Our team feels honored that this video investigation was awarded Video of the Year 2018 and Best News Feature 2018 by the Society of Publication Designers at a ceremony in New York on May 3. Recognition of stories like this helps, a little, to further the case for justice, which his family has not yet received. Thanks to followers of the Visual Investigations team and supporters of our work.
@@legionary1656 well it is a fact that the chinese government is oppressive af... not quite a country to stay if you're a fan of freedom, transparency and the truth no matter what...
Why is the NYT not doing a video on the slow killing of Julian Assange, happening right now? oh, right, they would have to talk about their own betrayal of journalism principles. You want to see great investigative journalism? watch The Lobby: UK and The Lobby USA, something the NYT would never do. ua-cam.com/video/3lSjXhMUVKE/v-deo.html & ua-cam.com/video/ceCOhdgRBoc/v-deo.html
Reminds me of Julian Assange, exposing the lies and seeking the truths. At least he's still in another country. When they bring him to the US, consider him dead.
@@rajprotimautriya5962 He achieved nothing. He just tried to go against the powerful people and was shown the way of the food chain. You cannot make a poweful person pay for their crimes, no amount of journalism can stop you from being taken out. He died a vain death and his legacy is now forgotten by even his own countrymen who have blatantly ignored the subject. The sooner you learn that it is fruitless to change the country and it's functioning, however bad it may be, the better. At least it might save your life unlike Jamal
Politics and politicians...all about imperialism & capitalism So whatever can increase that power and money...even if it means allowing certain countries to dismember humans at embassies...so let it be... So sad so so sad...
Mustafa Austin Powers lol “unreliable” search up us annual growth rate of oil production i can’t stand people who act as if they know what they are talking about
Rich D because we have ties with Saudi Arabia and if we refuse to acknowledge the Saudis government's involvement in this murder then what else are we willing to turn a blind eye to?
@@paulbenoit6076 so?? Its freedom of speech...and he was a journalist . That's his right, but in Saudi Arabia there is no freedom of speech or human rights.
These “Visual investigation” videos are incredibly done! It’s no surprise that this/these are and will be award winning. Especially when English only audiences like myself may have a hard time following some stories featuring the Saudi/Arabic language due to names/language pronunciations being difficult to retain. I’m sad to say ‘great job’ when it’s on a story that’s so tragic it shouldn’t exist, let alone be told.
I was heartbroken when I saw the footage of kashoggi with his fiance hands in hand sec before entering the Saudi embassy....felt bad for his fiancé 😔 😕 😞 😢
He let himself get fat and unfit, he coulda pounded them into the ground and been the one making an actual cool or smart/smooth exit, by his age doesn't look like he got much right, not even his wife although that's subjective, except money and provoking the saudi government and got it. If he got friends nobody would have left that consulate and it would have been a real thriller not one who is as f*cked up as the other, reality check. ..not his "wife" lol
@@joulupukki1607 then they're all complicit, how is he out of that norm? Just because in his bad, confused old age he talk about one thing that got him killed? He uses credit card full of money, going to get approval from 2 "bad guy" governments for his marriage, how is he like you?! He seems like he wants to be at the same car that he criticises and they pounded him inside it to let him know he can't have it both ways, he was a willing product of them. Is that a rolemodel worth crying after? lol i should complain then about his corruption, what sciences did he teach himself? Languages? He advises about products? Brought together his community? Adopted a child? Welcomes, advises, takes care of someone? Lacking awareness and Unfit to dead was just the one that got him. I don't see one person coming forth for him, just talk, barking and sensation.
Its really distressing to think that you can sit next to a killer on a commuter flight not knowing what they have been up to. Its truly chilling what is allowed to go on in this world. Makes me ill.
As a vegan i know what you mean...i too often have to sit next to sadistic brutal killers who dont think twice to put cruely upon other living creatures to get a little bit taste...
SALAM Please write to the Israeli authorities urging them to: i. guarantee the physical and psychological integrity of the female prisoners in Neve Tertze prison in Ramle at all times and ensure their access to medical care; ii. carry out a full and impartial investigation into the alleged torture and ill-treatment, in order to identify those responsible, bring them to trial and apply the penal, civil and/or administrative sanctions provided by law in accordance with international legal standards; iii. ensure that immediate action is taken to guarantee that the conditions in Neve Tertze prison in Ramle meet minimum international standards; iv. guarantee all human rights and fundamental freedoms in accordance with to the international human rights standards and in particular the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
An old Turkish saying goes, “Show me who your friend is, I’ll tell you who you are.” We as a nation are no different from these people if we stand as bystanders.
Incredibly powerful investigation & video. So professional. So many details and so much evidence. THANK YOU, New York Times team, for doing this. Keep doing this. It matters a lot.
Thanks very much @VykintasGlodenis. It took weeks of work by reporters and editors here in New York, Istanbul, Beirut, Paris, Brussels, Washington DC and across the U.S.
@@expetriat If it could be proved the way you are asking for there would not have been this discussion. But if you think logically at least there should not be a god the way we see him one with heavens hells prophets and stuff. But if you think and not just believe.
Ofcourse media ( Soros ) will blow up this. Kashogi was a disposable CIA agent, he's working for Soros and Tallal interest. One of their biggest enemy are crown prince, the only prince that willing to bring peace in middle east. The media keep silent about the shooting event that happened in crown prince resident some weeks before....
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ At the time, Trump was the president and people were wondering why the USA wasn't taking a harder stance and sanctioning Saudi. When the murderer lives in your building, it's kind of hard to seek justice. I guess this needs to be spelled out for some people.
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ CIA stated the order came from the Crown Prince. The high five with Putin pretty much said it all. He's a thug and a dictator.
There is absoultely NO WAY that something as consequential and potentially damning as the pre-meditated killing of a dissenter in a foreign embassy was done without the blessing of the highest ranking official in the land. I have no doubt in my mind that Mohammed Bone Saw personally authorized this egregious crime. Something as crucial as this would NEVER be concealed from the ruler of the entire nation because doing so without his consent would more than likely mean death.
DB Stevens If I was the president I’d send in a team of CIA operatives to take out the Prince. We know our intelligence agency is the best at covering up their tracks. We’ll say he hung himself or shot himself in the head 4 times 😉
Trump Administration, especially his Son in Law, Jared Kushner, WHO WERE 100% COMPLICIT, in the MURDER of AN AMERICAN, by MBS, SAUDI ARABIA. No Surprise, the TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IGNORED DEATH OF AMERICANS BECAUSE SAUDI, RUSSIAN, etc. $$$ MONEY HAS BEEN THE SOURCE OF THEIR AMERICAN LIVELIHOOD’S. JARED KUSHNER/ KUSHNER COMPANIES WOULD BE BANKRUPT IF NOT FOR DIRTY (MURDER OF AMERICANS) SAUDI MONEY
Saudis Arabia is not the only country where freedom of speech is becoming obsolete. China🇨🇳Venezuela🇻🇪Mexico🇲🇽Egypt🇪🇬Iran🇮🇷Tanzania🇹🇿Philippines🇵🇭 Scary and heartbreaking, because people in this country get away for with telling lies.
He came to Istanbul just for that, he wanted to go to New York embassy but told his fiancé that he wouldn't come out of there alive. he knew what was coming.
@@Celiktaban almost makes me wonder why he didn’t go to Ankara embassy or any other Saudi embassy. He chose to go to a goofy consulate, istg the Saudi consulate is the most deserted and depressing place in Istanbul, the aura that surrounds that place is in itself the epitome of evil.
he was going to get married soon and had to go into the consulate for the papers. and the first time he went there, they apparently welcomed him and treated him very kindly. that's why he thought nothing would happen.
@@Ari-lu5ve hi, 2 years have gone...where's the punishment and justice from allah? lolol i am sure mbs is enjoying and relaxing comparing to most citizens throughout the covid pandemic. taking so long? so many prayers for jamal yet no results lolol
I feel his remains have either been dissolve in acid inside the consul’s house, or have either been transported inside luggage carried by diplomatic personnel before being dropped from a privet plane
Can we just appreciate how freaking amazing The New York Times are at investigating?! Like wow the attention to detail and the journalism *chef’s kiss*.
I have always wondered as I unfortunately continue to do so because as far as I know society still does not know where his remains are. How is it that all this time could have gone by without finally learning how his body was disposed of? This case makes me so sad, it's so tragic, it's just disgusting. And so deplorable as to what a government can do and get away with.
What a mind blowing investigation. Kudos to the team. Keep up the fantastic work and bring out the truth from such conspiracies that affect the innocents.
That last walk, hand in hands, strolling down the road to death. That, moment of love entered into moment of death swiftly, leaving behind half of his love in excruciating emotional pain. They will get united, but what about the impunity with which he had been whacked into pieces? The truth is, it is one incident that has been brought into light. Ruthless dictators have been killing people with dissent the same way. My heart goes out for his fiance waiting outside counselate till the day end when he didn't appear. What would have been her feelings at that time.
Your lovely work seems almost impossible! How are you guys this genius! Please never stop your visual investigations! I love and follow them all the time.
....You CANNOT have the 3rd Temple without the Anti-Christ, and you CANNOT have the Anti-Christ without the 3rd Temple! 2nd Thessalonians 2:1- 12 says; "Now, brethren, concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our gathering together to Him, we ask you, 2not to be soon shaken in mind or troubled, either by spirit or by word or by letter, as if from us, as though the day of Christ had come. 3Let no one deceive you by any means; for that Day will not come unless the falling away comes first, and the man of sin is revealed, the son of perdition, 4who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped, so that he sits as God in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God....... 6And now you know what is restraining, that he may be revealed in his own time. 7For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work; only He who now restrains will do so until He is taken out of the way. 8And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord will consume with the breath of His mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming. 9The coming of the lawless one is according to the working of Satan, with all power, signs, and lying wonders, 10and with all unrighteous deception among those who perish, because they did not receive the love of the truth, that they might be saved. 11And for this reason God will send them strong delusion, that they should believe the lie, 12that they all may be condemned who did not believe the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness." (The Holy Spirit is the Restrainer Paul is speaking of). Naphtali Bennett is the end time Anti-Christ whose pogrom against the Palestinians will provoke the end time war- the Egyptians will invade Palestine, be beaten back and conquered, but while Bennett is in Egypt, the Gogites, (the end time Turk led coalition) will invade Palestine from the north and east, (Daniel 11:44); occupying Jerusalem & the West Bank! Zechariah 14:1-2; '1Behold, the day of the Lord is coming, And your spoil will be divided in your midst. 2For I will gather all the nations to battle against Jerusalem; The city shall be taken, The houses rifled, And the women ravished. Half of the city shall go into captivity, But the remnant of the people shall not be cut off from the city.' The Anti-Christ will then return from Egypt to nuke the Gogites; per Zechariah 14:12; "And this shall be the plague with which the Lord will strike all the people who fought against Jerusalem: Their flesh shall dissolve while they stand on their feet, Their eyes shall dissolve in their sockets, And their tongues shall dissolve in their mouths".- per the prophets, Jerusalem will be dark at midday; (beneath the nuclear mushroom cloud! In biblical numerology 12 is the number for the church- founded on 12 apostles, & for natural Israel, from the 12 sons of Jacob. 7 represents the fulness of time- God made creation in 6 days and rested on the 7th. 7 x 12 = 84. The Zionist state was founded in 1948, and will end in 2032- 84 years later. The end time war will be in the last quarter of 2032; and Jesus will return in late November/ early December, the night after the nuclear explosion! Please share this with the world!
Wow! This is the best report of this case that I've seen. There is so much detail. It's so bad everyones comfortable with MBS i remember what the Americans and Brits did during the Scripal case, an attempted murder with no concrete evidence caused a massive diplomatic chaos. But the two countries ignored this. What a shame
This is terrifying and horrifying. How can these seemingly normal people abet and cover up the murder of an innocent man? How does a government have connections to all these hit men? How can we have murderers as rulers? I'm thankful the Turkish government noticed what was going on so at least we know what the Saudis did. All this for a journalist who simply told the truth.
You can learn many things, most importantly how you can keep yourself safe, from this investigation report. Good job The New York Times and team of Malachy Browne. You guys did a Sherlock job.
Poor poor man just think of the terror he felt when he realized what was about to happen soon after he entered the building. I’m sure he was expecting something sinister to happen even though he was treated in a ‘friendly’ manner the last time he was at the embassy. So it was very brave of him to go inside the building and do what he thought he had to do.
Where does all of the CCTV footage for something like this come from. I am so impressed with these videos and the amount of detail that they contain. Amazing
Turkish state media was very closely connected to the Turkish investigators who gathered lots of the visual evidence and leaked it. We were able to confirm it using our sources and by finding social media profiles, phone numbers, passport numbers and older photos and videos of some of the hit men. For the autopsy expert, Salah al Tubaigy, we found an email address connected to his Twitter and LinkedIn profiles - the email led us to academic papers, conferences, committees he sits on, an overseas placement at an Australian forensics group. Maher Mutreb: we confirmed his details through national security reporting in the US, diplomatic sources in the UK, finding sources who knew him and could identify him, and by verifying his phone number and passport information. The body double we verified through biographical details on LinkedIn and photos on his Facebook account and other accounts (he has a very distinctive ear and nose!). And our reporters in France found other sources who worked with the Saudi royals and recognized some of the men. We also checked flight records to double check the entry times and passport checks that the Turkish officials released. So it was a combination of verifying those leaks, finding out who these men were, what their ties to the Saudi Crown Prince were and reconstructing their movements. Our graphics reporter Anjali Singhvi also obtained pictures inside the Consulate to model its interior, and using reporting from our Istanbul and Beirut teams, we could show where certain events happened. We are sitting on much more reporting that either we couldn't completely verify or which wasn't essential to the video piece, so we held back for clarity and accuracy. Reporting by the Washington Post and CNN also helped corroborate some of the reporting we were sitting on. www.nytimes.com/2018/10/16/world/middleeast/khashoggi-saudi-prince.html
Our team feels honored that this video investigation was awarded Video of the Year 2018 and Best News Feature 2018 by the Society of Publication Designers at a ceremony in New York on May 3. Recognition of stories like this helps, a little, to further the case for justice, which his family has not yet received. Thanks to followers of the Visual Investigations team and supporters of our work.
crazy
We need certain prove that crown prince who did ?
Can you try again ?
Whats the end result?
You need to thanx to Türkishe secret police that investigated this teribel crime!
Thank you so much for this piece! It's great to see that someone cares, our President sure doesn't care.
The fact that the world moved on without actually doing anything is horrifying
FavJam $ITS CALL MONEY$$$$$/$$$$$$$$$
Thanks Obama
FavJam .. that’s a very sad but very accurate statement ! I was wondering the same thing myself !
BOSTON BRUINS 12 $$$$$$$$$$
they didn't move on America pressured Saudi arabia and Saudi arabia said that they executed the killers
This gives me the creeps. Imagine that you just doin your job and went inside a building and you never walk outside ever again
msma Lmao what?
@@msmaa5 You're stupid my guy
@@legionary1656 well it is a fact that the chinese government is oppressive af... not quite a country to stay if you're a fan of freedom, transparency and the truth no matter what...
@@legionary1656 you should google "falun gong organ harvesting"!!!
@Florian Cravic Yeah well... Every country has restrictions... Some more than others... But you're definetely better of in the US than in China...
"in the final hours, they talk about dinner plans, and new furniture for their home"
Gosh that made me so sad
my god i felt that too 😢
They arrived at the consulate at 1:13pm.
She waited until midnight for him.
Bush said it was a mistake as if it was a soccer game mistake after killing millions of lives in Iraq,be sad at that
@@franco7928 Watch Dw documentary for more clarity
Man I feel so bad for his fiancee, imagine seeing your loved one enter a building but never coming out of it as you just wait endlessly until midnight
That’s sick. Ik she want they head on a stick.
He got cold feet😂😂😂
@@Markwaltonn5860That wasn't funny
This isn't a good time to make stupid jokes
@mikewatson5860 This isn't funny, this is not the place to be joking
@@gumpreeengthegumpreeeng i wouldn't pay any attention to morons.
Great investigative journalism here, it is rare these days. Keep it up!!
Claps to the Turkish authorities
@Snaggle Toothed only stupids like they are wiser, like you're
Why is the NYT not doing a video on the slow killing of Julian Assange, happening right now? oh, right, they would have to talk about their own betrayal of journalism principles. You want to see great investigative journalism? watch The Lobby: UK and The Lobby USA, something the NYT would never do.
ua-cam.com/video/3lSjXhMUVKE/v-deo.html & ua-cam.com/video/ceCOhdgRBoc/v-deo.html
They did a terrific job.
Khalid Ibn Alwaleed lol denial, instead of refuting certain details you flat out deny the entire investigation, how embarrassing
this story really makes my blood boil..how these people can get away with killing someone with zero consequences for their actions!
Well it happens everyday in America, how boiled is your blood really?
ottobong like our officials?
How many people have our own politicians killed?
The killers got the death penalty.
Idf killers check them out
America make a hero movie of a guy who murderd kids for fun
Rip Khashoggi. You died like a true patriot, exposing the wicked liars, and seeking the truth. You have left a legacy for many to follow.
No he didn't
🤫🤥🤮🥱🤡
Reminds me of Julian Assange, exposing the lies and seeking the truths. At least he's still in another country. When they bring him to the US, consider him dead.
@@gorillachilla Why ??
@@rajprotimautriya5962 He achieved nothing. He just tried to go against the powerful people and was shown the way of the food chain. You cannot make a poweful person pay for their crimes, no amount of journalism can stop you from being taken out. He died a vain death and his legacy is now forgotten by even his own countrymen who have blatantly ignored the subject. The sooner you learn that it is fruitless to change the country and it's functioning, however bad it may be, the better. At least it might save your life unlike Jamal
NOW CAN YOU IMAGINE IF IRAN HAD DONE SUCH A THING!!! BUT WHEN IT'S THE SAUDIS, THE U.S. GOVERNMENT TURNS A BLIND EYE.😏😏😉😉
Politics and politicians...all about imperialism & capitalism
So whatever can increase that power and money...even if it means allowing certain countries to dismember humans at embassies...so let it be...
So sad so so sad...
Oil is a big incentive
Yes they are their beloved pets in the region who,along with UEA, ensure the safety or Israel and us oil companies
Iran did do something like this. In 2015 and '17 two members of an opposition group who fled to the Netherlands where killed.
@DB Stevens WORLD IS FULL OF DEGENERATE LOW LIFES.
The U.S and the UK will not question the saudi regime because of oil.
English Nationalist USA is the largest producer of oil in the world now.
@@bravetimmy The Saudi has cheaper cost of extracting them,shale oil is unreliable.
America produces more oil than it uses......
Mustafa Austin Powers why is shale oil unreliable ?
Mustafa Austin Powers lol “unreliable” search up us annual growth rate of oil production i can’t stand people who act as if they know what they are talking about
Don’t need Interpol, FBI or detectives when you got New York Times
Harryboi 64 yes kratos the New York time are the best when it come to investigations
But it’s all other people works lol lol lol they’re literally copying Turkish/Arabic news channels
Fk fbi. fbi is puppet
@@alix4698 just like you?
@@alix4698 Based on what?
“For anybody who changes their principles depending on whom he is dealing, that is not a man who can lead a nation”. -Nelson Mandela
Absolutely. America need to to know this. My prayers for Kashoggi's family and Palestinians
Thanks for covering this. Seems like main stream media has forgotten about him and his story.
The NYT is part of the Mainstream Media
Why should Americans care about this?
Rich D because we have ties with Saudi Arabia and if we refuse to acknowledge the Saudis government's involvement in this murder then what else are we willing to turn a blind eye to?
The mainstream media hasnt forgotten they need to help cover it up and makes us forget so diplomacy continues... we are the sheep
@@rich2583 Ignoring this too much makes USA weaker in world politics.
His fiancee was still waiting outside!!! Broke my heart after watching this!! 💔💔
Dude, please stop this naivety. This woman is a Turkish intelligence agent, and if you sympathize with her with all due respect, you are really naive.
@@JL03-o8c you are naive for thinking that the fake royal saudi family is muslim.
@@Ramirez83786 And you are more naive to think that the Turkish intelligence agent, Hatice Genghis Khan, is his fiancée
They couldn’t tell her anything because they needed to save their own hides by getting out of the country.
It's heartbreaking to think the man was living a normal life with his fiance, days from getting married but got killed by ppl just for being honest.
He was not living a normal life. He was actively opposing the Saudi government
@@paulbenoit6076 so?? Its freedom of speech...and he was a journalist . That's his right, but in Saudi Arabia there is no freedom of speech or human rights.
@@Rosie_88 The UK and America need to sort Saudi arabia out.
@@CoolDude-jp1kj they'll never do that. Saudi Arabia is their biggest oil supplier. They might do that when their oil dries out lol
@@Rosie_88 contradiction is a thing 🤭
These “Visual investigation” videos are incredibly done! It’s no surprise that this/these are and will be award winning.
Especially when English only audiences like myself may have a hard time following some stories featuring the Saudi/Arabic language due to names/language pronunciations being difficult to retain. I’m sad to say ‘great job’ when it’s on a story that’s so tragic it shouldn’t exist, let alone be told.
I feel so sad about his fiancee they both look so happy and good together...it is sickening
I was heartbroken when I saw the footage of kashoggi with his fiance hands in hand sec before entering the Saudi embassy....felt bad for his fiancé 😔 😕 😞 😢
i feel bad for both of them
@@mnco5741 did his fiance die?
@@saraelmi875 no, i don t think so
@@saraelmi875 i think he feel bad because his fiance was just about to marry him and live together
Her pacing outside waiting makes me sad
They need to make a documentary about this and his life as a journalist.
Why? Nobody in America cares about this.
Rich D that’s not true it’s been headline news globally for two weeks. This video has 100k views
People do care. The most shocking thing to me is seeing him and his fiance wandering along relaxed and happy just before the assassination.
My understanding he was a dirt-bag. RIP
@@wordzmyth Looking at his Fiance seems the Saudi's did him a favor.
This is by far the most difficult thing I have ever watched. My heart goes out to his family.........
Their money wont take them to heaven, May God give strength that innocent woman 👩
🧕*
@@epiccookie9889 😐
@@epiccookie9889 😐
@@epiccookie9889 🤨
@@jinglefart Wrong emoji
My condolences to Mr. Khashoggi's family, loved ones and friends. May he rest in peace.
THE WORLD LET THIS MAN DOWN.
He let himself get fat and unfit, he coulda pounded them into the ground and been the one making an actual cool or smart/smooth exit, by his age doesn't look like he got much right, not even his wife although that's subjective, except money and provoking the saudi government and got it. If he got friends nobody would have left that consulate and it would have been a real thriller not one who is as f*cked up as the other, reality check. ..not his "wife" lol
THE WORLD.. ??
..and that delicate creature would have been listening to furniture then himself and a music of angels!
@@louly3212 yes world. Not one country said anything about this situation when it was clear who did it
@@joulupukki1607 then they're all complicit, how is he out of that norm? Just because in his bad, confused old age he talk about one thing that got him killed? He uses credit card full of money, going to get approval from 2 "bad guy" governments for his marriage, how is he like you?! He seems like he wants to be at the same car that he criticises and they pounded him inside it to let him know he can't have it both ways, he was a willing product of them. Is that a rolemodel worth crying after? lol i should complain then about his corruption, what sciences did he teach himself? Languages? He advises about products? Brought together his community? Adopted a child? Welcomes, advises, takes care of someone? Lacking awareness and Unfit to dead was just the one that got him. I don't see one person coming forth for him, just talk, barking and sensation.
This has to be the most shocking thing ever, imagine going by your day, entering a building and never leave. SAD! SAD! SAD!!😪
looks like they're new to the "making people disappear" thing.
Roy demeo
Exactly
italians do it better
They need pointers from Mossad
They're learning from the best
Imagine owning and controlling so much oil that you can literally get away with murder. Pathetic really isn’t it.
Its really distressing to think that you can sit next to a killer on a commuter flight not knowing what they have been up to. Its truly chilling what is allowed to go on in this world. Makes me ill.
this is reality wake up
Actually, they took 2 private jets not ordinary flights, that was a special mission.
As a vegan i know what you mean...i too often have to sit next to sadistic brutal killers who dont think twice to put cruely upon other living creatures to get a little bit taste...
U r so innocent at heart
SALAM Please write to the Israeli authorities urging them to:
i. guarantee the physical and psychological integrity of the female prisoners in Neve Tertze prison in Ramle at all times and ensure their access to medical care;
ii. carry out a full and impartial investigation into the alleged torture and ill-treatment, in order to identify those responsible, bring them to trial and apply the penal, civil and/or administrative sanctions provided by law in accordance with international legal standards;
iii. ensure that immediate action is taken to guarantee that the conditions in Neve Tertze prison in Ramle meet minimum international standards;
iv. guarantee all human rights and fundamental freedoms in accordance with to the international human rights standards and in particular the Convention on the Rights of the Child.
im getting goosebumps on how good this new york times investigate superb
An old Turkish saying goes, “Show me who your friend is, I’ll tell you who you are.” We as a nation are no different from these people if we stand as bystanders.
I hear you. How can we help?
You are nothing against people with power, snap out of the movies, live your life avoiding these people and try to help other
@@ehsanullah2325 what if someone comes?someone,who is mighty and ruthless.what happens the moment he attacks.
No wander that this disgusting criminals are among the US regime's best buddies..
Good thing i have no friends
Honestly, these are the most informative videos I've seen, and I've only seen two. First one was the Las Vegas analysis. Excellent work.
Yes! This channel does excellent work I must agree! Absolutely!! 💯
Except that Turkish investigators did everything, this channel just put it together for a video
@@feelsgoodman9751 They did say that most info came from Turkish investigators though.
Incredibly powerful investigation & video. So professional. So many details and so much evidence. THANK YOU, New York Times team, for doing this. Keep doing this. It matters a lot.
Thanks very much @VykintasGlodenis. It took weeks of work by reporters and editors here in New York, Istanbul, Beirut, Paris, Brussels, Washington DC and across the U.S.
Agree
Lol they have shown zero facts none
Yes New York Times team keep at them and give them no respite . Expose them at every turn and show them up for the vile decadent scum they are.
Are You Nuts It's Not Newyork Times , It's Turkish Investigation Team Collect All These Evidence
Didn't You Heard What The Anchor Says? Lol
Courageous, true journalism
I wouldn’t be surprised if Hollywood makes a movie of this someday.
Just to tone down the brutality of it huh
UPDATE: They are
Help they did make a movie
What's the name?
The dissident is the movie name
There is a judgment day waiting for every one. Whoever could escape in this world... He cannot do it there.
yes yaoum alqyama
this is a simple way for weak people to get some kind of comfort. Grow up, there is no God.
alexandre diakhate
Lmao show proof that there is no god or stfu.
@@expetriat If it could be proved the way you are asking for there would not have been this discussion. But if you think logically at least there should not be a god the way we see him one with heavens hells prophets and stuff. But if you think and not just believe.
U right bro
Not to mention that that "body double" had a full head of hair..
He does not look Like jamal
What's the point of the investigation when there is no legal repercussion, disgraceful.
It's disturbing how carefully planned Jamaal's murder was.
Not as perfect as 911 or JFK
And how poorly executed it was?
@@alexanderglynn9407 it wasnt poorly executed.. his body was never found, and none of these maniacs are in jail theyre walking free amongst us
That was a stupid plan
@@fatmftm1504 I agree. The man that acted as the body double had way more hair than Khashoggi, who’s almost bald.
Heartbreaking story...
But excellent journalism.
Kelly And Sam Seed that’s the Turkish government investigation
Ofcourse media ( Soros ) will blow up this. Kashogi was a disposable CIA agent, he's working for Soros and Tallal interest. One of their biggest enemy are crown prince, the only prince that willing to bring peace in middle east. The media keep silent about the shooting event that happened in crown prince resident some weeks before....
That's what you get for running that mouth
Yeah but when it. Comes to crimes against Palestine , Iraq , Syria Libya all we hear is lies or silence
1.1k dislikes are the Saudi Government and certain ppl.
@@joer.3240 you idio* these Saudi people are not Muslims as the claim so, they are hypocrites
Lol nice very smart ...
@@joer.3240 the man who was killed is muslim and was the most vocal against this regime, unlike your eu country or the Usa.
Yoki Chan then what are we ?
@@muftiabulayth8072 you mean the Saudi government? Because they are Wahhabis
I cannot imagine how much nefarious behavior went totally unnoticed before everyone started carrying a camera around.
It's like a great thriller movie, but this is a real life true story😢
I know right? Kinda reminds me of the Private novels.
Horror story
Reality is stranger then fiction.
@@deadmeme5726 I’d say more horrible
Rotty sneak
And yet no one likes to talk about the fact that The Crown Prince owns the 45th floor in The Trump Tower.
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ At the time, Trump was the president and people were wondering why the USA wasn't taking a harder stance and sanctioning Saudi. When the murderer lives in your building, it's kind of hard to seek justice. I guess this needs to be spelled out for some people.
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ CIA stated the order came from the Crown Prince. The high five with Putin pretty much said it all. He's a thug and a dictator.
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ they all got pardoned.
@⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻⸻ you are an embarrassment to rational thought.
Trade war with china was funny than😂
There is absoultely NO WAY that something as consequential and potentially damning as the pre-meditated killing of a dissenter in a foreign embassy was done without the blessing of the highest ranking official in the land. I have no doubt in my mind that Mohammed Bone Saw personally authorized this egregious crime. Something as crucial as this would NEVER be concealed from the ruler of the entire nation because doing so without his consent would more than likely mean death.
Thanks for an insightful comment I didn't think of it the way you put it!
DB Stevens If I was the president I’d send in a team of CIA operatives to take out the Prince. We know our intelligence agency is the best at covering up their tracks. We’ll say he hung himself or shot himself in the head 4 times 😉
Trump Administration, especially his Son in Law, Jared Kushner, WHO WERE 100% COMPLICIT, in the MURDER of AN AMERICAN, by MBS, SAUDI ARABIA. No Surprise, the TRUMP ADMINISTRATION IGNORED DEATH OF AMERICANS BECAUSE SAUDI, RUSSIAN, etc. $$$ MONEY HAS BEEN THE SOURCE OF THEIR AMERICAN LIVELIHOOD’S. JARED KUSHNER/ KUSHNER COMPANIES WOULD BE BANKRUPT IF NOT FOR DIRTY (MURDER OF AMERICANS) SAUDI MONEY
@@nineseven5252 That'd be a funny cover up. Seeing as suicide is heavily frowned upon in muslim communities. Literally no one would believe that lmao
@@cryptidv Don’t take it literally
It's scary to think that there is no international court to punish the leaders of a nation. How easy they can get away with such heinous crimes?
This is just needle in just hay stack..There are many hidden Hitlers in world we wouldn't even know responsible for genocides, wars..etc
noted, never do business with a Saudi
poorguy😂😃
Lol what it got to do with other saudis.
Saudis Arabia is not the only country where freedom of speech is becoming obsolete. China🇨🇳Venezuela🇻🇪Mexico🇲🇽Egypt🇪🇬Iran🇮🇷Tanzania🇹🇿Philippines🇵🇭 Scary and heartbreaking, because people in this country get away for with telling lies.
Terry Melvin I neglect to mention Russia🇷🇺
@@shova6995 your mother maybe nasty in nature not all saudis.
We living In a world where it's safer to be around wild animal than our dear brothers and sisters.
What a documentary! Kashoggi will always be remembered.
bita abdulrahman ...Unfortunately, the World has already forgotten him.
Mind blowing investigations that we rarely see now-a-days!
RIP Jamal Khashoggi 💔
And now they don't care anymore. They probably paid alot of money to keep this silenced now.
@Abdullah Alhumaidi Nah you can't pay me
@Abdullah Alhumaidi because I don't need it. I will pay you to turn into a nice person. Have a blessed day sir.
You all think now if this was done by North Korea or Iran what the U.S would do to them...
Whoever has oil gets away with it
@@urekmazino6800 thats not the case saudis are just american puppets thats why they let them get away with it
DB Stevens no, but the propaganda coverage would easily be 100x more
Uncle ruckus plz don’t put us in the same boat as the DPRK! Plz nd thank u 😓
No, Who does NOT have oil ALSO get away with it.
Simply chilling!! Great work at exposing this horrific thing carried out on a man just trying to get married!
Still boggles my mind how he thought walking into the consulate in the first place, was a good idea.
He came to Istanbul just for that, he wanted to go to New York embassy but told his fiancé that he wouldn't come out of there alive. he knew what was coming.
@@Celiktaban almost makes me wonder why he didn’t go to Ankara embassy or any other Saudi embassy. He chose to go to a goofy consulate, istg the Saudi consulate is the most deserted and depressing place in Istanbul, the aura that surrounds that place is in itself the epitome of evil.
he was going to get married soon and had to go into the consulate for the papers. and the first time he went there, they apparently welcomed him and treated him very kindly. that's why he thought nothing would happen.
This is called investigative journalism. Well done
Yeah but when it comes to America crimes all we hear is lies , killing if innocent ppl in the name of freedom , America is the biggest terrorist
Links connected. Great work NYT Team👏👍
The Investigation Made By Turkish Team.
@@ahmedquadri4459 its doesnt matter if its turkish or whoever, important thing is they revealed
Wow how do these people sleep at night .. I would be haunted
I guess they sleep soundly now that Khashoggi, their critic, is gone
They sleep well because the payment was big
They sleep as good as every other spy that works under every government
They're evil
lots of benzo's, and opioids...and they will have the final revenge.
Watching your channel from the Philippines 💞
The whole world knows that Saudi Crown Prince is involved and that nothing can be done.
Yeah :( all we can do is pray that Jamal rests in peace, and that those who have done this receive justice
Athear Nasery sadly they still didn’t face any justice but they will get a severe punishment from god for their horrible crime sooner or later
@@Ari-lu5ve where's the punishment & justice till today?
@@كونيمتألقة-ق9ش yup agreed
@@Ari-lu5ve hi, 2 years have gone...where's the punishment and justice from allah? lolol i am sure mbs is enjoying and relaxing comparing to most citizens throughout the covid pandemic. taking so long? so many prayers for jamal yet no results lolol
These killers committed the PERFECT Crime, it was so perfect we found out full details of what they did, the very next day, just PERFECT! NOT!
😂😂😂😂😂 dam they make our country fun to the all world
This is what happen when dady give you the power
shut up Karen
Its perfect because even with all the evidence they are still running around free 🤷♂️
@@mkviis you might be too young to be on the Internet man
@@Silverado-pq6xe I’m an adult
By the way, great reporting and analysis. Keep making these type of videos. Keep pushing the truth out! Awesome work ladies and gentlemen.
Thanks Matt. Some tips on how to follow our Visual Investigations. twitter.com/malachybrowne/status/1063812783383420928
I feel his remains have either been dissolve in acid inside the consul’s house, or have either been transported inside luggage carried by diplomatic personnel before being dropped from a privet plane
MBS still has his Decap Hand!!!
Well done Malachy Browne and NYT revealing the truth with such incredible reporting.
Very impressive investigative journalism.. Top notch i would rather say.👍
King Fantastic actually that is the Turkish government investigation even they said that in the report
Es resheoidophom
Excellent journalism and also excellent investigation by Turkey.
How inhuman it is 😭 how low people can go just for the sake of power and money, Rest in peace Jamal khashoggi.
This life is so weird, He was trying to build a new life , but they took his life.
توكل يا اهبل
Can we just appreciate how freaking amazing The New York Times are at investigating?! Like wow the attention to detail and the journalism *chef’s kiss*.
The investigation was actually done by the turkish authorities not the NY times. NY times just translated it and published it.
@@Rosie_88 Lets just say both of the orginizations put in effort to investigate that man's death
I have always wondered as I unfortunately continue to do so because as far as I know society still does not know where his remains are. How is it that all this time could have gone by without finally learning how his body was disposed of? This case makes me so sad, it's so tragic, it's just disgusting. And so deplorable as to what a government can do and get away with.
probably been put in acid or burned the remains and tossed somewhere since his body was cut into pieces
His body is turned into nothing. Basically there is no body anymore.
they dismembered him, and I'm pretty sure they'd have no reason to keep the remains. probably incinerated.
Wow NYT should ditch the paper and stick only to UA-cam- this is fantastic video.
Justice will never be served- MONEY RULES...........SAD
Free Speech It will. Allah promises that no soul shall be treated unjustly. Even if it was a weight of a mustard seed. Quran 21:47
so sad how they gutted him like an animal while his gf was waiting for him
@Mr Cabot haha naa shes a turkish Citizen they Would never dare to mess with That ,
Fiancee not gf
All he wanted was to get married
The truth is revealed here.
It was a great touch to sparsely scatter tidbits of Khashoggis life and future with fiancée. Really hits home the horror of it all
This Irishman really does some fabulous reporting
His soft republic of Ireland accent is unmistakable
What a mind blowing investigation. Kudos to the team. Keep up the fantastic work and bring out the truth from such conspiracies that affect the innocents.
That last walk, hand in hands, strolling down the road to death. That, moment of love entered into moment of death swiftly, leaving behind half of his love in excruciating emotional pain. They will get united, but what about the impunity with which he had been whacked into pieces? The truth is, it is one incident that has been brought into light. Ruthless dictators have been killing people with dissent the same way.
My heart goes out for his fiance waiting outside counselate till the day end when he didn't appear. What would have been her feelings at that time.
Your lovely work seems almost impossible! How are you guys this genius! Please never stop your visual investigations! I love and follow them all the time.
15 people was behind 9/1, 15 people was behind the Jamal Khasoggi murder .
....You CANNOT have the 3rd Temple without the Anti-Christ, and you CANNOT have the Anti-Christ without the 3rd Temple! 2nd Thessalonians 2:1- 12 says; "Now, brethren, concerning the coming of our Lord Jesus Christ and our gathering together to Him, we ask you, 2not to be soon shaken in mind or troubled, either by spirit or by word or by letter, as if from us, as though the day of Christ had come. 3Let no one deceive you by any means; for that Day will not come unless the falling away comes first, and the man of sin is revealed, the son of perdition, 4who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped, so that he sits as God in the temple of God, showing himself that he is God....... 6And now you know what is restraining, that he may be revealed in his own time. 7For the mystery of lawlessness is already at work; only He who now restrains will do so until He is taken out of the way. 8And then the lawless one will be revealed, whom the Lord will consume with the breath of His mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming. 9The coming of the lawless one is according to the working of Satan, with all power, signs, and lying wonders, 10and with all unrighteous deception among those who perish, because they did not receive the love of the truth, that they might be saved. 11And for this reason God will send them strong delusion, that they should believe the lie, 12that they all may be condemned who did not believe the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness." (The Holy Spirit is the Restrainer Paul is speaking of). Naphtali Bennett is the end time Anti-Christ whose pogrom against the Palestinians will provoke the end time war- the Egyptians will invade Palestine, be beaten back and conquered, but while Bennett is in Egypt, the Gogites, (the end time Turk led coalition) will invade Palestine from the north and east, (Daniel 11:44); occupying Jerusalem & the West Bank! Zechariah 14:1-2; '1Behold, the day of the Lord is coming, And your spoil will be divided in your midst.
2For I will gather all the nations to battle against Jerusalem; The city shall be taken, The houses rifled,
And the women ravished. Half of the city shall go into captivity, But the remnant of the people shall not be cut off from the city.' The Anti-Christ will then return from Egypt to nuke the Gogites; per Zechariah 14:12; "And this shall be the plague with which the Lord will strike all the people who fought against Jerusalem:
Their flesh shall dissolve while they stand on their feet, Their eyes shall dissolve in their sockets,
And their tongues shall dissolve in their mouths".- per the prophets, Jerusalem will be dark at midday; (beneath the nuclear mushroom cloud! In biblical numerology 12 is the number for the church- founded on 12 apostles, & for natural Israel, from the 12 sons of Jacob. 7 represents the fulness of time- God made creation in 6 days and rested on the 7th. 7 x 12 = 84. The Zionist state was founded in 1948, and will end in 2032- 84 years later. The end time war will be in the last quarter of 2032; and Jesus will return in late November/ early December, the night after the nuclear explosion! Please share this with the world!
"...dismembered his body by listening to music."
U mean there exists a track so fire that the drop capable of cutting off limbs?
Probably old school heavy metal, only 1983-86 thrash metal could do that
@@Defender78 hahaha no.
Horrifying, and yet I bet stuff like this happens all the time...
Yup, the guy that dismembered the body was listening to music, so it was completely routine
@@enriktigasna The Western countries do it aswell, google CIA/MI5 and their extrajudicial killings aka murders.
It's astonishing that they actually thought they'd get away with it with all the cameras and people everywhere!??! These people have no morals!!!
This absolutely makes me lose all hope for a decent future
Excellent investigation! Want to see more of such quality journalism.
I can't believe how sloppy this job was done 😭😂
Wow! This is the best report of this case that I've seen. There is so much detail. It's so bad everyones comfortable with MBS i remember what the Americans and Brits did during the Scripal case, an attempted murder with no concrete evidence caused a massive diplomatic chaos. But the two countries ignored this. What a shame
This is the standard of investigative journalism . Kudos.
Shame on us if we stay silent about this murder 😔
خالد ههههههه
@@غليصبنرماح-غ7ل they carrying their sins on their back and sins will not leave them. Justice for journalist
Superb investigative journalism
This is terrifying and horrifying. How can these seemingly normal people abet and cover up the murder of an innocent man? How does a government have connections to all these hit men? How can we have murderers as rulers? I'm thankful the Turkish government noticed what was going on so at least we know what the Saudis did. All this for a journalist who simply told the truth.
Trump is the Saudi friends, trump did nothing. Didn't even bat an eyelash.
You can learn many things, most importantly how you can keep yourself safe, from this investigation report.
Good job The New York Times and team of Malachy Browne. You guys did a Sherlock job.
These documentaries are soo well made! I am very impressed. Good job!
Fantastic job here! I hope Jamal truly receives justice ✝️
Seems far away....
HEY DONT TALK ABOUT TRUMPS FRIENDS THE SAUDIS LIKE THAT......
The chemist was probably there to dissolve his remains with solvents
SoupyAttorney he was already gone
no doubt
#facts ✅ That's that #stormwatermanagement type of behavior 🌪️🌀🌊
@Charlie K Hydrochloric acid is best 💯
Poor poor man just think of the terror he felt when he realized what was about to happen soon after he entered the building. I’m sure he was expecting something sinister to happen even though he was treated in a ‘friendly’ manner the last time he was at the embassy. So it was very brave of him to go inside the building and do what he thought he had to do.
Brave? That word is so often misused.
He couldnt know what was going to happen to him nobody thinks going embassy will get u choked and cut in pieces
"brave". He didn't know, he had gone to Saudi Embassy's many times before, in the UK and Turkey. They only reason he was killed is because of the spy.
That's some nice research my brother
you guys do amazing work!
Feel like, I am a part of this intelligence report!
Great job NYT!
Where does all of the CCTV footage for something like this come from. I am so impressed with these videos and the amount of detail that they contain. Amazing
Turkish state media was very closely connected to the Turkish investigators who gathered lots of the visual evidence and leaked it. We were able to confirm it using our sources and by finding social media profiles, phone numbers, passport numbers and older photos and videos of some of the hit men. For the autopsy expert, Salah al Tubaigy, we found an email address connected to his Twitter and LinkedIn profiles - the email led us to academic papers, conferences, committees he sits on, an overseas placement at an Australian forensics group. Maher Mutreb: we confirmed his details through national security reporting in the US, diplomatic sources in the UK, finding sources who knew him and could identify him, and by verifying his phone number and passport information. The body double we verified through biographical details on LinkedIn and photos on his Facebook account and other accounts (he has a very distinctive ear and nose!). And our reporters in France found other sources who worked with the Saudi royals and recognized some of the men. We also checked flight records to double check the entry times and passport checks that the Turkish officials released. So it was a combination of verifying those leaks, finding out who these men were, what their ties to the Saudi Crown Prince were and reconstructing their movements. Our graphics reporter Anjali Singhvi also obtained pictures inside the Consulate to model its interior, and using reporting from our Istanbul and Beirut teams, we could show where certain events happened. We are sitting on much more reporting that either we couldn't completely verify or which wasn't essential to the video piece, so we held back for clarity and accuracy. Reporting by the Washington Post and CNN also helped corroborate some of the reporting we were sitting on. www.nytimes.com/2018/10/16/world/middleeast/khashoggi-saudi-prince.html
My, my... so civilized people, so civilized... Outstanding investigative report by the NYT btw
Thanks for the brief information.. Subscribed
Thanks Savya