Acheron VS Sunday! Who Is Stronger Acheron Or Sunday In Honkai Star Rail Story Lore

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 136

  • @TheNamelessKaslana
    @TheNamelessKaslana  2 місяці тому +7

    Thank you very much for watching ❤
    If you are new here, help us to hit 10k subscribers by subscribing my channel and sharing it with your friends ❤

  • @MaliciousVeracity
    @MaliciousVeracity 2 місяці тому +3

    2:39 Boothill made a point of saying she knows exactly when to hold back and when to show no mercy, so "hesitancy" is canonically not a weakness of hers. Even Welt said he understood why she's so reluctant to draw her blade because she would've damaged the entire dreamscape were it not for Aventurine's power being from the path of preservation.
    She's also not a psychopath, all she wanted was Duke Inferno's invite, so, naturally, she didn't want to kill him.
    I don't know about lack of physical strength being Sunday's weakness either, because unless it's current Sunday who's powerless anyway, you can't even challenge him to a physical fight in the first place. I mean, you were automatically in Ena's dream and his mercy just by being inside the Asdana system.
    As for who is stronger, Acheron is flat-out immune to everything Sunday can do while Sunday can't return the favor. So Acheron.

  • @omnaaa
    @omnaaa 2 місяці тому +8

    I think it’d be Acheron and I’m saying it as a big Sunday fan. But I also want to remind you guys of the fact that Acheron may not be as resistant to the dreams’ influence (which Sunday directly controlled) as she claims to be and it’s directly shown in 2.1 quest.
    When Welt and Acheron went to Sunday’s mansion to investigate, Acheron said “I’ll use my powers of nihility to make myself invisible to others” or smth of the sort. Then Sunday comes into picture and he acknowledges her head on. And it’s not just a writing mistake in my opinion because it’s Shaoji we’re taking about so it was deliberate. He and his team are known to put a lot of thought into the dialogues, npc, side quests which makes me believe that 100% was smth that the players were supposed to catch on to. Even the fact that Sunday paused before acknowledging her works from a writing stand point, to build the suspense.
    So yeah. Overall I think by raw strength Acheron is very strong but Sunday has some sort of resistance to her powers at least in the dream. Aside from that it’s hard to tell.

    • @jade7631
      @jade7631 2 місяці тому +2

      In base form. If it is the embryo of philosophy, then Sunday is stronger.

    • @lesterism
      @lesterism 2 місяці тому +1

      ​​​​​​@@jade7631embryo of philosophy got beaten by the crew. He's not on par in Acheron's level especially she nullifies the Order's authorities as shown in the climax where she destroyed Ena's Dream to help wake up everyone in Penacony. Keep in mind that base Septimus can only trap non Emanator characters in AOE and his strongest version got beaten by the Crew and Robin. There's nothing that stops Acheron from one tapping Embryo of Philosophy. Also you're wrong, Acheron is the most powerful character we've seen strengthwise as already shown by her feats alone and we've never seen her going all out and her conceptual hax is superior compared to Sunday, just goes to show how far Emanators scales compared to Pathstriders like Sunday

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +1

      @@omnaaa Bro, what? So just because it's Shaoji means that Sunday's acknowledgement of Acheron isn't a writing mistake?
      Also that was just a momentary fluke. We clearly see Acheron casually resisting the Dreamscape's influence later on, which btw trapped millions of people and even destroyed it. It's either a writing fluke or the Nihility is not meant to be used secretively as Mei wasn't even that shocked that Sunday could see her.

    • @rickelmehanwinckel2699
      @rickelmehanwinckel2699 21 день тому

      ​@@lesterisma weakened Sunday that was in conflict if what he was doing is good or bad,that was figting It his own sister and even after it dominicus was show not a single scratch

  • @ShiraFuyu2022
    @ShiraFuyu2022 2 місяці тому +12

    Let it be known that Dreammaster went out of his way to kick Mei out of Penacony because of what she can do
    Mei was the key for everyone to break out of Ena's Dream since she's the only one that can match Harmonious Choir's power
    And lastly, she's the only one that's blatantly unaffected by Ena's Dream. Everyone has to wake up by finding a flawed in their dream
    So yeah, in terms of people featurer Penacony Mei is undoubtedly the Strongest one. And if anyone tried to say Welt, try doing that when he's a Proper Herrscher

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +3

      Not to mention, Mei left the Dreamscape herself. Dreammaster didn't do shit against her.

    • @dark_wolf260
      @dark_wolf260 2 місяці тому +1

      Correction: Only by finding a flaw is that they can know it's a dream, escaping is a whole different thing, and there's just 3 ways for that:
      - External help (What the Astral Express got)
      - Dying (What Firefly did)
      - Having a stronger willpower than the caster (Robin's case, that girl is secretly overpowered)

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому

      The Dream Master didnt do shit though. She just see herself the way out because she need go to express

    • @necasa4919
      @necasa4919 2 місяці тому

      ​@@shutup1037 Which actually supports the initial idea. It has to "ask" her to leave, because she would have defeated it easily if she didn't decide to comply.

  • @DeathkaiserG
    @DeathkaiserG 2 місяці тому +4

    Honestly, if Acheron doesnt have an objective or qualms in killing people. She would have destroyed entire penacony quest easily.

  • @lesterism
    @lesterism 2 місяці тому +1

    Acheron is immune to Sunday's authority plus he's not an Emanator = Sunday gets negged

  • @muhammadhanry7907
    @muhammadhanry7907 2 місяці тому +5

    Sunday get some power-up / benefit from both Stellaron and his own home world (Penacony) ... Also he got the power from all members of the Oak Family plus.. Blessing from the Order since he is one of the Order's Children...
    So in this case i think Mei (Acheron) is stronger than him...

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому

      @@muhammadhanry7907 yet still beaten by the express that previously beaten by him

  • @ikuto1318
    @ikuto1318 2 місяці тому +11

    Sunday the 🐐

  • @shallot7697
    @shallot7697 2 місяці тому +12

    My boy Sunday would've soloed everyone on Penacony if Acheron wasn't following the Nihility. Sunday is the strongest until now

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +12

      Doesn't that just mean Sunday is the strongest excluding Acheron? Which in case, he's the second strongest since Acheron is also a part of the Penacony cast, heck she wasn't even included in the final battle.

    • @dark_wolf260
      @dark_wolf260 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@djaxeman2424She wasn't included bcuz she would have stolen the spotlight

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому

      Sunday have stellaron and home advantage

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +1

      @@dark_wolf260 exactly. Mei would just murk wing boi.

    • @zeee3play757
      @zeee3play757 2 місяці тому +1

      He is technically still the strongest....

  • @NotDanch
    @NotDanch 2 місяці тому

    Great video and analysis! If I could make a suggestion, I believe light music in the background could help the overall quality and enjoyability of the video.

  • @EonOfDestruction
    @EonOfDestruction 2 місяці тому +8

    Sunday

  • @herrscherelysia5008
    @herrscherelysia5008 2 місяці тому +1

    They are both Top 1 and 2 in the story

  • @captainvalkyrie999
    @captainvalkyrie999 2 місяці тому +1

    It took the combination of the entire Astral Express, Robin's power and MC getting the Harmony Path to stand up to Sunday's monster form. Acheron would have a hard time.
    Sure Acheron is the Nihility's Emanator, but considering Sunday's Ultimate involves him making contact with (I think) Ena's hand which unleashes a huge explosion, it's definitely a close one.

    • @ShiraFuyu2022
      @ShiraFuyu2022 2 місяці тому

      @@captainvalkyrie999 that Monster Form is Xipe's Emanator

    • @nyes4596
      @nyes4596 2 місяці тому +2

      To be HONEST, i do think Acheron could be stronger, since the Nihility is able to cut off the Harmony brands off of Aventurine, what makes her unable to cut off Ena's power from Sunday? I mean, he's not a choosen Emanator but he is still having a power as strong as one, no?

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +3

      None of them, I mean none of them are close to how powerful Acheron is. There's a very good reason why Acheron wasn't involved in the final battle. Nihility is one big F U to most paths.

    • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
      @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@djaxeman2424Nah. Welt should scale closely to her, just without the resistance to other paths.

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +1

      @@jakeblitzcoffie4859 Prime Welt. Not current Welt. Man couldn't even put down the Abundance Deer while Mei two-shotted Aventurine with Diamond's abilities without trying.

  • @Sparkle367
    @Sparkle367 2 місяці тому +2

    I hope Sunday is playable

  • @capedcluckles
    @capedcluckles 2 місяці тому

    Sunday got his power taken away from him 😂😂😂

  • @flaviadossantossantos7093
    @flaviadossantossantos7093 2 місяці тому +1

    Acheron

  • @matteogalbusera1149
    @matteogalbusera1149 2 місяці тому +1

    Sunday, I mean, Acheron might be one of the two strongest character in the game, but Sunday is the final boss of penacony and she need our help to defeat him making him stronger

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому +4

      Nah, WE are the one that need her help

    • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
      @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@shutup1037 It was both. She needed our help. We needed hers.

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому

      @@jakeblitzcoffie4859 yea she need help only because she want entire asdana system to wake up

    • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
      @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому

      @@shutup1037 Right. Her shattering the dreamscape has nothing to do with her being more powerful than Sunday in a 1v1. That's simply a perk of the Nihility.

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому

      @@jakeblitzcoffie4859 you are forgetting Sunday using boost from Stellaron and other power sources 💀

  • @randomasian8715
    @randomasian8715 2 місяці тому

    We all agree sampo no diffs

  • @leonardobittencourt918
    @leonardobittencourt918 2 місяці тому

    I think acheron is a little stronger

  • @Akane_k.l
    @Akane_k.l 2 місяці тому

    acheron mid diff mostly, if not then high diff at most

  • @smallpp8891
    @smallpp8891 2 місяці тому +2

    Sunday was fighting the entire asdana system/ galaxy rangers/ IPC/ SAM/ memokeepers Acheron was only fighting Sunday.
    Sunday stronger

    • @shutup1037
      @shutup1037 2 місяці тому +3

      What😂 he is not fighting them, he is just manipulating them. Also all the planned came from previous Dream Master

    • @zaynyeinaung2343
      @zaynyeinaung2343 2 місяці тому +2

      U words are same as ur profile

    • @smallpp8891
      @smallpp8891 2 місяці тому +1

      @@shutup1037 as the fraud Acheron stood before the strongest in asdana, he began to open his domain:
      *“Stand proud, Acheron, you were strong”*
      Domain expansion: sign of order
      The domain makes it so it’s impossible to attack Sunday unless the trapped target follows a clearly labelled sign and walk towards Sunday.
      Acheron loses her way, walks in the opposite direction and falls off penacony
      Sunday stronger

    • @necasa4919
      @necasa4919 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@smallpp8891what...?

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +2

      @@necasa4919 JJK brain rot. Don't ask.

  • @shutup1037
    @shutup1037 2 місяці тому +1

    Sunday need to use Stellaron. Enough

    • @vietcuongnguyenle8530
      @vietcuongnguyenle8530 2 місяці тому +1

      The stellaron is to make the dream world stable
      He not use it for the fight

  • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
    @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому +5

    Sunday 100%. Not even Acheron could wake everyone up by herself. On top of that, if Acheron is really more powerful, why wouldn't she just go 1v1 him herself? A whole galaxy was at risk, and she was doing nothing to save it besides shattering the dreamscape. It's pretty obvious to me that Sunday is stronger. He wasn't just an Emanator, but the dude was on the brink of becoming a new Aeon. He was even able to summon part of the Harmony Aeon during the fight. Acheron wouldn't have chosen to leave Penacony if she could one-shot Sunday. The only reason she was asked to leave was because her power countered the dreamscape. But other than that, I wouldn't put her above Sunday. Now, if this was a fight in reality separate from the dreamscape of the Order, Acheron would win.

    • @yassinegacha-nm2wm
      @yassinegacha-nm2wm 2 місяці тому +4

      : its acheron its not even close 1 : nihility is inaffected by the other paths(she said that in the story ) . So sunday cant do shit to her .2: its because if acheron uses her power she would leave a lot of harm in the battle and cause dmg .But she instead chose to destroy the harmonious chair which posses the power of an emenator . while opening the path to the others to deal with it to reduce the harm and dmg . remember that millions of people exist in the dreamscape do you want to risk killing them in the process ? just like welt confirmed in the story acheron one slash at aventurine could have destroyed the whole dreamscape . SO this is more of she wanting to solve the problem rather than making it worse

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +2

      @@jakeblitzcoffie4859 "Dude was on the brink of becoming a new Aeon" how in the hell did he lose to the Astral Express and Robin then, who are much weaker than Acheron. The last time, the Express battled Phantylia with Jing Yuan's help, they had to outsmart her cause she was destroying them.
      Acheron didn't duel Sunday because it was the Astral Express's fight, not hers. Secondly, did you see the damage Acheron did with one slash to the Dreamscape before the final battle? She wasn't trying btw. Mei was legit trying to minimize the damage because a clash between Emanators results in a whole lot of destruction. Which is why the Express and Robin fought Sunday when his power got nerfed after Acheron severed the Dreamscape. There wouldn't be much collateral damage and the Nameless could claim Penacony back.

    • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
      @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому +1

      @djaxeman2424 Why would she risk billons of people's lives over something like that? It makes no sense. If what you are saying is true, you must also apply that to Welt as well, who actually has a reason for not trying or using Star of Eden. There would be too much collateral damage. The dude is a walking blackhole. If he had wanted it, Sunday would've been dead after breaking free from the Dreamscape. The same applies to Acheron. The thing is, she didn't do everything alone. She had help from multiple people. If she could do it all herself, she would have definitely done so.

    • @djaxeman2424
      @djaxeman2424 2 місяці тому +3

      @@jakeblitzcoffie4859 Exactly my point. That's the thing. Literally what I said. If Mei fought Sunday, the damages would've been disastrous. That's why she didn't fight him, not because she couldn't.
      I don't deny that Acheron needed help but not for the reasons you think for a totally different motive. Also Welt cannot actually generate black holes, those are pseudo black holes, and secondly you're talking about the Welt that fought Sirin, Welt in HSR is far weaker.

    • @jakeblitzcoffie4859
      @jakeblitzcoffie4859 2 місяці тому +1

      @yassinegacha-nm2wm First of all, she could have easily fought alongside the Astral Express to stop Sunday after shattering the Dreamscape. Secondly, Nihility CAN be affected by another path. The Finality. Which in its description states that it brings all Aeons and paths to an end, including IX. But yes, besides Finality, Nihility is a tricky path to deal with.

  • @jade7631
    @jade7631 2 місяці тому +1

    Sunday scales above Acheron. It really depends on his form. When at his peak state, no one we know of, other than JingYuan can single handed solve Penacony’s crisis. People said Acheron wasn’t affected by the “dream”, but she actually was which is why she wanted to confirm that she was in one by going to the express. Acheron does not scale above Sunday. Sunday is at least star system level at his current phase. Acheron is multi-planetary.

    • @JohnDoe-si4eg
      @JohnDoe-si4eg 2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah I was about to say it’s weird to say Acheron was unaffected by the dream when we know that’s not true as the entirety of Penacony, including her, was already within 1 layer of the dream.
      Oth she was unaffected by the deeper layer. So she has some resistance but not complete immunity.

    • @jade7631
      @jade7631 2 місяці тому

      @@JohnDoe-si4eg She wasn’t in the Dream, it was more so her being unsure of whether or not everyone else was in a dream. It is more of a secondhand effect. She was effected because everyone else around her was effected.

    • @zaynyeinaung2343
      @zaynyeinaung2343 2 місяці тому +2

      Lmao u acting like we already knew about Acheron peak. Acheron still not even show her peak lvl strength. Only she doing in Panycony was show she just make 2 slash (slash Adventurine and break Ena' dream).

    • @jade7631
      @jade7631 2 місяці тому

      @@zaynyeinaung2343 Then using your analogy, how can we scale any character in any verse? We use what we see and know.

    • @jade7631
      @jade7631 2 місяці тому +1

      @@zaynyeinaung2343 A person who did the story knows she did 2 slashes in aventurine, not 1.

  • @myersSquad
    @myersSquad 2 місяці тому

    I saw the avatar of the channel and thought that's my video lmao