Better than the Bambu Lab X1C (for the money) - Flashforge Adventurer 5M Pro

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 210

  • @mikelaurie3850
    @mikelaurie3850 3 місяці тому +16

    Thanks for the lengthy review with tons of detail, this is what all reviews should be like

  • @zravel
    @zravel 2 місяці тому +5

    I absolutely agree that the Adventure 5M is a really growing alternative at the moment. By far the biggest advantage of Flashfroge: Flashfrog is in the more expensive segment (Flashforge Guider 3 Ultra), it brings a lot of professionalism to the cheaper models. Customer support, customer proximity, open ears - this is on a higher level and plays in a different league and is absolutely outstanding. The not Pro model - an unbeatable price performance. I have the Pro, the non-Pro and Bambulab X1C. However, I don't see the 5M as the beginner printer. I see it as an additional printer for people who know their way by working with 3D Printes or those how will spend a littel more time to come into the topic.
    The M5 is a damn good printer, but in my opinion, there are also disadvantages, note: I Complain at a very high level, at this price there is actually no complaint at all:
    Missing spaghetti detection.
    Missing first Layer inspection.
    The PEI Plat is even worse than the old black one from Bambulab - so the PEI plate from the M5 is even worse than the one that Bambulab no longer sells (and I also have many such plates from the M5)
    A lot of work when creating profiles, Bambulab comes with a lot of generic profiles that only need small adjustments - these are already in Orca Slicer.
    At flashprint, new fillament profiles from 5M can`t be easily saved on 5M Pro (nothing at all).
    You can`t even save anything from 0.6 nozzel profiles to a 0.4mm nozzle setting because everything is saved in a single profile (i.e. printer settings and filament settings are not separated). In Flashprint there is no distinction between printer settings and general filament settings. And the supports produced by Flasprint (tree structers) are a disaster.
    If you want to operate the M5 in the Orca, you really have to start at the beginning with the profiles. There wasn't the slightest bit of preparatory work from Flashfrog. This takes a lot of time and you really have to buy more than one printer before you take the time to do it.
    Many filament manufacturers also offer prefabricated profiles for Bambulabs - no wonder, everyone wants to get their filaments on those printer. At Flashfrog, not even Flashfrog itself works on modifying their fillament printing profiles... so I think there will never be a filament manufacturer that will match them to the Flashfrog as well, and until that won`t happens, the M5 is just a lot more work. And that means in a few words: More work for the customer = fewer customers.

  • @Spartyo
    @Spartyo 2 місяці тому +3

    I think you're one of the best at in depth comparisons like this. Love to see these types of videos from you, you explain the *why* in ways that are both technical, yet easy to understand.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +1

      Thank you for the compliment. I hope you have a wonderful day.

  • @TweakRacer
    @TweakRacer 3 місяці тому +48

    Should be comparison with the PIP at the same $499 price, rather than the X1C and then using its higher price against it.

    • @Antrim3d
      @Antrim3d 3 місяці тому +5

      P1p is not enclosed at $499

    • @Andyah
      @Andyah 3 місяці тому +4

      @@Antrim3d p1s`?

    • @ljadf
      @ljadf 3 місяці тому +3

      The P1P and P1S are closer in price, perhaps not exactly the same, but larger volume. I think I'll stick with them.

    • @NWGR
      @NWGR 2 місяці тому +4

      @@ljadf Yeah, for apples to apples here, the P1S is only $100 more than the flashforge, and is a better printer in a lot of ways. That's where my money would go as well.

    • @anomicxtreme
      @anomicxtreme 2 місяці тому

      @@NWGR Only difference between P1P and P1S is the enclosure and both are 4 filament, with the X1-C being 16. Not to mention the types of filament as well. This is like saying a chevette is better than a corvette because I can put 85 octane in it. Ludicrous.

  • @Sfernan888
    @Sfernan888 3 місяці тому +7

    Our lab did an analysis on Magigoo. they said its 1 part 100% ipa, 1 part distilled water and 2 parts clear washable elmer's glue. if you want you can try it out and compare it to the other bed adheasives.

  • @NoMercyFtw
    @NoMercyFtw 3 місяці тому +10

    This printer is my go to recommendation for everyone wanting to get into 3D printing that's serious but not this model it's the regular one for $300 because you can enclose it for cheaper than $200 yourself again if you're serious about 3D printing this should not be an issue, and the one thing I love about this 3D printer is it's the only printer I've encountered that actually has 5G Wi-Fi speeds and it comes with an optional Ethernet port which IMO you don't need because of the fast Wi-Fi speeds lol............. The only downside to this printer is the cost of the replacement nozzles that's it, install the klipper mod to completely delete that filament waste when you change filaments, and it's $38 for the harden steel ones $35 only for the regular .4, great video........

    • @Numenor7
      @Numenor7 3 місяці тому +1

      How did you enclose it? How much did that cost?

  • @thelightspeed3d712
    @thelightspeed3d712 3 місяці тому +7

    I have thousands of hours on both these printers. I actually like how the FF loads and unloads filament

    • @Cheeky-Trivia
      @Cheeky-Trivia 2 місяці тому

      its actually pretty smart, just clip off the filament and load in new stuff. No waiting on unloading and then loading. IMO more efficient.

  • @brawndo8726
    @brawndo8726 3 місяці тому +5

    Nice review. FYI there was rumor that Bambu firmware was sending gcode back to home-base. The mere possibility of espionage is a bit of a deal breaker to me. The ability to self-install Klipper is probably something most people should add to their requirements list.

  • @daymianhayes2493
    @daymianhayes2493 3 місяці тому +6

    I own the Flashforge 5M, it was my first printer. It prints perfectly out of the box every time, with default settings in Orca slicer. I've done alot of testing with it and it can print at speeds up to 600mm/s. Its been very reliable, my favorite part is the quick change nozzles.

    • @Thadopeera
      @Thadopeera 3 місяці тому

      Dope feedback bro. Need as much info as I can get

  • @retromodernart4426
    @retromodernart4426 3 місяці тому +2

    Whoa, what an extensive review, that's the shining example of what a review should be!
    Your excellent review makes it VERY easy to decide to buy this printer 😃
    Thank you very much for setting such a high standard in printer review!

  • @thelightspeed3d712
    @thelightspeed3d712 3 місяці тому +3

    I did a ton of ASA with mine and the flashforge is now only doing ASA, PC nylon etc. it’s a dang good machine for that stuff. I love it lol I’m typing as I’m watching the video.

  • @ZURAD
    @ZURAD 3 місяці тому +4

    Looking at their website, they don't claim PA compatibility. That might be a deal breaker for me. Also I greatly appreciate that you tore down the hotend. That's huge

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +3

      Yeah, it's because of that hotend. Any filament that prints under 280° will work.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      Isnt pa in preset list on filament load menu?

  • @josephploettner7327
    @josephploettner7327 3 місяці тому +4

    Thanks for the great video! Glad to see some new things.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +1

      You're welcome. Thank you for the nice comment. Have a nice day.

  • @TastySlowCooker
    @TastySlowCooker 3 місяці тому +4

    Just FYI on the filament screen of the bambulab there’s an unload button. You don’t have to tap the screen a hundred times. Thanks for the review, it’s interesting to see what the rest of the industry is doing, but my partner will kill me if I get a third printer 😬

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +2

      I hate using the filament unload button because it makes you declare what filament you have which takes more time than just clicking the button a hundred times.

    • @TastySlowCooker
      @TastySlowCooker 3 місяці тому +1

      @@DesignPrototypeTest fair enough

  • @Antrim3d
    @Antrim3d 3 місяці тому +4

    Great video. Good insights. I've missed these style of videos. 👍🏻🤗

  • @jeffgoodin4278
    @jeffgoodin4278 8 днів тому

    Best review of this printer I've seen! Just bought mine 2 weeks ago and could not be happier! One issue I have is it stopping on a very large print with a Move Queue Overflow error. I heard it's because of very low system memory, but ... ?

  • @AJSax0n
    @AJSax0n 2 місяці тому +1

    The ultrasonic welded extruder unit is actually very easy to open. It pops open with your fingers.
    I’ve opened mine 3 time due to filament wrapping around the teeth inside.

  • @pixelbat
    @pixelbat 2 дні тому

    Excellent comprehensive review. I have the non pro version of this printer, and couldn't be happier. The proprietary nozzle is the biggest downside. However, there are aftermarket alternatives out now. There are bambu style hotends on Aliexpress for these printers. Ordered one the other day, can't wait to test it out :D

  • @janzugic6798
    @janzugic6798 3 місяці тому +2

    love the in depth review, thanks

  • @thelightspeed3d712
    @thelightspeed3d712 3 місяці тому +4

    The nozzle is the same nozzle flashforge has been using since 2018. My understanding is it can go to 300°. I did have an issue with mine. The z motor shaft was bent causing all kinds of weird stuff.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +2

      So If Bontech and Slice made a conversion, it would be compatible on many printers that Flashforge makes?

  • @yudhisthiradharma
    @yudhisthiradharma 3 місяці тому +4

    Nice review .. but I guess you should compare with the P1s cause it’s in the same range.. it’s not on the same league of the x1C .. still I like the flashforge touch screen …

  • @joseph-montanez
    @joseph-montanez 3 місяці тому +2

    Finally showed up on my recommended feed!

  • @ProjectDefi
    @ProjectDefi 3 місяці тому +1

    Bro great content. You earn a subscribe. I'm new to 3d printing. I got the a1 mini as my first printer. I'm pretty happy with ease of use. Was thinking x1 carbon. This has swayed me. Thank you. I will save a bunch

  • @Scr00ples
    @Scr00ples 3 місяці тому +3

    1:03:00 , you could try those felt pads that stick on to furniture legs. Cut them small and place them on the cable chain to prevent further rubbing/scratching.

    • @algisberziunas
      @algisberziunas 3 місяці тому +2

      @@Scr00ples just cut tube for 3cm off ant it wont scratch

  • @richiebricker
    @richiebricker 3 місяці тому +4

    Havent seen ya in a couple months, Stupid algorithm. I miss ya taking apart brand new stuff just so we can see how it works

  • @toalan
    @toalan 2 місяці тому +1

    One thing that nobody mentions in reviews is power consumption. The 5M Pro should have stellar energy efficiency since the bed is a bit smaller than average and the housing is plastic.

  • @mohammedssuliman9117
    @mohammedssuliman9117 3 місяці тому +1

    Hey long time no see, u look healthier .. good to see u

  • @TheIllya
    @TheIllya 3 місяці тому

    Just bought mine, it should arrive in a few days! Looking forward to playing with it

  • @kyndred-ry5mm
    @kyndred-ry5mm 3 місяці тому +1

    lots of detail ,thank you

  • @SrObser
    @SrObser 3 місяці тому +2

    Too bad about the proprietary hotend, but I guess with those speeds we can just stick with the included 0.4mm until an open source alternative comes up.

    • @davidwilson4190
      @davidwilson4190 2 місяці тому

      Print with the included .6 nozzle, OrcaFlash has the profile for the .6... it's a game changer. Prints .4 layer height at max, makes vase mode just smokin fast... layer lines on certain prints adds a certain effect that's desired

  • @1blktalon
    @1blktalon 3 місяці тому +2

    Thank you for this video.

  • @RonaldStear
    @RonaldStear 2 місяці тому

    Elmers purple school glue stick is master of all bed adhesives. Also every time you load filament you get a purge, no reason for plugged nozzles. Never happens to me and I've use this for hundreds of prints. Finally, to properly purge the head that's what that strange, crooked wire thingy was that you saw when you unboxed.

  • @lavafree
    @lavafree 3 місяці тому +4

    Great to see you back to a more positive video 👏🏻👏🏻💪🏻

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +9

      I'm always positive. Even when I'm being critical. I'm working to make things better.

  • @tylerplayzz8697
    @tylerplayzz8697 Місяць тому

    Try the Qidi Q1 pro, it can print just as fast at the 5M Pro, can get it for a decent bit less with a coupon code, has an actively heated chamber, and a bigger build volume than the 5M Pro

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  Місяць тому

      I've been burned twice accepting Qidi printers for review. I really wanted to like them. On paper they have everything that I'm looking for. In actuality the engineering is flawed and the printers don't deliver. At least the ones that I saw. It would take A LOT to get me to trust that brand. Basically every single other reviewer would have to be raving unanimously. Even then I would still be skeptical.

  • @kellio48
    @kellio48 Місяць тому

    As I watch this video, I'm sitting on the fence as to which way to jump off in buying my first 3D printer so thanks for helping me decide.
    BTW, those multi grips you used to dismantle the hot end nozzle look impressive. I'm curious as to what they're called and where to buy them?

  • @billkaroly
    @billkaroly 19 днів тому

    There are three machines that pique my interest. The Flashforge 5M Pro $469, the Infimech TX $329 and the beastly QIDI Q1 PRO $469. I think I would prefer the TX over the 5M but the QIDI Q1 Pro has a larger build volume and an active chamber heater. So in my mind the 21 Pro is the winner followed by the TX and second place.

  • @design9639
    @design9639 Місяць тому +1

    Good review! +1 for using Rhino! Components that are subject to wear and tear should be easy to access, and replace! Replacement parts shouldn't be expensive to purchase as we don't want to revisit the inkjet printing biz model selling those outrageously priced ink cartridges!

  • @MarcelHuguenin
    @MarcelHuguenin 3 місяці тому

    That was a great review, interesting and detailed. Thanks!

  • @ImaginationToForm
    @ImaginationToForm 2 місяці тому

    I think Flashforge actually put the spools on the back first. I had a clone of a Flashforge dual head printer and it had the spools on the back. Flashforge has been around a lot longer than Bambu.

  • @robertschrauder7537
    @robertschrauder7537 2 місяці тому +1

    apparently there's a mod allowing you to install a hotend from bamboolab on Flashforge Adventurer 5M / 5M pro

  • @DanSmith-fj2sd
    @DanSmith-fj2sd Місяць тому

    I love these videos. Good work 👍

  • @enosunim
    @enosunim 3 місяці тому +1

    They also have P1 clone, which is in frame without walls.

  • @dylanwei-s7t
    @dylanwei-s7t 3 місяці тому +1

    try the build plate with Gold color, the bed adhesion is better

  • @oddlytimbotwillison6296
    @oddlytimbotwillison6296 Місяць тому

    Well Bambu took a tonne of their innovation from Voron and then Prusa Slicer, so I don't really see a problem with others using their direction.

  • @alin619
    @alin619 3 місяці тому

    i had a Adventurer 5M and had nothing but problems, it worked fine for a few prints but then it would stop extruding mid prints. could not print TPU because of this. I own a P1P and X1C and there is no comparison, ive had minor issues with them as well but they're still working perfectly today. even though i bought the 5M on sale i wish i didn't, very cheaply made.

    • @NWGR
      @NWGR 2 місяці тому

      As is usually the case with all these companies trying to play catch-up with bambu. Bambu really shook up the landscape by making their printers work so easily and reliably with no tinkering or modding necessary.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      Are you paid to say so?

    • @alin619
      @alin619 Місяць тому

      @@juliusvalentinas nope, i have have all bambulab printers now and owned a Flashforge 5M. just my experience with Flashforge

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      @@alin619 Explain this video then "Review of the Bambu X1 Carbon You Didn't Expect"

  • @alishanmao
    @alishanmao 2 місяці тому

    On Bambu x1c, the screen you shown. click on filament and there is ,load and unload command. Maybe you missed it or you don't know it?😅😅

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому

      I'm fully aware of this workflow. It's more difficult than just pressing the up button on the extruder. When you click unload it asks you what filament is loaded. You have to scroll through the list. If you accidentally select a bamboo filament, it says it cannot read the chip. Very frustrating. That's why I was decrying the loading and unloading a filament on the bamboo lab as being difficult.

    • @alishanmao
      @alishanmao 2 місяці тому

      @@DesignPrototypeTest I am not using any ams system. Ordinary filament and its the most convenient function to load and unload just by one click

  • @MrHeHim
    @MrHeHim 3 місяці тому

    Nice breakdown
    One thing about Flashforge, they don't make bad printers.. and now there at good prices. My first printer was a wooden Flashforge Replicator Dual (MakerBot board inside) from around 2012, has well over 10K hours of print time on it. Although my newer printer that prints at about 6X the speed has defiantly printed more in the last two years
    I would argue a single pass filter to the outside is a false sense of security, unless its a HEPA filter (there not GF) and that's still letting pass some particulates. i have my filter running enclosed for both my resin and filament printers, and don't turn them off for at least ten minutes after the print is done. Sadly, your nose isn't the best for testing and you have to error on the safe side.
    About the part cooling. I designed a few part cooling fan ducts, one thing i found with a radial fan that is usually used is that the fins are oriented to accelerate the air and 'throws the air inward making one side of the ducts receive more air. Which is probably why its smaller on one side to give you similar cooling on both sides. Possible it does create a vortex, hard to tell how effective that is unless you have a smoke machine and a slowmo camera while printing all types of geometries
    Realistically it's just $100 cheaper than the Bambu Labs P1S, with a nicer screen

  • @richarddarkskyfell9236
    @richarddarkskyfell9236 7 днів тому

    do you have an upload of the spool holder you made? I love it

  • @deeber35
    @deeber35 3 дні тому

    Can thee front door be removed? Would that ruin its performance? I am short on space.

  • @flat-earther
    @flat-earther 2 дні тому

    thinking about getting this or K1 Max, what do you think?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 дні тому +1

      I have generally liked Creality products in the past. They are on their own program and they could definitely be better, But they are solid performers. That is all I can say about the K1 Max because Creality did not send one to me for review.

  • @MisterkeTube
    @MisterkeTube 2 місяці тому +1

    If the hardened steel nozzle hotend is also copper / brass except for that tiny last couple of mm of nozzle fitting over it, it won't be very resistant to the abrasive filaments, will it?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +1

      Great comment!
      My observations are that the hole in the nozzle gets widened with abrasives. Also, the tip of the nozzle gets rounded being dragged across abrasive filament after printing. I am sure that some whear will occur inside the melt chamber made of brass, but it won't be that important compared to the massive damage that gets done to tip of the nozzle.

  • @runesvensson1244
    @runesvensson1244 3 місяці тому

    Hope they will do a dual or multi color printer.

  • @wizardfpv7856
    @wizardfpv7856 3 місяці тому +1

    No heated chamber i think q1 pro is a better choice in that price range

  • @calank923
    @calank923 2 місяці тому

    If you click on settings in the X1C there is a load/unload. Same thing with every bambu lab printer I ever owned. Even the a1 and a1 mini have a load/unload filament option. You’re doing it wrong or you are on some extremely old firmware

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +1

      When you click on that, it asks you for the filament type. The menu is convoluted. It's easier and faster to just click the button.

    • @calank923
      @calank923 2 місяці тому

      The temperature menu you were in to extrude filament click on the filament tab to the right of it on top and should be a load/unload option. If not explore your menu no doubt in my mind that it’s got a load/unload option so you don’t have to click extract 10 plus times. It also preheats the nozzle and everything for you than backs the filament out all you have to do is pull it out the rest of the way.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +2

      That's the whole point that I'm trying to make. It's more of a difficulty to use the workflow you describe. The machine is trying to think for me. I am fully capable of running 3D printers. All I need is a warning if I try to remove filament when the nozzle is cold. But even then I still need to be able to remove filament without it at full temperature because of So-Called "cold pulls" to de-clog the nozzle. Seriously, the menu options are wrong and they're a very bad UX design. I should be able to just hold the up arrow on the extruder control and it should unload at full speed. If the nozzle isn't at temperature yet, it should just say "The nozzle is below printing temperatures. Are you sure you want to continue?"
      The printer treats you like you're an idiot. It's a dumb machine. I'm the human It should do what I want it to do. My options should not be buried deep in a convoluted menu somewhere.

  • @oaba201
    @oaba201 3 місяці тому +1

    The Z is homing to the bottom? Eh. You should use the P1S for comparison.

  • @ardi585
    @ardi585 25 днів тому +1

    i only buy Flashforge what is bambu

  • @MaxFenix8k
    @MaxFenix8k Місяць тому

    You can check the Creality k1C

  • @AN_Design_3d
    @AN_Design_3d 3 місяці тому

    Bambu isn't the only or first core XY, Trident is there, or Legacy is even older

  • @davidmccrary8136
    @davidmccrary8136 7 днів тому

    Nice video by the way would you by any chance know anywhere to find a file for a Glock 21 that I can download the slide I've been trying forever to find when I can't find the slide and barrel

  • @robbiegrant4977
    @robbiegrant4977 3 місяці тому

    Looks OK but 200mm cubed build plate? I want a bigger machine not a smaller one.

  • @weissefabrik
    @weissefabrik Місяць тому +1

    the clipper is the same shtty quality as the others...had 3 of these black ones...they all broke the moment I tried to cut a 2,5mm or 4mm cable :DDD

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  Місяць тому

      I've had one snap on me as well. And it was my favorite one. They don't do a good job of heat treating. I don't think they temper after the heat treatment. So the blades are as hard as they can be which is nice because cheap ones get those little dents in The cutting edge. But a really good pair would be sufficiently heat treated only on the cutting edge. This would maintain ductility everywhere else and they would be less likely to snap when you squeeze them hard cutting thick material.

  • @djsideshow5115
    @djsideshow5115 Місяць тому

    Sure but maybe do you know what the error code E0004 is? Because even the tech support couldn't tell me. The adventurer 5m pro was working great for about a month or two then now mine gets an error code e0004 now

  • @landroveraddict2457
    @landroveraddict2457 2 місяці тому

    I've always been apprehensive of bed rise printers particularly those with the bed supported on one side only. How much layer shift is noticeable?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +1

      This is a valid concern. If it was a CNC machine. The forces acting on a 3D printer are extremely minimal. The bed is plenty stiff. There are zero issues associated with The z-axis movement system. The bed is lifted at three points.

  • @Thadopeera
    @Thadopeera 3 місяці тому +1

    Resin is the future of 3D printing I believe in my opinion. I just picked a Phrozen Sonic 8k resin and it blows away anything I print FDM

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +4

      It's not that simple. Resin is equally strong in all three dimensions. It's called isotropic strength. But the underlying polymer is a thermoset. It degrades over time, especially when exposed to UV. So you need to paint your prints with a clear coat to block the UV.
      FDM prints are non-isotropic. They are weaker in the z direction. However they are generally stronger in the X and y direction compared to resin. Additionally, The thermoplastic used in FDM processes does not degrade as badly over time or when exposed to UV.
      FDM is a lot more pleasant to play with and requires no cleanup except a little sweeping with your hand.

  • @TheFeralEngineer
    @TheFeralEngineer 24 дні тому +1

    That there screwdriver is called a pozidriv.

  • @JoeyG1973
    @JoeyG1973 3 місяці тому +2

    What happened to the GMC Motorhome?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому

      Nothing. It's been sitting stagnant since the last video that I made about it.

    • @JoeyG1973
      @JoeyG1973 3 місяці тому +2

      @@DesignPrototypeTest I was enjoying how you were re-engineering it using your design and 3d printing skills.

  • @Happy3dprinting
    @Happy3dprinting 2 місяці тому

    Is Joseph going to send you a mk4s, best printer in the world if you listen to the shills. It’s nice to see an honest review, good, bad and just ugly of the printer. One review who looked at the mk4s explained how they had to stop using other brands to go back to basics to use the mk4s, is it that antiquated in design that you have to stop using advanced 3d printers to use a prusa? 1 step forward 10 steps back 😂

  • @KalelAr
    @KalelAr 3 місяці тому

    Does the FF have all of the auto-calibration of the X1C? I haven’t gotten too deep in the video yet.

  • @ClintonCaraway-CNC
    @ClintonCaraway-CNC 3 місяці тому +2

    Your still comparing apples to bananas. Without the AMS you are not even discussing the same class of printing. I don't do multicolor printing but I do absolutely use the AMS for multiple filament support interface. Without at least that option you may as well order a P1P.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +4

      Unfortunately, I don't have a P1S to compare to. tHe cOMmuNiTy decided to cancel me by contacting all of the companies I had previously worked with, spread lies about me and threaten to not work with them if they worked with me. The response from Bamboo Lab at the moment is "We have no intention to work with Design Prototype Test in the near future." So don't get mad at me for not doing a good comparison. Get mad at the cheating cabal who tries to control the information you are exposed to. Alternately, get mad at Bamboo Lab for caving to the demands from cheaters/liars. I've done nothing to deserve this treatment. I should not be canceled. They just want to maintain their power over you.

    • @par2228
      @par2228 3 місяці тому +2

      ​@@DesignPrototypeTest stop blaiming others for this, first I liked your review but noticed very fast how biased you are to FF and reading the comments cpnfirms this especially where you just blaim "the community" I love seeing reviews of printers but seriusly this blaiming others is just BS and spread mistrust.

  • @GameMaker04
    @GameMaker04 3 місяці тому +1

    it has no Multi material/color option though ?

    • @fuzedlabs
      @fuzedlabs Місяць тому

      exactly, they arent even comparable. Bambu is so much more advanced and useful for a machine at his compared price-point. P1P is superior in that without the enclosure, it can still do multicolor (for some more money, or by earning free gift cards through Bambu makerworld by releasing free models)

  • @ZURAD
    @ZURAD 3 місяці тому

    Is that link an aff link? I think I'm going to get this for my personal printer and would like to support you if/when I do

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +3

      It is NOT. If you want to support me, please go to patreon. That's the only way besides watching my videos that benefits me directly.

    • @ZURAD
      @ZURAD 3 місяці тому

      @@DesignPrototypeTest wilco!

  • @ksampler6183
    @ksampler6183 3 місяці тому

    While I find the video and channel very informative, I wanted to make some notes about a couple things.
    Why compare a $500 printer to a $1100-$1500 printer? You mention with the Bambu printer you *have to* use the cloud, you don't. You can set "LAN Only Mode" and not use any of the cloud stuff. They have also publicly stated that they don't care if you run custom firmware on the printers, you will loose all warranty. (X1C Has a custom firmware available to cut out all of the cloud stuff and add features.)
    I think that if you actually compared it apples to apples (P1S vs 5M) then it wouldn't come out as far in FlashForge's favor.
    To me in this video, there is nothing that would compel me to buy a FlashForge over a Bambu or even a similarly priced Creality K1. All I see are downsides to going FlashForge.
    This comment is not to fight anybody who likes FlashForge over other brands, just trying to share my opinion on it as somebody who has been in the 3D printing world for a while starting on hand built i3 style printers all the way up to just recently purchasing a X1C.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +1

      If you are only printing using a single filament the 5M pro is undeniably the better choice for the money compared to the X1C. I cannot recommend the P1S because I have no experience with that printer. I do not know if the value is as good as what Flashforge has achieved.
      As I said in the video I perceive BL as the best Chinese brand of 3D printers. I am saddened that members of tHe cOmMunItY contacted many companies to spread lies about me and cancel me. This effort was successful with BL and they "have no intention of working with Design Prototype Test in the near future." I would love to compare the P1S to this machine. Unfortunately BL has not sent me one to review. Therefore I will compare the flagship Flashforge printer to the flagship Bambu Lab printer.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      This not members of community, these are members of communism the modern blogger communism

  • @nortonshields8405
    @nortonshields8405 2 місяці тому

    Can u connect and print through the Ethernet connection

  • @peterkallend5012
    @peterkallend5012 3 місяці тому +4

    Yeah, nope. I have both and you're wrong. I did quality tests on both and the adventurer 5m pro just didn't stand up. Even the cost difference doesn't compensate. Don't get me wrong, the flashforge is excellent and I wouldn't trade it in for anything. It's just not even close to the quality and doesn't have the calibration and print defect detection. Flashforge even screwed up their own firmware and made the internal camera useless. They had to do 3 firmware updates in less than a month to fix the issues they created. The Flashforge isn't derivative at all. Also, reading instructions would have clued you into the screws holding the bed in place for shipping.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому

      We'll see how this one goes over time. I have had Chinese printers crap out on me after like a month or so. But also there's been a lot of time for them to iron out the kinks. This printer has been released for a little while. The problems you experienced might have been solved in these later production units.

    • @kevinbalcer8957
      @kevinbalcer8957 3 місяці тому

      For the cost of the x1c the flashforge is the better printer for less money. And the print quality is very good

    • @peterkallend5012
      @peterkallend5012 3 місяці тому +1

      @@kevinbalcer8957 trust me, you get what you pay for. The flashforge doesn't compare. Not even close. I can't even print over 270° for filaments it's supposed to be able to print. Have you tried printing in PA or PC? It's got preset loading temps for those materials, and can actually reach those temperatures, but the firmware prevents actual printing because it thinks the maximum print temp is only 270° and gives a hotend temp error. The X1 doesn't have this issue, nor does the P1. That's all the proof you need that it IS NOT a better printer for the money. X1 and P1 also have integrated multimaterial capability that the Adventurer 5M Pro does not have (not talking about AMS either), and it doesn't recognize custom GCode commands. It also has a smaller build volume.

    • @peterkallend5012
      @peterkallend5012 3 місяці тому +1

      @@DesignPrototypeTest nope, it's firmware not hardware. You're supposed to be able to print at high temp with the Flashforge, but it codes out every time on filaments it has presets for. Trust me, you get what you pay for. That's why I bought an X1C after a year of owning the Flashforge. I get much more consistent prints, and can achieve insanely tight tolerances that were just not possible with the Flashforge (even after optimizing every filament setting and slicer setting). Have you ever wondered why no other channel is making the claim you're making? Because it's simply not true.

  • @kylequinn1963
    @kylequinn1963 3 місяці тому

    The allure of a bambu is how easy they are to use and the quality of the machines, nevermind ecosystem that provides free filament and parts simply for using their platforms.

  • @ThierryC2373
    @ThierryC2373 Місяць тому

    You cannot compare a multicolor printer with a mono filament printer and tell the mono filament is a fraction of the price of the multicolor one... that is not serious.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  Місяць тому

      Tell me, does Bambu Lab sell the X1C as a single filament printer without including the AMS? Did I cheat by removing the multi-filament capability for this purposes of filming this video? Does the X1C have a holder for a single filament spool on the back of it?

  • @Zepeda3D
    @Zepeda3D 2 місяці тому +1

    Man, i`m subscribed to your channel but i never see your videos appear in my feed, i had to look for you by name in the search. Just so you know that how much I like you. Keep up the awesome work!

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +2

      Have you tried turning it off and on again?
      Seriously though, unsubscribe and then re-subscribe.
      ua-cam.com/video/p85xwZ_OLX0/v-deo.htmlsi=vnVYPHK6TqVSh5w_

    • @Zepeda3D
      @Zepeda3D 2 місяці тому

      @@DesignPrototypeTest Lol I appreciate the video reference. I will try that! Thank you! Great video BTW!

  • @stevendunn264
    @stevendunn264 3 місяці тому

    Will that slicer run on a 2015 IMac ?

  • @kaderjazairi887
    @kaderjazairi887 3 місяці тому +9

    Agree, 5m pro is superior in many ways, (& not just for the money)!. Looking forward till next month when FF will reveal their next line up. btw the extruder gear can be easily pulled apart. ua-cam.com/video/Hg3e4pWVFBk/v-deo.html
    Update: FF postponed new release till Oct!

    • @robertschrauder7537
      @robertschrauder7537 2 місяці тому +1

      apparently there's a mod allowing you to install a hotend from bamboolab on Flashforge Adventurer 5M / 5M pro

    • @3DThingg
      @3DThingg 2 місяці тому +2

      @@robertschrauder7537 True, and although it may have some advantages, you loose fast and tooless nozzle swap.

    • @andresgizmos1271
      @andresgizmos1271 2 місяці тому

      Wait what is flashforge going to release a new 3D printer next month? I just ordered a 5m pro 😢

    • @kaderjazairi887
      @kaderjazairi887 2 місяці тому +1

      @@andresgizmos1271 Yup. According to their roadmap '24, they will release several. Next generation 5M & pro, M1, and another TBA. And a few more printers in September.

    • @robertschrauder7537
      @robertschrauder7537 2 місяці тому

      @@andresgizmos1271 so the 5m pro price may drop even more, they had some discounts recently

  • @CdoGtheGreat
    @CdoGtheGreat 2 місяці тому

    Does it have an ams?

  • @shredder646
    @shredder646 Місяць тому

    I had the Flashforge, and I'm sorry but it doesn't come close to the X1 carbon. I have the X1 carbon now, and imo x1 is way better.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  Місяць тому

      Why are you sorry? Can you provide any details to support your assertion? Is this an emotional thing?

  • @ZZROBProductions
    @ZZROBProductions 9 днів тому

    I got this pinter less than a week again, and already, the filment gear is jammed after 2 prints

    • @ZZROBProductions
      @ZZROBProductions 9 днів тому

      Do you know where I can order a new one, I hope they will cover it under warranty

  • @juliusvalentinas
    @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

    Contact magneto x printer makers, they could use smart guy like you

  • @algisberziunas
    @algisberziunas 3 місяці тому

    good one thnks

    • @algisberziunas
      @algisberziunas 3 місяці тому +1

      for that print - you even do not need supports at all for this print ..I was testing it can take 80 degree angle no problm

    • @algisberziunas
      @algisberziunas 3 місяці тому

      by the way while printing any pla you can yurn off all m5pro fans exept nozzle it goes fine ....feed lubrications rails and sticker bed..thats it

  • @Numenor7
    @Numenor7 3 місяці тому

    Did you look at the QIDI Q1 PRO?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +1

      I've been burned by two Qidi printers. At this point they would need to pay me to do another review.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      Their printers we that bad? What models?

  • @mikelaurie3850
    @mikelaurie3850 3 місяці тому

    How would you rate this compared with a k1c or a qidi tech q1 pro

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +2

      tHe cOMmuNiTy reached out to every company I had worked with previously to slander me and make stuff up about my person. Telling them not to work with me. I am effectively canceled with every company they talked to. I never worked with flashforge before, therefore they did not talk to flashforge and I was able to receive this printer for review. I'm unable to compare it to the printers you were asking about. By the way Joel telling is massively influential in tHe cOMmuNiTy. It is a cabal trying to control the information you receive. Imagine if you were a company and received a message saying "Don't send any review printers to Design Prototype Test or tHe cOMmuNiTy will never work with you again."
      Thankfully I couldn't care less. I don't really want to be in the 3D printer review business. So this keeps my detractors otherwise occupied hitting me where they think it hurts. Wasting their time and energy. I'll do a review from time to time but they really don't pay the bills and they take a lot of effort so I'm glad I don't get that many offers.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      Who is the idiot joel?

  • @TheWebgecko
    @TheWebgecko 3 місяці тому +1

    “You Autists” 😭

    • @monafairy99
      @monafairy99 3 місяці тому

      Yeah that was craazy lmao

  • @איציקבנימין
    @איציקבנימין Місяць тому

    Where can I get the Stl file?

  • @zippytiff
    @zippytiff 3 місяці тому

    I had a 5m pro, yes good, but not a patch on the bambu labs. Bambu labs in every way, in every aspect (except for nozzle changing) is better by more than just the difference in price !!

  • @tsarrr
    @tsarrr 2 місяці тому

    Are you able to provide the stl for the G17 file?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +1

      Please watch the video. I answered your question there. Also, check out my X/Twitter account. Link in the description. Click on the "highlights" tab.

  • @MrBooth1974
    @MrBooth1974 3 місяці тому +2

    You could have turned off all the pre print calibration stuff before the print on the X1C. 🤷🏻‍♂️

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому

      I didn't think I hard about it. I just pressed print. Also, even if I had done that there is still some calibration that happens and you can't turn it off.

  • @TheWebgecko
    @TheWebgecko 3 місяці тому

    Curious about this vs the QIDI Q1 Pro

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  3 місяці тому +1

      Fool me once. Shame on you. Fool me twice. Shame on me. I reviewed two Qidi printers. I make no money from these videos to justify the time spent filming and editing. I couldn't get rid of those printers fast enough. At this point, Qidi would have to pay me to review another one of those printers. They may be fantastic now. I'm not taking the chance.

    • @TheWebgecko
      @TheWebgecko 2 місяці тому

      @@DesignPrototypeTest rip 😭

  • @tommyblair6008
    @tommyblair6008 2 місяці тому +1

    Should be comparing it to a P1S and then the 5M will lose big time. Your cost excuse goes out the window.

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  2 місяці тому +2

      You should tell Bamboo Lab. They gave me the X1C but then they demoted or fired the rep who I was working with. Barnacles and his followers doxed me and canceled me by reaching out to all of the companies saying that I was dangerous and shouldn't be worked with. So the line from Bamboo Lab now is "We have no intention of working with Design Prototype Test in the near future."
      Anyway, looking at the specs on paper, I'm not inclined to agree with you. Remember the 5m pro has a fully sealed chamber with industry-leading filtration. The 5m pro has a superior color touch screen compared to the monotone low resolution screen on the p1s
      And the P1S costs $100 more. Respectfully, I don't think you completely thought about your argument before making it. I think you just have some brand loyalty or something.

    • @juliusvalentinas
      @juliusvalentinas Місяць тому

      Barnacles - that mommy son is still alive, isnt he suppose to be vacinated educated and dead by now?

  • @CdoGtheGreat
    @CdoGtheGreat 2 місяці тому

    You marred the hotend plastic, totally ruined it with that blade, you should give it to me and get a new one 😂

  • @earlowens998
    @earlowens998 Місяць тому

    Better than the Bambu Lab X1C (for the money). How much do they pay yo to say that?

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  Місяць тому

      They provided the printer free of charge for the purposes of this video. If you consider that payment then that is the extent of what they paid me.

    • @earlowens998
      @earlowens998 Місяць тому

      $499 the printer cost. I have no idea if you get something from UA-cam. I have several different Bamboo printers and they just print.

  • @Cheeky-Trivia
    @Cheeky-Trivia 2 місяці тому

    I really hope someone has showed you how easy it really is to add/change filament. To the FF 5M Pro & the Bambu labs.... Youre making it harder than it is lol

  • @kalicacao
    @kalicacao Місяць тому

    Great review. Finally someone showed what is inside the nozzle. I didn't try to do ot - it's too expensive ;)
    I own FF AD5M pro for half a year and I think it's really a solid printer for the money. Those quick change nozzels are expensive but they are worth it. If you use a different nozze for each material there is really no problem with any clogs. I've printed somewhere close to 20kg of filaments on this printer and never had a single clog.

  • @adamklosterman8960
    @adamklosterman8960 2 місяці тому

    qidi q1 pro next

  • @loyodea221
    @loyodea221 2 місяці тому

    Standard metric M4 tap

  • @st0mper121
    @st0mper121 21 день тому

    I would look at the qidi Q1 pro @ $450 before you jump on that. bed is to small for my needs

    • @DesignPrototypeTest
      @DesignPrototypeTest  21 день тому

      I really want to like Qidi. I reviewed two of their printers. Fundamentally they were the same with the same problems. Fool me once: Shame on you. Fool me twice: Shame on me. Fool me three times???

    • @st0mper121
      @st0mper121 21 день тому

      @@DesignPrototypeTest I will have to look for your videos. I own a Max3 I did kinda have a bad start but overall i love the printer. replaced screen, filament sensor. was very disapointed to learn max3 does not have resume print after power loss. but i love the bed leveling sensor and the quality of parts its making.