What is the Optimal Price to Charge for Toilets in RCT2?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 8 вер 2024
  • Should your toilets be free? Should they cost 20 cents? In this video we take a look at what price makes you the most money.
    Deurklink's guide to shop prices: forums.openrct...
    Join my Discord server: / discord
    Follow me on Twitch: / marcelvos
    Follow me on Twitter: / marcelvos96
    My second channel: / @marcelvods2630
    OpenRCT2: openrct2.org/d...
    Outro music by Panorrrama:
    Outro Music: • RollerCoaster Tycoon g...
    Spotify: open.spotify.c...
    UA-cam: / @mengersponge

КОМЕНТАРІ • 607

  • @user-vd8uu1ef4w
    @user-vd8uu1ef4w 3 роки тому +1519

    Most unrealistic thing about RCT2 is that all customers flush after they're done

    • @BruinPhD2009
      @BruinPhD2009 3 роки тому +52

      ...and they probably don't wash their hands, either.

    • @wxl2562
      @wxl2562 3 роки тому +48

      @@TheWatchernator petition to update OpenRCT that allows vandals to break toilets when angry and need to use the bathroom. As well have clean up crew / sweepers be the ones who fix the toilets instead of mechanics.

    • @princesscadance197
      @princesscadance197 3 роки тому +10

      @@BruinPhD2009
      That’s what bothers me more than anything regarding public restrooms. Like really? You’re going to use something that everyone uses, and not wash your hands?

    • @KotoriHabane
      @KotoriHabane 3 роки тому +4

      @@princesscadance197 Exactly, ever since I was very young I always washed my hands more often than anyone else I knew, and I even had family members that pretty much never washed their hands at all(like once per week, it was horrid).

    • @StefanVeenstra
      @StefanVeenstra 3 роки тому +13

      @@princesscadance197 Public toilets are similar to prostitutes: you never know who went before.

  • @popahglo3609
    @popahglo3609 3 роки тому +1035

    Anti-clickbait, my favorite

    • @Paintplayer1
      @Paintplayer1 3 роки тому +110

      The best part is, I'll attentively watch a 12 min Marcel video but will skip the same length click bait video. Because Marcel actually makes engaging content and not just an over the top thumbnail and title. Maybe click bait producers should take note

    • @MichaelfromtheGraves
      @MichaelfromtheGraves 3 роки тому +24

      He did the same with mowing the grass. I love it.

    • @BierBart12
      @BierBart12 3 роки тому +36

      The answer is in the thumbnail/title, but you CAN watch it if you want a longer explanation
      This man goes above and beyond. Imagine if journalism could afford to do this

    • @Paintplayer1
      @Paintplayer1 3 роки тому +14

      @@BierBart12 they can afford to do it, but it would require them being forthright with their viewers and prioritizing their job of putting out information over profit from special interest groups

    • @daskampffredchen9242
      @daskampffredchen9242 3 роки тому +9

      Its just giving you the point. But then you simply wonder why and watch it to find out. Even in the mowing grass one I wanted to know if there really was no positive benefit (also learned that RCT2 deactivates the option and that it isnt an OpenRCT2 thing)

  • @reillywalker195
    @reillywalker195 3 роки тому +341

    I normally charge just $0.10 for toilets. Customers never complain about them being too expensive, but the revenues nevertheless help cover their operating costs.

    • @deathisnear2424
      @deathisnear2424 3 роки тому +57

      My friend always called that the 'Dime A Dump'.

    • @octaviacoquus8857
      @octaviacoquus8857 2 роки тому +33

      It's also a lot easier to imagine the stalls being unlocked when you put in a dime, rather than needing to have an attendant fumble about with change.

    • @Bobo-ox7fj
      @Bobo-ox7fj 10 місяців тому +1

      @@octaviacoquus8857 just use a change machine, so you can handle all the coins from other toilet-goers. Yum.

    • @octaviacoquus8857
      @octaviacoquus8857 10 місяців тому +1

      @@Bobo-ox7fj pecunia non olet

    • @Scudmaster11
      @Scudmaster11 5 місяців тому +1

      I did 1$

  • @MarkBiesheuvel
    @MarkBiesheuvel 3 роки тому +308

    Perhaps another thing to take into account is that fact that when a guest is walking to a toilet, they are not paying for more expensive rides. Therefore it might make sense to set the price to 10 cents, so they can always go right away, instead of walking to the toilet and turning around because of the high price. This way they can continue on to spend more money elsewhere.

    • @draco89123
      @draco89123 3 роки тому +52

      I just make it free, because I'm cleaning house with the priced rides. If it's park ticket only, then there's a logic to 30 cent toilets.

    • @Arjay404
      @Arjay404 3 роки тому +11

      I asked the same question. The one problem I can see with making it free or 10 cents, is that it encourages the guests to go the toilets more often which means they are not paying for rides more often. I wonder if there is a cooldown before they get the desire to go to the toilet again and if they have a memory about the price because if there is, I would say having the price be higher makes more sense as that would mean they walk to the toilets less to begin with. Also does the amount of time a guests spend in a toilet change based on how full their toilet bar is.

    • @MarkBiesheuvel
      @MarkBiesheuvel 3 роки тому +36

      @@Arjay404 Marcel said that the guests will go to the toilet if their value is above 70 wether the toilet is too expensive or not. If it is indeed that simple, I assume they would spend a lot of time unnecessarily walking over to a toilet, only to find out it's too expensive.

    • @StefanVeenstra
      @StefanVeenstra 3 роки тому +23

      Guests spend decades in your park without going home or calling in sick for work. Patience my boy, they'll pay the price eventually, and still enjoy your rides.

    • @ruediix
      @ruediix 2 роки тому +2

      20 cents gets a more than sufficient percentage.

  • @cypriencoon8744
    @cypriencoon8744 3 роки тому +58

    7:53 "I did this for all six possible toilet prices and, to get a larger sample size, I did it three times per price and then took the average." This is why I absolutely love you, Marcel

  • @warmCabin
    @warmCabin 3 роки тому +157

    8:57 So basically you're finding the optimal piss to money conversion ratio

    • @epicboomshine6595
      @epicboomshine6595 3 роки тому +22

      It’s liquid gold.

    • @gideonmele1556
      @gideonmele1556 3 роки тому +3

      They’re practically flushing their money away

    • @jacobnicola5950
      @jacobnicola5950 3 роки тому +12

      @@epicboomshine6595 literally alchemy

    • @dawndefender
      @dawndefender 3 роки тому +4

      Pecunia non olet, as the Romans used to say

    • @stuartdparnell
      @stuartdparnell 3 роки тому +2

      Add plenty of lemonade stalls and few eateries, with few toilets and you've gotten yourself a winning combo!!

  • @PTB_BE
    @PTB_BE 3 роки тому +627

    "Should your toilets be free?" Morally? Yes. But the urge to make money says max price.

    • @bultwini
      @bultwini 3 роки тому +19

      *money*

    • @NaughtyPrincessfkhandles
      @NaughtyPrincessfkhandles 3 роки тому +14

      Just change them $300 and say its the ride of the their life....... when they are about to explode

    • @michaelt5188
      @michaelt5188 3 роки тому +11

      in my RP i think of it as them paying for toilet tissue or something similar...it's not uncommon in the 3rd world for places to charge for those as the free rider dilemma hasn't really been overcome yet.

    • @daskampffredchen9242
      @daskampffredchen9242 3 роки тому +14

      @@michaelt5188 Its not only 3rd world. I went to some places in Germany that you had to pay for the toilet

    • @hellatze
      @hellatze 3 роки тому +4

      so you want to piss ?
      chose: grass or toilet.

  • @Zander10102
    @Zander10102 3 роки тому +36

    I just realized this. The guests are paying you to extract their urine. This video is a guide on how to maximize the amount of money you make per liter. Awesome.

  • @EchoingRuby
    @EchoingRuby 3 роки тому +36

    God that park at 4:40 is so beautiful, I thought someone had modded in a shader for a second.

  • @rjhelms
    @rjhelms 3 роки тому +110

    I'm pretty sure we studied this in 4th year microeconomics.

  • @erik060208
    @erik060208 3 роки тому +318

    Marcel, you mentioned to put Deurklink's guide to shop prices in the description, but I think you forgot

    • @MarcelVos
      @MarcelVos  3 роки тому +293

      My bad, fixed it. The first few minutes of the video are oddly relevant now lol.

  • @StefanVeenstra
    @StefanVeenstra 3 роки тому +127

    100% of guests will pay that 60 cents if you wait long enough. (And place more food and drink stalls)
    I have not yet been able to add a functional photo section to the toilet in Openrct2, it requires an entrance and exit and while I've gotten them to use the entrance, they never leave. (Probably has something to do with there being no existing car/train for the toilet.)

    • @AvenDonn
      @AvenDonn 3 роки тому +59

      Yes officer this comment right here

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому +13

      Indeed, all of this sounds so horrible, without or even with proper context. The more I read, the worse it gets.
      No, not even Akio as your profile pic would be able to redeem yourselr.

    • @Elbenzo64
      @Elbenzo64 2 роки тому +9

      And flush... SAY CHEESE

    • @StephenSpring1
      @StephenSpring1 2 роки тому +2

      yea, the whole video is predicated on an arbitrary %. Bad work Marcel

    • @glennzone12
      @glennzone12 2 роки тому +2

      True, but the Park Rating will tank.

  • @ReddFiveOhOh
    @ReddFiveOhOh 3 роки тому +95

    I'm always down to listen to the less-important mechanics of RCT just because learning is fucking radical. Like "guests exploding on a mini-golf" levels of radical.

  • @DeLorean4
    @DeLorean4 3 роки тому +160

    Marcel: * Mentions ATMs *
    Me: * Cries in RCT1 *

    • @Basssiiie
      @Basssiiie 3 роки тому +4

      Then again the maths may also be different in RCT1. :P

    • @claudetheclaudeqc6600
      @claudetheclaudeqc6600 3 роки тому +8

      me, doing extreme heights or any "no money" scenarios: "we don't make guest pay, everything is free*

    • @heroestratos
      @heroestratos 3 роки тому

      What is the context behind this?

    • @MisterDutch93
      @MisterDutch93 3 роки тому +14

      @@heroestratos RCT1 had no ATMs, meaning if your guests run out of money, they’re out.

    • @StefanVeenstra
      @StefanVeenstra 3 роки тому +2

      @@claudetheclaudeqc6600 Imagine a scenario with “■ no money” enabled and the only object you can place is the ATM.

  • @ImSquiggs
    @ImSquiggs 3 роки тому +96

    Glad to hear my boy's making that toilet money now

  • @bekerson4980
    @bekerson4980 3 роки тому +294

    I wonder how much free drinks affect this, if you end up making a profit overall, or just lose money

    • @rickpgriffin
      @rickpgriffin 3 роки тому +72

      Given that drinks base cost .30 (or so) to provide and you can charge a lot more for them, free drinks probably not. But question: does undercharging for drinks/food cause the average toilet value of the park to go up faster? I doubt it'd affect profits because toilet base price is naturally so cheap, profits from any increased toilet use would probably be marginal and under the rounding threshold

    • @lucasduque8289
      @lucasduque8289 3 роки тому +27

      That would be a cool thing to test out. Could be a good idea for a future video

    • @daskampffredchen9242
      @daskampffredchen9242 3 роки тому +54

      @@rickpgriffin Now I want to see a custom scenario where you have to make a certain profit from toilets

    • @tifforo1
      @tifforo1 3 роки тому +8

      Toilets are one of the least profitable things in your park, at least on a per-guest basis. But the volume can be high.

    • @TheTdw2000
      @TheTdw2000 3 роки тому +4

      perhaps not free but I'd imagine setting the price so that everyone who sees the drinks stand buys one is a profitable decision

  • @lostboy6268
    @lostboy6268 3 роки тому +15

    I really appreciate that you give the answer to the Title Question in the Thumbnail. I watch the whole thing regardless, but man, it´s nice to see someone who´s actually about informing people without clickbaiting. You deserve all the success my man.

  • @wrexmkw
    @wrexmkw 3 роки тому +35

    Sometimes I charge $.20 because it covers the cost to run it and guests will usually pay it anyway...

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому +1

      When I was a kid. I used to charge 4 whole dollars for toilets on the exits of rollercoasters and thrill rides in RCT1. I was a dumbass, didn't think of the morality of things yet in a game, and thought it works all the time just because I saw two ready-to-vomit kids enter even I raised it that high.

    • @DreHill1
      @DreHill1 2 місяці тому

      Same, but I always do 30 cents

  • @stevenlevesque4270
    @stevenlevesque4270 3 роки тому +69

    Hey Marcel:
    Can you do a video about shops/stalls?
    i.e. profit margins, guest preferences, min/max to charge, optimal prices, optimal number in a park, and why food courts are a waste of time.
    Edit: I see you provided a link to Deurklink's guide.

    • @MonJilley
      @MonJilley 3 роки тому +2

      I mean, the guide is there. I'd still like Marcel to do a video talking about this stuff, even if it's just an info dump.

    • @stevenlevesque4270
      @stevenlevesque4270 3 роки тому +3

      @@MonJilley he does a good job explaining things in a way that's easy to comprehend.

    • @StefanVeenstra
      @StefanVeenstra 3 роки тому +3

      Depends mostly on mood and weather. The happiest guests will easily pay 5.20 at the fishfood and pizza stalls and 4.20 for soda. But optimal you'd want most guests to buy without complaining. (Complaints hit the park rating)
      It's not hard to keep your guests from becoming unhappy or angry.
      Charging 1.80 for cold drinks and 2.30 for hot drinks and most foods. Some luxury foods like fish and pizza can optimally go for 2.80. Cheap items like candy cotton, ice cream, donuts and maps can go for 1.30. If I recall correctly from my own tests years back.
      My advice:
      Cheap items: $1
      Cold drinks: $1.50
      Hot drinks: $2
      Food: $2
      Luxury food: $2.50
      Luxury items*: $3.50
      Umbrella's: $20
      *Luxury items include hats, t-shirts, souvenirs, stuffed animals/toys and ride photo's.
      With above list, you'll have a good profit margin without much complaints and it's an easy list to remember.

  • @spockamania
    @spockamania 3 роки тому +22

    I feel like there are two ways of thinking. Either charge only $.20 so that there is no real happiness penalty as it is functionally identical to being free or $.40 as that's the most cost efficient

  • @mirrorsandstuff
    @mirrorsandstuff 3 роки тому +46

    Charging for your toilets may earn you $0.60, but it does eat a little piece of your soul in doing so.

    • @blacknight6337
      @blacknight6337 3 роки тому +16

      When you die and you charged for toilets in RCT, you get brought to a place with a full bladder, no money, and a $0.10 toilet charge

    • @zeroyuki92
      @zeroyuki92 Рік тому +5

      Exploding and drowning guests: Chillax it's just a game
      Charging for toilet: ABSOLUTE BLASPHEMY

  • @Manabender
    @Manabender 3 роки тому +8

    On one hand I love that you did *this much* math into the subject. On the other, I firmly believe that ethics still have a place in the game even though the guests aren't real. I always keep free toilets. It's a basic human right, honestly.

  • @MrLlama-gl2hk
    @MrLlama-gl2hk 3 роки тому +12

    What happens if you make a one-way row of toilets at different prices? Do the guests stop at the first toilet they're willing to pay?
    If so, you could guarantee that guests always pay their maximum amount. Guests leaving the park with a full bladder is potential money walking away!

    • @TheLastRaven6
      @TheLastRaven6 2 роки тому +5

      Thats not a bad idea, but a bunch of no entry signs, then descend the price. going away from the path of the No entry. So it might look like so.
      (.10) (.20) (.30) (.40) (.50) (.60)

  • @wisniamw
    @wisniamw 3 роки тому +14

    These thumbnails are instaclick for me just for the way you put informations in your videos
    great work

  • @hanshh3532
    @hanshh3532 Рік тому +2

    I love your scientific approach for these kind of questions. It totally gives no "real value" to explore these questions in this niche, but I get entertained and informed on a high level. Of course, that gives me much value.Thank you!

  • @5MadMovieMakers
    @5MadMovieMakers 3 роки тому +90

    I've wondered how pounds and euros convert to dollars. Does the game convert the currency or does the numerical value remain the same with different symbols in front?

    • @joshuadoll9000
      @joshuadoll9000 3 роки тому +68

      It's just an even conversion so 1 euro is equal to 1 dollar.

    • @agentstache135
      @agentstache135 3 роки тому +21

      Marcel actually already has a video on this: ua-cam.com/video/FT9J8QTt8Ek/v-deo.html

    • @theuncalledfor
      @theuncalledfor 3 роки тому +43

      In summary, since the prices don't really map to reality in any sensical way, currencies of similar real-life value just change the symbol and keep the value the same. For other currencies, powers of ten are used to get a nice, even number.

    • @daskampffredchen9242
      @daskampffredchen9242 2 роки тому +5

      @@theuncalledfor I think the Yen ditches the . so it is just one whole number

    • @kingcrimson4133
      @kingcrimson4133 2 роки тому

      @@daskampffredchen9242 That's a way to think about it, but it's not as if they're looking at US currency and thinking "let's just get rid of that pesky little decimal point and call it yen!" It is its own currency with its own history and reason for being the way it is. It just so happens that 1 USD is worth roughly 100 JPY, so conversion is simple enough. (Though in reality, 1 USD is worth 130 JPY at the moment.)

  • @JeffGoldblumsChest
    @JeffGoldblumsChest 3 роки тому +20

    I usually charge either nothing or $0.50, because it bugs me when peeps leave the park with $0.90 in their pockets and can't ride anything

    • @user-wk4np7fh2v
      @user-wk4np7fh2v 3 роки тому +24

      They can ride the toilet 2 more times

    • @mandowarrior123
      @mandowarrior123 3 роки тому

      @@user-wk4np7fh2v yes, but they won't be happy enough to need the loo again, so they won't.

  • @Bellicosy
    @Bellicosy 3 роки тому +71

    Do guests actively seek out amenities within the park after crossing a certain threshold, or does the game simply check the relevant values when a guest passes its respective stall? That is, is there another variable to consider here, that money can be lost as fewer guests are paying for rides as they seek out toilets? Also, is it possible to earn the "Best Toilet" award even if we charge 0.70 monies and noone uses them?

    • @Trancefreak12
      @Trancefreak12 3 роки тому +9

      Short answer is yes on seeking amenities: you can see in the list of guest actions that there are guests heading for stalls.
      Long answer is I don't know exactly when lol. Probably when the bar starts flashing.

    • @elijahbigsby4154
      @elijahbigsby4154 3 роки тому +8

      Ooooh. that's a good point. If they do seek them out, I think the question becomes "what is the lowest number of toilets, at the highest profit (or at least, lowest negative profit) that you can have in a park"?

    • @toimine8930
      @toimine8930 3 роки тому +5

      One of the requirements for the best toilets award is few guests thinking that they need to go, and that won't happen if they can't use the toilets

    • @claudetheclaudeqc6600
      @claudetheclaudeqc6600 3 роки тому +3

      @@toimine8930 except if they are leaving faster than supposed. like died and still have a ton of toilets

    • @dreamcanvas5321
      @dreamcanvas5321 2 роки тому +2

      @@claudetheclaudeqc6600 Most Dangerous Park in the Country. and BEsT ToiLEtS

  • @colecostie
    @colecostie 3 роки тому +4

    Only you could make a fun and interesting video on the pricing principals of video game toilets

  • @hordenmeisterAO
    @hordenmeisterAO 2 роки тому +2

    Another aspect that might play a role is that after the bladder check notices a value above 70, it will continue to rise while the guest walks to the toilet. Also guests with a value just short of 70 will probably jump to above 80 when having a drink. So the lower values that cause a guest to look for a toilet should be very rare. There should nearly never be a guest not willing to pay 20 cents.

  • @MrCheeze
    @MrCheeze 3 роки тому +2

    I like that this video shows the importance of real-world testing. The theoretical analysis is tricky to reason about but points toward 30 cents, but the empirical test disagrees and leads to developing a more accurate model.
    (Of course, there's a good chance that the optimal depends on factors like park size. But the testing also suggests that being off by 10 cents isn't a big deal anyway.)

  • @sanderbos4243
    @sanderbos4243 3 роки тому +1

    I really like that you didn't just speculate 30 cents being optimal and ended the video there, but actually did some empirical testing which eventually even gave you a different conclusion. :-)

    • @MarcelVos
      @MarcelVos  3 роки тому +2

      Originally I did end the video there, but after I recorded the script I decided that I should test if it's actually true and in a very rough test I saw that my conclusion didn't work so I made a more extensive test and extended the video.

    • @sanderbos4243
      @sanderbos4243 3 роки тому

      @@MarcelVos Awesome, good on you!

  • @bewlan
    @bewlan 3 роки тому +8

    I like the way you analysis questions. I almost believe €0.30 is the optimal value before you deep dive into simulation and come out the real optimal answer.

    • @88porpoise
      @88porpoise 3 роки тому +2

      That first analysis was simply inappropriate to the question. The expected value only really works for a single occurence.
      While I like that he included his (incorrect) workings I would appreciate him being more clear at the start because people may think that is an appropriate way to analyze the situation.
      The variables simply aren't structured in a way that a simple expected value calculation can work due to each event not being independent of the other.

  • @fo-ef8qo
    @fo-ef8qo 3 роки тому

    that single water fountain in the middle of the giant lake while explaining toilets was just a beautiful metaphor. 10/10 I wish I could like this video twice.

  • @paulharmo
    @paulharmo 3 роки тому +7

    So, this begs the final question to MarcelVos! Now that you know the optimal price, and have demonstrated that there is very little negative effect, will you start charging for toilets when you play RCT2?

  • @rsjc852
    @rsjc852 3 роки тому +1

    Hi Marcel! You've touched on this subject in several of your videos, but could you consider making a comprehensive guide on how different path layouts and sizes affect the way guests traverse the park? And/Or how guests routines function. It would be very interesting to see how guest behavior works (or doesn't) in different situations.
    Thanks for continuing to show me that even after 1000's of hours over 18+ years, there's still things I've yet to learn about RTC!

  • @chompythebeast
    @chompythebeast 3 роки тому

    The chutzpah to put the answer to the question posed in your own title right in your thumbnail, on algorithmically-dictated UA-cam, home of the pointless thumbnail arrow and circle that inexplicably drive clicks up X%, is comendable. Like a proper essay, your title tells me what you're gonna tell me, then your first bit _tells_ it to me, then you spend the whole thing explaining it, then you finish it by telling it to me again. That's the work of a confident student or educator alike, bravo, bravo
    May you hit 100k sooner rather than later

  • @alhei525
    @alhei525 3 роки тому +1

    This video made me remember that I was thinking about the optimal prices when I was a kid and figuring out this by looking at the profits over long times with differend prices so I ended up pricing my toilets between 0-40 cents depending on situation. Thanks for the revival of some old memories!

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому

      Reminds me of when I, too, was a kid. I used to charge 4 dollars for toilets on the exits of rollercoasters and thrill rides in RCT1. I was a dumbass, and thought it works all the time just because I saw two ready-to-vomit kids enter even I raised it that high.

  • @Talon_24
    @Talon_24 3 роки тому +2

    Great video! At 9:38 This would be been a great opportunity to add a little chart to show the peak/valley

  • @polikitez
    @polikitez 3 роки тому +1

    Great video as always! Video suggestion: A summary video of all of these "optimal" strategies, with the sole purpose of earning a lot of money and having a relatively good park. Not going deep into any of those but mentioning everything that you should definitely do or not do. Thanks!

  • @supersonicbros23
    @supersonicbros23 3 роки тому +1

    I can't remember where, but when I was a kid we stopped somewhere on a road trip to use the toilets and there was a hand-crank machine that gave you up to like, 5-10 squares of toiletpaper for a quarter per crank. Thankfully all we had to do was pee.

  • @chriso1373
    @chriso1373 3 роки тому +1

    Had to watch an ad to see this video. Glad everything is finallt resolved.

  • @HEYBUDDYMAN86
    @HEYBUDDYMAN86 3 роки тому

    me seeing my recommendations: Awesome, great Marcel Vos video. I remember the one where he talked about toilet pricing. I'll rewatch it.
    me later in my sub box realizing the video is 3 hours old: oh. okay NOW let's actually rewatch it.

  • @TheHabsburgJaw
    @TheHabsburgJaw 3 місяці тому

    I made one goofy roller coaster tycoon video, and now I get you in my recommended all the time. I love the content, love RCT, and have been playing since a very little kid.

  • @surrodox
    @surrodox 3 роки тому +5

    I charge toilets in my park saves $0.20, always worked for me
    Nice to see this though
    PS: Would you enable auto generated subtitles or make your own subtitles?

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому +2

      I miss the YT feature of community generated subtitles, it's one of the few good features they've implemented yet sacked.

  • @JLock_17
    @JLock_17 3 роки тому +1

    This is a good observation of real world pricing decisions. Sure you may think the price is outrageous now, but later when you're desperate you'll have to give in. E.G. gas prices.

  • @Skyblade12
    @Skyblade12 2 роки тому

    I love how in depth you took this question.

  • @LuckSpinner
    @LuckSpinner 3 роки тому +1

    That hot dog building! Hah! Amazing! Lately been on a buildings kick, always loved to decorate with plants but starting to play more with the walls and roofs. Thanks for another great video Marcel, would love to see a food court ideas video if you haven't made one yet. Laying out the paths/chairs is hard to get the peeps to stop getting lost and going in circles in them. =)

  • @SchrodingersCat8813
    @SchrodingersCat8813 3 роки тому +2

    Amazing analysis as usual! I really would’ve expected 10 cents was best, get some amount from everyone rather than more from less and I did assume it would lower your rating w tons of people needing to go...but seems not and lower prices are worse. Good stuff! Granted I don’t charge for toilets or park maps!

  • @2m2a2r2k2
    @2m2a2r2k2 3 роки тому +2

    Could you do a video about how long guests are willing to wait in queuelines, if / how those waiting times differ between rides, what the optimal queue length is and how entertainers / TV's influence that?

  • @RagnarokiaNG
    @RagnarokiaNG 3 роки тому +19

    *makes sickness inducing rides* "..."
    *kills guests in crashes* "..."
    *drowns guests* "..."
    *charges for toilets* "YOU HAVE GONE TOO FAR!"

  • @tifforo1
    @tifforo1 3 роки тому +1

    There is a third affect that happiness has: it affects how much guests will pay at shops!
    Basically, there is a "fair" price for each item, which does not change based on anything except the temperature, that is the maximum you can charge without any guests refusing because it is too expensive. (It's usually about 20 cents above the default price and is way higher than wholesale cost.) This amount is the same for happy and unhappy guests. However, if you charge more than this, there is a sliding scale where 1/8 of unhappy guests will refuse to pay for every 10 cents you go over. But for happy guests, it's for every 20 cents, and for very happy guests, it's for every 40 cents. This means that the maximum an unhappy guest will every pay is 70 cents above the "fair" price, but you can charge as much as $2.80 higher than the fair price and 1/8 of very happy guests will still pay it!
    I think this video understates the disadvantages of making guests unhappy since you can make better profits from stalls than toilets.

  • @Rinocapz
    @Rinocapz 3 роки тому +4

    Another toilet video!

  • @mintgreen292
    @mintgreen292 3 роки тому

    Very interesting to see that the negative effects of guests not being able to go to the bathroom are negligible. Quality content as always.

  • @GretgorPooper
    @GretgorPooper 3 роки тому +1

    Marcel is the only man capable of making me sit through a 12 minute video about proper toilet pricing.

  • @Noromdiputs
    @Noromdiputs 3 роки тому

    7:43 YES! Riggor! Was very worried you would just leave it at rough theory without actually testing any assumptions. This is fantastic.

  • @DakalaShade
    @DakalaShade 3 роки тому

    I used to run the toilets with their prices unlinked. In the middle of the park, the toilets were always 10 to 20 cents, getting more expensive on the way to the borders. I think I had some at the rim of the park (often labeled, as 10-year-old me thought was funny, "Pay2 Pee") that ran at 50 cents. I don't know if it made much of a difference, but again, my logic, at that age, was that guests would be more likely to stay in the middle of the park because toilets were cheaper there.
    For a while, I ran the toilets at the entrance at 60 cents, getting cheaper the further from the park entrance you were. This was done because I wanted to push guests towards newer rides I'd built, instead of clustering around the park entrance. I also had a "Pity Potty" at the very back of the park that was always left free.

  • @Pendragonthegreat
    @Pendragonthegreat 3 роки тому

    This video is giving me Economy 101 flashbacks from university days at USC XD
    Good work!

  • @MrOrzech1
    @MrOrzech1 2 роки тому

    Even though I had never any interest in this game, 11:17 perfectly explains why I watched this video xD
    Math and game mechanics are always fun to explore

  • @onfik
    @onfik 3 роки тому

    I don't even play this game, yet I watch all his videos.
    Especially the research ones. I just appreciate them and I find them really interesting.

  • @anythinggggg
    @anythinggggg 3 роки тому +2

    A video about playing scenarios without ATMs would be interesting. This video touched on it slightly.

  • @NoxmilesDe
    @NoxmilesDe 3 роки тому +11

    I Like math combined with RCT2

  • @1015AK
    @1015AK Рік тому

    I havent played rct in over 15 years but im addicted to these videos.

  • @TheIcyWizard705
    @TheIcyWizard705 3 роки тому

    I never thought i'd see a 12 minute video on pricing toilet use in RCT2

  • @gigabytemon
    @gigabytemon 3 роки тому

    I feel like I learn critical statistical analysis skills by watching your videos. Thank you for making this.

  • @OutwayKnoll1080
    @OutwayKnoll1080 Рік тому

    I love your thumbnails! Just went back to playing RCT2 and am using your thumbnails and vids so often ❤

  • @TheAmazingRacoon
    @TheAmazingRacoon 3 роки тому

    Almost 12 minutes video about toilets, i love this channel :D

  • @TonyDiTaranto
    @TonyDiTaranto 3 роки тому

    I’ve actually wondered this since I was a kid. Thanks for the analysis!

  • @Robin_Dragunov
    @Robin_Dragunov 3 роки тому +1

    the 1st thing i do when i see a new post from this channel is give a *LIKE* 👍
    ❤️ RCT

  • @Trollami
    @Trollami 3 роки тому +1

    Quality quota filled for the week. Thank you Marcel!

  • @JustAnotherHo
    @JustAnotherHo 3 роки тому +4

    In original RCT, as a child, I figured it out to be 20 cents. As I replayed the game, and became an adult, I generally keep it at 0, 10 or 20. Love the video.

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому

      When i was a kid, I placed it as 4.00 dollars but only the exits of roller coasters and thrill rides. Dad used to laugh how terrible and funny it was

  • @SleinMcAwesome
    @SleinMcAwesome 3 роки тому

    I never knew a video about virtual toilets in a video game could be so interesting. Thanks, Marcel! :)

  • @harkeofficial
    @harkeofficial 2 роки тому

    This is the most well researched, conclusive review on video game toilets I’ve ever seen. Or that probably exists. Great video, super informative.

  • @Arjay404
    @Arjay404 3 роки тому

    What is the cooldown before a guests think about having to go the toilet again? I could see this having a influence on your overall park's income, since a guest that is going to the toilet or in the toilets is a guest that currently isn't paying for a ride. Having the price be on the higher end might be better because it means the guests are staying away from the toilets for longer and spending money on rides that cost a lot more money.
    Having the price say at 20 cents for example, will have the guest going to the toilet 3 in the same time, as opposed to say having it at 60 which means they only go to the toilets once in that time, which means more time spent on rides/shops.
    Also do guests have a memory on what the price for toilets (or really anything else) is? So they will have a feeling they need to go to the toilet, but they also remember that the price is 60 cents, so instead of walking to the toilet, only to turn around because their need isn't that high, they will stay away from the toilet until their need gets high enough.

  • @leonhrad
    @leonhrad 3 роки тому +2

    5:50 ha, I get it. they're already too 'pissed' off

  • @James-eg3fr
    @James-eg3fr 2 роки тому

    An interesting thing i JUST learned about in RCT1/2, is that MOST of the RCT games have identical currency. As in, if you change USD, to Euros, Pounds, whatever number your money is currently at will remain the same if you change the currency. USD, Euros, Pound sterling, Deutsche Mark, Swedish krona, Spanish peseta, Dutch guilder, OR Swiss Franc, apparently, they all are identical, if not, are basically the same... MINUS one, or two other types of currency, such as the Japanese Yen.

  • @ZlueTheDragon
    @ZlueTheDragon 3 роки тому

    One factor you may want to include is that holland six-flags has problems (albeit small ones, giving 950 park rating), so guests may not stay as long as a perfect park of 999.
    The longer the guests stay, the more their toilet stat goes up. If you can guarantee a value that is high enough for 0.60 before the guests leave, it makes the most money.
    Unchanged Holland may run best on 0.40, but a better park may work better with 0.60 (a worse park may need a much lower price, like 0.30 or 0.20).
    I think it really comes down to how long you keep guests in your park, and how much you pioritise money over slight park ratings. If your park is already good enough, then it may be worth it to increase the price all the way to 0.60 becuase guests are more likely to pay it, whereas guests previously left before paying the 0.60 in holland.
    This needs more testing though, with a greater sample size of parks.
    Overall great video though.

  • @terenceshuen
    @terenceshuen 3 роки тому +25

    Should I start charging my family for toilets too ?

    • @xenox3
      @xenox3 3 роки тому +8

      yes

    • @WingMaster562
      @WingMaster562 2 роки тому

      When I was with cousins, apparently they charge each other by the hour in the toilet. First half hour is free, but each consecutive is charged. It's like a swear jar, but for not hogging the toilet.

  • @Smith.S.E.
    @Smith.S.E. 2 роки тому

    Man. I love your videos and your thumbnails . Absolute beast

  • @iunnor
    @iunnor 3 роки тому +8

    Only if we can put one of those dudes in the bathroom that sells vape pens and hand out napkins.

  • @yak3868
    @yak3868 2 роки тому +1

    I find it funny how you managed to make a 12 minute video on toilet prices in this game, and used every second so well

  • @samspencer7765
    @samspencer7765 3 роки тому

    What's interesting as well to me is that, when you look at the proportion of guests who want the toilet enough that they walk quickly, as if I remember right it makes them faster, so they spend less time walking and more time + money at stalls

  • @sgtscott8900
    @sgtscott8900 3 роки тому +4

    I tend to charge for toilets in parks that charge per ride and not a park entrance fee

  • @roym2185
    @roym2185 3 роки тому

    Who would have thought we would be looking at the negligible effect of toilet prices on the park rating and number of guests of a game from 20 years ago. Love the way the scientific method is used here haha. Personally I always charge 10 cents just to break even on the toilets... maybe we want to factor in the opportunity cost of charging people for toilets (e.g. people can afford more rides, happiness goes up, therefore park rating improves and more guests). But it all seems so negligible for this one as you noted.

  • @johnsaunders1435
    @johnsaunders1435 2 роки тому

    I always charged 20 cents to cover costs yet in my senior years of playing I like to find financial challenges as I play. One thing I learned a while back that I don't think I missed here and comical is how you can use the see they rides function and watch patrons use the restrooms!

  • @Timmzy27
    @Timmzy27 3 роки тому +17

    I arbitrarily always priced my toilets at £0.20, glad to see it wasn’t for no reason, though I guess I can charge £0.40 and get away with it

  • @Davtwan
    @Davtwan 3 роки тому +2

    Seeing the profit actually be higher than the running cost gave me a little dopamine boost.

  • @rowbot5555
    @rowbot5555 2 роки тому

    You put more effort into this game than I would have thought anyone would have and I commend your efforts!

  • @squishybrick
    @squishybrick 3 роки тому +1

    I feel like if he really wanted to go turbo-nerd on it, he could've ran further experiments on toilet prices, with the variable of LOCATION, having parks with varied prices, but putting either
    1. More, or less toilets
    2. Toilets that are closer together in certain areas, or farther apart, more-evenly spread across the park
    3. Toilets in either very low-traffic areas, or centralized in hub-points or high-traffic areas
    4. Toilets specifically located either right next to rides and food/drink vendors, or toilets completely by themselves in a specific area out of the way.
    The question/hypothesis being, does the guest's AI have any real bearing on how often or efficiently they use or find the toilets? Will they go out of their way to locate one far away from the normal paths like they actually know where it is? Or, if one isn't placed around normal-traffic paths, will they just aimlessly flounder about and NEVER use a toilet, because one simply isn't in front of them?
    If the latter is true, you could potentially rig your paths to purposefully draw out the guest's walking path so that it is perfectly timed, a bathroom only being present near or in front of them, after they already really need to go to the bathroom..
    Though, even if that was a viable tactic, I guess that'd be like peak tryharding. XD

  • @sweetchristabel
    @sweetchristabel 3 роки тому

    Ooh, a new video from Marcel!
    *saves to watch later*

  • @realityveil6151
    @realityveil6151 3 роки тому

    upvoting and full engagement watch for the anti-clickbait. We must reward this behavior, not only for Marcel, but for the youtube bots.

  • @Teylahime
    @Teylahime 3 роки тому

    I usually only charge for bathrooms in Pay for Entry locked parks, without an ATM the full bladder will force broke guests to leave instead of hanging around forever. Keeping guests cycling really helps with income I find, and it seems to harm the park rating less than no bathrooms at all.

  • @SilverScaleMA
    @SilverScaleMA 3 роки тому

    I usually charge $0.10 to $0.20 depending on how big and busy my park is. Basically as long as the price is paying for the running cost I don't go higher. I do charge $0.20 standard for the parks where the rides are free just because.

  • @sagacious03
    @sagacious03 3 роки тому

    Okay analysis! Thanks for uploading!

  • @teddy4271
    @teddy4271 3 роки тому +2

    I think it really just comes down to how long the average guest will stay in the park.
    If everyone sticks around long enough to fill their stats all the way to 255 at least once, it'd make sense to raise the price above the usual break point, yeah?

    • @Putnam3145
      @Putnam3145 3 роки тому

      Depends on if high toilet might make them leave in and of itself

  • @madisonhartley5707
    @madisonhartley5707 3 роки тому

    I love rct2 the more I learn about it. I love your videos!!

  • @Adman234videos
    @Adman234videos Рік тому

    Another thing to maybe consider is that a guest will use the toilet twice as often (roughly) if the price is half. So perhaps the lower values such as 0.20 could be more profitable if the guests are using the toilets more often. However this could also cause them to waste more time instead of doing other profitable activities. Maybe more tests are needed.

  • @Hassassin119
    @Hassassin119 3 роки тому

    I hope you do a video on the first aid stall. When I played it as a kid guests use to ignore it despite being at the verge of throwing up.

  • @MartinBentsen
    @MartinBentsen Рік тому

    I’ve found that offering cheap things for free, such as toilets, unpopular rides, and even some foods, you can generally make MORE money because people are so happy and your park rating increases. Then for your best rides, charge a premium. At $10/ticket, some coasters can make upwards of $16k/hr, and that more than makes up for losing money at $45-200/hr for underperforming rides and stalls.
    Charge premium prices for popular rides and stalls, and give everything else for free to increase guest happiness and get more people.
    In business terms this is called a “Barbell Strategy.”

  • @LePezzy66
    @LePezzy66 3 роки тому

    I'm just so happy the RTC2 community is still so active and wholesome