@@MrLAntrim well, right now is 10:50 pm here in Guadalajara, México, but 2020 will arrive soon. So !!!! Happy new year !!! New goals !!! New probes !!! New level in German !!!hahahaha. Big hug for you and your family !!!
I can’t seem to find examples, including this video, that shows the word order order when there are also adverbs in the sentence. I’ve seen claims that all adverbs come before the objects, between indirect and direct, and some say after both objects. And considering adverbs have their own order TaKaMoLo, hopefully the adverbs as a group at least stay together and are not split by the objects. Do you have any links to examples that include both objects and adverbs in the sentence. One easy to memorise sentence that includes one of everything would be really helpful (I am aware that adverbs can come before the verb to stress them). Thanks.
This video does have some pretty simple examples, which makes it lack what you are looking for. Let me try to provide that here instead. 1. The order of TeKaMoLo (Temporal, Kausal, Modal, Lokal) is correct, but only time can come before an object and even then only the direct object. All of the other adverbs/prepositional phrases go after the objects. Example: Meine Mutter (S) kauft (V) meinem Bruder (I.O.) morgen (Te) einen Hut (D.O.) für seine Glatze (Ka) mit ihrer Münzensammlung (Mo) vom Einkaufszentrum (Lo). 2. You can move the time to the front of the sentence, but that moves the subject to the other side of the verb. The rest of the sentence stays in the same order. Morgen kauft meine Mutter meinem Bruder einen Hut für seine Glatze mit ihrer Münzensammlung vom Einkaufszentrum. If you want a more in-depth explanation of this, this article is pretty good: www.fluentu.com/blog/german/german-sentence-structure/ I'll add this topic to my list of video ideas, as German word order is often requested, but no one has really said exactly what about word order they want to know until now.
Hallo Herr Antrim,vielen Dank! I do have one question though,..... Is there a rule when using Modall verbs, Sie können mir vertauen/Ich betrug Sie nie. The mir in first sentence is Dative?
"Im" is a contraction of "in" and "dem". "In" is a preposition and as such has no bearing on the direct vs indirect object conversation. There is no indirect object in that sentence. Only a direct object (einen Hund) and a prepositional phrase (im Wald).
Ihn is referring to a masculine noun as the direct object of the sentence. It is not always him. In this sentence it is just a masculine thing, not a person, so I used the translation "it" instead. This is also illustrated by the use of "dem" in front of "Schüler", as the student is receiving the "ihn" in the sentence.
why this sentence doesn't take dative, "Ich mag dieses T-shirt fuer dich"? here fuer dich should take dative. At the same time, I know fuer is an accusative preposition. PLEASE ASSIST!
There is nothing in that sentence that would require the dative case. The verb simply takes a direct object (dieses T-Shirt), which is accusative. The preposition "für" requires the accusative case too. There is nowhere to put the dative case in that sentence.
Learn German with Herr Antrim kein Problem, es macht nichts. Sie haben perfektes Englisch, Sie sind beneidenswert. Ich habe doch (oder noch?) eine Frage: warum so wenige Ansichten, obwohl Sie ein Lehrer sind und so viele Abonnenten haben? Ich sehe andere ‘Deutsch-Videos-creators’ , die viel weniger vorbereiten sind und doch viele views haben. Vielleicht Anzeige würde helfen? (Entschuldigung für mein Deutsch, ich bin Anfänger, ich will sie zu verbessern)
![German Word Order - Part 4: Direct & Indirect Objects - A1/A2 [with Jenny]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d6hHYEtG77A/mqdefault.jpg)
Practice what you learned in this video with a worksheet from my website: www.germanwithantrim.com/product/word-order-with-direct-indirect-objects/
One of the best German lessons I have ever had!
Many thanks from Brazil!
I'm glad you enjoyed it. Let me know if there is anything else I can do to help.
Ein sehr hilfreiches Video...Es gibt viele Beispiele bzw. Fälle worauf man achten soll...
Gut gemacht...
Danke Ihnen, Herr Antrim... 🌹
Danke. Es freut mich, dass Ihnen dieses Video gefällt.
Diese Video ist ein grösses Geschenk für das Neues Jahr!
Sorry if it’s wrong, but thank you for the video!
Richtig wäre:
Diese(s) Video ist ein gr(o)ẞes Geschenk für das neue() Jahr...
👌
Danke, Barakat. Genau das wollte ich auch sagen. 👍
I always love your videos. Thank you for everything you put into them. Have the happiest New Year.
Thank you very much. Happy New Year to you, too. Guten Rutsch ins neue Jahr.
still watching whenever i need to remind these thanks much
Thank you for all the effort you put in your videos. You are a great teacher ¡¡¡ have a great day ¡¡¡
Thank you so much. I hope your new year is off to a great start, too.
@@MrLAntrim well, right now is 10:50 pm here in Guadalajara, México, but 2020 will arrive soon. So !!!! Happy new year !!! New goals !!! New probes !!! New level in German !!!hahahaha. Big hug for you and your family !!!
I can’t seem to find examples, including this video, that shows the word order order when there are also adverbs in the sentence. I’ve seen claims that all adverbs come before the objects, between indirect and direct, and some say after both objects. And considering adverbs have their own order TaKaMoLo, hopefully the adverbs as a group at least stay together and are not split by the objects. Do you have any links to examples that include both objects and adverbs in the sentence. One easy to memorise sentence that includes one of everything would be really helpful (I am aware that adverbs can come before the verb to stress them). Thanks.
This video does have some pretty simple examples, which makes it lack what you are looking for. Let me try to provide that here instead.
1. The order of TeKaMoLo (Temporal, Kausal, Modal, Lokal) is correct, but only time can come before an object and even then only the direct object. All of the other adverbs/prepositional phrases go after the objects. Example:
Meine Mutter (S) kauft (V) meinem Bruder (I.O.) morgen (Te) einen Hut (D.O.) für seine Glatze (Ka) mit ihrer Münzensammlung (Mo) vom Einkaufszentrum (Lo).
2. You can move the time to the front of the sentence, but that moves the subject to the other side of the verb. The rest of the sentence stays in the same order.
Morgen kauft meine Mutter meinem Bruder einen Hut für seine Glatze mit ihrer Münzensammlung vom Einkaufszentrum.
If you want a more in-depth explanation of this, this article is pretty good: www.fluentu.com/blog/german/german-sentence-structure/
I'll add this topic to my list of video ideas, as German word order is often requested, but no one has really said exactly what about word order they want to know until now.
@@MrLAntrim That's great. Thank you very much.
Hallo Herr Antrim,vielen Dank! I do have one question though,..... Is there a rule when using Modall verbs, Sie können mir vertauen/Ich betrug Sie nie. The mir in first sentence is Dative?
The "mir" in that first sentence is dative because of the dative verb "vertrauen". The modal is not relevant for the case structure.
@@MrLAntrim Makes sense. Love the master class videos BTW!
At 5:23, Why is it "Er findet einen Hund im Wand" instead of "Er findet im Wand einen Hund" (According to the direct and indirect object rule)
"Im" is a contraction of "in" and "dem". "In" is a preposition and as such has no bearing on the direct vs indirect object conversation.
There is no indirect object in that sentence. Only a direct object (einen Hund) and a prepositional phrase (im Wald).
@@MrLAntrim okay, I got the point here. Thanks!
Hello Sir ,
Ich gebe ihn dem Schuler
ihn mens him but you translated as it shoud be ihm as per my understanding please confirm i'm confused
Ihn is referring to a masculine noun as the direct object of the sentence. It is not always him. In this sentence it is just a masculine thing, not a person, so I used the translation "it" instead. This is also illustrated by the use of "dem" in front of "Schüler", as the student is receiving the "ihn" in the sentence.
Danke schon! I'm from india beginning to learn Deutsch
Glad to have you on board. Let me know if there is anything I can do to help you on your German learning journey.
Where is the genitive case?
This video is about direct (accusative) and indirect (dative) objects. For genitive, click this link. ua-cam.com/video/Rli3lucRUU8/v-deo.html
why this sentence doesn't take dative, "Ich mag dieses T-shirt fuer dich"? here fuer dich should take dative.
At the same time, I know fuer is an accusative preposition. PLEASE ASSIST!
There is nothing in that sentence that would require the dative case. The verb simply takes a direct object (dieses T-Shirt), which is accusative. The preposition "für" requires the accusative case too. There is nowhere to put the dative case in that sentence.
@@MrLAntrim okay, I understand now. Thanks!
5:49 you read "sie" instead of "ihr" 🤔
Whoops. You are completely correct. I'm not sure what I was thinking there. Thanks for pointing it out.
Learn German with Herr Antrim kein Problem, es macht nichts. Sie haben perfektes Englisch, Sie sind beneidenswert. Ich habe doch (oder noch?) eine Frage: warum so wenige Ansichten, obwohl Sie ein Lehrer sind und so viele Abonnenten haben? Ich sehe andere ‘Deutsch-Videos-creators’ , die viel weniger vorbereiten sind und doch viele views haben. Vielleicht Anzeige würde helfen? (Entschuldigung für mein Deutsch, ich bin Anfänger, ich will sie zu verbessern)
Nicht alle wollen jedes Video sehen. Ich bezahle für keine Anzeigen. Ich möchte nicht dafür bezahlen.
He talks way too fast. 😢