Boris Johnson v Ian Blackford on the Scottish Referendum | House of Commons
Вставка
- Опубліковано 16 лис 2024
- Boris Johnson and the West Minister leader of the Scottish National Party Ian Blackford clashed over the Scottish Referendum.
Yesterday Boris Johnson formally refused to give Holyrood and Nicola Sturgeon the power to hold a second Scottish independence referendum. Ian Blackford called Boris Johnson a "democracy denier" and sais he had 'utter contempt for Scottish democracy and the Scottish Parliament'.
#BorisJohnson #ScottishIndependence #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs. We let you join the conversation and hold politicians to account.
Subscribe for more: l-bc.co/subscribe
Watch More Here:
The Latest Brexit Videos: l-bc.co/Brexit...
The Best Of The Nigel Farage Show: l-bc.co/Nigel
The Best Of James O’Brien: l-bc.co/JamesO...
The Best Of Iain Dale: l-bc.co/IainDale
The Latest Donald Trump Videos: l-bc.co/Donald...
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/newsle...
Like, follow and subscribe to LBC!
Website: lbc.co.uk
Facebook: lbc
Twitter: / lbc
Instagram: / lbc
I was born in Glasgow and have lived here all my life, Boris is 100% correct, the SNP need to move on and start dealing with the important issues here in scotland, well said Boris.
Billy Westbury stronger together 🏴🇬🇧🏴🏴
It was once in a lifetime like Brexit!
Too right Billy! My dear Glesga has far more urgent issues than SNPs vanity project 🇬🇧 🏴 🏴 🏴
Scotland has the right to choose a new path for their ppl .and as a democratic sovereign nation within a democratic union to refuse the ppl the choice is 100% undemocratic not to mention the fact that Westmiister sounds like a dictatorship also on what part of the Edinburgh Agreement does it state that it isa once in a lifetime event ? nowhere because Scotlsnd is just as sovereign as England and the ppl cannot be held in this toxic union against the will of the the ppl . so we ill choose again
The SNP ran alot of short term policies to gain popularity. They need independence before the country goes broke.
Thing about the SNP is that they're so focused on independence that if Scotland voted again and voted to remain, they wouldn't accept that either. They'll say and do anything to get independence, that undermines any points they make.
Brexit will sort everything out.
Nae worries.
Clout.
If they voted to remain the debate would be over. Problem is England has changed the game with Brexit.
But also you don’t know that.
Garry, so you're saying that if we'd voted to remain Nicola Sturgeon would have chucked in the towel and ended her campaign for Scottish independence? Have you not heard that lady speak...? Lol. They'd come up with any reason why the referendum was not binding and decisive.
(Until, that is, they got their way. Then it would be a legitimate referendum that can not be challenged)
I wish we had this sort of "back and forth" here in the US. Can you imagine President Trump and speaker Pelosi exchanging barbs?
That would be amazing.
You could always revoke the Declaration of Independence and join in our parliamentary system! lol
Certainly not,how Un English, you are not allowed to speak against the master race,very European plebbish,how very Democratic.
@Free Speech So Scotland should stay
@Free Speech parr of the E.U. and voted that way 2 months ago as well
The SNP are needing to give it a rest we VOTED to stay together get over it
As a guarantee that we would remain in the EU. That has not happened.
@Fruity Ronster Literally no one mentioned the EU in the whole independence campaign.
And even if someone did, it was nowhere near one of the key arguments why people voted to stay.
@@FruityRonster At no point was the Scottish Referendum billed as a Constitutional guarantee to remain in the EU!
@@FruityRonster There was no guarantee. You know it, I know it, so let's drop the childish game of trying to rewrite recent memory, shall we?
@@phillycheesetake no guarantee of what? This was a big part of the campaign. There is a material difference now in the arrangement and Scotland wants to stay in the EU.
He's like a broken record
Correct..... yada yada… he keeps on every time with the same clap trap..
Doesn't change the fact that Scotland wants out of the so "democratic" UK.
@@liolio000 rule Britannia 🇬🇧 🇮🇱
What, you are not tired of ' Get Brexit done', yet? Was Boris hypnotized to repeat that phrase over and over again? Are the English such halfwits that they can't grasp the meaning of sentences longer than three words?
@@liolio000 no but we do rule the UK
i blame the speaker for allowing him to repeat the same old rhetoric and every opportunity we are sick of it and should not let him speak unless he has something to talk about
Better then the last
I'd rather he brought up Scotland at every chance he gets instead of having some unionist clown in there scared to mention the word Scotland.
Better than not allowing people to voice their views. Would rather here a few idiots every now and again than not at all
@@carpathianhermit7228 i agree but it wastes parliamentary time that could be used for other issues .it is the wee nasty's instructions to make parliament sick of listening to him so the government will cave in ,the speakers need to step in and limit his parroting of the same phrase
@@rgsnr8702 indeed its the same talking points everytime. Politics is a punch and judy show
As an American this political theatre is fascinating. I love all the unique quirks. Like how people voice there approval and disaproval loudly while the person is speaking haha. Fascinating
I’m Scottish and I can’t stand the SNP . Well said Boris “ Change the Record “ 👍
Interesting reflection though isn't it David, the political class are so bad the Scottish would rather vote for the SNP. Do we dare to hope Boris is the real deal, believes in Britain and our people?
Majority of scots disagree with you.
Imagine getting a £1 for every time he says the " the people of Scotland". Quite rich I think. His wife must be glad he is in London and not at home. Is it any wonder you hear groans from parliament when he stands up to talk. Wee fud. 😂😂😂😂😂😂
I'm Scottish and I can't stand the tories. Well said Nicola ''Scotland has the right to self-determination''👍
@@hughclarkson4218 don't you see? the contempt our mps are treated with is exactly WHY we want independence. when you aren't taken seriously and are ignored by your partner in a 'union of equals' this is what happens.
You dont speak for the whole of scotland ya muppet
Peugeot David The King So why don’t you lobby for a Scottish voice of reason to speak for you in parliament? We’re all fed up listening to this oaf of a stuck record!
@Peugeot David The King Scotland needs another party..then there's only two choices, the new democratic party or the anti democratic snp party lol the liberal Democrats if you can call them that gained seats Purely because of a split vote, they literally represent the minority in such areas..Most votes were for brexit split between brexit party and tories.
Snp are killing Scotland
That's why there's the need for another referendum!
Correct sir, they only speak for 48 of 59 seats oh wait seems like a huge majority of seats keep electing the SNP. You either live in Dumfries or Aberdeenshire
John Maclagan
The snp policy of dumbing down education is starting to pay dividends.
Even though I side with Boris mainly on this... I still think the democratic thing is to hold a vote. It is never undemocratic to hold a vote. There are definitely enough people in favour of a referendum to constitute a mandate for a vote, so it should be held. Simple as that.
SNP are making Scotland such a laughing stock.
unitedwestand landslide meaning only got 45% of the vote, the exact same percentage as the indy referendum?
@@tothemax9696 the tories only got 43% of the vote so if they have a mandate for brexit then we have one for independence
What about the people in Scotland who don’t want "independence" because they feel they feel they already have it?
I am a proud to be Scottish, but Ian Blackford is just embarrassing, gonna stand up and actually put forward something other than independence, we had our chance we said NO, move on.
Exactly 👍
^
|
|
This dude is a genius
Mark Schofield people voted no to remain in the eu that was one of the major parts the tories pushed and now they want to leave sounds a bit hypocritical isn’t it?
u had ur chance and u chose to stay. U opted into being a democracy. Shut up and get on with it. I can’t stand these Scottish mps... it faces such a bad reflection of Scotland as a whole.
@A Mc They represent more than the tories do. Only 43% voted tory.
It is OK. They voted to leave. Leave. Revote to go back. That simple no one would vote to go back.
What are we talking about again?
I hate these fascist Tories. They're anti democratic, sociopathic liars and show England in a bad light. Surely the English aren't dumb enough to vote for BoJo the clown? You didn't just vote for them you handed them the keys to the kingdom. No wonder Britain's finished.
I agree and I am Scottish!
Agree and I am Scottish.
Whether you agree on Scottish independence or not, his point about the NHS being sold off to the US is very alive and true. This is a mess and we need to fix our NHS not privatise or sell it off!
Whenever I hear his ranting voice I always think of Private Fraser in Dads Army.."we're dooomed I tell ye..doooomed!
He is a buffoon, no question, and I'm a Scot, and NS is no better, I call her " A Smurf"
Johnson has a much louder and hectoring voice than Blackford. Johnson is a typical English, mocking the Scots and talking down his nose to them.
Well, believe it or not, sunshine, you very probably are. Brexit, so called, will destroy what will be left of the UK after Scotland ends the United Kingdom and Ireland reunites and removes N.I. from the Kingdom of England. You really have no concept of what Brexit is going to do.
I've been attempting to engage in reasoned and informed debate throughout this entire Brexit fiasco. I have yet to come across even one who could put up a proper reasoned argument for Brexit and some of them were actual government ministers, although catching one as they flew in and out the Westminster revolving doors was not an easy thing to do.
Now just why do you imagine there was such a turnover of cabinet ministers going on throughout this whole fiasco? If these people were genned up on the matter and knew their jobs why were they lucky to last more than 20 minutes in the post?
They, and any other so called, "Brexiteers", didn't last five minutes without making some outrageous errors of facts. The things they claimed were utter hogwash.
If no one can get the facts right why are you so sure you can?
I'll tell you this, no SNP MP will get up in Parliament ant tell lies or not be properly briefed on the matters they are debating..
@Auld Bob. As most can see by my comment,I don't take life too seriously. Your comment sounds genuine and passionate and you could well be proven right..who knows? I voted to leave the EU and trust Boris to 'get it done' Kind Regards
@@TheAuldBob Not so sure. Many SNP MPs are ex Labour, and careerists. They see the SNP as a place to further their promotions. If Labour gets back, they will ditch the SNP. I like the SNP ideals, but don't trust their people, other than Nicola, who is genuine.
Labour people are staunch and true, as they stick by the poor they represent through thick and thin.
I agree with you about "Brexiteers". They just hate Germans.
When will the SNP get on with running Scotland. If these MP’s could direct their hot air to improving the lives of their people they would be better employed.
They are doing just that. The biggest issue at the moment is that the blond, foaming around the mouth clown has doomed any possibility of negotiating a trade deal with the EU and hard Brexit is inevitable. That means economic suicide for UK. Why would the Scots suffer from the stupidity of the 60 million English oppressor?
wefwq efwea they clearly aren’t doing a great job. Scotland has the worst performing hospitals and schools in the UK, despite them being far better funded than in any other country
He just drones on and on, if he can't ask about anything other than another vote, its time for the speaker to stop calling him.
How democratic of you...
I think this is from PMQs. As the 3rd largest party the SNP have a guaranteed number of questions so the speaker must call on them.
So hold on, this happened after boris Johnson declined a second referendum, are you telling me he's not allowed to ask?!
@@guleiro Democracy isn't asking people time and time again the same question until you got the answer you expect.
@@damienmouly3318
Scotland voted to remain in the British union because it was assured the UK would stay in the EU.
Brexit has changed that and now Scotland will be independent an nation...
It's only a matter of time.
That facepalm by BJ on the thumbnail is 😂👍
I’m unsure how I’d vote in indyref2, but I’m uncomfortable with Boris denying Scotland’s right to choose given the clear change that has happened in recent years
There’s only one choice for Scotland to flourish at this point
Give it up for God's sake. Start working for the United Kingdom, not just for the Scotish Kingdom !
@pammens miss Make the UK a proud nation again, a world leader. Whatever you believe in, believe in your nation and country within the nation !
@@jakkyte5733 You mean England when saying 'uk'
@@ScottishRoss27 no I mean UK. I live in Stourbridge, The Black Country, West Midlands, England, United Kingdom. Not just England. All Unite !
Why would Scotland has to suffer the consequences of misinformed, 60 million, English stupidity?
@@jakkyte5733 West Midlands economic region of England total GDP is £62.6 billion , 2.9 millon population
East Midlands economic region of England total GDP is £116,8 billion, 4.8 million population
English Midlands Combined Population 7.7 million
English Midlands Combined GDP One Hundred Seventy-Nine Billion Four Hundred Million
. 9.3% of the UK total.
Scottish national gdp £180 billion 9.4% of the UK total , population 5,4 million,
Scotland's far superior Exports per head versus the rUK (£17,455 per year for Scotland versus a staggeringly poor £8,626 per head for the rest of the UK) demonstrates that Scotland is an Exporting nation whilst the rest of the UK is an Importing nation.
The UK current account deficit narrowed by £7.9 billion to £25.2 billion or 4.6% of gross domestic product (GDP).
Total Scottish Exports £81.4 billion.
The UK current account deficit will rise to around £56.2 billion
Does insanity run in the Blackford family.
Apparently yes.
Yep, like a recessive gene.
It doesn't run in the family.....It gallops!!
it doesnt run at all he,d trip over his gut
he is not insane, the guys more than a millionaire ffs he knows what he is doing !!
I love the way Ian Blackford comes up with new, unusual, and important subjects to talk about every time he rises to make a point in the House of Commons.
This is your British humour coming out.
Every timeblackfords on t.v. I press the mute button on my remote control so that I don't have to listen to that balloon. He's full of hot air.
I’m from Scotland and this is all that we hear from these guys, the amount of times I’ve heard “we’re being dragged out against our will” is unbelievable. Don’t agree with the tories either and Scotland needs to be listened to more but there are ways to do that as a stronger union
We've suffered 300yrs of strutting swaggering sneering snarling bullying dictatorial extractive exploitative domineering jeering english Tory colonial contempt !
And you want to make that ":stronger ". ? ?
Boris's CHANGE THE RECORD was the most epic mic drop moment I've seen in the commons
How is the Scottish NHS these days, still meeting all the targets they set 🤔
@CM is that why your life span is less and drug addiction levels are higher than any UK major city?
Much better than England’s NHS.
@alan bane you seem mercifully free from the ravages of intelligence!
The Barnett formula means that Scotland can afford to spend more on the NHS than England does
- thank you English tax payers!
;)
@CM well said!!!
Ian Blackford makes me laugh. We need more comedians.
We have abbot comedy gold.
@@makeitsonumberone1358 How could I forget :-)
He looks like a proper clown!! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
boris is a comedian and a lieing one at that .
Kim Bird loooool 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
Trump? Honestly, he has nothing to do with this discussion.
Of course he has...
The UK will become a US vassal after Brexit.
You are niave if you really believe that or you don't have a clue what is going on in American politics atm.
guleiro It won’t, don’t be a fool. Trump literally has a british nationality in him.
@@JohnSmith-oe5rx That 'America First' British Nationality.
@@OrphanAnnie10 ok explain how then?
As much as I couldn't stand Angus Robertson, what I have to say is: 'Come back, Angus, all is forgiven'!
At least Robertson showed a smattering of intelligence.
Daniele Iannarelli Blackford is less sanctimonious than Robertson, but he’s also less intelligent - and definitely more cynical. It’s a close call!
a smattering more than you then, my dear.
Let them go ........ but I bet they still want to use the NHS and all the benefits
Can we English have a referendum on letting the Scots stay in the ‘’ United Kingdom’’
That's what the SNP want
;)
Do it. We would love that.
You only see the likes of Nicola Sturgeon, Ian Blackford and co talk on our behalf and because of that I understand why you’re saying what you’re saying. However, not all of us are on board with the SNP. I’m very worried what would happen if Scotland became independent. Scotland will always be stronger together with the United Kingdom.
@@jackjohnston8350 Scotland will always be the underdog in the UK too. Having our economy decided for us down at Westminster. Stronger militarily, that's about it and it's not WW2 anymore.
Well, you already proved your stupidity and ignorance once, what is one more time?
Is this all this guy talks about every time at PMQs? Don’t they have other things to do for the Scottish people.
It’s pathetic.
That's the biggest issue at the moment. After all the pretenses of being a democratic union, UK acts as a dictatorship from the Third World. Scotland showed more than once that it wants to be part of the biggest and richest, free trade union in the world but Scots are denied that because they are just 10 times smaller in population than the arrogant, ignorant English oppressors.
wefwq efwea interesting😂
He's like Stan Boardman and his use of the word "Germans"....
@@liolio000 Eu is nothing more than like 4 countries carrying the rest on their back.
@@liolio000 how are we oppressors please explain apart from you wanting Independence Explain it to me because I don't get it?
As a scot I'm truly embarrassed we have people like Blackford representing us
"OnCe iN a LiFeTiMe". Maybe the SNP consider 6 years a lifetime? 👀🤣
on a diet of irn bru and deep fried haggis, 6 years is an average lifespan, so yes :p
@@judyhopps9380 I'm Scottish but that is funny 😂😂😂
6 years just seems like a lifetime having to put up with this bull on a daily basis
@@Darth-Shaneious And I'm English but I love our Northern cousins *hug* please never leave us. We'd be lost without you
@@judyhopps9380 Agreed, I think we would both be lesser countries without each other
I'm English but I would encourage anyone who wants a better future for scotland to vote yes when this referendum happens.
Explain why
@unitedwestand well i think he does and yes i do know what democracy is its from the ancient greek word demos whitch meant a city such as athens run by its citizens
Ian blackford needs to lay off the pies.
If Scottish Independence is pie in the sky should he lay of that pie too?
And battered Mars bars!
Patrick Walsh LOL
If he doesn’t we won’t have to put up with his BS much longer 😏
And irn bru
When Cyril Smith died, Blackford bought all his old suits.
Comedy gold. 😁😁😁
Oof
fodsaks
And had them let out.
BLACKFORD is a wind bag Scotland has the Highest DEFICIT in EUROPE,THE WORST DRUG PROBLEM in EUROPE and GROWING
I hope has has not adopted Cyril Smiths perversions too.
voted no in 2014! do i think we should have Independence, i'm not sure i'm on the fence, but we have the right to make that choice after the lies we were told in 2014.
ThePrenti......its not independence if snp then joins the eu and hands all the oil wealth over to stay in that big club..............Scotland can NOT afford to be an independent country
@@geoffdundee if we cant afford it then why do you want us to stay so badly? surely if we are so poor and funded by you, you would be leading the charge for independence
Scotland should leave the UK
I'm from Scotland and don't want independence. The SNP can't take a loss.
He reminds of that remoaner who was paid to protest for the eu outside Parliament
Well imagine that. Ian is indeed paid. The same rate as all the other MPs in Westminster except for the PM and the cabinet. The thing is Mr Blackford has been telling you all the truth now for a considerable time. Not our problem if you don't believe him but don't say you have not been warned.
@@TheAuldBob not according to the reffferndum result
@unitedwestand yes but refferndums are once in a lifetime so Blackford should sit down and shut up
Is the main Tory strategy for Brexit to repeat 'Get Brexit done' until a 'great' trade deal with US appears from thin air?
Ian Blackford is becoming a laughing stock with his incessant nonsense
;)
Becoming a facist state down there.
He doesn't really have anything of importance to say. Completely lacking in his representation of the people in Scotland that voted for SNP.
@@bigballetlover Scotland makes up 9.4% of the total UK gdp. population of 5.4million
Yorkshire makes up 6.5% of the total, pop 5.4million
South West England makes up 7% of the total, pop 5.5million
Midlands combined makes up 9.3% of the total , pop 7.7million
Scottish gdp/economy is now same size as Portugals (we have half the population)
@@ScottishRoss27. Cool story Bro.
@@jimmyyorkshire4495 What you colonist?
Scotland will choose its own future. With or without England blessing.
MC -
"without England blessing............"
Scotland would have been NOTHIN ! As Dr Johnson said (in effect)..............................
i. rob
Americans first.
@@marvinc999 I would rather have been a nothing , than a murdering rich c t . Johnson the degenerate ,some of his ancestors came from the sacred land. So he wasn't totally puggled,
@i. rob gle mhath,smashing, Sassenach
Lol put a wall and let scotland be México huehuehuehue
Discontent was the voice of the people who were treated bad
Which people were they?
"Once in a generation vote" - Nicola Sturgeon.
@@michaelthomasshields The once in a generation was entirely his personal opinion/stance, as said in the interview. According to the edinburgh agreement, both sides would honour the referendum with no mention of a minimum time between it and a next one (which they could have agreed upon to make it a bit more watertight). So they are completely in their right to keep asking for a referendum if they wish so.
My wife is Scottish so hopefully they have another referendum and vote to leave cause to be honest after 25yrs of marriage shes got alot of hard miles behind her and also I'd like a change ... this way no one gets hurt
Well said Boris,,, I myself a Scotsman and a very proud one.
But first we are British secondly Scottish and myself thirdly Glaswegian...
Someone should sort this SNP mug out
2021 is election AFAIK.
AFAIK, well your point is what.
@@francisburke2136 you want to sort SNP out, 2021 is your chance.
unless there is a mechanism to trigger scottish elections earlier
rivenoak we’ll said,,,I just hope that the correct decision will be made and we don’t allow false pride to dictate or future...
I wish you well
You had your referendum in 2014 and the answer was no. The United Kingdom voted to leave the EU, a United Kingdom which Scotland is a hugely important part of.
FreedomIsSlavery Democracy 🤔
Well, Boris is drawing another picture... that Scotland is a failed state and a financial burden to the UK economy. But he keeps denying them the referendum they want. On all of the consequent elections Scotland showed that wants to remain part of the EU. English prevailed in 2016 because they are just 10 times more. That don't give them any right to deny the totally democratic right of Scots to express their will.
Right to change there mind because it was before Brexit.
NaniGaming you really think this was because of Brexit. The SNP started calling for a referendum after the 2015 election.
@@gogledhol indy ref 1 was 2014 , eu referendum was in 2016 , you do the maths
@@franksmith900 When they won another huge majority . Try and keep up.
Jonathan McAllister not what I’m saying. My point is that no matter what happens, the SNP will continue to shout for another referendum until they get their independence. Hence 2015, when they started asking for another referendum less than a year after the 2014 referendum
Let them go and let's get on with our country.
Ian Blackford needs to move on!!!
I can't see is face ! 😂
Let them have independence, it'll be like Greece but without the sun.
Lord Bezzington exactly Scots wake up!!
Blackford doesn’t have a second gear.....just like wee krankie. (Over revving all the time.)
Personal insults, don't you have anything original Britnat ?
I bet you would licked Boris Johnson's shoes and screamed if he had a trickle for you.
They should change the party name to the Scottish European party
They can change it to whatever they want after they get rid of the 60 million English ballast that is dragging Scotland in debt.
wefwq efwea i dont think you fully grasp what happens if Scotland leave the UK.
Would be devastated to see Scotland leave the UK. Love the sense of
humour and have alot of family up there! 🏴 🇬🇧 🏴 FAITH in UK!
So sad, seeing people beguiled by wee krankie🇬🇧
unitedwestand
Chip on your shoulder?
The vote in the Scottish Parliament was 68 to 54.
It's not in the power of Sturgeon or the SNP to make the Indyref2 request.
I'm from America...what's the deal with them saying Trump wants the NHS? Not our business.....
@unitedwestand American big pharma is the Anti-Christ................
Billy MacBunter abandons the tuckshop to make a fool of himself at PMQ's.
Well, he's maybe a fat BAWBAG, but he is still the prime minister 🤣
Well said borris
I really wish the snp would change the record.
Victim mentalility, poor Scotland
Problem with the SNP is all thier concern is on independence. Not the failing public services! What happens when their have the gold ticket.? What then
We voted NO! leave it at that!
Apparently you didn't give the correct answer at the time.
most Scots voted to leave the UK, most English living in Scotland voted to stay in the UK, swinging it back to no. Maybe that's why the English banned the EU nationals living in the UK from having the vote; as they saw
The result of the foreign demographic on the vote. A bit of a poll tax moment in Tory social experimenting. Maybe next time we shouldn't let you lot take part, just like you did during the Brexit vote, never to late to play you're games.
Great and strong response from Boris at the end
It’s lovely to see Bozza give Blackford a bollocking.
Everybody is wrong other than BOzza and the boys,43% canny even convince his own family of English separatism .
.
I want democracy! (unless I lose)
Notice how Boris doesn't actually answer the questions or deny the suggestion the NHS is on the table?
You had your vote. Deal with it!!!
About time someone dealt with the SNP.
Mate I am Scottish but I am glad that boris is telling the snp to shut up and deal with it
@@kieranrattray8111 I'm Scottish as well btw
@@archierch0463 SNP won 'more' seats from Scottish torys last GE , Its SNP dealing with your branch managers on instruction from voting Scots
FFS enough already
We had a referendum on Scotland we are stronger together. SNP broken record
That's old news. Now 60 million of English idiots are trying to impose their stupidity on Scotland simply because they are 10 times more. They also have the audacity to claim that UK is a democratic union, when it's clear that the dictatorship in Westminster won't allow the Scots to express their will.
wefwq efwea I guess you don’t like democracy. We had the vote we stay together.
The goal posts have moved mate, i voted NO in 2014 because Better Together told me vote no is the only way to stay in the EU - now look England decides it dusnae like foreigners so were leaving the EU (although still members of the customs union)
Snp have no right to call anyone undemocratic
What a plonker.
Who Johnson?.....I agree!
Thought this was Prime Ministers questions not SNP speech time.
Because they're the 3rd largest party in the Disunited Kingdom, they get to ask Bawbag Johnson a few questions
Best to refrain from thinking.
So it’s ok for England to break a union but Scotland can’t?
If Scotland leaves, then the whole UK will fall apart ;)
U need to understand how a democracy works, if the majority voted to leave then minority can't say "NO WE DON'T LIKE THAT! WE'RE NOT DOING IT!"
SNP makes me sick!
Really braveheart esq.
Not 100% on this but if Scotland did become independent wouldn't they lose access to all of the United Kingdom's national services like the NHS and welfare and any other national service.
The nhs in Scotland is devolved so no but everything else would be up for negotiations like the uk debt share oil Fields and such. We could always just go for no deal and have no debt and take 60% of the seas which are Scottish and all uk assets in Scotland
They keep referring to the people of Scotland - I live in Scotland and have never seen or talked to any of these baloons. If they had done their day job and proved that they are worthy of the responsibility things may be different?
Go Boris. Ur 100% right
SNP the bed
Geeze peace blackford
why why why when we voted to stay together is this allowed to happen we voted once in a lifetime vote and because you didn't get what yous wanted we need to vote again. if we had voted yes do you think we would be aloud to vote again no! makes me embarrassed to be Scottish
Does the SNP want to remain in the E.U but leave the rest of the U.K?
Because that makes sense (sarcasm)
Bojo has made the eu look more democratic. as they didnt prevent Englands choice on their referendum. Plus the eu is less centralised than the ''uk''
It makes perfect sense. EU will never deny referendums to any of it's members. All countries are free to choose if they want to stay or leave any time they want. The sole purpose of the EU is profit, prosperity and security of its members.
wefwq efwea I agree with you, but it’s not that the EU will not ‘deny’ a referendum, it’s that they physically cannot do that
Yes it does. Who wants to remain with a country ruled by Boris Johnson?
Because the UK are leaving the EU and Scotland want to be separate so they can join back to the EU if we leave. We don’t want to be involved as leaving the EU will heavily damage Scotland. The EU even said they will take Scotland back, most of Scotland voted for the SNP so they deserve to have another referendum and see how it goes this time.
"Once in a generation vote" - Nicola Sturgeon.
This is the perfect example of how lies, if repeated enough, become the truth to some people. The quote is "this is a once in a generation opportunity" meaning the chance to vote in the indy ref. This has been misquoted and quite frankly lied about. She did not say "this is our only chance for a generation" big, big difference. Then again, the biased English right wing gutter press don't let facts get in the way of their agenda...hence Brexit.
Northern Ireland act of 1998 states a political generation is 7 years!
Who cares though, if the people want it, the people will decide
In 2014 there's no issue of Brexit. Now situation changed and everyone has right to change mind and make decisions what is right for them. If BoJo don't allow them second referendum it would be undemocratic for Scottish people...
Scottish democracy in the hands of EU ! Have these Scottish people no idea about what EU is doing ?
Jan Schlossar the Dutch are prohibited to have a referendum because they would vote leave. Look for the lunatic Verhofstadt and his unimaginable terrible speeches on UA-cam. He's a Belgian former national politician, nobody wanted him so he went to EU. Look what EU did to Europe.
0:17 We’ve already had a Scottish referendum and the majority voted to remain in the UK. What is it with people not wanting to respect democratic votes and then pleading for more votes?
That went out the window after the English show of stupidity in 2016.
Empty vessels make the most noise.....
Blackford still banging on...... yawn 🥱
Ian “I only accept democracy when it suits me” Blackford
spackoid
To be fair, Better Together (campaign made of Tory + Labour members) said repeatedly that a vote for independence is a vote to leave the EU effectively all alone.
now they’re leaving the EU without the Independence part and that’s “democracy”. Lie and cheat and steal.
You being a Britnat, describe what you think democracy means ?
John Maclagan it’s system of government held by either elected MP’s or the by people.
What’s your point?
@@StuFlyboyReay How many Tories were elected in Scotland ? How many constituencies in Scotland voted to leave the EU ? I'll give England the mandate for Brexit because youse elected over 350 Tory MP's. Is that British democracy ?
John Maclagan yes that is democracy
Right on set Scotland FREE
Free yourself from being detained
Ian didnt like this video
Boris like a BOSS
Well to be fair, all of Scotland voted remain in the Eu, and it was pretty much just England that wanted to leave. Scotland is a country, but it cannot make its own decisions unfortunately. I think that’s what it wants. England is aware if it loses Scotland, it loses a lot of income
09BIJAN09 no that not correct Scottish shown through the referendum before that they want to remain in Britain . These SNP muppets are dragging this issue , Scottish people are the most valued in Britain we love them and they can never leave us
Yahya Elmi yes they did want to remain in UK when there was no talk of leaving Eu.
Just go look at the map votes, England voted to leave Eu, Scotland didn’t.
09BIJAN09 but that’s part of democracy , at the end of the day ,
09BIJAN09 but that’s part of democracy , at the end of the day ,
Yahya Elmi being lied to is part of democracy as well?
Well done Boris
Strange logic from the SNP......they want to become independent, but then would 'sell out' and loose any self determination or control right back to Brussels by re-joining the EU
“Our” precious NHS? Scotland has their own it has nothing to do with England.
Loyalists out in full force in LBC comment sections it seems.
@Callum Enlighten us , how is Scotland suffering under SNP ? NHS outperforms England , Crime rate far lower , more students going to universities , Scotland exports more , GDP/ head higher than England , so over to you .
let referendum done in scotland nowwwww
Ask the english if they want the Scottish....
@steve gale scotland would never reject the military, it's in there security interest and financially.
@steve gale exactly my point, things will rock the boat if they vote for independence. The government wont be pushed over by little Scotland anymore.
Dear Oh dear, Oh dear, the Mother of Parliament.