Editorial With Sujit Nair | “Will Bring Back Electoral Bonds After Wider Consultations,” Says FM
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 кві 2024
- In this episode of ‘Editorial’ Mr. Sujit Nair discusses about the statement made by the Finance Minister Of India Nirmala Sitharaman about bringing back the Electoral Bonds Scheme after wider consultations.
Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman announced that the BJP plans to reintroduce electoral bonds, in some other form, after wider consultation, if they secure victory in the Lok Sabha elections. The Supreme Court had previously deemed the scheme unconstitutional, citing concerns over transparency and the potential for quid pro quo transactions. Sitharaman noted that the government has yet to decide on pursuing a review petition against the court's decision. She emphasized the need for extensive consultations with various stakeholders to develop a framework that ensures transparency and prevents the infiltration of illicit funds.
#NirmalaSitharaman #FinanceMinister #ElectoralBonds #BharatiyaJanataParty #NDA #SurpemeCourtOfIndia #SBI #NarendraModi #QuidProQuo #PoliticalFunding #LokSabhaPolls #lokSabhaElections #CorporateFunding #HWNews
To get the latest news updates at your fingertips, download the HW News Shorts app: onelink.to/85hk86
To Join UA-cam Membership - / @hwnewsenglish
SUBSCRIBE to HW News English Here ► bit.ly/Subscribe-HWNews-English
Connect With Us On:
→ Facebook: / hwnewsenglish
→ Twitter: / hwnewsenglish
→ Instagram: / hwnewsenglish
→ Dailymotion : www.dailymotion.com/hwenglish
For More Videos Visit Here:
hwnews.in/
This is called as dictator mindset it's ridiculous
See the arrogance of this lady she doesn't eat Garlic and Onion and hence she don't know the plight of common man and still beggars are voting for them
Yes we need dictatorship for development of India
Yes bonds give shivers to corrupt who prefers cash in bags
Probably u r right. Instead of give freebies to muslims using Hindus wealth, being dictator to protect Hindus in Hindu country is far better.
How can someone be so shameless 😢
people voted for them!!! 😮. Soon EVMs will be voting.
It happens (once in a lifetime)!
Along with modi she is responsible for economic disaster.
@@giftfortoday2643 They voted, they will be voting, Even SC Judges favour EVM voting for bjp.
This is our Finance Minister. Imagine that.
Finance minister of the country. Wants to hollow out the country economy. Openly announcing. This is the horrible state of reality.
Her own husband is saying Electoral bond is world's biggest scam and this monster is saying we will bring it back.
What bring it back? No one abolished the bonds. Does she have any common sense or not?
SC only made them transparent. What bring back the bonds? Just say you will reintroduce bills to add corruption again somehow.
This is why, Her own husband is critical about her
I wonder how poor Parakalla is coping up with her.
@@santanodcosta3360 because of her, sanghies spared him
Husband critical = that is thriving democracy
Money is needed to purchase MLAs of opponents and form illegal government.
Absolutely right
Yes you are absolutely right this is how BJP run State Governments.
It basically means that the fault isn't just in bjp itself but because people are so easily corruptible and can be bought in any corner of the country and the world.
But there is another truth and that is in spite of such challenges some countries have significantly less corruption than others. And that is where we need to focus on, as a government, as a society, as a nation, as a multicultural diaspora, as one.
Illegal govt........? Congress dismissed over 50 state govts using Art 356. Khud fascist and call a noble righteous wing entity fasicist? Time for that gundadari is over. Modi 400 Paar........ Congress + only 40 paar that too only because of the Ali Baba and the Chalees...........
CJI Sir please take action on this bloody currupted Communal Sanghis
Italian Maino and son out only on bail. 😅😅
@@kurupk7742toh kya hua? What does bail mean? Do you even understand? If some women put you on a rape charge and you get bail.. does that mean what you said here? 😂 Andhbhakt.
He wrote Communal not Common.
@@kurupk7742Modi Shah are only out because they are in power. Soon they will be behind bar
@@kurupk7742if they lose elections Bill & Ranga will also join Kejri.
FM says bring back Electoral bonds. Her hubby says it's a biggest scam
That too in the world.
😂wonder how they live in the same house. 😅
This is called freedom of expression.
Husband wife fight is universal, it is true in most houses 🤣🤣
It seems somebody else is f....... Her😂😂😂😂
Totally shameless
How can this woman who is FM be so arrogant. No respect for Supreme Court, Justice system or Our Constitution. She is should be prosecuted for contempt of court n sent to jail with huge exemplary costs to set a deterrent lesson to the rest of her clans. This is truly shameless on part of a Finance Minister of India.
The whole clan (as well as their subscribers) are shameless!
totally agree l
fully agree bro
The same Kangana Ranaut who was hooting about Netaji earlier for personal political gain, she doesn't realize if he was alive, this corrupt FM would definitely be jailed no doubt.
Yes when the administration is with them, none can take action it should their mental ability as if Country is their father's property
When our Hon’ble Supreme Court declares the Electoral Bounds, our most Hon’ble Finance Minister says, she will bring it back. It’s clear that her utterances calls for contempt of Court, thereby insults the Hon’ble Supreme Court and send this lady behind the bards. Whenever this lady opens her mouth, she will come out with nonsense remark like this... craziness!!!
She should be in jail
They are the biggest shameless scoundrel...!!!
Remember what Bernadshaw said " politics is the last resort for scoundrel " They will do anything and everything. No one can catch the culprit is the moral of the story!
Patriotism is the last resort for scoundrels. In our context, deshbhakts.
If they do come back, expect more than what we've already seen and more
despite being declared unconstitutional, how they are so confident about their coming back to power before voting is completed.
Ms Nirmala Sitharaman rubbishes the views Dr Parakala Prabhakar.
Our FM is saying she ll bring back E.Bonds bez she can buy MLA and M.P from other party's to be in power .
So arrogant PM can speak like this. So also his Finance minister. Only solution, Modi hatao desh bachao. BJP hatao desh bachao.
Are these statements not undermining decisions already made by the highest court of the land.?Shocking indeed.
All these statements, proves one thing: that India is sliding down as a democracy!
‘Shameless’ is the only word to say.
They not just received 8252 crores. What about 4000 crores where donor name was not revealed?
What about PM cares, where did all that money go?
This just the tip of the iceberg!
Serious illegality in the scam is taking money through bonds from loss making co's and newly floated co's. These are clear cases of shell co's being started to launder black money stashed abroad which can be very serious as those money's could be drugs related or terrorism related etc apart from the fact these electoral bonds were used as extortion money through threats of ED, CBI ,IT raids or through sweet deals through quid-pro-quo arrangements as in the case of Megha Infrastructure being granted projects in Maharashtra & tunnel contracts in Uttarkhand etc.
Shame to anybody who cannot be honest in any way in public life
There is no question of bringing back ELECTORAL BONDS
FM is at peak of arrogance this will end soon all these bjp jokers will run away from this country.
Hopefully
Contempt of supreme court order. First book case and throw her in jail
Arrogance to the core
Shocking!! Despite the verdict & being relentlessly criticised & being called "Chanda Mama", they still want to bring back EBs. Guess this is what they meant by this was just the trailer.
Chanda mama nahi, Chanda chicha.😂😂
A very good analysis! Hope the people understand what is happening.
Mr Nair, with his quaint turns of phrase being especially endearing, is a highly intelligent, brilliantly perceptive professional who has proved he does justice to whichever hat he wears - as ad.man, political analyst, anchor or whatever.
His passion and unprompted, extempore narrations are a treat. Especially when his usual calm is breached. As today.
There can be no better or more eloquent indictment of Mr Modi and Mrs Sitharaman than Sujit Nair's sputtering, near wordless shock and dismay and.
I hope all of us who respect Mr Nair, will take his indignation to the polling booth with us, remembering too well this senior journalist's utter disbelief of how our country has been morally corrupted - deep-seated rot a hundred times worse than mere avarice.
And this is why these people simply have to go. Have to be made to go.
What aN ARROGANCE! It is a clearer indication of sanadana varna way of Governance. SHE MUST BE DISQUALIFIED AS MINISTER AND MEMBER OF RAJYA SABHA.
Everybody in the Party is arrogant. They yell on top of their voices even inside the Parliament like roadside urchins😡
Is this woman for real? SC should examine the scam under the watchful eyes of reliable judges n bring the FM and her party to book
Annamalie said he will not spend even Rs.1 for ellection. But he was caught red-handed twice. 3.99 crores was caught from one from a BJP functionary...
He will not spend, but his gang will.
Appalling statements being made everyday by the government! And the people are taking all this at face value. Is the country more important or any political party and it’s Leader!
Is it not a contempt of court
The finanace minister shouid be prosecuted for her unruly remark
FM will put Chief justice right next to Arvind Kejriwal. Tihar is going to be the greatest infrastructure spending promised.
When the political leaders become cult and messiah, such powers are bestowed by the foolish subjects of his ‘kingdom’ to reign and rule over them with greater power!
Know. what contempt of court .
How can they bring back illegal and unconstitutional articles?
I will vote for CPI
When this regime does not believe in the constitution of India...they can go against the decision of SC of this country😡..Tai is out of her senses😁
When was she in her senses??😂😂😂
How arrogant this FM. She is challanging SC.
We have seen that how opposition had been perished in parliament and nort allowed any discussion on any issue inside both houses forcefully ,politically and dictotarily. So question of wider discussion is a hoax.
She should go in for investigation on unethical many financial transfer in public domain to bring back lost political image and also take advice from his husband who is extremely vocal against electoral bond scam.Let first take him to cofidence.
Sir, first it was PM who has taken the credit of bringing illegal & unconstitutional bonds. Now, our FM joined him. Even after his husband claiming it to be world's biggest scam. Bjp has done this with 3 farm laws. Even after PM took it back the then agriculture minister said we will bring it back.
Wider consultation to figure out how to loot foolproof???
Wider consultation?? BJP?? Seriously
Wider consultation, as how can the shortcomings in the previous law of secret electoral bonds can be fixed, and it can be made more legal.😂😂 Remember how they overturned the Supreme Court's decision regarding appointment of Election Commissioner?
These days laws are enacted in Parliament with no much of debates! Then how wide consultations?
It was the Cong Left that imposed emergency and modified even preamble of constitution under dictatorial rule = 42nd Amdt Act 1976................ Fascist themselves but call others who are saintly fascist.
It was the Cong Left that imposed 42 Amdt under dictatorship of Emergency 1976. Khud fascist and call others fascist? Time for that subterfuge is over.
Yes. After suspending all opposition members. They'll have wider consultation among ruling party members.
The real question behind electoral bond relevation is why did future games (Santiago Martin) pay 1500 crores as bribe?? Where did that money come from? What did he get in return? Amazing that no journalist wants to investigate that 😄
bjp voter 😂
Unfortunate
So Arrogant as BOSS
All these fellows in the various agencies, institutions and even judiciary who have done illegal acts should be tried for anti-national activities and jailed after trial. The new government should ensure such action which will be an example to all who would venture into such activities.
@@siddhartha5875 Jhumla and ghotala Modi govt
Begging for power from foreign countries is not anti national for you.
Yeah. New Modi Govt and all the anti nationals corrupt fascist pseudo Chekular - Cong Left DK TMC SP RJD buggers behind bars. AAP di monkey already counting bars.......
@@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 truth will remain truth irrespective of from which country one is asking or telling
How do you know the person who wrote above is rom foreign country? Just by seeing the name ?
And you will tell me that I am writing from India by seeing my name ? If you think that I am writing this message from India then this is not true. I am in Germany now
Garland in the hands of monkeys.😢
What an analysis ❤
She should be made a contest for the loksabha election from the Southern part of India, after that let her give the statement..
But Modi mock Sonia as She became Rajya sabha MP but He forgot his FM didn't fray in elections what a double standard of Modi.
Jumla statement.
They need the money to upkeep with their lifestyles
First the party should return back the black money received through electoral bonds to the govt.
ECI please take action, as talk against SC is contempt and unconstitutional
The best channel ever. Thank you Sir, keep updating
Speaking against the apex body and Constitution is anti national.
Why is the body silent on manipur? Is it not Anti ?
Also why there is no tax for all this money they get as bonds? Why are we only paying tax..what a shit country we are living .
Holy Shit = Gobar (cow dung)!
Consultation? I had no idea this government knew this word. Impressed!
Electoral Bonds truly unconstitutional as said by the Chief Justice of India.
The people of India should strongly oppose reinstatement of such Electoral Bonds and the Supreme Court should take an action on such a statement of reinstatement
Remember this that every 'unconstitutional' will be legally if majority in Parliament (extreme majority). This is to think about by people of India.
DEMOCRACY IS OUR RIGHT
You will see constitutional amendment to get it done. Where is then unconstitutional.Power corrupts Absolute Power ………
This lady called Nirmala the FM in RSS/BJP government, have no good ears to listen to her husband. She is arrogant/stubborn by her nature & her husband a good understanding educated man ...
I don’t understand, how can a lady with such misdemeanour and arrogance be liked by anybody and win elections!?!
Husband Wife have different views and yet family survives.........That is Democracy THRIVING
You like open mind where Husband Wife Equal. Why should Wife only listen to Husband? After all That is Ramayana ls it not? And You hate Ramayana........ Rama tch tch tch tch LOL
when supreme Court says electoral bonds are unconstitutional, if Nirmala wants to reintroduce then it's contempt of court as of now, she must be booked and prosecuted.... 😎
When declared unconditional, why the court is silent on the amount collected? It should be returned to the donors properly through banking Channels.
Much appreciated video. You asked such a valid questions straight on the face of ruling party
The main issue is not with donations. The main issue is with how much more the donors get benefitted, either by getting public contracts, or by evading the taxes, which is much much more higher than the donations that they gave, that too all those contracts or the tax money is public money, they belong to citizens of the country.
I think social media should stop talking about electoral bonds upto the time the SC declared them to be unconstitutional, but should now discuss about what action will be taken on the unconstitutionality of the elec.bonds. Nothing seems to be done in this direction.
Not even a single mainstream media who are interviewing Modi and shah are ready to ask questions in detail on electrol bonds.
What is their to ask. SC has dismissed EBs as unconstitutional.
@@ravindranmokkilmaruthur23 regarding the extroion to comanies by our PM and HM from ED , CBI and IT
I feel that the SC went half way. If a scheme is unconstitutional, it means that it is not covered by any law in force. It is unlawful. Funds obtained by the unlawful scheme are illegal acquisition and must be frozen in the recipient account or moved to the Govt treasury. The SC allowed the political parties to retain the sums so collected. It has given an unnatural advantage to the ruling combine.
There is also the news that even after the bonds were declared unconstitutional, an inventory of bonds of about 10000 crs still existed for purchases. This is blatant.
We have added a huge number of young voters in the last ten years. All of them in the age group of 18 to 28 age group. They will decide who will rule us.
Their is a very basic principle, that is being violated through the introduction of electoral funding schemes. Can a recognized political party use any organ of the Indian State to collect money from private citizens. As elected representatives, members of a party are under a solemn oath to the Constitution. They can use party offices/ platforms to appeal for funds. So the electoral bond scheme introduced through Parliament has rightly been declared as unconstitutional/illegal by the Apex court. In a way the Finance Minister, when she endorses the scheme, with a promise to bring it back, is automatically in contempt of the apex court.
Was these answers for Mr parkala prabakar??
Contempt of court must filed!, This govt. Must be dissolved immediately by supremecourt!!! 😮😮😮
When arrogance sets in the Governance anything is possible.
Sitaraman isnt contesting elections. Kick ber out of the Parliament.
They would be back in governance, create a rule supreme court has no powers,n
Say
They needn't answer rti,
Any pm funds,
No cag, as
they have proven Ram worked, n even SC permits evm's knowing how India is bleeding to death.
Supreme Court orders are nothing for Modi Sarkar... They passed bills without holding discussions, then who is going to be their wider discussion partners..... Yes, they need money to buy MLAs and MPs ....
People are forgetting about pm care fund. Cji has not questioned about it .
Rougue!!
I don't have money to contest election....holding..पैसे की पोटली
Bag of lies!
We all are not Gujarati. Non Gujarati will fight Back. Gujarati can leave their wife and Children and say I'm connected to Almighty 😮
Arey wah, good one sujit! 👍
If U ask the finance minister of India why the prices of onion have gone up her answer is " Sorry!! I don't add onions in my food"….. thts her mindset. She is so far removed from ordinary people and their lives.
She was in Marketing so obviously only knows how to market stuff, irrespective if unconstitutional.
Nirmal sitaraman ji says openly about E Bonds, beeing our FM she is agreeing n saying " corruption will be regularised once BJP comes to ruling" is it good move?
The reason this was announced now is simply to say that, despite the declaration of the SC court decision, based on the evidence of votes, it would be stated as public’s choice..
Don’t give that chance to them
by using weapon i.e VOTE POWER 🔥🇮🇳
Very good explanation
Such an audacious statement by the finance minister
Nothing but echoing her masters voice.
She said we are against Constitution
It's simply that
The finance minister says that black money will not come through electoral bonds but will come through hawala or from under the table.
Bringing back electoral bonds again by suspending opposition party MPs? SC had struck this down comprehensively. Isn't the statement by FM contempt of court?
Rulers wanted to open a Bank parallel to Swiss Bank in the name of Electoral Bond.
Loyalty to the Constitution of India and respect to the Supreme Court's verdict have reached its lowest, evident from the statement of Finance Minister.
The accounts of political parties should be audited also and compliance reported
Should be taxed also.
She has booked her next finance ministry berth if ever they are elected again 😮
Sir, the recent move by Modi to meet young gaming streamers was such a brilliant move, everyone is praising it as a great move to promote gaming industry in India even though he did not propose anything substantial that can promote the industry. Just his presence was good enough. When I watched that I was gutted feeling it was such a huge missed opportunity for Rahul Gandhi to reach out to young first time voters. I don't understand what RG's PR team is up to but he would have been better suited than Modi at communicating with young people, talk about games, discuss ideas about promoting this industry and understand other aspects of what GenZ faces today.
Sir, I would appreciate if you did an Editorial piece on this topic.
Thank you 🙏
Thanks Sir ji
The public should revolt against electoral bonds whichever party is.
SO SHAMELESS! HOW CAN A PERSON BE....
People have to give a befitting reply for taking us citizens for a ride. If people will repeat their mistake again ignoring the dangerous facts, then whom do we blame?
Iñ our country democracy meant for political parties.
Great
These people cannot survive without corruption!!!
EAST INDIA IS BACK, LET'S BE PREPARED TO FIGHT FOR😢😢😢INDEPENDENCE, MAYBE 2047,AS PROMISED BHARAT MATA KI JAI, 🙏
Bad judgement. Giving money in hard cash which has no trail is something no law enforcer can catch. To ensure the trail of cash through Banking channels the Electoral Bonds were introduced. Now as usual after 7 long years the SC has finally woken up and declared them as illegal. How ridiculous !!!
Government used 14crs tax payers money, for printing the electrol Bonds Is this justified???
Parkala P. Sir. - Then I will call NIRMALA Gate 😬😬😬😬