As someone who has had their fair share of struggles in wet weather: Fassie is my MOTM. Getting those high bombs so securely in those conditions is very underrated.
Fassi's attacking prowess has never been in question. It's his defense that calls for scrutiny, and this Wallabies team didn't really test him. He certainly didn't hurt his chances, that's for sure.
@@mthabitX Very disrespectful comment. Willie has created more try-scoring opportunities through his excellent distribution than any other player in the team. He makes one error of judgement and so-called "fans" like you are eager to put him down.
I was impressed by the little saw of Canan Moodie last week playing fullback for Bulls. Canan is perfectly suited to 15 too. Let’s have Fassi and Canan. We’ll want them both for the 2027 squad.
You guys are forgetting Damian is a our number so i see it 1st. Damian 2nd. Fassi, Le Roux will retire as he gets his 100. Canan is more of wing and hopefully 13.
Thanks Tim. I believe if the weather had been clear and scrums not uncontested, the Bokke would have put 50 points on the board. All conjecture, I know. Ellis Park is going to be amazing - high altitude and what a stadium to be in when at full capacity!🏆🏉🇿🇦
Jasper Wiese’s ban seems ridiculous long. We’ve seen Kellaway and White get away with lifting players above horizontal. They got nothing. Meanwhile Wiese is yet to play for the Boks in 2024.
What he did in that Premiership game was as bad as what the Italians did to Duane Vermeulen in 2019. You want to argue about Kelleway and White then fine, but let's not make excuses for Jasper.
@Karma-qt4ji Jasper picked a guy up kept him horizontal and then dropped him on his stomach. Red card 6 week ban Last week an Aussie player picked up Reinarch, lifted him above horizontal and dropped him on his head. Yellow card South Africa plays by different rules in this sport and we are still clearly the best. When a player wears a green jersey then open themselves up to bias and world rugby to not protect their safety
@@Forest9528 Wiese started with a cheap shoulder charge to the rib cage - only one intention there - then lifted the player and DROVE him head first into the ground. If you can't even be honest about the incident then there really is no point debating this. I understand and agree with your frustration that Kelleher and White got away with what they did but all that means is that they should have been sanctioned further, it does not mean that Jasper should have been sanctioned less. My take on the RC so far is that SANZAAR clearly are not applying the same harsh level to dangerous play as the rest of the world does. In a URC game, Malcolm would almost certainly have seen his yellow upgraded to red last week and Kelleher as well. Stop playing the victim. Leave that shit for the New Zealanders with their "Siya should have seen red".
Hey Tim, Kia Ora from New Zealand….mate, I absolutely love your videos, it’s soooo refreshing to hear your perspective on the Southern Hemisphere teams, and, especially liked your impression of John Kirwan( I’m sure he would laugh if he saw it(it’s a national sport in NZ to take the piss out of each other)…. I also really appreciate your enthusiasm and hope you have a blast in South Africa watching the Springboks/All Black tests…..
When all is said and done, we may not have looked clinical out there in the downpour, but we come away with an aggregate 63 - 19 and 10 log points after an away leg in Australia where we usually battle. Some players played out of their socks today and others were not as good, but overall, we did the job we set out to do and now we are firmly in control of the the RC. We have to keep winning now, sure, but we are definitely capable of doing just that. We also learned the worth of a lot of the youngsters and that is money in the bank for us. Proud of the boys!
Also, i think a few names can safely and confidently be added to the pool of reliable test players, such as: BJ Dixon, Nortje, I think Marco VS, Fassi, and Thomas DT... Ah, maybe Elrigh L as well...
Spot on. Great comment! They're definitely creating depth and I thought the youngsters got better as the half wore on. Mapimpi and Sacha such basic errors that would've changed the game
Also, you guys over there have 60 million fans, good for the channel subscribers 😅just saying, I might be wrong, could just be business, and he is a AB's fan
I have so much love and respect for you Tim. I love the point you made about Libbok, he's a great player however his greatness is overshadowed by his inability to kick. He's a playmaker and always creating opportunities but he's not appreciated and people crucify him quicker than the other 2 flyhalves.
How much does Kolbe have to do on a field to be in the best player in the world conversation. This guy is consistently delivering match defining moments.
I feel like Louw is doing good consistent things ... But just isn't that X factor no.8. I've always felt like he or JLDP were more similar to Mostert in 2019 as a utility flank/lock option. Van Staden never looks good to me, but then you look at his game stats and realise he did way more than you realised. Agree both are worth keeping in the squad, but not sold on them being first choice just yet.
Grant Williams really deserves a start at 9. Yes, he brings it off the bench, but he really looks to be the form player at the position for the Boks right now. I’d like to see him start against AB at Ellis Park with Reinach on the bench, or maybe Faf if Rassie thinks they’d need a bit of extra grit on defense late in the game, but I’d lean more to Williams/Reinach on current form.
Cool im glade you are coming to SA 'again' i think you are hooked on our country, weather, girl's, beer and of course the Springboks 😂 you will enjoy Ellis Park Stadium its gote the best vibes ever. See u there. Here in Gauteng we have sunshine 365 days a year. I enjoy yr program.
The whole set scrum situation was sketchy and affected the game plan for the Boks, yet they adapted and still made it look relatively easy in the 2nd half.
2 місяці тому+2
Hi Tim Great review as usual. I thought Pollard and Libbok were a good combination. I'm enjoying the creativeness in the Springbok camp. I hope you have a wonderful trip to SA, especially Cape Town. Take something warm and a raincoat.
@@simorfunfortunately when Willie or Damian are at fullback, who is gonna kick? Faf? Kolbe? They are not much better. I love Manie’s running game and his kicking game but off the tee is becoming a serious persistent issue for him that he needs to sort out.
I don't think it's hate. I feel for the guy. I know what it feels like to have a psychological hinderence in a specific area of performance. He needs professional help to calm his nerves. I think for now, he shouldn't be put under pressure to kick, until he is mentally fit for that. Goal scoring has won us World Cups. That is something we can not just ignore. So let's be fair, and not use the word hate liberally. That won't help his course
Tim, you made it to your 100K subscribers and beyond!! Well done! Shoo the rain was pissing down in the beginning, rain always makes me worried because South Africans and wet balls don't mix well haha. Great to see the younger players getting some game time, we have so much young talent coming through and the coaches need to give them game time to impress them because ultimately we will have to phase out the older players eventually. Manie Libbok is such an amazing player, I have been rewatching Chasing the sun 2 and he was such a huge part of winning the games with his play other than the kicking, I wonder if he can get the kicking right? Look Sasha is great too but the side kicks(not sure of the proper terminology) he puts through can change the game. Aphelele Fassi has been one of my favourite's since his debut, he had a number of injuries which caused a number of delays in seeing him back in a Springbok jersey, and I am so happy to see him back. Incredible hands and those long legs, just so fast. I think there will be a lot more of letting lesser known players get some game time in the near future!
Hey Tim, Love your channel and content! So happy you had a great trip to South Africa and that you are coming back soon.. I was trying to find the vid where you mentioned wanting to interview Deon Fourie.. my brother made Chasing the Sun and can connect you!
Good selection headaches to have. Rotation and depth tested. A win is win in wet conditions away from home. Some guys need more time to shine. We are at a good stage mixing youth and experience.
At test level in atrocious conditions, the youngsters did well enough. So all those scores are fair. Aphalele "The Weekend Special" Fassi is one of my favourites! He'll catch any ball and run it straight back where it came from all day long! He improved his defence slightly, but can still be better.
Alot of young guys, weather and nerves...wouldn't read anything more into it than we got the 5...they will learn from this....ABs will feature more of the A team guys and less of the emerging guys I think....so good practice and good experience...these guys will feature more against Argies
Nortje worked his butt off for the whole game. Definitely put his hand up. Fassi has always been an exceptional attacking talent. That part of his game was never in question, and since the Wallabies didn't really stress the Bok defense, we haven't learned much new about Fassi. Grant Williams (just like Cobus Reinach) is insanely fast. There's a value in having two sniping, lightning fast scrum halves, who'll test and stress the opposition's D for 80mins.
Jan Hendrik was giving Allaltoia a hard time for his first time at prop, so I am happy with his scrumming, and yes accuracy wasnt that good for boks but it was pounding down with rain, , dont worry when we at Ellispark the sun will shine and we will run hard aginst the all blacks, cant wait. Boks can win both games against AB'S.
Thinking back to the twicknham game before RWC23, I think they might pull a 7.1 split, starting Rienach and Libbok with Pollard on the bench this time.
I wouldn't read too much in the back-to-back victories against a team that is rebuilding itself. The 2 tests against New Zealand on home soil will give one a better idea how good SA is.
Regards to Grant think he’s secured the bench spot, personally I think he’s more on form than both faf and cobus, but I think they rate his pace against tired opponents, so think he will be on bench for the foreseeable future
Hello Tim, Once more thanks a lot for your participation. Concerning JH Wessels one has to take into account that he is still very young as far as international props are concerned. I never played at this level but I was at my strongest and had the most endurance at age 33. I didn't think he fared so badly in the scrums save for one and perhaps two scrums. Concerning the rest I thought he was his opponent's equal and sometimes even the better. As far as the scrum rules are concerned it is an absolute mess. Most of the rime no one knows why or who contravened a rule, least of all the referee. No high level referee that I know of has been a prop. And on top of that the rules are just plainly ridiculous. Whoever made then do not have the faintest understanding of basic physics. I am a civil engineer who took physics up to 3rd year level at university so I have a basic idea of force, structure and motion. I am an advocate for reintroducing the rule that loose head props should bind with a straight left arm by gripping the top of the pants of the opposing tight head. In this way a rigid beam is formed on each side of the scrum, ensuring much more stability. This ensures that the scrum is stable once the sides have bound. It consequently ensures rhat the scrumhalf can put the ball in straight, and that hookers can actually hook the ball. Penalties are awarded if the ball had been put in skew, foot up by the hooker before the ball has been put in, and if one side starts pushing before the ball has been put in. Please never stop with you programme. We are looking forward to having you back in SA 😊
Watched both your summaries of today's game, Tim. As a Bok supporter, I always head towards you first. You report really quality insight. I agree about the new recruits who didn't take their opportunities. For me, Moerat is a quality leader, but his overall game doesn't qualify for international standards. Nottingham with all the quality locks we currently have. Secondly, I know the conditions were wet & heavy underfoot, but for me, Du Toit, who is the biggest prop we have, is far too nice of a player. For his height & weight, he should be far more aggressive against opposition and really bringing it. Make opponents remember him, which he's not doing imo. I'm a huge Grant Williams fan. I hope he doesn't become a bomb squader. He offers the Boks so much more in his natural game than that. 8th man? I'm an Evan Roos fan. He's a natural enforcer. People go on too much about his discipline imo. He'll mature like Eben Estebeth did. The main thing is, he's a beast, and he almost always crosses the gain line in his powerful runs. He's my 1st choice 8. He's 1 guy I believe he needs to stop stop/starting otherwise, he'll lose confidence and we'll lose him. He's already been made huge offers by the Japanese clubs. Otherwise, great show, Tim, as usual !!!
I like how Tim has picked up on our age old picking apart players short comings,(mentioning Le Bok and Williams ) that's so part of South African rugby supporters way of mercilessly and sometimes undeservedly roast the players they don't rate . We are VERY opinionated people ..right or wrong 😂😂
My interest is in the combo of Libbok and Pollard on the field at the same time. It might elevate Libbok amd give Pollard bok longevity, wish we got more time to see that
The weather conditions for the two games was significantly different. The storm had largely passed by the 10-minute mark of the NZ game. Not great conditions to be sure but nothing like that monsoon in Perth. Did I miss Am's rating?
Agree with all those scores! And I'd give the Boks 6.5 overall in that match! 😊 There were some good bits, yes, but the not so good bits were just shocking! 😂 Still, it wasn't a bad day at the office! Not many coaches can rotate a team AND come away with a bonus point win at the same time! 👌🏾 Lets see what we can do against New Zealand! The Mighty All Blacks seem to have their fire back which will make for a proper test! 🇿🇦❤🇳🇿
Love the channel, Tim. I also love PSDT - one of the best ever. But I disagree about the runs down the wing. I’ve never been a fan of the locks/hookers taking the ball down the sideline when there’s space: 1) they’re too slow so the defence can usually catch up, 2) they typically lack the skills to get a cheeky little grubber, off-load, or chip kick to convert to a try. Take a look at those PsdT breaks down the sidelines and tell me how many of them were converted into points?
Ideally Kobe needs a backup. But Kobe is elite this moment. Moodie can cover 13 as well. cause at 15 Damian, Fassi, Le Roux are all specialist fullbacks for their URC teams.
Mannie is the best attacking flyhalf we have had since Honiball. Do you want to score tries or do you want to try to dominate up front and kick penalties?
I don't think the idea was ever to use Sasha as 10 against NZ, I think the idea was to see how he goes against Australia, pretty sure Pollard will be back for All Blacks
Slightly harsh on a few players I think but none the less, if the Boks perform at a 6.5 and get a bonus point win, I’ll take it 🇿🇦🇿🇦 thanks for the content Tim.
At this point Tim could make a video where he rates the best springboks beards and we would watch it 😂
😂 agree ❤
Totally agree
"...the state of his beard given the conditions..."
Absolutely. Watch the subscriber count after the All Black tour. 63 Million 🇿🇦
😂 you got that right😅
As someone who has had their fair share of struggles in wet weather: Fassie is my MOTM. Getting those high bombs so securely in those conditions is very underrated.
Brah... Weekend special
Yes he is a special player and his speed is a real asset. He burnt the Aussie wing by 3m in 50 m.
in
Agree - I'm thinking he is putting up his hand for first choice selection at full back.
Thanks for giving Fassi his flowers. He's not appreciated enough
he's really not. He's never had a bad game in this series.
@@mcebomathenjwa2761 exactly, he has been really solid and did everything required of him. One thing I noticed was also how vocal he was with the team
Not a terrible showing, boy did ok
Love the kid really solid under those ball's. I'm really surprised on how he went about his business even in that condition
He was solid where he needed to be, really think hes been good the last few games and consistent
I ve been shouting for Fassi for a while, great to see him score today.
And Canan Moodie, hopefully he gets a run for our home games.
I was not convinced he was an option at 15 before the match, was glad to see him do so well.
Fassi's attacking prowess has never been in question. It's his defense that calls for scrutiny, and this Wallabies team didn't really test him. He certainly didn't hurt his chances, that's for sure.
Fasi did very well. He needs to be mentored by Le Roux.
He can mentor Le Roux on catching a ball....
Willie needs Mentoring.
@@mthabitX Very disrespectful comment. Willie has created more try-scoring opportunities through his excellent distribution than any other player in the team. He makes one error of judgement and so-called "fans" like you are eager to put him down.
I was impressed by the little saw of Canan Moodie last week playing fullback for Bulls. Canan is perfectly suited to 15 too.
Let’s have Fassi and Canan. We’ll want them both for the 2027 squad.
You guys are forgetting Damian is a our number so i see it 1st. Damian 2nd. Fassi, Le Roux will retire as he gets his 100.
Canan is more of wing and hopefully 13.
Good to see Am back!
Thanks Tim. I believe if the weather had been clear and scrums not uncontested, the Bokke would have put 50 points on the board. All conjecture, I know.
Ellis Park is going to be amazing - high altitude and what a stadium to be in when at full capacity!🏆🏉🇿🇦
Jasper Wiese’s ban seems ridiculous long. We’ve seen Kellaway and White get away with lifting players above horizontal. They got nothing. Meanwhile Wiese is yet to play for the Boks in 2024.
What he did in that Premiership game was as bad as what the Italians did to Duane Vermeulen in 2019. You want to argue about Kelleway and White then fine, but let's not make excuses for Jasper.
@Karma-qt4ji Jasper picked a guy up kept him horizontal and then dropped him on his stomach. Red card 6 week ban
Last week an Aussie player picked up Reinarch, lifted him above horizontal and dropped him on his head. Yellow card
South Africa plays by different rules in this sport and we are still clearly the best. When a player wears a green jersey then open themselves up to bias and world rugby to not protect their safety
@@Forest9528 Wiese started with a cheap shoulder charge to the rib cage - only one intention there - then lifted the player and DROVE him head first into the ground. If you can't even be honest about the incident then there really is no point debating this.
I understand and agree with your frustration that Kelleher and White got away with what they did but all that means is that they should have been sanctioned further, it does not mean that Jasper should have been sanctioned less. My take on the RC so far is that SANZAAR clearly are not applying the same harsh level to dangerous play as the rest of the world does. In a URC game, Malcolm would almost certainly have seen his yellow upgraded to red last week and Kelleher as well.
Stop playing the victim. Leave that shit for the New Zealanders with their "Siya should have seen red".
His ban is as long as it needed to be. You’ve seen what he was banned for, right?
@@Forest9528victim mentality is pretty boring
Hey Tim, Kia Ora from New Zealand….mate, I absolutely love your videos, it’s soooo refreshing to hear your perspective on the Southern Hemisphere teams, and, especially liked your impression of John Kirwan( I’m sure he would laugh if he saw it(it’s a national sport in NZ to take the piss out of each other)….
I also really appreciate your enthusiasm and hope you have a blast in South Africa watching the Springboks/All Black tests…..
Cheers for the content Tim💪🇿🇦
Best Rugby channel ever😊😊
When all is said and done, we may not have looked clinical out there in the downpour, but we come away with an aggregate 63 - 19 and 10 log points after an away leg in Australia where we usually battle. Some players played out of their socks today and others were not as good, but overall, we did the job we set out to do and now we are firmly in control of the the RC.
We have to keep winning now, sure, but we are definitely capable of doing just that.
We also learned the worth of a lot of the youngsters and that is money in the bank for us.
Proud of the boys!
Also, i think a few names can safely and confidently be added to the pool of reliable test players, such as:
BJ Dixon, Nortje, I think Marco VS, Fassi, and Thomas DT...
Ah, maybe Elrigh L as well...
Spot on. Great comment! They're definitely creating depth and I thought the youngsters got better as the half wore on. Mapimpi and Sacha such basic errors that would've changed the game
🎉
This is the only rugby channel I follow - brilliant unbiased insight!
Don't know about unbiased, Tim clearly is a springbok fan😂isn't that right Tim? And any fan has some bias
Also, you guys over there have 60 million fans, good for the channel subscribers 😅just saying, I might be wrong, could just be business, and he is a AB's fan
Thanks for spreading the word of Rugby Tim enjoy your take on the game as usual Proud Springbok Supporter go Bokke
Tim!!! You’re coming back to SA!!! Yay!! 🎉
Hope you have the best time!!
Thank you 😊
Great to hear you will be traveling to sa for the nz tests 🎉
So good as always Tim!
Love your work Eggie !
I have so much love and respect for you Tim. I love the point you made about Libbok, he's a great player however his greatness is overshadowed by his inability to kick. He's a playmaker and always creating opportunities but he's not appreciated and people crucify him quicker than the other 2 flyhalves.
Fassi my man of the match. I think he deserved a bit more than a 7.5 for that performance
Tim!!! You’re coming back to SA!!! Yay!! 🎉
Hope you have the best time!!
Welcome home Tim!! 😊
The biggest plus is the experience for those young players which is what Rassie is interested in.
Hi Tim, let us know if you need accommodation during the Cape Town leg of your visit. Thanks for the "lekker" content, we enjoy your channel.
How much does Kolbe have to do on a field to be in the best player in the world conversation. This guy is consistently delivering match defining moments.
The day he takes over from the ref😂😂😂
I really think we are missing the best potential Bok scrumhalf: Nohamba!
10000% why he is not involved will always be a mystery the best 9 AND 10 at the lions
@@JackN13_ he's injured - I think most agree that he's better than Van Den Berg
You are ne of the best podcasters in rugby Tim, objective and intelligent. Agree that Fassi, Nortje,Williams and du Toit enhanced their reputations.
Your ratings are spot on Tim!!
You are brilliant 🙌🏾
Ruan, Sasha, mapimpi, psdt/Kriel, cheslin bungled a try. 30 points at least... We really suck in the rain.
These are not our usual conditions. True we suck...
That Kriel one hurt the most as PSDT do all the work all Kriel had to do is fall over the ball. haha
@@mackyj7801PSDT pass was forward?
Tim I wait for your videos like I waited for exam results in uni😂 come check out Pirates vs SA legends when you are here, 30 Aug in Jhb
What time on the 30th
@@pete-fv8zs 6pm
Excellent summation! Thank you.
Agree all in all. Marco van Staden and Louw are worth persevering with I think. Viva Nortje out of the new forwards.
I feel like Louw is doing good consistent things ... But just isn't that X factor no.8. I've always felt like he or JLDP were more similar to Mostert in 2019 as a utility flank/lock option.
Van Staden never looks good to me, but then you look at his game stats and realise he did way more than you realised.
Agree both are worth keeping in the squad, but not sold on them being first choice just yet.
Love the Dweba comment...😢
Tim. 🎉🎉🎉 good review. Very accurate.
Game changed when Polly came on. He settles it down and controls it
Once again, your comments are so good. I can’t differ with any of it. Thumbs up 👍
Grant Williams really deserves a start at 9. Yes, he brings it off the bench, but he really looks to be the form player at the position for the Boks right now. I’d like to see him start against AB at Ellis Park with Reinach on the bench, or maybe Faf if Rassie thinks they’d need a bit of extra grit on defense late in the game, but I’d lean more to Williams/Reinach on current form.
Would like to see Jaden Hendrikse back at 9 as our 3rd scrummie, Morne did not impress.
All the players will be better for today, very tough conditions, SA left a lot of tries on the table. All in all very happy.
Cool im glade you are coming to SA 'again' i think you are hooked on our country, weather, girl's, beer and of course the Springboks 😂 you will enjoy Ellis Park Stadium its gote the best vibes ever. See u there. Here in Gauteng we have sunshine 365 days a year. I enjoy yr program.
Thanks, mate. love how much you love rugby.
Love your work man
Sacha FM...love it! 😁
Wooooo! Over 100k subs bruvah. Been here since 6 nations 22 I think ❤
The whole set scrum situation was sketchy and affected the game plan for the Boks, yet they adapted and still made it look relatively easy in the 2nd half.
Hi Tim
Great review as usual. I thought Pollard and Libbok were a good combination. I'm enjoying the creativeness in the Springbok camp. I hope you have a wonderful trip to SA, especially Cape Town. Take something warm and a raincoat.
I agree about Manie- I don’t understand the hate towards him…
He missed most of his kick when he played I think that is the only concern for them.
Its his very very poor kicking… c’mon. This is an area he must sort out or fall by the wayside… its that simple! Focus and help him!
@@michaelmcilrath9466 or have someone else kick like other teams do
@@simorfunfortunately when Willie or Damian are at fullback, who is gonna kick? Faf? Kolbe? They are not much better. I love Manie’s running game and his kicking game but off the tee is becoming a serious persistent issue for him that he needs to sort out.
I don't think it's hate. I feel for the guy. I know what it feels like to have a psychological hinderence in a specific area of performance. He needs professional help to calm his nerves. I think for now, he shouldn't be put under pressure to kick, until he is mentally fit for that. Goal scoring has won us World Cups. That is something we can not just ignore. So let's be fair, and not use the word hate liberally. That won't help his course
Love your work mate❤
Tim, you made it to your 100K subscribers and beyond!! Well done! Shoo the rain was pissing down in the beginning, rain always makes me worried because South Africans and wet balls don't mix well haha. Great to see the younger players getting some game time, we have so much young talent coming through and the coaches need to give them game time to impress them because ultimately we will have to phase out the older players eventually. Manie Libbok is such an amazing player, I have been rewatching Chasing the sun 2 and he was such a huge part of winning the games with his play other than the kicking, I wonder if he can get the kicking right? Look Sasha is great too but the side kicks(not sure of the proper terminology) he puts through can change the game. Aphelele Fassi has been one of my favourite's since his debut, he had a number of injuries which caused a number of delays in seeing him back in a Springbok jersey, and I am so happy to see him back. Incredible hands and those long legs, just so fast. I think there will be a lot more of letting lesser known players get some game time in the near future!
Moment of the match - Ref telling Nick White: "not today"
...mic drop moment.
Thanks Tim..interesting view points.
Love your content Tim. I'll be looking out for you at the CT match. If I see you, I'll defo ask for a selfie at least.
Awesome take as ever well done!!!
I really like how objective your analysis is , you call a spade a spade . Love the channel please visit Soweto when you come to SA
Hey Tim, Love your channel and content! So happy you had a great trip to South Africa and that you are coming back soon.. I was trying to find the vid where you mentioned wanting to interview Deon Fourie.. my brother made Chasing the Sun and can connect you!
Good selection headaches to have. Rotation and depth tested. A win is win in wet conditions away from home. Some guys need more time to shine. We are at a good stage mixing youth and experience.
At test level in atrocious conditions, the youngsters did well enough. So all those scores are fair.
Aphalele "The Weekend Special" Fassi is one of my favourites! He'll catch any ball and run it straight back where it came from all day long! He improved his defence slightly, but can still be better.
Ostrich Egg omelette is the best. But really, Tim, have some ostrich meat when you are in Cape Town it's a stunning meat 🍖
Very objective evaluation, thanks.
Alot of young guys, weather and nerves...wouldn't read anything more into it than we got the 5...they will learn from this....ABs will feature more of the A team guys and less of the emerging guys I think....so good practice and good experience...these guys will feature more against Argies
Nortje worked his butt off for the whole game. Definitely put his hand up.
Fassi has always been an exceptional attacking talent. That part of his game was never in question, and since the Wallabies didn't really stress the Bok defense, we haven't learned much new about Fassi.
Grant Williams (just like Cobus Reinach) is insanely fast. There's a value in having two sniping, lightning fast scrum halves, who'll test and stress the opposition's D for 80mins.
Well summed up, Tim - have a good 'un in SA & welcome back then!!
Jan Hendrik was giving Allaltoia a hard time for his first time at prop, so I am happy with his scrumming, and yes accuracy wasnt that good for boks but it was pounding down with rain, , dont worry when we at Ellispark the sun will shine and we will run hard aginst the all blacks, cant wait. Boks can win both games against AB'S.
Not his first time on prop but did what needed to be done...if it where better condition, he would have performed better but give him some time
Thinking back to the twicknham game before RWC23, I think they might pull a 7.1 split, starting Rienach and Libbok with Pollard on the bench this time.
I wouldn't read too much in the back-to-back victories against a team that is rebuilding itself. The 2 tests against New Zealand on home soil will give one a better idea how good SA is.
Thanks Tim for great comment. Yours is the go-to rugby pod.
Regards to Grant think he’s secured the bench spot, personally I think he’s more on form than both faf and cobus, but I think they rate his pace against tired opponents, so think he will be on bench for the foreseeable future
Hello Tim,
Once more thanks a lot for your participation.
Concerning JH Wessels one has to take into account that he is still very young as far as international props are concerned. I never played at this level but I was at my strongest and had the most endurance at age 33.
I didn't think he fared so badly in the scrums save for one and perhaps two scrums.
Concerning the rest I thought he was his opponent's equal and sometimes even the better.
As far as the scrum rules are concerned it is an absolute mess. Most of the rime no one knows why or who contravened a rule, least of all the referee. No high level referee that I know of has been a prop.
And on top of that the rules are just plainly ridiculous. Whoever made then do not have the faintest understanding of basic physics.
I am a civil engineer who took physics up to 3rd year level at university so I have a basic idea of force, structure and motion.
I am an advocate for reintroducing the rule that loose head props should bind with a straight left arm by gripping the top of the pants of the opposing tight head. In this way a rigid beam is formed on each side of the scrum, ensuring much more stability. This ensures that the scrum is stable once the sides have bound.
It consequently ensures rhat the scrumhalf can put the ball in straight, and that hookers can actually hook the ball.
Penalties are awarded if the ball had been put in skew, foot up by the hooker before the ball has been put in, and if one side starts pushing before the ball has been put in.
Please never stop with you programme. We are looking forward to having you back in SA 😊
I see you understand exactly how we as south african supports criticise and support our players🇿🇦
Marx is awesome!
He now had scored 19
tries! The same as Danie Gerber. 😊 ( I know he played many more tests)
As a NZer, I'm really looking forward to the challenge of playing the Springboks in SA. The Boks are clearly the best team in world rugby.
Also can't wait, Boks v AB's is a treat! ❤🇿🇦
Watched both your summaries of today's game, Tim. As a Bok supporter, I always head towards you first. You report really quality insight.
I agree about the new recruits who didn't take their opportunities. For me, Moerat is a quality leader, but his overall game doesn't qualify for international standards. Nottingham with all the quality locks we currently have.
Secondly, I know the conditions were wet & heavy underfoot, but for me, Du Toit, who is the biggest prop we have, is far too nice of a player. For his height & weight, he should be far more aggressive against opposition and really bringing it. Make opponents remember him, which he's not doing imo. I'm a huge Grant Williams fan. I hope he doesn't become a bomb squader. He offers the Boks so much more in his natural game than that. 8th man? I'm an Evan Roos fan. He's a natural enforcer. People go on too much about his discipline imo. He'll mature like Eben Estebeth did. The main thing is, he's a beast, and he almost always crosses the gain line in his powerful runs. He's my 1st choice 8. He's 1 guy I believe he needs to stop stop/starting otherwise, he'll lose confidence and we'll lose him. He's already been made huge offers by the Japanese clubs. Otherwise, great show, Tim, as usual !!!
Fair comment on the Joseph Dweba. He’s very underrated and a lot of stick. He is also more effective physically. Joseph needs more opportunities.
Cheslin man of the match ?
Love your show Tim, great analysis and concise breakdown, couldn't agree more
I like how Tim has picked up on our age old picking apart players short comings,(mentioning Le Bok and Williams ) that's so part of South African rugby supporters way of mercilessly and sometimes undeservedly roast the players they don't rate . We are VERY opinionated people ..right or wrong 😂😂
Good analysis Eggy..
Fassi needs lots of love
Love this show
New front row not ready yet, especially grobbelaar.
My interest is in the combo of Libbok and Pollard on the field at the same time. It might elevate Libbok amd give Pollard bok longevity, wish we got more time to see that
Really excited for Boks v ABs 🤩
Suggestion. Put number & position under name. I'm a Saffa and struggle to know who fits where. Great channel.
Slightly off topic:
How about this as a team of the (near future):
1. Nche
2. Marx
3. Malherbe
4. Etsebeth
5.Snyman
6. Kolisi (c)
7. PTSD
8. Hanekom
9. Williams
10. Pollard
11. Arendse
12. de Allende
13. Kriel
14. Kolbe
15. Willemse
16. Mbonambi
17. Kitshoff
18. Du Toit
19. Moerat
20. Dixon (covers flank, lock)
21. Smith (covers flank, 8th man)
22. Nohamba (covers scrumhalf, flyhalf)
23. Feinberg-Mngomezulu (covers Flyhalf, Inside Centre, Fullback)
Fassi was excellent my number 1 for full back ❤❤❤❤
You forgot Eben?
The weather conditions for the two games was significantly different. The storm had largely passed by the 10-minute mark of the NZ game. Not great conditions to be sure but nothing like that monsoon in Perth. Did I miss Am's rating?
You won't want to return to England once you have experienced Cape Town and it's glorious views and food. And above most the people.
Agree with all those scores! And I'd give the Boks 6.5 overall in that match! 😊 There were some good bits, yes, but the not so good bits were just shocking! 😂 Still, it wasn't a bad day at the office! Not many coaches can rotate a team AND come away with a bonus point win at the same time! 👌🏾
Lets see what we can do against New Zealand! The Mighty All Blacks seem to have their fire back which will make for a proper test! 🇿🇦❤🇳🇿
I agree. Fair ratings. They need to be much better to best the ABs.
Love the channel, Tim.
I also love PSDT - one of the best ever. But I disagree about the runs down the wing. I’ve never been a fan of the locks/hookers taking the ball down the sideline when there’s space:
1) they’re too slow so the defence can usually catch up,
2) they typically lack the skills to get a cheeky little grubber, off-load, or chip kick to convert to a try.
Take a look at those PsdT breaks down the sidelines and tell me how many of them were converted into points?
💯 Tim about the effects of the bomb squad 👍🏽
I think too many changes
I guess ons has one has to start somewhere to blood the new guys.
Fassi has matured a lot as a player. Its time to start shifting out Le Roux and Mapimpi and start shifting in Fassi and Moodie
Moodie? So we are retiring Arendse?
Ideally Kobe needs a backup. But Kobe is elite this moment. Moodie can cover 13 as well.
cause at 15 Damian, Fassi, Le Roux are all specialist fullbacks for their URC teams.
@Karma-qt4ji a squad has more than 2 wings
@@nicolasvanstaden263 ah okay. Got ya.
Mannie is the best attacking flyhalf we have had since Honiball.
Do you want to score tries or do you want to try to dominate up front and kick penalties?
Was a really scrappy game, could blame weather but ABs also played in bad weather and were amazing.
Willie Le Roux, Damian Wilemse,Fassie...full back options. ❤❤❤
I don't think the idea was ever to use Sasha as 10 against NZ, I think the idea was to see how he goes against Australia, pretty sure Pollard will be back for All Blacks
Yeah they will go back to the Ireland team.
Slightly harsh on a few players I think but none the less, if the Boks perform at a 6.5 and get a bonus point win, I’ll take it 🇿🇦🇿🇦 thanks for the content Tim.
You're quite right about what would've happened to Dweba had he thrown those poor line-outs.
Hello Tim. Do you follow Salford Red Devils. Just wondering. Once upon a time I watched 50+ City matches annually.
Good viewing Tim!