IIT prof's advice to students for JOSAA Counselling
Вставка
- Опубліковано 24 лис 2024
- Playlist related to JEE/JOSAA counselling: • Advice related to JEE/...
During JOSAA counselling, students face a number of confusing questions or dilemmas like:
Whether to choose a non-circuital department in a higher ranked institute or a circuital department elsewhere?
Whether to take just any seat in an older IIT or to go to some desirable department elsewhere?
Whether to listen to one's heart's desire or to follow the advice of parents, teachers etc.?
Each of these questions have different answers for different students. In this video I discuss some important points that students should consider so that they can arrive at the answers suitable for themselves.
Website: www.facweb.iitk...
GitHub: github.com/jee...
Twitter: / jeevanjyoti
Blog: jchakraborty.w...
Disclaimer: I am a faculty member in the Mechanical Engineering Department of IIT Kharagpur. However, the views expressed in this video are my own and do not necessarily represent those of my Department or my Institute.
#jc #JOSAA #JEE
Who is watching this video in 2024 for Josaa counselling 2024 😊
This is failure of IIT admission system.Students must be admitted without branch allotment. Branch allotment must be done after first year when students get some insight about branches. It is possible as they all study common courses in first year.
But then how will the coaching mafia sell dreams ? Its all a nexus.
Exactly, that's the way it should be
Not even IITs take the lead to bring about a change in branch selection methodology like in the European or American Universities.
Even if they did everyone would still mindlessly chase in the sequence CSE->ECE->EE->ME etc.
Most of the students who get selected are the type that are able to work extremely hard consistently for an externally acquired goal that is not deeply rooted in their brain and are also Intelligent. (This doesn't happen in developed countries because of less population and respectable colleges even at mid-level which is not the case in India) These types never really grew the neural networks required to determine what they want to be. So even if the branch change method is made more flexible it would still be useless and would step back to the current style. Most of the people I know who made it into IITs are just enjoying their time and waiting for the placement day and very understandable because they worked so hard till burn-out and everyone around them congratulated them so much that they think that they have completed life, why would they wonder what to choose between Electrical or Mechanical when they can just go to the website and check for placement stats, how does it even matter if they like to study Advanced Magnetism or Advanced Rotational mechanics? they literally studied any chapter thrown at them for the sake of a future with a high-paying job so why wouldn't placement stats not be the no. 1 priority for them? It would be a illogical to prioritize ones interests at this point
Iam interested in finance related fields.
Shoud I opt for Economics in IITK or IITB
@@SaiKrishna-lb3uf Economics or MnC
Got a Rank of 127 🙏🙏
Luckily discovered your channel at a good time for further support
Wonderful! A big congratulations! Where do you want to join?
@@Prof_JC Confused between wether to take 4 year CSE at IIT Madras ( location disadvantage since I am in Delhi ) or IIT Kanpur , or take a 5 year Integrated Dual Degree CSE at Delhi ( Location wise best + have some seniors i know here )
@@yashrawat5071 your are from mount carmel school, dwarka right? congrats!
@@izlamastfgil5309 yes , thanks
@@Prof_JC sir are there any good IIITs for 27k rank in mains?
Thank you sir, this is eye opener for many parents and students who are getting pushed towards specific branches like computer science just because of money and placements. 😊
Nice video Sir. After following your channel for more than an year, I feel that, perhaps I would have gained more knowledge in all these areas than an average Indian parent. Thank you
And, I must thank you for being absolutely unwavering in your support all throughout the year!
@@Prof_JC it’s my pleasure Sir. Actually lot of learning.
Thank you very much, JC Sir for bringing out this much needed videos🙏
Sir Your advice is really an eye-opener for parents of students cracking competitive exams..most students face the exact problem you discussed in this video whether to go to a lower branch in top colleges or step down to next level colleges for the desired branch...with your guidance we would choose the right path for our children..thank you ...
The main advantage at IIT was the students with many talents and living in a dorm. I spent 5 years as an undergraduate student as an average student, playing bridge most of the time. Did not really know what to do when I graduated and so like most (40 years back) went to USA as a MS student. Again, being an average student did ok academically but did learn a lot about life. Now, I am retired but have done well in career and financially. Note: Not one day did I work as a mechanical engineer even though it was my specialty in school. In short, be curious, passionate about something and you will do well.
Good content....
Teaching is very important wherever a student enters... Good teaching is backbone to the outcome of personality...
I was confused between iit mandi mech and iit jammu electrical before but now I have decided for jammu coz electrical seems much more intresting than mechanical after some research
thank you sir
Yes son.... ee dept. Better thanmechanical
Thank you very much, JC Sir for bringing out this much needed video.. It certainly provides much needed direction for both parents and prospective students.. Thanks from the bottom of my heart
You are most welcome. And thank you for the kind words.
@@Prof_JCsir could you please make a video about what you learn in mechanical engineering
pleaseee
Thank you sir🙏🏽
Please make a video for 'How to do preparation for jee Advanced '
Appreciate your help to share facts and experience about IITs. Really great 👍
Hello Prof ,
Been watching your vids once in a while since Tharun’s video…..i am a BE from Jadavpur University and just wanted to say to my juniors that department doesn’t matter as long as your institution is under like Top 20 in NIRF ranking …i have friends from non Circuital branches who got big tech jobs …also IIT gives sliding unlike JU but still we had a lot of inter departmental courses …keep making videos these are really helpful and eye opening for juniors
bro nirf rankings are an obvious scam dont misguide aspirants, your college is within 20 so u use that arbritary filter to judge institutions
@@yojitkapoor8489obviously prefer government institutions….thats like a given that every aspirants knows that all private institutions except BITS are not that good and they should resort to them as a last option
Thank you so much sir for such a valuable video .
After getting IIT Kanpur Economics i got very excited, have done lot of research about it's curicullum too have also got some interest but at the same time have done around 1 year of coding too, which was at basic level but interesting . I am getting the opportunity to join CS at one of the old and reputated institute of maharashtra COEP .
Before seeing your video , I guess I was being emotional ,so now going with CS . Once again thank you sir !
Thank you very much for sharing your views. Invaluable!
I have done doctorate from NIT DURGAPUR. You are right sir in chemical engineering there is full of maths in Mathematical modeling. My experiment is based on design expert through CCD approach. Also the thesis is full of graphs 📊 based on mathematics.
It is unfortunate that many young students do not realise this!
being general is a crime i did not qualify just by 1 marks😭😭😭
😢😢
Same me also 85 marks😭😭😭😭😭😭
Generals have to pay जजिया to the system in the same way as Hindus have to pay during Mughal era
Bro what's u mains rank
Same with me 76 obc
Thank you Prof. JC, you really addressed the critical problems in JOSAA counselling. It helped very much! Keep making videos!
sir, can you please make video on scope of BS-MS from IISERs.
everything is okay, I have interest but being from a middle class family...money factor worries me...please make a video on it.
I failed to crack IIT but I don't regret at all. I have learnt a lot of things while preparing for JEE and that knowledge will be there with me forever.
Thank you sir for this helpful video. Now I just have one wish, I wish to get mentors like you in the institute where I will be going.
Thank you for thinking in such a mature fashion. Please maintain this attitude. And, I really wish that going forward that your career trajectory will rise higher and higher. All the very best!
Same , but I am very sad .All this learnt very much , gained knowledge is okay to say , but the disappointment , the rage of not getting an IIT , more importantly not clearing the exam you prepared for , is much much more devastating.
App ab kya kr rhe ho mtlb kis college se konsi branch
@@HarshDPatil123ap ab kya kr rhe ho??
Thanks a lot sir
I always wanted to persue a career as a researcher and for the 1st time I have come across a perfect direction for that career
what have you pursued
This video really great for too choose best in which you doing best 😊❤❤
Please help me to choose best branch for me and also suggest good college based on jee advanced cutoff my sc Category rank is 4878 🙏🙏🙏
sir can you please make a brief video about the mechanical eng curriculum
I was thinking of making something along those lines. Let me see; I will think seriously about it.
For performing experiments good knowledge in Chemistry is must. As my father 👨 is scientist in CSIR CIMFR Dhanbad I am excellent in performing experiments therefore my experimental data comes 100% correct. My paper published in best SCI journals.
Thankyou Sir for valuable guidance🙏
A wonderful information video, thanks a lot, Sir
Thank you for the kind words.
i don't know if anybody will believe me or not
the probable confuson of aspirants you discussed in first 2 min of video is the most relatable thing in my life and it is up to 100% recision that i had exactly same doubts, not even a ingle word was not relatable to me, i never though someone who doesn't know me would put up exactly what i was thinking
thanks for the wise advices that pehople don't give even after taking counselling fees
Sir,.Day by day you are looking handsome 😅
Sir, I was wondering if you could share what your views are on differences between branches ECE and other variants like EEE (Electrical and Electronics) and EIE (Electronics and Instrumentation). If someone’s interest is in ECE, how badly off will he be choosing EEE or EIE? ECE in a few positions lower ranked institute or EEE / EIE in slightly higher ones? If you could kindly share your thoughts? In any case, thanks again for your videos on such topics. Very very helpful!
In IITs, there is EE which is EEE actually ( in fact more inclined towards ECE)
Just search their syllabus on the internet see how much difference they have in their syllabus. You will know what to choose.
You know instead of asking cliche questions like this, you can simply see the course structure and electives of the subjects and make up your own mind
Sir what is your opinion on a 5 year program at a more prestigious iit (top 5) vis a vis a 4 year program at a comparatively newer IIT? Especially in mechanical/aerospace where a masters is somewhat necessary for a good career ( r&d career ).
May kindly make a video about the Biotechnology/ Bioengineering/ Biomedical Engineering/Biosciences courses of different IIT. Which IIT Courses is the best for this discipline at present, Sir
IIT Hyd Biomed
aap amit gupta sir wale raushan kumar ho? unacademy?
Thank u sir for such unbiased guidance
General rank -6000 obc rank-1200
Sir, Your views and thoughts are quite logical and thought provoking. On this, I would like to share some thoughts. The basic issue is most Class 12 students have not much aawareness of engg. departments. I have seen many students only corelate Comp. Sc. with Department because they have a curriculum in Class 12 as Comp. Sc. Their mindset is only comp. sc. is the only area to study further. Secondly, they observe in society 90% of his friends are in circuital branch, that is another motivation works behind the mind. Even after getting scope in IIT, NIT non circuital branch they opt for Tire2 or 3 colleges.
You have mentioned some very strong points behind the decisions of the students. I am trying to spread a bit more awareness through these videos.
Ok bro... but u tell...niw.. which department ..has good placement other than circuit branches ...pls tell us
@saivarshaproducts4306 For the average student who are looking for a job immediately after B.Tech, it is best to choose the circuital branches. But circuital also includes Electrical. And Electrical cannot be taught properly in places which don't have proper facilities.
Tq for yoyr reply sir...
@@Prof_JCr even if I have a mild inclination towards a particular branch should I go for it?
I dont know why ece interests me
I am getting mechanical in iits like tirupati,dharwad etc but I don't wish to learn thermo again
I feel kind of hurt to leave this iit seat and pursue ece somewhere else...
Please help sir🙏🙏🙏🙏
Thank you very much Sir. Very helpful indeed...
SIr can you tell a bit about minors. I want to take chemical engineering but would also like mathematics/something related to computer science as a minor
Sir pls pls pls sir make a video on govt scrapping of jee adavnced ,will be exam scrapped
Got rank 9193 in jee adv pls suggest some option
Bro what did you choose?
Sir got 23227 crl rank and 6071 obc rank. Anyways Thank You so much Sir❤❤
Kya loge bhai fir kuch mil rha h kya?
@@udaybhan3698 power of bheem
Sir your advice help us a lot
Sir, I need your guidance. Please let me know about your availability and any suitable mode in which I can reach to you?
I've been offered Mechanical Direct PhD in IIT Kanpur and MS-Research Entrepreneurship in IIT Madras. Please guide me, I'm struck in these options.
Sir I am from medical College and i want to meet you. So, sir could you please tell me how I can meet you ???
Instantly liked the video at 0:55
Unofficial ranking among IIT not on nirf -
• IITB - IITD - IITM/IITK/IITKGP - IITR/IITG- IITHYD - now remaining IIT
Sir u can Only teach Us😢 but fir bhi yahi hoga sir. 😅
I needed this ...tomorrow is the last chance of choice filling b4 mock allotments... but now i need to rearrange my choices
I thought the last date of filling in the choice was June 17 or June 18. Please correct me if I am wrong.
Yes sir ur absolutely right...but 1st mock allotment will be done on the basis of choice filling we made on 14th of june and the 2nd one will be on the basis of changes in choices made by us on 16th june.
9787 rank at 126 marks. Never expected such a bad rank. Speechless.
Bro you are taking new IIts or nit cse
Cutoff is very high this year
A single mark boosts the rank by 200-600 depending on the rank.
What do you plan to do now?
9977 rank at 125.Never expected such a bad rank. Speechless
@@shivanshmehra3365 how did adv go?
Sir, what do you think about professors of top NIT's in biomedical/biotechnology engineering?
Pls reply
secured air 3k i might go for iit kgp mechanical if so im excited to see you sir :)
Thank you. It will be great to meet.
I got 3462, not sure whether will get mech at iit Kharagpur going by previous cut offs
I am watching this for my MHT CET CAP Round admission process.
Sir can you please explain actual difference between computer science engineering and Mathematics & computing
Sir pls make video on chemical engineering in old IIT
General rank-2412 & obc rank-410 , i liked your guidance.....
Bro kia le rhe ho?
Sir really an informative video. Lot of students would get benefitted from this lecture. In this connection I have question which many aspiring students ask.
1) Does location of an IIT plays a factor in shaping a student's career? Or simply it's a myth.To clarify I am giving an example. Suppose a student has an option both at IIT KGP Chemical Engg and also at IIT Delhi Chemical Engg which institute he should select? I personally think this may be a dicy situation since both are old IIT's but one is located in the Capital and other is situated in a semi rural area. Rural Urban divide is a reality in India. Kindly throw some light in this issue.
as an iitian (iit guwahati 3rd year) -> location does play a factor, in kgp the surrounding area is not urban so there is not much to do outside, iitd would be much better as far as college life goes, as far as academics and placement goes, these are both top colleges so your own effort in the next 4 years matters wayy more than the college you select for placements, location only determines your life other than studies
nearly the same exact companies come for placements in all old iits and also the professors are the top researchers in thier own respective field, imo academics in all old iits are very similar after talking to my friends in other iits
Sir is the branch BS+MS(5 yr) in Chemistry (UG) still there in IIT Kgp for 2023? Becuase I am unable to find that course on JoSAA choice filling website but its curriculum is there in IIT Kgp website. Or sir do we have to take the BS degree of 4 years first through JoSAA and then during college we can shift it into the integrated MS one??? Do we have that facility in IIT Kgp sir?
Sir please share how you all teach and guide students at IITs
so that how couldn't make it can follow the same path please sir
Sir your efforts are great
But please keep Video of
short duration
Sir my daughter scored 98.24percentile with 27813 rank
Which nit and branch should be choosen by her
respected sir i got a bad rank in advance ...wanted to know your opnion on nsut and dtu electrical engineering...my inclination is rather towards mechanical... is mechanical at dtu(formerly dce) a good option or i should stick to electrical?
Sir please suggest : iit bhu or iit indore. Sir in many rankings iit indore is ahead while iit bhu is an old institute and it's placement is also better
Sir , I am 12th standard student (2023)
In class 12th , my score is overall 80.2%
But my math is optional subject.
I am a PCMB (physics, chemistry, biology, math) student
The aggregate marks in
Physics + chemistry + math + one language subject + another subject
I got 78%
Can I take addmission into IIT for B. Tech in 2024 ?
No
@@blurofficial4031 why?
Sie which should i choose dtu cs or bhu ceramic engineering.... I have heard a lot about that being at lower brnach at iits many companies would not alow you for their jobs.... At last i don't want just the tag of being called an iitian. I also want job after completing my course i really have no interest in ceramic ... I'm confused someone isa saying take cs and my mom wanted me to be called an iitan..... Please sir help me out
Where you are now
Dear Prof. JC, Thank you for the fantastic effort on your UA-cam videos, they're really very informative for a wide audience. I am particularly interested in the faculty recruitment process at IIT KGP (in your department for example) and wonder if you could shed some light on it. For instance, what goes into the initial shortlisting process - are there any specific criteria that a candidate needs to satisfy to get shortlisted? Next, how is the candidate selected after the faculty seminar - are all the professors who attended asked for feedback (in a specific questionnaire format or as a general impression they've formed of the candidate), do all professors count equally or is there a committee of a few that makes the decision? Finally, what does the final interview consist of - general questions or specific subject knowledge related questions? Would be great if you could answer these questions here or through a video. No resource exists regarding this topic as far as I have seen. Thank you.
@Prof_JC
I think you had also mentioned this as a comment in one of my blog posts, right? If you wish you can email me.
@@Prof_JC Thank you for reply Prof. JC. Yes, I had mentioned this as a comment on your blog as well. Apologies for spamming. I have sent you an email.
Sir
I know that its very hard to believe on which i am saying but trust me that happened to me this year
My JEE mains percentile at first was something and after around 11 days that get changed
I also email NTA regarding this but they said that they were just investigating.....
Also not only this year this happened last year also this happened with many students
I didn't get chance to sit in advance
on my firsy percentile i was selected for advance
Bhai if this is true , you should file a case in high Court
Bhai High court and supreme court ko bhi email likh di koi response nahi aaya
Case filling se bas case saalo tak courts mein chalta rhega
Inke uper tho vaise bhi last year ke same cases file h but kuch hua nahi bus vo saare cases court mein chal hi rhe h
And proof ke naam per bus ek transaction complete ka screenshot h jab mene advance ka form badha tha jab Mera result change nahi hua tha or jab mene result change hone ke baad advance vaali website pe log in Kara then vo invalid show karne laga
Sir, IIT Roorkee Engineering Physics vs IIT Mandi Electrical
Sir, I am getting iitkgp electrical dual /instrumentation and jadavpur university cs.What should i choose between them?Everyone i am asking giving preference to iitkgp over ju.Even iitkgp is my dream college but on the other hand computer science is something i want to study.
Thankyou sir.
What did u choose
Got air 10387 ,EWS-1412 mains-6344 , feeling like a total loser i feel i have wasted my two years, feel like crying right now, IIT was my dream but alas . Hope i would do something good in future, my parents are satisfied with my results but i am not, want to take drop but parents are not in favour, feeling lost .
Just wanted to pour my heart out ,
Please a a video on which departments at iits to choose if your rank is low getting last branches in older iits or electrical in newer iits
Sir is English language be a hurdle in iit /nit 's classrooms
Because i am understanding English and speak English little bit as well but not efficiently like you . Does it may create any problem in asking questions in classes. Please reply
Speaking will also be taught in every IITs and nits.
And in IITs and nits, we have to learn by ourself. This is very much imp and have to face every question by ourself cuz we cant ask doubts and things in classroom. To learn and ask doubts toppers can help you out there in Exchange of money.
Sir, I'm confused with the choice filling. Do I have to give higher preference to the colleges and branches I'm getting based on previous year's cutoff or should I start with top college and top branch?
I have discussed some of these issues in this video: ua-cam.com/video/_fENTnz1Gz8/v-deo.html
@@Prof_JC Thank you, sir!
thankyou sir❤❤
Getting CS in LPU how is it ? Please reply anyone 🙏🙏
Sir i am getting tier 2 nit lower branch vs iet Lucknow cse/ece very confusing what to join
Can you pls help ma
Sir, I wanna pursue research in theoratical physics. Which one would be better IISC BS or IIT ENGINEERING PHYSICS? I'm confused about this because if i want to do a phd after iisc msc abroad or in india will I be able to make my ends meet only by doing a phd?
Even i have the same doubt. I am also confused whether to tzke bs in physics from iit
IISC bs or IIT kanpur bs, don't go for engineering physics, if you are serious about Theoretical Physics. You have to do PhD+postdoc for a faculty position in top institutes. If you want other job then go for engineering physics in IIT Bombay, you will get good job.
@@Jesus-cm6ln Thank you
Sir please make a video on preparatory course at iit
Sir, I wanted to pursue sciences but my parents wouldn't allow.
I am confused among cse at new IITs or ee at IIT Hyderabad or mechanical at IIT Kanpur or civil at IIT Bombay
Sir, based on my rank in advanced I am consider cse at IIT ropar ,computational mechanics in IIT Hyderabad or thinking of CSE at bits pilani, what would be your opinion on this. Which would prove to be better?
Degrade from cse to eee Or ece
PILANI CSE
Cse pilani
IIT Hyderabad/BHU metallurgy vs IIT Bhilai/Jammu EE 😭😭😭
Sir plz say how is the college jalpaiguri government engineering college?
Sir please tell for my son IITBOMBAY ENVIRONMENTAL or IIT DELHI CIVIL OR IIT KANPUR ECONOMICS
sir, can you please guide us on how to move abroad for our bachelor/master's study.
Sir according to you would 5 year CS at IITD be better or 4 year CS at IIT Kanpur? I live in Delhi so would prefer to stay here.
I have exact same question bro
What is sadness? Not qualified from 9 marks
Thanks a lot sir 🙏
Sir, I am considering IIT KGP, Instrumentation Engineering. I do know it is not your dept., but could you perhaps provide some insight and some thoughts about the department? Thank you for such a great video nevertheless.
Thank you. Instrumentation is a specialization within the Electrical Engineering Department. As an undergraduate student, many of the basic courses you will do in the initial years will be common with EE and even ECE and sometimes CS. It can be a very good choice.
@@Prof_JC Thank you so much for your time sir, do you perhaps know a source where I could find out some more about this course?
I have already checked out the course structure and the few details in the website
@@fearmemortals2.084 Best is if you could find some senior student or a recent graduate. But probably this is not a very realistic suggestion! Have you looked into the course structure in some more detail: erp.iitkgp.ac.in/ERPWebServices/curricula/CurriculaSubjectsList.jsp?stuType=UG&splCode=IE&curr_type=NEW. Please click on the individual subject codes to know the details of the various subjects.
@@Prof_JC Oh wow, I actually didn't know about that.
Thank you so very much sir.
THANKYOU SIR
Sir please 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 make the paper easy it's my humble request to you
Hello sir I have secured 2866 rank in jee advanced , should I take energy engineering iit d , engineering physics iit d, or IIT madras mechanical?
Sir i mera state obc card 2018 ka bana hai or central obc card 2023 1st April ka bad ka keya e valid hai jossa ke liye???
Hi prof i just love studying maths my jee mains crl is 32874 and advance 17860
Should I go for nit warangal or nit rourkela mathematics?
Apne kya choose kiya bro???
Sir aap counselling bhi ker vate ho?
Sir can u please throw some light oj applied geology and mining branch of IIT KGP . I am a bit confused . And also how it would be for a female candidate .
sir, i got 162 all india rank general category. im female and wanted to join iisc bs-ms degree. is this a good choice or should i go for cse at iit madras?? thank you
congrats! iisc would be a great choice
Iisc girl!
If you're interested in research.
Go for it!
IISC is the best choice
Congratulations. Just a random question, which state are you from?
thank you for the video sir. I want to get into academics, especially in bio and math. Given the options of BSMS Interdisciplinary Sciences in IIT Dharwad vs IISER Pune, which do you suggest for me to pursue?
I don't have any idea about IIT Dharwad. But the IISERs are a great choice for students who wish to go into research and academia.
@@Prof_JC thank you very much sir
Sir how to choose tht which college is better for same department....on the basis of nirf ranking or their placement records????? I m confused about it ...please help
Just want your honest opinion here. Suppose a student loves math, is passionate and can get a seat for an integrated MSc. But parents say that becoming a professor won't get you the kind of salary that an IT job will, and discourage the student...what do you say? In a way, the student does see the money part as there are software engineers all around living luxurious lives. Please be honest... how's the income of a faculty in a College like IIT Kharagpur? No need to reveal yours but some idea and a realistic view of whether it's enough to support a family in future.
Sir according to my rank in jee mains 2024
I was getting nit surat msc physics,chem branches
is it worth by choosing this branch in concern about placement ?
What's your advice for me ?
I am dropper tooo
Plz help me 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏 about this
Same doubt
Sir just had a doubt specifically about IIT KGP... can we change our branch from bsc to btech after the first year and how easy or difficult is it pertaining to IIT KGP
sir what should i choose iit kanpur chemical iit roorkee chemical iit Guwahati mech i want to go into finance afterwards