Corruption Arcs and Agency: GOT vs. Hannibal
Вставка
- Опубліковано 17 жов 2024
- TW for slight gore // SPOILER WARNING for GOT season 8 and all three seasons of Hannibal // Take a deep dive into the structure of corruption arcs, and find out why Daenerys’ arc in season 8 was so unsatisfying…
~=+=~
Written, narrated, and edited by Davy Rey Stoces
Their channel: / @postmortem1704
~=+=~
Resources:
“Writing Stories of Corruption and Madness” - Savage Books
• Writing Stories of Cor...
“Learn 5 Types of Character Arc at a Glance: The 3 Negative Arcs (Part 2 of 2)” - K.M. Weiland
www.helpingwri...
“Just What The Humping Heck Is ‘Character Agency,’ Anyway?” - Chuck Wendig
terribleminds.c...
~=+=~
Music credits:
Gymnopedie No. 1 by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
Waltz (Tschikovsky Op. 40) by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
Virtutes Instrumenti by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
Trio for Piano Violin and Viola by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
Sonatina in C Minor by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
Toccata and Fugue in D Minor by Kevin MacLeod
Link: incompetech.fi...
License: creativecommons...
The NBC Hannibal was one of the most twisted love stories ever told. I think it's my favorite show ever.
The show that left me the most disappointed and the show that gives me the greatest joy to this day. Hannibal>GoT
Ahhh Hannibal!
I thought Hannibal was rushed in 3rd season. I loved it but certain things should have been elaborated.
3rd season was definitely rushed. Francis as a character was underdeveloped and the final episode didn't really feel like a final ep, felt like they just had a good finale and tried to scrap up an episode to reach that point
This is helpful, as someone studying corruption arcs who doesn't want to slog through Game of Thrones to study why that one didn't work. Haha. I gave up on that show after Season 5. Thank you for doing this analysis so I didn't have to! :P
Oh, I see. If Dany had a Hannibal in her life instead of a bunch of sorry-sap yes men then season 8 wouldn't have been the dumpster fire that it was so clearly was. Got it. Well done synopsis 🤓
I love a season 4 . Confirmed that Will and Hannibal lived
Can’t believe i’m only finding this now! Absolutely amazing work!!
Wondeful essay. I love hannibal story writing and cinematograhpy, absolute masterpiece. The video essay is absolutely great too, helpful on studying how to write a good corruption arc
Thank you for this comparison. It really makes lots of senses and it is really well executed. In other words, trauma is not corruption, nor is it necessary the cause
GOD I FUCKING LOVE THIS
Oooo I’m late to this video but this is a great look at how both shows handled one of their main character’s corruption!
I knew how Dany would end up because Miura's "Berserk" is my favorite series and she was very like Griffith (at least, when she was still well written) and I hoped she'd give Jon a betrayal moment that was a epic as Griffith's.
I think the first major mistake of her character arc is the way she just breezed out of Slaver's Bay. Didn't set up a democratic ruling body or anything about food/refugees/economy - that could easily be a slog, but not addressing it at all was weird.
She could've ended up in Westeros easily winning, but making demands of various houses to help settle and feed her refugees (Including of Jon) and when that goes as well as you'd expect - she retaliates with burning things. It's still totally within character - she's still the hero in her own head and Jon still has motivation to stab her.
Her descent into madness would've worked so much better as a slowburn. I felt nothing when she died. I feel more for the characters on HOTD then I ever did for her.
gotta acknowledge a fellow berserk fan 🫡 respect mate may the godhand save you and keep you from harm
4 years late to the party, but.
Great essay that surprisingly gave me some new thoughts about Will's character development.
Thank you for your work.
this is an incredible analysis thank you so much for making it!!
This was a beautiful analysis, thank you
Well done!
It's actually a good vedio, can you recommend Sourcess on writing corruption arcs?
Perfect video ❤
Which got theme is used in the start?
thank you.
GOT was ruined when it deviated from the narrative GRR Martin actually wrote.
Love Hannibal ❤❤❤