Allahh discloses whatever he chooses to whomever he chooses, for reasons he only knows, and at a time that he chooses! Only those who want us to believe that Allahh is silent or that Allahh stopped talking to us after the first 3 generations would argue against this. I don't claim to be better than anyone else, except that Allahh allowed me to see the evidence to be able to express it. My test and challenge is to present it as best as I can. Insha Allahh I have done so. Regards
I had to leave the tribal Muslim community for years in order to find my way back to the one and only Creator, Allahh azzawajall. I see this channel & revelations have been the answer to my many nights of tears and solemn supplication for Allahh to guide me back to Him.. AlhamdoliLLAHH! Although I still have much to learn, I have complete peace in my heart. JazakAllahu kolla Khalid, brother Hany.
Alhamdulielah, I have rewatched this entire series again and i have enjoyed it so much more! Powerful...! I recommend others to rewatch it again. There is so much information and beautiful nuggets. Shukran Dr. Hany!!!!!
This is truly shocking to think all this time we were unknowingly duped into practicing and implementing "Shirk". I am reveiwing this video because I never ever want to forget this atrocity and how Allah saved us from commtting such an horendous deed. All of this research you have done on this subject needs to be publiczed to the four corners of the muslim communities. But im afraid that the information would not be receieved. Brother Hany I can't express to you with words how much I appreciate your expertise in revealing the Ibrahamic Locution and sharing it with the world, This is the most important video ever. After all shirk is the unforgivable sin. Allah is truly Al Afuw Ar Ra'uf to those of us who are striving to learn, uncover and implement the truth of Al Quran. Believe me my Dear Brother, I really need Allah's approval to survive in this dunya. Thank you for all of you hard amazing work.
This is one of the best, thoroughly explained with detailed proofs, beautiful and humble presentations. The message is very scary as well. JazakaAllah khair.
Salamun Aleikum, this really shocked me but makes perfect sense, we need to reflect and accept we were wrong and start by making a change. InshaAllah I will continue my quest for the truth provided by Allah. Thank you Dr Hany!
I agree with that , Dr Hany . I am so lonely on this journey , but I learn so much from Allah and I try to use the du'as that Allah teaches us in His wonderful Qur'an . Adam's du'a is the one which I use the most , cause it suits me better , until now . May peace and blessings from Allah be up on you.
i’m watching it again and again dr hany jazakallahu khairun. i want to refresh my mind. because when you are in a world full of sheep’s and drowning mass and unthinkable baise, they’ll drag it down with you to the fire with them.
Salamun alaykum dear brother. I’ve incinerated the whole bag of duas containing Allahhuma. Alhamdullilah, Allahh makes it easy for me! Now starting to reload certainty and useful insight to my mental frame. Everything from now on has to be clean and pure.
Very important question. Please reply! I am a new Muslim. Could you kindly tell me how will I say the Darood-e-Ibrahimi (the one we read in the salah) without Allahhuma?
One scholar is Much more Better than Thousands of worshippers in the sight of Almighty Allah. Dr Hany you are the real scholar No one did a research for for a single aya like this Islam was hijacked damaged Our mission is to restore it in its original form
@@nafisaahmed9682 give me evidence or prove In any of His lectures I am ready leave this channel. Be open minded Empty your cup Unlearn Ask questions Alhamthu Lillah Almighty May open up your heart Almighty May show you the hidden knowledge Insha Allah 1400 years we are living with Divine Book Observe our Islamic ummah Compare the nature of our community with other community without a Divine Book Start giving scores both side In which area we are better than others In which area we are not better than others
For 1400yrs Muslim were cursing themselves in Dua, how cud Allah used same generation to transmitting the Quran to us, the Quran that this guy has no problem to use it as a evidence to support his argument while he knows very well that this Quran had passed through to those people who were cursed themselves in Dua, how cud Allah do that, I really I don't understand and it does not make sense,
We provided the answer in the video. Being cursed means to be deprived of direct guidance. It does not mean that Allahh took away all your other faculties such as memorization, or the human ability to write and preserve copies of the Quran. Please learn the basics of monotheism before you get yourself in more trouble, defending the errors of the forefathers, because you are too afraid to trust Allahh, and you are too ungrateful to give credit to Allahh for all the blessings he gave you, including preserving the Quran! Furthermore, I did not say that everyone was cursed! All it takes is a few people whom Allahh guided to transmit the Quran correctly! Those who mis-spoke about the Quran and misguided people were not the real transmitters of the Quran. As a matter of fact, there are hundreds of Sahabas who transmitted the Quran but we have never heard any hadeeth or any interpretation from. So the two groups are NOT the same! As I said in my reply to your other comment: Allahh preserved the Quran FOR you. Do you want to give credit to humans for the preservation of the Quran??? You are like someone who wants to give credit to his parents for the perfect creation Allahh gave him! Are you that ignorant??? Are you that ungrateful to Allahh???
This issue needs to be discussed by prominent scholars around the world. We cannot just jump into conclution and accept the opinion of one single person. It involves the recitation of our daily prayers.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hany. I am a revert and have been making a deliberate conscious effort to learn to read the Quran over the last 6 years. I have been also been referring to the available translations to understand the Quran. I came across your Channel from a comment in another channel that does some amazing interviews and I became curious about Marvelous Quran. I have been listening to all your videos and I am deeply affected by these new discoveries. I have listened to this particular video more that 5 tines and it has really been on my mind and I have been asking Allah for guidance. Today, I was reading Surah An Naml and when I read verses 27:60-64, I felt a shift. I continued to read the translations to the end of the Surah. And I wanted to share this with you. May Allah guide us to that which benefits us.
Peace be with you, Dr. Hani. Listening to your critical analysis sure helped me in better understanding myself. Timestamp 1:33:51 "Being preached by Jews and Christian theologians through the Ummayad Dynsty" really caught my attention. I was wondering if there's any video of you dealing with your understanding of the Historic Islam and its roots in Arabia and as to what followed after the Prophet passed away until the time when first recorded Tafseer/Tareekh begin circulation. Im just a regular 45 yr old fellow-Muslim from Pakistan, trying to understand what caused us to come all the way to LIVE the MOMENTS that the scripture seems to use as WARNING and CLEAR SIGNS. May you be among the MOMINEEN. -v-
Allahumma was mentioned in the Quran 5 times, It is most definitely an Arabic word. and Allah uses it in the Quran to teach us how to make supplications.It was used once by normal people, and 4 other times by prophets and as Duaa of people in the Janna. Do not mistranslate the Quran for Allah is close by and will hold you responsible for what you say and do.
@@thebeesnuts777 the point is اللهم is 100% Arabic, I watched the video and it is totally not convincing. I am an Arab Muslim and I know my Arabic well. Allah would not include a foreign non Arabic word in the Quran when he clearly says many times that he delivered an Arabic Quran, and the Quran in a clear Arabic tongue. Furthermore, the prophet who is Arabic mentioned اللهم in many Hadith. The Arabic prophet peace be upon him who speaks in Arabic tongue does not include a Hebrew word in his speech. Don’t follow blindly and think and reflect yourself to know the truth. اللهم is NOT a curse may Allah forbid. This is by far the most outrageous explanation I heard.
When Arab Christians use the word Allah does that has the same meaning as the word Allah used by Muslims? So, even if we assume that the word Allahumma has another origin, how can we conclude that they will have the same meaning irrespective of the context.
@@imamibrahim6282 Allah for Muslims is the same as Allah for Christians and is the same for Allah for Jews. Allah Subhannah is the God of Ibrahim peace be upon him. Allah was known to all prophets for all faiths by this name.
When we supplicate to Allah and we say Subhana Allahum Wa Bihamdik سبحانك اللهم وبحمدك which was also a Duaa or supplication of the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him what do you think that means according to this video ? Or when Pilgroms say لبيك اللهم لبيك، what do you think it means ? Your proposal not only misinterprets Arabic and Quran text, it also misinterprets the value and meaning and context of use of Allah’s name glorified is He. I advise you to delete this video and withdraw your proposal. May Allah forgive you.
You have proved it beyond doubt, height of ignorance in fact we have institutionalised ignorance and then value the ignorance no parralals in human history!
The biggest mistake in his reasoning is that he compares Arabic اللهم with Hebrew elohim. Elohim in the testaments is used to call Allah, the fact that it's plural in linguistic perspective has nothing to do with polytheism! We read also Allah which is masculin in Arabic, does it mean that Allah is masculin too? Nonsense don't relate physical aspects to grammatical one's! Furthermore he said first that Allahomma means according to elohim 'polydieties'.......after he said that it's a cursing word...that doesn't sound logic to me. His interpretation of the verses are also full of errors.
سبحان الله العظيم I don’t know if this has been mentioned or not but ‘dakwa’ (pronounced as دَكْوَا) means accuse, claim, reckon, declare in Malay. Obviously adopted from Arabic thanks to you. You just taught me an etymology of another language. كشجرة طيبة ❤
That's one good reason to not say prefabricated prayers constructed by someone other than yourself. It's important to have an open conversation with your creator during a servants entire life. Say, "Call him Allah or Ar RaHman, in whichever way/name you call him, his are the best names. Do not be to loud in Salah, not be to low in it. And seek a way in between. Quran 17:110 The correct way. Allah does not reject salah made with a pure and sincere heart. No matter what popular non Quranic teachings say.
I don't know whether to agree or disagree, but I have been pondering, searching for some time n couldn't really get some words. This is one of them it always ringged a bell to me as elohim .
@Mfvpill Keep watching. I have discussed this issue further (with more evidence) in YT170 and again in YT178. You can find these segments on the channel page.
I agree with you whole heartedly. How come he is the first one to mention it. And the way he explains the use of Allahjma in the Quran is completely misguided. Twisting your tongue is not enough to argue your point dr hani.
@ C Hasan @ Sarah Hopeful Just one question: Did you watch the video about Allahhumma with all the Quranic evidence we presented? If yes, can you please argue Quranic evidence against Quranic evidence? If you have studied Islamic sciences (which it seems that you have, masha Allahh), you would know that scholars consider the highest, most reliable evidence is the Quranic evidence. So don't bring me a hadeeth and claim that it is nullifying the evidence from Quran. I am waiting. Did you watch the video about Allahhumma in full? Your argument about all the people before us who were misguided was used by the Christians and the Jews against our beloved SAWS. Please be careful not to use their arguments against the Quranic evidence we presented.
@@MarvelousQuranYou are using the same tactics as the poeple of the book by using their writing to put new meanings to the verses of the Quran. Your knowledge of Arabic may fool few Muslims in believing the outrageous assertion you put forward because they understandably are not Arabes, but you are not fooling anyone who knows Arabic. I have not watched your other videos so my comments are related to this particular video and subject. You asked about my credentials, but I am not the one putting out videos with shocking titles. May I ask you in what field did you obtain your doctorate?
Please review surah 8 : 32 in regular translation whose say allahuma. Those are disbeliefer who inquire answer from they own gods. If you can see it, then i dont know. Anyway, its mention at 27:55
@@entdre is it common to start a sentence with " say:" in the imperative and include a word that is should not be used in what you have been asked to say? His assertion as completely strange and weird . Please don't fall for his so called know knowledge of arabic. If you are not an Arabic speaker you should at least relay on the understanding of those who spent their life dedicating it for the honest reading of the Quran. This dr make the mistaken assertion that the word Alkahuma is in fact the word illuhim found in the bible. He took the definition of the word illuhim and applied it to the word Allahuma in order to distort the meaning of the verses of the Quran. I can not believe the sheer ignorance displayed in this video.
Thank you Dr. Atchan for bringing the Truth to the ummah. I pray that your interpretation of the Quran by engaging the methodology defined in the Quran touches the heart of all including the ummah. Thanks for teaching us to supplicate using Rabbi and Rabbana.
The Truth is not a relic or an object that anyone can possess. The Truth does not belong to a specific group, sect, denomination, people or nation. The Truth is not dependant on the number of people to hold on to a particular creed, doctrine or ideology. The Truth is not a set of rituals and dogma to blindly follow. Our Lord, guide us ever closer to the truth, our Lord guide us ever closer towards You.
I do not understand and confused about what he is saying.here. “ Dorude Ibrahim” was recited by our prophet, his sahabees, his family members , four Imams and we as well as all Muslims in every salat.
Language brings a new era. When the usage of a language is good and proper, the era becomes decent and prosperous. And when the usage of language becomes corrupted and indecent, the era of indecency erupts and the downfall of humanity starts and continues until the corrupted language has been abandoned and that language has been purified. Human beings distinct themselves from all creatures and become the masters of this tool called language. This session has brought us to show the usage of Millat Ibrahim to purify our language. It’s also a cutting edge between the users of the purified language and the corrupted usage and users of the misguided language. This reveals a sad truth that we would be separated from our acquaintances through the usage of the proper language and would never see them again in afterlife unless they come back to this new era of purification and prosperity :’(
Salam aleikoum, i noticed that the imperative verb(s) that are used in supplications is not there after the “allahumma” in the 39-46, isn’t it another hint that “wa 9ul allahumma” is split from the rest of the aya?! Rabbi zidna 3ilma May allah reward you with evenmore knowledge for all the thourough work you do! Thank you Dr Hani
Journey is getting more and more intriguing day by day. Information in Each video segment is just phenomenal than other. Yes, we truly support your brand new findings in Qur'an, criticizers must need to enrich their knowledge. It's all a common sense but the dogmas laid by dear brainy responsibility taking scholars say, "NO, THINKING NOT ALLOWED,ELSE 👽"
To be duped for 1400 years is exaggerating and disrespect of ulama in the earliest history of Islam. All lectures by our known ulama make use of "Allahumma"..
@ Jangan Marah Let me ask you a simple question: Do the Jews and Christians before us have scholars and Ulamaa who were duped into teaching the wrong thing? Why do you think we are immune to that?
@@MarvelousQuran Can I answer you with this question? Have you spoken to Islamic scholars before you claimed you were given knowledge unknown to the earliest ulama in the history of Islam and declared yourself champion in bringing your findings to the muslim masses in the youtube? Why don't you declare your findings to the islamic authorities in many muslim countries before you rudely and disrespectfully calling muslims duped for thousand of years? Don't be like another Yasir Qadhi! Please don't compare Jews and Christian Bible scholars with Muslim Quranic scholars because their source are different.
These are the very people who brings misguidance to those with little or no knowledge of Islam. Islam is simple and beautiful. Allahuma is beseeching Allah in a humble way, and you twisting the words of Allah.
@ Bahdon Dahir If you had watched the full video with the intention to learn, you would have learned that I used a hadeeth to confirm what I said. So stop being cynical and learn. Cynicism is only blocking you, my brother! It does not hurt anyone else.
I agree with you, brother. He is misguiding the Muslims. Ellohim was never understood by the ancient ppl as many gods. The sufix -im is a plural of respect. And was understood like that. I listened Jewish Rabbis explaining that very good. The great Islamic schoolers of old age, knew that too, that's why they did never had a problem with Allahumma. I speak 3 languages and all of these languages still have a plural of respect when you speak formally. If I talk to someone that is not very close to me like a friend or a family member, or if I write a formal letter, I always address the person with the pronoun in the plural, but that doesn't mean that I think that I speak to more than one. The brother made right in the beginning this big mistake and has built a whole case on a wrong preposition. He need to understand that it's not enough to know the language, but also the context, how did the ppl of those times understood it? That's why it matters very much, how did our great schoolers, those who came not long time after the revelation, how did they understood it? They did not see any flaw in the use of Allahumma, right?
@Safya Farooq You can accuse me of whatever you want. However, plz consider two issues: 1. Do we ever address Allahh in Duaa in the plural, even in the majestic plural? 2. Did any of the messengers and prophets in the Quran use Allahhumma for Duaa? Don't we have over 100 examples of messengers and prophets in the Quran using Rabbee or Rabbana for Duaa? Stop arguing in vain, just to defend the writings of people you don't know, who transmitted verbal reports without any authoritativeness.
Subhanallah While going revision of all the segments I managed to see this again. First time I didn’t understand in detail but today I have realised how important it is to take Allah words as authority. No wonder almost all Muslim ummah is following intermediaries in one or other forms. Especially taking words of Muhammad SA as authority over Quran without trying to investigate weather he could have said this and second taking opinion of sheikhs or immams in the form of fatwa over Devine lexicon. I can only hope Allah may guid them if he wills. Most of Muslims do supplication which are handed down the generations as traditions.
Salamum alaykum, Alhumdulilah. Following your research videos, learning and correcting our understanding. Thank you Dr. Hany. May Allah accept your efforts, lead us on self-correcting methodology and guide us.
My dear fellow muslims and all those who want to be guided, please pick the Qur'an and read those verses he has cited yourself. If you don't understand Arabic like myself pick one with english translation. Read the verses before those with "Allahhumma" and judge for yourself. Most of the things he said in the video are his own interpolations. I entreat you to read Sura 5:114, which is a prayer by prophet Issah (as) and Sura 10:10 which is a continuation of how the people of Jannah shall behave from 10:9. Please lets all be circumspect, we should not just be moved by people with big titles. Some people are out there to mislead others. May the Almighty Allah guide us all.
Just one question: Did you watch the video about Allahhumma with all the evidence we presented? If yes, can you please argue Quranic evidence against Quranic evidence? If you have studied Islamic sciences (which it seems that you have, masha Allahh), you would know that scholars consider the highest, most reliable evidence is the Quranic evidence. So don't brng me a hadeeth and claim that it is nullifying the evidence from Quran. I am waiting. Did you watch the video about Allahhumma in full?
Alhamdulillah. Jazāk Allāhu Khayran Dr Hany for sharing your work and research. At least he now can stop ourselves from continuing to be dupe or mislead and have a proper way of making supplications. May Allah continue to give you guidance in your work and cause.
for many years I have been saying that the second our beloved prophet Muhammad S.A.W passed away, the Jews of Madina (bauda) started this process and the division had to be established (the 2 major sects)in order to control our destiny, they were there for almost 600 yrs waiting for our beloved S.A.W, and Allah S.W.T openly tells us in the Quran about them (the bauda) and yet we became exactly as Allah S.W.T said "they have eyes but yet they are blind, they have ears but yet they are deaf, they have mouths but yet they are dumb" may Allah S.W.T guide and protect us in'sha'allah, shukran for clarifying for what has been in my heart for a very long time, alhamdulillah Allah S.W.T for your guidance
Darood-e Ibrahim a part of Salat, then how do we recite in salat, it start with 'Allahumma'.. 2nd in Hajj & Umrah .لبيك اللهم لبيك لبيك لا شريك لك لبيك إن الحمد والنعمة لك والملك، لا شريك لك لبيك. please explain. Barak Allah.
Evidence based knowledge from Quran directly. I watched the vid a few times and oft had to rewind and then text reveals itself, it's as clear as daylight..Absolutely amazing what you have uncovered that was conceited for 1400 yrs. You have provided critical thinking patterns.. I for one need to reflect and pray on this! These are Standard operating procedures..Alhamdulilah May Allahh bless your tedious efforts and grant you all the success. It has unravelled and revealed beautiful insights and has connected soo many dots!
Yes, shocking as promised indeed. Denial, confuse, panic, relief. all mix up currently. Alhamdulilahh, all these inshaAllah will tear down the shroud covering our qalb. Thank you Dr Hany
سلام عليكم Alhamdulilahh Alhamdulilahh الحمد لله اللذي هدانا لهذا وما كنا لنهتدي لولا أن هدانا الله، لقد جائت رسل ربنا ب الحق . This segment still brings so much raw emotions but Alhamdulilahh Alhamdulilahh for Allahh’s mercy and fadl فضل. الحمد لله رب العالمين ❤
Speechless.....I have seen and been using the Doas with Allahumma all these while without realizing how Allahumma originates and means. all these while I thought that it means O Allah.. thank you Dr Hany for the clear interpretation.
Salam to all faithful brothers and sisters in Islam. I'm a convert in Islam and it's not easy for me to understand many things. I don't believe the words from most Muslims but I read Quran translations myself and try to understand . One day I will be reading Quran. Brother I watched few videos and for me I makes sense . It may be controversial to born Muslims. May Allah bless this brother Hani . I'm sorry of I say the name wrong. I was told by local sheikh's to follow the footsteps of prophet Muhammad. I cannot copy and paste the life of our beloved prophet but I am trying to understand he's teachings. I was given some Darood to memories and send salutations to believed prophet. Brother Hani is busy in important things so I ask any of my brothers and sisters few things. Brother Hani is Talking about " Allah hummah". In the Quran. I can't read Quran so I cannot understand the importance of Allah Hummah. All I know that the Darood I learned by heart also has " Allah Hummah in the beginning. For example Allah Hummah - Swalleh ala Muhammadui wa ala aleh Muhammadin .............. I realize Allah Hummah is mentioned in all Darood . Is it wrong to use this . If it is wrong then what do I do. This is the only Arabic I memorised apart from Sura Iklas after surah fatiha. I'm blessed that I am still learning new things by investigation. I don't care if I end up in hell but what ever I practice in Islam want to do correct way told by Allah. I accept Islam not because of Muslims around me but the knowledge of Quran. Islam gives me strength against the evil powers of man. I feel I am in full control of myself when I study Quran. Please some one tell me how to deal with Allah Hummah in the Darood of Prophet.
@@thebeesnuts777 you need to look for some one who can answer your question not everyone has the answers. This guy hasn't given evidence but twisted words if you listen to him properly and when comments expose him he deletes them like he did to some one's who left a comment under my comment.
@@thebeesnuts777 Well what kind of evidence do you want? This guy has no evidence whatsoever except he just cuts the "Allahumma" part from every prayer/sentence in the Qur'an and claiming it's not part of the prayer or the next sentence. The scholars of islam refers to *every* arabic linguistic experts for 1400 years in their books that are readily accessible even now, they explain that at least Allahumma has 3 meanings.. and one of them is for Calling Allah, but none of them is for cursing. So this guy invent something out of thin air by cutting verses, and you called it evidence and accept it without hesitation. Moreover, you readily accept his explanation that Allah misguides billions of muslims for 1400years into cursing each other, and on top of that you also readily accept that billions of tongues curse the prophet at every time for 1400 years ?? What madness is this?
Please let us know how we can be good to ourselves and to mankind. How to build character & moralities? Muslims are involved in that details that will not be questioned in the judgement day. We should focus on good deeds and stay away from the controversial things. May Allah bless direction all of us on the right path. Ameen.
Thank you very much for this video. It scared me a lot to know that I had been cursing my self all along. Now that I know the truth, its definitely going to to take a lot of effort to re-learn the duas by changing the words. May Almighty Allah bless you always and give you the strength and guidance to produce more of this nature.
Time Stamps 11:56 Allahhumma 17:05 Allahhumma is used in the Hebrew Bible as deities or judges 19:50 Analysis of Allahhumma in the Quran 26:18 Multiple intermediaries 31:57 Its usage among Bani Israel Dawud 40:08 Eissa and Hawariyin 44:18 Analysis of Surah Yunus 57:16 Review 58:08 Nested interpretation of D'awaahum 1:01:15 Linguistic derivation of D'awaahum 1:08:06 Lexical Dictionary analysis of D'awa 1:13:23 How come our scholars are oblivious to this? 1:20:27 People will still argue for Allahumma 1:28:37 Premonition in the Quran that explains our current status 1:39:00 Role of Abrahamic Locution in Dua' 1:46:21 Proper way to start Dua' according to the Quran 1:51:55 The good news: You don't have to be perfect! 1:53:46 An example supplication using Abrahamic locution 1:55:52 What to do with this information?
I couldn't stop crying after seeing this video and YES I have been doing my homework going back to the Qu'ran and looking up word for word I ENCOURAGE ALL MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS TO DO THE SAME. I have seen many mistakes and involvements in wrong activities by the MASJIDS AND MADRASA THE AALIMS IMAMS MUFTI AND HAFIZ but they're heedless all heading together in a crowd to NOWHERE THAT'S THE REASON WHY I HAVE DEPARTED FROM THEM. I THANK ALLAH FOR PROTECTING ME AND SAVING MY MIND FROM THEIR CORRUPTION. Ameen
Same. More I understand the depthneas of the Quran, the more all of these “institutions” start looking like they parrot each other on the most basic principles. Allah is direct with humans with no middle men.
Indeed a wake up call for our community ‼ AlHamdulillah and Thank you for the fruits of Jannah Dr.Hany and team. This segment really broke my heart 💔 recovering slowly. I literally cried when You said that you made a long D'uaa before presenting this video segment. We are 200% fully confident that this channel won't misguide us. Long back I started making D'uaa using RABBANA , RABBI. Now saying no to Allahhahumma. And really don't understand when people arguing for the sake of argument apart from so many evidences given from the Quran. Rabbana, Rabbi ✅✅✅ Allahhahumma ❎❎❎ "Rabbana atina fid dunya hasana wa fil Aakhirati hasana waqina ‘adhaban-nar"
Regarding Salaam not the proper greeting for the believers, can you explain verse 11:69 where Prophet Ibrahim & the angels greeted each other with only “Salaam”?
@ Hassan Mohamed That was only for the pinned comment, only to discourage people who abuse the pinned comment to get their comment to the top of the page. All the other replies I provide do not have that instruction. and people reply to my reply with no problem. Take it easy brother.
asslamualaikum, Thank you. May Allah guide us to true path and help us to understand Devine revelations. Insha Allah will reward you and recompense with good tidings. I am amazed, feel touched deep inside. Fi Amanillah
Dr Hany does this mean we have to omit the part “ in some of the Duas and also Selawat that starts with “Allahumma” …I need to rectify cause I do Supplicate some duas with Allahumma …😟
Salaamun aalikum I find your objection to the use of expression “Ya Allahh” in the supplications to be based on hurried interpretation of the expression “Ya”. When a person calls out to another person by using the expression “Ya” he/she not only seeks the attention of the other person but also turns his/her attention towards that person. Therefore, if the caller is an ordinary insaan and he/she supplicates to ALLAH (SWT) using the expression “Ya Allahh” it actually means that the caller is turning his/her attention towards Allahh (SWT) knowing fully well that Allah (SWT) is always attentive towards His creatures. However, if the person making supplication belongs to the category of Abrar he need not use the expression “Ya Allahh” since Abrar by definition is always attentive towards Allah (SWT), this may explain why Quranic supplication do not use the expression “Ya Allahh”.
For the past one month i have been revisiting my memorization of surah al baqarah and analizing every word that i have memorized in the entire surah. In verse 26 somehow i felt that when reading with the prior and after verses and trying in vain to establish the correct context to the meaning of بعوضة i got stucked. Earlier i understood that بعوضة is translated as mosquito, which is fine to me when the verse is read independent of prior and after verses. The parable of mosquito is quite miraculous in itself but when i tried to link the verse with the adjacent surahs is what made me want to investigate more into the intrinsic and deeper into primitive meaning of root word بعوضة . As i was combing and surfing into youtubes i stumbled into lectures of dr. Hani ahcan on the meaning of word بعوضة which fell into harmony and resonance in context of the other verses prior and after. From then on, i was overwhelmed by the logical, scholarly and thorough expositions of dr. Hani when he interperates the words according to the intrinsic lexicons in the quran itself. His lectures typically last more than an hour, so one needs to be very attentive and serious in his effort to understand the quran inorder to listen to his entire sessions. Never i have been more satisfied about the method of interpretation of quranic verses by dr. Hani that i spent hours after hours listening and exploring with him the true meaning of the words in the quran every day since i discovered dr hani. Everything he explains rings the bell and is like a knock out punch to those who is willing and sincere to listen and accept the truth ...i can't wait to listen to more lectures from dr. Hani.
Alhamdullillah... The Quran was sent down as the greatest book to read, understand, analyze, reflect and ponder at is beauty!! While sadly, millions out there just do speed reciting with absolutely no understanding. May Allah swt make every person ponder over HIS divine book.
what is your answer about this ayah in jannah : دَعْوَاهُمْ فِيهَا سُبْحَانَكَ اللَّهُمَّ وَتَحِيَّتُهُمْ فِيهَا سَلَامٌ ۚ وَآخِرُ دَعْوَاهُمْ أَنِ الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ رَبِّ الْعَالَمِينَ ﴿١٠﴾
Brother, 1. You said that allahumma is not an arabic word, then you equate it with elohim. How did you come to the conclusion ? 2. The strength of your arguments very much relies on the punctuation right after the word 'allahumma'. How did you decide on the punctuation in the verse. Was it based on certain criteria or your own gut feel ?
Re. Question #1, we answered this issue fully in the video Re. Question #2: See Aya 5:114. #issa used Allahhumma followed by Rabbana. When you develop a good understanding of the style of the Quran, you realize that the Quran does not repeat words, back to back, unless it is trying to teach you something: In other words, it is trying to teach you that they are not the same. When you add the fact that 3issa cursed them, it makes perfect sense. This point is reinforced in Aya 3:26 and 39:46 Finally: The strength of the argument does not rely on the issue you mentioned. It relies on the fact that all messengers and prophets in the Quran used Rabbee and Rabbana for their supplications. Over 100 instances!!! This is the true lesson for us if we honor the words of Allahh to be above the words of people. This segment is a test for the audience members. What will your choice be? Allahh's words or people's words?
Subha Allah the prophet pbuh said there will be teachings in the future that not your parents heard or you grand parents and we should watch out for this new teachings. May Allah SWT guide us all and forgive Ur sins and be mercy with us in this dunya and aghira
@@thebeesnuts777 no because our parents did not had that chance cause we was more bothered working in the west.Arabs where mastering math and algebra and many more. Don't make us look stupid akhi. Im just telling watch out for new teachings. It's easy to mix a bit truth with a much greater lie
So essentially since the last 1400 years every scholar and Muslim has been misguided, and no disrespect, this guy figured it out on his own with his research.
Rabbana, make us easy to substitute the wrong word in our supplication, forgive us for our ignorance in using the cursing expression. thank you dr hany for the shocking exposure and alerting us on using the cursing word in du'a. Subhanallah, Allah's way is the best way!
Was the Duaa’ Dario-e-Ibrahim recited during the life time of our beloved Prophet Mohammed SalalauAlayiwasalam? There no Muslim who doesn’t recite this Duaa at least 5 time a day. Allah You are Only one we worship and You are the one we ask for help, please help to clear out this confusion.
It is somewhat mind boggling that none of Al-Farahidi's contemporaries such as Imam Malik, Imam Abu Hanifa and especially Imam Shaafi were unable to pick up this error. Their chosen versions of the Dua-e-Qunoot all begin with Allahhumma!
And you don't think that they were following a chain going back to sayyidina Muhammad (saws) and the rightly guided khulafaa? Imam Malik was born and raised in Madina. As you probably already know, he saw, heard, and learned the 'amal of the people of Madina up close and personal.
@M F First, Al-Farahidy was a grammarian, not a peer to Malik or Abu Hanifa. Second, the books of Tafseer that we have available to us today were all written at least 100-150 years after Al-Farahidy. Third, even if they accepted knowingly his opinion as legitimate, it is not legitimate because, as we said in the video, the Quran never includes "Ya Allahh" as a legitimate supplication. Fourth, do not assume that everyone knew everything that everyone else said. They did not have an easy exchange of information at that time. Fifth, all hadeeths that have been recorded, never mentioned a justification for using Allahhumma in the claimed prophetic supplications. Moreover, all hadeeths were transmitted "by meaning", not verbatim. In other words, it is very possible that this word "Allahhumma" became how they understood the supplications (just like us saying our lord, or 'God' or 'Dieu') and thus transmitted these supplications with this word Good question
@@MarvelousQuran Jazaakallah for your response Dr Atchan. The point you raise that one "should not assume that everyone knew..." is precisely my point. Imam Malik was in Madina and Imam Abu Hanifa in Kufa yet both their Qunoots begin with Allahhumma. I understand your assertion that they were transmitted by meaning in many cases. But if Yaa ALLAHH was not the intended meaning ( because it did not exist in the Quráan) what did these learned scholars transmit as its meaning? Surely some of their Mureeds/students must have written down many of the salient duas transmitted?
@M F @Nathar Daniel I am not sure how many times we need to keep saying: Either you follow the Quran or you follow what we were told that this Imam or that Imam said. We provided the evidence from the Quran. Your argument is basically that we have many people who say otherwise. It's up to you to choose, and insha Allahh, Allahh will open your mind and make you receptive to the truth, not just defending the forefathers blindly. As far as Imam Malik and others: They all lived 150 years after the prophet SAWS. That's 100 years of Umayyad preaching... KEEP THAT IN MIND. Furthermore, none of the original manuscripts are available. The earliest manuscript is at least 200 years after their original authors... In other words, we have what someone said that Imam Malik of Abu Haneefah said, not necessarily verifiable quotes from them directly... Be wise my brothers and stop arguing in vain, just to defend some books that we really do not have authentication of their sources. The Quranic evidence speaks for itself, as we have demonstrated in the video (Please watch it in full) Regards
May Allah bless Dr. Hany-what an awakening call. Is it possible to have a pdf file of this presentation of the information you showed on the screen. Thanks Qur'an commands us to change our view when presented with clear evidence -in line with Qur'an.
Salaamun alaykum..thank u for ur hard work..im using that allahumma for very long time and now im shock.but im thankful to u for this and i wanna practise rabbana..tqvm
I always wondered why muslims said allahuma. I didn’t understand how it can mean ya Allah. I also never understood why muslims say Asalam Alaikum when Salam means peace and Asalam does not. There is no basis for anyone to continue using the word allahuma. RABI 100X RABBANA 100X!!!!!!!!!! TALK TO YOUR LORD DIRECTLY!!!!!!! He is closer to you than your jugular vein so don’t use the phrase ya Allah
@Marvelous Quran in an old segment we learnt ya ayuha ladhina aamanuu is in the past tense and it does not talk about us.. therefore, ayat 3:100 is not talking to us muuminuun?
Good question. I will address the difference between the two in a future segment. But good observation. Having said that, the content of the warning definitely applies to all believers... Don't you agree?
How come the 4 imams, several great scholars, muftis, ulemas, Sufi awliyas, etc, etc. missed this for the last 1400 years??!!
Allahh discloses whatever he chooses to whomever he chooses, for reasons he only knows, and at a time that he chooses!
Only those who want us to believe that Allahh is silent or that Allahh stopped talking to us after the first 3 generations would argue against this.
I don't claim to be better than anyone else, except that Allahh allowed me to see the evidence to be able to express it.
My test and challenge is to present it as best as I can. Insha Allahh I have done so.
Regards
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT.
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT.
PLEASE DO NOT REPLY TO THIS COMMENT.
It will be deleted
Slms dr hany y ha ve confused me how will we make our Allaahumma Sallie Alaa Muhammed after our Attahiyat
Smls dr hany please advise how to read doa after attahiat in salaat Allaahumma Sallie Alaa Muhammed .. plse advise so confused now
Plz explain can we avoid allahumma in durud and atiyihat in salat
I had to leave the tribal Muslim community for years in order to find my way back to the one and only Creator, Allahh azzawajall. I see this channel & revelations have been the answer to my many nights of tears and solemn supplication for Allahh to guide me back to Him.. AlhamdoliLLAHH! Although I still have much to learn, I have complete peace in my heart. JazakAllahu kolla Khalid, brother Hany.
Alhamdulielah, I have rewatched this entire series again and i have enjoyed it so much more! Powerful...! I recommend others to rewatch it again. There is so much information and beautiful nuggets. Shukran Dr. Hany!!!!!
Mr Hani thank u for helping us understand it actually makes sense waiting for your 2022 version realises hope fully soon in sha allah
This is truly shocking to think all this time we were unknowingly duped into practicing and implementing "Shirk". I am reveiwing this video because I never ever want to forget this atrocity and how Allah saved us from commtting such an horendous deed. All of this research you have done on this subject needs to be publiczed to the four corners of the muslim communities. But im afraid that the information would not be receieved. Brother Hany I can't express to you with words how much I appreciate your expertise in revealing the Ibrahamic Locution and sharing it with the world, This is the most important video ever. After all shirk is the unforgivable sin. Allah is truly Al Afuw Ar Ra'uf to those of us who are striving to learn, uncover and implement the truth of Al Quran. Believe me my Dear Brother, I really need Allah's approval to survive in this dunya. Thank you for all of you hard amazing work.
This is one of the best, thoroughly explained with detailed proofs, beautiful and humble presentations. The message is very scary as well. JazakaAllah khair.
Could you please guide me how to recite drood in 5 times salah without using Allahumma. Thanks Jazakallah.
Salamun Aleikum, this really shocked me but makes perfect sense, we need to reflect and accept we were wrong and start by making a change. InshaAllah I will continue my quest for the truth provided by Allah. Thank you Dr Hany!
I agree with that , Dr Hany . I am so lonely on this journey , but I learn so much from Allah and I try to use the du'as that Allah teaches us in His wonderful Qur'an . Adam's du'a is the one which I use the most , cause it suits me better , until now . May peace and blessings from Allah be up on you.
I am so scared right now !!
All my life I used Allahumma
While supplicating
But now …
Salaamun Alaykum thanks Dr Hany! I understand it perfectly now
i’m watching it again and again dr hany jazakallahu khairun. i want to refresh my mind. because when you are in a world full of sheep’s and drowning mass and unthinkable baise, they’ll drag it down with you to the fire with them.
Asalāmu’alaikim Sir,
Indeed humma is prular in Arabic. Can’t thank You enough for awakening me and showing me the right path 🙏🏻
Asalāmu’alaikum Sir,
Sincerely thankful 🥲 for your guidance 🙏🏻
Allah bless you with the best of blessings 🙏🏻
Salamun alaykum dear brother. I’ve incinerated the whole bag of duas containing Allahhuma. Alhamdullilah, Allahh makes it easy for me! Now starting to reload certainty and useful insight to my mental frame. Everything from now on has to be clean and pure.
Alhamdulillahhi maa syaa Allahh...may Allahh guide us all to His true parh.
Alhamdulillahhi maa syaa Allahh...may Allahh guide us all to His true parh.
@@nikhassan6148 amin brother
Very important question. Please reply! I am a new Muslim. Could you kindly tell me how will I say the Darood-e-Ibrahimi (the one we read in the salah) without Allahhuma?
Let you can start with Rabbana Salli Ala Muhammad wa Ala Aale Muhammad , Kamaa Sallaita Alaa Ibraheem wa Alaa Aale Ibraheem, InnakavHamidummajeed.
One scholar is Much more Better than Thousands of worshippers in the sight of Almighty Allah.
Dr Hany you are the real scholar
No one did a research for for a single aya like this
Islam was hijacked damaged
Our mission is to restore it in its original form
@@nafisaahmed9682 were you one of them? who joined 3 months ago just to reply for embarassing yourself..
@@nafisaahmed9682 give me evidence or prove
In any of His lectures I am ready leave this channel.
Be open minded
Empty your cup
Unlearn
Ask questions
Alhamthu Lillah
Almighty May open up your heart
Almighty May show you the hidden knowledge
Insha Allah
1400 years we are living with Divine Book
Observe our Islamic ummah
Compare the nature of our community with other community without a Divine Book
Start giving scores both side
In which area we are better than others
In which area we are not better than others
For 1400yrs Muslim were cursing themselves in Dua, how cud Allah used same generation to transmitting the Quran to us, the Quran that this guy has no problem to use it as a evidence to support his argument while he knows very well that this Quran had passed through to those people who were cursed themselves in Dua, how cud Allah do that, I really I don't understand and it does not make sense,
We provided the answer in the video. Being cursed means to be deprived of direct guidance. It does not mean that Allahh took away all your other faculties such as memorization, or the human ability to write and preserve copies of the Quran.
Please learn the basics of monotheism before you get yourself in more trouble, defending the errors of the forefathers, because you are too afraid to trust Allahh, and you are too ungrateful to give credit to Allahh for all the blessings he gave you, including preserving the Quran!
Furthermore, I did not say that everyone was cursed! All it takes is a few people whom Allahh guided to transmit the Quran correctly! Those who mis-spoke about the Quran and misguided people were not the real transmitters of the Quran. As a matter of fact, there are hundreds of Sahabas who transmitted the Quran but we have never heard any hadeeth or any interpretation from. So the two groups are NOT the same!
As I said in my reply to your other comment:
Allahh preserved the Quran FOR you. Do you want to give credit to humans for the preservation of the Quran???
You are like someone who wants to give credit to his parents for the perfect creation Allahh gave him!
Are you that ignorant??? Are you that ungrateful to Allahh???
This issue needs to be discussed by prominent scholars around the world. We cannot just jump into conclution and accept the opinion of one single person. It involves the recitation of our daily prayers.
@ fitt Rege
Scholars who do not surrender to the primacy and irrefutability of Quranic evidence should never be consulted regarding the Quran.
Assalamualaikum Dr Hany. I am a revert and have been making a deliberate conscious effort to learn to read the Quran over the last 6 years. I have been also been referring to the available translations to understand the Quran. I came across your Channel from a comment in another channel that does some amazing interviews and I became curious about Marvelous Quran. I have been listening to all your videos and I am deeply affected by these new discoveries. I have listened to this particular video more that 5 tines and it has really been on my mind and I have been asking Allah for guidance. Today, I was reading Surah An Naml and when I read verses 27:60-64, I felt a shift. I continued to read the translations to the end of the Surah. And I wanted to share this with you. May Allah guide us to that which benefits us.
@ siti sarah cardoza
Alhamdulillah. May Allahh increase you in sincerity and bring you ever closer to him alone
Peace be with you, Dr. Hani. Listening to your critical analysis sure helped me in better understanding myself.
Timestamp 1:33:51 "Being preached by Jews and Christian theologians through the Ummayad Dynsty" really caught my attention. I was wondering if there's any video of you dealing with your understanding of the Historic Islam and its roots in Arabia and as to what followed after the Prophet passed away until the time when first recorded Tafseer/Tareekh begin circulation.
Im just a regular 45 yr old fellow-Muslim from Pakistan, trying to understand what caused us to come all the way to LIVE the MOMENTS that the scripture seems to use as WARNING and CLEAR SIGNS.
May you be among the MOMINEEN.
-v-
Allahumma was mentioned in the Quran 5 times, It is most definitely an Arabic word. and Allah uses it in the Quran to teach us how to make supplications.It was used once by normal people, and 4 other times by prophets and as Duaa of people in the Janna. Do not mistranslate the Quran for Allah is close by and will hold you responsible for what you say and do.
Watch the video
@@thebeesnuts777 the point is اللهم is 100% Arabic, I watched the video and it is totally not convincing. I am an Arab Muslim and I know my Arabic well. Allah would not include a foreign non Arabic word in the Quran when he clearly says many times that he delivered an Arabic Quran, and the Quran in a clear Arabic tongue. Furthermore, the prophet who is Arabic mentioned اللهم in many Hadith. The Arabic prophet peace be upon him who speaks in Arabic tongue does not include a Hebrew word in his speech. Don’t follow blindly and think and reflect yourself to know the truth. اللهم is NOT a curse may Allah forbid. This is by far the most outrageous explanation I heard.
When Arab Christians use the word Allah does that has the same meaning as the word Allah used by Muslims? So, even if we assume that the word Allahumma has another origin, how can we conclude that they will have the same meaning irrespective of the context.
@@imamibrahim6282 Allah for Muslims is the same as Allah for Christians and is the same for Allah for Jews. Allah Subhannah is the God of Ibrahim peace be upon him. Allah was known to all prophets for all faiths by this name.
When we supplicate to Allah and we say Subhana Allahum Wa Bihamdik سبحانك اللهم وبحمدك which was also a Duaa or supplication of the prophet Muhammad peace be upon him what do you think that means according to this video ? Or when Pilgroms say لبيك اللهم لبيك، what do you think it means ? Your proposal not only misinterprets Arabic and Quran text, it also misinterprets the value and meaning and context of use of Allah’s name glorified is He. I advise you to delete this video and withdraw your proposal. May Allah forgive you.
I just heard this talk.. this makes me shivers knowing that my whole life saying allahumma.. may Allah forgive Us all And keep guiding Us. Amin
Salaamun alaikum Dr. Hany. I am just half way through your segment and I have tears in my eyes. Thank you for bringing us this truth. Alhamdulillah.
Alhamdulillah dr. Hany, Allahh has bestowed better response since i hv started using Rabbi and stopped using Allahumma.
You have proved it beyond doubt, height of ignorance in fact we have institutionalised ignorance and then value the ignorance no parralals in human history!
Al hamdulillahil Rabbil alemin. May Allah bless u with all the best for teaching me and us this such IMPORTANT lecture!
The biggest mistake in his reasoning is that he compares Arabic اللهم with Hebrew elohim. Elohim in the testaments is used to call Allah, the fact that it's plural in linguistic perspective has nothing to do with polytheism! We read also Allah which is masculin in Arabic, does it mean that Allah is masculin too? Nonsense don't relate physical aspects to grammatical one's! Furthermore he said first that Allahomma means according to elohim 'polydieties'.......after he said that it's a cursing word...that doesn't sound logic to me. His interpretation of the verses are also full of errors.
But I thought Allah swt, refer to Himself as "WE"
@@mrs210 so did the queen of England.
Jazakallahu khairan kathiran. Thank you very much for this.
سبحان الله العظيم
I don’t know if this has been mentioned or not but ‘dakwa’ (pronounced as دَكْوَا) means accuse, claim, reckon, declare in Malay. Obviously adopted from Arabic thanks to you. You just taught me an etymology of another language.
كشجرة طيبة ❤
That's one good reason to not say prefabricated prayers constructed by someone other than yourself. It's important to have an open conversation with your creator during a servants entire life.
Say, "Call him Allah or Ar RaHman, in whichever way/name you call him, his are the best names. Do not be to loud in Salah, not be to low in it. And seek a way in between. Quran 17:110
The correct way. Allah does not reject salah made with a pure and sincere heart. No matter what popular non Quranic teachings say.
Well said 🤲🏼
I don't know whether to agree or disagree, but I have been pondering, searching for some time n couldn't really get some words. This is one of them it always ringged a bell to me as elohim .
@Mfvpill
Keep watching. I have discussed this issue further (with more evidence) in YT170 and again in YT178. You can find these segments on the channel page.
HOW COME ONLY YOU WHO KNOWS THIS?
HAVE THE BILLIONS OF MUSLIMS AND ULEMA, CURRENTLY AND THE SAHABAHS HAVE NOT KNOWN IT?
I agree with you whole heartedly. How come he is the first one to mention it. And the way he explains the use of Allahjma in the Quran is completely misguided. Twisting your tongue is not enough to argue your point dr hani.
@ C Hasan
@ Sarah Hopeful
Just one question: Did you watch the video about Allahhumma with all the Quranic evidence we presented?
If yes, can you please argue Quranic evidence against Quranic evidence?
If you have studied Islamic sciences (which it seems that you have, masha Allahh), you would know that scholars consider the highest, most reliable evidence is the Quranic evidence. So don't bring me a hadeeth and claim that it is nullifying the evidence from Quran.
I am waiting.
Did you watch the video about Allahhumma in full?
Your argument about all the people before us who were misguided was used by the Christians and the Jews against our beloved SAWS. Please be careful not to use their arguments against the Quranic evidence we presented.
@@MarvelousQuranYou are using the same tactics as the poeple of the book by using their writing to put new meanings to the verses of the Quran.
Your knowledge of Arabic may fool few Muslims in believing the outrageous assertion you put forward because they understandably are not Arabes, but you are not fooling anyone who knows Arabic.
I have not watched your other videos so my comments are related to this particular video and subject. You asked about my credentials, but I am not the one putting out videos with shocking titles. May I ask you in what field did you obtain your doctorate?
Please review surah 8 : 32 in regular translation whose say allahuma. Those are disbeliefer who inquire answer from they own gods. If you can see it, then i dont know. Anyway, its mention at 27:55
@@entdre is it common to start a sentence with " say:" in the imperative and include a word that is should not be used in what you have been asked to say?
His assertion as completely strange and weird . Please don't fall for his so called know knowledge of arabic. If you are not an Arabic speaker you should at least relay on the understanding of those who spent their life dedicating it for the honest reading of the Quran.
This dr make the mistaken assertion that the word Alkahuma is in fact the word illuhim found in the bible. He took the definition of the word illuhim and applied it to the word Allahuma in order to distort the meaning of the verses of the Quran.
I can not believe the sheer ignorance displayed in this video.
Thank you Dr. Atchan for bringing the Truth to the ummah. I pray that your interpretation of the Quran by engaging the methodology defined in the Quran touches the heart of all including the ummah. Thanks for teaching us to supplicate using Rabbi and Rabbana.
Barakallahu fiikum. May Allah bless you and all of us. Alhamdulillah for the knowledge.
Hamduli'llah, this is very important information. I was always suspicious of this word. Thank you.
The Truth is not a relic or an object that anyone can possess.
The Truth does not belong to a specific group, sect, denomination, people or nation.
The Truth is not dependant on the number of people to hold on to a particular creed, doctrine or ideology.
The Truth is not a set of rituals and dogma to blindly follow.
Our Lord, guide us ever closer to the truth, our Lord guide us ever closer towards You.
BEAUTIFUL
I do not understand and confused about what he is saying.here. “ Dorude Ibrahim” was recited by our prophet, his sahabees, his family members , four Imams and we as well as all Muslims in every salat.
Aslm Dr. Hany,
Always grateful for your time and effort to share. Alhamdulillah.
امیدوارم به فضل کرم ورحمت پروردگار عالمها که به صراط مستقیم گام نهم وتشکر فراوان از شما برادر مهربان
JAZZAKALLAH:- MAY ALLAH KAREEM REWARD you BEYOND my THOUGHTS. You ARE MAKING SURGERY KEEP IT ON TO MAKE us HEALTHY. FEAMANALLAH KAREEM.
Language brings a new era. When the usage of a language is good and proper, the era becomes decent and prosperous. And when the usage of language becomes corrupted and indecent, the era of indecency erupts and the downfall of humanity starts and continues until the corrupted language has been abandoned and that language has been purified. Human beings distinct themselves from all creatures and become the masters of this tool called language.
This session has brought us to show the usage of Millat Ibrahim to purify our language. It’s also a cutting edge between the users of the purified language and the corrupted usage and users of the misguided language. This reveals a sad truth that we would be separated from our acquaintances through the usage of the proper language and would never see them again in afterlife unless they come back to this new era of purification and prosperity :’(
Asalmu alaikum how you can explain talbiya of hajj laabik allhahumma laabik
Salam aleikoum, i noticed that the imperative verb(s) that are used in supplications is not there after the “allahumma” in the 39-46, isn’t it another hint that “wa 9ul allahumma” is split from the rest of the aya?!
Rabbi zidna 3ilma
May allah reward you with evenmore knowledge for all the thourough work you do! Thank you Dr Hani
Good observation!
Journey is getting more and more intriguing day by day. Information in Each video segment is just phenomenal than other. Yes, we truly support your brand new findings in Qur'an, criticizers must need to enrich their knowledge. It's all a common sense but the dogmas laid by dear brainy responsibility taking scholars say, "NO, THINKING NOT ALLOWED,ELSE 👽"
اللهم ادم علينا نعمة الاسلام ، والطف بنا واحطنا برعايتك. اللهم ابعد عنا شر الخلق من كل دجال وفاسق. انت مولانا وعليك نتوكل في امور ديننا ودنيانا.لك الشكر ولك الحمد واليك المصير.
To be duped for 1400 years is exaggerating and disrespect of ulama in the earliest history of Islam.
All lectures by our known ulama make use of "Allahumma"..
@ Jangan Marah
Let me ask you a simple question: Do the Jews and Christians before us have scholars and Ulamaa who were duped into teaching the wrong thing?
Why do you think we are immune to that?
@@MarvelousQuran
Can I answer you with this question? Have you spoken to Islamic scholars before you claimed you were given knowledge unknown to the earliest ulama in the history of Islam and declared yourself champion in bringing your findings to the muslim masses in the youtube?
Why don't you declare your findings to the islamic authorities in many muslim countries before you rudely and disrespectfully calling muslims duped for thousand of years?
Don't be like another Yasir Qadhi!
Please don't compare Jews and Christian Bible scholars with Muslim Quranic scholars because their source are different.
Alhamdulillah
Reviewing past videos as I'm waiting for the new video regarding the same topic
These are the very people who brings misguidance to those with little or no knowledge of Islam. Islam is simple and beautiful. Allahuma is beseeching Allah in a humble way, and you twisting the words of Allah.
Salamun alaykum brother! May be if you watch again this segment tentatively, the word twisting will disappear forever in your journey to Allahh
@@nazimnasir71 Labeka allahuma labeyk then this one is false right? Do you guys believe any ahadiths like bukhari or ... Muslim
@ Bahdon Dahir
If you had watched the full video with the intention to learn, you would have learned that I used a hadeeth to confirm what I said. So stop being cynical and learn. Cynicism is only blocking you, my brother! It does not hurt anyone else.
I agree with you, brother. He is misguiding the Muslims. Ellohim was never understood by the ancient ppl as many gods. The sufix -im is a plural of respect. And was understood like that. I listened Jewish Rabbis explaining that very good.
The great Islamic schoolers of old age, knew that too, that's why they did never had a problem with Allahumma.
I speak 3 languages and all of these languages still have a plural of respect when you speak formally. If I talk to someone that is not very close to me like a friend or a family member, or if I write a formal letter, I always address the person with the pronoun in the plural, but that doesn't mean that I think that I speak to more than one.
The brother made right in the beginning this big mistake and has built a whole case on a wrong preposition. He need to understand that it's not enough to know the language, but also the context, how did the ppl of those times understood it? That's why it matters very much, how did our great schoolers, those who came not long time after the revelation, how did they understood it? They did not see any flaw in the use of Allahumma, right?
@Safya Farooq
You can accuse me of whatever you want. However, plz consider two issues:
1. Do we ever address Allahh in Duaa in the plural, even in the majestic plural?
2. Did any of the messengers and prophets in the Quran use Allahhumma for Duaa? Don't we have over 100 examples of messengers and prophets in the Quran using Rabbee or Rabbana for Duaa?
Stop arguing in vain, just to defend the writings of people you don't know, who transmitted verbal reports without any authoritativeness.
Subhanallah
While going revision of all the segments I managed to see this again. First time I didn’t understand in detail but today I have realised how important it is to take Allah words as authority. No wonder almost all Muslim ummah is following intermediaries in one or other forms. Especially taking words of Muhammad SA as authority over Quran without trying to investigate weather he could have said this and second taking opinion of sheikhs or immams in the form of fatwa over Devine lexicon. I can only hope Allah may guid them if he wills. Most of Muslims do supplication which are handed down the generations as traditions.
Salamum alaykum,
Alhumdulilah. Following your research videos, learning and correcting our understanding. Thank you Dr. Hany.
May Allah accept your efforts, lead us on self-correcting methodology and guide us.
My dear fellow muslims and all those who want to be guided, please pick the Qur'an and read those verses he has cited yourself. If you don't understand Arabic like myself pick one with english translation. Read the verses before those with "Allahhumma" and judge for yourself. Most of the things he said in the video are his own interpolations. I entreat you to read Sura 5:114, which is a prayer by prophet Issah (as) and Sura 10:10 which is a continuation of how the people of Jannah shall behave from 10:9.
Please lets all be circumspect, we should not just be moved by people with big titles. Some people are out there to mislead others. May the Almighty Allah guide us all.
Just one question: Did you watch the video about Allahhumma with all the evidence we presented?
If yes, can you please argue Quranic evidence against Quranic evidence?
If you have studied Islamic sciences (which it seems that you have, masha Allahh), you would know that scholars consider the highest, most reliable evidence is the Quranic evidence. So don't brng me a hadeeth and claim that it is nullifying the evidence from Quran.
I am waiting.
Did you watch the video about Allahhumma in full?
Amazing, Dr Hany. JazzakaLlahu khayran for this insightful and inspiring presentation.
Alhamdulillah.
Jazāk Allāhu Khayran Dr Hany for sharing your work and research. At least he now can stop ourselves from continuing to be dupe or mislead and have a proper way of making supplications. May Allah continue to give you guidance in your work and cause.
for many years I have been saying that the second our beloved prophet Muhammad S.A.W passed away, the Jews of Madina (bauda) started this process and the division had to be established (the 2 major sects)in order to control our destiny, they were there for almost 600 yrs waiting for our beloved S.A.W, and Allah S.W.T openly tells us in the Quran about them (the bauda) and yet we became exactly as Allah S.W.T said "they have eyes but yet they are blind, they have ears but yet they are deaf, they have mouths but yet they are dumb" may Allah S.W.T guide and protect us in'sha'allah, shukran for clarifying for what has been in my heart for a very long time, alhamdulillah Allah S.W.T for your guidance
Please stop using S.W.T in your prayers and watch the dr other lectures, ta’ala is not what you think it is…
AlhamduLillah
Darood-e Ibrahim a part of Salat, then how do we recite in salat, it start with 'Allahumma'.. 2nd in Hajj & Umrah .لبيك اللهم لبيك لبيك لا شريك لك لبيك إن الحمد والنعمة لك والملك، لا شريك لك لبيك. please explain. Barak Allah.
May Allah help us!!!
Evidence based knowledge from Quran directly. I watched the vid a few times and oft had to rewind and then text reveals itself, it's as clear as daylight..Absolutely amazing what you have uncovered that was conceited for 1400 yrs. You have provided critical thinking patterns.. I for one need to reflect and pray on this! These are Standard operating procedures..Alhamdulilah
May Allahh bless your tedious efforts and grant you all the success. It has unravelled and revealed beautiful insights and has connected soo many dots!
Yes, shocking as promised indeed. Denial, confuse, panic, relief. all mix up currently. Alhamdulilahh, all these inshaAllah will tear down the shroud covering our qalb. Thank you Dr Hany
سلام عليكم
Alhamdulilahh Alhamdulilahh
الحمد لله اللذي هدانا لهذا وما كنا لنهتدي لولا أن هدانا الله، لقد جائت رسل ربنا ب الحق . This segment still brings so much raw emotions but Alhamdulilahh Alhamdulilahh for Allahh’s mercy and fadl فضل. الحمد لله رب العالمين ❤
Speechless.....I have seen and been using the Doas with Allahumma all these while without realizing how Allahumma originates and means. all these while I thought that it means O Allah.. thank you Dr Hany for the clear interpretation.
syaitan will always make you indoubt of the truth,
in our salawat we start with "alhumassolliàla muhammad",
the person that you thank are an imposter,
Alhamdulillahh! So much information.
Salam to all faithful brothers and sisters in Islam.
I'm a convert in Islam and it's not easy for me to understand many things.
I don't believe the words from most Muslims but I read Quran translations myself and try to understand .
One day I will be reading Quran.
Brother I watched few videos and for me I makes sense . It may be controversial to born Muslims.
May Allah bless this brother Hani . I'm sorry of I say the name wrong.
I was told by local sheikh's to follow the footsteps of prophet Muhammad. I cannot copy and paste the life of our beloved prophet but I am trying to understand he's teachings.
I was given some Darood to memories and send salutations to believed prophet.
Brother Hani is busy in important things so I ask any of my brothers and sisters few things.
Brother Hani is Talking about " Allah hummah". In the Quran. I can't read Quran so I cannot understand the importance of Allah Hummah.
All I know that the Darood I learned by heart also has " Allah Hummah in the beginning.
For example
Allah Hummah - Swalleh ala Muhammadui wa ala aleh Muhammadin ..............
I realize Allah Hummah is mentioned in all Darood . Is it wrong to use this .
If it is wrong then what do I do.
This is the only Arabic I memorised apart from Sura Iklas after surah fatiha.
I'm blessed that I am still learning new things by investigation.
I don't care if I end up in hell but what ever I practice in Islam want to do correct way told by Allah.
I accept Islam not because of Muslims around me but the knowledge of Quran.
Islam gives me strength against the evil powers of man.
I feel I am in full control of myself when I study Quran.
Please some one tell me how to deal with Allah Hummah in the Darood of Prophet.
Watch the next video segment after this one. It clarifies some of the concepts. Basically, replace Allahhumma with Rabbee.
Regards
Hany
@@MarvelousQuran Salaam Dr.Hani, may i start Darood with Rabbanna instaed of Allahumma ? pls reply
Regards.
I can't believe people are actually falling for this. It is important to ask your scholars and not take things from UA-cam.
Does that mean that everything on UA-cam is wrong?
People falling for satanism.. this is lesser, arguably 😂
@@thebeesnuts777 you need to look for some one who can answer your question not everyone has the answers. This guy hasn't given evidence but twisted words if you listen to him properly and when comments expose him he deletes them like he did to some one's who left a comment under my comment.
@@housse51 this is no less but could be more.
@@thebeesnuts777 Well what kind of evidence do you want?
This guy has no evidence whatsoever except he just cuts the "Allahumma" part from every prayer/sentence in the Qur'an and claiming it's not part of the prayer or the next sentence.
The scholars of islam refers to *every* arabic linguistic experts for 1400 years in their books that are readily accessible even now, they explain that at least Allahumma has 3 meanings.. and one of them is for Calling Allah, but none of them is for cursing.
So this guy invent something out of thin air by cutting verses, and you called it evidence and accept it without hesitation. Moreover, you readily accept his explanation that Allah misguides billions of muslims for 1400years into cursing each other, and on top of that you also readily accept that billions of tongues curse the prophet at every time for 1400 years ?? What madness is this?
Please let us know how we can be good to ourselves and to mankind. How to build character & moralities? Muslims are involved in that details that will not be questioned in the judgement day. We should focus on good deeds and stay away from the controversial things. May Allah bless direction all of us on the right path. Ameen.
Thank you very much for this video. It scared me a lot to know that I had been cursing my self all along. Now that I know the truth, its definitely going to to take a lot of effort to re-learn the duas by changing the words. May Almighty Allah bless you always and give you the strength and guidance to produce more of this nature.
Insha Allahh
Time Stamps
11:56 Allahhumma
17:05 Allahhumma is used in the Hebrew Bible as deities or judges
19:50 Analysis of Allahhumma in the Quran
26:18 Multiple intermediaries
31:57 Its usage among Bani Israel Dawud
40:08 Eissa and Hawariyin
44:18 Analysis of Surah Yunus
57:16 Review
58:08 Nested interpretation of D'awaahum
1:01:15 Linguistic derivation of D'awaahum
1:08:06 Lexical Dictionary analysis of D'awa
1:13:23 How come our scholars are oblivious to this?
1:20:27 People will still argue for Allahumma
1:28:37 Premonition in the Quran that explains our current status
1:39:00 Role of Abrahamic Locution in Dua'
1:46:21 Proper way to start Dua' according to the Quran
1:51:55 The good news: You don't have to be perfect!
1:53:46 An example supplication using Abrahamic locution
1:55:52 What to do with this information?
@ Nomad Jinn
Thank you very much. Loaded it into the chapter list.
Thank you Sir
Salamuin Alyikum....3:24 nar touch or effect ?
I couldn't stop crying after seeing this video and YES I have been doing my homework going back to the Qu'ran and looking up word for word I ENCOURAGE ALL MY BROTHERS AND SISTERS TO DO THE SAME.
I have seen many mistakes and involvements in wrong activities by the MASJIDS AND MADRASA THE AALIMS IMAMS MUFTI AND HAFIZ but they're heedless all heading together in a crowd to NOWHERE THAT'S THE REASON WHY I HAVE DEPARTED FROM THEM. I THANK ALLAH FOR PROTECTING ME AND SAVING MY MIND FROM THEIR CORRUPTION. Ameen
Same.
More I understand the depthneas of the Quran, the more all of these “institutions” start looking like they parrot each other on the most basic principles. Allah is direct with humans with no middle men.
I am blown away ........
Alhamdulillah, Allah guided me to your channel, finally learning with contentment
This session made me so teary ....😭😭😭
We are BLESSED ALLAH made us find YOU DR. HANY ❤ Alhumdulillah .May Allah except all your efforts Ameen .
Indeed a wake up call for our community ‼
AlHamdulillah and Thank you for the fruits of Jannah Dr.Hany and team.
This segment really broke my heart 💔 recovering slowly. I literally cried when You said that you made a long D'uaa before presenting this video segment. We are 200% fully confident that this channel won't misguide us.
Long back I started making D'uaa using RABBANA , RABBI. Now saying no to Allahhahumma.
And really don't understand when people arguing for the sake of argument apart from so many evidences given from the Quran.
Rabbana, Rabbi ✅✅✅
Allahhahumma ❎❎❎
"Rabbana atina fid dunya hasana wa fil Aakhirati hasana waqina ‘adhaban-nar"
Thank you for helping me see the light.
Shocking revealations… Tq very much Dr Hany for your abundance efforts…. I feel like crying..May Allah guides us all before it’s too late..Ameen…
Regarding Salaam not the proper greeting for the believers, can you explain verse 11:69 where Prophet Ibrahim & the angels greeted each other with only “Salaam”?
And when you write "don't reply to your reply". For us it means you don't want to be challenged. That is not a scholarly attitude Dr. Hany.
@ Hassan Mohamed
That was only for the pinned comment, only to discourage people who abuse the pinned comment to get their comment to the top of the page.
All the other replies I provide do not have that instruction. and people reply to my reply with no problem.
Take it easy brother.
1:58:03 ❤Alhamdulillahh, listenung again, this is too beautiful, full of infor. Thanks Dr. HA. Love u
asslamualaikum, Thank you. May Allah guide us to true path and help us to understand Devine revelations. Insha Allah will reward you and recompense with good tidings. I am amazed, feel touched deep inside. Fi Amanillah
Thank Allah to educate a brother for such blessings and beautiful descriptions for meaningful work
Thanks again Dr Hany
Thanks so much, Dr Hany
Dr Hany does this mean we have to omit the part “ in some of the Duas and also Selawat that starts with “Allahumma” …I need to rectify cause I do Supplicate some duas with Allahumma …😟
YES Brother.......He already answered someone else in the comment section
Quran 3:26 Say! Allhumma malik al Mulk. --- Allahumma cannot be a cursing phrase.
@pkasb90
We detailed this aya in the video...
Please watch the video in full
watch this part 38:50 and of course, think before you talk. i am sure you are new to this channel or not paying any attention while watching.
@@MarvelousQuran Salam Dr.Hany, so Therefore ALLAHUMMA means Allah Curse them?
Salaamun aalikum
I find your objection to the use of expression “Ya Allahh” in the supplications to be based on hurried interpretation of the expression “Ya”. When a person calls out to another person by using the expression “Ya” he/she not only seeks the attention of the other person but also turns his/her attention towards that person. Therefore, if the caller is an ordinary insaan and he/she supplicates to ALLAH (SWT) using the expression “Ya Allahh” it actually means that the caller is turning his/her attention towards Allahh (SWT) knowing fully well that Allah (SWT) is always attentive towards His creatures. However, if the person making supplication belongs to the category of Abrar he need not use the expression “Ya Allahh” since Abrar by definition is always attentive towards Allah (SWT), this may explain why Quranic supplication do not use the expression “Ya Allahh”.
Give me one duaa where a messenger or a prophet used "Ya" in the Quran.
Why should we resist learning from the Quran so much?
Hasten interpretation indeed!
For the past one month i have been revisiting my memorization of surah al baqarah and analizing every word that i have memorized in the entire surah.
In verse 26 somehow i felt that when reading with the prior and after verses and trying in vain to establish the correct context to the meaning of بعوضة i got stucked. Earlier i understood that بعوضة is translated as mosquito, which is fine to me when the verse is read independent of prior and after verses. The parable of mosquito is quite miraculous in itself but when i tried to link the verse with the adjacent surahs is what made me want to investigate more into the intrinsic and deeper into primitive meaning of root word بعوضة . As i was combing and surfing into youtubes i stumbled into lectures of dr. Hani ahcan on the meaning of word بعوضة which fell into harmony and resonance in context of the other verses prior and after.
From then on, i was overwhelmed by the logical, scholarly and thorough expositions of dr. Hani when he interperates the words according to the intrinsic lexicons in the quran itself. His lectures typically last more than an hour, so one needs to be very attentive and serious in his effort to understand the quran inorder to listen to his entire sessions. Never i have been more satisfied about the method of interpretation of quranic verses by dr. Hani that i spent hours after hours listening and exploring with him the true meaning of the words in the quran every day since i discovered dr hani.
Everything he explains rings the bell and is like a knock out punch to those who is willing and sincere to listen and accept the truth ...i can't wait to listen to more lectures from dr. Hani.
@ Zahari Man
Alhamdulillah my brother. It's all from Allahh.
Glad that it is resonating with you
Regards
Alhamdullillah... The Quran was sent down as the greatest book to read, understand, analyze, reflect and ponder at is beauty!!
While sadly, millions out there just do speed reciting with absolutely no understanding.
May Allah swt make every person ponder over HIS divine book.
what is your answer about this ayah in jannah : دَعْوَاهُمْ فِيهَا سُبْحَانَكَ اللَّهُمَّ وَتَحِيَّتُهُمْ فِيهَا سَلَامٌ ۚ وَآخِرُ دَعْوَاهُمْ أَنِ الْحَمْدُ لِلَّهِ رَبِّ الْعَالَمِينَ ﴿١٠﴾
Watch the video. Watch the video. Watch the video!!!!!!
Excellent Research. JasakAllah for enlighteneing the Muslims Ummah.
Brother,
1. You said that allahumma is not an arabic word, then you equate it with elohim. How did you come to the conclusion ?
2. The strength of your arguments very much relies on the punctuation right after the word 'allahumma'. How did you decide on the punctuation in the verse. Was it based on certain criteria or your own gut feel ?
Re. Question #1, we answered this issue fully in the video
Re. Question #2: See Aya 5:114. #issa used Allahhumma followed by Rabbana. When you develop a good understanding of the style of the Quran, you realize that the Quran does not repeat words, back to back, unless it is trying to teach you something: In other words, it is trying to teach you that they are not the same. When you add the fact that 3issa cursed them, it makes perfect sense.
This point is reinforced in Aya 3:26 and 39:46
Finally: The strength of the argument does not rely on the issue you mentioned. It relies on the fact that all messengers and prophets in the Quran used Rabbee and Rabbana for their supplications. Over 100 instances!!!
This is the true lesson for us if we honor the words of Allahh to be above the words of people.
This segment is a test for the audience members. What will your choice be? Allahh's words or people's words?
What about the dua' Rasulullah ﷺ taught Aeishah to recite on the night of lailatulqadr:
*ٱللّٰهُمَّ انك عفو تحب العفو فاعف عني*
وٱللّٰهُ اعلم..
Subha Allah the prophet pbuh said there will be teachings in the future that not your parents heard or you grand parents and we should watch out for this new teachings. May Allah SWT guide us all and forgive Ur sins and be mercy with us in this dunya and aghira
@@thebeesnuts777 no because our parents did not had that chance cause we was more bothered working in the west.Arabs where mastering math and algebra and many more. Don't make us look stupid akhi. Im just telling watch out for new teachings. It's easy to mix a bit truth with a much greater lie
@@thebeesnuts777 you free to disagree and nobody is talking about shirk.
A punch in the stomach again... JAZAKALLAH SIR for your efforts .SCARRY BUT BEAUTIFUL.....MAY ALLAHH REWARD YOU AND YOUR FAMILY AND GUIDE US ALL...
So essentially since the last 1400 years every scholar and Muslim has been misguided, and no disrespect, this guy figured it out on his own with his research.
Rabbana, make us easy to substitute the wrong word in our supplication, forgive us for our ignorance in using the cursing expression. thank you dr hany for the shocking exposure and alerting us on using the cursing word in du'a. Subhanallah, Allah's way is the best way!
Good to know
Alhamdulillah Aamiin MaashaAllah thank you Dr.Hany
I just wonder that "Did Muhammad (SAW) include the part of Salawat nabi, Allahummasalli Ala Muhammad, in his prayer before Salam?"
Please let us know Dr Hany
Yes Dr Hany we the Indian in our court proceeding use the exact the same word Daowa for claim
Was the Duaa’ Dario-e-Ibrahim recited during the life time of our beloved Prophet Mohammed SalalauAlayiwasalam? There no Muslim who doesn’t recite this Duaa at least 5 time a day. Allah You are Only one we worship and You are the one we ask for help, please help to clear out this confusion.
Very insightful --- full of wisdom -- and surprising too. May Allah reward you for your efforts and sharing your discoveries with us.❤❤❤👋👋👋
It is somewhat mind boggling that none of Al-Farahidi's contemporaries such as Imam Malik, Imam Abu Hanifa and especially Imam Shaafi were unable to pick up this error. Their chosen versions of the Dua-e-Qunoot all begin with Allahhumma!
And you don't think that they were following a chain going back to sayyidina Muhammad (saws) and the rightly guided khulafaa?
Imam Malik was born and raised in Madina. As you probably already know, he saw, heard, and learned the 'amal of the people of Madina up close and personal.
@M F
First, Al-Farahidy was a grammarian, not a peer to Malik or Abu Hanifa.
Second, the books of Tafseer that we have available to us today were all written at least 100-150 years after Al-Farahidy.
Third, even if they accepted knowingly his opinion as legitimate, it is not legitimate because, as we said in the video, the Quran never includes "Ya Allahh" as a legitimate supplication.
Fourth, do not assume that everyone knew everything that everyone else said. They did not have an easy exchange of information at that time.
Fifth, all hadeeths that have been recorded, never mentioned a justification for using Allahhumma in the claimed prophetic supplications. Moreover, all hadeeths were transmitted "by meaning", not verbatim. In other words, it is very possible that this word "Allahhumma" became how they understood the supplications (just like us saying our lord, or 'God' or 'Dieu') and thus transmitted these supplications with this word
Good question
@@MarvelousQuran Jazaakallah for your response Dr Atchan. The point you raise that one "should not assume that everyone knew..." is precisely my point. Imam Malik was in Madina and Imam Abu Hanifa in Kufa yet both their Qunoots begin with Allahhumma. I understand your assertion that they were transmitted by meaning in many cases. But if Yaa ALLAHH was not the intended meaning ( because it did not exist in the Quráan) what did these learned scholars transmit as its meaning? Surely some of their Mureeds/students must have written down many of the salient duas transmitted?
@@nathardaniel5819 Absolutely!
@M F
@Nathar Daniel
I am not sure how many times we need to keep saying: Either you follow the Quran or you follow what we were told that this Imam or that Imam said.
We provided the evidence from the Quran. Your argument is basically that we have many people who say otherwise.
It's up to you to choose, and insha Allahh, Allahh will open your mind and make you receptive to the truth, not just defending the forefathers blindly.
As far as Imam Malik and others: They all lived 150 years after the prophet SAWS. That's 100 years of Umayyad preaching... KEEP THAT IN MIND.
Furthermore, none of the original manuscripts are available. The earliest manuscript is at least 200 years after their original authors... In other words, we have what someone said that Imam Malik of Abu Haneefah said, not necessarily verifiable quotes from them directly...
Be wise my brothers and stop arguing in vain, just to defend some books that we really do not have authentication of their sources. The Quranic evidence speaks for itself, as we have demonstrated in the video (Please watch it in full)
Regards
I am already heart broken. I can only imagine what had happened in addition to this.
@ Abdi Karim
We have a lot of work to do
May Allah bless Dr. Hany-what an awakening call. Is it possible to have a pdf file of this presentation of the information you showed on the screen. Thanks Qur'an commands us to change our view when presented with clear evidence -in line with Qur'an.
Salaamun alaykum..thank u for ur hard work..im using that allahumma for very long time and now im shock.but im thankful to u for this and i wanna practise rabbana..tqvm
I always wondered why muslims said allahuma. I didn’t understand how it can mean ya Allah. I also never understood why muslims say Asalam Alaikum when Salam means peace and Asalam does not. There is no basis for anyone to continue using the word allahuma. RABI 100X RABBANA 100X!!!!!!!!!! TALK TO YOUR LORD DIRECTLY!!!!!!! He is closer to you than your jugular vein so don’t use the phrase ya Allah
@Marvelous Quran in an old segment we learnt ya ayuha ladhina aamanuu is in the past tense and it does not talk about us.. therefore, ayat 3:100 is not talking to us muuminuun?
Good question. I will address the difference between the two in a future segment. But good observation.
Having said that, the content of the warning definitely applies to all believers... Don't you agree?