She may not have meant to but she didn’t show remorse either. Theres also the theory that if it was following the books for this plot but gender flipped then it was somewhat intentional, but that is just a theory ofc. But seriously, throwing a stink *bomb* in a closed room knowing someone is in there is malicious intent, what did she think would happen… She was a horrible person before A and before she found out about the NAT club- they didn’t make her who she is she was just a mean person. Yes being groomed by multiple older me, exploited by NAT & bullied by A, would make it worse, but she had already done a lot of shady stuff anyway so it can’t all be blamed on them. We can like a character without erasing the bad things they do or pinning blame for the bad things onto someone else. I love Alis character (pre time jump) but she is evil lol
@@jackie9090 A stink bomb is not a malicious intent. Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place. By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there. And Jenna was not the target. 🎯 She clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby. Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs. The night of the explosion, her fight with him was about him lurking around and spying on her. And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars did even when Allison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her. Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer. Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done. He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime. Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him. But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️ Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risk her life to bring them home. 🏡 And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same. Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative. So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻 Alison suffers from being an enigma. Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️ How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality? (Ezria) is an example of that. Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was. Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival. Alison lived in poverty and squalor. She could’ve left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could. Her actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot. She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t. She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
@@jackie9090 A stink bomb is not a malicious intent. Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place. By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there. And Jenna was not the target. 🎯 Jenna was probably in the shed trying to sexually assault Toby again and karma did what it does. Alison clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby. Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs. The night of the explosion, Alison fight with him was about Toby was about him lurking around and spying on her. And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars and their parents thought that too. Based off of Toby‘s behavior alone, they all thought this even when Alison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her. Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer. Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done. He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime. Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him. But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️ Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risked her life to bring them home. 🏡 And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same. Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative. So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻 Alison suffers from being an enigma. Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️ How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality? (Ezria) is an example of that. Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was. Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival. Alison lived in poverty and squalor. She could have left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could. Her actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot. She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t. She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
@@jackie9090 A stink bomb is not a malicious intent. Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place. By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there. And Jenna was not the target. 🎯 Jenna was probably in the shed trying to sexually assault Toby again and karma did what it does. Alison clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby. Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs. The night of the explosion, Alison fight with him was about Toby was about him lurking around and spying on her. And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars and their parents thought that too. Based off of Toby‘s behavior alone, they all thought this even when Alison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her. Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer. Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done. He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime. Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him. But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️ Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risked her life to bring them home. 🏡 And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same. Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative. So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻 Alison suffers from being an enigma. Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️ How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality? (Ezria) is an example of that. Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was. Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival. Alison lived in poverty and squalor. She could have left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could. Alison actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot. She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t. She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
Lovely video with great points but audio grated me. A little tip keep your mic in one spot as you are beautifully animated however the mic is picking up the movement sound as it's so close to your mouth.
![an unhinged deep dive into the pretty little liars books [PART 1]](/img/n.gif)
Watching Pll as a criminal justice major is such a journey cause felonies are being committed left and right
THIS IS SO FUNNY 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
@@LucyDudgeon23 no because during my last rewatch the girls were doing everything I was learning about in lectures and I was LOSING IT
As a criminology student this is way to true 😅 it’s a wild ride
THE WAY I GAGGED
Try watching it while you work in criminal justice and know the classification code like the back of your hand. I think there are fewer characters that aren't felons than those that are. The only St. is probably Emily's dad.
Also I’m not buying that Ezra did not know Alison was 14. Absolutely no chance someone could mistake a 14 year old child for an adult
Especially considering he turned around and intentionally hooked up with a 16 year old lmao
@BeautyQueen2023Xdoesnt matter no one would actually believe a 14 year old saying they’re 19
@@dem0litionsss it was confirmed that he didn't know her age because she lied. You saying he did know is just your headcanon theory. Your headcanon theory is what doesn't matter.
@@Riskofrain527 the point is NO 14 year old looks 21. he’s just attracted to kids
Well Allison did look older if we go by flashbacks
I disagree with Aria's worst thing.
I think Aria's worst thing is destroying Emily and Alison's nursery. Yes, the way she treated Hanna was awful. However, the fact that she was willing to destroy the bedroom of two of her best friend's future children all to protect her abuser from facing the consequences of his actions, is just absolutely disgusting.
oh yeah absolutely!! this is defo a valid point
She was always choosing Ezra over the girls who did more for her than that man ever did.
I think it’s a tie!! She literally yelled at Hanna in rage over an actual traumatic situation.. friends especially should stick together and believe each other when it comes to things like these. I can barely ever forgive Aria when she lashes outs at her “friends” 😩
alison fr blinded someone because she felt threatened 😭
like…is it ever that serious
I actually think this is furthest thing from the worst of Alison. Remember she was only 13 at the time, and the entire incident was an accident - a prank gone wrong. The outcome was tragic but realistically it shouldn’t define her. The blame which was placed on Toby only landed him in juvie for a year or less. 🤷♀️
@@roses7400 When Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too.
A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response.
Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟.
That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her.
That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
Don't forget Alison completely dismissing the girls' mental health and asking them to lie so Charlotte could get out of the mental hospital.
@@emilysullivan3875 well they completely dismissed her trauma. So I’m not about to throw them a pity party.
Good point but I think it's understandable. Alison was just desperate for a loving family member, she did far worse things.
to me - hannah’s worst action is definitely preventing aria from going to the cops abt ezra.
The worst thing Emily did was date Paige after she tried to drown her 😂
LITERALLYYYY I GET BAFFLED EVERY TIME I RMB
I do not know one person who liked Paige…
The worst thing Mona ever did was obviously running Hanna over with a car and trying to kill Alison and murdering Bethany Young and Charlotte.
Exactly
charlotte deserved it
Summary, PLL has the worst parents and the apples didn’t fall far from the tree 😂
I’m pretty sure Toby never watched the girls, Ali made it up so she’d have an excuse to hurt jenna with the firecracker
In the books (spoilers) Toby was an abuser and “alison” was trying to help her and accidentally blinded her. But in the show version I agree since it doesn’t correlate with Toby’s charafter
Did you forget the Alex literally TURNED WREN INTO A DIAMOND????
that was a gaggery sorry
@@LucyDudgeon23😭😭😭
and used his juice to fertilize Emily and alisons baby ? how when she was in the mirror with the baby and she said she knew he would have nice eyes and male beautiful babies . that was spine chilling
Melissa also buried someone alive so...
Love a Mona apologist. “She was the best gal around! Murder? What murder?”
Also that time she intentionally faked her own death and let her mother believe she was dead
Tampering with Ian’s corpse, attempting to murder Alison, actually bludgeoning Bethany, accidentally killing Charlotte and then dressing and cleaning her body to stage it, in a way that would incriminate Spencer. These have to be her most heinous actions imo.
like SORRY I SUPPORT WOMENS RIGHTS AND WRONGS
4:39 also because she felt like if he didn’t sleep with her, that meant he wasn’t attracted to her. and considering her history with food/her body, she felt like she had to get that validation from him
hanna's worst thing being just regular teenage angst (not defending it, but definitely keeping in mind that she is a 15/16 year old girl who just wanted her boyfriend to want her) while everyone else is literally murder, kidnapping, assault, etc.
sends me
yeah i understand the hanna stuff, honestly i couldn’t fault her much in the show and she was my fave liar!!
THE DIFFERENCE IS KILLING ME
@@LucyDudgeon23 she's my favourite too! top 3 being hanna, spencer and mona (she COUNTS okay!). the way it got worse as it goes down my list lol but i'm just gay
Remember when she listened to aria gush about her date with Ezra knowing she had gifted the tickets to Ella to expose it all.... Or when she told aria not to tell the cops about her groomer..... She wasn't an angel either
Aria and Alison’s list is too long lol they are both HORRIBLE people ngl. They would’ve made the perfect A team
where did these girls even get the time to do all this
they had 0 bookings and a dream ❤️❤️❤️
Right! Great point! Like I struggle as it is with a full time job and life 😅
Didn't Hannah try to cover up a murder in Season 4? Well, it was Wilden's death, so it wasn't really that wrong, hahaha.
It was a murder, but not a crime.
It was illegal, but not immoral
The worst thing Mary did was the fully premeditated murder of her twin sister, then she was involved with Rollins’ plot to steal Alison’s money. She knew what Alex was doing and gave no pushback. ❤love her tho slay
Mary only did that cuz she found out Jessica and Peter were planning to kill her
@@jasonmoukala8909 that’s Mary’s story, but no evidence is shown to support it - personally I don’t think she’s a reliable narrator! Mirroring Spencer and Alex’s narrative, I believe Mary always resented Jessica for having the life that Mary felt robbed of. Shorty after Jessica’s death, Mary literally dressed as Jessica to watch Spencer, just like how later Alex impersonated Spencer. We know this was not the first time Mary impersonated Jessica, since that was what led to the conception of Spencer and Alex in the first place. To me, Mary’s character is similar to Mona’s - both highly intelligent, secretive and vengeful.
@@roses7400 Peter literally admitted it in season 7
@@jasonmoukala8909 ooh, I don’t remember that - a rewatch is definitely on
If I remember correctly, Caleb didn’t actually fall in love with Miranda or left Hanna for her, she went missing and he just went looking for her, so I don’t think it was that bad as he was trying to save someone’s life ?
For me, the Spaleb thing is definitely the worst thing he did, like how can you date your first love’s best friend ?!! I don’t know what the writers did to Caleb but his character just annoyed me towards the end.
They ruined so many people, it’s so sad
Also I totally agree that male traumas definitely don’t get talked about enough! Like,Toby was assaulted multiple times by different people and Peter is forced to have children with his assaulter (though he should have kept his legs closed 😭)
I LOVE THIS IDEA. i would also love a gossip girl/glee version of this
Ian's relationship with the girls is the worst thing? He tried to straight up kill Spencer. I'm not sure, I'd say that's... worse?
ian’s overall character is the worst thing he’s done 😭 terrrrribllleeeee maaan…the underage stuff i mentioned is just the dust on top of the many layers of him honestly!!
i feel like you could've said WILDEN as a whole like you said just CECE speaks for herself hahaha but other than that, great video!!!!
The worst thing Spencer did was constantly dating other peoples bfs…
I forget about the fact that Malcom turned out to not be Ezra’s 😅 like they just wrote that kid out. Like thanks, plot point served, bye now
The worst thing Hanna did was definitely what she did to Lucas
Or how she would talk to her mother 🫤
What did she do to Lucas? I don’t remember
@@Shiann444 But yes! For real she was so disrespectful towards her mother sometimes
Lucas was literally part of the A Team. HE MASSAGED EMILY AS A. What did Hanna do to him? She was a friend to him
"All he had to do is keep the legs close, babe" I CAN'T 😭😭
LIKE SHUT THEM PLEASE
Are we forgetting that Melissa literally buried Bethany alive😂
for spencer its defff the caleb thing bc never date a friends ex perioddd
!!!!
nahh no way dating your friends high school boyfriend after she was already engaged to another man is worse than kidnapping and defacing someone’s grave. while its still not great, definitely not worse than
Not Haaland being your lockscreen babe 😂😂
HEHEH THATS MY BOY
love the consistency!!🤭😚
Ian also attempted to murder Spencer which is actually wild
Archer is the worse jennas whole crew is too
I hate what everyone did to Toby in this show, I honestly would have understood his motivation if he turned out to be A.
i think the worst thing ashley’s done was being sesually active with hanna around the house, specially with wilden. i know she did it to protect her daughter and although i love her, i think doing it with hanna there seeing and hearing it was f up. also hooking up with jason was weird as hell, he’s so much younger and she saw him grow up
I would agree HOWEVER 1) Ashley didn’t know that Hanna was up that late. 2) Wilden used his position as a police officer to blackmail and coerce Ashley. He essentially R worded her.
Worst thing Emily did was get in a relationship with Paige 🙄
i thought spencer became A after she found out he was ? she knew he was alive at that point . she was heartbroken
Well, you need to follow the timeline of when Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too.
A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response.
Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟.
That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her.
That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
Didn't Emily kill two people? She killed Lyndon James and she was the reason Noel Kahn died. (And before someone replies to this like "no she didn't kill Noel", let me just remind you that she punched him so hard that he fell on an axe and was beheaded. 💀)
Sure, it was self-defence both times but killing a man not once but twice is arguably worse than framing someone for murder. 😬
lyndon was actually pure self defence though? he shot caleb and was about to kill her too, as well as him being maya’s stalker and killer !
and the noel ones is also kinda the same…he bought the axe to kill them, she had no pure intention to go out of her way to kill him
The big wedding shouldn’t of been aria and Ezra it should have been Caleb and Hannah
did you take inspiration for this video from reddit? i’ve been seeing this trend going around!!
i saw it on tiktok first hand! but thanks for letting me know! i’ll check out reddit and see what others are saying !
it’s so great i loved it (and your takes) in youtube form!!!
Didn't Melissa put Aria in a box with Garetts dead body and then tried to throw the box out of a frickin train😅
This is such an interesting concept/video.
my thoughts to add on, sorry its a bit of an essay haha: even though Noel was a POS Hanna abducting him and hurting him is probably the worst thing shes ever done imo haha.
Emily I would say killing that guy- it was self-defence, but it is still murder, so i would class it as worse than almost planting evidence??
Toby didn't watch the girls, Ali made that up.
Moana is such a hard one for picking one worst thing like she was such a menace lmao we love her but she hit hannah with a car, killed multiple people and tortured the girls like how do we chose just one?!🤣🤣
Melissa also killed someone but to be fair I agree with your point as her killing bethany wasnt purposeful. i dont understand how she can say she buried her to protect spencer and then not protect spencer any other time like she literally bullies her and victim blames her and forces her abuser to live in her garden like pick a side!
Ashley ran Wilden over which could arguably be worse than stealing money? however he totally deserved it & survived... and she also paid (most of) the money back to the old dead lady so... she basically is not too bad compared to others
Caleb basically started seeing hanna to spy on her for Jenna which is super shady, or cheating on Spencer with hanna. considering everyone else does felonies he really isnt that bad ey!
Alison did not make up. Her suspicions about Toby.
You need to follow the timeline of when Alison made Toby take the blame. She didn’t know that, darling Jenna and Toby’s sex escapades were not consensual. Alison thought Toby was a member of the NAT club because he was being creepy lurking around at night, hiding in shadows. And bushes. Alison was full-blown being exploited by the NAT club. She was dealing with -A and a lot of shit. 💩 She was under a lot of stress, And here’s this sneaky guy who’s always being shady. And he’s sleeping with his sister obviously 🙄, the natural conclusion would be that he’s a depraved pervert too.
A lot of the worst things Alison have has done are a direct reflection of severe trauma response.
Alison never intended to hurt Jenna. Matter fact, she didn’t intend to hurt her at all. She threw a stink bomb 💣 at intended Target, 🎯 Toby, who she was convinced was peeping through her bedroom window 🪟.
That was literally what their argument was about when she blackmailed him about him peeing through her window 🪟. And spying on her.
That is not premeditated, malicious intent. That is a straight up accident. Plain and simple.
@@sarickacampbell2642 I think she did make it up; it is never confirmed that she actually saw him creeping, and they heavily imply it was a lie or heavily exaggerated within the show, plus she lied as much as she breathed air.
She didn’t know Jenna was SA’ing Toby until she went to do the stink bomb, hence her shocked expression when she looked inside, and her comments in the argument after. So take that out of your comment- still a “depraved pervert”, for simply being a loner? As she didn’t know who he was “sleeping with”
Their argument was him saying he wasn’t peeping and then her blackmailing him, using his trauma against him. How kind!
Ali not “intending” to blind Jenna isn’t all too relevant imo, it is still the worst thing she has ever done. i.e you don’t mean to kill someone, but you still did- you didn’t mean to blind them, but you did. the outcome is criminal regardless. She then didn’t even apologise she double and tripled down on it by threatening her multiple times. She may not have meant to but she didn’t show remorse either.
Theres also the theory that if it was following the books for this plot but gender flipped then it was somewhat intentional, but that is just a theory ofc.
But seriously, throwing a stink *bomb* in a closed room knowing someone is in there is malicious intent, what did she think would happen…
She was a horrible person before A and before she found out about the NAT club- they didn’t make her who she is she was just a mean person. Yes being groomed by multiple older me, exploited by NAT & bullied by A, would make it worse, but she had already done a lot of shady stuff anyway so it can’t all be blamed on them.
We can like a character without erasing the bad things they do or pinning blame for the bad things onto someone else. I love Alis character (pre time jump) but she is evil lol
@@jackie9090
A stink bomb is not a malicious intent. Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place. By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there.
And Jenna was not the target. 🎯 She clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby.
Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs. The night of the explosion, her fight with him was about him lurking around and spying on her.
And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars did even when Allison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her. Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer.
Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done.
He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime.
Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him.
But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️
Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risk her life to bring them home. 🏡
And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same.
Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative.
So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻
Alison suffers from being an enigma.
Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️
How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality?
(Ezria) is an example of that. Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was.
Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival.
Alison lived in poverty and squalor.
She could’ve left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could.
Her actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot.
She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t. She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
@@jackie9090 A stink bomb is not a malicious intent. Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place. By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there.
And Jenna was not the target. 🎯 Jenna was probably in the shed trying to sexually assault Toby again and karma did what it does.
Alison clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby. Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs.
The night of the explosion, Alison fight with him was about Toby was about him lurking around and spying on her. And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars and their parents thought that too. Based off of Toby‘s behavior alone, they all thought this even when Alison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her.
Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer. Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done.
He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime.
Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him. But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️
Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risked her life to bring them home. 🏡 And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same.
Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative. So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻 Alison suffers from being an enigma.
Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️
How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality? (Ezria) is an example of that.
Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was. Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival.
Alison lived in poverty and squalor. She could have left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could. Her actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot. She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t.
She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
@@jackie9090 A stink bomb is not a malicious intent.
Have you never used a stinkbomb before all it does is does is stink up the place.
By your logic all the boys at camp who threw stink bombs in each other’s rooms they should all be convicted as dangerous and psychotic. It’s a child’s prank toy. She didn’t know there was a gas ⛽️ leak that would’ve cause an explosion 💥 when she threw it in there. And Jenna was not the target. 🎯
Jenna was probably in the shed trying to sexually assault Toby again and karma did what it does. Alison clearly said the stink bomb was for Toby.
Alison has said multiple times that Toby is a creep and a perv. Heavily suggesting that she knows something about Toby suggesting that she thinks that he’s one of the NAT pervs. The night of the explosion, Alison fight with him was about Toby was about him lurking around and spying on her. And she’s not the only person guilty of accusing Toby of being a creep and a pervert all the liars and their parents thought that too. Based off of Toby‘s behavior alone, they all thought this even when Alison wasn’t around and Emily thought he wanted to murder her. Spencer was convinced that he was a murderer.
Toby is no saint, everything that he did when he was pretending to be a part of the -A team was worse than anything Alison has ever done. He intentionally faked his death. Alison didn’t. Her only crime was running away. 🏃♀️ being a teenage runaway isn’t a crime.
Toby Saw what he was doing to Spencer and he never even apologized for it. She just forgave him. But Toby gets putting on a pedestal as a valiant hero. 🦸🏻♂️
Alison has done nothing but shown remorse. She is the one who apologized to the liars for them framing her for murder. She’s the one who risked her life to bring them home. 🏡 And Spencer made it very clear that she wouldn’t have done the same.
Alison story is never told from her perspective or her point of view. It’s always told from somebody else’s. She never gets a narrate her own narrative. So her motivations are never explained which is just piss poor writing. ✍🏻
Alison suffers from being an enigma. Which means that she is a constant projection & perception Of everybody else’s perspective heightened, feelings, and emotions,Making Alison a projection of everyone’s insecurities and fears. Memories that can be changed due to circumstances. Recollections, can be faulty due to not having sufficient understanding or information.ℹ️ How many of our memories have changed since adulthood from childhood? and our perception of reality? (Ezria) is an example of that. Many people said that they shipped Ezra and Aria together. But now they realize how messed up it all was. Alison was not a horrible person. At least not intentionally or vindictively. She was a deeply traumatized hurt 😔 person who developed an addicted to control as a severe coping mechanism in her mind, she had to get control. She had to keep it , at all cost as a means to her survival. Alison lived in poverty and squalor. She could have left the country. She could’ve gone to Paris, but she stayed for the girls out of loyalty so she was always there to stay one step ahead of -A and protect them. The best she could.
Alison actions speak for itself she could have betrayed all the liars told about the fact that Aria killed Shauna Mike knew about the whole plot to frame her for murder. Told the police that Melissa is the one who buried Bethany. So technically is a one who killed her. Alison could have put her brother (Jason) away in prison for life because he started the NAT club She actively consciously walked away from the girls when Shauna was holding a gun to her so she would be the only one to get shot. She could’ve stayed holding onto Spencer or make Emily keep using her body to shield her, but she didn’t. She walked away from them. So she would be the only casualty.
Didnt Melissa bury Alison or Bethany alive????
i low-key forgot about that when i was putting this together 😭😭😭😭
And was the queen of hearts during the halloween train.
Lovely video with great points but audio grated me. A little tip keep your mic in one spot as you are beautifully animated however the mic is picking up the movement sound as it's so close to your mouth.
Didn’t Emily kill “Nate”
self defence your honour
Just started - saying than there isn’t a morally good character … are we forgetting about our man Wayne Fields? 🫡😔
the only valid man!
@@LucyDudgeon23pastor ted!!