The Great Surrender - Stalingrad

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 14 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 493

  • @odysseusrex5908
    @odysseusrex5908 6 років тому +163

    How few remain, who even understand the significance of these events, much less remember them.

    • @АлександрКим-ж7о
      @АлександрКим-ж7о 5 років тому +13

      Odysseus Rex Ex Soviets remember. For us it is impossible to forget. On the 9th of May we celebrate Victory Day. A great number of people go out into the central street with the photos of our grandfathers and grandmothers who fought at ww2.

    • @newhorizon1355
      @newhorizon1355 4 роки тому +4

      Pointless now in time.... What does it matter that Egypt, Rome, etc were great. Their civilizations no longer exist nor have power over your life today. Neither does Hitler or Stalin. What matters is what you do and if you serve God before you too jump into a coffin.

    • @odysseusrex5908
      @odysseusrex5908 4 роки тому +14

      @@newhorizon1355 Actually, Rome has a significant affect on your life today. Your language, your cultural outlook, and your religion, are all shaped by the continuing influence of Rome. The world you inhabit simply would not exist had it not been for Rome.

    • @odysseusrex5908
      @odysseusrex5908 4 роки тому +1

      @@АлександрКим-ж7о That is a very good thing.

    • @rafaelreyes9100
      @rafaelreyes9100 4 роки тому +1

      They were nazi dogs. 5,000 survived. That was 5,000 too many! Nazis should've been exterminated.

  • @reyzuna
    @reyzuna 5 років тому +63

    Lols funny how they surrender like they just lost in a chess game

    • @kjragg1099
      @kjragg1099 3 роки тому +3

      A lot of this footage was probably staged. The video says Paulus was in good health when he surrendered yet in reality he was suffering from
      dysentery

    • @The_last_prime
      @The_last_prime 2 роки тому

      nothing having to do with the horrors of the east in ww2 is funny

    • @AntonyMurithi-xt4ep
      @AntonyMurithi-xt4ep 10 місяців тому

      They realised they have reached a dead end!!!

  • @comradedimitri3610
    @comradedimitri3610 5 років тому +82

    *Germans surrender*
    *Some ramdom Disney music start playin*

    • @kickyourshoesoff
      @kickyourshoesoff 4 роки тому +1

      British orchestral music.

    • @peterpretzington9669
      @peterpretzington9669 4 роки тому

      Why humans wanted this global holocaust in the first place shows how naive we are about life

    • @Opoczynski
      @Opoczynski 3 роки тому +4

      Tchaikovsky's 6th Symphony, 3rd Movement.

    • @ПолковникЗайцын
      @ПолковникЗайцын 3 роки тому +4

      Tchaikovsky's 6th symphony, Red Army air force anthem, Communist International anthem and other Dysney masterpieces...

    • @Opoczynski
      @Opoczynski 3 роки тому

      @@ПолковникЗайцын Спасибо, Андрей.

  • @markprange6593
    @markprange6593 8 років тому +78

    2:10 - 2:30 This is a mostly-enclosed courtyard in Stalingrad South, west of the intersection of Barrikadnaya & Kozlovskaya. The building is shown ablock away at 7:56. It is still standing in 2016.
    The grain silos are almost a km away, coming into view at 8:01.

  • @2prize
    @2prize 4 роки тому +90

    *Aftermath of one of the most deadly battles history*
    The music: 😇💃🕺✨🎈🤗

    • @michaelscott5653
      @michaelscott5653 3 роки тому +20

      *The* most deadliest battle in history

    • @Milovan-c9x
      @Milovan-c9x 9 місяців тому +1

      ​@@michaelscott5653Pretty much yeah👍

  • @MrWolf-kd8yh
    @MrWolf-kd8yh 3 роки тому +78

    Fascinating listen, thank you for uploading.
    My grandfather was captured with the 6th army at Stalingrad, he was in the 44th infantry division.
    Many deaths occured in his POW camp of malnutrition. He ultimately lost around 80 pounds moving around different Russian labour camps. Fortunately he became one of the few survivors to finally return to Germany in the mid 1950s where he lived a long peaceful life
    His younger brother made it to the end of the war as a loader for the Jagdtiger in the 512th Heavy tank destroyer battalion and surrendered to the Americans May 1945

  • @vikramnandakumaran2434
    @vikramnandakumaran2434 6 років тому +239

    events of Stalingrad led to the downfall of Nazis ...and USSR deserves all the credit

    • @silverkitty2503
      @silverkitty2503 6 років тому +41

      Russia ....and they deserve way more credit than they get.

    • @tusidex5228
      @tusidex5228 5 років тому +13

      Vikram Nandakumaran they also deserve all the credit in enslaving half of Europe.

    • @wh_kers
      @wh_kers 5 років тому +5

      nope. it was the Brits & British navy first. they failed & lost already the war, even before attack on russia.

    • @ihmpall
      @ihmpall 5 років тому +16

      Usse would have been crushed by the Germans has us not started the lend lease policy.

    • @svendbosanvovski4241
      @svendbosanvovski4241 5 років тому +16

      Winston Churchill conceded as much when he acknowledged that its was the Soviets who tore the belly out of the German war machine. They played a horrendous price with 27.2 million dead, but what choice did they have? The Nazi's made their intentions clear. The same fate visited upon the Jews was planned for the Slavic peoples.

  • @99mainpure99
    @99mainpure99 4 роки тому +62

    This must have been pretty awkward for both parties. The Germans were like 'Yeah i just laid waste to this part of your country and now I surrender when I've used up all my ammunition'.

    • @Froggo188
      @Froggo188 3 роки тому +5

      The goal was to secure the road to the oil fields in the South and they failed it so it's without a doubt a a costly Soviet victory and a crushing defeat for the Sixth army

    • @99mainpure99
      @99mainpure99 3 роки тому +8

      @@Froggo188 Well I never mentioned anything about strategic or tactical objectives in my comment. Just pointing out how awkward it is given the context of this video. To capture the commander of an Army in modern combat AND to have the ability to record his surrender is pretty rare and awkward for those captured.

    • @SE-dn7xl
      @SE-dn7xl 3 роки тому +1

      Not really what happened but it wasn't that awkward considering over 90% of the prisoners never came home.

    • @99mainpure99
      @99mainpure99 3 роки тому +5

      @@SE-dn7xl Do you think I'm trying to convey a 1:1 picture of what happened in this particular battle, in just two sentences? I'm just commenting on how novel this whole thing is. Whether or not this footage is raw or a re-enactment is not the point I'm arguing. A German General is captured alive almost after almost two years of fighting in the east. Unheard of right? Also, a lot of prisoners, of different nationalities, of past wars, never got to go home either.

    • @josephp8815
      @josephp8815 3 роки тому +1

      @@SE-dn7xl Probably those prisoners have met their Maker😂😂😂😂

  • @bissonboy7130
    @bissonboy7130 3 роки тому +53

    You can tell this is real war. Apart from some high ranking officers the other German soldiers are dressed nothing like they are portrayed in the movies.

    • @matthewmaurysmith2486
      @matthewmaurysmith2486 Рік тому

      They were probably all wearing stolen clothing by the end! Lol, they probably looked more like the Russian army

    • @ИванТароев-ж3ю
      @ИванТароев-ж3ю Рік тому +3

      Посмотри на нашу войну с Украинскими нацистами. С обеих сторон иногда одеты в спортивную одежду, резиновые сапоги и гражданскую теплую одежду.

    • @XanderHerman-y8j
      @XanderHerman-y8j 6 місяців тому +4

      @@ИванТароев-ж3юhate to break it to you mate but the Ukrainians aren’t Nazis, Russia just invaded a sovereign democratic nation.
      Yeah the Azov battalion is a disgustingly radical nationalist group, but it’s a small part of the nation.
      Ukraine just wants to survive. Its infrastructure and power is being bombed daily.
      I hope that one day this war can end, and both sides can return to the peace that the men In this video fought to create.
      Have a nice day

  • @rstthomas
    @rstthomas 4 роки тому +52

    6 months later at operation "Citadel" [Kursk] marked the end of German offensive operations in the East. Permanently.

    • @darklysm8345
      @darklysm8345 3 роки тому +1

      large scale operations only.

  • @raincoast2396
    @raincoast2396 6 років тому +37

    The German 6th Army started with 300,000 men, of which 93,000 were taken prisoner at Stalingrad. The survivors at 5,400 were not released until 1954 after Stalin died.

    • @zagmodell
      @zagmodell 6 років тому +20

      too many left alive

    • @dragos1894
      @dragos1894 6 років тому +16

      One more thing.The soviets said they were the liberation army, when they actually enslaved half of Europe.Everybody hates them(at least all eastern Europe) except for their own people.

    • @Elisângela8968
      @Elisângela8968 5 років тому +4

      @@dragos1894 atleast they did not fuckin try to kill almost all of eastern europe

    • @yakutza3922
      @yakutza3922 4 роки тому +19

      @@dragos1894 I will disappoint you, nazis called themselves like high aryian race. And after war, they would annihilate literally everyone. They would betray Japans, Italians. They gonna kill everyone, or enslave them.
      Communists used bad methods, but their ideology was about uniting nations in to one - soviet. They was absolutely anti nazistic. Nazi about annihilating, communism about uniting, but both used force methods, at least, Soviets wasn't so cruel like nazis, they even not killed them (Germans) , they restore eastern Europe.

    • @darklysm8345
      @darklysm8345 3 роки тому +2

      @@yakutza3922 okay mister genius. How do you know that. lol

  • @simonyip5978
    @simonyip5978 4 роки тому +26

    A well known piece of footage taken by the Soviets shows lines of German and Axis prisoners of war.
    One particular PoW is probably either Romanian, Italian or any other non German soldier who is seen emerging from their positions to surrender, the reason why I can still remember him is because he is wearing just a thin looking shirt and trousers, without any headwear, greatcoat, camouflage padded smock/tunic, sweater or even a field uniform shirt. I don't doubt that he would have died of the freezing weather conditions within a short time but I wonder what his final few days and hours were actually like.

    • @ikmarchini
      @ikmarchini 3 роки тому +2

      And the line looks exactly like the line in Ivan the Terrible, the movie by Eisenstein at the same time.

    • @jacqueline6406
      @jacqueline6406 2 роки тому +2

      Лагеря Смерти

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому +16

    My mother's father was kia in the Battle of Kursk mid-7/1943, and lost her uncle , a Luftwaffe fighter pilot of a FW190 fighter plane, shot down in Italy near Anzio.
    Ironically my father's father was a paratrooper with the USAs 82nd Airborne Division , and was a medic with permission to carry a weapon , and was in DDay, Operation Market Garden( a fiasco by Field Marshall General Bernard Montgomery to out flank the Nazis into ending the war through Holland xing the Rhine into the heart of Germany, but it was a "Bridge too Far.) And, he was wounded in The Battle of The Bulge. He didn't say toouch about his experience in WW2 , for it brought too many horrible memories, seeing death by the hundreds , USA , and Nazi- German.

  • @felipesalazar942
    @felipesalazar942 7 місяців тому +5

    This battle was the real turning point of the war, not the so-called Dday, a year and a half later, on June 1944 as we are taught here in the west.

  • @juliuscorleoni1585
    @juliuscorleoni1585 3 роки тому +18

    Bloodiest battle of history

    • @dankk2754
      @dankk2754 3 роки тому +5

      They’re still finding bodies till this day I think, most of em are unidentified

    • @kissthis5361
      @kissthis5361 4 місяці тому

      ​@@dankk2754Westerners don't think so...

  • @300thNPC
    @300thNPC 10 місяців тому +2

    Stalingrad is so intense even just literally reading about it. I cant even imagine the sheer desperation that must have been in the air for the people actually experiencing it.

  • @blockmasterscott
    @blockmasterscott 2 роки тому +5

    What's a trip was that there were 2 more years of fighting after this.

  • @cartwheel8319
    @cartwheel8319 4 роки тому +28

    Every kilometer the German Army advanced into occupied territories behind them were the Gestapo and Einsatz Gruppen doing their murderous villainy. The heroic German soldier is a myth because the very nature of their leader's starting of war was criminal. Poland was the first victim of this monstrous war. September 1, 1939. People were asleep, civilians, at home and died from aerial bombing. For what. Too many Nazis under the Western occupation managed to go on to live charmed lives as if nothing every happened, many went into top positions of government and the new German military and by the late 1950s they were even commanding troops of the allies.

    • @darklysm8345
      @darklysm8345 3 роки тому +1

      stfu alliboo

    • @subjetividadobjetivaconmak4259
      @subjetividadobjetivaconmak4259 3 роки тому +2

      @@darklysm8345 Wehraboo shithead.

    • @lalo-kt4te
      @lalo-kt4te 3 роки тому +8

      I mean the Russians also invaded Poland?

    • @kingremarmarkov1997
      @kingremarmarkov1997 2 роки тому +1

      @@lalo-kt4te It was a division buddy the two sides allowed themselves a non-aggression pact since Hitler knows he can't defeat Soviet Union only the Finnish war gave him idea to cross the line they created on Poland.

    • @emadbagheri
      @emadbagheri 2 роки тому +3

      I like how you don't know or won't mention the Ukrainian involvement in the extermination, the Nazi spirit lives on in Ukraine through the Azov Battalion

  • @Angrycomments
    @Angrycomments 5 років тому +22

    That is the wrong tune for that..

  • @toohdvaetihom7088
    @toohdvaetihom7088 Рік тому +4

    2:35 They still referred to the Nazi symbol as Crukade cross. The name Swastika was later applied to shift the blame from Christian Nazis to Hindus.

  • @thuyeinkyaw-zaw8538
    @thuyeinkyaw-zaw8538 5 років тому +7

    Did anyone notice the music at 4:12? It's the Communist International song.
    Voelker, Hoert die Signale!!! Goose bumps all over me.

    • @thuyeinkyaw-zaw8538
      @thuyeinkyaw-zaw8538 5 років тому +3

      An incredible array of military talents the Red Army were able to rely on: Marshals (later) Konev, Malinovsky, Voronov, Rokossovsky, Katukov, Admiral (later) Kuznetsov, not to mention Gen Chuikov, Yeremenko, Zhukov, Rotmisov from the highest commander level down to Sergeant Pavlov and countless many others. My eternal respect to the Soviet people for saving us from fascists!!!

    • @markprange2430
      @markprange2430 2 роки тому +1

      Internationale

  • @wozzer2727
    @wozzer2727 4 роки тому +7

    1:25 Shows how tough the Russians were, no coat necessary on this Russian officer!

    • @anmetious4779
      @anmetious4779 2 роки тому

      many Russians are tempered in winter, there are many methods to increase resistance to cold, but its not really popular now

  • @johnsmith-jk5pz
    @johnsmith-jk5pz 4 роки тому +7

    At 4:55 looks like they move in slow motion.

  • @mrpaddy3318
    @mrpaddy3318 6 років тому +22

    we will talk about that in 1000000 years

    • @ВасилийКлименко-н9у
      @ВасилийКлименко-н9у 4 роки тому

      Yes:))) You nazi-pig! May 9, 1945 - THIS IS A FACT !! REAL FACT!

    • @suazmin107
      @suazmin107 4 роки тому

      @@ВасилийКлименко-н9у that's a joke

    • @nineteenfortyfive7692
      @nineteenfortyfive7692 3 роки тому +1

      @@darklysm8345 They still beat you in Russia, and in your country they took your city, mama, papa to prison camp. Shut Germany once and for all.

    • @nineteenfortyfive7692
      @nineteenfortyfive7692 3 роки тому

      @@darklysm8345 That’s true Germany is rich country.. but Russia is not poor country either

    • @Napolean46
      @Napolean46 8 місяців тому

      ​@@darklysm8345even then Germany was wealthy but lost to russia

  • @ahmadsantoso9712
    @ahmadsantoso9712 2 роки тому +6

    From Stalinsad ☹️
    to Stalinglad ☺️

  • @jamesfarrell8339
    @jamesfarrell8339 6 років тому +15

    One of the biggest mistakes of the Germans was too stay in a city that had been reduced to ruble. There strong point was the blitzkrieg and by not being able to move quickly in the city gave a big advantage to the Russians. The battle became one of attrition where the Germans would be defeated. The Germans would be fighting street to street and house to house.
    You could not manover tanks and artillery peices around in such condition's.

    • @jamesfarrell8339
      @jamesfarrell8339 6 років тому +2

      Charles Carmichael .
      Great insight.

    • @depdark1
      @depdark1 5 років тому +3

      The leader of the german army asked hitler to break out but hitler refused. Told him to fight to the death

    • @Glorreich
      @Glorreich 3 роки тому +1

      Try another way, mafaka.
      I will meet you.

    • @jamesfarrell8339
      @jamesfarrell8339 3 роки тому +1

      Thank you 😊

    • @kniespel6243
      @kniespel6243 3 роки тому +3

      @@jamesfarrell8339 big mistake of the germans (adolf actually) was that he split the army in the summer 1942. Half for Caucasus and the other half to Stalingrad. That was the mistake. Otherwise,in short time Stalingrad was in german hands ! Here wasn't russian bravery or big russian victory. Only Adolf stupidity .

  • @mikyruna
    @mikyruna 4 роки тому +17

    7:04 pride and haughtiness in the face of this soldier...eternal glories to these heroes who fought all over europe

    • @suazmin107
      @suazmin107 4 роки тому +2

      Hero to his country

    • @charliedanrick6494
      @charliedanrick6494 3 роки тому +4

      And they lost all over Europe too. Decimated. Hitler kaput.

    • @kjragg1099
      @kjragg1099 3 роки тому +3

      No doubt still proud at the enormous feats of the Wehrmacht even against all odds. Conquering all of continental Europe. Flinging the Soviets all the way to the Volga until their own leader had to step in and tell them to stop running away from the Germans otherwise they’d be shot. What a force they were. But I’ll say that the Soviets were also incredibly brave and fought tenaciously when it mattered

    • @cedricliggins7528
      @cedricliggins7528 2 роки тому

      Teutonic pride

    • @blueshirtman8875
      @blueshirtman8875 2 роки тому +4

      "these heroes who fought all over europe"..............Which heroes?

  • @chavdarnaidenov2661
    @chavdarnaidenov2661 7 місяців тому +1

    The Nazis started the siege of the city with merciless aerial carpet-bombing and 2 days of artillery destruction. And near the finale, seeing they were surrounded and even air-drops of food were impossible, they starved to semi-death, convinced that they would be measured with the same yardstick they had used on the civilians of Stalingrad.

  • @bandwagon22
    @bandwagon22 6 років тому +9

    Great surrender - August 1991?

  • @sztamgast
    @sztamgast 6 років тому +18

    Rokosowski was one of few Soviet Generals that actually do not slaughter their soldiers

  • @alexnunezramos1720
    @alexnunezramos1720 2 роки тому +7

    6 army had a chance to escape. But no Hitler said no .💀♠️❄

  • @stevenmorris2293
    @stevenmorris2293 17 днів тому +1

    Would have been something if they could have sent Hitler a copy of this .

  • @davidcoleman2463
    @davidcoleman2463 6 років тому +8

    I have seen this video before but not with the narrative . Like it is a holiday time . The music . Wow

    • @jasminemadden4138
      @jasminemadden4138 5 років тому

      after the hell they endured to get here I think they deserve a damned party

    • @angelapapa79
      @angelapapa79 5 років тому +2

      Do not forget .. the films were shown back home in theatres with civilian audiences for information and empowerment. 😊

    • @ikmarchini
      @ikmarchini 3 роки тому +1

      Can't beat Tchaikovsky for a film score. And it's free.

  • @solisgod
    @solisgod 4 роки тому +2

    narrator is throwing some serious shade

  • @shafur3
    @shafur3 3 роки тому +4

    Did any of these men face the Neumberg trials

    • @tonygreene81able
      @tonygreene81able 3 роки тому +10

      Paules was one of the big witnesses for the prosecution.

  • @cgtvelloquenderoretro
    @cgtvelloquenderoretro 5 років тому +4

    0:01 20th century fox?

  • @hgcjgcugfugv9293
    @hgcjgcugfugv9293 6 років тому +9

    There was about 20 thousand that did not surrender. They Fought to the death. Germans, Austro, Croat, Italians, French and Spanish. It was the Spanish that kept the fight.

    • @derrickfield8957
      @derrickfield8957 6 років тому +1

      This is correct the fighting did not finally stop until well into April.

    • @arthurpozner7701
      @arthurpozner7701 6 років тому +11

      Austria was no longer a separate country after 1938.There were no French or Spanish units there. Romanians and Hungarians were nearly wiped out completely...

    • @IamMysterium
      @IamMysterium 6 років тому +4

      Lee Christy: and today the enemy the Third Reich and her allies fought on the Eastern Front are essentially the same leftist, Marxist, Globalist forces now trying to destroy Western Civilization. Will the Third Reich go down as the last stand for Western Civilization?

    • @nkvdcomradeorion7336
      @nkvdcomradeorion7336 6 років тому +5

      SyncKo The same invasion that the Germans conducted aswell? LOL hypocrit much? The two aggressors went at it, and the strongest won LOL get salty XD mad that Germs were brutally killed and raped after invading ? Too bad, you get what you give ROFL

    • @arthurlewis9193
      @arthurlewis9193 6 років тому +1

      Spanish!!! Fuck Off!

  • @LegateMalpais
    @LegateMalpais 5 років тому +1

    The last scene with the Univermag building... damn, RO PTSD right there!

  • @cedricliggins7528
    @cedricliggins7528 2 роки тому +6

    If Paulus and Schmidt had listened more to general von Drebber perhaps things would have turned out differently

  • @jacqueline6406
    @jacqueline6406 2 роки тому

    WoW , you became SO MANY for a Stalingrad Battle

  • @ahmedbenslim3396
    @ahmedbenslim3396 4 роки тому +1

    One thing
    How they recorded the video

  • @bobg6638
    @bobg6638 Рік тому +3

    Stalin vs. Hitler. Two of the biggest monsters in history. The US and UK were perfectly happy to let these two monsters fight it out. Who can blame them?

  • @rickyrobocop
    @rickyrobocop 4 роки тому

    2:20 the man in the background, is he german in the sights?

  • @mranonymous8725
    @mranonymous8725 7 років тому +38

    What destroys this short video is the typical british propaganda narrator. The germans were soldiers doing there duty just like us.
    Respect from uk
    And respect to russian soldiers.
    One day the human race will learn to live in peece.

    • @futuristic8748
      @futuristic8748 6 років тому

      Richard Morgan well said mate !!

    • @hermankranendonk
      @hermankranendonk 6 років тому +2

      Its an American voice, not British.

    • @alexanderskvortsov6654
      @alexanderskvortsov6654 6 років тому +9

      what duty? destroy soviet towns/villagers/prime civillians?

    • @carl-os4603
      @carl-os4603 6 років тому

      Uchiha Obito, thats called a "brave germans"

    • @alexanderskvortsov6654
      @alexanderskvortsov6654 6 років тому +2

      Video shows what will happen to invaders who will come to our lands.

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому +2

    Very, very Sad!

  • @vincentreynolds2127
    @vincentreynolds2127 6 років тому +15

    Germany-Played 2 LOST 2.

  • @joaquimtavares9680
    @joaquimtavares9680 6 років тому +23

    Os russos são mesmo, mesmo heróis.

  • @patrickcamusat2798
    @patrickcamusat2798 6 років тому +1

    What happened to those prisoners ? How many survived ? Who has a documented objective answer ?

  • @johnwest7463
    @johnwest7463 6 років тому +3

    Paulasshould have pulled back the six army reguardless of what Hitler's said saved his men rommellwould have

  • @peterellis1946
    @peterellis1946 7 років тому +21

    Paulus was bad but not that bad.He countermanded Hitler's order to shoot civilians and Russian soldiers as and when and it is untrue that he had ordered his men to take no prisoners and not to surrender. These were Hitler's orders which he disobeyed as he disobeyed Hitler's order not to surrender his forces. In the Western hemisphere he might well have been regarded as well as Rommel, because overall he was a gentleman and believed in the rules of war although it would not have seemed like it in Russia.
    Talking of Rommel most people are not aware that he led the army into Poland in 1939 where the most terrible atrocities occurred including raising Warsaw to the ground. You never hear of anything he did to stop it because he never considered it. He was a Nazi through and through and he believed in the Nazi creed. The fact that in the western hemisphere he acted according to the rules of war seemed to make him well regarded but he had a history.

    • @danielmarso7242
      @danielmarso7242 6 років тому +3

      He razed Warsaw to the ground.

    • @jamesfarrell8339
      @jamesfarrell8339 6 років тому +4

      Peter Ellis
      Unfortunately the Nazis war machine eventually turned on him and he was forced to commit suicide.
      There was nothing positive about the war and the Russians were as bad or worse than the Germans.

    • @arthurpozner7701
      @arthurpozner7701 6 років тому +2

      Erwin Rommel was in Africa during the Warsaw Ghetto uprising in 1943. During the 1944 Polish uprising he was nearing house detention/sick/dead.

  • @vincentreynolds2127
    @vincentreynolds2127 6 років тому +7

    Long Walk Home?

  • @johnsnowkumar359
    @johnsnowkumar359 7 років тому +10

    Despite orders to not discriminate Nazi German prisoners, there was subtle discrimination in prison camps. Italian and Hungarian troops were allowed to work in kitchens, and even to cook, so that they could overfeed their buddies. The Russian and other officials from unified countries/ kingdoms refused access to Germans to the prison kitchens cooking facilities to Nazi prisoners. The false excuse was that the Russian and unified commanders were afraid that the Germans will poison the food in the prisons.The Soviet prison officials simply told Nazis that they cannot every order from Moscow. The Nazi Germans had to deal with doleful food handouts, and were not allowed to cook or to go to the kitchens inside prisons.

    • @aCaptAmerica
      @aCaptAmerica 7 років тому +8

      John Snow Kumar ahhhhh poor babies lol fuck off.

    • @nkvdcomradeorion7336
      @nkvdcomradeorion7336 6 років тому +12

      Good, they're lucky Stalin even decided to keep them alive in the first place XD

    • @1994g0
      @1994g0 6 років тому +9

      Awwwwwww.The Nazis murdered millions in cold blood.And you`re bitching that Nazi prisoners had lousy food handout?

    • @Primal-Weed
      @Primal-Weed 6 років тому

      😂

    • @kjragg1099
      @kjragg1099 3 роки тому +1

      @@1994g0 the Soviets committed just as many crimes.

  • @vincentkosik403
    @vincentkosik403 2 роки тому +1

    What goes around comes around

  • @shafur3
    @shafur3 3 роки тому +2

    Germany would of never been able to control Russia

  • @sachiinrauut7790
    @sachiinrauut7790 2 роки тому +2

    4:59 Russian HEADQUARTER 😮

  • @kanthector
    @kanthector 5 років тому +2

    How could just this one defeat affect Germany so much

    • @joostdriesens3984
      @joostdriesens3984 5 років тому +13

      It was very important for Germany to either capture Russia's political and (a) manufacturing center (Moscow) and / or its oil fields in the south east. Through mismanagement by Hitler they ended up fighting at Stalingrad. They won nothing, even worse, they lost a lot of men and equipment. Remember that time is everything in war, it was basically Germany (Axis factions) against the world, they had to win fast or run out or resources while their enemies had time to grow in strength. While Germany was struggling at Stalingrad, Russia was building a gigantic army and then unleashed it. It was the beginning of the end.

    • @kanthector
      @kanthector 5 років тому

      I mean this was just one city. If sixth army lost, they could have sent one more army and continued the siege of the city. I am sure they had many more armies.

    • @joostdriesens3984
      @joostdriesens3984 5 років тому +3

      @@kanthector There were actually multiple armies involved in the battle of Stalingrad that were heavily damaged and prevented to assist in the battle of Stalingrad.
      The Army Group for instance included Romanian forces on the flanks outside the city.
      Another army was sent from the south, but it was attacked in the flank and could not advance further.
      After that is was not possible to quickly send more reinforcements. The Germans still had Armies but they were weakened and had to defend two fronts (east and west) stretching over thousands of kilometers. Moving any more armies would create gaps in the front line elsewhere.

    • @kanthector
      @kanthector 5 років тому +2

      I see, I thought perhaps the 6th army was one of the superior armies they had compared to others. So a defeat for that means no other army could do it. Wonder what Hitler cud have done after this defeat to save germany, but surrendering.

    • @r.h.2618
      @r.h.2618 5 років тому +1

      @@kanthector they send a new army but the army was stopped and pushed back. In 1943 in the battle by Kursk Wehrmacht has lost a new big battle. After this Red Army begun an offensive that ended in Berlin.

  • @SubStrange
    @SubStrange 5 років тому +2

    Did the Russian play their National anthem in battle?

  • @amvisca4155
    @amvisca4155 3 роки тому +3

    why no german people comment on this?

    • @mavjimbo
      @mavjimbo Рік тому +3

      They have really distanced themselves for sure

    • @Realistuuul
      @Realistuuul 6 місяців тому

      Try a vpn

  • @sotiriospapafragkou4422
    @sotiriospapafragkou4422 6 років тому +2

    Interesting Paulus had a twitching eye since then. He died of ALS about 10 years later.

    • @anthonycruciani939
      @anthonycruciani939 6 років тому +3

      The stress broke him down as it did Hitler.

    • @ikmarchini
      @ikmarchini 3 роки тому +4

      @@anthonycruciani939 He knew Barbarossa would fail. They had discovered that in war games from 1940. Supply and attrition would be their end. Paulus was overruled by Halder.

    • @anthonycruciani939
      @anthonycruciani939 3 роки тому

      @@ikmarchini I'm not sure about that. Hitler said all he had to do was kick the door in and the entire rotten edifice would collapse. Barbarossa was based on a horribly flawed intelligence assessment.

  • @jeffsmith6596
    @jeffsmith6596 5 років тому +16

    слава нашим красноармейским товарищам!

  • @bankimkulshreshtha8695
    @bankimkulshreshtha8695 6 років тому +2

    This force allegedly by the fascist standards was made of Aryans race,,they surrendered & their Fuerer committed suicide ,,greatness of peoples army of communist Russia,,Hitlers generally do not survive in the world ,,they only die but by the time they die public had paid a great cost,,fascism is first & last wish of capitalism to deform the democracies in the world,,Advocate Bankim kulshreshtha Indian

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому

    Stalingrad was the bloodiest Battle of them all in both pto, and eto.

  • @knowledgetree691
    @knowledgetree691 6 років тому +1

    who's general trabooti??

    • @hajime2k
      @hajime2k 5 років тому +4

      General Tolbukhin. He later led the Red Army to capturing Romania, Bulgaria, Yugoslavia, and I believe Vienna as well.

  • @LoneIcon
    @LoneIcon 5 місяців тому

    Bloodiest urban battle
    1. Stalingrad
    2. Battle of Manila

  • @legallyresistingtyranny5901
    @legallyresistingtyranny5901 6 років тому +19

    Point of fact: The Soviets actually lost far more troops at Stalingrad, than the Germans did.

    • @alexanderskvortsov6654
      @alexanderskvortsov6654 6 років тому +7

      Lol, losses are comparable

    • @legallyresistingtyranny5901
      @legallyresistingtyranny5901 6 років тому

      Urchin Obo, Wrong! You've obviously never looked up the losses for both sides.

    • @Primal-Weed
      @Primal-Weed 6 років тому +13

      Lol losses mean nothing. Victory is all that matters.

    • @legallyresistingtyranny5901
      @legallyresistingtyranny5901 6 років тому

      'Losses mean nothing'? Good luck finding anyone who will agree with you on that. LOL!!

    • @alexanderskvortsov6654
      @alexanderskvortsov6654 6 років тому +1

      Either side losses are higher than 1,000,000 people. There were a lot of romanian, hungarian, italian soldiers who became good fertilise for russian lands. Germans lost much equipment like tanks, aircarfts, artillerty that can't be restored very fast.

  • @jacqueline6406
    @jacqueline6406 2 роки тому +1

    I’m from the Stalingrad

  • @vitokito1071
    @vitokito1071 2 роки тому +1

    The eye twitch is a message. He doesn’t do it unless he looks at the camera first

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому +3

    The USA had to eventually fight indirectly The Hammer an Sickle; Cuban Missile Crisis, Korea, SouthVietnam, .

    • @stgr0186
      @stgr0186 9 місяців тому

      Those are problems the US created themselves, especially Cuban Missile Crisis that was a soviet counteract to the Turkish nuclear crisis, the US nuclear weapons that still are right under Russian (then soviet) mainland in Turkey.

  • @jordanmorris5827
    @jordanmorris5827 3 роки тому +1

    Would Friedrich Paulus have had a worst fate if Germany won?

  • @anawa7edminalnass206
    @anawa7edminalnass206 4 роки тому +2

    يمعود هذا محترم
    طلع بلبس نظيف وشرف بلده
    حتى السوفييت احترموه لأنه استسلم استسلام مشرف.
    أما صدام معطي نفسه اعلى رتبة بالعالم وهي مهيب
    ولما دخلوا الامريكان دخل الحفرة وفتحوا الحفرة طلع لهم وقالهم يابا انا صدام

  • @luiscalcano4359
    @luiscalcano4359 2 роки тому +1

    Oh yeah, the Berlin Airlift in Joe Stalin's Berlin Airlift where the USA prevailed in keeping the west from starving.

  • @joseph-sj7do
    @joseph-sj7do 2 місяці тому

    Rokossovsky had been sent to Gulag before Nazi Invasion by Stalin in 1940 but was released and appointed General in Dec 1941 at Battle of Moscow , Stalin said Britain gave time, Americans Money and Russians Blood to defeat the Nazis, combined UK and USA lost less than 1 Million dead Russians 27 Million to defeat Nazis , 95000 German Soldiers surrendered only 5000 survived to return to Germany in 1955 , 12 years later, all the Generals survived

  • @knhmutknhmut9849
    @knhmutknhmut9849 6 років тому +4

    Well done Russia for dooming

  • @kniespel6243
    @kniespel6243 2 роки тому +2

    The great surrender ?! Bullshit! 110.000 soldiers is not a great surrender dude. Great surrender was in 1941 at Briansk and Veazma ,where the germans took it 1 milllion russian pows!!

    • @Brslld
      @Brslld Рік тому +5

      Idk capturing unprepared conscripts with 10 days of training using air superiority is less of an achievement as destroying the largest german field army and 2 romanian armies man to man. Besides, Vyazma wasn't even 1 million. Its 250k (least stupid Soviet generals 😂😂😂).
      Anyways 110k prisoners from an army that brands itself as "superhumans" and "superior" is pretty funny ngl.

    • @kniespel6243
      @kniespel6243 Рік тому

      @@Brslld from what source you know that? I sow a lot of books and documentaries about 1941,Briansk and Veazma ,about russian pow's. Indeed it was 1 million russian pow's. Russians never tooked such pow's! Russians was so many , like sheeps.

    • @Brslld
      @Brslld Рік тому +2

      @@kniespel6243 No, what source did you have? If you just searched the vyazma and briansk pockets every source (books, reports and such) would cap it at 600k. For me personally I do not watch documentaries, they're all slop, made to cater to the mainstream, I'd rather waste my time finding information in the internet (for free I might add) than to watch condensed entertainment garbage, because thats pretty much what most ww2 docus are.

  • @rfj1156
    @rfj1156 2 роки тому

    what tf is Klitschko doing in Stalingrad 7:02

  • @geoeconomics3067
    @geoeconomics3067 5 років тому +1

    But why all this ?
    It's imperative that no Eurasian Challenger emerges capable of dominating EurAsian landmass and thus of also of challenging America
    -- -
    Zbignew Brzezinski
    How ?
    Those who control Eurasia control the world
    -
    John Halford Mackinder

  • @araldo82
    @araldo82 3 роки тому

    4:42 Giulio Andreotti

  • @vladimir57694
    @vladimir57694 4 роки тому +1

    I would advice to remember this event! Now days nobody going to stay in tranches, nuclear bombs.........

  • @antique7391
    @antique7391 8 місяців тому

    Always listed as one of the worst battles in human history. Hitler seemed pretty much impervious to the loss of life. Just a test of Germanys will to win. I suppose the First World War shaped his thoughts..

  • @johnwright291
    @johnwright291 2 роки тому +1

    Wow Rokosvsky was gettin his rocks off. Yeah I went there. Sorry. The surrendered generals didn't have to much to worry about and were probably relieved. Not so much the file and rank soldiers.

  • @hotsiam3193
    @hotsiam3193 6 років тому +1

    the nazis could have prevented 20 million people starving to death :(

    • @CA-jz9bm
      @CA-jz9bm 3 роки тому +3

      20 million never starved, but Germans literally were starving people, you know hunger plan? Generaplan Ost? Blokade of Leningrad?

  • @jimmyho6849
    @jimmyho6849 3 роки тому +1

    91000 surrenders and just 6000 backed to their home

    • @admiralbeez8143
      @admiralbeez8143 3 роки тому

      A similar number (about 90,000) British Empire troops were captured at Singapore, but the majority came home. The Germans, as you show were not so luckily.

  • @xxalligatorxxzz7565
    @xxalligatorxxzz7565 3 роки тому

    Out of the 200,000 troops around 5k returned back to germany

    • @kjragg1099
      @kjragg1099 3 роки тому +1

      And of those 5k I wonder how many weren’t scarred by their experiences in the post-war Soviet POW camps and gulags. Poor men

    • @simonsimonovic4478
      @simonsimonovic4478 3 роки тому

      No, 6th army had 300 000 man, of whom 90 000 were alive when they surrendered, of whom 5 K returned to Germany in 1955

  • @بمبميميمي
    @بمبميميمي 6 років тому

    معركة ستلنغراد التي انتهت نهاية مأساوية لألمان انكسار الجيش الالماني السادس بغزو روسيا بقيادة الجنرال فريدرك باولوس

  • @marireynolds3996
    @marireynolds3996 4 роки тому

    Fight till the very end no surrender

  • @geoeconomics3067
    @geoeconomics3067 4 роки тому

    But why ?
    Now you will learn what is up:
    Those who control
    EurAsia
    control the World
    -
    John Halford Mackinder
    USA can not conquer Eurasia
    From this came Balance of Power
    -
    It's IMPERATIVE
    that no Eurasian challenger emerges emerges capable of dominating EurAsia and thus of also challenging America
    -
    Zbignew Brzezinski

  • @revol148
    @revol148 2 роки тому +5

    As Henry Kissinger said about the 1980-88 Iran v Iraq war: "isn't it a shame both sides can't lose" - I feel the same about the war in the East - the USSR was slightly worse than the Nazis.

    • @miles2142
      @miles2142 Рік тому +4

      kissinger's armies got annihilated in vietnam by rice farmers lmao

    • @stgr0186
      @stgr0186 9 місяців тому

      So much of anti-soviet false propaganda has been pushed in the west so many years that we have results like these, alternating historical facts and taking propagandist lies as truths not based on any historical or documented proof against the USSR.

    • @aAverageFan
      @aAverageFan 8 місяців тому

      The British Empire was worse than the USSR

  • @mponsie
    @mponsie 4 роки тому +4

    The importance of this defeat is overlooked by many. At that time the - more clever - top Nazi’s started to understand that the war was lost then and there. If you spent some time to view some vid’s about the rise of Hitler, you understand that is was - for most Germans - a matter of being forced to join the army (Hitler made it simple, you’re with us or against us). Everyone made huge sacrifices (the Russians even more than the Nazi’s). Eventually a lot of those Nazi soldiers never returned. Regardless of who was wrong or wright it is human suffering.

  • @КириллГолованов-п4ы
    @КириллГолованов-п4ы 6 років тому +1

    Вам чтобы понять надо оказаться здесь

  • @Ivan_Drago.
    @Ivan_Drago. 5 років тому +1

    A tragedy

    • @rttr8001
      @rttr8001 5 років тому

      What?

    • @SnafuWT
      @SnafuWT 4 роки тому

      @@rttr8001 people died.

  • @kdfulton3152
    @kdfulton3152 2 роки тому +4

    If it weren’t for the Russians tenacity at Stalingrad, Hitler could of owned the Volga, thereby starving Russia of her oil.
    We could all be speaking German today if it weren’t for the Russians. And how do we repay them? By being sneaky and disrespectful.

    • @shianzekri7629
      @shianzekri7629 Рік тому +1

      We speak English because England successfully dominated the world . We don't speak German because Germany was unsuccessful at dominating the world.
      So I don't understand what are you are trying to prove here saying we would be speaking German today as if speaking German is a sin. There's nothing wrong with that. Instead just say we would be ruled under nazis today that's not good.

    • @Brslld
      @Brslld Рік тому

      ​@heptex8989truth

  • @Arthur-tx8fd
    @Arthur-tx8fd 8 місяців тому

    As Churchill would say. " Hooray for communism"

  • @paulmicelli5819
    @paulmicelli5819 Рік тому

    The beginning of the END!

  • @hiterbober2545
    @hiterbober2545 5 років тому

    очень хорошо

  • @Mitulmahakal4529
    @Mitulmahakal4529 6 років тому +9

    Russia the great

  • @paulsimon8269
    @paulsimon8269 5 років тому +2

    Reference title Enemy At The Gates by William Craig 1973. The battle for Stalingrad...similar to napoleons disaster in Russia.predictable fate by Russian winter made them an easy kill...

  • @4555joe
    @4555joe 6 років тому +14

    Good day for freedom!!!

  • @IcExHeCz
    @IcExHeCz 4 роки тому +1

    music is ridiculous

    • @ikmarchini
      @ikmarchini 3 роки тому

      You find Tchaikovsky ridiculous?

  • @sloppy_rat
    @sloppy_rat 6 років тому

    tim tim jon is my roblox pass

  • @manjinderatwal5178
    @manjinderatwal5178 4 роки тому +1

    Black day German army