Honestly, even though I don't like Emily's attitude, I completely understand her anger here. They were so quick to the gun instead of looking in the book in the first place, especially when Ashley was screaming for her to basically kill herself by going back into the lodge.
I like how Chris' way to contribute was telling them he knows how the Wendigo works, despite him JUST coming in contact with one. Then he proceeds to let Ashley get slapped and just reaches hand out like "Oh no...don't do that." I swear, Chris and Ashley are perfect for each other, perfect wimps.
+Elliot4 0 4 yes but Sam I the opportunity to kill Mike Ashley and Emily if you choose to run for the switch Early but Ashley does one think by freezing and not opening the door she did not tell Mike to shoot Emily she was scared a lot people would be it happens jezz
Also like JESUS, let alone being threatened by a gun, can you IMAGINE the internal stress of thinking you are actively turning into one of those monsters? Girl was probably LOSING it internally, a slap is a perfectly acceptable reaction.
Emily is that one character that grew on everyone which is so deserved. She's went against wendigoes by herself without knowing what they were AND was held at gunpoint by her own friends. She's an icon, she's a legend and she IS the moment
@@RitsuSakuma69 Sam and Emily are the best characters Even though some stuff too the scale aka Emily laughing at Hannah when the prank happened And Sam tried to help aka warn Hannah They both queens 👑
Whether you liked or hated Emily or Ashley, I've gotta side with Emily here. Ashley had that slap coming. And before anyone says "But they didn't know the bite was infectious!!" I call bullshit on this option to shoot Emily because of that. The miner Chris met, the one who TOLD the gang about the wendigos even existed, EXPLICITLY said that the only way you can turn into one was if you consumed human flesh on the mountains. Ashley and Mike were the ones who jumped to the conclusion that the wendigo bite had zombie level effects without consulting the journal. Again which would have confirmed that the bite was not infectious even if they weren't listening to the miner, which they clearly weren't.
They jump into conclusions, Emily was upset about it, she gave Ashley a slap and I don't think there are sides in this situation. After she was slapped, Ashley just said sorry because she knew deserved
Ashley didn't beg for Mike to shoot her, nor did she tell him to. As you should know, Ashley is not the type to think Rationally in tense situations. She can barely pay attention. And even though Emily could have been shot, Ashley was held at gun point not to mention tied to a chair.
Yep, she stopped as if to think "Did I do the right thing, did she deserve it?" - 30 seconds later "Well, she didn't stop Mike from trying to shoot me...All's fair in war"
people who don't agree that the slap is well-deserved don't know how really terrifying it is to have a gun aimed at you even if you're the manliest man in all of manhood.
Well considering that a little while back, Ashley also potentially had a gun aimed at her while being tied to a chair, _and_ potentially had that gun *fired* at her, I don't think Emily would have been any more scared during this moment than Ashley would have been.
Yea, but there wasn't a second person next to Chris telling him to kill Ashley or telling Ashley she should basically go kill herself in order to save Chris. Not to mention the fact that if you made Chris shoot Ashley, she basically kills Chris later on. What I'm saying is Ashley is a mistake and should always die.
@Jen Ngo I do agree with everything you said. My point was that Emily wouldn't have been any more scared than Ashley was at the moment. Emily and Ashley were both scared, but for different reasons. Emily was scared of almost being shot (something Ashley already faced in Josh's second saw trap), while Ashley was scared of the possibility of Emily turning into a Wendigo and killing them all. While she was in the wrong, in the heat of the moment, she didn't know. It was at the very least, understandable that she'd react in such a way. Emily's anger is justified, but I feel it should have been directed more at Mike, the person who was _actually_ about to shoot her. Had the roles been reversed, I feel like Emily would've reacted the same way as Ashley or worse (since she's more aggressive while Ashley's more passive).
not to Ashley she could slap Mike Ashley did not have the gun Ashley just did not want Emily in the safe place if she turned I bet you do the same thing omg she bit she has to go
James Gemsss Bloodison But when they discovered the thing, Mike wasn't there! She was encouraging him! (And yes, by enguoraging doesn't have to mean you actually tell them "yes do it")
+Li Quanzhe is precious go vote for him she just said leave get out like Sam said she was scared and the fact Emily thinks she the only one that scared I sorry but slapping someone in this situation kinda yum were getting haunted Ill confront the latter type situation because honestly they need to work together to survive but yea why didn't she slap Mike after meeting up with him huh are chris for not even doing nothing but stand there while Mike had the gun any of them could take the gun away and be like shut up Mike
Ashley brought attention to the bite, convinced Mike that Emily was infected, which lead to the scene. Ashley wasn't opposed to Mike shooting Emily either. She pretty much lead to Emily even having a gun pointed at her and being frightened enough that she, Emily, an incredibly confident and intelligent woman who other than Sam and somewhat Matt, has been fairly composed compared to the others, was cowering against the wall in fear of her friend and ex-boyfriend shooting her. Imagine finding out something that terrifying and traumatizing was literally for nothing and could have been avoided, and the girl that pretty much initiated it is trying to justify nearly killing you. She's perfectly justified. She was literally almost murdered over an assumption, and can be if you wanna shoot her.
xSPiDERaY Ashley was opposed to Mike shooting Emily, though. At least as far as I remember, if you do shoot her, Ashley's relationship with Mike immediately drops to zero. So yeah, she was unreasonable and annoying in that scene, but she didn't want Emily dead. And Ashley does enough shit herself, let's not blame her for Mike's choices on top of that xD
Markiplier continually says about how much he likes Ashley, but you can see how she can easily leave her friends to die. She even lets Chris die to wendigos because she doesn't want to open the lodge door even though he's begging- before being ripped apart lol. I think Markiplier's hate for Emily combined with his love for Ashley made him blind to the fact that Emily's slap was completely justified. Anyways, stan Emily
Chris drops to nothing once he survives the outside chase because so many people are expected to die there. As much as I love this game, it never lived up to its tagline of so many choices. The game is extremely linear and forced. Most decisions come to nothing and things start feeling extra like Chris does here.
While I like Ashley, that slap was completely deserved. She almost egged on her friends into ostracizing a friend and sending her to her death or shooting her. This was the one moment that I thought the person she was mean to actually sorta earned it. The ONLY moment.
@@Yormiyaaa Ashley didn't kill or hurt Emily. She made a mistake and jumped to conclusions which caused panic, but it was _not_ her intention to have Emily killed. Her relationship with Mike drops to *zero* if he shoots Emily. Ashley just wanted her separated from them, which is why I feel Emily was taking her anger out on the wrong person.
@@AA_360 she didn't just jump do conclusion but she was really dumb. Literally few moments before that scene, the flamethrower dude told them that you transform into a wendigo if you do acts of cannibalism on the mountain. She wasn't listening and almost killed someone out of her dumbness.
@@domix1973 The reason people are giving Ashley shit is because she draws attention to the bite and egged on Mike in her paranoia. He was originally going to just leave and get the cable car key back from Josh. Not saying Mike is blameless in the situation but if Ashley didn't spiral into panic mode *again* ,and she does that frequently throughout the game, then Mike probably would've just left and never pull a gun on Emily.
@@domix1973 Bruh Ashley was literally encouraging Mike to shoot her and shit she also kept pushing Em to gtfo while its obvious the outside was full of wendigos,it's suicide.Basically wanted Em dead just because of her ignorant behaviour which can be prevented if she actually pays attention and stops whining for once.Nothing but an indiscriminate useless bitch.The hate is deserved.
She’s got horrible attitude but I gotta give her props for being the smartest and resourceful out of all of them. Her sequence on the mines as she was being chased by a Wendigo is badass (assuming you hit the right buttons).
+Crazy Guy and your going to be a useless bitch in this type situation to you don't look like you can Handel your self honestly no one could if there a good dam windego after you
James Gemsss Bloodison First: Spelling, please check it before you write. Second: I’ve seen you defend Ashley so much with the excuse of what an actual person would do. This particular person literally said they know they would be useless but wish they could be like Emily. People know what they would do and know what’s right. Ashley granted wasn’t the one to hold up the gun but encouraged him to shoot her before anyone looked in the damn book. I don’t give a flying fuck about her feelings, she could have actually helped someone get killed. Edit: Sorry this is so long but seeing you defend her for this is so annoying.
Lmfao people in the comments defending Ashley as if she didn't have this coming. She literally begs Chris to shoot her, then purposely lets him die if he does try to.
The people defending Ashley are just blinded by their dislike for Emily. And everyone should know Ashley knew she deserved the slap because she did put her life in danger
Ashley starts acting freaky and I like how some youtubers noticed that. Its obvious that she and Mike deserve a slap cuz they almost kill sb recklessly. Emily is rude but she's so damn smooth to survive and she called the investigators. She's the MVP along with Sam and Mike.
@@Iam29941 this argument is not gonna help Emily, if Mike shot her. She died basically for nothing, just because her friends were so paranoid. Sure, remorse is the good thing, but it's not gonna change anything.
who aim the gun? ash is just frightened the 2 others have a problem too if they let him shoot em in the face not only ash. the problem is mike after he did what he did he go by himself only to go back instead while they can just wait until dawn and how tf did Hannah starved when the gang literally circle the lodged>mines in not even a day only hours.
The flamethrower dude literally told them, “should anyone resort to cannibalism on this mountain, the spirit of the wendigo shall be unleashed”. That means, becoming a cannibal is the only way to turn into one of them! Mike and Ashley are honestly two of the, if not THE, dumbest characters in the game.
ashley was the most annoying character in this game. i mean she lets chris die by the wendigo if you chose to shoot her like wtf. i don't care if emily has an attitude, ashley deserved this slap.
That's basically saying Ashley didnt deserve to be a bitch but it doesnt matter if Emilys one. Whats more Emilys a bitch the whole game, while Ashley just has bitchy moments that are few and far between. In this specific scene, Emily was right to be angry, but imo she's by far the most annoying character in the Until Dawn
@@bluebay1031 lmao "bouhouu Emily had bad manners the whole game and Ashley only twice 😭😭... okay she kills someone and contributes to someone else's death but damn it's ONLY a few 😭"
I don't care how "traumatized" Ashley was, she's the type to lead a "burn the witch" parade and then apologize when she realizes the witch wasn't a witch. I'm glad her goofy ass got slapped. She is literally the least helpful person in this game.
I love what the game did with the “confess” option. The camera angle is different, you see Emily’s corpse in clear view-a pure realization of what you’ve done. I think it’s genius
I completely agree that Emily's anger was justified in this situation. Having a gun pointed right towards your face is really scary. What I never really understood though was why so many people seem to blame this entire situation on Ashley. I can understand why some people don't like her, she might get on some people's nerves and I get it, but I don't think the slap was entirely deserved. If anyone deserved that slap, it was Mike. Emily only took it out on Ashley because Mike was gone. Ashley was the one who noticed the bite, and yes, she wanted Emily out of the room. But so did Mike. And so did Chris ("I've seen what these f**kers can do. I don't want to see it again.") Ashley never wanted Mike to shoot Emily. And if Mike does shoot her, Ashley's relationship with him drops to zero. Ashley only wanted what everyone else in the room wanted (apart from Sam). The only thing Ashley did was notice the bite first, but from then on Mike became the driving force behind the whole situation and he can literally kill Emily at the end of it, yet people don't seem to be mad at him at all and he remains the fan favorite. I am not saying Ashley's actions are completely justified here. I am just trying to say I don't really understand why Ashley alone is blamed and villainized when she, Chris, and Mike shared the same exact opinion on the matter.
Because he's a dude and some men just get away with anything. And Ashley is (among other things) an anxious and somewhat impulsive character who makes questionable decisions without taking the time to think them through. She is "annoying and weak". But that just makes her realistic imo. I for one wouldn't have been mentally stable in those circumstances either. The hate she gets kinda disturbs me.
If Chris survived, he's the biggest asshole in the room because he wanted her dead when he knows fully that the only way to turn into one is to cannibalize
Sorry I'm late, but you're right, and I was wrongfully mad at Ashley, cause it wasn't her fault entirely, like while she was part of the problem wanting Emily to leave, Mike was the main problem with the fact he can literally kill Emily, so yeah, I can see where you're coming from most definitely.
But she is still an ass can u imagine she’s over telling someone to shoot someone else and if Chris actually did she leaves him to die later on in the story like what
In a real life situation would you immediately shoot a friend? Let alone someone you loved before? (as Mike) Regardless if Emily is a bitch or not, you really shouldn't be killing someone just because of an accusation. And just because she is mean, doesn't mean she deserves to die. (I know this is just a game but imagine this kind of situation in real life with your good friends)
Yeah but everyone is not really sure how the bite works. Sam opened the idea that maybe it's just a bite. Would you not consider that possibility and immediately shoot? Anyway, I hope you don't think Im too serious about this xD I just love the discussion :3
+blazingscore004 Yeah I agree. Emily is easily my least favorite character but Mike was out of line here. He could have restrained Emily in a chair or forced her out of the room or something.
Emily just had her ex boyfriend point a gun at her; intent to kill her. She’s freaking out that she could very well turn into the monster that had chased her. And Ashley decided to reassure her after encouraging shooting her. Emily deserved to slap Ashley. She was forced at death’s door
Emily is actually my most favorite character, even if she's a bitch sometimes, she's the smartest and most rational and this slap was really satisfying.
Coming from someone who hated Emily from the beginning and gladly had Matt abandon her, I am completely with her on this one. It was totally ridiculous from the start that shooting her was an actual option! Her reaction was totally understandable. I dont approve of course but Ashley had it coming
Emily is my favorite character. I don't care that she is bitchy. She is smart and athletic us fuck. Reason that they live, is Em. (Because of what hepened in the fire tower). Also she's such a badass, she survived wendigo attacks. Even flamethrower guy died running away from that creature. I love her
Exactly, people give Ashley way too much credit here, the entire game she's whining and crying and doesn't help out at all. She even lets Chris die if Chris chooses to shoot Ashley, despite Ashley saying for Chris to shoot her. Plus Ashley literally encourages for Mike to shoot Emily, without even reading the book first that has a ton of information about the Wendigo.
I don't know, Emily is smart and gets credit for saving them, but Stranger's death is just bad writing. I wouldn't say that she's my least favorite, my least favorite is Jess or Matt because neither of them have a satisfying character arc. My favorite characters are Josh, because he is the best written character in the game, Ashley is a scaredy cat but still pretty realistic and a caring person overall. Yes, she can leave the door closed for Chris, but the developers have explained why this happened and my favorite is Chris, overall a nice character, but is not as complex of a character as Josh, but not as bad as Sam, Mike and Matt, whose charactet arcs are either non-existent or way too radical.
i have always sided with emily on this, while her attitude was not always the best, she was overall an okay person. yes, she had her faults, but who in the group didn't? she had a gun aimed at her face, and people screaming to get her killed, it doesn't matter how tough you think someone is: that crap is terrifying, she had the right to be mad, and the slap was well-deserved. ashley and mike were unsure, but look at how sam reacted, she wasn't sure and yet wasn't siding with getting emily killed, that shows some understanding. at most, they could have kept her secluded in a side of the room, maybe even outside in a safe space since the "transformation," also takes a couple of days to take effect.
I think also keeping in mind that she was just overall pissed since the beginning considering her “best friend” Jessica was literally dating her ex Mike when not even at least a year after she broke up with him passed, id have a bltchy attitude too. She’s a badass who honestly saved everyone and we really don’t know enough about outside of this to understand the reason she’s the way she is.
XFlamingAshesX Agree with you. But remeber that Josh was given wrong pills for another mental illness that he had! (That means his mental illness wasn't "controlled"). So he is a little 'justified'.
XFlamingAshesX this is why a used " ' " with justified!^^ But when you have a mental illness (that is really severe) you would never think straight! Especially when they gave him the wrong medicines!^^ Dr. Hill (from what we see in the game) wasn't a good psychiatrist, just look how he responded (the facial expressions etc) to us 'players'. He never was calm. That also made Josh be scared by him.^^ (This is just my point of view (??), but there is no way that I'm trying to justify his intentions to the others characters ^^)
@Alejandra Jess, Emily and Mike all have high bravery meters, Ashley has one of the *lowest* bravery meters in the game. That's _literally_ the cliché her character is built off of. She's fragile and a lot more scared than the others, it's pretty obvious. Some people genuinely can't handle these sort of terrifying situations and you know it. Different people handle scary / traumatic experiences differently. Just because the others could keep it together doesn't mean Ashley has to be able to. She's just not as mentally strong. Keep in mind that she's also unstable and very anxious.
@@AA_360 As much as one knows the reasons why Ashley acts in a certain way, that does not change the reality that she is one of the most useless characters in the game. One can understand why, but that does not mean that she dislikes you less. That's the facts.
i dont understand why everyone hates emily, she’s brave, useful and she can take care of herself (unlike ashley). em is my number one 🤠 edit: glad to see so many people agree :)
For real if it wasn't for Emily calling for help at the radio tower and surviving in the mines like a badass and learning about the wendiogos the group wouldn't have been saved. They owe Emily their lives. Unlike Ashley whose utterly useless.
I was sooooo satisfied when this happened! Ever since Ashley let Chris die in my game, I despised her! She begged me to shoot her instead of Chris so I panicked and shot her and...yeah. Chris was one of my favorite people! THEN she blindly demands for Emily to basically die! She is a stone hearted sociopath. I wanted revenge so badly.... That slap was from both Emily AND me.
With the whole Chris thing, there is literally a guidance totem that shows Chris putting the gun down (meaning not shooting either of them). Shooting Ashley is _very_ out of character for Chris. If you didn't notice, Chris also repeatedly told Ashley that he wouldn't let her die. Ashley letting Chris die is essentially the game getting back at you for being selfish and not playing like the character. As for Emily, Ashley did _not_ demand for her to be killed. She simply wanted her out of the room. Mike was the _only_ one who outright tried to kill her. If Mike shoots Emily, Ashley's relationship with him drops to ZERO so no, she did not want Emily killed, she just wanted her to be separated from the rest of them.
Chris dying for shooting her is a direct punishment for trying to play him out of character, he says countless times he would never do anything to Ashley, and there's literally a totem showing you to shoot yourself, Ashley was testing Chris to see how far he would go for her
I appreciate that some of the smarter players were concerned about them leaving the gun. Those guys are the ones who will survive a life or death situation in real life.
They need a bonus scene of the characters reunited after the police interviews. Emily really should slap Mike for actually pointing the gun at her & I’m sure Matt would have something to say about that as well.
How do people to comprehend that Ashley was literally egging mike on and the then he ended up pointing a gun at her, like imagine your ex threatening to shoot you oml. Ash deserved the slap so much
Emily is my fave character purely for this line it's so good I keep her alive till this moment just to hear it😂. My mum was in the room when I played the scene and just said "fair enough I would do the same"😂😂
Everyone saying "Oh Emily is such a bitch" like they wouldn't do worse if one of their trusted friends almost got them shot/killed and was willingly going to let it happen. She almost egged on her friends into ostracizing her friend and sending her to her death BEFORE even reading the book to see if it was justified!! That slap was well deserved, heck had Emily punched or even Crocop'd her, it would have been justified as well.
Yeah, like you can't defend Ashley at all in this situation, she literally encouraged Mike to shoot Emily, without even reading the book first that has a ton of information about the Wendigo. You can't even say Ash was scared in this moment, because first, Emily was the one with a gun pointed at her, and second, even if you are scared, you shouldn't be going around encouraging someone to shoot someone else.
It's actually really stupid. Ashley messed up big time, but between Mike (the one who actually wanted to shoot Emily), Chris and herself, Ashley is the only one to actually apologise and show remorse. Mike and Chris are neither called out by Emily, nor do they feel the need to own up and say "yeah, it's on us too, sorry Emily". The way Chris is depicted as a character, he should have stepped up and apologised to Emily as well. Of course, the reason why he barely reacts is because there are versions of this scene in which he's already dead and absent, so the developers made his role smaller for convenience's sake.
Bc in general Mike is a more likeable and selfless character. So part of it stems from overall distaste for Ashley. And Ashley did side with Mike and tried getting Emily kicked out which I would say did egg mile on. But yea Mike is a dick tbh
Ashley was creating hysteria. If someone had tried to intervene to protect Emily, Mike would have injured them. Put the whole damn group in danger. Ashley had that dlsp coming.
I know that this game us old but can we pay attention to the fact that Ashley doesn't decide to look at the journal until after emily almost gets shot, also for everyone saying that Ashley didn't exactly say that she wanted Emily shot, she literally doesn't care to try and hear Emily out and insists on her leaving (which is basically death for Emily)
Unlike a lot of people who didn’t play the game and feel their heart pounding... I did. And I felt like it was an understandable gesture from her to be mad at the person who egged on the guy who almost shot her instead of looking in the book first.
i knew the most of the people would say "take the fucking gun" or something, cause i mean HELOOOOOOOO THE MOST SMART CHOICE THAT THIS GAME COULDA LET 1. cause of the action 2. not fucking dying
While I don't like Emily's attitude, at least she's real. Ashley genuinely annoyed me in the game and felt so fake and "pick me" like. The slap was well-deserved. Emily was scared that she was going to be turned into a monster and then had her boyfriend point a gun at her. Ashley basically was telling Emily to off herself when suggesting she go back to the cabin. Not only that, but the "stranger" told them all exactly how a person becomes a wendigo, by consuming human flesh on the mountain. Matt and Ashley just assumed a bite had zombie level effects and ran with it.
Emily: the reason for panic Mike: calm but sounds like he would lose his cool at any moment Ashley: literally freaking out Sam: the only one keeping her cool Chris: the silent ninja
If you think about it, given the right circumstances, Ashley get directly cause Chris' death by letting him get killed by the wendigos, and indirectly cause Emily's death if she's bitten and Mike shoots her.
Emily is most awesome of all characters imo, outside of Mike she dealt with the hardest night... ohh and nichole bloom ( her voice actor ) is a real stunner 🥰
You hv no idea how many times I replayed that scene, it was SO satisfying watching Ashley get slap like that, she was of no use at all to anyone one or anything in this entire game.
This scene is honestly impressive just because of how polarized the community is about it, some people say Ashley did nothing wrong and others say Emily was completely justified to do what she did. That is how you can tell a game has good characters when hatred for a character isn't universal.
I do understand why Ashly was horrified, I mean if someone I knew was bitten I'd probably be afraid. But I definitely wouldn't tell that person to die. I empathize with Ashly, but she definitely deserved that slap.
I think I understand both sides to this. If the bite was infectious and they decided not to shoot only to have her turn, people would get mad at how dumb they are cuz like zombie bites
Lmao I know this is 5 years old, but why was THAT Mark's reaction cmonnn 💀 like yeah, like Emily or not, that slap was 100% justified. She had a gun pointed at her head dude! And Ashley was literally egging Mike on 💀
If that was me getting slapped, the second the slap connected with my face I'd do a full 360 no scope retaliation move so dam fast it'd make her rethink her life decisions 🤣🤣🤣
Honestly, even though I don't like Emily's attitude, I completely understand her anger here. They were so quick to the gun instead of looking in the book in the first place, especially when Ashley was screaming for her to basically kill herself by going back into the lodge.
I like how Chris' way to contribute was telling them he knows how the Wendigo works, despite him JUST coming in contact with one. Then he proceeds to let Ashley get slapped and just reaches hand out like "Oh no...don't do that." I swear, Chris and Ashley are perfect for each other, perfect wimps.
+Elliot4 0 4 yes but Sam I the opportunity to kill Mike Ashley and Emily if you choose to run for the switch Early but Ashley does one think by freezing and not opening the door she did not tell Mike to shoot Emily she was scared a lot people would be it happens jezz
Elliot4 0 4 Yeah. Thats why Sam is SuperBae. 😃
Slimeball In Ashley’s defense, Mike did the same thing
@@ashleyg2065 Basically everyone is an ass in the game instead of Sam, Matt & maybe Jess.
No one realizes how hurt Emily sounds when she say, "There's no excuse, there's no excuse for this."
omg i just realised that
I just realised it too. She cleaned the hurting with the slap. LMAO
Also like JESUS, let alone being threatened by a gun, can you IMAGINE the internal stress of thinking you are actively turning into one of those monsters? Girl was probably LOSING it internally, a slap is a perfectly acceptable reaction.
Her voice breaks for the first time in the game. It’s like she’s about to cry, if Ashley gave her space she wouldn’t get bitch slapped so hard lol
@@nathi060200 her voice can break before if she finds beths head or is accused of cheating by Matt
Emily is that one character that grew on everyone which is so deserved. She's went against wendigoes by herself without knowing what they were AND was held at gunpoint by her own friends. She's an icon, she's a legend and she IS the moment
*Emily was literally the best character in the game, my girl deserved a vacation after all the shit she been through! Lmao*
@@RitsuSakuma69 Sam and Emily are the best characters
Even though some stuff too the scale aka
Emily laughing at Hannah when the prank happened
And Sam tried to help aka warn Hannah
They both queens 👑
exactly like shes an icon
Speak on it!
I know the prank wasn’t right, but tf Hannah, you don’t just try to flash another girl’s guy.
Whether you liked or hated Emily or Ashley, I've gotta side with Emily here. Ashley had that slap coming. And before anyone says "But they didn't know the bite was infectious!!" I call bullshit on this option to shoot Emily because of that. The miner Chris met, the one who TOLD the gang about the wendigos even existed, EXPLICITLY said that the only way you can turn into one was if you consumed human flesh on the mountains. Ashley and Mike were the ones who jumped to the conclusion that the wendigo bite had zombie level effects without consulting the journal. Again which would have confirmed that the bite was not infectious even if they weren't listening to the miner, which they clearly weren't.
Wow, so I wasn't the only one who was thinking along those lines
They jump into conclusions, Emily was upset about it, she gave Ashley a slap and I don't think there are sides in this situation. After she was slapped, Ashley just said sorry because she knew deserved
Ashley didn't beg for Mike to shoot her, nor did she tell him to. As you should know, Ashley is not the type to think Rationally in tense situations. She can barely pay attention. And even though Emily could have been shot, Ashley was held at gun point not to mention tied to a chair.
Again, that's why I said 75:25 as opposed to 100:00
Clockwork Pixie Ashley didn’t want Emily to die but she did want her to leave. Like Sam said, she was scared. So I don’t side with Em at all
I like how Emily had that second of remorse and regret but brushed it off instantly.
Yea, she was like "shit i overdid it...but fuck it, i almost got killed!"
Yep, she stopped as if to think "Did I do the right thing, did she deserve it?" - 30 seconds later "Well, she didn't stop Mike from trying to shoot me...All's fair in war"
people who don't agree that the slap is well-deserved don't know how really terrifying it is to have a gun aimed at you even if you're the manliest man in all of manhood.
I agree whit you
same here
Well considering that a little while back, Ashley also potentially had a gun aimed at her while being tied to a chair, _and_ potentially had that gun *fired* at her, I don't think Emily would have been any more scared during this moment than Ashley would have been.
Yea, but there wasn't a second person next to Chris telling him to kill Ashley or telling Ashley she should basically go kill herself in order to save Chris. Not to mention the fact that if you made Chris shoot Ashley, she basically kills Chris later on. What I'm saying is Ashley is a mistake and should always die.
@Jen Ngo I do agree with everything you said. My point was that Emily wouldn't have been any more scared than Ashley was at the moment. Emily and Ashley were both scared, but for different reasons. Emily was scared of almost being shot (something Ashley already faced in Josh's second saw trap), while Ashley was scared of the possibility of Emily turning into a Wendigo and killing them all. While she was in the wrong, in the heat of the moment, she didn't know. It was at the very least, understandable that she'd react in such a way.
Emily's anger is justified, but I feel it should have been directed more at Mike, the person who was _actually_ about to shoot her. Had the roles been reversed, I feel like Emily would've reacted the same way as Ashley or worse (since she's more aggressive while Ashley's more passive).
That slap and that line combined was so satisfying to watch!
YES. THAT WAS THE BEST ONE LINER EVER!
Ahahaha
@@PLSSIcant understand my hand bitch
I'm so lost as to why emily is considered to be a bitch in this scene. Her life was on the line, and that slap was 100% justified.
not to Ashley she could slap Mike Ashley did not have the gun Ashley just did not want Emily in the safe place if she turned I bet you do the same thing omg she bit she has to go
James Gemsss Bloodison But when they discovered the thing, Mike wasn't there! She was encouraging him! (And yes, by enguoraging doesn't have to mean you actually tell them "yes do it")
+Li Quanzhe is precious go vote for him she just said leave get out like Sam said she was scared and the fact Emily thinks she the only one that scared I sorry but slapping someone in this situation kinda yum were getting haunted Ill confront the latter type situation because honestly they need to work together to survive but yea why didn't she slap Mike after meeting up with him huh are chris for not even doing nothing but stand there while Mike had the gun any of them could take the gun away and be like shut up Mike
Ashley brought attention to the bite, convinced Mike that Emily was infected, which lead to the scene. Ashley wasn't opposed to Mike shooting Emily either. She pretty much lead to Emily even having a gun pointed at her and being frightened enough that she, Emily, an incredibly confident and intelligent woman who other than Sam and somewhat Matt, has been fairly composed compared to the others, was cowering against the wall in fear of her friend and ex-boyfriend shooting her. Imagine finding out something that terrifying and traumatizing was literally for nothing and could have been avoided, and the girl that pretty much initiated it is trying to justify nearly killing you. She's perfectly justified. She was literally almost murdered over an assumption, and can be if you wanna shoot her.
xSPiDERaY Ashley was opposed to Mike shooting Emily, though. At least as far as I remember, if you do shoot her, Ashley's relationship with Mike immediately drops to zero. So yeah, she was unreasonable and annoying in that scene, but she didn't want Emily dead. And Ashley does enough shit herself, let's not blame her for Mike's choices on top of that xD
Markiplier continually says about how much he likes Ashley, but you can see how she can easily leave her friends to die. She even lets Chris die to wendigos because she doesn't want to open the lodge door even though he's begging- before being ripped apart lol. I think Markiplier's hate for Emily combined with his love for Ashley made him blind to the fact that Emily's slap was completely justified. Anyways, stan Emily
she did not open because of mistrust
Mark really irked me with his constant support of Ashley, she was an idiot
Yeah Mark really annoyed me there. Like how would he react in Em's position?
@@paulinasandten8538 slap mike instead?
@@coolkidbear1165 Ash pushed him to do it so she contributed
All the girls are fighting and chris is just sitting there... and he just saw his crush got slapped in the face.
Not even Chris has the balls to stand up to Emily
Probably because he can be dead in that scene already, so they let him out to not overcomplicate the script.
Chris drops to nothing once he survives the outside chase because so many people are expected to die there. As much as I love this game, it never lived up to its tagline of so many choices. The game is extremely linear and forced. Most decisions come to nothing and things start feeling extra like Chris does here.
His hand's like "hey, hey, calm down"
@@shihoblade bruh chris has the right to be that. he just saw the flamethrower dude killed yet you call him extra?
While I like Ashley, that slap was completely deserved. She almost egged on her friends into ostracizing a friend and sending her to her death or shooting her. This was the one moment that I thought the person she was mean to actually sorta earned it. The ONLY moment.
Either should emily, Ashley was encouraging her death
@Not a Witch even if they killed a person or hurt someone? just questioning
@@Yormiyaaa Ashley didn't kill or hurt Emily. She made a mistake and jumped to conclusions which caused panic, but it was _not_ her intention to have Emily killed. Her relationship with Mike drops to *zero* if he shoots Emily. Ashley just wanted her separated from them, which is why I feel Emily was taking her anger out on the wrong person.
@@AA_360 Well.. you are right but, if this is real life... some people just might jump into this scene. Well.. damn.
@@AA_360 she didn't just jump do conclusion but she was really dumb. Literally few moments before that scene, the flamethrower dude told them that you transform into a wendigo if you do acts of cannibalism on the mountain. She wasn't listening and almost killed someone out of her dumbness.
Ashley almost got this girl killed without knowing any concrete information or facts about what was going on, so that slap was VERY much deserved.
Well Mike was the one shooting and it depends all on your actions if you shot her or nah so i Dont get why everyone is hating on ash lol
@@domix1973 The reason people are giving Ashley shit is because she draws attention to the bite and egged on Mike in her paranoia. He was originally going to just leave and get the cable car key back from Josh. Not saying Mike is blameless in the situation but if Ashley didn't spiral into panic mode *again* ,and she does that frequently throughout the game, then Mike probably would've just left and never pull a gun on Emily.
@@domix1973 Bruh Ashley was literally encouraging Mike to shoot her and shit she also kept pushing Em to gtfo while its obvious the outside was full of wendigos,it's suicide.Basically wanted Em dead just because of her ignorant behaviour which can be prevented if she actually pays attention and stops whining for once.Nothing but an indiscriminate useless bitch.The hate is deserved.
@@nhatthanh4070 🤣🤣 its legit a game yall doin too much
@@domix1973 exactly so people can hate ash if they want to
She’s got horrible attitude but I gotta give her props for being the smartest and resourceful out of all of them. Her sequence on the mines as she was being chased by a Wendigo is badass (assuming you hit the right buttons).
Intelligent AND resourceful are her character traits afterall
Ashley is heaps worse than Emily. At least Emily is useful and knows how to protect herself. Ashley just cries and whines.
Hannah McBride I wish I could be as honest as you.
Me Me Big Boy we all know ashley is a useless bitch
+Hannah McBride you have no room to judge then almost everyone will cry are whine even guys who act all mucho
+Crazy Guy and your going to be a useless bitch in this type situation to you don't look like you can Handel your self honestly no one could if there a good dam windego after you
James Gemsss Bloodison First: Spelling, please check it before you write.
Second: I’ve seen you defend Ashley so much with the excuse of what an actual person would do. This particular person literally said they know they would be useless but wish they could be like Emily. People know what they would do and know what’s right. Ashley granted wasn’t the one to hold up the gun but encouraged him to shoot her before anyone looked in the damn book. I don’t give a flying fuck about her feelings, she could have actually helped someone get killed.
Edit: Sorry this is so long but seeing you defend her for this is so annoying.
Lmfao people in the comments defending Ashley as if she didn't have this coming.
She literally begs Chris to shoot her, then purposely lets him die if he does try to.
YEAH SHES A BITCH
Yeah If I was Chris right before dying I would be like, "Bitch you asked me to shoot yo ass. Now you mad at that? Yous a bitch ass nigga"
Lmfao, you're not supposed to _actually_ listen to your crazy friend in those situations.
Actually that was a script mistake
The people defending Ashley are just blinded by their dislike for Emily. And everyone should know Ashley knew she deserved the slap because she did put her life in danger
Ashley starts acting freaky and I like how some youtubers noticed that. Its obvious that she and Mike deserve a slap cuz they almost kill sb recklessly. Emily is rude but she's so damn smooth to survive and she called the investigators. She's the MVP along with Sam and Mike.
em is mah fave
I know right
Emily is a badass bitch. All Ashley do is to cry and be useless
But ashley acting freaky is also correct i mean the poor girl got the worst shit hapenning to her at josh's prank
@@Iam29941 this argument is not gonna help Emily, if Mike shot her. She died basically for nothing, just because her friends were so paranoid. Sure, remorse is the good thing, but it's not gonna change anything.
I like Ashley, but it was a well deserved slap. They could have just looked through the book but them were pretty quick to aim guns at Emily
I understand Emily's anger, but I also understand Ash's panic and irrationality in this scene...
who aim the gun? ash is just frightened the 2 others have a problem too if they let him shoot em in the face not only ash. the problem is mike after he did what he did he go by himself only to go back instead while they can just wait until dawn and how tf did Hannah starved when the gang literally circle the lodged>mines in not even a day only hours.
The flamethrower dude literally told them, “should anyone resort to cannibalism on this mountain, the spirit of the wendigo shall be unleashed”. That means, becoming a cannibal is the only way to turn into one of them! Mike and Ashley are honestly two of the, if not THE, dumbest characters in the game.
random person that’s what I’ve been saying, Ashley wasn’t even thinking properly even tho her character trait is thoughtful it doesn’t make sense…
To be fair though, she is so continually hateful to everyone you have to ask yourself would you really miss Emily if they did shoot her?
"BRING THE F*CKING GUN!!!" I always laughed at these reactions!!
The title should be *UA-camr telling to the characters to bring the gun XD
ashley was the most annoying character in this game. i mean she lets chris die by the wendigo if you chose to shoot her like wtf. i don't care if emily has an attitude, ashley deserved this slap.
That's basically saying Ashley didnt deserve to be a bitch but it doesnt matter if Emilys one. Whats more Emilys a bitch the whole game, while Ashley just has bitchy moments that are few and far between. In this specific scene, Emily was right to be angry, but imo she's by far the most annoying character in the Until Dawn
scyjynx There’s kind of a difference between being a bitch and contributing to someone’s unnecessary death.
@@bluebay1031 lmao "bouhouu Emily had bad manners the whole game and Ashley only twice 😭😭... okay she kills someone and contributes to someone else's death but damn it's ONLY a few 😭"
@@MahouShoujoAi incorrect she said she needed to leave and never stated she wanted her dead .
@@jaylanmayhew589 leaving basement would be a suicide since the outside was full of wendigos
I don't care how "traumatized" Ashley was, she's the type to lead a "burn the witch" parade and then apologize when she realizes the witch wasn't a witch. I'm glad her goofy ass got slapped. She is literally the least helpful person in this game.
Fr
In another scene if you choose to shoot her she will get Chris killed
That slap was soooo satisfying (I wish she did it to mike tho)
Yeah, he would have deserved it.
Your an idiot
agreed
Best scene ever!
Jennifer Cacal yea Emily is queen
"Understand the palm of my hand, bitch" is the best line in the game 😂😂
I love what the game did with the “confess” option. The camera angle is different, you see Emily’s corpse in clear view-a pure realization of what you’ve done. I think it’s genius
I completely agree that Emily's anger was justified in this situation. Having a gun pointed right towards your face is really scary. What I never really understood though was why so many people seem to blame this entire situation on Ashley. I can understand why some people don't like her, she might get on some people's nerves and I get it, but I don't think the slap was entirely deserved. If anyone deserved that slap, it was Mike. Emily only took it out on Ashley because Mike was gone. Ashley was the one who noticed the bite, and yes, she wanted Emily out of the room. But so did Mike. And so did Chris ("I've seen what these f**kers can do. I don't want to see it again.") Ashley never wanted Mike to shoot Emily. And if Mike does shoot her, Ashley's relationship with him drops to zero. Ashley only wanted what everyone else in the room wanted (apart from Sam). The only thing Ashley did was notice the bite first, but from then on Mike became the driving force behind the whole situation and he can literally kill Emily at the end of it, yet people don't seem to be mad at him at all and he remains the fan favorite. I am not saying Ashley's actions are completely justified here. I am just trying to say I don't really understand why Ashley alone is blamed and villainized when she, Chris, and Mike shared the same exact opinion on the matter.
Because he's a dude and some men just get away with anything. And Ashley is (among other things) an anxious and somewhat impulsive character who makes questionable decisions without taking the time to think them through. She is "annoying and weak". But that just makes her realistic imo. I for one wouldn't have been mentally stable in those circumstances either. The hate she gets kinda disturbs me.
If Chris survived, he's the biggest asshole in the room because he wanted her dead when he knows fully that the only way to turn into one is to cannibalize
We all know why. One’s a dude.
Sorry I'm late, but you're right, and I was wrongfully mad at Ashley, cause it wasn't her fault entirely, like while she was part of the problem wanting Emily to leave, Mike was the main problem with the fact he can literally kill Emily, so yeah, I can see where you're coming from most definitely.
But she is still an ass can u imagine she’s over telling someone to shoot someone else and if Chris actually did she leaves him to die later on in the story like what
As an Emily stan, this is my favorite moment in the game.
In a real life situation would you immediately shoot a friend? Let alone someone you loved before? (as Mike)
Regardless if Emily is a bitch or not, you really shouldn't be killing someone just because of an accusation.
And just because she is mean, doesn't mean she deserves to die.
(I know this is just a game but imagine this kind of situation in real life with your good friends)
blazingscore004 Agreed
You don't shoot her out of hatred you shoot out of fear.
Yeah but everyone is not really sure how the bite works. Sam opened the idea that maybe it's just a bite. Would you not consider that possibility and immediately shoot?
Anyway, I hope you don't think Im too serious about this xD
I just love the discussion :3
+blazingscore004 Yeah I agree. Emily is easily my least favorite character but Mike was out of line here. He could have restrained Emily in a chair or forced her out of the room or something.
charlie true. Tbh Ashley only wanted her out, not dead.
Mark: “DONT FORGET THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUN THE GUUN THE GU-“
Emily just had her ex boyfriend point a gun at her; intent to kill her. She’s freaking out that she could very well turn into the monster that had chased her. And Ashley decided to reassure her after encouraging shooting her.
Emily deserved to slap Ashley. She was forced at death’s door
Almost every youtuber was concerned about the gun.
Emily is actually my most favorite character, even if she's a bitch sometimes, she's the smartest and most rational and this slap was really satisfying.
Coming from someone who hated Emily from the beginning and gladly had Matt abandon her, I am completely with her on this one. It was totally ridiculous from the start that shooting her was an actual option! Her reaction was totally understandable. I dont approve of course but Ashley had it coming
Emily is my favorite character. I don't care that she is bitchy. She is smart and athletic us fuck. Reason that they live, is Em. (Because of what hepened in the fire tower). Also she's such a badass, she survived wendigo attacks. Even flamethrower guy died running away from that creature. I love her
Exactly, people give Ashley way too much credit here, the entire game she's whining and crying and doesn't help out at all. She even lets Chris die if Chris chooses to shoot Ashley, despite Ashley saying for Chris to shoot her. Plus Ashley literally encourages for Mike to shoot Emily, without even reading the book first that has a ton of information about the Wendigo.
I don't know, Emily is smart and gets credit for saving them, but Stranger's death is just bad writing. I wouldn't say that she's my least favorite, my least favorite is Jess or Matt because neither of them have a satisfying character arc. My favorite characters are Josh, because he is the best written character in the game, Ashley is a scaredy cat but still pretty realistic and a caring person overall. Yes, she can leave the door closed for Chris, but the developers have explained why this happened and my favorite is Chris, overall a nice character, but is not as complex of a character as Josh, but not as bad as Sam, Mike and Matt, whose charactet arcs are either non-existent or way too radical.
Poiised only had Ashley and Sam? He must really suck at keeping folks alive, ah?
He wanted Emily to die the ever since her first bitchy moment. He just didn't care about keeping her alive.
WillFanofMany How the fuck do you kill off Chris?
Game_Biz I know but like he's the easiest to keep alive
shumishu Chris dying is Ashley being a fucking bitch I hate her so much lmfao
LillRiceGaming Same
i have always sided with emily on this, while her attitude was not always the best, she was overall an okay person. yes, she had her faults, but who in the group didn't? she had a gun aimed at her face, and people screaming to get her killed, it doesn't matter how tough you think someone is: that crap is terrifying, she had the right to be mad, and the slap was well-deserved. ashley and mike were unsure, but look at how sam reacted, she wasn't sure and yet wasn't siding with getting emily killed, that shows some understanding. at most, they could have kept her secluded in a side of the room, maybe even outside in a safe space since the "transformation," also takes a couple of days to take effect.
I think also keeping in mind that she was just overall pissed since the beginning considering her “best friend” Jessica was literally dating her ex Mike when not even at least a year after she broke up with him passed, id have a bltchy attitude too.
She’s a badass who honestly saved everyone and we really don’t know enough about outside of this to understand the reason she’s the way she is.
Am I the only one who doesn't feel bad for Ashley? Is she only a pain in the ass to me? lol
AdamantineSierra no she one of most fakest bitch in the game.
XFlamingAshesX Agree with you. But remeber that Josh was given wrong pills for another mental illness that he had! (That means his mental illness wasn't "controlled"). So he is a little 'justified'.
XFlamingAshesX this is why a used " ' " with justified!^^ But when you have a mental illness (that is really severe) you would never think straight! Especially when they gave him the wrong medicines!^^ Dr. Hill (from what we see in the game) wasn't a good psychiatrist, just look how he responded (the facial expressions etc) to us 'players'. He never was calm. That also made Josh be scared by him.^^
(This is just my point of view (??), but there is no way that I'm trying to justify his intentions to the others characters ^^)
Storm7urk spoken like a two faced fucking Gemini
Li Quanzhe is precious go vote for him Your right, but Ashley isn’t
I like how Poiised had like every1 dead..
Awkward...
So damn funny XD
Wow ...wow
I absolutely HATED Ashley so I kinda cheered when she got slapped. She was pissing me off so much.
So glad Ashley got slapped here she is the most annoying character in Until Dawn! I was sad she couldn’t get killed off earlier in the game tbh.
Simply Alex agreed
Fix Dead by Daylight Thanks agree sam jess matt etc except ashley were useful.I mean Ashley was like "trying" to be useful by lying to everyone
Simply Alex you bitch ash was just scared
@Alejandra Jess, Emily and Mike all have high bravery meters, Ashley has one of the *lowest* bravery meters in the game. That's _literally_ the cliché her character is built off of. She's fragile and a lot more scared than the others, it's pretty obvious. Some people genuinely can't handle these sort of terrifying situations and you know it. Different people handle scary / traumatic experiences differently. Just because the others could keep it together doesn't mean Ashley has to be able to. She's just not as mentally strong. Keep in mind that she's also unstable and very anxious.
@@AA_360 As much as one knows the reasons why Ashley acts in a certain way, that does not change the reality that she is one of the most useless characters in the game. One can understand why, but that does not mean that she dislikes you less. That's the facts.
i dont understand why everyone hates emily, she’s brave, useful and she can take care of herself (unlike ashley). em is my number one 🤠
edit: glad to see so many people agree :)
For real if it wasn't for Emily calling for help at the radio tower and surviving in the mines like a badass and learning about the wendiogos the group wouldn't have been saved. They owe Emily their lives. Unlike Ashley whose utterly useless.
🙄
Zack Fair 🙄💁🏼♀️
Murat Uysal ua-cam.com/video/dz8-dx8zOxk/v-deo.html team Emily❤
For one thing they blame the prank on her. The one Jessica set up one on the beginning
I was sooooo satisfied when this happened! Ever since Ashley let Chris die in my game, I despised her! She begged me to shoot her instead of Chris so I panicked and shot her and...yeah. Chris was one of my favorite people! THEN she blindly demands for Emily to basically die! She is a stone hearted sociopath. I wanted revenge so badly.... That slap was from both Emily AND me.
With the whole Chris thing, there is literally a guidance totem that shows Chris putting the gun down (meaning not shooting either of them). Shooting Ashley is _very_ out of character for Chris. If you didn't notice, Chris also repeatedly told Ashley that he wouldn't let her die. Ashley letting Chris die is essentially the game getting back at you for being selfish and not playing like the character.
As for Emily, Ashley did _not_ demand for her to be killed. She simply wanted her out of the room. Mike was the _only_ one who outright tried to kill her. If Mike shoots Emily, Ashley's relationship with him drops to ZERO so no, she did not want Emily killed, she just wanted her to be separated from the rest of them.
U choose to shoot her idiot
Joseph Adventures you’re telling me if you were blind to this game and wanted to shoot Chris or Ashley you’d shoot Chris?
LillRiceGaming yeah
Chris dying for shooting her is a direct punishment for trying to play him out of character, he says countless times he would never do anything to Ashley, and there's literally a totem showing you to shoot yourself, Ashley was testing Chris to see how far he would go for her
I appreciate that some of the smarter players were concerned about them leaving the gun. Those guys are the ones who will survive a life or death situation in real life.
Damn the Power Puff Girls going through some drama I see.
Funny how Ash was my favorite female character at first and Em was the worst to me, now it's reversed xD
Understand the palm of my hand bitch. - Emily is now my favourite character.
I honestly didnt like Ashley she was so annoying and she couldve killed chris at one part if he tried to shoot her instead of himself
Dino Lover That's the players fault. Not Ashley's lol.
@@mandyfuckyoumircosoft2981 it's her fault. especially since she kept telling chris to shoot her so he could live. she is a hypocrite.
Plus there'd be no damage done, the gun fired blanks
I like how they all were yelling about the gun lmao😂
But Markiplier was the only one
Wait I realize some was
Best girl slaps worst girl...I've always loved that scene.
ZeldaxShadow42 Damn, You're a Masochist
ZeldaxShadow42 Emily the best girl? In what universe?
More like second-worst girl slaps worst girl.
Not a Witch lmao Hannah was an annoying bitch tbh
Sam is best girl. Just facts bro
Honestly Mike deserved that slap more than Ashley.
This took me from hating Emily to loving her.
They need a bonus scene of the characters reunited after the police interviews. Emily really should slap Mike for actually pointing the gun at her & I’m sure Matt would have something to say about that as well.
She gets back in that chair pretty fast lol
How do people to comprehend that Ashley was literally egging mike on and the then he ended up pointing a gun at her, like imagine your ex threatening to shoot you oml. Ash deserved the slap so much
Am I the only one who didnt have this scene because everyone was already dead?
NSNSNZNZJXJNSMS THIS COMMENT IS SENDING ME
Lol how would you have managed to kill Sam, Mike and Ashley? None of them had been in a life threatening situation at this point
LOL same
Yes you are
Yes Emily slay! Best character for me. Ashley is officially cancelled.
@@shobco1646 she's phillipin tho
Emily is my girl!
@@shobco1646 and you act like a racist and dumb person 🤷
Of Japanese and Irish descent, so habibi is correct
@@shobco1646 How do you act white...?
Emily is my fave character purely for this line it's so good I keep her alive till this moment just to hear it😂. My mum was in the room when I played the scene and just said "fair enough I would do the same"😂😂
She got hit really BAD
I mean if you were about to get shot wouldn’t you want the person who was really cheering for it to happen to get karma?
The most painful moment in this video isn't Emily slapping Ashley, it's them leaving the gun behind! ARGH! WHO DOES THAT! lol
Ashley is like my 2nd favorite character, but she did have that slap coming to her...
Everyone saying "Oh Emily is such a bitch" like they wouldn't do worse if one of their trusted friends almost got them shot/killed and was willingly going to let it happen. She almost egged on her friends into ostracizing her friend and sending her to her death BEFORE even reading the book to see if it was justified!!
That slap was well deserved, heck had Emily punched or even Crocop'd her, it would have been justified as well.
Vote me up if you hated Emily until this very scene...
LadyCeag840
Honestly haha.
Nah, I loved her after the mines lol
In my opinion, Emily is the only character who SHOULD die. Josh is more sympathetic than her. F*ck Emily.
I actually stopped hating Emily long before this scene, but I'll upvote you :)
Chris Schoenthaler She was smart, everyone has the right to live. (My opinion)
I love how Chris didn’t defend Ash because even he knew that the slap was deserved
Yeah, like you can't defend Ashley at all in this situation, she literally encouraged Mike to shoot Emily, without even reading the book first that has a ton of information about the Wendigo. You can't even say Ash was scared in this moment, because first, Emily was the one with a gun pointed at her, and second, even if you are scared, you shouldn't be going around encouraging someone to shoot someone else.
Well Chris try to kill em too he was on Mike and Ash side lmao
It's actually really stupid. Ashley messed up big time, but between Mike (the one who actually wanted to shoot Emily), Chris and herself, Ashley is the only one to actually apologise and show remorse. Mike and Chris are neither called out by Emily, nor do they feel the need to own up and say "yeah, it's on us too, sorry Emily".
The way Chris is depicted as a character, he should have stepped up and apologised to Emily as well. Of course, the reason why he barely reacts is because there are versions of this scene in which he's already dead and absent, so the developers made his role smaller for convenience's sake.
Love how everyone crucifies Ash more than Mike. Ash never told him to shoot her. That was all him
Bc in general Mike is a more likeable and selfless character. So part of it stems from overall distaste for Ashley. And Ashley did side with Mike and tried getting Emily kicked out which I would say did egg mile on. But yea Mike is a dick tbh
Completely justified. Ashley and Mike lost their fucking minds.
Chris doesnt care about Ashely cuz all he did was sit there and let her get slap
He did care he just obviously couldnt do anything cuz he knew emily was mad. Same with Sam. They saw it coming
That bitch deserved it
Ashley was creating hysteria. If someone had tried to intervene to protect Emily, Mike would have injured them. Put the whole damn group in danger. Ashley had that dlsp coming.
Just finished playing and found Emily slapping Ashley the most statisfying thing in the game.
I know that this game us old but can we pay attention to the fact that Ashley doesn't decide to look at the journal until after emily almost gets shot, also for everyone saying that Ashley didn't exactly say that she wanted Emily shot, she literally doesn't care to try and hear Emily out and insists on her leaving (which is basically death for Emily)
I love Chris’s reaction in the corner of just like “woah chill”
Em is totally iconic! I love her badassness
Emily: understand the palm of my hand beatch
**Emily beatch slaps Ashley**
Mike: i can still shoot you
me: so much for the *safe* room
Mike was heading back to the sanatorium at that point, he wasn't there
Exactly my thoughts when he pointed the gun at her in the first place. This is the SAFE ROOM, Mike... NOT the MURDER ROOM!
no joke the slap is the reason i got into this game, emily is just THAT iconic
Unlike a lot of people who didn’t play the game and feel their heart pounding... I did. And I felt like it was an understandable gesture from her to be mad at the person who egged on the guy who almost shot her instead of looking in the book first.
“Understand the palm of my hand bech “ 😎❤️
i knew the most of the people would say "take the fucking gun" or something, cause i mean HELOOOOOOOO THE MOST SMART CHOICE THAT THIS GAME COULDA LET
1. cause of the action
2. not fucking dying
Is nobody gonna talk about chris just sitting there just watching her girl get slapped? Lol
"her girl" omg chris is a skinny legend ok
seriously though, his*
Chris didn't even take up for Ashley. 😂
While I don't like Emily's attitude, at least she's real. Ashley genuinely annoyed me in the game and felt so fake and "pick me" like. The slap was well-deserved. Emily was scared that she was going to be turned into a monster and then had her boyfriend point a gun at her. Ashley basically was telling Emily to off herself when suggesting she go back to the cabin. Not only that, but the "stranger" told them all exactly how a person becomes a wendigo, by consuming human flesh on the mountain. Matt and Ashley just assumed a bite had zombie level effects and ran with it.
Emily: the reason for panic
Mike: calm but sounds like he would lose his cool at any moment
Ashley: literally freaking out
Sam: the only one keeping her cool
Chris: the silent ninja
lmao when it cut to poiised and you could see just emily dead in the background
If you think about it, given the right circumstances, Ashley get directly cause Chris' death by letting him get killed by the wendigos, and indirectly cause Emily's death if she's bitten and Mike shoots her.
2:22 the gun the gun the GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI GHANDI 😂
I like how chris really doesnt do anything lmao, its like hes saying "she kinda deserved that.." 🤣
I love the music that plays when she goes “I’m sorry what did you say.”
Dude if I was Chris I would’ve said something!
Emily is most awesome of all characters imo, outside of Mike she dealt with the hardest night... ohh and nichole bloom ( her voice actor ) is a real stunner 🥰
Damn, Emily slapped Ashley so hard, she reset back to Factory Settings.
You hv no idea how many times I replayed that scene, it was SO satisfying watching Ashley get slap like that, she was of no use at all to anyone one or anything in this entire game.
This scene is honestly impressive just because of how polarized the community is about it, some people say Ashley did nothing wrong and others say Emily was completely justified to do what she did. That is how you can tell a game has good characters when hatred for a character isn't universal.
"UNDERSTAND THE PALM OF MY HAND, BITCH!" BEST PHRASE OF THIS GAME!!
I do understand why Ashly was horrified, I mean if someone I knew was bitten I'd probably be afraid. But I definitely wouldn't tell that person to die. I empathize with Ashly, but she definitely deserved that slap.
she did not tell her to die
If I was in the game I would have stopped her from slapping Ashley.
"Understand the palm of my hand, bitch"
*_D E S T R O Y E D_*
I love Cory’s reaction, just shaking his head at everything lol
Don’t got time for this drama, yo
I think I understand both sides to this. If the bite was infectious and they decided not to shoot only to have her turn, people would get mad at how dumb they are cuz like zombie bites
Lmao I know this is 5 years old, but why was THAT Mark's reaction cmonnn 💀 like yeah, like Emily or not, that slap was 100% justified. She had a gun pointed at her head dude! And Ashley was literally egging Mike on 💀
You're talking about the same guy who deleted his entire save file to restart anytime time he made a mistake with Ashley, lol.
isnt his favorite ashley LOL
FR it was so weird
@@mynameiskyeei'll never understand why lol
@@menot1 i like ashley, but my favorite is sam lolol
If that was me getting slapped, the second the slap connected with my face I'd do a full 360 no scope retaliation move so dam fast it'd make her rethink her life decisions 🤣🤣🤣
she deserved it in my opinion.
are these people forgetting how sure Ashley was that Emily would turn and how hard she faught to have her thrown out. Slap well deserved
That slap though
"understand the palm of my hand" I'M SCREAMINGGGGG WE LOVE YOU EMILY