I feel like the bye bye under eye is made to work on mature skin so it doesn't settle into lines. For me the Tarte seems to cease more. At least that is what I'm see on the video. Probably also why the bye bye is more hydrating because the it products for good for mature skin that that skin type needs more moisture.
this is my exact situation right now and just the vid i was looking for. i couldn't imagine anything covering more than bye bye undereye but im pretty excited to try the shape tape, it seems so much more convenient! either way i dont think theres a concealer on this planet which can get rid of my dark circles completely lmao
J I knowwww same girl! My under eyes just always seem to peep through one way or another! The bye bye is probably the best for full full coverage! Thanks so much for watching J! 💕
I have used them both.. bought Tarte 1st, love the gentle scent ( and I don't usually like scent) and the form..however for me, the bye bye has a more velvety texture.. Both long lasting.. I have inherited dark circles with very fair skin so it's been alot of trial and error. I think I will stay with the Bye Bye
Hi!! Yes, I have to completely agree with you on this throwback winner here! The Tarte Shape Tape is my absolute favorite undereye concealer as of now! I'm truly obsessed with it! I also agree with everything you had as to say about it. I use my best blender as well. My question to you is, do you use your beauty blender damp with this or dry? I'm still trying to figure out which way I like to use it the most. I think if the beauty blender is very lightly damp, just barely (like a mist) that it makes the look more flawless and kinda helps out a bit with the undereye lines/creases.
YES! I have been misting my beauty blender with the Mario Badescu spray which works wonders, but sometimes i need to dampen it just a bit if i'm feeling extra dry! Thank you so so much for watching Candice!
You don’t need to choose, keep both of them and that’s it! Please keep in mind that the IT Cosmetics are chemicals and parabens free, talc powder free, they have been formulated as skin products with plastic surgeons and contain peptide, hyaluronic acid, collagen and many other great ingredients.
Those are the same 2 shades I have .. I take the tarte and just put it on the darkest inner corner and then cover it with the bye bye.. A little goes a long way
i needed this! i think i'll go for the it cosmetics one as i am a huge fan of skin care and sometimes i just do a bit of concealer and powder, so i don't need full coverage. also, the bye bye undereye should last a lot longer as it's 8ml and the tarte one is just like 4ml? i just need to figure out which shade i am!!
I used to use the Bye Bye every day, and i didn't like it. I've never used Tarte Shape Tape, but i really want to. I just switched from Bye Bye to Maybelline Fit Me Concealer, and I LOVE it! I prefer it over Bye Bye.
I know this video is quite old now but if you're still taking suggestions I'd love to see a comparison with the NYX Big and Loud Lash Primer (£6.00) and ELF Mascara Primer (£4.50) ☺
Christine Francillo I'm currently struggling a bit with that to at the moment. I just came back from the beach and my skin feels extra dry! I switched over to my bye bye undereye when my skin feels parched! And you are so right! It's super hard to match tarte shape tape to your skin tone! I have to mix two together sometimes! Thank you so much for watching!
Thanks for making this. I just fell in love with Shape Tape about 2 months ago. But I just bought my first IT products (Their double ended brush, Bye Bye Under Eye Correcter Pot, Celebrate Foundation Powder compact and the double ended Eyebrow brush) THEN I got the Bye Bye Under Eye concealer in my Ipsy today and I am in looovee. I want to do a side by side comparison on my own face to see..but I kinda feel that BBUEC is my winner. Still obsessed with the Shape Tape Foundation and actually scared to try any IT Foundation in case I fall in ♡ with it too ughh lol. BTW I liked both on you but I think the BBUEC was a bit better 😉
Thanks for the review. I do think though that if you compared both products in more similar shades, the comparison would reflect more of the difference in the products.. because how they look on your face has a lot to do with the shade, and since your concealers were in such different shades, it would have skewed the results significantly. For example, perhaps the Tarte concealer covered the dark circles more because you picked a much ligher shade, which is generally what is recommended for covering dark circles.
I know this is an older video, but these were good products to compare to each other. My comment if you are continuing to do these comparison videos is to consider how much product is used when evaluating value. The shape tape was less per ounce, but you use a lot more product per application than you do with the bye bye under eye. So I would actually feel that the bye bye under eye was a better value. Just my take. Nice video!
Unfortunately for me the tart doesn’t agree with my skin 😩 it doesn’t last long and it settles on the corner of my eyes. 😱 Now I wear bye bye and it doesn’t settle into any of my lines🙂
Judy ahh! Good! I’m so glad you found Bye Bye! I go back and forth between the two!! I am also loving the new Laura Mercier concealer on days where I need a quick application and a medium coverage! 💕 thanks for watching Judy!
Kat Hamilton I think you would prefer the tarte shape tape then! It's not as thick as the bye bye undereye but it's also not as moisturizing! Thanks so much for watching! ❤️
FYI.... Per instructions, use their brush or your finger to apply. It is my belief, the sponge removes some of the product. I use my finger to apply and I use a large face brush to apply a small dusting of It Cosmetics finishing powder. I sometimes set with Urban Decay setting spray.👌
For wrinkles, dryness, and texture the Tarte dries and sets on its own and sucks any moisture out of my skin making it look worse. Coverage and smell and shades are great with Tarte but even with eye cream or beauty oils it has such a dehydrated appearance that it makes me look even older.I feel like IT emphasizes crepeyness when applying but at least it doesn’t dry up my skin.
hi hannah ive noticed you have music on your intro. How about something custom to you to make your videos instantly recognisable as YOUR brand. Im offering to provide a custom piece of music for your intro in any genre, with an exclusive lease meaning you have exclusive rights to that music and noone else can use it. This would instantly boost your brand recognition and your fans would be hyped up for the intro theme before the video even starts. good viewer mindset leads to them enjoyting and consuming the video in a more memorable way. If this is something youd be interested in lemme know. If not im always here to help with any kinds of musical projects. have a great week. Tommy
I feel like bye bye under eye looked better, maybe it was just the better color match but I think it looks so good :)
I agree!! The bye bye undereye was a MUCH better color match! I switch back and forth between the two!! Thank you so much for watching Angel!
I feel like the bye bye under eye is made to work on mature skin so it doesn't settle into lines. For me the Tarte seems to cease more. At least that is what I'm see on the video. Probably also why the bye bye is more hydrating because the it products for good for mature skin that that skin type needs more moisture.
katlady5000 sooo true!! Thanks so much for watching girl! 💖
I agree. I just tried bye bye underage after using tarte creaseless concealer for 4 years! And I loved bye bye undereye!!
I like the Bye bye under eye concealer the best !!! looks amazing thanks for sharing !You look beautiful
this is my exact situation right now and just the vid i was looking for. i couldn't imagine anything covering more than bye bye undereye but im pretty excited to try the shape tape, it seems so much more convenient! either way i dont think theres a concealer on this planet which can get rid of my dark circles completely lmao
J I knowwww same girl! My under eyes just always seem to peep through one way or another! The bye bye is probably the best for full full coverage! Thanks so much for watching J! 💕
I have used them both.. bought Tarte 1st, love the gentle scent ( and I don't usually like scent) and the form..however for me, the bye bye has a more velvety texture.. Both long lasting.. I have inherited dark circles with very fair skin so it's been alot of trial and error. I think I will stay with the Bye Bye
I KNOW!! I feel the same! I go back and forth all the time depending on the day and what I’m needing!
I prefer the BBUE over the tarte ST on you.
I have both but I only just purchased BBUE today so I’ll see.
The tart looks better!!
I’m switching to it
I have using bye bye for years
Switching
Thank you !
Yia 1 thanks so much for watching Yia!!!
I tried both on and I can't really tell the difference on me at all but I'd also choose tarte because it's just easier to apply! :)
kavelasquez78 me too!! I love it so much! Thanks so much for watching!!
I've been looking for a comparison of these two! Awesome review :)
Sarah Says thanks so much for watching!! I'm so glad you found it!!
Hi!! Yes, I have to completely agree with you on this throwback winner here! The Tarte Shape Tape is my absolute favorite undereye concealer as of now! I'm truly obsessed with it! I also agree with everything you had as to say about it.
I use my best blender as well. My question to you is, do you use your beauty blender damp with this or dry? I'm still trying to figure out which way I like to use it the most. I think if the beauty blender is very lightly damp, just barely (like a mist) that it makes the look more flawless and kinda helps out a bit with the undereye lines/creases.
YES! I have been misting my beauty blender with the Mario Badescu spray which works wonders, but sometimes i need to dampen it just a bit if i'm feeling extra dry! Thank you so so much for watching Candice!
You don’t need to choose, keep both of them and that’s it! Please keep in mind that the IT Cosmetics are chemicals and parabens free, talc powder free, they have been formulated as skin products with plastic surgeons and contain peptide, hyaluronic acid, collagen and many other great ingredients.
Thank you! Such great info!!
That's y I stick to IT cosmetics.
But how do u set bye bye concelaer?I use mac mineralize
@@tehminafaisal6253 I like not setting mine. It's really up to personal use.
What shade are you in? both bye bye undereye and shape tape...
I'm in light neutral in tarte and medium in bye bye undereye! Thanks for watching!
Those are the same 2 shades I have .. I take the tarte and just put it on the darkest inner corner and then cover it with the bye bye.. A little goes a long way
cantstopsinging sooo true!! It really does! Thanks so much for watching! 💕💕
i needed this! i think i'll go for the it cosmetics one as i am a huge fan of skin care and sometimes i just do a bit of concealer and powder, so i don't need full coverage. also, the bye bye undereye should last a lot longer as it's 8ml and the tarte one is just like 4ml? i just need to figure out which shade i am!!
I used to use the Bye Bye every day, and i didn't like it. I've never used Tarte Shape Tape, but i really want to. I just switched from Bye Bye to Maybelline Fit Me Concealer, and I LOVE it! I prefer it over Bye Bye.
I know this video is quite old now but if you're still taking suggestions I'd love to see a comparison with the NYX Big and Loud Lash Primer (£6.00) and ELF Mascara Primer (£4.50) ☺
Hannah Swift I will definitely pick those up and try them out!! Thanks so much for your suggestion!
Hannah Denton thank you so much! Just subbed ☺
The Tarte concealer seems a bit drying on me and it's difficult to find the right shade.
Christine Francillo I'm currently struggling a bit with that to at the moment. I just came back from the beach and my skin feels extra dry! I switched over to my bye bye undereye when my skin feels parched! And you are so right! It's super hard to match tarte shape tape to your skin tone! I have to mix two together sometimes! Thank you so much for watching!
Christine Francillo the tube is more sanitary!
which color do you use in both concealers? I am NC25..cannot find the right match
Thanks for making this. I just fell in love with Shape Tape about 2 months ago. But I just bought my first IT products (Their double ended brush, Bye Bye Under Eye Correcter Pot, Celebrate Foundation Powder compact and the double ended Eyebrow brush) THEN I got the Bye Bye Under Eye concealer in my Ipsy today and I am in looovee. I want to do a side by side comparison on my own face to see..but I kinda feel that BBUEC is my winner. Still obsessed with the Shape Tape Foundation and actually scared to try any IT Foundation in case I fall in ♡ with it too ughh lol. BTW I liked both on you but I think the BBUEC was a bit better 😉
You deserve so many more subscribers!! I love your videos. Please more concealer videos!!
Arti Patel thank you so much Arti! I love comparing concealers so I will definetly make more videos! 💖
what colors did you use?
Thanks for the review. I do think though that if you compared both products in more similar shades, the comparison would reflect more of the difference in the products.. because how they look on your face has a lot to do with the shade, and since your concealers were in such different shades, it would have skewed the results significantly. For example, perhaps the Tarte concealer covered the dark circles more because you picked a much ligher shade, which is generally what is recommended for covering dark circles.
Hey! what color is it on bye bye concealer?
i like bye bye more i have oil skin i think the shade and amount with tarte made the difference ..byebye lasts longer
I know this is an older video, but these were good products to compare to each other. My comment if you are continuing to do these comparison videos is to consider how much product is used when evaluating value. The shape tape was less per ounce, but you use a lot more product per application than you do with the bye bye under eye. So I would actually feel that the bye bye under eye was a better value. Just my take. Nice video!
What shade did you use for the tape shape concealer? Amazing review!!
Selina S-f thank you so much! I used the shade fair neutral, its a little light for me! I wish I would have gone a shade or two darker!
Unfortunately for me the tart doesn’t agree with my skin 😩 it doesn’t last long and it settles on the corner of my eyes. 😱 Now I wear bye bye and it doesn’t settle into any of my lines🙂
Judy ahh! Good! I’m so glad you found Bye Bye! I go back and forth between the two!! I am also loving the new Laura Mercier concealer on days where I need a quick application and a medium coverage! 💕 thanks for watching Judy!
nice comparison. I like the fact you compared value too.
Thanks for watching!!
What shade tape I'm light bye bye and just ordered light medium shape tape but looks like my skin
Hi Hannah, which concealer do you think is a thinner consistency? I prefer a thinner texture in my concealers. Great video. Thankyou. 🎃
Kat Hamilton I think you would prefer the tarte shape tape then! It's not as thick as the bye bye undereye but it's also not as moisturizing! Thanks so much for watching! ❤️
The bye bye undereye is HELLA THIC. But it’s more full coverage. Also, a little goes a long way with the bye bye under eye.
honestly,your circles aren't that bad..but both look sides look exactly the same..i just started using the Bye BYe under eye and LOVE it
FYI.... Per instructions, use their brush or your finger to apply. It is my belief, the sponge removes some of the product. I use my finger to apply and I use a large face brush to apply a small dusting of It Cosmetics finishing powder. I sometimes set with Urban Decay setting spray.👌
Great comparison video!
Kris LM thanks so much Kris! Do you have any other products you would like me to compare?
What other products would you like me to compare!?
Oh girl that color
The It Cosmetics is better on the skin. it is more natural looking.
Yessy Mariana I agree! It does look a lot more natural! Thanks so much for watching Yessy!
the bye bye looks more natural
For wrinkles, dryness, and texture the Tarte dries and sets on its own and sucks any moisture out of my skin making it look worse. Coverage and smell and shades are great with Tarte but even with eye cream or beauty oils it has such a dehydrated appearance that it makes me look even older.I feel like IT emphasizes crepeyness when applying but at least it doesn’t dry up my skin.
hey friend tfs....
shape tape vs makeup revolution concealer
Concealer can’t, and won’t, make your natural under eye creases go away. You’re looking at how the product settles into those fine lines.
The tube is more sanitary
Bye bye under eye looks more smooth the tart looks tooo dry . Bye bye for sure
Bye bye all day.
hi hannah ive noticed you have music on your intro. How about something custom to you to make your videos instantly recognisable as YOUR brand. Im offering to provide a custom piece of music for your intro in any genre, with an exclusive lease meaning you have exclusive rights to that music and noone else can use it. This would instantly boost your brand recognition and your fans would be hyped up for the intro theme before the video even starts. good viewer mindset leads to them enjoyting and consuming the video in a more memorable way. If this is something youd be interested in lemme know. If not im always here to help with any kinds of musical projects. have a great week. Tommy
You look like Jaclyn Hill
The Makeup Lover that is the biggest compliment to me. Thank you so much! 💓😘
No problem ❤️❤️
What shade are you using in the shape tape?
light neutral! Thank you so much for watching!
What shade are you in bye bye?
I go between light and medium! I think I had medium in this video!