@@rockeye i can't say i agree there, i hear soul all over the place in his playing. not to mention hes younger than Derek Trucks and he's already this good? Dudes a beast
Mad quest vibes. Hard to really pin point a stand out talent here, the group as a whole slayed every beat on this masterpiece. I see this as a "If Pink Floyd Came out in 2024" type of thing.
Whole lot of Floyd fans holding their breath watching a band launch this song. Half way through the slide bit....big smile on my face. Amazing guys 😊.... had to be a blast to hear yourselves as well 😂
Shoutout to Chad Collins on drums! The guitar playing is insane, but the drums have a perfect vibe of ghost notes while still honouring the original! Awesome guys 🙌
Absolutely stunning… Pink Floyd is likely my favorite band of my entire life. I am hypercritical of covers, and so too is the rest of the world. Personalizing a Floyd song is mighty dangerous territory, especially one with vocals that literally can NOT be duplicated. The bar is impossibly high, and the penalty for failure is swift & severe. Having said that, this is the most amazing arrangement of a PF cover I have EVER heard. I am in AWE !!!!!! Thank you all for an amazing 9 minutes....
couldn't have worded it any better. You either do Floyd note for note or you stay far away from it. This challenges every bit of that, especially replacing arguably the most infamous lyrical performance ever yet absolutely hitting it out of the park.
When the break occurred and Dylan came in with the slide rendition of the vocal part at 1:43... The hair on my arms and back of my neck stood straight up...goose bumps bro....OUTSTANDING.
I come here expecting amazing stuff from Rhett and Dylan so can we talk about the rhythm section? Holy crap! Makes me want to practice! Damn fine playing!
Dylan is a phenom and I’m convinced will be recognized soon as the best slide player in the world. That’s not disrespect for Derek T. and other notable players. Dylan’s hybrid playing is just on a different realm…his melodic choices simply fit the song perfectly.
Awesome! You should get Deacon Knight back together, add Dylan to the band and make some more great music. I'm sure I'm not the only one who would love that.
It's one thing to see players you love on UA-cam. Can you imagine the feelings everyone had getting to experience each other for the first time? Dylan's respect and appreciation for Rhett and vice versa are the things inspiration are made of.
Absolutely Amazing! As a Pink Floyd fan & my FAVORITE band, Ever...I'm Extremely hesitant when I see other bands cover Floyd tunes & most don't due Floyd's music justice. That being said - Love this cover & Y'all knocked it outta the park! Well done 😊
Yeah, covers make me wince 9 times out of 10… generally in good hands with Nashville musicians, though! If it’s Nashville people I tend to watch because i’m happy 9 times out of 10.
Rippin’ it! Really enjoying the new project, recording together live. Takes guts but that’s where the real magic happens. Wishing you guys loads of the magic in 2024.
Wow, that was so awsome. No safety net, no editing, just laying down the track. Tight (by timing means) and loose (in improvisational freedom) at the same time. So amazing. Looking forward to the coming episodes of this series.
Using your platform to elevate an incredible player and giving us one of I hope a bunch of cool performances, is really putting some good into the world. Respect.
What a kick ass tribute, in a completely unique style. Doing such an iconic vocal piece on slide is genious... the ability to curve around notes with the added raw edge of that prs, sweeet
Pretty incredible, Dylan will go far in this music world and will certainly benefit from your help and guidance. I can't imagine what keys and vocals mught sound like with this band. Well done. Love the one take live to tape approach.
I've not heard of Dylan before. I'm halfway through listening to this video and I'm already a fan. Going to be looking for more of his stuff. Thanks Rhett for bringing him to my attention!
Wow, just incredible. This has been one of my all time favorite songs since I first heard it many moons ago. You guys are absolutely KILLING! If this what’s in store for fans of this channel, then the “live to tape” idea will definitely be one of the best things on UA-cam. And to pick Great Gig in the Sky as the first piece took some serious balls!😂 Looking forward to seeing what else ya’ll have to offer. 🤘🏻
Main Squeeze did an amazing cover of this song a couple years ago, and I wasn’t sure if anyone could come close to it. You guys absolutely crushed this!!! Congrats Rhett, Dylan and gang on an amazing track!!
The clip ends with “You guys were killing in my ears!” Damn right! I watched the video twice I just didn’t have enough… Simply delightful! The execution is crazy good, the sound is awesome, I love hearing the room in the snare, it really gives a live feel to the recording. The dynamic is there as well, not too compressed. You guys are killing it! We need more of these… very inspirational, I’ll go grab my guitar now :) thank you!
This is great - I love to hear talented musicians put they own inventive spin on great songs. But, going back to the composers of any great song, no matter what genre or century, I find it fascinating to try and understand what they first heard in their minds to put together such an amazing composition that would be enjoyed throughout the ages. A Massive thank you to the composers and a massive thank you to guys like this for keeping these great pieces at the forefront of us the listeners who can only dream of having such talent. Keep it going and keep growing.
This formula is GOLD! You and Dylan together are magical and compliment each other perfectly. The arrangement was on point. Not too close and not too far from the original. I was mesmerized from start to finish and couldn't take my eyes and ears off this. Would love to see this project grow into something that could be compiled into an album.
The only issue I had with the original was that it wasn’t long enough. I wanted more. This scratched that itch and I would buy this on iTunes in a heartbeat. Excellent work. Also hearing the original vocal melody at the start of when Dylan comes in, really makes you appreciate how she used her voice as an instrument (as per instructed by DG). But my god, that has to go down as one of the best vocal performances ever recorded, and this has done it some serious justice 🎉
Plot twist! I was totally not expecting Dylan to be in your basement studio. I figured he did his take over yours at home. Way cool! Glad to see you guys collab with Dylan because he’s a force. I hope to see more of Dylan and you guys doing stuff!
This is one of the best ideas I've seen on the internet. This makes me, and I'm sure tons of people feel so much more confident. Thank you for this. And Happy New Year! 🤘🏼🍻
Great playing by all. Have you all been practising together? I'd like to see a short follow up video discussing how it got made/arranged, how it was mixed and if anyone was unhappy or ecstatic about any parts.
![Allman Brothers - Whipping Post [Live To Tape]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/7bwgRzq64FE/mqdefault.jpg)
![Allman Brothers – Whipping Post [Live To Tape]](/img/tr.png)
Dylan has the same intensity and emotion as Duane and Derek, but he sounds 100% like himself. Unreal talent
That's an amazing tone he gets
Great tone, great phrasing. Also Chad Collins destroying it on drums. Pocket is unreal.
also, Rhett your playing always reminds me of why i continue to pick up a guitar. you always look and sound like you're having fun. Great stuff!
He’s got the sound and licks but lacks the soul. He can definitely plays circles but they are empty.
Derek plays less with way more soulful punch.
@@rockeye i can't say i agree there, i hear soul all over the place in his playing. not to mention hes younger than Derek Trucks and he's already this good? Dudes a beast
Those birds on the PRS didn't even know what hit'em. Incredible playing by everyone. More of this please.
Really ❤
Mr Smith would most definitely approve.😎
Everyone rightfully giving Dylan lots of credit, but let’s not overlook the drummer laying it DOWN! Love his fills and pocket
The bassist is also good. They are all incredible. I was captivated by this cover
@@jesusa_ikher Agree, everyone crushed it!
Mad quest vibes. Hard to really pin point a stand out talent here, the group as a whole slayed every beat on this masterpiece. I see this as a "If Pink Floyd Came out in 2024" type of thing.
Dylan's entrance literally made me go WOW. Goosebumps. Just like the first time I heard Dark Side.
More like Dark Slide of the Moon
I literally just wrote that I got goosebumps too, before I even read your comment.
SAME!
I really hope this new series is gonna be a main stay on your channel. This is incredible!
So cool, who is your drummer?
Couldn't agree more!
One word for you, Rhett - more 🙂 Great to see Dylan playing here!
Absolutely second this!!
That's the plan!
Whole lot of Floyd fans holding their breath watching a band launch this song. Half way through the slide bit....big smile on my face. Amazing guys 😊.... had to be a blast to hear yourselves as well 😂
I was like who is he gonna have sing this shit??? Then I had my fuckin face melted by that slide hahah
Shoutout to Chad Collins on drums! The guitar playing is insane, but the drums have a perfect vibe of ghost notes while still honouring the original! Awesome guys 🙌
Chad is amazing, subdued perfection..
Yes! That was a great performance!
So tight and locked in. Would kill to have a drummer like that to play with
No doubt! @@gibbysg8143
Dylan's playing is packed with original and cool ideas, like Robben Ford's. Repeated listens are rewarding.
Absolutely stunning…
Pink Floyd is likely my favorite band of my entire life. I am hypercritical of covers, and so too is the rest of the world.
Personalizing a Floyd song is mighty dangerous territory, especially one with vocals that literally can NOT be duplicated.
The bar is impossibly high, and the penalty for failure is swift & severe.
Having said that, this is the most amazing arrangement of a PF cover I have EVER heard.
I am in AWE !!!!!!
Thank you all for an amazing 9 minutes....
So true
couldn't have worded it any better. You either do Floyd note for note or you stay far away from it. This challenges every bit of that, especially replacing arguably the most infamous lyrical performance ever yet absolutely hitting it out of the park.
When the break occurred and Dylan came in with the slide rendition of the vocal part at 1:43... The hair on my arms and back of my neck stood straight up...goose bumps bro....OUTSTANDING.
I come here expecting amazing stuff from Rhett and Dylan so can we talk about the rhythm section? Holy crap! Makes me want to practice! Damn fine playing!
Fantastic work all!! Beautiful playing
This is the antithesis of how the Internet approaches music. I freakin love it!!!! Your always inspiring, Rhett. Happy New Years and thank you.
Dylan is a phenom and I’m convinced will be recognized soon as the best slide player in the world. That’s not disrespect for Derek T. and other notable players. Dylan’s hybrid playing is just on a different realm…his melodic choices simply fit the song perfectly.
loved the mix! amazing playing from all of you!
Simply amazing! What a treat!
That's slide tone that even Josh would be happy with! Very impressive!
😂😂😂😂
I was here hoping I’d see this comment 😂
Lovely cover. It looked like you guys had fun. Keep them coming.
WOW! That was killer. Such amazing solos. Well done everyone. Fantastic
Unreal. Amazing. Thanks
Awesome! You should get Deacon Knight back together, add Dylan to the band and make some more great music. I'm sure I'm not the only one who would love that.
Amen!
@@gshull85 aren't you Rhett's dad? If so, maybe you could put in a good word, the world needs more of these fine folks making great music together 😎
Holy Shiite……. Frigging explosive guys…..made my day. I’d pay to see that performance!!!! Thank you!
Happy New Year!
For sure!!!❤
This is one of the best ideas i have ever heard
Amazing work everyone!! Can't wait to see what's next
That was amazing!!! Just wow
Simply amazing!!!
A joy to listen and to watch. Never heard this song like this before, killer version guys! 👏🏻
Great job! Gonna' love this series... wonderful idea!
Absolutely amazing!!!
Fantastic. Thank you
Holy crap that was fantastic Rhett!!! Look forward to more of these sessions!
Wonderful VIBES 💛
Wow you guys nailed it! Great playing by all. Sound was amazing. Would love to see more of these.
Loved it!!
Great idea!!
my god, the first phrase Dylan hits after the intro yanked tears right out of my eyes.
Only 2 words can really be said here: Thank You
It's one thing to see players you love on UA-cam.
Can you imagine the feelings everyone had getting to experience each other for the first time?
Dylan's respect and appreciation for Rhett and vice versa are the things inspiration are made of.
What a great way to start the New Year!
Beautiful! Hope to see more from this series!!
Loved it! Lots of energy and creative on-the-spot improvising. It's great you started this series! Already ready to watch the next dozen you release!
Very, very cool! I miss playing with musicians, I needed this today.
I’ve listened to this atleast 10 times today. Amazing
Absolutely Fantastic! Amazing!
Amazing!!! Love everything about it.
I always get chills listening to the power of this song. Your interpretation is no exception. Thank you
Absolutely Amazing! As a Pink Floyd fan & my FAVORITE band, Ever...I'm Extremely hesitant when I see other bands cover Floyd tunes & most don't due Floyd's music justice. That being said - Love this cover & Y'all knocked it outta the park! Well done 😊
Yeah, covers make me wince 9 times out of 10… generally in good hands with Nashville musicians, though! If it’s Nashville people I tend to watch because i’m happy 9 times out of 10.
Totally agree.
Look up the main squeeze. Their covers are amazing too.
I got pink Floyd socks for Christmas lol
Just gorgeous playing and tones
Absolutely beautiful...great job guys
Outstanding! Such a great take on such an iconic song! You guys absolutely crushed it and made it uniquely your own! 👏👏👏
Rippin’ it! Really enjoying the new project, recording together live. Takes guts but that’s where the real magic happens. Wishing you guys loads of the magic in 2024.
Man... Amazing! Congratulations!!!
This is fantastic, would love more of this content from you! You all sound so great.
That might just be the cleanest slide playing I've ever seen! Every note was so clear without extra rattling going on. Very cool.
Killer, guys! One of the best things I’ve seen on UA-cam in quite awhile.
Superb....all of you!
WHOA! Energy. Loved it!
I love this cover! You’re recording music the old way, the human connection is so important.
HOME RUN! Out of the park! Great capture Rhett, so dope.
This idea is so great. Really looking forward to more of these.
Keep this series going! so good
Wow, that was so awsome. No safety net, no editing, just laying down the track. Tight (by timing means) and loose (in improvisational freedom) at the same time. So amazing. Looking forward to the coming episodes of this series.
Using your platform to elevate an incredible player and giving us one of I hope a bunch of cool performances, is really putting some good into the world. Respect.
Incredible. Beautiful.
Love this format already!
What a kick ass tribute, in a completely unique style. Doing such an iconic vocal piece on slide is genious... the ability to curve around notes with the added raw edge of that prs, sweeet
Pretty incredible, Dylan will go far in this music world and will certainly benefit from your help and guidance. I can't imagine what keys and vocals mught sound like with this band. Well done. Love the one take live to tape approach.
Wow! More of this, please. Thank you, sir. Fantastic!
THat was absolutely amazing!
I've not heard of Dylan before. I'm halfway through listening to this video and I'm already a fan. Going to be looking for more of his stuff. Thanks Rhett for bringing him to my attention!
Wow...just WOW! Sounded AMAZING!! Kudos to Chad for keeping perfect time on drums. You and Dylan absolutely KILLED IT!!👍🤘✌
Amazing. All four of you nailed it.
amazing guys great mix as well
Wow, just incredible. This has been one of my all time favorite songs since I first heard it many moons ago. You guys are absolutely KILLING! If this what’s in store for fans of this channel, then the “live to tape” idea will definitely be one of the best things on UA-cam. And to pick Great Gig in the Sky as the first piece took some serious balls!😂 Looking forward to seeing what else ya’ll have to offer. 🤘🏻
The tape is a big part of the way music gels with a vintage sound and feeling and you are playing great. Hope people sign up for this live stuff.
Amazing. More of this please !!
Awesome series and concept and playing, looking forward to them :D
Main Squeeze did an amazing cover of this song a couple years ago, and I wasn’t sure if anyone could come close to it. You guys absolutely crushed this!!! Congrats Rhett, Dylan and gang on an amazing track!!
Wow! Monster playing, Dylan!
Rhett ain’t no slouch either, brilliant tones and creativity from both of the for sure!
Awesome
That was mind blowing; what a trip that performance is. Thanks for preparing and sharing that work. You are pros for a reason
This is simply amazing.
The clip ends with “You guys were killing in my ears!” Damn right! I watched the video twice I just didn’t have enough… Simply delightful! The execution is crazy good, the sound is awesome, I love hearing the room in the snare, it really gives a live feel to the recording. The dynamic is there as well, not too compressed. You guys are killing it! We need more of these… very inspirational, I’ll go grab my guitar now :) thank you!
Dylan is shredding that guitar. So much for PRS guitars not having as much mojo as other brands. That thing sounded incredible.
Absolutely
Just wow!
I am just blown away...incredible!!!
This is great - I love to hear talented musicians put they own inventive spin on great songs. But, going back to the composers of any great song, no matter what genre or century, I find it fascinating to try and understand what they first heard in their minds to put together such an amazing composition that would be enjoyed throughout the ages. A Massive thank you to the composers and a massive thank you to guys like this for keeping these great pieces at the forefront of us the listeners who can only dream of having such talent. Keep it going and keep growing.
This formula is GOLD! You and Dylan together are magical and compliment each other perfectly. The arrangement was on point. Not too close and not too far from the original. I was mesmerized from start to finish and couldn't take my eyes and ears off this. Would love to see this project grow into something that could be compiled into an album.
Just freakin’ awesome 😎!!!
Wow......absolutely wonderful
Dylan is well on his way to being one of the all time greats. This was killer
The only issue I had with the original was that it wasn’t long enough. I wanted more. This scratched that itch and I would buy this on iTunes in a heartbeat. Excellent work. Also hearing the original vocal melody at the start of when Dylan comes in, really makes you appreciate how she used her voice as an instrument (as per instructed by DG). But my god, that has to go down as one of the best vocal performances ever recorded, and this has done it some serious justice 🎉
Wonderful video, music, sound and playing.
Please please please made another thousand of this type of content! 🙏
Spectacular!
Amazeballs. Dylan is obviously spectacular but the whole vibe, live take, sound & playing of all is amazeballs.
What's not to like! Dylan is a BEAST!
Nicely done Rhett! This series is a brilliant idea.
Love this series already!
Plot twist! I was totally not expecting Dylan to be in your basement studio. I figured he did his take over yours at home. Way cool! Glad to see you guys collab with Dylan because he’s a force. I hope to see more of Dylan and you guys doing stuff!
i am so excited Rhett
This is one of my favorites! Amazing work!
Wow!!! More of this!!
This is one of the best ideas I've seen on the internet. This makes me, and I'm sure tons of people feel so much more confident. Thank you for this. And Happy New Year! 🤘🏼🍻
Great playing by all. Have you all been practising together? I'd like to see a short follow up video discussing how it got made/arranged, how it was mixed and if anyone was unhappy or ecstatic about any parts.
I've been loking forward for this for days now thank you
EXCELLENT ! 😮👍👍👍 Thank you Rhett and the band for this wonderful gift! Perfect to start this new year🙏🙏🙏