I Paid 5 Designers To Design THE SAME Logo... 💸 (So Clean)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2024
- Sponsored by Squarespace!
10% OFF code: PATERSON
www.squarespace.com/williampat...
Next episode here! • I Paid 5 Designers To ...
Logan Krinn - Experienced amateur - $75
www.thykingdomstudios.com/
Henry James - Experienced designer $150
Portfolio: @Henryjamess13 (Twitter)
James Kaigai - Experienced designer - $100
/ kaigai_james
David Pruitt - Expert Designer - $300
Portfolio: davidpruittdesignco.myportfolio.com
0:00 Intro
0:20 The Brief
1:06 Logan $75
3:58 Henry $150
6:28 Sponsor Segment
7:36 James $100
11:13 David Pruitt $300
Instagram: / willpat
Thanks for watching! Hope you enjoyed this video!
If there's anything you would like me to cover in a UA-cam Video, then let me know by commenting down below!
Edited by Jordan Summers: www.1five.co.uk
If you like what I do, and you want to partner with me:
BECOME A MEMBER! / @willpatersondesign
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design
If you would like me to design you a logo, poster or anything for your UA-cam Channel or business, then I'm your man! I would love to work with you to make what you want a reality! Check out my website and portfolio for more information.
Hire me: www.willpaterson.design - Навчання та стиль
New Episode LIVE NOW! ua-cam.com/video/3FfDcmQT1Ls/v-deo.html
Henry logo u paid 150$ waste just pay me $70 for good pro logo
i would make the A a microphone
ur an idiot "i dont like this logo its bad " proceeds to just make the A smaller "now its perfect"
Lol - Calling me and idiot when you can't even spell. 🧐
Thankyou will for the amazing opportunity. I had so much fun during my 3hrs.
Congrats 👏
Well done, James!
@@naomipaterson9300 Thankyou Naomi
Yours was the best imo, totally killed it buddy
you did awesome man!
James wins this round hands down. That logo was incredible, especially for only 3 hours worth of time. Well done James!
Thankyou. Glad you liked it
@@kaigaijames yu
@@kaigaijames I'm baffled that you managed to do that in 3 hrs
you are amazing, that was awesome
You were so kind to that designer who just randomly plugged in a vector microphone. I get that 3hr is a tough time restraint but that is nowhere near a logo.
U nailed it.
I even find it expensive for $150 if it was 3 hours of work. It doesn't feel like a podcast app/service. He didn't even make a brief, just sent it like that. Also, seeing his work, he's more of an illustrator, not logo designer.
@@etnevel.naitzsirk yeah, I guess Will had a lot of money to throw away. Unfortunately, many other people weren't chosen who would have presented something far better
To be fair, seeing a lot of American podcasts, many of them have that style of “logo”
@@gabbyeebzie4103 because they hire new or inexperienced designers to pinch money
James' design was SO clean! Loved that one
Thankyou. Glad you loved it.
@@kaigaijames u rock 🔥
My favourite
@@kaigaijames Also looks like an ear. Which I'm assuming is what you were kind of going for?
James' design was #1 in my hearth
The 'A' in the first concept initially made me think of a signal tower, as if it is casting out the podcast far and wide...
100% the same. If it was mine, I'd have experimented with a bulb and signal brackets to see if it'd work without ruining the 'A' identifiability (that even a word? XD)
@@takoshihitsamaru4675 Yes, signal brackets is what that needed.
I got huge Adobe vibes from it honestly
Exactly what i was thinking
Me, too
James just went above and beyond - especially for that price 😱 The man is a design beast. I wish him amazing projects - and good pay - in the future!
Thankyou so much.
@@kaigaijames Hey man, as a business owner i can tell you that you need to charge more for your works, with respect of course. Your price is not matching your quality.
@@kaigaijames ukipandisha bei usinisahau
I felt robbed by Henry's design and it wasn't even me who paid for that
@@tannguyenjin8648 are you ok?
All It is is text and an image off Google
Even if he made the mic himself it looks bad tbh and doesn't match the simple style trending today
@@CrseTheGod He didn’t, it’s a stock vector
@@davidmedina8136 yeh ok
James definitely killed it. Minimal design, so clean and modern. I loved it.
150 USD one was literally a vector of Microphone lol 😂😂
ye, that "logo" was so bad
😂 literally placed a Microphone 😂
Yeah, that one was not good at all.
Swindle af xD
I think you’re talking about $100 one. $150 is actually a great logo if we look at the time he took to design it.
Some clients are so worse , when you send them a practical logo like the one James made. They outright reject that. And then they like the one with vector microphone.
You exactly say what is in my mind. This is absolutely true that in most of the cases clients go for the worst one not for the creative one.
i actually think the microphone was better. looked cooler by far the other one looked like something you'd get from a online logo generator
@@festusbojangles7027 Hm, you probably don't really know much about designing. You could literally get that same microphone at *freepik* in less than 1 min, which is what I'm 100% sure he did, since he didn't present any drafts, concepts, ideas, etc. Also, I'm pretty sure Will asked them to design a logo for a spotify podcast, not a radio station from the 90s
@@Querviinho the end result is still better
@@festusbojangles7027 It’s not worth 150 it’s a ripoff. You can get a middle schooler to do the same work for a bag of candy.
This guy James really has a taste. I would fork out more for such level of work from him. Congratulations James.
Thankyopu so much Daniel
Unless James at 7:40 is an absolute machine of a designer there is no way he created all variations, presentation, and posters in 3 hours, unless he is using some type of templates for everything
I’m sure he used a template for the 3d mock-up and maybe even the posters, but I feel like a lot of the extra stuff can be done pretty quickly by an experienced designer. Especially if he uses a similar presentation style for other clients.
There is just no way he did all that in 3hrs
It was a fun challenge, bro! Thanks for including me!
You did so well!
@@naomipaterson9300 thank you so much, friend!
I was hoping that Will could judge you fairly, but sadly he could not. Your logo cannot be scaled down and used as app icon. He was bashing previous guy for that and did not even mentioned that for you.
@@Zarezy I totally agree with you. I unfortunately ran out of time. For three hours, you have to get a quick design and move on to color and presentation. I would have definitely worked more on scaleability.
@@Zarezy Indeed!!
I really liked James design. That’s the best for me.
Thakyou so much
@@kaigaijames How can you be hired? I’d like to do some work with you sometime
@MeDiAAiDeM stfu
James' design was the best for me. Most functional, scalable and professional
Thankyou
@@kaigaijames Best one about you, apart from your logo you're thanking everyone individually who considered your work as the best. It shows your honest and dedication James. Wishing you a great future ❤
@@pandiyanpandiyan1791 thankyou my brother
100 $ for a free pick logo, no presentation, nothing?? OMG!!
James and David got it!
no, 150$!
IMO:
4th: Henry
3rd: Logan
2nd: David
1st: James
The $150 one was simply and mildly put - TRASH!!!
That guy doesn't really know much of logo design.
Rest were all at least workable or usable even if not perfect, but sensible for the price.
The $300 one just stood out because he took a totally different approach although I don't think I instantly recognized that as a vintage microphone.
James hit the nail in true terms. Considering how the Brands are approaching and rebranding, every logo is being turned into a minimal one! Not just that but the logo made by James is just too good to look at and its checks every requirement and condition on the list needed by a legible logo
Thankyou
@@kaigaijames Lovely work man! I am going to follow you on instagram. As a student I hope to learn alot from you! Cheers 🍻
The 150 guy, took a vector from Freepik and added it to the logo.... Simply terrible! Loved the last one, vintage approach on point!
Wow, I googled it, and it was the first thing that came up O.o
the $150 one? or the 100$
Its Henry the 150$ one
While I don't necessarily have any issue using vector pre-mades, it's all about implementation and what you do to improve on the stock assets.
This being said, I've worked for companies who do this as a time saver, and as much as it crushes the designer in me, most clients don't give a shit about perfect original creations. It shouldn't be the rule or anything, but sometimes we need to remember that we aren't doing work for other graphic designers.
@@takoshihitsamaru4675 Well, if he had made it somehow right, we wouldn't be commenting about it. Still, I know it's your opinion and I respect it!
But no brief, no idea, no concept, no vision, nothing, just taking an svg file and implementing it like if he didn't cared much. For $150 we have seen already on this channel how much work can be done for that budget. I'm not judging by the way he works, it's fine, the problem is that he sells his profile as an experienced designer, and if we talk about reviewing, it's not a good work at all and says how much he has to improve and focus to deliver a better product.
Logan's reminds me of the Apex Legends logo, Henry's gives me that 90s Morning Radio show vibe, James' logo feels like Pintrest, Patreon, etc but different enough in a good way, and David reminds me of a modern small business/brewery logo. All of these were really well done and are good inspirations for an aspiring designer like me
All I could think of was apex
3:58 Henry just straight up scammed you dude. That's just like 5 minutes effort put into that abomination of a logo.
Took me literally 5 minutes to find that exact microphone vector file on a stock images website.
You should create an open brief on twitter as a "design competition" and show you favourite type of results in a video. This way someone like me can participate with other designers and get attention by you and your viewers/this community.
@@willpatersondesign I dont know how many will actually take place in this competition. But its a great chance to let unknown designers like me show their result and get great feedback.I do really hope to see this kind of comp soon :)
@@willpatersondesign You can also create a brief on twitter where people comment their price and you choose like 5 of them and do basically the same. Twitter designers have a lot change + people like me who had no gig on fiverr get still the change to participate. I hope you get what I try to explain and let you understand out of my point of view/perspective.
We do something like this already :) it’s called Come design with me if you want to find it on the channel - although we haven’t done one in a little while now!
@@LogiicLucky I agree with this concept. It will be a great platform for many great underrated designers out there to showcase their talent..
@@moatoshipongen9089 **whispers** this is already a concept we do 🙃
Well done James Kaigai. Keep soaring high.. The creativity is dope.
Yikes. Henry cannot be using assets of vector-based microphones that are so commonly used lol. Too many "designers" are going around charging folks and doing the bare minimum. When you look at his Twitter timeline, he has subpar illustration work but then logo work with detailed illustrations.. which were obviously taken from websites.
Shoutout to James, though, for going all the way! I hope he makes it far with his career!
Kaigai put in about $300 more work than Mr Experienced designer at the end there.
Honestly, if you've got any qualification beyond a Certificate in Graphic Design and you're charging less than $150 for a logo, you're selling yourself short.
James is definitely the winner. Minimalism prevails
A definition of a well-articulated work. Awesome job James. I will definitely contact you for a gig in the future.
Thankyou. Looking forward
The last two designers did a great job for 3 hours of work, well done 🔥
James was amazing. With that presentation and the quality of the logo, it takes the win
James has nailed it. I feel so much challenged by such masterpieces of creativity and passion for Graphics Designing. Thumbs up
Wow I love this, I'm a graphic design student I took some semesters off because of my job, im currently working on a hospital, but I do love design, I got back to school if all goes well, next year by around this date I would be graduating, and I just need to soak up more design more inspiration, this hit the nail as you said, definitely subscribing
This was such a fun concept for vid, I’m digging them all
James' Design was incredibly clean, Excellent work dude!
THANK YOU FOR MAKING THIS AGAIN, KEEP THE FIVERR VIDS COMING
I love the last two designs. Delightful!
i loved james design..simple and detailed...fantastic!
I'm new to your channel. As a designer myself, I thoroughly enjoyed this. Subscribed with the quickness.
Awesome, thank you!
James Kaigai's design was the best for me.🙌
James' design is the most beautiful because it is simple and expressive as well as beautiful
Super video, and variety in the end results... Am gonna sound like a grouch, but the last op - cool vintage idea, but I disagree with it scaling well. And thought to concentrate the limited time to make one of those ops Stella. But appreciate it's a three hour deadline which ain't long... And huge kudos to James, as that was achieved in the time frame. As said great vid, and entertaining to watch. 👍😎
James Kaigai , truely nailed it 👌
Simple , sober , Effective, Functional 👍
Thankyou so much
Man, you're really starting to look less like a designer and more like a philosopher and that's brilliant. Good video as usual
Good job James 👏
Wow hats off to James and the work video!
Am humbled
Cool looking, clean and concise: James 👍
James made it, really great job! 💪🏽
I really liked the colour scheme of Logan's idea, had a vintage professional feel to it - which I can see might not fit the brief fully, but man it was sexy.
James Kaigai you are the best !!!!
I love these videos and your accent makes it better ❤️ !
Kaigai james to win this🔥🔥 amazing work
Well done James. Absolutely awesome.
james went above and beyond for that price
davids logo was great
hey... paterson ...
will want more This type of challenging logo design contest ... i love it so.....💓💓💓
Great video and very cool logos
Good work,James kaigai
I'm late to this party as I just stumbled on this channel..but I liked James presentations because before I even saw the logo, I was impressed with the word mapping and brief...I really liked James overall, because it was simple yet effective..But I was already impressed with the presentation ..I would have chosen James but I tend t lean more towards minimalist and simple..The microphone one with block letters reminds me of something you'd get off a logo website, but three hours isn't much time...
Great work and nice video. Posting my work on reddit soon
The one by James was amazing!
i think the first one was the best as it was simple and remarkable. the second was the worst, it didn't have a right word connection as pc = personal computer and it certainly looked as it was made using some clip art in the 90s. the third one reminded me of oldness because of the similarity to walking stick so didn't really spot on the idea it was trying to express. and the fourth one was just fancy. perhaps it's a good design but i like it simple.
Procast is honestly such a good idea. I hope one day someone makes it real because I’d love it!!
All of these logos were amazing podcast logos but I really liked James’ design for the reason that it fits the college/university student app vibe
Thankyou so much
James the best design, he did it well
I like that they did a presentation that made it easy to make feedback on. While Henry's problem is that one wouldn't know where to start the corrections because of no presentation. A presentation is important to start correction like on the colour, on the size, on the metaphoric etc.
Thought the cheaper option was great! Love seeing these videos to see what kind of results people get for different price bands. Felt the blue mic stock vector wasn't worth the money though :D Cant wait to see the next ones!
Glad you enjoyed!
James' was honestly so nice
James logo was amazing, nice contest I will love to participate next one!
I liked the 1st one. It kind of made me think of a space ship blasting off or reaching the top of a mountain peak towards success.
Although all designers did correct and an OK work in minimal, I also think James nailed it with the design. The most compact one with combining P, r , sound waves and even wi fi perhaps ? Also, works best as an icon with it`s smooth lines and colors.
Keep up the great work !
Thankyou so much
I'd love to see the full video of James Kaigai
James' design was soo cool. He deserves a Nobel prize 🏅Best designer of all time!
don’t know about a Nobel prize mate
Awesome Video
OMG James. You have bright future for this!!
The first one with your edit is the best for me. I like simple logos
These are all great
Going into this, I was thinking that I could be at the top of the list with my skill level. INSTANTLY humbled when I saw Dave's work. 3 hours for everything he made there?! That would take me at least a week! He is truly an embodiment of an expert and has inspired me to keep learning.
They all did so well for 3 hours didn’t they!
Thank you so much! Man that means a lot!
you should make a video where yu announce this competition so we can all participate and try ourselves, even the beginners.
I love this, i dont really pay much attention to GD but this was pretty entertaining, i am curious about the brief, was it supposed to be disruptive or competitive, where there antecedents, did they search for them. Was there any reference material or a about us of the fake company?
How do you curate your selection for these videos out of your subscribers. Would love to be involved in one of these, I find the briefs you propose exciting, challenging and the feedback, breakdowns and educational format you take makes an informative watch without bombarding the audience. It's always interesting to see the perception of value and how different price points sometimes can reflect accurately or in-accurately of the work produced in response to the brief regarding their outcomes.
Hi Kyle, we like to choose different ways :) so far we’ve done Fiverr, Twitter, Discord and choose a random selection of designers from those who respond of different prices and experience levels :)
I’m glad you like the briefs! That’s one of the more fun parts of my job! 😇 Mindscape was my best one for sure, which we did actually turn into an app that I still use regularly!
Hands down James nailed it!
I appreciate the colors of the first one.
James killed it.
dude, love the video. also LOVE that keyboard what is it ?
Anne Pro 2 I believe :)
You have the best voice. Once I have enough $$ saved to make an animated pilot, I hope I can hire you to do a character voice!
Hands down James nailed it for $100... Well done man!
Bruh! James!!! This guy nailed it! Unreal for 3hrs
The color could b better tho IMO
James Kaigai killed it. And in just 3hrs.... Oh boy!!
Last 2 were very nice
Obviously you had to say the most expensive was the best but James absolutely smashed this.
really very helpful video, they all work for their own purposes.
James design was outstanding.Simple and classy
I like James one a lot but the logo looks like a lowercase r to me. Still super impressive especially for the time constraint.
Shout-Outs to Mr.Kaigai really really impressive and nicely done ^_^
James is the best 💚💚
I love James' logo. It's the best in my opinion
My favourite is the james one i love it
Really glad I found this account
I think James blew it out of the park, super nice