Premanand baba may God bless you and your family Abundantly may God Almighty give you courage n strength to do this hunger strike to save ur village n Goa n also may God enlighten them to change their minds n revoke the Buthani license right away
From day one I have always kept you PREMAND and your Courageous wife for taking bold decision allowing her husband taking decision to save not only SANCAOL but I believe whole of GOA.Ipray to ALMIGHTY COVER PREMAND,his wife and son with the BLOOD OF JESUS. and strengthen him to keep him in GOOD HEALTH.
May the LORD ALMIGHTY be kind And gracious towards you PREMAND YOUR wife and Son.My prayers GOD to build a hedge around you and your Courageous wife and son
I. Legal Arguments to Challenge the Construction License 1. Irregular Voting Procedure within the Panchayat a. Violation of Panchayati Raj Act Provisions: Procedure Adherence: Ensure that the Panchayat followed the stipulated procedures under the Panchayati Raj Act (likely the 73rd Constitutional Amendment if in India). Irregularities in voting can render decisions null and void. Quorum and Majority Requirements: Verify if the voting met the quorum and majority requirements as specified by the Act or local bylaws. Any deviation can be a ground for contesting the license. b. Transparency and Accountability: Lack of Transparent Processes: If the voting lacked transparency, it violates principles of good governance, allowing for administrative challenges. Conflict of Interest: Investigate if any Panchayat members had conflicts of interest influencing the vote, which can be grounds for invalidation. 2. Overuse of Village Resources (Water and Electricity) a. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Non-Compliance: Mandatory EIA: Construction projects typically require an EIA to assess resource usage and environmental impact. Failure to conduct or adhere to EIA recommendations can invalidate the license. b. Water and Electricity Regulatory Violations: Resource Allocation Laws: Overuse of resources like water and electricity may breach local or national regulations governing resource distribution and sustainability. Public Resource Mismanagement: Mismanagement of communal resources can be contested under laws protecting public utilities. 3. Significant Demographic Impact Due to Influx of 700 Families a. Land-Use and Zoning Regulations: Zoning Compliance: Verify if the project aligns with existing land-use and zoning laws. An influx of 700 families may exceed permissible density limits. b. Infrastructure and Urban Planning Laws: Infrastructure Strain: Assess whether local infrastructure (roads, schools, healthcare) can support the demographic increase, as mandated by urban planning statutes. c. Social Impact Assessments: Community Welfare: Lack of social impact assessments or ignoring their findings can be a procedural violation. 4. Caste-Based Discrimination and Procedural Bias a. Protection Under the Scheduled Castes and Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act: Discrimination Claims: The physical confrontation and caste-based slurs by Panchayat Acting Secretary Orville Vales can constitute caste discrimination, violating this Act. b. Fundamental Rights Under the Constitution: Equality Before Law (Article 14): Any discriminatory actions violate the right to equality. Prohibition of Discrimination (Article 15): Explicitly prohibits discrimination on grounds of caste. c. Administrative Bias: Fair Hearing (Due Process): Procedural bias undermines the principles of natural justice, providing grounds to challenge the decision. 5. Environmental Impacts a. Compliance with Environmental Laws: Environmental Protection Act: Ensure the project adheres to national environmental standards and guidelines. Local Environmental Regulations: Comply with state-specific environmental laws which may impose stricter controls. b. Sustainable Development Concerns: Long-Term Impact: Highlight potential long-term environmental degradation, affecting community livelihoods and health. 6. Procedural Violations a. Lack of Public Consultation: Public Hearing Requirements: Many jurisdictions mandate public consultations for significant construction projects. Absence of such processes can be contested. b. Documentation and Licensing Process: Incomplete or Falsified Documentation: Scrutinize the licensing process for any irregularities or omissions in required documentation. 7. Community Rights a. Right to Livelihood and Habitat: Displacement Issues: If the project leads to displacement, it violates the community’s right to livelihood and habitat. b. Indigenous and Local Rights: Recognition of Local Governance: Uphold the rights of the Panchayat and local governance structures to make decisions that reflect the community’s interests. II. Immediate Steps for Filing Complaints or Appeals 1. Gather and Document Evidence Meeting Records: Collect minutes, recordings, or any documentation of the Panchayat meetings, especially those indicating irregular voting procedures. Resource Usage Data: Compile data showing the current usage of water and electricity and projections post-construction. Demographic Studies: Present studies or reports highlighting the strain on local infrastructure due to the proposed influx. Incident Reports: Document the confrontation with Orville Vales, including any available evidence (videos, witness statements). 2. File an Immediate Injunction High Court Petition: File for an interim injunction in the relevant High Court to halt the construction until a thorough review is conducted. Urgency Justification: Emphasize potential irreparable harm to the community and environment to justify the urgency. 3. Submit Appeals to Relevant Authorities Local Administrative Bodies: Appeal to higher authorities within the Panchayat system or relevant state agencies overseeing land-use and construction. Environmental Authorities: Submit complaints to the State Pollution Control Board or equivalent bodies regarding EIA non-compliance and environmental concerns. 4. Lodge Complaints for Discrimination and Abuse National Human Rights Commission (NHRC): File a complaint detailing the caste-based discrimination and procedural bias encountered. State Human Rights Commission: Additionally, approach the state-level commission for localized support. Police Report: If physical confrontation occurred, file an FIR (First Information Report) with the local police citing assault and hate speech. 5. Engage with Judicial Review Mechanisms Public Interest Litigation (PIL): Consider filing a PIL in the High Court or Supreme Court highlighting the collective grievances of the community. Review Under Environmental Laws: Seek judicial review based on environmental law violations and procedural lapses. 6. Mobilize Community Support and Media Attention Awareness Campaigns: Organize community meetings to unify efforts and present a consolidated front. Media Engagement: Leverage local and national media to highlight the issues, increasing public pressure on authorities to act justly. 7. Consult Legal Experts and NGOs Legal Representation: Engage lawyers specializing in environmental law, human rights, and land-use disputes. NGO Support: Collaborate with non-governmental organizations that focus on community rights and environmental protection for additional resources and advocacy. III. Strategic Considerations 1. Timeline Adherence Statutory Deadlines: Ensure all filings are made within legal timelines to avoid dismissal on procedural grounds. 2. Comprehensive Legal Strategy Multi-Pronged Approach: Utilize a combination of administrative appeals, judicial reviews, and public advocacy to strengthen the challenge. 3. Evidence-Based Arguments Solid Documentation: Base all claims on verifiable evidence to enhance credibility and legal standing. 4. Continuous Monitoring Project Developments: Stay informed about any changes or developments in the Butani Infra project to promptly address new challenges.
❤This man premanand naik is a modern freedom fighter fighting to save Goa ❤people bring leaders to power to save n solve all problems of Goa and goans ❤before voting please take in writing ❤monoj parabs Pogo bill is very important ❤
Do not fast ...for these type of situation. This guy is paid to sign the licences ..he will also be finished if here revokes the license.. so you please live ..that guy may be frightened
This is same tactics app used in Delhi during congress with help of ana hazare and was disaster for Delhi today so history is telling us that this guy is ana hazare of goa .so in 2027 APP is making government in goa?
What our CM doing why no rules in Goa what he doing Only CM name??? Why so trouble for our Goan you people playing with our Goan what you people thinking to do stop playing Games 🙏
Please all Goa youth come out and sapport bab pramanand and saved our goa
Premanand baba may God bless you and your family Abundantly may God Almighty give you courage n strength to do this hunger strike to save ur village n Goa n also may God enlighten them to change their minds n revoke the Buthani license right away
I support premanad bab
From day one I have always kept you PREMAND and your Courageous wife for taking bold decision allowing her husband taking decision to save not only SANCAOL but I believe whole of GOA.Ipray to ALMIGHTY COVER PREMAND,his wife and son with the BLOOD OF JESUS. and strengthen him to keep him in GOOD HEALTH.
May the LORD ALMIGHTY be kind And gracious towards you PREMAND YOUR wife and Son.My prayers GOD to build a hedge around you and your Courageous wife and son
Youth came to forward now student now your time to save goa
I support for premanand bhai love u ❤
Lord premanand need strength pls protect him n enlighten those corrupt officers n corrupt politicians
Are goan brothers and sisters please come out this is the time to save goa.🙏🙏🙏
Need a change of government in Goa! Resign CM from your post you are not serving people of Goa and save Goans, you are playing with Goans life!
I. Legal Arguments to Challenge the Construction License
1. Irregular Voting Procedure within the Panchayat
a. Violation of Panchayati Raj Act Provisions:
Procedure Adherence: Ensure that the Panchayat followed the stipulated procedures under the Panchayati Raj Act (likely the 73rd Constitutional Amendment if in India). Irregularities in voting can render decisions null and void.
Quorum and Majority Requirements: Verify if the voting met the quorum and majority requirements as specified by the Act or local bylaws. Any deviation can be a ground for contesting the license.
b. Transparency and Accountability:
Lack of Transparent Processes: If the voting lacked transparency, it violates principles of good governance, allowing for administrative challenges.
Conflict of Interest: Investigate if any Panchayat members had conflicts of interest influencing the vote, which can be grounds for invalidation.
2. Overuse of Village Resources (Water and Electricity)
a. Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) Non-Compliance:
Mandatory EIA: Construction projects typically require an EIA to assess resource usage and environmental impact. Failure to conduct or adhere to EIA recommendations can invalidate the license.
b. Water and Electricity Regulatory Violations:
Resource Allocation Laws: Overuse of resources like water and electricity may breach local or national regulations governing resource distribution and sustainability.
Public Resource Mismanagement: Mismanagement of communal resources can be contested under laws protecting public utilities.
3. Significant Demographic Impact Due to Influx of 700 Families
a. Land-Use and Zoning Regulations:
Zoning Compliance: Verify if the project aligns with existing land-use and zoning laws. An influx of 700 families may exceed permissible density limits.
b. Infrastructure and Urban Planning Laws:
Infrastructure Strain: Assess whether local infrastructure (roads, schools, healthcare) can support the demographic increase, as mandated by urban planning statutes.
c. Social Impact Assessments:
Community Welfare: Lack of social impact assessments or ignoring their findings can be a procedural violation.
4. Caste-Based Discrimination and Procedural Bias
a. Protection Under the Scheduled Castes and Tribes (Prevention of Atrocities) Act:
Discrimination Claims: The physical confrontation and caste-based slurs by Panchayat Acting Secretary Orville Vales can constitute caste discrimination, violating this Act.
b. Fundamental Rights Under the Constitution:
Equality Before Law (Article 14): Any discriminatory actions violate the right to equality.
Prohibition of Discrimination (Article 15): Explicitly prohibits discrimination on grounds of caste.
c. Administrative Bias:
Fair Hearing (Due Process): Procedural bias undermines the principles of natural justice, providing grounds to challenge the decision.
5. Environmental Impacts
a. Compliance with Environmental Laws:
Environmental Protection Act: Ensure the project adheres to national environmental standards and guidelines.
Local Environmental Regulations: Comply with state-specific environmental laws which may impose stricter controls.
b. Sustainable Development Concerns:
Long-Term Impact: Highlight potential long-term environmental degradation, affecting community livelihoods and health.
6. Procedural Violations
a. Lack of Public Consultation:
Public Hearing Requirements: Many jurisdictions mandate public consultations for significant construction projects. Absence of such processes can be contested.
b. Documentation and Licensing Process:
Incomplete or Falsified Documentation: Scrutinize the licensing process for any irregularities or omissions in required documentation.
7. Community Rights
a. Right to Livelihood and Habitat:
Displacement Issues: If the project leads to displacement, it violates the community’s right to livelihood and habitat.
b. Indigenous and Local Rights:
Recognition of Local Governance: Uphold the rights of the Panchayat and local governance structures to make decisions that reflect the community’s interests.
II. Immediate Steps for Filing Complaints or Appeals
1. Gather and Document Evidence
Meeting Records: Collect minutes, recordings, or any documentation of the Panchayat meetings, especially those indicating irregular voting procedures.
Resource Usage Data: Compile data showing the current usage of water and electricity and projections post-construction.
Demographic Studies: Present studies or reports highlighting the strain on local infrastructure due to the proposed influx.
Incident Reports: Document the confrontation with Orville Vales, including any available evidence (videos, witness statements).
2. File an Immediate Injunction
High Court Petition: File for an interim injunction in the relevant High Court to halt the construction until a thorough review is conducted.
Urgency Justification: Emphasize potential irreparable harm to the community and environment to justify the urgency.
3. Submit Appeals to Relevant Authorities
Local Administrative Bodies: Appeal to higher authorities within the Panchayat system or relevant state agencies overseeing land-use and construction.
Environmental Authorities: Submit complaints to the State Pollution Control Board or equivalent bodies regarding EIA non-compliance and environmental concerns.
4. Lodge Complaints for Discrimination and Abuse
National Human Rights Commission (NHRC): File a complaint detailing the caste-based discrimination and procedural bias encountered.
State Human Rights Commission: Additionally, approach the state-level commission for localized support.
Police Report: If physical confrontation occurred, file an FIR (First Information Report) with the local police citing assault and hate speech.
5. Engage with Judicial Review Mechanisms
Public Interest Litigation (PIL): Consider filing a PIL in the High Court or Supreme Court highlighting the collective grievances of the community.
Review Under Environmental Laws: Seek judicial review based on environmental law violations and procedural lapses.
6. Mobilize Community Support and Media Attention
Awareness Campaigns: Organize community meetings to unify efforts and present a consolidated front.
Media Engagement: Leverage local and national media to highlight the issues, increasing public pressure on authorities to act justly.
7. Consult Legal Experts and NGOs
Legal Representation: Engage lawyers specializing in environmental law, human rights, and land-use disputes.
NGO Support: Collaborate with non-governmental organizations that focus on community rights and environmental protection for additional resources and advocacy.
III. Strategic Considerations
1. Timeline Adherence
Statutory Deadlines: Ensure all filings are made within legal timelines to avoid dismissal on procedural grounds.
2. Comprehensive Legal Strategy
Multi-Pronged Approach: Utilize a combination of administrative appeals, judicial reviews, and public advocacy to strengthen the challenge.
3. Evidence-Based Arguments
Solid Documentation: Base all claims on verifiable evidence to enhance credibility and legal standing.
4. Continuous Monitoring
Project Developments: Stay informed about any changes or developments in the Butani Infra project to promptly address new challenges.
All 33 mla involve
The govt has to intervene immediately.
❤This man premanand naik is a modern freedom fighter fighting to save Goa ❤people bring leaders to power to save n solve all problems of Goa and goans ❤before voting please take in writing ❤monoj parabs Pogo bill is very important ❤
Take a morcha to the CM to protect mr.Premanand.It has to be done. All the ministers r sitting quietly. Make them take a decision.
Why can't the licence be revoked...CM are you sleeping... shame shame
How school students will come in Sancoale, as there are no original Goans children, 80 percent are migrants even in all Goa colleges.
i support from my heart it's very true goan all must at critical situation of our beautiful Goa
Hope don't give chance to this outsider
Do not fast ...for these type of situation. This guy is paid to sign the licences ..he will also be finished if here revokes the license.. so you please live ..that guy may be frightened
I support to mr permanand Naik
❤
Goichea saiba st Francis Xavier amchea bavak premanandk tum rak ani sambal ani tachea familicher subam ashirvad gall 🙏
So bad , Goa 's state of affairs.
Where is karntakarie boys
Ujjo ghalat cm savant chya ghara ochon ,jor hya आमच्या bhavak किते जाईत jalear cm savantak main target korat ,
This is same tactics app used in Delhi during congress with help of ana hazare and was disaster for Delhi today so history is telling us that this guy is ana hazare of goa .so in 2027 APP is making government in goa?
What our CM doing why no rules in Goa what he doing
Only CM name??? Why so trouble for our Goan you people playing with our Goan what you people thinking to do stop playing
Games 🙏
Cm look you and BJP destroy Goa people come out
Waste