Dell P2721Q 4K USB-C Monitor Review - Good for MacBook Pro?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 25 гру 2020
- TechWalls reviewed the Dell P2721Q 27-inch 4K USB-C Monitor.
Buy on Amazon: amzn.to/3lClkKs
Full review on www.techwalls.com/
Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. - Наука та технологія
Just ordered one after reading your review! Thanks for the video too!!
Nice review it helped me out a lot. Especially when you moved it around.
Thank you very much for your clear, very detailed, and very insightful review.
Excellent review - THANK YOU!
Great detailed review. Thank you.
Been searching and comparing with all the different models, and I am finally convinced to get this monitor! Thank you for your in depth review! I hope it turns out as what I needed!
did you buy the monitor? if you did, how good is this monitor?
@RazorBackX have you had any problems with this monitor yet? Do you use MacBook Pro with it? Just trying to see if it’s worth buying . Thanks
Nicely done...thanks for the review
Excellent review. Thank you.
Great video, Sir ! Liked and subscribed
I could listen to this guy review anything.
Straight forward review. No fluff. Soothing voice.
And that monitor desktop wallpaper is fire.
nice research and review bro
Thanks for your review. I just ordered this display.
are you satisfied?
@@igoryukhnin Yes, I am!
using usb c-c cable connects mac and the monitor, the screen is 4k 60hz automatic or you have to adjust the resolution/refresh rate manually? thank you.
i just ordered me this Dell P2721Q because of ur video! Right now im using the Dell P2421DC, but the text is so blurry, that i can't keep it. I hope the new monitor will display crisp text for my macbook air m1!
Hello ,really nice review.I would like to ask,I have external speakers with the classic jack cable,how exactly can these be connected to the monitor in that case? I will set it up with the Mac mini M1.
Tks for the review. In the display settings menu there are available different scale options. Could you please confirm which one suits better for the 27” 4k monitor? Is it the QHD?
It looks like the one by default (first from the left) is 1080p HD. From what I've read, it is the one that is the best optimized for the screen and GPU because it is exactly half the native resolution (3840 x 2160p => 1920 x 1080p). Then he switches for the second from the left which is 1440p QHD indeed. It gives him more space but reduces texts size. I would personally prefer 1080p because I prefer larger texts than having too much space. I like having my apps fullscreen, and 1440p leaves too much white space for my liking. But this all depends on personal preferences, whether you have good sight and if you like to open multiple windows on one desktop. FYI the 5K 27" iMac has a default resolution of 1440p optimized for its native resolution of 2880p. Personally on a 27" 5K iMac I prefer the larger scaled resolution of 1152p which I think is the perfect compromise between text size and space. I think it is possible to use 1152p resolution on the Dell monitor if you click on the "scaled" radio button while maintaining ALT/Option key pressed. I will ask Tuan Do in a separate comment what he thinks of this rez.
Hello! Are you using a common USB-C cable or is it a thunderbolt 3? i'm looking for a USB-C cable to connect my monitor to my Mac mini and save my HDMI port for a TV, but i'm worried that the cable are not able to send the video, only data...
I am thinking of getting this but using scaling. Not the last option but second to last scale option. I was also thinking of a 32” scaled so. What’s your feeling about this?
I see a little bit laggy while you adjust the height as well as the tilt. Is that right?
Got two monitors of these…will get delivered tomorrow 🚀🚀🚀
Hey Im choosing between s2721qs and this monitor (p2721q). Which one do you think is better ?
Mình đang dùng macbook 13 2017 không biết có chạy nổi với cái màn hình này không ? nếu bạn có thông tin cho mình biết nhé.
Hi ! Is it possible to scale at 1152p clicking on the "scaled" radio button while keeping Alt/Option key pressed ? What do you think of this resolution ? I am thinking it could be the perfect compromise between large text size at 1080p and more space at 1440p. Thank you for your review I like what you had to say about the monitor it was really helpful.
Yes, but I think it's better on 1296p.
Thanks, bro. A good 4k monitor for mac mini. Please introduce more cheap and good digital devices
hi, does your macbook get heat while connecting this 4K monitors ?
is your macbook with apple M1 chip?
Hi, nice video! How much watt output have the USB-A Ports? E.g. for charging an iPhone. Thank you.
I did exactly the same!! Return the Benq to Amazon, then do the research and now I am stuck with Dell P2721Q or ultra-thin
What u got
Is it possible to adjust the brightness of the display via the keyboard?
I personally prefer 2 27's @ 1440 but it does seem like the U and P q monitors from dell got almost everything right. If I were looking for one of these this is a pretty solid quick no nonsense review.
Thanks for the video!! I have just bought Dell P2721Q. Loved!! Text is crystal clear! Please, would you tell me where can I find the wallpaper shown in the video? Thanks.
ok, I found it! I guess it's built in Mac wallpapers.
Bro , i was also amazed by the monitor and wanted to know about the wallpaper.
Is charging when you plug the usb c cable to mac's thunderbolt 3 ?
hi, is this monitor good enough to play ps5 in 4k? i would use it with my mac 2020 13 inch and for casual gaming on ps5.
Hi Tuan Do, I just purchased myself this model Dell P2721Q too after watching this video. You are right, the monitor is awesome! However, do you experienced very light screen flickering at times? It's just like you video record from your phone on the LDC light build flickering, if you do what is your solution for this? Thanks in advance.
Use the warranty, I would suggest.
Did you fix the issue?
@@zikamikakokoku hi, im not sure what i did, I did not see it flickering anymore
Man, can you share your wallpaper ? thank you
Hello! Which MBP do you connect to this monitor? Do the USB 3.2 Gen ports work with this connection? Also interested in whether the MBP 16 " will be charged, or the power will not be enough?
I have read that they don't, unless you plug the monitor using the display port.
Thanks for this review. Text clarity is my #1 priority, and this was helpful. A question : is your Macbook Pro an M1 model, and what OS are you running? I noticed that the output is in RGB (when you show the OSD).
Amit K: related info, i just managed to set my Dell U2520D to RGB mode by turning on the HDR mode in the OSD settings while having de-activated the HDR mode in the macOS display settings. Previously, I only got Ypbpr mode using my MacBook Pro M1.
Macbook pro m1 . All fine but after restart loosing usb hub connection. How to solve this issue. The usb on screen
Thanks for this really helpful review! Any reasons why you didn’t consider LG monitors in your choice?
I actually considered the LG 27UK850-W but it is 3 years old and has some backlight bleed complaint. Besides, the Dell was way cheaper when I bought it.
Hi there, i’m using macbook pro 2017, i’m not sure the performance when we extend from mac, thanks everyone for the answer.
Hey Tuan Do, at what scaling option do you use the monitor? Do fonts and icons look ok, or to small (or to big) ?
I choose the scaled resolution of 2560x1440. Everything looks great because it is actually scaled down from 5120x2880.
@@TechWallsReview many thanks! Will be buying the same monitor.
Hi anyone can to tell me if the cable comes with the monitor works with usb-c MacBook Pro 2020 four ThunderBolt or we have to buy another cable ?
Thanks
Did you experienced any issues with your macbook overheating while being connected to your 4k monitor? Thanks
yes i wondering the temperature too, is it safe..
How's the USB-C charging? 15"/16" Macbook Pro requires 95W for charging but this monitor only provides 65W. Do you think its still usable doing your tasks while charging lower than the standard Watts?
No problem, I'm using the MacBook Pro 15" with this monitor.
Ủng hộ bác reviewer VN :D
SOLD!
Would you use it for gaming on a PS5 and regular use of MacBook ?
No this is not good for PS5. I used it for a few months with my MacBook before switching to another monitor.
After 1 year of using, what's your conclusion?
You just sold me the monitor, thanks!
I considering getting one, but I stuck between a S2721QS - which has great reviews, it's cheaper but less functional and uglier (white back) and P2721Q - any thoughts on comparing those two ?
I think the quality of the panel in P series is better from my research.
this is a Cheaper version of the better performing monitor DELL U2720Q. where I am the LG 27UL850-w is a competitor which is also a little cheaper.
Can you also share the weight in Kg?
What is model of your audio system? Thanks!
This ua-cam.com/video/Bwi5JBbUf_o/v-deo.html
is the text sharp enough?
Quick question: Can this monitor charge a MB Pro 16" which by default comes with a 96w charger? Thank you.
Sure, it works fine without the charger.
Dell S3221QS Curved Monitor or Dell S2722QC
I would appreciate any answer in that case from anyone reading this,since I have no clue about it and been searching a while how I can connect my external speakers to the specific monitor :P I am really convinced purchasing the monitor especially after watching the review ,but not sure if my speakers can be connected to that.
You can’t connect your speaker on thé screnn (no jack). You have to connecte your speaker at you mac
Excellent review. How do you keep the macbook closed and still get a signal?
Have your laptop lid/cover open, plug in monitor, then close laptop lid/cover.
Thanks, a bit hard to decide between P2721Q and U2720Q
or Dell S2721QS
U2720Q if you use a 15-16 inch MacBook Pro. P2721Q if you use other MacBooks with less power usage. Advice stands for Windows laptops; check power consumption before purchasing, because the power output is different between the two monitors (90W for U2720Q and 65W for P2721Q I think). I don't recommend the S2721QS unless you're using a desktop computer, because the 27W of output probably won't charge your laptop fast enough.
@@seiji5756 i have a mbp 15" and ordered the p2721q.. is there any way to turn off the usb-c charging functionality? im worried about using the monitor power deliver above its capacity.
Damn very clear, nice voice. This is a surprisingly valuable review! Cám ơn bạn!
I and my friend bought 2 monitors U2720Q and P2721Q. Seems P has the better white color
So this is like having another Retina Display, right? Same quality. Same resolution. Same sharp text, right?
No.
@@edimarjunior572 How close?
@@joelcipriano1985 close.
But can your Macbook Pro maintain its charge while using both the monitor and the macbook's screen?
Looking into this, I would not get this monitor. 65W is not enough to keep the MBP charged, and therefore you will be going through power cycles wearing down your battery.
Yes, I've used this monitor for 6 months and it charges my MacBook with no issue.
Can I connect it like a extended monitor with Mac proc.?
Sure you can.
Is as sharp as the retina display? The 2560x1440p scale doesnt looks blurry?
The ppi is lower but can't see the difference.
@@TechWallsReview at 1440p doesnt looks blurry?
@@edimarrodrigrove3377 Of course it does. 1440p downscaling on any 4k monitor will always look blurrier than native 1440. A lot of people recommend against it. For example, every 1.5 (3840/2560) vertical pixels now becomes one vertical pixel. You can't cut pixels in half like that so you get a blurry image.
If using in 4k, ppi is 163 vs retina ppi of >220 on macbook pros.
@@NN-sp9tu Well, no. Even scaled 4K to 1440p looks way better than nativa 1440p.
@@edimarjunior572
Maybe in your opinion. It’s just a fact that it’s blurry, maybe some people interpret that as smoothness but I’ve never heard of anyone that thinks it looks good
I connected the monitor using an HDMI and the apple connector. The monitor worked fine and then started to flickr. Did I do something wrong?
Have you tried the USB-C connection? Mine flickers just a few times per day.
Thank you. I used the USB C and connected in the first port from the back of the laptop. Now I see aorund the bezels.over use of glue. Do you see that in your monitor?
@@TechWallsReview Thank you for the recommendations. I re-ordered the monitor and it came today. Is better than the previous one. I like the contrast and the picture quality is fantastic. Thank you again for the review.
$600 for this monitor, I think the 2k monitor-2721DE is the better option
Why
Hello, 32-bit programs, it got blurry (blurry). 64-bit programs are ok. Is this normal for this monitor (P2721Q)?
Its not the monitor, are the 32bit programs.
@@edimarjunior572 It's the monitor! I already managed to solve it! I found a solution! Here on UA-cam nobody talks about this monitor defect, and how to solve it. After a lot of research I found a solution, Thanks
@@carmo3d213 its not a problem with the monitor. Is a problem with 32bit apps scaling.
@@edimarjunior572 Thanks for listening. I already solve!
m1?
who else hears buzzing and whining noise from the display?
Just to make things clear about the power situation- If you own 13' MacBook Pro, 65W charging is more than enough so described problems will not be the case.
And the 14" m1x pro?
Anyone else having weird problems with this monitor and a macbook pro M1? After an hour of use it will start to develop vertical lines and then flicker. I ran the self test and it does it even with nothing connected. I actually ordered a replacement and now it's doing the exact same thing!!! It seems a weird coincidence 2 dell P2721Q would have the same fault so I wonder if the silicon macbook pro is to blame? But it's weird it would flicker even in self test without the macbook connected. It even shows a slight ghost image of the osx big sur interface!
I’d really like to know where you land on this as I am considering one for my M1 MBP
@@matts7696 Honestly I’m still in the same boat. It seems to be certain colours like dark gray that trigger it. But it’s so inconsistent I can’t really say for sure. It only happened once in the past few days of use after I switched to using safari instead of Firefox m1 beta. But it might be coincidence
I had this problem with an M1 MacBook Air and a Dell U2713HM from 2013. It's the Mac, not the monitor.
@@aednichols Yea I found out later once I got the replacement monitor it did the exact same thing. But now it's not doing it for the past week. Makes no sense
@@paul6925 can you check the monitor’s OSD for the color mode, RGB or YPbPr? The M1 Macs sometimes want to output the wrong one, especially to Dell monitors. Thanks in advance.
not work with apple silicon m1 chips.
really? Why not?
@@lucasckassio na verdade funciona, mas voce precisa comprar um cabo thunderbolt 3 usb c de 100w de corrente ( que nao vem com o monitor) custa uns 200 bolsonaros. e se for pra video, nao recomendo pq ele nao tem brilho, e é muito descalibrado no vermelho ( nao tem software de calibração pra mac) ai tu ve na tela do mac, e ve na tela dell e sao duas coisas bem diferentes. fora isso é bom e barato.
@@levigarcia7035 Levi, Tô com o mesmo problema, cara! Meu MBP M1 não joga vídeo no monitor.. com você funcionou a comprar um cabo a parte? você recomenda algum específico no Mercado Livre?
@@jonatas_winston tem que comprar um cabo usb c thundebolt 100w que funciona
i think 2720Q is far more better!
Of course, its way expensive
Could you explain why? I'm choosing one of them.
it's not 4k monitor
The Dell P2721Q? Yes it is!
Q suffix stands for 4k at Dell...
Blacks will NEVER look like perfect blacks with LCD panels, even if you set brightness to the lowest usable value
Of course, but that doesn't stop them from being able to have excellent blacks.
Sorry, but this is *NOT* a REVIEW. It is more an unboxing and a first hands-on.
In my opinion, a review should include hard facts like measurements with professional equipment.
Brightness, black level, contrast, image homogeneity/illumination, coating, viewing angle, color reproduction (before and after calibration), response behavior, latency time...
Colorspace, Responstime, But this requires a colorimeter.
Also consider to mention alternatives in the future. Nevertheless, I highly enjoyed your video.
It's not in-depth but this is still a review.
Well, you always can buy and make yourself video.
Don't try to say what people should do or not.
U2720Q still be better than this :)
Of course, its way expensive.