makoto’s smile fading into bloody snow and then the distorted music cutting out to the shot of his mom and that one word: “live”, just everything about this scnee gives me chills every time i watch it
I have a theory that makoto did in fact choose the bad ending but when the fall came The game reset to when he saved before he killed Ryoji. You know like some Undertale stuff
...no. He just had a vision (rather nightmare, as Elizabeth said) of what his alternative universe self did, for every ending in MegaTen Multiverse (or Amala Universe, if you want to get "scientific") is canon. It's just that some spawn sequels while some don't. For now, at least. Heck, some are still curious how Tatsuya from Innocent Sin is doing with (remaining members of) The Masked Circle, or what Demi-Fiend of the True Freedom ending is up to now: did he give up his powers completely? Is he training to best not only The Great Will, but also The True Demon self?
Oh my God and they even played a sadder version of "Memories of you" the song that plays in the end of the good ending. I thought the good ending was already sad enough but this is just painful
*Unfortunately Makoto/Kotone will never got an afterlife. Their souls are stuck being the seal to keep Nyx at bay which means Thanatos a.k.a Ryoji will never be able to guide their soul to the afterlife! ☹️*
exactly, before playing P3, I watched the bad ending and honestly couldnt even tell that it was. Finally when I played the whole game, I watched the bad ending and I died inside from all the character development gone and it’s so bittersweet but terrible. P4 and P5 are in your face about it, P3 however, isnt and it makes it feel 150% worse.
Sweetie Lion yeah in my opinion it’s the worst one. Everyone just forgets what happened and starts to live their lives for the next couple of months. They have no idea that within a month or two, they’ll die yet aigis is the only one that knows about it. Definitely the darkest one
seven You misunderstood what I meant. I know it’s hard to find Izanami, i accidentally got the good ending instead of the true ending lol. I meant the bad ending is very “in your face” with the mood, looks because it looks grim. In P3 and P5’s bad endings, it looks normal which makes it worst. That what I meant, Persona 4 isnt obvious about what’s the right choice or what to do.
K I need to watch the movie ASAP. 3:04 Where the music starts to distort...holy sh*t I hate it but I love it at the same time. It hits the mark spot on. Whoever these guys are writing the story for P3 as well as the guys who made the movie and sound effects are very talented. Also REALLY depressing to see the only time he truly smiles is in the bad ending :,D
I'm sure you have probably already found out by now, but if not, then to answer your question, not quite. This ending is better understood in the game actually. Ryoji tells them that if they kill him righ then and there, it will simply buy them more time to enjoy thier lives since it will stave off nyx for a few more months, while also wiping thier memories clean of everything they had done during the dark hour. Essentially they would go for the next couple of months blissfully unaware that the entire world is about to end....imagine how awful it must have been once nyx finally did descend and nobody knew what the the hell was going on.
@@BleedingDaze01*Ryoji stated that they wouldn't know it happened so I'm guessing the only reason why the sky was forming like that was because of Nyx's avatar trying to reach Nyx from the moon, not herself coming to earth.* *It would be like a meteor crashing down to Earth vs the sun just randomly exploding one day. The meteorite crashing down is Nyx's avatar and everyone can see it happening but there is nothing they can do. Nyx's arrival without the help of Nyx's avatar will be instant and nobody will realize it because they will all be turned into the LOST like how nobody will realize the sun is gone unless they were looking DIRECTLY at it.*
@BitterOrange i think its up to interpretation. From yukaris pov it was as real as it could be but later, Mitsuru comments how it was probably just a hallucination. We don't really know which one is right
@@Joaquin-xq5wo if i remember good, there was a discussion bout it that makes yukari think more about dead and it make her have a bit strength to face the vhs bout her father's original message that fuuka gave to her
It doesn't have an official name because of weird circumstances, so it's just known as Memories of The School (Piano) ua-cam.com/video/0IO5k4k3vQ0/v-deo.html
That's kinda the point. The Shin Megami Tensei series is dark as a whole, it's not meant to be a fun trip it usually includes tons of suffering with demons, evil angels, evil gods and etc. The Persona Series is a sugarcoated spin-off lol
Not really. P5R’s bad ending is everyone living a truly happy life, even if said happy life is an illusion. This ending is being blissfully unaware that the world is going to end in 3 months.
*P5R bad ending is like choosing to be high asf to escape the reality of your bad situation, P3 bad ending is like knowing a meteorite was gonna hit earth but you forgot the date of when that will happen.*
The world ends and every living thing dies isn’t a bad ending, but getting blackmailed into being the accomplice to a serial killer is. Both are definitely horrible, but one’s a bit worse.
Bad ending was killing ryoji By kiling ryoji the mc erase everyone memories except aigis and postponed the fall so what the mc did is just erase their memories so their don worry about their death
![Persona 3 [ペルソナ3] funny scene - The secret side of Shinjiro Aragi [ENG SUB]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Nrh8anV3MSY/mqdefault.jpg)
Honestly the most impactful scene in the movie. This is the perfect way to understand what the bad ending really is.
THEY ALL FUCKING DIED
makoto’s smile fading into bloody snow and then the distorted music cutting out to the shot of his mom and that one word: “live”, just everything about this scnee gives me chills every time i watch it
I have a theory that makoto did in fact choose the bad ending but when the fall came The game reset to when he saved before he killed Ryoji. You know like some Undertale stuff
Sad
...no. He just had a vision (rather nightmare, as Elizabeth said) of what his alternative universe self did, for every ending in MegaTen Multiverse (or Amala Universe, if you want to get "scientific") is canon. It's just that some spawn sequels while some don't. For now, at least. Heck, some are still curious how Tatsuya from Innocent Sin is doing with (remaining members of) The Masked Circle, or what Demi-Fiend of the True Freedom ending is up to now: did he give up his powers completely? Is he training to best not only The Great Will, but also The True Demon self?
Persona 4: it's snowing!!
Persona 3: it's snowing...
Persona 5?
@@namang2956 does it snow in Persona 5?
@@knightcat2726 does scramble count?
@@namang2956 I've only played the original version from 2017
@@knightcat2726 ok. Btw, does it rain in P3?
The earrape made me laugh when I watched this for the first time
It's also very similar to a very loud minecraft theme
@@sartexir9285 or a ytp
I hate you so much ahahahahhaa
@@sartexir9285 my favorite part is hearing the word, "Live." and seeing Makoto's reaction.
Bro XD
3:45 Elizabeth’s just randomly hanging out up there, what a legend
I love your videos Heavenly! Keep up the great work!
Elizabest.
lol nice seeing you here
-
She needs Makoto to take her on a trip to McDonald’s for their chicken shaped nuggets
Oh my God and they even played a sadder version of "Memories of you" the song that plays in the end of the good ending.
I thought the good ending was already sad enough but this is just painful
Neat right?
Memories of the school
Aaand it gets all screwy near the end...
...epic, huh?
bro when i first saw this scene i didn’t realize that was the persona summoning sfx and i genuinely thought makoto just fucking shot himself
it made a lot more sense when i watched a playthrough proper but it was still a very confusing 2 minutes
@@mogfoil Same Thing Happened with me haha😂
In the bad ending, only Aigis has the Memories of You.
In the true ending, everyone shares their memories of you as you pass on into the afterlife.
Memories of youuu!!
*Unfortunately Makoto/Kotone will never got an afterlife. Their souls are stuck being the seal to keep Nyx at bay which means Thanatos a.k.a Ryoji will never be able to guide their soul to the afterlife! ☹️*
3:00 Makoto smiling and looking happy just makes this whole scene even more sad.
Lad was depressed for a full decade now when he's finally happy he must forget about it.
Dang I wanna play this so bad
Damn, the earrape scared me, as if telling us their eventual fate in the bad ending
Can we talk about how eerie Ryoji's smile is?
This is why i think the bad ending to p3 is the best bad ending in all of persona. It may not look bad but its what happens after and it hurts
exactly, before playing P3, I watched the bad ending and honestly couldnt even tell that it was. Finally when I played the whole game, I watched the bad ending and I died inside from all the character development gone and it’s so bittersweet but terrible. P4 and P5 are in your face about it, P3 however, isnt and it makes it feel 150% worse.
Sweetie Lion yeah in my opinion it’s the worst one. Everyone just forgets what happened and starts to live their lives for the next couple of months. They have no idea that within a month or two, they’ll die yet aigis is the only one that knows about it. Definitely the darkest one
ARAnime P5R’s bad ending was similar to P3 in a way, but it doesnt come close to the feeling that P3 gets. P4 it’s in your face about it though.
@@sweetiethelion3430 golden isn't in your face about finding izanami
seven You misunderstood what I meant. I know it’s hard to find Izanami, i accidentally got the good ending instead of the true ending lol. I meant the bad ending is very “in your face” with the mood, looks because it looks grim. In P3 and P5’s bad endings, it looks normal which makes it worst. That what I meant, Persona 4 isnt obvious about what’s the right choice or what to do.
This gave me too many mixed feelings and made me feel uneasy, and that last part eerie as hell.
Perfectly executed.
The gasp and Makoto's heavy breathing is a nice touch.
So did Elizabeth give him the vision of the potential future or was it Makoto?
K I need to watch the movie ASAP.
3:04 Where the music starts to distort...holy sh*t I hate it but I love it at the same time.
It hits the mark spot on. Whoever these guys are writing the story for P3 as well as the guys who made the movie and sound effects are very talented.
Also REALLY depressing to see the only time he truly smiles is in the bad ending :,D
"I've made a terrible mistake."
Is that a team four star reference
"OhOhOhOh I mAdE a TeRrIbLe MiStAkE" That's you.
- Aegis
So when Ryoji said he would give them a few months before the end... it was literal. From the looks of it, only the SEES were left alive. Is that it?
I'm sure you have probably already found out by now, but if not, then to answer your question, not quite. This ending is better understood in the game actually. Ryoji tells them that if they kill him righ then and there, it will simply buy them more time to enjoy thier lives since it will stave off nyx for a few more months, while also wiping thier memories clean of everything they had done during the dark hour. Essentially they would go for the next couple of months blissfully unaware that the entire world is about to end....imagine how awful it must have been once nyx finally did descend and nobody knew what the the hell was going on.
@@BleedingDaze01*Ryoji stated that they wouldn't know it happened so I'm guessing the only reason why the sky was forming like that was because of Nyx's avatar trying to reach Nyx from the moon, not herself coming to earth.*
*It would be like a meteor crashing down to Earth vs the sun just randomly exploding one day. The meteorite crashing down is Nyx's avatar and everyone can see it happening but there is nothing they can do. Nyx's arrival without the help of Nyx's avatar will be instant and nobody will realize it because they will all be turned into the LOST like how nobody will realize the sun is gone unless they were looking DIRECTLY at it.*
Is nobody gonna talk about how Yukari is in the hospital? After starving herself, no less?
Spoiler:
In movie her persona gone berserk and tried to choke her to death because she was too scared
@@bobanfrombangladesh, that was a lucid dream she had
She starts to have the same symptoms as Shinjiro because she started to wish that she was dead.
@BitterOrange i think its up to interpretation. From yukaris pov it was as real as it could be but later, Mitsuru comments how it was probably just a hallucination. We don't really know which one is right
@@Joaquin-xq5wo if i remember good, there was a discussion bout it that makes yukari think more about dead and it make her have a bit strength to face the vhs bout her father's original message that fuuka gave to her
The earrape is so scary wtf
ここ泣いたわ
段々とディストーションがかかって歪んでいく演出はすごい
2:58 the moment everything ended....
Let Makoto live, but the vision Future see what happens from your heart.
3:23-3:37 me whenever I ponder the meaning of life.
Genius way to show the bad end in the movie, though I'm not sure which bad end I find sadder, the game's or the movie's
This movie gave me pain.... all kinds of pain
Mokoto's smile... There is still any faith on humanity
Wtf MOkoto
Bro, I'm really crying ...
Anyone know the remix of Memories of the School that plays just before Makoto wakes up?
I wish, but sorry I dont
Memories of the school
@@Raspygrain ok
@@Erkien9800 ho vinto
It doesn't have an official name because of weird circumstances, so it's just known as Memories of The School (Piano)
ua-cam.com/video/0IO5k4k3vQ0/v-deo.html
It's a CRIME this never got dubbed.
The bad ending that everyone would want
I like that in this scene everyone is still friends. In the game they barely know each other.
Wish they showed how the fall would've looked like
Thank You
Is it bad to say that I laughed my ass off at the earrape, I get what they were going for it’s just I find earrape very funny
i wish they put this scene in p3 reload
The lack of music makes sad
There's no good ending in this game....
True, only a better one
What if in the Movie's Bad Ending, the world dies right as they took that picture? Compared to the game where it ends while singing Karaoke?
I feel like they kinda implied that, since that's when all the blood-colored snow started falling
*I mean Ryoji DID say they will die before spring came and it's still snowing while that was happened. . .*
Don't ironically these bad ending combines with ost velvet room,want or not is final good same this
There is nothing wrong if you want to look away from the harsh reality.
Blud thinks he's maruki 💀
*Wrap it up, Ryoji. We know it's you!*
What's the song that plays in this scene?
Memories of the school
unknown guy with earape
ua-cam.com/video/4eCjannOhdw/v-deo.html
'Heart wavers' from persona 3 movie
音割れ版キミの記憶
やめちくり～
みみっちいこと言うとこれは「キミの記憶」じゃなくて「学園の記憶」
Who was the one that said “Live”?
The protagonists mother.
Every ending have someone dies wtf persona i really love the persona series but the endings are just dark
That's kinda the point. The Shin Megami Tensei series is dark as a whole, it's not meant to be a fun trip it usually includes tons of suffering with demons, evil angels, evil gods and etc. The Persona Series is a sugarcoated spin-off lol
@@mementomori3736 oh ok atleast they make persona 4 happy and persona 5 cool
Well. Even in P5 Royal still uncertain if Akechi is really alive or not
If someday its confirmed that he's really dead.
So. Yeah someone always die.
@@kirunashi6862 Persona 4 got a lot of bad endings though
@@veo1053 at least they are good endings not like persona 3
was this scene's soundtrack ever released? I can't find it anywhere :(
yeah i think on Spotify! search Persona OST
i dont know the whole name of the song but all the games song are there
@@LastGhost12 yeah, it's "Memories of School" I think. The problem is that I can't find this version.
@@Garmagic2yFhenrakh9 sorry man, I have no clue where to find it then.
ua-cam.com/video/4eCjannOhdw/v-deo.html
The song suddenly became earape
Wait . this happens when you choose to kill pharos right ?
/ryoji* but yup 👍
@@shishiorins ryoji and pharos are the same person
@@shishiorins*Ryoji is the pokemon evolution of Pharos*
Similar to p5r bad ending
Not really. P5R’s bad ending is everyone living a truly happy life, even if said happy life is an illusion. This ending is being blissfully unaware that the world is going to end in 3 months.
*P5R bad ending is like choosing to be high asf to escape the reality of your bad situation, P3 bad ending is like knowing a meteorite was gonna hit earth but you forgot the date of when that will happen.*
This isn't bad ending. If what we call bad ending is like persona4 "good bye mr accomplice"
and also see how nanako dies
literally *everyone dies* - I dunno what you define as a bad ending but if that's not a bad ending in your book, you may wanna see a therapist
You probably didnt understand the full context or play the game
The world ends and every living thing dies isn’t a bad ending, but getting blackmailed into being the accomplice to a serial killer is. Both are definitely horrible, but one’s a bit worse.
Song?
ua-cam.com/video/4eCjannOhdw/v-deo.html
Is this a dream sequence in the movie im confused
More or less, yeah
@@hamsteralt thank you I appreciate it
Kinda , Makoto Yuki saw into another universe where he chose to kill Ryoji
Minecraft earrape
Good ending Kill ryoji
True ending sacrifice to save the world but all ending is 😭
Bad ending was killing ryoji
By kiling ryoji the mc erase everyone memories except aigis and postponed the fall so what the mc did is just erase their memories so their don worry about their death
That was not a good ending. The good ending was Minato dying.
@@ihavenonamestilldonthaveon8970 hes technically not dead
He is. His soul is elsewhere and he physically died
Youd know from playing The Answer
@@mrsgamer9218 He is dead, but his soul cannot go back to the sea of souls to reincarnate.
"bad"
It is bad though
this comment would apply to one of the ending in p5 royal for sure.
no persona 5 pc :(
It’s coming soon
@@xv1thanatos956 it came out