James McMurtry - Rachel's Song

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 25 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 108

  • @jmvlock1929
    @jmvlock1929 9 років тому +99

    This guy is so ridiculously underrated.

    • @JohnnygOdoubleT
      @JohnnygOdoubleT 5 років тому +1

      Always will be but not to me 🤷‍♂️🙏💯

    • @lucaspeden3727
      @lucaspeden3727 2 роки тому

      @Evan Hodge sometimes there's calm before the storm

    • @stanvice9945
      @stanvice9945 2 роки тому +1

      I don't want him to be bigger.
      It would ruin the experience

    • @howardrobinson4938
      @howardrobinson4938 2 роки тому

      Oh really? By whom?

    • @marcwhite6596
      @marcwhite6596 Рік тому

      Absolitley. Reminds me of growing up. My parents would blare mcmurtry while drinking in the kitchen. NOWTALGIC AF

  • @charlesdeshazo2893
    @charlesdeshazo2893 3 роки тому +18

    When you understand this, the end is closing in.
    Thank you for singing what I feel

  • @brianmock8441
    @brianmock8441 3 роки тому +5

    I left a car on its side one night. Been sober awhile now My son is coming to visit me for a week soon and we are going to play guitars and howl at the moon. I guess I’m like the mother in some ways. I feel so blessed to get back in the door

  • @peerman2006
    @peerman2006 9 років тому +58

    "If Anyone can claim they're all right, so can I"

  • @cuznjoey1976
    @cuznjoey1976 3 роки тому +7

    Amazing song lyrics .. hit home with me .. I relate it to my wife passing suddenly.........and I have a black and white picture that resembles the girl at the end of the video........." if anyone can claim their allright. so can I"

  • @cathystruska1558
    @cathystruska1558 5 років тому +12

    I can see every image in this song so vividly. Few songwriters can do that. I can see the snowflakes peeking through the glass. Best American songwriter of the last 30 years....PPTJ STRUSKA

  • @maypost
    @maypost 11 років тому +27

    This man is truly his father's son. Such beautiful writing

    • @davidlabelle361
      @davidlabelle361 4 роки тому +3

      Larry ain’t got nuthin’ on James, man!

    • @lucaspeden3727
      @lucaspeden3727 2 роки тому

      @@davidlabelle361 nuttin and i do mean nuttin- bein a blind squirrel and all

    • @lesevans6567
      @lesevans6567 2 місяці тому

      Yes, both are very descriptive. I read his dad’s book Pretty Boy Floyd. He had me in the Midwest of the 20’s and 30’s. Remarkable!

  • @kyleboring5300
    @kyleboring5300 10 років тому +29

    My Critical Listening professor had us analyze this song for a test about two months ago. Haven't been able to stop listening since.

    • @sirris4330
      @sirris4330 7 років тому +3

      you have an amazing professor

    • @chrisbarrett5416
      @chrisbarrett5416 5 років тому +4

      Please tell us Mr. Boring, What did you learn in " Critical listening " class? Any Professor that used James Mcmurtry in class has to be a Genius!!!

    • @malcolmreynolds3696
      @malcolmreynolds3696 4 роки тому

      Compared to my Sociology "Professor" who made us do a whole freakin' project on, We didn't start the fire, by Billy Joel in a Tech and Society class . Don't even get me started on the state of higher education. Colossal waste of time and effort. Arrrrgggghhh!!! Still irked to this day and I was 19 then back in 1993. When 90+ percent of the class recognizes you're mailing it in, it's time to retire. F'n Billy Joel! Just go sing about your uptown girl.

    • @charleswhite2609
      @charleswhite2609 4 роки тому

      Awesome

  • @billscraze7504
    @billscraze7504 5 років тому +11

    I must have listened to this about ten times today it just doesn’t get old

  • @Osaenfuego
    @Osaenfuego 13 років тому +15

    This song absolutely haunts me. I catch myself singing it even when I'm happy;.

  • @rtreyd33
    @rtreyd33 4 роки тому +7

    One of the handful of perfect songs ever written.

  • @rickp10116
    @rickp10116 8 років тому +11

    What a great song. It always reminds me of my best friend."I probably ought to quit my drinkin', but I don't believe I will."

  • @ericbonsell6536
    @ericbonsell6536 7 місяців тому +1

    Always come back to this song.

  • @soundman5150
    @soundman5150 14 років тому +11

    This is amazing. I have never heard so much emotion in a song.

  • @mc98smusicmoviereviews93
    @mc98smusicmoviereviews93 2 роки тому +4

    Fucking masterpiece. Probably James' magnus opus.

  • @harobikes730
    @harobikes730 14 років тому +6

    james... You have successfully brought me to tears

  • @50StillRocks
    @50StillRocks 4 роки тому +4

    One of my faves that touches my soul...A poet.

  • @kujo1978lol
    @kujo1978lol 7 років тому +9

    Just discovered this guy. Absolutely amazing music!

  • @mikethornhill2481
    @mikethornhill2481 Рік тому

    I think this dude & Chris knight would be a great show!😊❤

  • @rachealmaillet5942
    @rachealmaillet5942 5 років тому +34

    any other Rachel’s here ?

  • @dboogeman2002
    @dboogeman2002 3 роки тому +2

    Love this song so fkn much

  • @mueltenius6952
    @mueltenius6952 8 років тому +6

    another man, who moves me threw my day, thank YOU James McMurtry, I am grateful you share your talent, you with the those of us who love to listen.

  • @mentaltfladdrig
    @mentaltfladdrig 12 років тому +2

    Even my pet poodle loves this song!

  • @cherylrunyonlehman226
    @cherylrunyonlehman226 4 роки тому +1

    These guys were really great. Songs about real stuff.

  • @Lola-lh5kl
    @Lola-lh5kl 4 роки тому +1

    Never heard of this or the artists but it's so beautiful so glad I found this.

  • @scvman992000
    @scvman992000 13 років тому +3

    No dislikes...and there should never be any

  • @sirris4330
    @sirris4330 7 років тому +10

    Ill say it, better than anything Johnny Cash ever did...and I even like Johnny Cash. James Mcmurtry is the most under appreciated talent of the modern music era.

  • @dmoss74
    @dmoss74 15 років тому +3

    one of his best tunes.

  • @cityzen2717
    @cityzen2717 5 років тому +12

    Must be a cold front coming
    Cause I saw the eastbound C&O
    And the coal cars were dusted with a half inch of snow
    And that boy'll drive me crazy
    Don't know what I'll do with him
    School will be out tomorrow if that cold front moves in
    Calling out
    To the dying daylight
    The shadows of the mountains
    Bringing on the night
    The old folks like to whisper
    He favors your side in his face
    When he gets a little older
    He's going to lead a merry chase
    When I'm all alone it's all right
    It Isn't going to wound my pride
    If anyone can claim they're all right
    So can I
    I wrecked the El Camino
    Would have been DWI
    So I just walked off and left it
    Laying on its side
    The troopers found it in the morning
    And they said it's purely luck I wasn't killed
    I probably ought to quit my drinking
    But I don't believe I will
    When I'm all alone it's all right
    It Isn't going to wound my pride
    If anyone can claim they're all right
    So can I
    He used to ask about you
    About a million times a day
    I got so tired of trying to answer
    I just turned my head away
    Now he don't pay me much attention
    He's not asking anymore
    I guess he'd probably know you
    If you walked back in the door
    Calling out to the empty night
    Watching as the snowflakes
    Come dancing round the light
    Dancing up against the window
    It's like they're peeking through the glass
    And they hover for a moment
    And then they fall on past
    Calling out
    Source: LyricFind
    Songwriters: James Mc Murtry

  • @jqapac
    @jqapac 14 років тому +2

    Beautiful song.

  • @RF-bc4ij
    @RF-bc4ij 11 місяців тому

    Omg! How did you know!?

  • @debbiecawley7046
    @debbiecawley7046 8 років тому +2

    Saw this guy last nite in Norwich...he was fab! His band were great esp the dude on the accordion who made some mean shapes on the guitar! Pleasantly surprised.

  • @starhunterterra9849
    @starhunterterra9849 10 років тому +1

    Haunting song, goes well with country sound.

  • @Rxx22
    @Rxx22 12 років тому +1

    this is beautiful

  • @lookin4space
    @lookin4space 14 років тому +4

    One of McMurtry's best songs

  • @AnthonyCobb182
    @AnthonyCobb182 10 років тому +1

    Very interesting and dark song, a lot like life at times; traveling through one of life's dark tunnels, the light at the end is at time hard to see.

  • @robertodasz3739
    @robertodasz3739 4 роки тому

    I know I'm repeating this. ON PURPOSE!

  • @Kerry_kit_slayer
    @Kerry_kit_slayer 5 років тому +1

    Found this after meeting a girl named Rachel, and damn I'm glad I did.

  • @rosemarypeace9000
    @rosemarypeace9000 2 роки тому

    Cool

  • @joesimmons1877
    @joesimmons1877 12 років тому

    saw him for the first time the other day.

  • @abderrahimelhamdawi708
    @abderrahimelhamdawi708 9 років тому

    Cooooool

  • @rustwrangler5506
    @rustwrangler5506 11 років тому +8

    songs from the gut

  • @cuznjoey1976
    @cuznjoey1976 3 роки тому

    mostly a true story for me ............

  • @monoshock57
    @monoshock57 14 років тому +2

    So, did Rachel die or just up and leave?

    • @ujutae
      @ujutae 6 років тому

      She died

  • @alexshaffer3819
    @alexshaffer3819 Місяць тому

    winter

  • @xrandy11
    @xrandy11 10 років тому +9

    Re below comments: Is it about Rachel or Rachel's ex? Yes, no, either both. It depends on your perspective. There is no right answer. When a song is made public it is up to the listener to interpret.

    • @GENERALLEE27
      @GENERALLEE27 10 років тому

      Correct!

    • @tomcranmer343
      @tomcranmer343 9 років тому +2

      Randy Hansen isn't it about a son and father who loses his mum/partner

    • @xrandy11
      @xrandy11 9 років тому +5

      Tom it's ambiguous. Notice how the only pronoun used is to describe the son ('he"). To me the song is written from the perspective of a father (as you suggest) and the woman is named "Rachel", giving the title a slightly sardonic sheen. Others think that the narrator is a woman named Rachel.

    • @rickbowers3788
      @rickbowers3788 9 років тому +1

      michael porterfield well we can't all be a genius, as you obviously are with such an eloquent comment.

    • @georgegaros1760
      @georgegaros1760 Рік тому

      boston globe 3/20/23
      . Do people ever get confused?
      A. Absolutely. “Rachel’s Song,” it’s not a song for Rachel. Rachel is the narrator. But a lot of people don’t get that because I don’t spell it out like Prine or Steve Goodman.

  • @racheal6392
    @racheal6392 5 років тому +1

    ha thats my name ;)

    • @rachealwinger6718
      @rachealwinger6718 5 років тому

      Racheal big mood and you spell your name the right way 🙌🏼

  • @notreallysure9
    @notreallysure9 4 роки тому

    so.... are you saying this is 'Rachel' singing and the Husband is the one who left?

  • @rachelzoecosplay1570
    @rachelzoecosplay1570 Рік тому

    Right here lol

  • @marieschneider2813
    @marieschneider2813 4 роки тому +1

    my name is Rachel

  • @michaeldavey9658
    @michaeldavey9658 11 місяців тому

    Soak an eye.

  • @AKidintheway
    @AKidintheway 14 років тому

    I dida cover of this one my page love him much respect

  • @Coondog407
    @Coondog407 14 років тому +4

    Ethereal.

    • @bradsimpson9897
      @bradsimpson9897 Рік тому

      This is my favorite UA-cam comment ever. I think about it often, you are so right

  • @TheFlite29
    @TheFlite29 13 років тому +3

    Wrong...It's written from Rachel's perspective

    • @notreallysure9
      @notreallysure9 4 роки тому

      WHAT!! are you saying this is 'Rachel' singing and the Husband is the one who left?

    • @1om8cat
      @1om8cat 4 роки тому +1

      @@notreallysure9 According to James McMurtry himself, yes. He has other songs where a woman is the intended narrator.

    • @notreallysure9
      @notreallysure9 4 роки тому

      @@1om8cat which other songs?

    • @1om8cat
      @1om8cat 4 роки тому

      @@notreallysure9 Lights of Cheyenne, Fire Line Road.

    • @1om8cat
      @1om8cat 4 роки тому

      @@notreallysure9 Also "Crazy Wind" on his first album. The narrator is ambiguous but it's definitely the woman's perspective described.

  • @themonkeyboyz1950
    @themonkeyboyz1950 12 років тому +5

    lou reed out of texas!

  • @rachelstone2443
    @rachelstone2443 2 роки тому

    Rachel here

  • @carriemccrossen7535
    @carriemccrossen7535 3 роки тому

    Jake I hate/ love you

  • @sweatervestfest918
    @sweatervestfest918 7 років тому +1

    obviously none of you have lived in sand springs, okla

    • @typacsk
      @typacsk 2 роки тому

      Well, I've got to admit that's true... the closest I've been was a couple of job sites outside of Alva, but then I got sent north into Kansas

  • @ctgriffin4191
    @ctgriffin4191 3 роки тому +1

    Must be a cold front coming
    Cause I saw the eastbound C&O
    And the coal cars were dusted with a half inch of snow
    And that boy'll drive me crazy
    Don't know what I'll do with him
    School will be out tomorrow if that cold front moves in
    Calling out
    To the dying daylight
    The shadows of the mountains
    Bringing on the night
    The old folks like to whisper
    He favors your side in his face
    When he gets a little older
    He's going to lead a merry chase
    When I'm all alone it's all right
    It Isn't going to wound my pride
    If anyone can claim they're all right
    So can I
    I wrecked the El Camino
    Would have been DWI
    So I just walked off and left it
    Laying on its side
    The troopers found it in the morning
    And they said it's purely luck I wasn't killed
    I probably ought to quit my drinking
    But I don't believe I will
    When I'm all alone it's all right
    It Isn't going to wound my pride
    If anyone can claim they're all right
    So can I
    He used to ask about you
    About a million times a day
    I got so tired of trying to answer
    I just turned my head away
    Now he don't pay me much attention
    He's not asking anymore
    I guess he'd probably know you
    If you walked back in the door
    Calling out to the empty night
    Watching as the snowflakes
    Come dancing round the light
    Dancing up against the window
    It's like they're peeking through the glass
    And they hover for a moment
    And then they fall on past
    Calling out