LINK THE TWINK

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 1,9 тис.

  • @iamwrong2239
    @iamwrong2239 Рік тому +1572

    I do think it matters when a character is changed. Because it's mainly for political reasons, if Samus is trans then you ruin the idea that women can do masculine things and still be women. I don't like this and neither should you

    • @ShortFatOtaku
      @ShortFatOtaku  Рік тому +496

      oh yeah let me be more specific: it doesn't violate the zelda lore if they make zelda/link a different race/gender/sexuality/whatever because they're reincarnations, not the same person, but it DOES violate the metroid lore if they do it to samus. i personally don't care much about the metroid lore, so for me it only really matters if the game is good. but for metroid fanatics i can see why they'd be angry if they actually made samus trans.

    • @iamwrong2239
      @iamwrong2239 Рік тому +153

      @@ShortFatOtaku Well thank you for clarifying

    • @iamwrong2239
      @iamwrong2239 Рік тому +217

      @@ShortFatOtaku Tbh dev I'm not sure if we want to make Link gay or Samus trans. It will never be enough for them

    • @daskampffredchen
      @daskampffredchen Рік тому +132

      What, a strong female character?! Impossible, must be a man

    • @Skeloperch
      @Skeloperch Рік тому +91

      @@ShortFatOtaku >I personally don't care about the metroid lore
      How fucking dare you. Pick up Metroid Prime Remastered right this instant and start reading those Space Pirate logs.

  • @TheTGOAC
    @TheTGOAC Рік тому +1884

    "Wearing a dress doesn't make you a woman!"
    "Omg link wears *women's* clothes, he's clearly trans!"
    It's all so tiresome.

    • @kyosokutai
      @kyosokutai Рік тому +118

      There is a reason Transgender and Transvestite are different words.

    • @PaulvonOberstein
      @PaulvonOberstein Рік тому +143

      @@kyosokutai Don't they consider transvestite to be a slur now?

    • @ShortFatOtaku
      @ShortFatOtaku  Рік тому +406

      @@PaulvonOberstein they consider any words that describe alternative modes of being that are visually similar to them, but nonetheless different, to be transphobic, because they want to erase the differences and roll them all into being trans. this is why "femboys are trans" and "femboy is a slur" in the minds of the activists

    • @s.s.r.s2641
      @s.s.r.s2641 Рік тому +38

      Remember that clothes don't have gender 🤓

    • @FF-tp7qs
      @FF-tp7qs Рік тому +15

      ​@@s.s.r.s2641even the Venom Symbiote suit?

  • @Alex5000148
    @Alex5000148 Рік тому +622

    4 19 "Gender stereotypes are bad!"
    4 20 "If a woman doesn't act like a stereotype, she is trans"

    • @LeoVital
      @LeoVital Рік тому +96

      Or when someone sees a tomboy who likes doing typically masculine things, or who says that she's always felt like "one of the boys", and they start saying that "she's an egg". God, I hate that shit.

    • @barneystinson2781
      @barneystinson2781 Рік тому

      All of the talking points by the alphabet mafia are nonsense.
      "Gender and sex aren't the same" but they have to change sexual characteristics to match their gender. They insist on using female and male (sex classifications) for the one they feel like, but are not. Gay is same sex attraction, but it's transphobic for gay men to not be attracted to trannies. Nothing about it is logical.

    • @GeneralTantzu
      @GeneralTantzu Рік тому +25

      This weirdo cult ideology is insane and the NPC meme fits it almost frighteningly well.

    • @lainiwakura1776
      @lainiwakura1776 Рік тому +27

      This is the crap that makes me miss the 90s and early 2000s.

    • @juanrodriguez9971
      @juanrodriguez9971 Рік тому +25

      + Please define woman
      - We don't engage with mysoginistic questions

  • @HarleyHerbert
    @HarleyHerbert Рік тому +340

    We must never forgive these activists for committing their tomboy genocide.

    • @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz
      @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz Рік тому +48

      The greatest loss of a generation.

    • @darkzeroprojects4245
      @darkzeroprojects4245 Рік тому +26

      We can still make more though.
      Screw what they demand.

    • @orangetoes223
      @orangetoes223 7 місяців тому

      Honestly I think there’s more straight tomboy’s out there than ever. They just go by they/them pronouns and are obnoxious.

  • @llamasmeowing2061
    @llamasmeowing2061 Рік тому +552

    Dude, I remember other girls in my prog town making fun of me and bullying me for being a tomboy up to the moment they cut their hair, started calling themselves Trans (and were still wearing as much makeup and dresses as always), and then they said I was the one bullying them.

    • @zandrus9191
      @zandrus9191 Рік тому +106

      I feel bad for ya. I am in solidarity with you and other tomboys who got shat on for being who they are (much cuter than the normal gals).
      Now that the social illness of narcissism and oversexualization progressed, they want you to be part of their misery. All we got that will work is fighting back.

    • @llamasmeowing2061
      @llamasmeowing2061 Рік тому +28

      @@zandrus9191 thanks for the support lol!

    • @HeavyHouse24
      @HeavyHouse24 Рік тому +40

      When being bullied is considered cool they all take the credits without withstand the disability 😂🤣

    • @darwinxavier3516
      @darwinxavier3516 Рік тому

      They just went from one form of brainless conformity to another. Anything that gives them power over you.

    • @HypnoChode74
      @HypnoChode74 Рік тому

      As a man who has a thing for Tomboys I’m sorry to hear those stuck up mentally ill whores treated you bad.

  • @addex1236
    @addex1236 Рік тому +935

    I love how with Naoto her enteir arc is self acceptance and yet that causes people to scream shes trans when thats literally the exact opposite meaning

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +182

      They can’t accept that someone would _not_ choose to go down that road. Likely one they have or trying to go down. They want someone, something to enable/tell them what they’re doing is good/right. The outcome of that story bugs them because it makes them self-reflect on whether they should/shouldn’t and they can’t handle it. Even worse if they’ve already taken some permanent steps.

    • @jamalisujang2712
      @jamalisujang2712 Рік тому

      The thong about modetn trans is that they chase the unattainable feminine body.
      However I think we will be able to make homunculi bodies for many uses when we can reliably colonize the solar system.

    • @davidsplooge14
      @davidsplooge14 Рік тому +8

      ​@@mrshmuga9I just hope technology improves in the future so the process of transitioning becomes smoother and things become less permanent.

    • @sekijokes451
      @sekijokes451 Рік тому

      ​@@davidsplooge14You say that but I guarantee you that these progs will decry such technology to be "transphobic".
      After all, "the war is not meant to be won. It is meant to be continous."

    • @briandorough498
      @briandorough498 Рік тому +3

      P4 gud

  • @aminehouzane6223
    @aminehouzane6223 Рік тому +347

    Historians in the future will look into our present and see that's the reason the LGBT community collapse on it self was because they attacked and targeted the most oppress group in history
    GAMERS

  • @DjDeadpig
    @DjDeadpig Рік тому +923

    Man, I just find it hilarious that someone’s porn history is the basis for why some people support the trans umbrella argument.

    • @t.k.5844
      @t.k.5844 Рік тому +177

      I mean, *my* porn history is (one of) the reasons I *don't* support it. You know how hard it is to look up Bimbofication *without* 90% being genderbending sissification stuff?
      .... Obviously not, so let me tell ya it's pretty damn hard.

    • @xX_Pokeman_Xx
      @xX_Pokeman_Xx Рік тому +53

      ​@@t.k.5844Man, tell me about it! I'm all good for gender bending, but more and more of the transformation stuff is also accompanied by gender transformation these days!

    • @leonardolopes6360
      @leonardolopes6360 Рік тому +18

      Please do share some insights, gentlemen

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому +21

      Kinda makes you think what trans really is.

    • @PaulvonOberstein
      @PaulvonOberstein Рік тому +87

      It's the sort of thing that reminds me of the massive overlap between transgenderism and autism. That twitter comment Dev had in the video, where the guy compares drawing straight porn of a fictional lesbian character to real world r-pe, has to be some kind of manifestation of autism.

  • @Citizen_J
    @Citizen_J Рік тому +143

    Link has been, and always will be, a man.
    Samus has been, and always will be, a woman.

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому

      Given Nintendo's trackrecord, they're most likely, immune to ideological conquest. They seem to be a pretty conservative institution so they're covered in the terms of the rules of conquest.

    • @q-tip9962
      @q-tip9962 Рік тому +1

      Yeah, you are right about that, but these characters are important for those who explore their identity, that first push to actually discover themselves. I like that and I don't want it that fact to be erased.

    • @crypterion_moon
      @crypterion_moon Рік тому +2

      Watch as the activists go REEEEEEEEE

    • @darkzeroprojects4245
      @darkzeroprojects4245 Рік тому +4

      @@q-tip9962
      Too bad those who do misunderstand gender nonconformity, or just want to subvert shit.

    • @aaacowsad6388
      @aaacowsad6388 Рік тому +3

      Isn't link an elf, you know that race of people so beautiful their men are mistake for women by other races

  • @Melehan
    @Melehan Рік тому +78

    "Those who cannot conceive Friendship as a substantive love but only as a disguise or elaboration of Eros betray the fact that they have never had a Friend...."

  • @MrKhanMan1510
    @MrKhanMan1510 Рік тому +197

    Link is depicted in a feminine manner because he's usually also depicted as very young, and he's usually depicted as young because the original inspiration for his design was none other than Peter Pan, the eternally young boy of Neverland.

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +21

      Peter Pan was trans because Mary Martin played him in the 1954 broadway production.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому +27

      Being an eternally young boy is not a bug for these people, it's a feature.

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому +8

      @@kaizokujimbei143 I'm pretty sure not aging and having a mentally stunted development are two radically different things.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому +1

      @@Saint_Wolf_ The alphabet mafia are mentally stunted in their development. The children they are trying to groom are the exact age the alphabet mafia like them. So you are correct, they are different things. One is the predator and the other the innocent victim.

    • @Amin-al-Husseini_1941picture
      @Amin-al-Husseini_1941picture Рік тому +4

      @@kaizokujimbei143 eternally child is exactly what they want lol
      (there was a woman with dwarfism that looked like a child, 99% of her dates were pedofiles trying to have a legal relationship)

  • @TurtleChad1
    @TurtleChad1 Рік тому +881

    LGBT community try not to call all characters gay (IMPOSSIBLE CHALLENGE)

    • @lostinadifferentworld2752
      @lostinadifferentworld2752 Рік тому +2

      Being triggered by people on the internet calling a video game character gay is unemployed behavior 😂
      Scroll down to see a bunch of butthurt neets 👇

    • @justinambru8529
      @justinambru8529 Рік тому +25

      @@lostinadifferentworld2752 That ain't a trigger boy.

    • @benjaf1058
      @benjaf1058 Рік тому +81

      LGBT+ Teenage boys
      🤝
      Calling everything gay

    • @lostinadifferentworld2752
      @lostinadifferentworld2752 Рік тому +3

      @@justinambru8529 Really? Cause you seem awfully upset, boy. 😂

    • @justinambru8529
      @justinambru8529 Рік тому +9

      @@lostinadifferentworld2752 How exactly?

  • @sandyjourneys
    @sandyjourneys Рік тому +428

    The bromance between link and Sidon is amazing the people calling it homophobic or whatever are just brophobic.

    • @DankPogchamp
      @DankPogchamp Рік тому +75

      Calling the SJWs reality-phobic is also equally as effective.

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +40

      My husband and I joked about it basically being a one sided affair. Sidon is just “to nice” on the creepy scale. He wants Link to be his bro and Link is like “Wtf get back in your Pokeball you weirdo”.

    • @TheFatalcrest
      @TheFatalcrest Рік тому +22

      XD I was playing BOTW and was like "
      ...why do people ship this guy with link again? He seems cool but....not like he's giving me a vibe here. "

    • @malicekerendu3574
      @malicekerendu3574 Рік тому +49

      Also Link was spending time with his sister when Sidon could barely talk. He kinda helped raising him.
      Link is like a ln older brother or cousin to him and they're still peddling that notion.
      Oh well. It's not like that fetish is rare.

    • @pqp12
      @pqp12 Рік тому +21

      If you can't act gay with your homies then are you really homies?

  • @Slick_Tails
    @Slick_Tails Рік тому +378

    "Tails is trans"
    Okay, now you've crossed the line.

    • @sir-scudio
      @sir-scudio Рік тому +66

      indeed they have mate, we live in a fucked world honestly.

    • @Slick_Tails
      @Slick_Tails Рік тому +52

      @@sir-scudio OMG brother, your pfp is literally mine but zoomed out.
      We are kin. ✊

    • @sir-scudio
      @sir-scudio Рік тому +38

      @@Slick_Tails hell yea, we gotta stick together brother.

    • @spirituskitsune
      @spirituskitsune Рік тому +52

      Well, they ARE in fact trying to go for people much younger than 12, so..

    • @DiZtheJedi
      @DiZtheJedi Рік тому +22

      They stepped on the wrong tail this time.

  • @erich3531
    @erich3531 Рік тому +151

    Despite Link’s more cutesy depictions (which is done solely to appeal to all boys and girls in the games’ audience), he fulfills the traditional masculine roles of warrior and protector in every game. He doesn’t begin his adventures seeking glory, instead having it thrust upon him as a consequence of his own motivations. Sure, he’s a chosen hero in some iterations, but that only comes about due to the trials he overcomes. Link fights to protect his village, his family, his kingdom, or the woman he loves, usually a mix of all of these. He becomes a legendary hero by performing his duty and fulfilling his role in Hyrule’s society.
    Link does not and cannot fall into a progressive queer framework because to do so would undermine the values and messages at the series’ core.

    • @sniperrecon676
      @sniperrecon676 Рік тому +10

      That’s why they want to make the character LGBT in identity: it gives them the opportunity to subvert the traditional archetype of the hero.

    • @cloudirubez07
      @cloudirubez07 7 місяців тому +1

      Exactly this. Link is a *protector*, a traditionally masculine thing, and has always been. Although I personally hate how Link turned into an anime trap for fanservice during a single sequence of the game and as a result got fetishized by certain people online (2017-2018 was a dark age, also Link’s like 17 to make matters worse), he’s still at his core a defender and a fighter, and never escapes that role. He isn’t some uwu femboy and I kinda hate how he’s depicted as one when he’s realistically just a bishounen type character and nothing more.

  • @Fiver_Hyzenthlay
    @Fiver_Hyzenthlay Рік тому +637

    As a gay man I find link extremely attractive but obviously my personal lust towards a character does not mean the character is gay. You can have a head cannon and enjoy characters in your own way but that doesn’t make it cannon nor should it.

    • @Rebrn-bk5em
      @Rebrn-bk5em Рік тому +119

      Link is so androgynous it doesn’t even make men gay imo. A pretty face is still a pretty face regardless

    • @poyobotyahoo7494
      @poyobotyahoo7494 Рік тому

      ​@@Rebrn-bk5emnah man that is still pretty gay lmao

    • @akiraishin7141
      @akiraishin7141 Рік тому +74

      Thank you! I get so annoyed seeing people do this. I think the one that has been annoying me the most recently is people putting Piccolo from Dragon Ball into sexual relationships with humans, especially human women.
      Piccolo is an alien slug man. He cannonicaly does not have a penis! He can't find humans attractive, let alone women because his species Masculine hermaphrodites

    • @Niyucuatro
      @Niyucuatro Рік тому

      @@akiraishin7141 I wouldn't even call them hermafrodites. That implies sexual reperoduction, Namkeians reproduce asexually. Only one progenitor pukes eggs without the need of a second progenitor.

    • @mrbox9654
      @mrbox9654 Рік тому +9

      🗿🏳️‍🌈

  • @raynightshade8317
    @raynightshade8317 Рік тому +375

    I like how Cloud and Link are men that dresses as women to get in women's places and the LGBTQ calls them trans.

    • @Liberty_or_Ded
      @Liberty_or_Ded Рік тому +111

      Yeah, they have a tendency to unintentionally snitch on themselves.

    • @TheCoolerDrilis
      @TheCoolerDrilis Рік тому +2

      "Cloak"? Cloud?

    • @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz
      @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz Рік тому +23

      Dont say based, dont say based...

    • @olivesama
      @olivesama Рік тому +6

      When my sister saw the trailer for the previous game a few years back, she immediately assumed that they had turned Link into a girl this time around.
      So whatever is influencing people's impressions, it isn't just the clothes.

    • @bob74h67
      @bob74h67 Рік тому

      They are just femboys
      men that look girly

  • @itssunday1990
    @itssunday1990 Рік тому +103

    Every Otokonoko or /cm/ thread on 4chan has at least one anon calling them all "eggs" and closeted trans and immediately get told to leave the twinks alone and endgame themselves.

  • @heroinpenguin666
    @heroinpenguin666 Рік тому +92

    As I said in chat:
    Link who beats up all the monsters, saves the princess, eats massive amounts of foods, skydives and climes every mountain. Can't get much more manly than that!
    As you said Dev, he is courage personified and in Tears of the Kingdom clearly in a relationship with Zelda. The Breath of the Wild/Tears of the Kingdom Zelda universe is more "mature" and it fits that you'd see stable relationships between men and women as a basis for creating functional families in that timeline. Be it the Zora heirs or the Hudson family as well for example.
    Not everything is political, not everyone who possibly could be trans, should be. It's fine if some things and some people are, but repressive tolerance is a hateful ideology and leads to oppressive violence when taken to it's logical conclusion.

  • @DarkVeghetta
    @DarkVeghetta Рік тому +82

    To the femboys out there: You are rare flowers and I'm glad you exist. Please don't stop existing.
    Sincerely, a bisexual guy that looks like he's escaped a bara manga.

    • @q-tip9962
      @q-tip9962 Рік тому

      Trust me, this flower isn't wilting anytime soon. And as someone who would be called woke by conservatives, I hate the people that are doing this as much as everyone else. They are loud, obnoxious, and do nothing but give actual activists a bad name.

    • @ieatmice751
      @ieatmice751 Рік тому +1

      hear hear

    • @bottleneck-5548
      @bottleneck-5548 Рік тому +1

      I stand by this

    • @omnitone
      @omnitone 8 місяців тому +3

      BARA MAGNA b r u h
      edit: i read you wrong sorry. thought you were referencing bionicle.

  • @TheHylianJuggalo
    @TheHylianJuggalo Рік тому +178

    This "Every Character in recent fiction is some flavor of rainbow sexuality" phenomenon, is, I think, a direct result of the "Fujoshi" girls of the early and mid 2000's - The type of chick who would dress exclusively from Hot Topic and jumped on the Twilight bandwagon. I know SO MANY of these women who would ship Naruto and Invader Zim characters together (mostly gay pairings), and now that these women are 30 (We're old now, cope), the ones who never grew out of it are now working for these rag "Journalist" outlets and writing this tripe.

    • @Higesgirl
      @Higesgirl Рік тому +28

      I agree with you as a former fujoshi (I loved Hot Topic, but hated Twilight). I grew outta it and seeing people who haven't is really sad and pathetic.

    • @spiritpyros
      @spiritpyros Рік тому +36

      Ah remember when we used to call them yaoi fangirls

    • @TJK10
      @TJK10 Рік тому +25

      @@spiritpyros
      I’ll do you one better: remember gals who loved yaoi paddles and ‘glomping’, lol?

    • @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle
      @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle Рік тому +20

      ​@@TJK10the word "glomping" has brought back bad memories

    • @lorblauh
      @lorblauh Рік тому +15

      As someone who was 20% that girl (was too lazy and poor to get too into it but I read a lot of fanfiction) I completely agree and it makes me want to die. 😕

  • @xxCrapNamexx
    @xxCrapNamexx Рік тому +75

    "Whoever controls the coom, controls the universe."- Baron Vladimir Harkonnen.

  • @compatriot852
    @compatriot852 Рік тому +133

    I find this viewpoint hilarious considering the game points out multiple times how women view Link as very attractive and how he has a relationship with Zelda

    • @Patchuiko
      @Patchuiko Рік тому +32

      That because most of them never actually played the game or read game lore/context, all these weirdos do, is find characters to turn trans or gay for their twisted desire or trans agenda.

    • @kurosan0079
      @kurosan0079 Рік тому +29

      Troons are jealous that a straight man like Link looks better in women's clothes than they'll ever be.

    • @Athalwolf13
      @Athalwolf13 Рік тому +8

      Possibly because they only know of their characters from porn.
      And in Link case a *ton* of a feminisation / sissification porn.

    • @summ.3433
      @summ.3433 Рік тому +1

      Pretty sure most of ZeLink fanart is majority of women artists.

  • @bloodygypsy3740
    @bloodygypsy3740 Рік тому +438

    LGBTQ: we must break masculine stereotypes!
    *Male character with a skin slim fit appears
    LGBTQ: omg he's absolutely gay!!

    • @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle
      @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle Рік тому +114

      Mfw you're so progressive you enforce the gender norms you sought to destroy

    • @bloodygypsy3740
      @bloodygypsy3740 Рік тому +39

      ​It seems to happen every time like clockwork

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +47

      @@ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandleThat’s just the motte. The bailey is they want to label more people gay so they internalize it, become gay (or engage on some part) and create more options for partners. Items funny because in the 90’s/00’s people would say “that’s gay” as a pejorative (effeminate or dumb) a lot, and they got mad at that. But now they’re saying “that’s gay” as a way to inject themselves into the conversation/flirt/lust, even if the person/character’s sexuality is ambiguous or stated/implied as straight. They complain about “misgendering” but somehow saying someone is gay and hitting on them when they’re not is somehow okay. Because there’s no way to “breed” more gay people other than gaslighting people into thinking they are.

    • @JodyBruchon
      @JodyBruchon Рік тому +6

      Wojak memes abound

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +16

      You can always tell who’s trans by how sterotypical they are dressed. Transwomen I’ve seen dressed in pink rainbow tutus with bows in their hair, trans men are often in suits where is really isn’t fitting or have neckbeards if they can’t pull off the suit.

  • @dudsummon3803
    @dudsummon3803 Рік тому +306

    Link as a twink has been a joke before the current madness, was pretty funny in drawn together.

    • @ichmich9324
      @ichmich9324 Рік тому +9

      The first time I encountered that was when some one did a mod for smash bros brawl where link is in zeldas outfit. Then he was just twink

    • @APerson-ws4cw
      @APerson-ws4cw Рік тому +5

      there was a LoZ reference in Drawn Together?

    • @MegaGlassguy
      @MegaGlassguy Рік тому +43

      @@APerson-ws4cw One of the main characters of the show, Xandir, was intended to be a parody of Link. And yes, he's unambiguously gay.

    • @FreakazoidRobots
      @FreakazoidRobots Рік тому +14

      It was great as a joke, but I don't want to see it become reality.

    • @stevensilvainus6084
      @stevensilvainus6084 Рік тому +2

      The only other twink that can stop a charging lynel with a back hand, is Bruce Lee.

  • @EndlessDelusion
    @EndlessDelusion Рік тому +1405

    The trans community looking at link crossdressing to enter a women only space and yelling "write that down!"

    • @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089
      @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089 Рік тому +195

      They practically invented the concept not exactly shocking given they base their whole lifestyle off of it.

    • @ShortFatOtaku
      @ShortFatOtaku  Рік тому +269

      HAHAHAHA

    • @Bronimin
      @Bronimin Рік тому +20

      lmfao

    • @RezaQin
      @RezaQin Рік тому

      The "trans community" will only live up to age 35 so...won't be around that long.

    • @puffbair
      @puffbair Рік тому +23

      yeah haha transphobia funny 🙈🔫 yeah kill me haha

  • @MrSophire
    @MrSophire Рік тому +65

    As a Catholic, the Joan of Ace hurts. If they knew anything about her they would have realized that she was a teen girl who was sent be God himself (according to Catholic beliefs). She preferred to wear dresses historically, she burn at the stake on trump up charges.

    • @JohnSmith-wx9wj
      @JohnSmith-wx9wj Рік тому +26

      I read Mark Twain's novel of her. He tried his best to base it on history. Reading it was an amazing experience. And what it portrayed was the ultimate show of feminine strength and power. Yeah, she cut her hair and wore trousers for battle. Everything else about her was hyper-feminine without being diabetic. Joan as a trans is just pure malediction.

    • @jht3fougifh393
      @jht3fougifh393 Рік тому +11

      Exactly. She only wore armor in battle, and iirc asked for a dress when incarcerated. They ended up not even getting her for that, because it didn't make any sense.

  • @AnikiPlay
    @AnikiPlay Рік тому +492

    the egg thing with the trans community always freaks me out, it feel so slimy and frightening god this is grooming to it's purest form

    • @yarlodek5842
      @yarlodek5842 Рік тому +146

      It’s convincing someone to modify their body. Grooming is temporary, transitioning is permanent, which makes egg cracking arguably worse than grooming. And then there’s always the “what if the child wanted to be groomed” oops I mean “what if their egg needed to be cracked” excuse.

    • @Probably_JENOVA
      @Probably_JENOVA Рік тому +88

      Definitely a grooming thing. It feels so creepy, gross, and uncomfortable. It’s just psychological manipulation and degeneracy at its core.

    • @puffbair
      @puffbair Рік тому +6

      if some people making porn of a video game characters played by tons of adults offends you because youre worried itll affect children, you need to restrict what your kids see.

    • @Liberty_or_Ded
      @Liberty_or_Ded Рік тому +53

      Jay Exsi, a youtuber I really like, went from demonstrating no feminine traits to out of nowhere becoming trans and he describes himself as an "egg."
      Doesn't change my opinion of his content, but it does demonstrate how susceptible to social contagion people can be.

    • @crakhaed
      @crakhaed Рік тому +23

      @@Liberty_or_Ded that's disturbing. Just all at once he shifted?

  • @thatroxxguy
    @thatroxxguy Рік тому +61

    I don't believe for a second that there were no real trans-people involved in this.
    I had entire debates with trans-people over shit like this. For example, the youtuber Pyrocynical cross dressed as multiple female characters from movies, animes etc. and all trans-subreddit dwelling crazies were screeching in the comments how that obviously means that he is trans (he isn't, he isn't even lgbtq or really a crossdresser, he was just doing a favour for his girlfriend). When I talked with them about that, they were really quick to admit that they would like it if there were more trans-people in this world, because they would have more people like them etc.
    Basically wishing a condition on someone that will cause this person pain and confusion, just so they can have another "group member". I also once heard about a gay crossdresser, which was constantly told that he was trans by multiple trans-people and nearly transitioned, only to have a mental-breakdown at the last second and realize that he does not want to change his sex.
    This "egg" bullshit is of the same caliber. A term to describe someone that isn't "aware" of their condition, used frequently to gaslight people into believing that they are trans.
    Imagine a person in a wheel chair getting excited to see someone getting hit by a bus or trying to get them to jump off a building, because they revell in their condition and want more people with the same problem as them.
    And yes of course, not all trans-people. But I still believe there is a fair share of trans-people, who are narcisstic and constantly need to be validated. Some of them probably being supremacist, believing that being trans is better than not being trans.
    Also, I personally would care if they changed Link into being gay or etc. For me, it's just an aspect of the character. Of course this wouldn't make a Zelda game bad, I would just find it weird to play the game, since the character has lost one of his prime characteristics. Maybe I have a bias, because Zelda games are my childhood and I kind of wanted to be Link when I was little, idk.
    However, the change would still be unnecessary and unwarranted. There wouldn't be really a reason to do it besides an ideological one.

    • @xxkankala1671
      @xxkankala1671 Рік тому +2

      So now your transphobic because of one person damn

    • @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster
      @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster Рік тому +21

      @@xxkankala1671 Bro the whole "egg" concept is creepy as heck. Let the person come out by themselves if they are trans, which they may not even be.
      Stop this weird psuedo grooming stuff

    • @q-tip9962
      @q-tip9962 Рік тому +8

      I'd argue that sexual preference has never been a trait of Link's character to begin with. To me, it doesn't matter if Link swings one way or another, Link is still Link to me. Gender non-conforming or not.

    • @q-tip9962
      @q-tip9962 Рік тому +1

      You mentioned how being trans is a condition that brings pain and confusion to a person. That pain and confusion only comes because these people lack information about themselves and are in fear of what would happen if they were explore there gender. They are afraid of being hurt by family and being abandoned for not being considered normal. That pain comes from people not being accpted by people around and feeling forced to play a role that they don't feel associated with. Itd be like a straight person being called gay just because they don't have standard characteristics of a straight person.

    • @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster
      @thedarkmasterthedarkmaster Рік тому +4

      @@q-tip9962 Where do you stand on the whole egg thing

  • @daskampffredchen
    @daskampffredchen Рік тому +134

    Whenever a female character achieves something they claim that they are actually men. Ironic

    • @20thcentury_toy
      @20thcentury_toy Рік тому +3

      Nah it's pretty reasonable

    • @glorioustigereye
      @glorioustigereye Рік тому +16

      Didn’t a man get some woman’s award from the US president a while ago

    • @jht3fougifh393
      @jht3fougifh393 Рік тому +6

      ​@@glorioustigereye Yeah this kind of stuff keeps happening. It's really insulting, lol.

    • @makvande576
      @makvande576 Рік тому +3

      REEEEE SAMUS IS A TROON LIKE US REEEEEE

    • @danteshollowedgrounds
      @danteshollowedgrounds Рік тому +1

      @@makvande576 👌👌👌

  • @popopopoqwerty
    @popopopoqwerty Рік тому +55

    Yeah, it's all so tiresome.
    As an androgynous male living in conservative country, it's those tropes from anime and games that helped me open up a bit and realise that I can just dip into feminine side a bit without rejecting male one. I'm still a man, I just stopped giving a fuck about gender norms.
    Also, thumbs up for Catherine ost in the background.

    • @cloud8521
      @cloud8521 Рік тому

      It is crazy, gender norms, while based on reality, are not sedimentary. People can deviate from them, always could. But now people are treating gender norms as rock solid foundations that deviation into a diffrent gender's norms means you have to now be that gender... it is amazing how sexist they have become.

  • @WILIZIN
    @WILIZIN Рік тому +153

    There has never been a greater argument against pornography then showcasing the results of what it does to your brain like this.
    " careful Timmy if you watch too much pornography you'll end up being a massive ball of cringe"

    • @pank3245
      @pank3245 Рік тому

      I think the greater issue being these people are socially inept. They lack the table manners of keeping their sexual thoughts "indoors" but online echo chambers enable their eneptness.

    • @electricfishfan
      @electricfishfan Рік тому +6

      I’d say all the rape and performer injuries are worse, but, sure, that’s the second.

    • @jeremychicken3339
      @jeremychicken3339 Рік тому +30

      @@electricfishfan but that only applies to IRL porn, not digital.

    • @WILIZIN
      @WILIZIN Рік тому

      @@jeremychicken3339 dude I'd say furries are more fucked up than people with irl porn.

    • @hope-cat4894
      @hope-cat4894 Рік тому +12

      Instead of telling kids they'll grow hairy palms or go blind, just tell them they'll spend the rest of their lives arguing with strangers on Twitter over fictional characters having sex with their friends. 😱

  • @Sound557
    @Sound557 Рік тому +697

    I swear, we’re going to look back on the Trans kids movement the same way we look back at the lobotomy movement.

  • @puz369
    @puz369 Рік тому +76

    I think you cut off the most important quote from that Eiji Aonuma interview: "As far as gender goes, Link is definitely a male, but I wanted to create a character where anybody would be able to relate to the character.”"
    As one of your last pictures showed, Link is also canonically Christian 🤣 AND, while he may wear women's clothing every once in awhile, he certainly falls into the masculine role almost perfectly.

    • @grimjoker5572
      @grimjoker5572 Рік тому +10

      He's only Christian in the bad timeline.

    • @FunkyKong2112
      @FunkyKong2112 Рік тому +10

      The official Twilight Princess art depicted Link as particularly manly compared to the rest of the franchise I've always thought. He's got a stoic facial expression and actually looked like he was swinging a sword around.

    • @ShortFatOtaku
      @ShortFatOtaku  Рік тому +43

      Aonuma's also stated that link's kind of a weird guy, but he's absolutely a guy - he doesn't really care about being considered a pretty woman when he's crossdressing, and he doesn't really care about having to crossdress, he just finds it surprising. link's basically the apex of unflappability

    • @puz369
      @puz369 Рік тому +14

      @@ShortFatOtaku which is why we love him.

    • @browal14
      @browal14 Рік тому +5

      @@ShortFatOtaku link is one of those characters that is almost superhuman in his adaptability and athleticism

  • @PetrolPaladin
    @PetrolPaladin Рік тому +47

    The anger and confusion over the Sidon thing is telling. They're mistaking affection for romantic love. As a child, Sidon idolised the awesome knight that was (maybe) dating his sister. The other Zora tell you that he's always bragging about his BEST FREIND, Link. He commssioned a statue of them saving the kingdom together. Sidon is written as a boy that is super proud of, and seeking the approval of, his older brother. Also, how can anyone hate Yona? She's cute AF.

    • @ovider6625
      @ovider6625 Рік тому

      Cute? She’s the hottest piece of fish ass I’ve seen in the entire Zora species (also adult Ruto she’s smoking)

    • @PrismTheKid
      @PrismTheKid 9 місяців тому

      I thought her manta ray head looked stupid
      but other than that she's fine I guess

  • @jaybon2076
    @jaybon2076 Рік тому +20

    When it comes to the Link/Sidon relationship, I can't help but think of this C.S. Lewis quote:
    “Those who cannot conceive of Friendship as a substantive love but only as a disguise or elaboration of Eros betray the fact that they have never had a Friend.”
    - C. S. Lewis

  • @maxieprimo2758
    @maxieprimo2758 Рік тому +60

    Interesting how some of the only places where "revolutionary queerness" sticks is the ones most saturated with pornography.

    • @juuchanIRL
      @juuchanIRL Рік тому +7

      also interesting that in countries where "the message" isn't enforced 24/7, the number of LGBTQWERTY youths is very low.
      only ones act like this are chronically online people, almost as if there are certain contagion zones that convert them.

  • @Tounushi
    @Tounushi Рік тому +39

    It's amazing that after decades of complaining that gender roles are too constrictive and that there's a wide variety of being a man or a woman, they go 180 degrees and say there's an infinitesimally narrow definition of a masculine man and a feminine woman and everything outside those two is automatically trans.

    • @juuchanIRL
      @juuchanIRL Рік тому

      because they discovered they can trap people into their ideology forever if they convince them to take body-destroying hormones and surgery.
      in order to grow their numbers, they need to force propaganda onto non-conforming teens who are willing to give in.

    • @Friendly_Neigborhood_Astolfo
      @Friendly_Neigborhood_Astolfo Рік тому +1

      Um nobody was saying that

  • @JohnDoe-yp3zv
    @JohnDoe-yp3zv Рік тому +67

    "Tails is trans because he's voiced by a woman."
    By that metric, why stop there? Every single young boy in cartoons is trans because they're almost all voiced by women, because options for voicing young boys are limited. You either go with a female voice actress as that's the most convenient option, or you go with a genuine boy and often end up with a stinted delivery because they're too young to know how to act well (Tails in the Adventure games have this at its best and Heroes arguably has it at its worst; it's also a confirmed case of a voice actor having to be replaced by their own younger brother because their voice deepened too much to be reprised for the role).

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +7

      Bart, Linda, Tina - all trans.

    • @svagglaorde4387
      @svagglaorde4387 Рік тому +9

      Male anime characters even Goku voiced by women - all trans

    • @lifelikeafrog3233
      @lifelikeafrog3233 Рік тому +5

      I guess naruto is trans

    • @chad_bro_chill
      @chad_bro_chill Рік тому +2

      Interesting case with The Land Before Time, where Littlefoot is sometimes voiced by boys and sometimes by women. Some have voice cracking because the kid is just getting too old for the role.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому

      I guess by this logic Monkey D Luffy is also trans.

  • @Deverud
    @Deverud Рік тому +33

    If Tails is trans because female voice actor, I guess Bart Simpson is trans too (voiced by Nancy Cartwright)

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +7

      Linda and Tina are also trans (voiced by male voice actors).

    • @jalapinoy3790
      @jalapinoy3790 Рік тому +4

      Don’t give them ideas

  • @FyterianTV
    @FyterianTV Рік тому +35

    on twitter, whenever i see someone use the terms "coded" or "media literacy", i just know i'm about to see someone inject their politics into a game/movie...
    ಠ_ಠ
    edit: hilarious sign off 😹

    • @robertallan8035
      @robertallan8035 8 місяців тому

      "media literacy" is a redundant term. Real media literacy is just literacy. People who misunderstand media are illiterate.

  • @HyperJohnua
    @HyperJohnua Рік тому +131

    Im a fan of femboy link, but i am about to set aside my perverse desires and separate it from reality

    • @hombreg1
      @hombreg1 Рік тому +34

      You truly are the warrior poet of the degenerate world

    • @owencooney7178
      @owencooney7178 Рік тому +10

      No just a regular degenerate

    • @TotalWannabe
      @TotalWannabe Рік тому +5

      You and me too, but we're fans of femboys, not trans anyway.

    • @machine-shopbilly6584
      @machine-shopbilly6584 Рік тому +1

      Hell yeah dude

  • @justinwhite2725
    @justinwhite2725 Рік тому +24

    22:18 and this is why gatekeeping is important. Remember this when someone accuses you of gatekeeping a hobby.

  • @Dionaea_floridensis
    @Dionaea_floridensis Рік тому +22

    Samus has been fused with so much alien DNA at this point she's barely even a human lol

  • @erraticuk
    @erraticuk Рік тому +26

    It was never about representation, It was never about having something of their own.
    Its all about taking away whats yours. Like a sibling refusing to change the TV channel out of nothing more than spite.
    This is why they dont create new characters but instead destroy old characters and then move on to the next thing.
    On the rare creation of a new LGBT character they dont go out and surport it by buying the product.

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому +5

      Not just taking what's "yours" it's about upending and getting the allegiances of things that you don't care about so they can know that others will be exposed to their ideological slop, for everything is political and if everything is political, everything shall have my ideological bent, slant and stance. And if they don't, if they refuse, if they play both sides as even, equal and akin, portray flaws on both sides, refuse to take sides or actively promote another ideology then it cannot be allowed to stand, every rock shall understand and be under these people's influence, there shall be no book you can open, no device that you can turn on, no place where you turn your sight that doesn't feed you the ideology.
      If YOU want to consume it (even if they don't cuz they brokeass), it shall have spread to you their ideology precisely because otherwise, most likely, you're out of reach to them nor you trust them or wanna hear them preach on about their ideology. But the company you're buying a product from, they got your trust and they should abuse it to spread their worldview, even if that makes you reject your stance and not buy another product of them again. They think that there won't come products that won't go against them or just be neutral.

  • @calvincoolidge5795
    @calvincoolidge5795 Рік тому +54

    There's definitely something weird going on here with how some people are very puritanical about sexuality and fetishization in media. But Only in the ways they disagree with.
    When it comes to stuff they like and do agree with, they are completely fine with it being Sexy and easy to fetishize. The Furies who call people porn addicts for wanting sexy women in video games, when their twitter page is filled with fury porn is just one example of this hypocrisy I can think of.
    I'm sure there is much much more.

    • @GeneralTantzu
      @GeneralTantzu Рік тому

      Being a furry is being some sort of porn addict automatically.
      How can you not be a deranged individual when you wack it to animal characters.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому

      Anything other than normal "husband and wife sexuality" is a mental malady. Period.

  • @horatiusromanus
    @horatiusromanus Рік тому +22

    Does it ever bother anyone that the same people that say, "Gender stereotypes are stupid and not real," are the same people that say if someone is slightly feminine if they are a man they MUST be trans? They are also the people who dress in the most gender stereotyped clothes in the world.

    • @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz
      @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz Рік тому +9

      If it wasnt for double speak, theyd have nothing to say.

    • @slydoorkeeper4783
      @slydoorkeeper4783 Рік тому +7

      I've been saying it for a while. If someone is a femboy, they can't just be a femboy, they HAVE to be trans and will eventually come out of their "egg". Same for tomboys. Overall though, its funny how porn ridden that crowd is and how much it influences their judgement. It has gotten to the point where I almost just assume trans people were either abused, or became addicted to porn.

    • @Friendly_Neigborhood_Astolfo
      @Friendly_Neigborhood_Astolfo Рік тому

      Those are 2 separate people talking?

    • @q-tip9962
      @q-tip9962 Рік тому

      Finally, a good fucking comment that doesn't make me want to commit Roblox over braindead discourse of how "PeOpLe ArE pUsHiNg WoKe AgEnDa On OuR vIdEo GaMeS"
      In my personal experience, the people who are saying "x is trans", or "x not dating y is homophobic" are typically people are aren't trans or gay themselves. True trans activists are the ones who want people to be themselves, they don't call Femboys like me eggs that are in the closet, and they don't get outrage over petty stuff like this.

  • @thorny7138
    @thorny7138 11 місяців тому +10

    It's like people don't know what "wearing a disguise" is anymore.

  • @joji8725
    @joji8725 Рік тому +28

    Even if I was any of the identities they support I'd be so completely insulted. they don't care about you as a person but as a commodity, a product, a means to an end.

    • @MissRora
      @MissRora Рік тому +7

      I meet a few of their "sacred cow" criteria (female, bi), and you hit the nail on the head. The goal isn't even normalization like Dev claims; if that were the case, they'd leave us alone and let us be normal. Instead, we get... _all of this bullshit._

    • @lainiwakura1776
      @lainiwakura1776 Рік тому +2

      It's why they worship corporations so much.

  • @skyfoil
    @skyfoil Рік тому +16

    I love how Link is portrayed in BotW and TotK. He's a typical, to the T brave knight who risks life and limb for his kingdom and for its princess. He quite literally threw himself into a black abyss to save Zelda despite minutes ago being mortally wounded by Ganondorf. He's an honourable hero you can't help but admire. But something about seeing this honest, steadfast hero being torn down to be a gay twink all because he had to cross dress that one time really bothers me and I hate it.

  • @Custodian_Hiom
    @Custodian_Hiom Рік тому +51

    Little fun fact about Vivian I vaguely remember; in the european spanish manual for the game it is stated that Vivian is in fact a girl, but because she was way prettier than her sisters and they were incredibly jealous, they convinced her that she was in fact male in order to psychologically abuse her. Sadly I don't have a manual to confirm this and I'm not paying 200€ for the OG game just to read the manual.

    • @crakhaed
      @crakhaed Рік тому +16

      That is pretty fucked up and dark if they did that, damn lol

    • @GeneralTantzu
      @GeneralTantzu Рік тому +15

      Holy shit, that sounds dark af

    • @inkubus6192
      @inkubus6192 Рік тому +5

      Considering the Bridget debacle, taking someone who was abused into their identity and claiming that as an ideological win seems par for the course for these freaks.

    • @based980
      @based980 Рік тому

      wow

    • @Zerarick
      @Zerarick 9 місяців тому

      Fun fact, in the original Japanese version Vivian is an otokonoko

  • @dominicperez3777
    @dominicperez3777 Рік тому +37

    19:33 - 19:47 Holy shit. She went off unhinged. Ladies and gentlemen this is actual cultural marxism. This is what wokeness looks like. Wow... Gatekeep your fandoms from activists, people.

    • @xxkankala1671
      @xxkankala1671 Рік тому

      Literally what? Calm down its not the big deal

    • @BisexualPlagueDoctor
      @BisexualPlagueDoctor Рік тому

      ??? Alright first off, extremists exist on both sides, weird people exist everywhere, second off, seriously? What?? Why do people intentionally believe something that is literally inherently not good, like the extremist takes it way too fucking far trying to be good, but actively being against.. change???? What????
      And I don’t mean this specific example, I mean you being against activism as an idea, and using ‘wokeness’ as a term, which inherently means the same thing as ‘wake up, open your eyes’, just by the name
      Using wokeness to describe people like this is insulting yourself, because saying they are woke implies they are right, just call them idiots

  • @Jack93885
    @Jack93885 Рік тому +10

    The egg thing is insidious. I ended up having to quit my job because every day I'd go to work and my mind would be stuck in this gender identity crisis (one which I had already gotten over in my younger years). It really messed me up for a bit.

  • @bobbydyne
    @bobbydyne Рік тому +26

    Weird how people, that base their whole personality on who they like to bump uglies with, constantly make non-sexual things sexual

  • @SwordsmanOrion
    @SwordsmanOrion Рік тому +7

    I always felt weird and upset about the way Bridget's character in Guilty Gear Strive was retconned and assassinated, but then I learned that Arcsys had recently set up a NA branch in California and now that entire forced character assassination made complete sense.

  • @EdwardPHandsBasedManchild
    @EdwardPHandsBasedManchild Рік тому +31

    It was bizarre seeing the reaction to Sidon being engaged.
    These folks really want their headcanon to be actual canon.
    Least the meltdown made for good entertainment.

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому

      I’m not a fan of it being injected in everything - but com’on you know Sidons not into it.

    • @GeneralTantzu
      @GeneralTantzu Рік тому +9

      Sidon getting a waifu was a wholesome moment. Let them seethe.

    • @svagglaorde4387
      @svagglaorde4387 Рік тому +3

      And them launching her wife to space with their rocket ship builds in game should at least trigger some kind of boss fight with Sidon.

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому

      Well, they are gramnschian so they want reality to be what they think reality should be for the good of the oppressed and the revolution.

    • @soomitsunami5936
      @soomitsunami5936 Рік тому

      @@svagglaorde4387Sidon:FUCK YOU LINK SHE WAS MY WIFE NOT YOU I NEVER LOVED YOU WIERDO

  • @silentnight3192
    @silentnight3192 Рік тому +51

    You should care. They are trying to push politics where they weren't any.

    • @AGamingEntity
      @AGamingEntity Рік тому

      every piece of media ever (whether consciously or not) does this, you only notice it when its politics you disagree with

    • @harrygenderson6847
      @harrygenderson6847 Рік тому +1

      There is a sense in which all video games are political. Or at least, all stories. Any story must have some kind of narrative, with themes and through-lines that guide it. These themes are in turn formed by a set of values, and to some degree represent those values. In this sense, every story and its values are linked, but stand on their own, and don't necessarily represent the current zeitgeist. Attempting to subvert and replace the values these beloved stories are built upon is then akin to heresy from within the perspective of the story.

    • @kaizokujimbei143
      @kaizokujimbei143 Рік тому +7

      @@harrygenderson6847 You conflate politics with morality and virtue. Politics is not the only thing that exists and it certainly is not the most encompassing.

    • @harrygenderson6847
      @harrygenderson6847 Рік тому +2

      @@kaizokujimbei143 Alright, point taken. While politics is indeed concerned with values, specifically with regard to how to govern, not all values pertain to politics. Therefore not everything is or can be political.

  • @half-bakedpotato1078
    @half-bakedpotato1078 Рік тому +13

    My sisters are all very obsessed with all things pride related and will assign sexuality to all characters even when it doesn’t really matter. They all use they/them or he/him for Naoto and ship her with Kanji as a gay couple. This misses the point of both of their arcs, which basically mirror each other. Kanji is either a straight or possibly bi man who likes cute things, but dresses and acts like a tough guy and is attracted to Naoto before and after it’s revealed she’s a girl (kinda like Li Shang in Mulan). Part of his arc is to accept that even as a man, it’s okay to like typically girly things and it doesn’t necessarily mean you’re gay. I understand people wanting representation, but don’t feed into stereotypes to claim it. As a woman, I feel more empowered by a story like Naoto’s than one about a totally stereotypical woman.
    As for Link, he’s kind of meant to be a blank slate, so I get people imprinting themselves onto him, but putting words into the mouth of a protagonist who can’t speak is kinda icky. He gets enough of that from all the characters in the game lol. If he seems gay to you, that’s your head canon. If he’s trans to you, whatever. All I care about is cutting the grass and breaking pots for money 😉

  • @Higesgirl
    @Higesgirl Рік тому +112

    I will always say this, Link has alwas been a bishie aka a pretty boy. Even his official art (Ocarina of Time, Twilight Princess, Skyward Sword, and even the newest ones) he looks really attractive (cute and handsome). Just because he's a pretty boy that doesn't make him gay.

    • @lostinadifferentworld2752
      @lostinadifferentworld2752 Рік тому

      Why you so pressed about it tho? 😅

    • @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle
      @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle Рік тому +29

      ​@@lostinadifferentworld2752didn't realize having a rational objection to an opinion you disagree with is being "pressed" but when has that ever stopped you from saying stupid shit?

    • @lostinadifferentworld2752
      @lostinadifferentworld2752 Рік тому

      @@ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle Yeah, you totally don't seem pressed at all 😂

    • @lostinadifferentworld2752
      @lostinadifferentworld2752 Рік тому +1

      @@ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle How much of a basement dwelling chronically online weirdo do you have to be to actually care about this let alone even be aware of it? 😂

    • @Luminus2
      @Luminus2 Рік тому +14

      That's not being pretty, that's being young. He's around 17 years old. Young Link is around 11 years old.

  • @TheCoolerDrilis
    @TheCoolerDrilis Рік тому +8

    13:16
    Funny thing is that not only was it a waste of time, but even though Bill and Frank _were_ gay in the game, the episode still goes against the canon by portraying it as a happy relationship when, in the game, Frank hated Bill so much he decided suicide was preferable to spending another moment with him.

  • @TheRealW.S.Foster
    @TheRealW.S.Foster Рік тому +17

    (8:07) Lynels went from "It's a pleasure to meet you, sir" to *_"Your daughter calls me daddy, too."_*
    *Edit:* I added the time stamp

  • @DoctorLazertron
    @DoctorLazertron Рік тому +17

    Wait til they find out Link is Catholic.

  • @doomerhumor5479
    @doomerhumor5479 Рік тому +106

    If they made Link gay I would not get the game. Because it would be obvious that they did it for political points.

    • @puffbair
      @puffbair Рік тому

      im gonna fucking kill myself i cant take this shit anymore i hate being political just because im pansexual or gay or w/e tf why tf cant i just be normal🙈🔫

  • @Zetact_
    @Zetact_ Рік тому +28

    Poison's entire situation is extremely convoluted and based largely on playing a game of telephone with various statements made almost two decades after Final Fight's release that don't really mesh with all the known evidence.
    The common reference to Poison being changed from a woman to a trans woman was in "All About Capcom" interview with Nishitani (the game's designer) who gave the story of changing Poison after the release out of fears of backlash from the West. But this is not entirely accurate with what happened in the localization. The Japanese manual for the SNES port in fact does label Poison as a Newhalf so if it was a post-release thing then it was as early as the first Japanese SNES port (approximately one year after the Arcade release in Japan) and Poison has been established as trans from that point forward (in Japanese media). I think that the confusion is that in the US release Poison and Roxy were LITERALLY replaced with men, Billy and Sid, in the English release - they weren't retconned as trans specifically for the English release, they were cut from the game entirely.
    Also that there was a statement from Capcom USA saying it was tasteless to have your characters beating up women and was given the response of "there are no female enemies in the game" and when he brought up Roxy the designers responded with pointing out the character was a "crossdresser" but Capcom USA decided to replace the sprites anyway. I've heard that this is something in the book "Game Over: How Nintendo Conquered the World" first published in 1993 so it's the closest we've ever gotten to the release for the story but it doesn't really say anything other than "Poison and Roxy were already trans at that time in Japan and Capcom USA simply decided to replace them with Billy and Sid to prevent confusion." The exchange suggests that there probably was some official documentation that the Japanese team sent to the USA team and the USA team probably just didn't know what "Newhalf" meant.
    But the statement of it being something that didn't happen during the design process is also called into question when some of the concept art later came up and there's a note in the art labeling Poison's concept as "Newhalf" and based on most of the statements made it seems like that idea was always in the minds of the creators and it might even have been due to potential fear of backlash over hitting women but they didn't come up with a consistent answer. Various people involved with Final Fight have given conflicting answers on things, sometimes changing their own details. Likely it was something they had a brief but ultimately unimportant chat about during the design process and nobody really remembers it that well. The most recent statement was made by Ono where he seems to think the only regional difference is whether Poison is pre or post op. But people who directly worked on Final Fight have pretty much taken the stance of, "We don't know, decide for yourself."
    Some main bullet points:
    * it is likely that the decision was made out of a fear of offending people but from concept art to the Japanese releases it's always been something in mind.
    * Poison was canonically and officially referred to as such as early as the first Japanese SNES port.
    * The "replaced with men in the US release" is a misconception about Poison and Roxy being given full-on sprite edits to make them different characters.
    * Capcom's official statements have been conflicting all over the place.

    • @settame1
      @settame1 Рік тому +6

      Damn. That’s the most coherent and well informed comment I’ve seen in a long time.

    • @KaNoMikoProductions
      @KaNoMikoProductions Рік тому +1

      "* Poison was canonically and officially referred to as such as early as the first Japanese SNES port."
      As what?

    • @TheFatalcrest
      @TheFatalcrest Рік тому +2

      So they made the game, corporate was nervous of offending the western market (because they have issues with depicting violence to women in media) and they then started to struggle to justify the characters to try to appeal to market in the hopes it would be a good excuse....😂 bruh I'd sooner say "fuck it we selling it in Japan until these guys want it" but ey, this is why I'm not in business meetings. I took their word on it anyhow, and I'm okay with Poison as a cross dresser or not, I like the look of the character and the fact they beat people up.

    • @Zetact_
      @Zetact_ Рік тому +3

      @@KaNoMikoProductions In the manual for the Super Famicom port of Final Fight, Poison is referred to as a Newhalf.

    • @KaNoMikoProductions
      @KaNoMikoProductions Рік тому

      @@Zetact_ Ok, you should probably write that in your bullet points so that "as such" actually refers back to something.

  • @Wannabechefguy
    @Wannabechefguy Рік тому +51

    I went to a middle school play last year to support the local arts. There was a trans student amongst all of the young girls (they were ftm). When talking about it with my family, I brought up how this seems to be a post-covid thing since everyone was forced inside to consume algorithmic content online and not interact with anyone outside of their immediate family. And my family thought I was insane for thinking that way. Not because they're TRAs or anything. But because they didn't think that children being unsupervised online for hours at a time is a bad thing.

    • @DankPogchamp
      @DankPogchamp Рік тому +26

      I swear, dude. If people can call others crazy for saying something completely reasonable, then this world is definitely going to Hell in a hand-basket.

    • @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089
      @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089 Рік тому

      Ftms are so sad. mtfs are among the most disgustingly fetishistic groups on the planet and are very irritating and obnoxious, but when you see an ftm 90% of the time she went through something horrific..

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +3

      What does TRA stand for?

    • @DankPogchamp
      @DankPogchamp Рік тому +8

      @@mrshmuga9 If I recall correctly, it stands for "trans rights activist".

    • @barneystinson2781
      @barneystinson2781 Рік тому +18

      My young step brothers constantly watch garbage UA-cam shorts that are extremely random and highly inappropriate for their age and their father doesn't get a flying fuck. Some people are just bad parents.

  • @magetsalive5162
    @magetsalive5162 Рік тому +7

    If it's "yours", they want it and will do whatever it takes to claim it.
    If it's "theirs", you can't have it, and if you mess with it, it's heinous violence and you need to be stopped and deplatformed.

  • @wrathfulslime1009
    @wrathfulslime1009 Рік тому +14

    Just remember how many times Link goes back to the great fairies for that level four armor upgrade. Link is a chubby chaser if anything.

    • @jesusalonso2179
      @jesusalonso2179 Рік тому +6

      Death by SNU-SNU!!!

    • @JeffHikari
      @JeffHikari Рік тому +6

      Judging by his reaction to each upgrade, he doesn't seem exactly OKAY with the process, but he's gotta get those upgrades..

  • @Isaac-lunar09
    @Isaac-lunar09 Рік тому +10

    I'd say Dev did took a long time searching for all that femboy link hentai but let's be honest. Dev probably bookmarked so of those for future reference.

  • @HeyRavenousRaven
    @HeyRavenousRaven Рік тому +14

    That one Twitter account dating way back is a prime example of malicious. Close to being evil but definitely malicious. And no, it does matter if Link is trans or not and I rather Link stays Link. Giving these freaks what they want is how things got this far and
    It's gonna keep getting worse because of goodfaithness that the freaks continue to take advantage of.
    I hate it.

  • @metallord6960
    @metallord6960 Рік тому +11

    I'm just gonna lay this out now because I feel like it gets a bad rap these day.. Shipping, on it's own, is harmless. If someone on the internet gets their rocks off by imagining two fictional characters in a relationship, whatever. It's a problem when they expect their headcanon to become canon and, in some cases, harass the creator when it doesn't.

  • @richardlee3679
    @richardlee3679 Рік тому +12

    Link is and always has been a dude, and this literally comes down to Japanese standards.
    Japan, in general, likes their male heroes slim, 'cool' and youthful. Making someone too muscly or 'manly' isn't a good thing, at least to them.
    Ike from Fire Emblem is a good example. When he got aged up for Path of Radiance, a lot of the Japanese audience complained that he looked like a 'gorilla', even though he's fairly 'standard hero build' by western standards. It didn't matter that Ike didn't even come close to western strong man standards like Arnie and Stallone, he was too muscly for a Japanese audience, at least initially.
    Link, meanwhile, is a typical Japanese hero and there's never any doubt about that IN Japan. Talk of him being a 'twink' comes entirely from western fetish communities who want to claim a popular character as 'theirs'.

    • @StarStoneWolf
      @StarStoneWolf Рік тому +5

      In How to Train Your Dragon 3, DreamWorks had to remove Hiccup's beard at the end of the film for the Asian release.
      The standards are extremely high for women, too. Double eyelid surgery and skin whitening are largely popular.
      There may be romance manga similar to beauty and the Beast but with no prince transformation at the end. But if the story trope is flipped, and the girl so much has a scar on her face, it'll get fixed up in the story pretty quickly.
      And beauty standards in Japan are so wild to the point that it's practically illegal to even be overweight. Not even kidding, the government made a law to fight against citizens' weight gain called the Metabo Law.
      With that said... I have no idea how Mario is the most iconic video game character. Short, chubby, and facial hair? Now I wanna know if they also consider Luigi to be hot there like in the west, but Google won't tell me.

  • @utubenoobie01
    @utubenoobie01 Рік тому +17

    I care if Link is gay or a girl. I care if Samus is a transistor! These characters were not created that way. If you want all the rainbow bullsh@t in your game then make a new I.P. and don't hijack existing ones!!!!
    Good vid Devon!!! Thanks buddy!!!!

  • @Monsuco
    @Monsuco Рік тому +18

    People be arguing over whether modern Link is a Twink or feminine but rule 34 artists were happy to make classic Link a shota.

    • @tatsuostatic8567
      @tatsuostatic8567 Рік тому +3

      I find that kinda disturbing because artists have a way of turning a popular character into something they're not. It's a guilty pleasure

  • @grimnir8872
    @grimnir8872 Рік тому +11

    I like how you point out Midna in the Twilight Princess game as a romantic interest, because the Official Manga ( which was still ongoing until it finished this year ) literally confirmed TP Link and Midna are an item.

  • @BigTrog1993
    @BigTrog1993 5 місяців тому +6

    Why is every "this game character is gay/trans" argument something that would be the joke of some 2012 video game parody webcomic.

  • @SouthernGothicYT
    @SouthernGothicYT Рік тому +8

    The hypocrisy never stops. It reminds me of how in the vocaloid fandom, there's an UTAU (yeah not technically vocaloid idc) by the name of Namine Ritsu, who is canonically an okama, aka cross dresser. I wouldn't know for myself having dipped out of the fandom a while ago but I bet he's already declared as trans.

    • @chirimoyan
      @chirimoyan Рік тому +4

      yep! i see a lot of (no offense, but) people new to vocaloid discovering VIPPERloids of which Ritsu is one and claiming him as a transgender woman. there are other VIPPERloids who have interesting gender identities. i forgot their names, but one of them has black pigtails and heterochromia and the other has blue hair and glasses, they are hermaphrodite and genderless respectively. both look very feminine though. of course, these two also get claimed as non binary representation.
      the thing is, VIPPERloids (and other troll loids) often have unique or eccentric designs and lore because they are made as jokes, it's to make people go "no way! they made a crossdressing rocket boobs vocaloid?!" only to immediatly discover that nope none of that is official and they've been misled. the point is, it's not serious representation so why claim it as such. idk.
      sorry i wrote a bible under your comment lol
      edit: Yokune Ruko and Taya Soune are their names :). also, i made a mistake, Soune is an UTAU not a VIPPERloid, oops

  • @fierceditiesnaruto
    @fierceditiesnaruto Рік тому +27

    I still love Link and Mipha together the most.

  • @DinkyKnag
    @DinkyKnag Рік тому +7

    A very funny side note on the Samus part is that there is an interview where Yoshio Sakamoto, the co-creator of the Metroid series, he said in summary "That the likelyhood of a Metroid game coming to the PS2 is as likely as Samus being a newhalf."
    I always think about that whenever the Samus brainrot takes hold.

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому

      Hahaha

    • @GELTONZ
      @GELTONZ Рік тому

      You know...Samus almost made it into the PS2 version of Marvel: Ultimate Alliance. Vicarious Visions was nearly torn to shreds for that one.

    • @DinkyKnag
      @DinkyKnag Рік тому +2

      @@GELTONZ They really wanted to keep this quote true, huh?

    • @shagohad3
      @shagohad3 Рік тому

      @@GELTONZ Raven Soft, you mean. Vicarious Visions made MUA 2

  • @Drucifer1018
    @Drucifer1018 8 місяців тому +4

    I actually first noticed this in the harry potter community, when you first start looking at headcannons people have its the typical fans fixing plotholes and filling in blanks for unanswered questions, but it quickly devolves into the overtly sexual gay fanfics about how sirius is gay and in love with james who is bi and lily catches them making out all the time and lupin is the ultimate furry but pettigrew is always left out because he turns out to be a villain, and it goes on and on like that, i eventually had to unfollow harry potter stuff on social media because i got tired of everything evolving into gay porn, it gets old

  • @mrshmuga9
    @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +9

    People “forget” Tracer is a lesbian because it’s an online shooter with no story, and the few cutscenes (not even in-game) that exist I don’t think feature her girlfriend. It’s basically completely meaningless. It’s easier to assume straight because reality. It’s only when she’s featured in gay pride merch (or yelled at online) that people are made aware/remember.

    • @cloud8521
      @cloud8521 Рік тому +8

      and because they made her gay long after release..... in fact they are pretty much just making every character gay and trans now. its ridiculous

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +4

      @@cloud8521 That too. We have fictional characters "coming out" years later knowing them as if they're real, lol.

    • @cloud8521
      @cloud8521 Рік тому +4

      @@mrshmuga9 every character you grew up with? nope genetic dead ends now

  • @dotmadhack
    @dotmadhack Рік тому +9

    I've always said that sexuality really doesn't matter until it's made into porn or hentai. Tracer from Overwatch is a Lesbian? Tell that to the hundreds of thousands of artists making her do any and every act. Does it affect her gameplay and mechanics? No. So why mention it? Oh, the grift, right.
    Doesn't really bother me people think Link is a Twink. Outside of porn it doesn't matter and isn't true. The truth is storywise, he's an unstoppable force that will kill anything and everything to fulfil his destiny.

  • @TheSachiPlan
    @TheSachiPlan Рік тому +15

    No, Devon. That's a Bokoblin, which are a comparatively more recent addition to the Zelda world. They're basically mini-moblins. They mostly exist to be basic enemies so the much more classic moblins can be larger tougher threats, and so moblins have underlings they can comically pick up and throw at you. And Tears of the Kingdom even gave Bokoblins their own elite variant the Boss Bokoblin who act as leaders and can even force nearby bokoblins to use tactics and form up into formations.
    Super Metroid is not the original Metroid. In Super Metroid, they make it abundantly she's a woman because it was the third game and the cat was long out of the bag. Samus being a woman in the first place was borderline a joke. It was a last minute decision based solely on how funny it would be funny if the player finds out they've been playing a girl at the end. It's great that she's developed and grown into a much more iconic character.
    Heaven help us if the progs ever find those non-canon promo comics that were written before the reveal, where the writers seriously thought she's a man.

    • @ericriley1985
      @ericriley1985 Рік тому +2

      If you're talking about the picture at 8:17, that is indeed a Moblin, the artwork being from the original Legend of Zelda from 1986. Bokoblins weren't introduced until Wind Waker. If there's any confusion, its probably because the Tears of the Kingdom footage in the background shows him fighting Bokoblins.

    • @TheSachiPlan
      @TheSachiPlan Рік тому +2

      @@ericriley1985
      I was referring to the game footage. The drawing shown is indeed an OG drawing of a moblin, but his game footage shows combat with bokoblins instead of the current moblin iteration.
      It's like a rule to give Dev a hard time for his videos. He knows it's because I care.

    • @ericriley1985
      @ericriley1985 Рік тому

      @@TheSachiPlan Got it.

  • @Mr_Jumbles
    @Mr_Jumbles Рік тому +7

    "Just let us enjoy things!"
    Unless it's what others enjoy, then they get to tell you what you're allowed to think and enjoy.

  • @krazyivan9733
    @krazyivan9733 Рік тому +8

    They literally all forgot that link was engaged to be married to mipha.

    • @thlover27
      @thlover27 10 місяців тому

      To be fair, Mipha made the armor but didn't have the chance to give it to Link before she died and he had no idea what the armor represented (the armor being basically a proposal like an engagement ring), so no he wasn't really ever engaged to Mipha. She wanted to marry him, but it's unclear if Link ever even returned her feelings like that.

  • @RorytheRomulan
    @RorytheRomulan Рік тому +6

    "They're eggs that need to be hatched!" Woman, maybe YOUR eggs need to be hatched.

  • @Maehedrose
    @Maehedrose Рік тому +34

    I am a feminine man and I get so sick of people trying to make me gay. I'm middle-aged, a modern adult, I'm comfortable with my sexuality, stop trying to force gayness on me. I just happen to be a man who only had positive female rolemodels, and abusive male figures, in my life so I ended up valuing feminine things over masculine during my formative years - thus making that a permanent part of my personality. Yet everywhere I go, people are convinced I'm gay; I'm sorry, my sexuality isn't policed by your heteronormativity. Our personalities are made up of a lot more than just our sexuality, no matter what the bigots have always wanted you to believe (whichever side of the argument they were on).

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому

      Based straight twink.

    • @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz
      @ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz Рік тому +4

      Hetero is normal, deal with it.

    • @Maehedrose
      @Maehedrose Рік тому

      @@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz You're an idiot, deal with it.

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому

      @@ALovelyBunchOfDragonballz You completely missed the point, he's saying that because he's a bit of an affeminste twink man and people want him to be and, imply he should be gay but he's straight.

  • @hunterwolf9591
    @hunterwolf9591 Рік тому +94

    I'm a femboy and this video is a massive sanity pill for me, thank you. You've put into words what has been on my mind for like the past two years, I just wanna be a bisexual femboy and be left alone, who gives a fuck what's what. The LGBTQ+ stuff has been fucking exhausting along with the trans stuff.

    • @20thcentury_toy
      @20thcentury_toy Рік тому +17

      Yeah my brother don't let the mob mentality get to you

    • @JudgeNicodemus
      @JudgeNicodemus Рік тому +13

      Stay strong lad.

    • @AiluridaeAureus
      @AiluridaeAureus Рік тому +1

      Dude saaame. I just want to be allowed to find hot girls and twinks hot in piece with all these weird indoctrinated straight people using my identity as a fucking political bludgeon for their commie retardation.

    • @assortmentofpillsbutneverb3756
      @assortmentofpillsbutneverb3756 Рік тому +10

      Yeah, its kind of funny that modern LGBT is so set in its arguments that they gender roles as strong as OG trads. One gay or trans thought/experience and you are 1000% hardcore gay forever

    • @hunterwolf9591
      @hunterwolf9591 Рік тому +10

      @@assortmentofpillsbutneverb3756 True, and I've faced the projection of them saying I'm apparently an 'egg' waiting to be hatched like mentioned in the video because of said experiences. No I'm fucking not, I'm just a guy that likes being feminine, who likes girls and guys and that's it. Some of these people can be so fucking obnoxious lol

  • @sdbzfan1
    @sdbzfan1 Рік тому +13

    I've been talking with my brother about this too
    Representation stopped feeling like Representation the moment I realized a lot of these people screaming for it just wanted the thing they liked to be popular
    Why do they always go for traps, because people like traps and not them not realizing trying to change something into something its not won't make them like you in fact it makes them hate you more
    The Aerial thing proved it the most recently
    But at the same time Spider Verse did too by being a good original movie, diversity ain't the issue, making a good product is all that matters
    A story can have gay characters like the Last of Us 1 but Last of Us 2 Showed that maturity is respecting your audience rather forcing them to understand your plight, people focusing on the gay parts is underselling the good parts of the game, I'm not gay but even then I think Ellie had a decent life with Dina only to throw it all away, thats something not specific to the gay experience but people got mad the only two gay characters didn't have a happy ending(plus the joel death) and saw it as an attack against gays like there's no winning with these people so its best to not care about the fact they want this shit the way they want to view it

    • @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089
      @enclaveherewhyisntyourvide3089 Рік тому

      They go for traps because the only people who like the 'male crossdresser' trope are people too far long gone to put up any meaningful resistance to the trans shit. The only reason it doesn't really work is because people who like traps (closet homosexuals) are so attracted to the character being male that they will endlessly complain about losing their little boy to sexually obsess over.

    • @lainiwakura1776
      @lainiwakura1776 Рік тому +1

      Also us nerds learned it's not a good thing when the thing you like is popular. I gatekeep.

  • @LukeStudioD2
    @LukeStudioD2 Рік тому +227

    He may not be gay but he is most definitely breedable

    • @desuretard8654
      @desuretard8654 Рік тому

      You're about as breedable as a fictional character.

    • @MrDarthtelos
      @MrDarthtelos Рік тому +5

      Oh yeah.

    • @JodyBruchon
      @JodyBruchon Рік тому +4

      As long as he's forced to breed all over the floor in the process.

    • @613-shadow9
      @613-shadow9 Рік тому +14

      @@JodyBruchon then you must scrub all the floors in Hyrule!

    • @JodyBruchon
      @JodyBruchon Рік тому +6

      @@613-shadow9 if it lets me fill that position then so be it!

  • @JRProductions1203
    @JRProductions1203 24 дні тому +2

    This is exactly the same thing on how I feel about the Birdo character from the Mario Brothers Games.
    Unless they say otherwise: Just because a Male Character dresses up as a Female, Doesn't automatically mean he's Trans. (At Best he's a Femboy or Gender Fluid)

  • @TheCoolerDrilis
    @TheCoolerDrilis Рік тому +4

    15:50
    Yeah, there's actually something really weird about the whole Goron thing. They were allowed into the city in BotW despite being men (and yes, they're men, not "gender-neutral," they even say so in BotW), presumably because the entire race would have to be barred otherwise, they mine and sell ores valuable to Gerudo society, Gerudo wouldn't find them sexually compatible, or a combination of those factors, and yet one trying to get into the city in TotK is denied access. Granted, that _could_ just be because he had a male Hylian companion, but it's still weird this happened in the same continuity.

  • @gothicpando
    @gothicpando Рік тому +23

    Make them stop please.
    We cant ALL be gay.
    Then there will be no more humans...
    ...wait...

    • @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle
      @ICantThinkOfAFunnyHandle Рік тому

      If there are no humans:
      Climate change will cease to exist
      Racism will cease to exist
      Capitalism will cease to exist
      [Insert]phobia will cease to exist.
      I think I just figured out their plans

    • @AndrewChumKaser
      @AndrewChumKaser Рік тому +6

      You figured out that that's actually the point.

  • @kalamitus2269
    @kalamitus2269 Рік тому +11

    Essay warning:
    You ever notice how when these regressives discuss and celebrate “trans representation in video games,” they really only ever talk about trans women?
    Think about it. Let’s say that the trans icons they constantly champion were actually trans. What would they be?
    Well, let’s bring up the most popular examples.
    Birdo from Mario: mtf
    Vivian from Paper Mario: mtf
    Poison from Final Fight/Street Fighter: mtf
    Madeleine from Celeste: mtf
    Bridget from Guilty Gear: mtf
    Samus from Metroid: They constantly push that she’s a trans woman, MTF
    Link from Legend of Zelda: As this video discusses, MTF
    Heck, I’ll even bring up the brainlets that superficially call pokémon trans because of gender ratio and design clashes (braixen, primarina, etc.) or just ones like sylveon where its color palette happens to match the trans pride flag. Guess what they do. 90% of the pokémon that they make as “trans icons” are feminine-looking pokémon that are predominantly male.
    So even with these ludicrous ideas here, they are still talking predominantly about M T F!
    *Note: lots of these pokémon are considered “fairy types” in the games.
    Ironic, isn’t it?
    But I digress.
    These are probably the most standout examples of trans icons in games that they constantly peddle out, and not a single one of them is a trans man, apart from when they push for Naoto being ftm.
    I’m sure if you dig deep enough, you’ll probably find some more trans man characters in gaming, but it’s very clear that there is a disproportionate ratio of trans women to trans men, especially in the eyes of these “activists.”

    • @chad_bro_chill
      @chad_bro_chill Рік тому +2

      A quality essay, thank you. You forgot quotes around "trans icons" in the second to last paragraph, though. Are ANY of the examples you listed actually trans? Birdo/Vivian/Bridget are all otokonoko (crossdressers) in Japan, with the first two being just female rather than mtf in most Western translations.
      Fun fact: The obviously male character in BOTW that sells you the Gerudo clothes was also named Vivian in Japan.

    • @kalamitus2269
      @kalamitus2269 Рік тому +3

      @@chad_bro_chill Thank you very much. I’m glad you liked it. I did want to respond to some things though.
      Yeah, the “let’s say the trans icons they constantly champion were actually trans” part was supposed to be taken like “let’s assume that these characters were actually trans and not just crossdressers.” I probably could have worded that better.
      As for the rest of your comment.
      I left out the second pair of quotations around “trans icons” because
      a) I was lazy lol
      and
      b) I figured people would see my usage of the term with my previous quotation and put two-and-two together on how I was using it.
      I see what you mean with Vivian and… Vivian lol. To be honest, I didn’t know that much about Vivian. All I knew was that there was some controversy about the character, and I just… strayed away from it and never looked back lol.
      Bridget is _technically_ trans now. Lead developer of Guilty Gear said so.
      That doesn’t mean I agree with the decision though.
      Oh no.
      _Very_ much the opposite in fact. (whole ‘nother can of worms though)
      But if the artist wants to burn his own art, you can’t really stop his own free choice, right? _sigh_
      Birdo afaik is trans. The Super Mario Bros 2 instructions describe Birdo as “a guy who thinks he is a girl.” Granted, Birdo is a weird case as Nintendo does a lot of weird things with her pronouns and gender and whatnot as I’m sure you and everybody else knows. In recent games, she’s called by she/her pronouns, but I can’t tell if it’s Nintendo retconning her to be an actual girl, or if they are secretly going that whole “trans women are women” route. It’s all very muddled.
      The Poison stuff is actually news to me though lol. I knew about them changing her into a cross dresser to avoid controversy, but I never knew that it only applied to Western games. Makes me curious what Street Fighter 5 (SFV) did with her story, then. I never actually read into it, sooooooo yeah lol.
      And, while I’m at it, here’s a fun fact for you:
      Poison’s English VA in SFV is voiced by Karen Straussman.
      Not only is she *not* trans, but twitter has actually labeled her as an anti-BLM *TERF!*
      Oh! Again, the irony.
      Chef’s kiss.
      Again, thank you for the reply. I’m glad to actually talk about this with someone for once lol.
      *Edit: Spelling/grammar corrections and other comments/revisions.

  • @mkv2718
    @mkv2718 Рік тому +116

    Instead of “cis,” can we just call them “actual?”

    • @Saint_Wolf_
      @Saint_Wolf_ Рік тому

      Cis being literally coined to shame people who don't have the regime's approved of mental illness, so yea, I'm all for saying "real women" or "actual women".

    • @jht3fougifh393
      @jht3fougifh393 Рік тому +13

      I vote for no prefix.

    • @juuchanIRL
      @juuchanIRL Рік тому +20

      or just "normal"

    • @selinnazsur2328
      @selinnazsur2328 Рік тому +6

      @@jht3fougifh393 I second that but I still like OP's sass 😂

    • @flamestoyershadowkill
      @flamestoyershadowkill Рік тому +2

      Or let's be cool and call ourselves gestalt

  • @Toygains
    @Toygains Рік тому +8

    If these questions come to your mind while playing a game you're probably not wrapped too tight.

  • @Dumbledoresarmy13
    @Dumbledoresarmy13 Рік тому +8

    Wow, that Tails one is a contortionist level stretch. Almost all young boy cartoon characters were played by women in the past...because obviously if you use a real boy you run the risk of having like an Alphonse Elric situation where the English VA couldn't voice him in Brotherhood because puberty. Obviously to avoid that problem altogether you hire an adult woman to do a young boy voice.

  • @MisterVyle
    @MisterVyle Рік тому +12

    "We can't write good trans character so we'll take all the normal ones" Thats a pretty unhealthy mindset tbh

    • @hope-cat4894
      @hope-cat4894 Рік тому +2

      And shows how creatively bankrupt they are. They can't write a trans character that is as beloved and iconic as Indiana Jones, Link, or Princess Lea, so they just attach themselves to other established characters and force them into the LGBT community and act like all the work has been done.
      It reminds me of when the advice to write female characters was just write a male character and change the gender around. This way you don't get bogged down by trying to make the character perfect and allows them to be human. It honestly was better advice than what we are getting now.

  • @thejudge4421
    @thejudge4421 Рік тому +13

    link is a gigachad that gets mad women

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +3

      In a bunch of games too. Fromnamed characters like: Zelda, Malon, Saria, Ruto, Ilia, Midna, and Paya to random NPC women. Some female NPC in TotK hit on Link, got embarrassed, and then said he was too clingy when I kept clicking the option to “not forget” what happened, lol.

  • @ace0135
    @ace0135 Рік тому +7

    You know dude is wilin’ when he doesn’t end his video with an “I love you”

  • @Antenacactus
    @Antenacactus Рік тому +12

    The ending of bayonetta 3 is an example of a Japanese dev getting rid of characters people love and replacing them with a character everyone hates

    • @ShortFatOtaku
      @ShortFatOtaku  Рік тому

      tbh i didn't mind the new character

    • @mrshmuga9
      @mrshmuga9 Рік тому +4

      I think it’s probably a fake out given a number of details. Also, Bayo killed God in the first game, and rescued Jeanne from Hell. I wouldn’t take anything the game says as “permanent” seriously. They’ll make some excuse to reverse/contradict it 10s later.