@Edith-id4diAnd you called him arrogant and that he looked down on his bandmates when he was just telling the truth. At the worst moment of his life, you made the poor boy feel like garbage.
In my opinion, all five of these young handsome boys did their best in this audition whether they were shy, lacked a bit of confidence or whatever, they hit it on that big screen. Just love them all 😊❤🎉
Harry's charisma looks and the way he presented himself is how you could see he could definitely be a star it's not just about the voice if it would be we would have tons of stars it's crazy how his voice sounded back then compared to now actually none of their voices was incredible compared to some other people on the show
Liam Payne who sang Cry me a River left us in 16th October 2024 He have a big man's voice in this 17 years old . Liam Payne Rest in Peace you're now a little star shining in the sky together on the moonlight. (1993-2024). The world and the music will missed you .
Something tells me Harry practiced his song in a different key and production gave him the original key. Liam definitely had the best audition, even though he was basically mimicking Michael Bublé. Rest in Peace ❤
RIP Liam. you were the voice of many people that was suffering like you from depression and mental issues. Even though you stayed happy through the whole journey and gave everything to us we just couldn't help you at your hard times. I'm deeply devastated by your passing but you will still remain in all of our hearts. Fly high King Rest In Peace 🕊
@@celineconnaugh7861 he was right about experience. he couldn't sing on key in the first song which he got better later on. but if this were someone else, simon would have rejected them after the first song
Love 1D! Niall is my fav he was so confident (and correct) and he had such a great vibe!! Liam was fantastic (the strongest audition imo and I always thought he had the best voice starting out) Zayn had nice riffs Louis reminded me of myself!😊 Harry, isn't he lovely?? His voice certainly was! ♡
He was a special child. I had one so I could spot the difference. That's the reason why he could not fathom the persona in him. How I wish that they could have provided him with a professional help. He may have lived shortly, but for sure he has served his purpose well.❤
Liam Payne, you were the best audition by far. if only you could read all the positive things about you, if only we could have helped you before fame and hate took you that far. you were always my fav, love you always. RIP. always will have a soft spot in our hearts
Seeing Liams family there in the wings while he sang his way through the audition with 4 yes’s!, especially his Mum, how excited and giddy she was for Liam, if only they had known he was only going to alive for another 15 years once in the music industry…… so much love is sent to Liam’s mum, dad and sisters ❤❤❤❤
I love one direction so much because when I was younger I loved their songs so much but didn’t know them well and it’s so sad knowing them now and I feel so bad for Liam it’s just sad how he was ignored by some people
The one thing i got out of this videos is that the judges had such patience and such a great ear ear like.... we'll be honest most of the boys (except Liam RIP) had very mid to absolutely terrible first auditions but they gave them a chance to sing again and let them shine especially niall and harry their second songs were leagues ahead of their firsts and it just blows my mind that the judges listened to THAT and thought hmmm theres something here
Poor louis could not sing clearly Zayn could sing but had no confidence Niall ; average performance but good confidence Harry : below average performance but very good confidence Liam : THE BESTEST AUDITION WITH CONFIDENCE AND CHARISMA
These 5 boys did their very best and well deserved for what they are now..Among the 5, Liam got the standing ovations in their audition in the XFactor..Love you all 1D..
They were so mean to Niall let’s be for real he did an amazing job and he was good as he thought he was. He came prepared let’s hear Simon sing. They were mean to Niall for no reason it was amazing I loved it
This is a prime example that we used in music business class of why marketing is more important than talent. None of their voices were anything more than average. You can see right in the beginning why Simon absolutely thought Harry had potential not because of his voice but because of his looks, charisma and the way he presented himself. He probably immediately thought of what audience he could attract. Basically, the whole concept of One Direction was not about talent; it was the idea of a boy band that was intentionally designed to be mass-appealing and especially targeting teenagers, who respond more to charisma, looks and appearance rather than musical talent.Their songs are catchy and revolve around themes like love and anything that resonates with their audience. Teenagers project their own desires onto the band members and usually have a crush on one of them, which makes the fan connection even more personal and intense. And a strong sense of community forms around the band, extending far beyond the music itself. Such a band, with such a fanbase along with the merchandise basically become a money machine.I think thats the reason they put them together and it worked out better than they'd have imagined.The band members dont have to be really musically talented or creative, although it helps of course.They just need to have something like charisma, looks, confidence and be adaptable and shapeable.That concept has been working for ages.Music might be about talent but music business aint if it would be all about musical talent we would have tons of stars there are so many gifted singers out there.To have a great presence and simply being such a likeable person like Harry is for example is something you cant learn and is also a talent.So dont get me wrong i actually like some of their music but I wouldn't consider it creative and I'm glad they all separately moved on with their lifes and found their own paths.
Wow, Liam (RIP 💔) was the only one who sounded good and that's because he was not pushed through before he had some experience and time to work on it for 2 years. I'm actually surprised that they got pushed through. It was purely their looks because a couple of them didn't have any personality. This is the first time I've seen this. Thank you so much for putting it together. It definitely gives me some insight.
They were not the best singers except for poor liam,even on that island or whatever, but zayn and harry had good tone. I think they had the personality and looks and with all Simons backing and promotion, great witers ..they made it big. They should be grateful that he gave them 1d. Sadly, Liam was too honest and real for showbiz, perhaps being in 1d was not the best for him
to be fair to them, they worked very very hard to improve and it paid off. they were also practically children at the age they auditioned, they have matured loads and so have their voices. I do agree though in terms of having the money and promotion backing the. without that they would never have been successful. but that’s also a double edged sword- look at how traumatised they are from their time in one direction
I hate how people only say he was the best singer after he died. Like no one said that before. It’s actually so sad how quick people can change to look better 😕
based on the first song he did, Harry definitely shouldn't have gone through. but the a cappella rendition of Isn't She Lovely was actually pretty good, one of the best 1D auditions imo. Niall probably only went through because he had a pleasant tone and was cute, kudos to him though, he's put in massive work and is probably only second to Harry in terms of solo music these days
@stefannita3439 yeah Harry's tone is unique, and he had the boldness. Yeah amazing how far Niall came from that audition. Still love Louis voice the most tho. Liam could sing anything but needed to find a sound he could own. His Christmas ballad and teardrops were his best songs and he should have went with that kind of sound
Para mim one direction tinha acabado , mas agora sem o liam acabou definitivamente, já não fará mais sentido, era o meu preferido da banda. Fica em paz liam 💔🤍🖤 tão triste , tão jovem
He got a standing ovation 10 seconds into his audition…RIP one of the best talents of this generation 🕊️
Liam was definitely the best out of all of them, his voice is so powerful. RIP Liam 🕊️
@Edith-id4diAnd you called him arrogant and that he looked down on his bandmates when he was just telling the truth. At the worst moment of his life, you made the poor boy feel like garbage.
@@mirkonaviaclaros3344 erm I did nothing
@@mirkonaviaclaros3344when?
Such a sweet, talented and humble young guy and now he's dead. It's so sad, unbelievable😢
LIAM PAYNE. Best audition of 1D. 💔R.I.P💔
Definitely
😢
😢
😭💔
4twr5wq3ts3tdefsef3td3fs3tr3g😢
In my opinion, all five of these young handsome boys did their best in this audition whether they were shy, lacked a bit of confidence or whatever, they hit it on that big screen. Just love them all 😊❤🎉
Erano ragazzini....Liam era il più TOSTO.. già allora😢❤
Harry's charisma looks and the way he presented himself is how you could see he could definitely be a star it's not just about the voice if it would be we would have tons of stars it's crazy how his voice sounded back then compared to now actually none of their voices was incredible compared to some other people on the show
Harry is a natural showman. He was like that from birth apparently
Liam Payne who sang Cry me a River left us in 16th October 2024 He have a big man's voice in this 17 years old . Liam Payne Rest in Peace you're now a little star shining in the sky together on the moonlight. (1993-2024). The world and the music will missed you .
Even at 14 his voice was amazing
Liam was quite obviously the best singer.
Evet, ses muhteşem
Not anymore 😂
@@shawnn6522 shut the hell up
@@shawnn6522 He passed away, have some decency.
@@janashouman3871 hey listen, this guy was the one to say he was better than everybody else, that’s also rude to say even if he passed away. RIP
Something tells me Harry practiced his song in a different key and production gave him the original key. Liam definitely had the best audition, even though he was basically mimicking Michael Bublé. Rest in Peace ❤
Standing ovation...for liam😢
Forever in my heart One Direction 💝💔
Liam really nailed the audition. Look at the crowd standing and cheering
Siiiii
All the boys Audtion TimeStamps:)
1:05 Harry’s Audtion
5:52 Zayns Audtion
8:22 Liam’s Audition
14:12 Niall’s Audition
20:26 Louis Audition
☺️Thank you☺️
"Please, just give me a chance" just shows how important it was to Louis ❤
The way how much of giggled I came out to louis audition, he is so adorable 😫❤
RIP KID this makes me cry 💔😭💔they’re all Gorgeous and great singers.
liam my dear.
Im gonna miss you and your voice so much. I can not describe how much im gonna miss you.
Rest in Peace, i love you.
😢😢😢
Drugman😂
@@encikstark8590😢
Aww, I miss Liam too.
😭
One Direction is not the same without him.
RIP Liam. you were the voice of many people that was suffering like you from depression and mental issues. Even though you stayed happy through the whole journey and gave everything to us we just couldn't help you at your hard times. I'm deeply devastated by your passing but you will still remain in all of our hearts. Fly high King Rest In Peace 🕊
The last thing Harry lacked was confidence.
❤ He absolutely commanded the stage. Smiling and connecting with the crowd. And several Grammys later and a Vogue cover, Louis should feel stupid
No he had confidence,Zayne lacked confidence!
@@gjnoto1 No? Did you actually read what I said. I said Harry DIDN'T lack confidence.
@@celineconnaugh7861 he was right about experience. he couldn't sing on key in the first song which he got better later on. but if this were someone else, simon would have rejected them after the first song
@@AS-yz2iz aaahhh lol NOW I get it
I like the way Simon trust in all boys ... Simon say Yes of all of them😢
There all voice are Amazing nice one..
They have different voice. Love them all! Liam is one of a very good singer in the entire world!
Love 1D!
Niall is my fav he was so confident (and correct) and he had such a great vibe!!
Liam was fantastic (the strongest audition imo and I always thought he had the best voice starting out)
Zayn had nice riffs
Louis reminded me of myself!😊
Harry, isn't he lovely?? His voice certainly was! ♡
He had the best audition! Niall was awesome!
Neil was so much sweet in all guys
Sleep well my Payno ❤️ you will be missed 🕊️
i just miss all of them together 😿💔 Rip Liam , we love you since forever
liam had something i cant really discribe. too good for this world;( rest easy our payno
He was a special child. I had one so I could spot the difference. That's the reason why he could not fathom the persona in him. How I wish that they could have provided him with a professional help. He may have lived shortly, but for sure he has served his purpose well.❤
It’s so weird seeing them again when Liam is done 😢
Yeah, it is isn’t it
Liam Payne, you were the best audition by far. if only you could read all the positive things about you, if only we could have helped you before fame and hate took you that far. you were always my fav, love you always. RIP. always will have a soft spot in our hearts
His mom looks amazing. Reason Harry is gorgeous. She also paid tribute to Liam ❤
Niall was so adorable ❤ omg
Just casually crying while rewatching Liam's X Factor audition... eugh my heart
when simon said he agreed with someone saying rubbish in the crowd you can tell harry thought he was calling him rubbish 5:00
Teary-eyed when i saw Liam's audition again😢
Me too!😢
Same and he had an amazing voice 🥺❤️
Same 😢😢
Same here
Seeing Liams family there in the wings while he sang his way through the audition with 4 yes’s!, especially his Mum, how excited and giddy she was for Liam, if only they had known he was only going to alive for another 15 years once in the music industry…… so much love is sent to Liam’s mum, dad and sisters ❤❤❤❤
I love one direction so much because when I was younger I loved their songs so much but didn’t know them well and it’s so sad knowing them now and I feel so bad for Liam it’s just sad how he was ignored by some people
Liams voice was amazing and so beautiful he was so cute and adorable watching this makes me really sad now rest in peace liam 🥺❤️
rest in peace liam 🫶🏽
I died it looked like Zayn flipped them off twice 😂 7:23 7:50
Liams audition is SO GOOD
Liam😢....i really miss those days when you were young and very innocent🥺🥺
He still was in his adulthood?
Harry in a band prior Xfactor. Coming with experience .😊
I love Liam hair back then when one judge said you look like Justin Bieber I loved it I am missed it 😢 ❤
Rip😢 liam is one of my favorite , it's confidence, beautiful voice with beautiful face... You are always in our hearts 💕🥰. Goosebumps 😢😢
Harry’s confidence 🥲
The way Simon just said mum normally don’t know the audacity
The only two who could sing well were Liam and Zayn, with Zayn lacking the confidence - and Liam having the full package!
Rest peace Liam Payne you such a good singer ❤🙏😥
This is so mean but when harry started singing hey so sisters i burst out laughing😭 he’s was amazing tho 3:06
Although he had the wrong tune
Yeah, he was OFFKEY 😅
I thought that Harry was good but off key at the same time? 🕰️
Who else agrees with me?
The sparkle in liams eyes 😢
Its still so hard to believe that liam payne has died rest in peace liam
Bro i love seeing zayns audition every time because its so easy to notice the moment he blew nicole away its so beautiful to see
This hit me. Liam, its too soon...
*I adore 1D GOD!!!* ❤
Loui must feel bad right now saying no to harry
He must be
Yea
And that's how one direction came into being ❤❤❤🎉
The one thing i got out of this videos is that the judges had such patience and such a great ear ear like.... we'll be honest most of the boys (except Liam RIP) had very mid to absolutely terrible first auditions but they gave them a chance to sing again and let them shine especially niall and harry their second songs were leagues ahead of their firsts and it just blows my mind that the judges listened to THAT and thought hmmm theres something here
Mental health is such a horrible disease that so many people have these day's but there is help out there guys R.I.P Liam payne
Poor louis could not sing clearly
Zayn could sing but had no confidence
Niall ; average performance but good confidence
Harry : below average performance but very good confidence
Liam : THE BESTEST AUDITION WITH CONFIDENCE AND CHARISMA
Rest in Peace Liam Payne 😢😢
These 5 boys did their very best and well deserved for what they are now..Among the 5, Liam got the standing ovations in their audition in the XFactor..Love you all 1D..
Everytime I hear Doncaster I think of “Oyyyy Donny love!!”
I love One Direction!😊♥️
Sorry man.
Same here, man.
I love One Direction too.
It’s my favourite band.
Liam was the best singer ever sad your gone go will the angels to heaven from.Australia
Not me sobbing in November 2024 when they put Liam through💔
After the funeral :,)(
Mmm😭
They were so mean to Niall let’s be for real he did an amazing job and he was good as he thought he was. He came prepared let’s hear Simon sing. They were mean to Niall for no reason it was amazing I loved it
This is a prime example that we used in music business class of why marketing is more important than talent. None of their voices were anything more than average. You can see right in the beginning why Simon absolutely thought Harry had potential not because of his voice but because of his looks, charisma and the way he presented himself. He probably immediately thought of what audience he could attract. Basically, the whole concept of One Direction was not about talent; it was the idea of a boy band that was intentionally designed to be mass-appealing and especially targeting teenagers, who respond more to charisma, looks and appearance rather than musical talent.Their songs are catchy and revolve around themes like love and anything that resonates with their audience. Teenagers project their own desires onto the band members and usually have a crush on one of them, which makes the fan connection even more personal and intense. And a strong sense of community forms around the band, extending far beyond the music itself. Such a band, with such a fanbase along with the merchandise basically become a money machine.I think thats the reason they put them together and it worked out better than they'd have imagined.The band members dont have to be really musically talented or creative, although it helps of course.They just need to have something like charisma, looks, confidence and be adaptable and shapeable.That concept has been working for ages.Music might be about talent but music business aint if it would be all about musical talent we would have tons of stars there are so many gifted singers out there.To have a great presence and simply being such a likeable person like Harry is for example is something you cant learn and is also a talent.So dont get me wrong i actually like some of their music but I wouldn't consider it creative and I'm glad they all separately moved on with their lifes and found their own paths.
Simon knows when a singer can bring him financial profit
Louis was enjoyable and sweet
Why did I cry after this 😢
Rest in heaven Liam ❤
And Cheryl Cole had his baby.
8:24 we must chant his name to hear us from heaven while he's having a good time with jesus 🕊️🌹
Liam is the perfect pitch ❤
Viendo el comienzo de ellos y duele Liam 🥹🕊️✨🙏🏼
why am i watching this now
Same
One day i'm gonna be there standing on that stage
The STAR was born .... Liam was awesome ... and the rest of the boys
Wow, Liam (RIP 💔) was the only one who sounded good and that's because he was not pushed through before he had some experience and time to work on it for 2 years. I'm actually surprised that they got pushed through. It was purely their looks because a couple of them didn't have any personality. This is the first time I've seen this. Thank you so much for putting it together. It definitely gives me some insight.
Happy to heer you sing and happy to wacting you sing together❤❤❤❤
They were not the best singers except for poor liam,even on that island or whatever, but zayn and harry had good tone. I think they had the personality and looks and with all Simons backing and promotion, great witers ..they made it big. They should be grateful that he gave them 1d. Sadly, Liam was too honest and real for showbiz, perhaps being in 1d was not the best for him
Just shows you don’t need talent to be huge , you need good management and promotion.
to be fair to them, they worked very very hard to improve and it paid off. they were also practically children at the age they auditioned, they have matured loads and so have their voices. I do agree though in terms of having the money and promotion backing the. without that they would never have been successful. but that’s also a double edged sword- look at how traumatised they are from their time in one direction
I’ve watched these type of videos so much and this showed up so I feel forced to watch it😂
RIP LIAM ❤
Liam was born to be a star!
Love You so much, Liam❤
I hate how people only say he was the best singer after he died. Like no one said that before. It’s actually so sad how quick people can change to look better 😕
Yeah, I agree
Liam was the most talented in all of them. change my mind
So sad that we have lost a big star ⭐️💔
If it was on talent alone, Harry and niall shouldn't have gone through. Zayn had potential. Liam was great and Louis was unique
Harry has the best vocals wdym
@raghadammar615 now yes but back then his tone was good but his singing wasn't, at least not in the auditions
based on the first song he did, Harry definitely shouldn't have gone through. but the a cappella rendition of Isn't She Lovely was actually pretty good, one of the best 1D auditions imo. Niall probably only went through because he had a pleasant tone and was cute, kudos to him though, he's put in massive work and is probably only second to Harry in terms of solo music these days
@stefannita3439 yeah Harry's tone is unique, and he had the boldness. Yeah amazing how far Niall came from that audition. Still love Louis voice the most tho. Liam could sing anything but needed to find a sound he could own. His Christmas ballad and teardrops were his best songs and he should have went with that kind of sound
For the talent to shine you need charisma too which he totally had so bam he went viral
12:50 what simon meant was that Liam could take his place right at that chair
Best audition Liam Payne ❤
If it want for katy Perry they will not have been a Niall Horan
I was just thinking that earlier when a Katy Perry song came on
These boys were soooooooooo nervous, but they all got 2 chances from Simon!!.
Liam ❤😭😭
I was about to cry to see lovely Liam in the video and feeling so heartbroken gone too soon my friend never forget you 😭😭😭
Liam tinha a voz mais completa, podia cantar de tudo 💔
We ll miss u liam
Awh Liam did do good ❤🎉
Crying a river over Liam
Niall had the best audition!
Para mim one direction tinha acabado , mas agora sem o liam acabou definitivamente, já não fará mais sentido, era o meu preferido da banda.
Fica em paz liam 💔🤍🖤 tão triste , tão jovem
Harry soooo cute😅
😅Thank you😅