Comparison - Spider-Man PS2 vs XBOX vs GC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 сер 2024
- Gamecube version captured through Wii console. All versions captured through original PAL Playstation, Xbox, Wii and PS2 consoles with component cables. More comparison videos can be found here: • Game comparisons
Theme music by Rekki: / rekki
The PS2 seems to have the worst frame rate of the three. Xbox seems to have the sharpest image, although all three are really close.
All are great versions. Xbox and GameCube benefit from a locked 60fps, while PS2 has an unlocked framerate which hangs around the 30s most of the time but suffers from lots of judder.
The Xbox/Gamecube version has a better Framerate than the PS2 Version. The rest seems to be fairly equal
Looks like reflections are better on game cube in the intro
XBox: best anti-aliasing. More windows with reflections outside. Darker and a bit blurry. Short loading.
GC: Brighter textures. Sharper graphics. Average loading.
PS2: slightly better light effects. Longest loading and worst aliasing.
On Xbox characters have better shadows. Ps2 and GC only got a circle shadow beneath the characters other than Spider-man. Xbox also have better textures in places. Just pointing out what I have noticed, when I played those. :)
Erkkade hey it's true
GC has no grass.
PS2 version have a 50% Xbox/GC framerate
You forgot the most important: PS2 runs at 30 fps, Gamecube and Xbox run at 60 fps.
remember that PS2 was very hard to program back then, so most (if not all) PS2 early games had a lot of problems and awful N64 plastic textures and unstable framerates, even with Dreamcast ports.
Xbox version is my favorite in my opinion, because it has Kraven level.
Same
This with Kraven's levels? Now I see why the Xbox version was considered the best.
I grew up with the Xbox version. I definitely like the Xbox version the best, mainly because of the Kraven levels.
I have also played the GameCube version via Dolphin. Never played the PS2 version.
Xbox was just ahead of its time
xbox was a pentium 3 computer had GPU that was in between a Geforce 3 Series and Geforce 4 Series
adidas1984x as well as the Dreamcast.
The xbox was released two years later than the PS2...
It was, literally.
So, let's see.
Ps2: Frame inconsistent
Xbox: Crisp, bright, and has extra Kraven stage
Gamecube: Well-lit
PC (Yes, there was a pc port of this that is the console version unlike whatever spider-man 2 did): Awful Controls, but good-looking
The definitive winner is Xbox cause of the extra kraven stage.
PS2 1. PS2 has the best controls 2. nice lighting effects XBOX 1. XBOX kept it in the middle of the lighting 2. shorter loading times 3. has a bonus level were you fight Kraven Nintendo gamecube 1. The Nintendo gamecube version was the popular version PS2 has 2 points XBOX has 3 points and Nintendo gamecube has 1 point the winner is the XBOX version.
Xbox was the most powerful console of those three, so it's improved visuals make sense.
That being said they all look pretty good for an early game in the 6th generation
Is PC version same as ps2 or XBOX?
@@yeswanth_mocharla the PC version is an entirely different game
@@TenWolf-wb7pc i thought thats the only case for spider-man 2?? Spider-man 1 is same as well??
@@yeswanth_mocharla Spider-Man 1 in PC is the same version of PS2, Xbox and Gamecube.
@@yeswanth_mocharla Not 100%, but it might be the Xbox version without the Kraven levels.
To anyone wondering why is the ps2 version so "choppy" it's because it's the PAL version of the game, which runs at 50hz and 25fps instead of 60hz and 30fps on NTSC.
Kind of odd but interesting how in one scene, the Xbox has the best textures, in another, the Gamcube has the best textures, and another, the PS2 has the best textures. Interesting how they chose to optimize specific objects. They're largely equal though.
Gamecube is the victor here.
Xbox wins. It has exclusive Kraven levels.
This game is literally just Neversoft's Spider-Man with the movie style skinned over it..
So? 🙄 It's not like it's a bad thing
@@ClassicGamer9044 It's pretty bad, seeing as Neversoft's Spider-Man games were good, but old and Activision decided to be lazy, here. I hate laziness. They couldn't be bothered to make a fully new game until Spider-Man 2, which they were about to re-use Neversofts blueprints yet again..
@@liger4414 I wouldn't call it lazy more like inspiration seeing as how both spiderman games on PS1 were well received
Edit: although Activision did reuse a lot of assets exclusively for the PSP version 😅
@@ClassicGamer9044 So, that's my point. Activision couldn't be bothered to do something new except the graphics, they reuse assets and gameplay a lot back then. Which was my gripe for this game. I wanted a brand new Spider-Man THE MOVIE game, not an updating looking Spider-Man PS1 game lol.
@@liger4414 I think you are exaggerating on how similar they are.
I only like the GameCube one because I love the controls
4:42 "One world" poster in building, 4:48 CHAOS writing in the clouds.
the PS2 was known to have the weakest hardware of the 3 consoles, so it had a 10 second load screen and slow performance while the Gamecube had better hardware with a 5 second load screen, though the Xbox was impressive with some advanced hardware that could render 1080i resolution out of the box, so it was impressive at the time
Rageant Cyborg correct
Rageant Cyborg did every original xbox game support 1080i of was it only a select few?
@@sunfade Only about 50 games, but most of them have true 640x480.
This game and spider man 2 were the first games my mom bought for me and my brother on Xbox. I wish they could remaster them.
Childhood, where are you?
I'd say the Gamecube and Xbox are superior as they manage to retain a solid 60 fps, in comparison the PS2 looks lower, and less fluid as a result.
PS2 Needs Help. The Frame Rate is Chunky.
1:15 oh shi
Xbox has to be the best one here simply because of the fact that every enemies have dynamic shadows, whereas on GC and Ps2, only Spiderman has dynamic shadows while everyone else has a circle below them- which looks inconsistent.
The PC port also looks inferior, even spiderman himself doesn't have dynamic shadow on the pc port.
The Xbox always winss!!
Xbox looks the best
It looks the fucking same
@@mrbinbin7 Watch your language
@@mrbinbin7 It takes one good look at the enemies to see why you’re wrong. All characters have dynamic shadows instead of just Spider Man
I like gamecube better because it's so classic
Which version is more similar to pc?
none only diffrejt between ps2 xbox gamecube is xbox has some extra level PC is very different
forgot everything I said I got confused between Spider Man 2 game
I grew up with the PS2 version but XBOX does look the best, and has the fastest loading and I recently found out that it has a Kraven the Hunter mission
I have both the PS2 and Xbox versions while I did grew up with the PS2 version I’d say the Xbox is the overall better version.
Xbox like that’s all it takes and it has Kraven levels. GameCube welcome to
I have the GC version of this game, but sadly the disc doesn't work anymore. i still keep it for memories sake.
TurtleKjellberg lol
You can get a second used copy on Amazon for cheap
Just buy the Disc Only on eBay
Xbox
Gamecube
PS2
Xbox has a new level. That alone makes it better.
xbox verison runs higher res than ps2 and game cube
xbox ! smooooooooth fps
Are any of these running at 60fps?
TheSalamanderMenace4 sometimes in ps2 version dunno about GameCube and Xbox versions
It's hard to say. Should have some kind of equipment to see the exact frame rates. But these are PAL versions, so the refresh rate is 50hz, but there was an option for 60hz if I could remember which one.
I played it recently on GameCube and it seemed to target 60, but I don't think it held it that well.
The Xbox version in NTSC runs at 480p 60fps, the GameCube tends to target 60 fps but its unstable, and the PS2 version is just awful with terrible frame-rate and lower 512x448i graphics.
Yes and PS2 is awful
Which version has the best load times? Does anyone know?
ua-cam.com/video/vu95lzpyutE/v-deo.htmlm45s
@@Erkkade wow i never noticed how slow the load times were in the ps2 version lol XD
Xbox
I think the worst version is the version of the ps2, because it has more jaggies than the other versions, and has some parts with lower textures, the part of the video that appears a billboard with the car 4:59, the car and writing is very blurred in the ps2, the wall behind in 3:44 too .
Sorry for my english
Which is surprising because, often, the Gamecube version of games ends up having worse textures, presumably because of disk space.
MetroidJunkie that's what I was thinking too, in this case the game cube had better textures than the PS2, even with less disk space.
TheFred128 PS2 runs in 30fps
Lack of PC version. I think that is the worst but is not included.
Probs cuz Xbox is more powerful but the fmvs are the same to be honest Ps2 has awful framerate GameCube idk what is wrong with that version
Winner is the Xbox formatting
back off UGLI
Game Cube Win
No Kraven so Xbox is easily better
Spider-Man Xbox much better version of graphics
Finally :D
or this
What?, oh i mean the Video, before i was asking if there would be a Comparison of the Spider-Man 2002 Video Game of what it would look like with the other Game Console Versions.
Johnathon Barker yeah i have both Spider-Man 1 Game On Xbox & PS2. and you the GameCube?
@@gduarte124 Yeah.
Xbox always better
cara essa imagem do game cube esta péssima, mais ai no seu video, pois na real é muito superior a isso!
Ps2 is the best because of there controllers
Forever Alone Guy the Xbox version has better controls and a better port overall.
@@retroboy-fh1ji Not to mention the exclusive Kraven levels
PS2 garbage and no Kraven
xbox win
Xbox beat ps2 then Xbox 360 beat ps3 but then PS4 kicked the Xbox ones ass. How.....?
Andy But now Xbox One X kicked PS4 Pro ass. :)
The PS2 beat Xbox. This was just a better game on Xbox then on PS2.
Every time I watch a comparison ps2 always the worst but it outselled all the consoles
Spider-Man on the PS2: the graphics aren't that great and the PS2 version sucks I was gonna get the PS2 version but it sucks
Spider-Man on the Xbox: it's alot better the Xbox version has an Extra stage (Kraven) so on the Xbox it's alot better
Spider-Man on the GameCube: I owned it since July 2005 played it and I hate the GameCube version
the Winner is Xbox because Spider-Man 1 2 and 3 is better on the Xbox the graphics aren't that great on the PS2 versions on the Xbox it's alot better I'm gonna pick up Spider-Man 1 and 2 for the Xbox
zpushy633 Sora ok
Right
Please calm down because this is making me really fucking furious
@@anapario Get over yourself. OG Xbox is superior
Playstation 2 fucking horrible console of all time, as well as the Playstation 3
PFFT. PS2 and PS3 are not horrible. Your being ignorant. PS3 has Blu-ray, free online, better exclusives, and less failure rates. I like both PS2, Xbox, and Gamecube as well as the PS3 and Xbox 360. PERIOD!
I own both PS3 and 360. I play the PS3 more.
Wow it's been a long time since I seen such a Xbone fanboy. Like seriously dude this is fucking pathetic.
BTW only the first XBOX which was released YEARS later PS2 was better.
PS3 and PS4 are not only much stronger than their rival but they are also give you MUCH BETTER exclusives.
PS3 also gave you blu ray and 3D while shitbox 360 has given you a disc option that was dead at arrive and was the main reason why they had to dumb down the games for PS3 and PC.
Same thing with Xbone one. It is by far the weakest console this generation (Nintendo is amazing so it doesn't count) and is AGAIN the reason that they have to dumb down the games so it can play on shitbox too.
There is a GOOD reason why PS exclusives look far better.
But hey heads up! You will have the opportunity to play 4K games like PC users did for YEARS in November by paying FAR MORE than you need to get the same experience from Windows 10.
It's a great time to MS fanboy right?
LMAO I love Xbone fanboys. I especially love how they say that it's SONY who holds back the market when it's actually the original shitbox one which does. Really you guys are the funniest and most ignorant bunch.
андреич бармалеич The PS2 is the best selling console of all time. Games like GT4 and Black have graphics that almost look like ps4 games. Be incorrect somewhere else.
Xbox wins