New 2023 Honda CR-V A Better Choice Over Nissan Rogue? SUV Comparison.
Вставка
- Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
- 2023 Honda CR-V Hybrid vs 2022 Nissan Rogue Turbo
Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @samcarlegion
2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Timestamp:
00:01 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Intro
01:05 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Exterior Differences
02:09 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Trunk Space Comparison
04:34 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue 90 Degree Second Row Doors
05:542023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Interior, second row
08:11 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Interior First Row Tech and Space
12:20 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Driving Impressions
12:41 2023 Honda CRV Engine Specs
13:42 2022 Nissan Rogue Engine Specs
14:41 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Pricing Canada and US
18:19 2023 Honda CRV vs Nissan Rogue Final Thoughts and Winner
I drove both and the rogue is just a more complete package!
I have a Nissan Rogue with 26k miles and I am still in love with it. Good on gas, powerful enough, comfy...just amazing for my taste.
Nissan Rogue absolutely wins for me.
Especially Nissan reputation 🥴
Yesss....Honda not good
Rogue is the best. I test drove Rav4, CRV and Rogue. Bought the rogue at the end.
Did you find the Rogue comfortable? I am on the fence between the 2.
@@cindynorris5983 It is comfortable in drive, elegant in looks, equipped with the safety features starting from the base trim. In other brands, they charge for basic safety features like blind spot sensor and automatic braking.
@@danishhussain8046 Thank you. Buying a car can be stressful and confusing.
Sam, I love your comparison videos. They are so informative. Real world comparisons that are ruthlessly truthful.
Glad you like them!
Thanks for the video. Just a couple of points to add. The 1.5 turbo CRV does have a spare tire. Also, the CRVs rear seats recline to give a little more room.
We road tested both the Honda HRV and Toyota Cross.
My mother was also there and she couldn't believe how LOUD the engine drone noise was during acceleration.
Their prices were also too over marked.
Already signed and sealed for the Rogue.
All we're waiting for is delivered.
Sam, Great comparison video as always. Two formidable contenders in a very competitive segment. I like what Nissan has done with the 2022 Rogue, options, fit and finish, style and overall package. It's spot on for most busy families, as they have price points and trims to make it doable on all budgets. As for the CR-V, well it does everything pretty much bang on and has since 1997 when it first launched. I don't know of one owner that didn't love their CR-V other than maybe engine output with the first gen series. With that said; I feel the available options on the Rogue (Panaroof, heads up display) make it feel like a more luxurious delivery than the CR-V. Trim level for trim level it feels more upscale. As for price? Well the CR-V just keep climbing up and up to where it's priced itself out of some people compact SUV budget, but then again the resale is and always has been top notch - so perhaps that $7,000 premium over the Rogue (Initially) might not be $7,000 in the end? Nevertheless, great video, great camera shots of stills and rolling content. Keep up the great work! Chris
Thanks for your input Chris :)
@@SamCarLegion What is the real life fuel efficiency you got with both the cars?
I rented the rogue this weekend while out of town. I was really impressed with the overall performance & comfort. I put over a thousand miles on it in 2 days. The 3 cylinder turbo never struggled to get to speed. I didn’t know it was a 3 until I did some research. It felt like a much larger displacement engine. The fit, finish, comfort & ride was very good. The think I was impressed with most was the gas mileage. I averaged 33 while cruising at 85-90mph. In city it got even better fuel mileage with peaks of 39. I could definitely see this as a daily driver.
you did this testing with epower?
39 city? How ???
@@Gopinathk17 That's impossible with the Rogue. I rented one for a week.
@@patrickcotter5629 Yeah I was shocked too when he said 39 city because I'm getting somewhere between 18-25mpg in city. Don't know if he has some hybrid version but no hybrid version released in the US as far as I know.
Yes I regular get 35-37 mpg on standard with highway driving. Just have to press the gas pedal w love.
CRV over Rogue. End of the day Honda has better known reliability and resale. If Nissan could get rid of their garbage Jatco transmissions it would be a step in the right direction. Aside from resale and reliability, CRV has better exterior styling and I slightly prefer the Nissans interior over CRV. But end of the day CRV overall, just more pros than cons. I’ve driven a rogue and they just feel under powered as well compared to a Honda. A family member of mine has had multiple Altimas since 06 and they have all had multiple problems with different things by the end of a 3yr lease with all of them and have terrible resale value
Nice comparison, I'm from Saudi Arabia, The Nissan rogue's name in our market is X-trail, I'm not quite sure if Honda already launched this new generation of CRV in our markets. To be honest I still haven't noticed any in the streets. Nevertheless, I was confused between the X-trail and some other competitors in the market like RV4, CX5, and Hyundai Tucson. I ended up buying the X-trail because for me it was the best overall when it comes to features, performance, space, and driving experience, apart from the front design which I'm not a big fan of, just like you I think that Nissan did a great job with this new X-trail (Rouge) I'm sure that the front will grow on me, I hope so😅 back to your comparison, Nissan rogue for me is the winner by miles hands down, and I'm not biased at all, I used to fan of Honda but I think that they have been improving slowly in the recent years and they still need a lot of work in order to catch up with the other competitors.
Cheers
أي فئة أخذت و كيف الموتر معاك ، ناوي اشتريه و محتار بينه و بين Cx5
I would still pick the crv but Nissan is definitely kicking butt. Makes me question why Honda hasn’t added more tech for the price…. This is exactly why I won’t be getting the crv this year. It is still lacking 😢
I have the previous nissan rouge 225.000 miles and stills runs grate
got my daughter a new Rogue SV recently and she loves it, so does her kid. thing has some decent get up and go with that turbo!
☮
Both are very good Japanese compact SUV´s 👍
Great comparison, but i wish you wouldve done the 1.5t CRV. The Rogue's interior is so much nicer, but I worry about longevity of the tiny 1.5t 3 cylinder.
The CRV wins on exterior styling and the hybrid/handling, but the Rogue clearly has a better interior/tech.
I go with the Rogue. No doubt.
By no mean, Nissan and Mitsubishi is comparable with Honda and Toyota. If you are just fan of features, then CRV is a big no. But you have to also consider where they will stand after 6-7 years and how much I can sell them for. Nissan most probably ranks below Ford in terms of resale value. Just two cents.
In terms of Brand image Yes Honda is ahead of Nissan .. in terms of quality and value for money i wouldn't put Honda in the same sentence as Toyota and
certainly not above Nissan at this point.. the pre 2017 CRV are just bullet proof this newer ones i wouldn't pay the extra money for less.. rear camber issues that plagued the out going gen drivers i know can't keep rear tires on just wears excessively and Honda didn't have a fix along with other concerns coupled with a loud cabin.. no thanks u ..
Hi, Sam, great video. The comparison between CRV hybrid vs Rouge is a little bit off. Actually, I bought Rouge SV in March, and just purchase a CRV EX last month. I can say that I like the Rouge way better, and it is cheaper. Here are some comparisons from mine. 1) Engine: CRV engine is the same as last verion and is less power than Rouge's new engine. I can feel that very obvious at freeway speed above 70 mph; 2) Infotainment display: CRV is 7 in, while Rouge is 9 in. CRV driver display is a weird combination of half LCD and a meter; 3) Suepension: CRV is more comfortable; 4) I feel Rouge is bigger in space; CRV reduce the headroom by 2 in compared to the previous version. People always saying CRV is longer and wider, but not mentioning shorter. Overall, I feel Rouge worth the money.
Thanks for your info but why does anyone ever need two SUVs which are gas guzzlers. Someone with family should have a small car and SUV. Use small car for groceries or do some errands in city.
@@Flying-Fox19 Both my wife and I have to commute long to work unfortunately, and we have two kids. SUVs are safer and comfortable, they are the last protection in such crazy LA traffic. I bought Rouge early 2022 to trade in my 190k miles old sedan, just bought CRV because our minivan has been reared end by a Tesla to total loss.
I drove 25000 miles per year, and my company provide free charging. I was thinking buying EV, but SUV EVs are super expensive. Tesla Y is my dream car, but I cannot afford it, because I have to drove more than 150k miles to balance the higher cost, let alone the higher insurance and the tire cost.
Dealers add a lot of mark up to hybrid models, and I also need to drove at least 100k miles to compensate the cost.
I don't think EV and hydrid worth the money I pay extra. My next car will be an EV in 4-5 years. Right now I am OK to suffer from visiting gas station twice a week and high gas price. Overall, we are happy to drive our Rouge and CRV,
I bought the CRV EXL back in October, i drove it for 3.5k mile already. 1) the 1.5T is just enough, other than the slow acceleration, i don't have any problem getting above 70mph. (if i wait 2 more month, i would have get the Touring) 2) EXL has 9inch display so i don't have any complain. 3) CRV is very smooth and more quiet than the last gen 4) CRV is more roomy than Rouge and rear seats are more comfortable.
Other than the few thousand dollar difference, i think CRV is better than the Rouge. Eventually it will make up from the repair bill.
My old car was a 2007 Nissan Altima, after those bad experience, i will never go back to Nissan
@@azzdesigner I agree with you that CRV is definitely more smooth and comfortable than Rouge. But I don't like Honda reduce the headroom to front/back 38.2/38.2 from the previous generation (front/back 40.1/39.2), which is the same as the Rouge. Honda says this new CRV is more sedan like. I like to drive sitting high, so the old CRV and Rouge fit better for me. Overall, I have both, and will find out which one break first.
@@Flying-Fox19 my small car is worst on gas than the Rogue :D ... the 1.5l engine is really great on gas.
Both good cars! However, i would pick the CRV
I am a nissan rogue owner and if I can switch to crv won’t think twice the cvt feels boring the long run also cars are becoming faster and faster every year is a problem when merging highways or intersections do not buy cvt
@@kennyplayer7731 What year of the Nissan Rogue do you own? The CVT and the engines were upgraded for 2022+
@@davoncci 2017. There is no change with the 2022 it still being a cvt maybe wont break that often but the acceleration still trash
I will pick up honda I already proven that Honda Car is very reliable. 100percent! 1 decade I used Honda civic, Crv and Ridgeline.
Nissan is one of the worst brand ...
The new Nissan three cylinder engine in the Rogue is experiencing major issues. I work at a Nissan dealership and we’ve replaced a few long blocks on them due to cracking. Out of the close to 30 employees at my service department (Advisors and techs), only 6-7 drive Nissans. And they are mostly 90s Nissans when they were reliable.
There’s a reason I chose to work at Nissan but drive a Honda. Because the month-end bonus at Nissan is way higher compared to Honda. Replacing transmissions gross way higher than spark plugs and air filters, even if it’s warranty jobs. We easily have 20+ transmissions in the storage area right now. Some waiting to go back to Nissan, some waiting to go into cars.
Umm, Hondas are problematic vehicles with oil delusion. Honda is a Nissan in a Gucci belt.
@@odnamorvr3053 yea, that only happens in cold climates like Minnesota. We’ve had customers here at Nissan with 80k on their cars already on the third CVT. Honda has problems, but they are mostly covered by warranty extensions. Unlike Nissan.
@@LouAntonioGiordano Honda cars are overpriced trash. At least Nissans are cheap, so legitimately speaking you can't beat on them because you get what you pay for, plus if you treat Nissans right they will last you.
@@odnamorvr3053 Aww Honda didn’t approve you? Had to settle for a Nissan I persume?
I had a brand new 1998 Accord EX V6 coupe. Within a month the cable operating the sliding mechanism on the passenger's side seat broke without having anyone sit in it. I had to wait a few months while the replacement cable came from Japan. Hondas aren't what they used to be.
The 2021 Rogue Platinum is a winner. No issues as of 40K miles on it. Power is fine, premium feel, and the heads up display sealed the deal. Best bang for the buck hands down. Go and test drive one. The new CVT is fine
Recently just got the CRV EX-L for my mother and I really did my research. For her and some people specifically, more bells and whistles are not a good thing. This will be her vehicle until its reaches the end of its life and more things to break down or maintain in 10 years plus is no good. Found new hondas on average to be more reliable than nissan from various reviews, CReports and online feedback from reddit and I wanted my mother to be as worry free as possible so that was a big deciding factor. We find new tech features to be gimmicky as its not essential to operate and just adds too many options which isn't always good. In our case for her needs, the new CR-V was well worth the price for peace of mind and simplicity. Prefer the look of it also in the white option with dark accents.
First of all, congratulation on your new baby. Great review as always and I agree the Rouge is a better value from these two SUV.
Thank you
I work at a Honda dealership. Sold 200 total cars this year, we get lots of trade ins, good and bad. For a Nissan Rogue to pass our safety inspection, it has to be 2018 or up model, if it’s older than that, it always fails our safety. We also have cars that are excellent condition even at 2010( it always happens to be a Honda or Toyota)
I’m always scared of selling OFF MAKE brands like Nissan, Hyundai, Kia, VW, I want to build a good clientele and get referrals business and if I sell those brands, I’m not getting any business back. Out of all the Hondas I have sold, only one car had some issues, that was a 2021 Passport touring, my customer had to come back to the dealership 3 times because the screen would go off on him and the wireless charging would not work. Never had anyone come back with a new or pre owned crv.
Are you guys still selling with markups? Few months back when I visited Honda dealer he said atleast 3-6k markup on all cars.
I feel Rogue, Tucson and Sportage are actually very good cars. Their brand value might be less but they have good sales after RAV4 and CRV in this segment. Hyundai and Kia give 10 year warranty on the power train.
Also, 2022 Rogue got higher safety ratings compared to CRV as per IIHS safety picks, check their site.
Also, Tucson and Sportage are on their top 5 best small SUVs as per Edmunds rankings.
@@Gopinathk17
We never did mark ups for more than $500 which is all weather mats and trunk they.
The Koreans have some a long way, the only thing they can give is 10 years warranty, which is 100,000 .
Unfortunately, the cars die after that, they don’t invest in good engines and transmission for reliability. Rogue was redesigned in 2022, that why it has a higher safety rating, now in 2023 cr-will pass with flying colours in iihs
No matter how the car looks in videos, test drive is crucially important, it makes such a difference and that’s the reason Honda and Toyota fall in tier one of car sales.
I agree with honda and toyota being better, especially for the long run. We have lots of mechanics in the family and lots of shops all over our big county.
All you see over the years are toyota and hondas being ones with least issues! I always say no to Kia, VW, BMW Hyundai, Nissan...etc.
We were in the market for a new compact suv. Test drove the new Nissan Rogue platinum, and then we test drove the 2024 CRV Touring Hybrid. Our findings were that Nissan Rouge had more bells and whistles. We found Rouge to be more roomier. It was also $7k less than CRV. Rogue had a heads-up display, a 360-degree camera, almost full ceiling moon roof. CRV was lacking all that. Just to name a few. The decision was easy. We went for the Rogue. I'm picking up my new Rogue tomorrow.
I would go with the Nissan Rogue
The honda looks fantastic. So glad they actually listened to feedback and started including volume knobs again.
What do you mean? Last generation crv also had a volume knob!
I bought the Rogue after being a Honda guy for years, In Canada Honda’s increased Price and lack of trims made me look else where. Also i think Honda has gotten complacent again, compared to competition for the price they don’t offer enough, do better Honda!
Merge the exterior of crv and interior of rogue while maintaining the same price point and that's it for me. If i have to choose one would be the crv. I like hybrid to be my next car
Thanks for the comparison, Even Mitsubishi Outlander 2023 Made In Japan competes and a good choice !
Lol the new outlander is basically a rogue. Check it out
@@cliby25 No.
@@cliby25 drive both variants and revisit your comment :) yes both share same platform to exchange technology but Mitsubishi got there own engine tuning and components made in japan vs US .. you will clearly see the difference ! i own Mitsubishi Outlander SEL 2023 the best in class so clam and premium vehicle I might go for PHEV is the best of the best one.
@@bankperson1366 the new Rogue is made in Japan too.
I have the 2023 bolden grey Nissan midnight edition rogue. It has everything but the heated seating in the back and it doesn’t have the full digital display gauge. Other than that I love the vehicle and it stands out better than the platinum look with the all black
CRV all day.
The 1.5T is now tried and tested for a few years, the Hybrid is a joy to drive too.
No is not ,its still a piece of crap engine and the way every toyota drives are crap , boring cars specially that cvt is horrible 😂
CR-V is slower than Rogue.
@@MG-ce3dx The thing with the CRV and most current Honda's is that they aren't the fastest or the most powerful. But if you look at it as an overall package in terms of practicality, space, tech, reliability, driving dynamics and resale value it is hard to beat Honda as it they have found a lovely balance. The interiors also are a lot more premium, the major misses in this gen CRV are the Pano roof and the 360 degree cam.
@@KP-xi4bj Idk too many people who would want to race these cars.
They are both perfectly adequate for everyday driving.
@@SFWolf8 Maybe in the event of an emergency manoeuvre on the highway and you need to speed up to get out of harm's way?
I would get the Rouge. Which ever one you get definitely get a extended Powertrain warranty or find a dealer with at least 100K warranty. They're both using a CVT.
CR-V does not, its direct drive.
CRV has CVT as well. But Honda CVTs are reliable.
@@Gopinathk17 When Honda went to CVT, there was a lawsuit with the shaking and shuddering...I joined the owners chat even while I owned the Rogue-just to get info on how they rectified the situation......it was a mess early on. Honda is too overpriced-will stick with Nissan.
I was favouring the Rouge until he talked about the 3 cylinder turbo engine with a Cvt. Then I switched back to the Honda.
They both a CVT 😭
Those paddle shifters are to regenerate the battery, inside and outside I would take the CRV. The quality of the Rogue is cheap even the camera looks bad quality. I was looking for both but to be honest, the CR-V is a better car than the Nissan “my opinion” Great video! I love when you do this type of videos.
Really very good competition between them but I like CR-V more.
I would go with a CRV just because when my wife bought her used 2011 Honda Fit last year, the Ontario Honda dealership replaced the suspension front and rear, the brakes front and rear, and replaced the indicator lights and reflectors and touched up the body paint. We were both impressed that Honda did not have to do that, but they did.
I will see what happens in a couple of years, but if I can swing it, I will get a used CRV. I still have not test driven any CRV, so I’m looking forward to doing so.
Car was shit to begin with
@@lilpeppa117G what are you talking about?
They ain’t doing that in America for free
I agree. I voted for the Nissan Rogue, too, when I got one a week ago.
Honda CR-V EX-L 2023 is around 35k(3.9 APR for 24-48 months) and Nissan Rogue SV 2023 is $28500 (1.9 APR for 36 months) in my area, so Nissan is the winner!
I love my 2022 Rogue. For me, as long as you take care of your car/engine you can't go wrong with CRV or Rogue.
True.. but the Rogue is nicer and quieter though.. For less.. 🤗 ..
Sam this I was a good video because in the beginning you wanted not to like the CRV until you drove it. I have driven both also. The CRVs drive is awesome.
I can't stand the styling of rogue, hence crv for me.
Good point
Most nissans have questionable designs, although the Maxima looks pretty good
Honda sales will go down
Sales are already down. Nobody buys Hondas anymore except diehard Honda fanboys.
Well to me you can't compare them because the CRV is a legend it's gonna always be people first pick 💯
The crv is a much better SUV however I wish they will put fog lights
I totally agree with this review. I am a fan of CRVs ( I have had the opportunity to own two of them) and when I went to the dealership to buy a 2023 CRV of the new generation, I left there really disappointed, then I decided to give the Nissan Rogue a chance, when I finally saw it, I was amazed., and I am very sorry to say it, but the comfort and luxury is superior to the Honda CRV, Honda has been regulating the features and increasing the price, The final result is more than evident, especially when you compare the complete package.
Honda interior is still second rated , Rogue interior is beautiful!
Imo, nissan should bring a designer from Kia. Merry Christmas! Good job Sam!
Same to you bud
Excellent point! GM could use a few of those designers on loan as well 😂
What? Kia cars are not bad looking, but Nissan cars look way better than any Kia. Some Kias are overdesigned and are copies of other car brands' design. Nissans have great designs that look original and not a copy.
Yes KIA have the best design in the car industry game.
@HarutHajin KIAs got the best design. Nissan have ugliest design. That's a fact.
1.5 turbo with 201 hp with Nissan reliability...They gonna make a lot of mechanics happy
Yeah, I would wait a few years to let Nissan work out some of the bugs.
The 2 litre turbo has no issues. The 1•5 is based on the same design. The 1.5 from Honda has oil delution problem. Injector issues as well
In my humble opinion, A 1.5 liter 3-cylinder engine never is a better value than a 4-cylinder engine assisted with a 184 horse power electric engine. A3-cylinder engine never has the refinement of a 4-cylinder engine.
sure, Rogue is tough competition for CRV. but I can list rivals that I’d take the CRV over any day now:
- Tiguan (unless VW swears to put buttons back into the redesigned Tiguan, but spy photos say otherwise)
- Equinox (Chevy’s 9at is actually not as smooth as their own CVT, which their CVT is found in the Malibu)
- Escape (Honda is more reliable than Ford)
- 2024 Forester (making everything rely on the touchscreen is not a reassuring design)
- Sportage (may be more techy, but bad ergonomics are a turn off)
- Tuscon (capacitive buttons are bad ergonomics, they need to put real buttons in like they’re doing with the 2024 Kona)
In this segment, It always between Rav4, CRV and CX-50.
Sportage and Tuscon are close, but i just hate Kimchi car, which only "Look" good
@@azzdesigner Mazda is trying to go upmarket, so CX50 is trying to compete against the Buick Envision, Lexus NX, Acura RDX, Audi Q5, Volvo XC60, Infiniti QX50
I currently have the CR-V AWD. Honestly, it drives very well, good handling, spacious and comfy. I drove the Equinox as rental during my last vacations and it feels crap and low quality materials compared to my CR-V. I'm not sure about the other competitors in this category.
Rather go with the Toyota Venza.
@@patrickcotter5629 Venza is not even a CRV competitor. Venza is a midsize, CRV is compact
I’ve owned three Hondas and eight Nissans. I’ve noticed no difference in quality.
Good Nissan Rogue/ no issues we'll made with good reliability. Honda had 1.5 l injectors leaking causing engine issues.
Optimum word "had" as did the Nissan's with their transmissions. Both companies have made improvements if you read on line comments.
Touring is using 2.0
@@goni274 JATCO cvt is now at gen 3...its much more responsible than the previous ones...it also fakes shifts very well (majority of the time)...I think we should be good as long as we don't tow anything and don't get used to rocket start everytime....
Man this nissan looks so good ❤
LOL you consider junk better as Honda? Your mind is backwards.
Why didn't you compare the Rogue with the base CR-V with the 1.5 turbo instead, as that would be more similar in price and power? The hybrid CR-V is more comparable to the X-Trail E-power which isn't available in Canada.
Picked highest trims for both
Nissan Rogue/X-Trail for me, although I'm not so sure about that CVT.
Love our 22’ rogue for sure
Thanks for the good comparison. But how about the cost of ownership specifically the cost of gas. Will the hybrid make up the price difference with better gas mileage? Lots of variables to consider but it is worth mentioning the value of the hybrid engine in this respect. Thanks Sam.
Well when it's 7k more that's alot of gas and if you're on the highway they pretty much get the same gas mileage with the crv being better in the city but if you're in the city only that means you don't drive much so the savings per year is small.
Based on what i have heard and seen on reviews i don't know for fact.. this new rogue sipps fuel knocking on hybrid territory so the delta for the hybrid payback is going to be alot longer if not virtually impossible when comparing the two.. the out going rogue i know for a fact did get decent fuel efficiency
@Joe Brown thanks Joe. I agree with your conclusions. The rogue seems like a very good option.
@@joebrown9621 my coworker is averaging 37mpg in her rogue lol mostly highway and backroads
@@occckid123 that's great .. especially for a 4 wheel drive SUV .. i bet if they'l drive it really gingerly properly hit 40 mpg what more could you ask for.. i wouldn't spend the extra for a hybrid
The Nissan's 3 cylinder engine and the way it operates to get the horsepower it achieves will be a total nightmare when things go wrong.. Trust anyone when they tell you this! I would not want to own this vehicle once it gets out of warranty !!!
The CRV is hybrid which is twice as problematic- hybrid dies you are done
@@SamCarLegion I don’t recall Honda’s hybrid system being overly problematic? Actually I have probably heard more issues with the 1.5 turbo engine.
@@chrissimmons9969 If ICE in CR-V is kaput can you still drive the CR-V with only the electric motors? Yeah, didn't think so.
@@KP-xi4bj you can drive slow if there's enough battery. The engine will only connect mechanically to the wheels at a particular speed range, but aside from that, the engine mostly is there to charge the battery. If the engine goes bad, the car will still be able to drive slow for a few more miles, depending on how full the battery was
@@KP-xi4bj the ICE in the CRV hybrid is less likely to go kaput than the rogue VC-T. It is a relatively simple naturally aspirated engine that will last a very long time. The 2.0 has been out since 2018, and there hasn't been problems with that engine.
Nissan Rogue is far better in all ways… come on Honda!
Ty for the review, as always good info ... I have been going with Nissans since 2020 just cause it was easier to deal with the personal, service and in general ... both have there ups and downs so if you pick a price point it will fall so close with each other that to me at the end it will come down to what you need, want and the dealer experience when shopping ...
Zero info about fuel economy? You tested a hybrid CRV against a non hybrid Rogue and then complained about the price differential. Either the hybrid premium is taken in account with the fuel savings or next time, test two non hybrid vehicles together. You also don't mention down the road, the Honda resale value will be superior to that of the Nissan.
1 - the fuel economy numbers are online, but they are also related to each driver differently so not a big fan of the fuel economy numbers.
2 - resale value is different for every car. If you read reviews rarely journalists talk about resale value.
These two topics can be covered by 2 different videos focusing on them separately.
@@SamCarLegion Your $7000 difference in price negates what you just said. Apples to apples better compared than apples to a hybrid orange.
@@goni274 even the standard non Hybrid gives you less tech features and no towing in comparison to the Rogue.
@@SamCarLegion granted but $7000 difference is my point.
Hey bottom line- I like your reviews. Keep them coming guy!
Go Ni.
@@goni274 thank you.
I have a 2021 rogue sl. Wonderful car. Test drove the 2023 today. So disappointed they put such a tiny engine in it. Sure it’s a little speedier but it just doesn’t have the guts the 2.5l has. The 1.5 l just feels like it’s working too much. It’s a deal breaker for me to upgrade.
Great comparison video! Exactly the 2 cars I’m looking at. Thank you! Also love you running in the opening credits 😂
I recommend the Rogue.
I got the 2022 Rogue SL and am very happy with it. The interior is where you spend most of the time and it’s incredible
I also recommend the Rogue. I tested the previous CRV and the RAV4...The Rogue is far superior...
Man let’s get real…the CRV rear end looks WAY better than the Rogue. The Rogue is unattractive overall. It’s not even a competition. Maybe you’re sponsored and need to say some good stuff about the car, but man is it not a looker.
The CRV is a good looking car, but the previous generation CRV coupe be the ugliest known to man
Apparently you haven't drove both I have and the Nissan is way better. I drove the loaded High Brid. I know Honda is very reliable but dealers are asking 7000 above MSRP
HONDA CRV will last longer! Rogue transmission will surely fail: not if, but when.
Rogue cvt usually fail around 80k miles… major repair people!
ok chucky yoohoo😂
Excellent video comparison as usual. Different opinions from most UA-camrs.
Love the watch. Nice to see a fellow Oris owner. Which boots are those?
I’m looking at both, but can’t afford the top trims. Looking at Rogue SV Premium and CRV EXL. I like the Rogue. My only concerns are the front seat space being a little tight. (I’m fat and 6’ tall) and the small info screen. Worried these things will start to really bug me over time. Concerns with the CRV is mostly the price. I can lease the Rogue for quite a bit less.
Nissan rogue is better than this crv
Go with natural aspiration engine, which you can not go wrong with. It is old school and it is robust and reliable. In terms of this, I would prefer Honda hybrid.
Hi Sam. Nice review. Can you make review with 2 car seat installed. Also review what kind of latches both cars has? Will it fit 3 people in rear, can it fit full size stroller in trunk. Thank you in advance
Will do
Why would you compare a hybrid with a non-hybrid?
With the 7,000 dollars your saving on the Rogue you can put that money away for the 8,000 dollar replacement transmission you will need in 70,000 miles.
The rogue looks very nice and feature rich inside. The exterior is a miss to me though.
Honda has a Premium price for an average SUV. Don't see any reasons to buy Honda not only over Nissan, over any brands.
The Nissan will break down long before the Honda
@@AE86FTS False
To be honest, at least for the US a top end rogue doesn’t have much more features than a top trim CR-V but it actually costs 2000 more, I would say it’s worth sacrificing a couple fancy toys for better resale and reliability. In ten years the Honda will be worth a lot more than the Nissan.
@Odnamor VR30 true, Nissan is crap now. Their Transmission breaks down quick
Honda is more about driving refinement, interior quality and general overall quality. They feel more expensive than the price suggests. I know they are less feature rich vs some competition. Hyundai is way better in terms of tech features. Nissan has better value in terms of features as well
I’d choose the CRV any day.
The CRV in my opinion is overall just the better car. In terms of design, the read end of both cars feels switched. But the CRV’s curved taillights are iconic and known for it, so I’m glad Honda is still keeping that tradition!
What sucks is that removed the rear led turn signals.
Blind Much?
i like, that i don't need premium gas even with that turbo! my best is 38mpg so far!
Finally something affordable
Ahhh, people are so naive to the fact that Nissan is so unreliable. Why do you think they are way cheaper? The tech is great. The interior is also great. But do your research on turbo engines, they fail so often is amazing they still keep selling them. What about the famous Nissan CVT transmissions? It's a nightmare. Honda knows they are more expensive 🫰 but you definitely wont be visiting the dealership for car problems. The price difference is literally... RELIABILITY
Not to pile on BUT a NISSAN mechanic came here and said they are seeing problems with the three cylinder engine block CRACKING and requiring replacement. I read elsewhere that you would be doing good to get 140K miles out of a Nissan Rogue engine. I have 300K on my '08 CRV right now and it's going strong. I'm about to spend $1,000 fixing an oil leak caused by bad mechanics doing oil changes.
My problem is my partner doesn't like the new CRVs. I would prefer the hybrid but it's overpriced and doesn't really get much better MPG on the highway so it seems like a total waste of money.
I drove a friend's Rogue for several hundred miles and was impressed with how it drove and performance. Was considering it for a new car until I read about the engine. Honda has a long long reputation of making great engines. Nissan, not so much.
Love the looks of the rogue! I don’t think Orange stitching on a red car works for me! If they wanted to give it more of a designer look the stitching should match the exterior!
I have a 2021 Nissan rouge platinum 4 cylinder…love it
I'd take the Rogue all day everyday.
Rented the rogue and the suv is really nice, comfy, quick handling. It looks great and you can’t tell it’s a cvt transmission.
The CR-V will last longer, especially compared to the 1.5l 3cyl in the Rogue. However, I think they are both great SUVs
The 1.5 CR-V engine presented problems, this new Nissan engine has prove to have a better performance, eficiency and to be reliable.
@@rafaelg9016 but trans is trash
After taking delivery of ‘23 Rogue SL, I realized that fuel door cannot be locked…not everyone lives in a nice neighborhood and its so easy to tamper with…
I own a Rogue and love the variable compression turbo engine but when the I bought it in 2022 the 2023 CRV wasn't offered yet. I love my Rogue but it has been recalled for a few issues already. Also I wish they offered a hybrid version like the CRV. I would choose the new CRV over the Rogue if I had to buy today.
I really like your comparisons ❤
Hopefully they bring the hybrid next year to N. America. The X-Trail Hybrid drives like an EV and it has great reviews from Europe and Australia. I think the 3 cylinder was really designed as part of a hybrid system.
Auto dimming mirror with a homelink garage door opener on the platinum rouge .
Im a bit confused: so the new CR-V backdoors do not open up to 90 degrees, but the previous model had this feature. And it was a big positive feature which was mentioned all the time… why they changed that?
They do, but not as stretched as the Rogue I wouldn’t say full 90 degrees
@@SamCarLegion You mean on a new version (as in the video) or the previous one? As I said, the previous has the same angle as in the new Rogue, isn’t it?
Sam. This top 2023 gas Nissan Rogue with delivery in Canada comes in at almost $45000. The 2023 Honda CRV EX-L gas model with delivery is $45300.
Of course the Honda Hybrid is more. I agree way more and over priced.
You can not in this review say the advantage goes to Nissan because of price.
Compare both gas models and they are about the same price. That price
comes into the equation in another way- they are both over priced!!
Example. The 23 EX-L Honda is $3300 over the price of the 22 EX-L. Not sure how much Nissan went up.
Resale goes in the CR-V’s favour.
The Nissan transmission problems I hear are improved and the CR-V gas oil delusion problem is fixed now- so Honda says!
Go Ni
@@jpf1978 That is a good price., So with tires you paid about $3000 less than a fully loaded Gas 23 Honda CRV. My point is, Sam can not give the advantage to the Rogue because a Hybrid CRV comes in $7000 more. Compare Apples to Apple not a hybrid orange. You did well. When it is trade in time you will be about even in value on depreciation overall in money put out with the CRV more or less. Then it comes down to personal preference.
I bought the 23 CRV EX-L and with tax paid a whopping $51000 in Manitoba with the pst and gst included. You of course paid taxes over that $43700 coming in for you at just under $50 G's!
Too much for both of us. So why did I pay over $3300 more for this 23 EX-O over it's 22 EX-L price? Because I got $4000 more on my trade than others were offering and It was $1500 over black book (black book is to the dealers advantage as they are using pre-covid numbers).
Oh and I leased for the first time ever. I will pay $186 a month for four years or 48 months. Buy back with tax will be $25000 but I know I can sell for that or more. My plan is to buy it out.
In the mean time I have invested my money. That money isn't doing too well either I must say lol.
Go Ni
I go for honda more quality!
The 1.5L Rogues are all made in Japan.
Not all ..only Platinum trims.
Nissan made really fast cars, all other classes is💩. Honda its Honda! Honda better in everything. Sam has very biased and specific opinion about Rouge.
The reviewer is biased review against honda.
No difference opening the tail gate and no difference with the opening door angle.
Space wise crv is better than rouge “on paper” as per the reviewer
Long story short biased review
Awesome video ty!❤️
You are so welcome!
Honda really missed an opportunity on the CR-V: No HUD, No 360 degree view camera, no ventilated seats, and no panoramic roof.