Can we hit 3000 likes this video? W or L ranking? Which other tier lists should I create? Thanks for watching, make sure to like and subscribe ;) ! My MSM friend code: 1019492054LA Join my discord: discord.gg/vRvZBWT2bF
I have a disagreement on Gold Island. It deserves at least A or S tier because it actually sounds like a goodbye song and you saying it doesn’t hit hard enough is quite the understatement because The intro part and the mid part and the last part is all great and hits like a sledgehammer and yeah sure some monster are drowned out but most of the monsters that are drowned out are pretty minor in Gold Island but yeah that’s what I just wanted to say about Gold Island.
Boutta get hella downvoted for this....but actually this is a very fair ranking video. People are saying they feel how the ratings are too harsh, but I prefer when people are honest with their thoughts, rather than chucking everything into S, A, and B tier because they feel too scared to judge the songs more objectively - to MSM fans, you can consider this an open opportunity to be more free with your unpopular opinions and be honest with which songs/monsters you don't like! Plus I don't think you said anything that outlandish - Gobbleygourd objectively ruined the fire islands like how you said with Oasis, some songs definitely have too much clutter/empty space, the music composers for Shugabush and Seasonal Shanty robbed their potential and could've done much better etc. - but unfortunately if you say any of your honest feelings in the MSM community especially the subreddit, you just get downvoted into oblivion and replies threatening you simply because you don't prefer one song over another lol.
That must have taken a lot of courage for an Elsen to write that, proud of you. Although, I think it’s understandable to put most of the islands in high tiers, if you genuinely like them all
Your shugabush island rating is too harsh, it is either A or S tier. I honestly never see anyone saying anything bad about shugabush, it's always seen as an awesome island, and plus you have to keep in mind it was made in 2013 so it is an AWESOME island especially for the period of time it was made in. Of course it's not going to be the best island since it barely has had any additions other than viveine, so you still need to give it credit
@@Inxy_editz78 at the end of the video he literally said "do you agree? Disagree? Comment down bellow" So they're just commenting if they agree or disagree 💀
Yeah but it still has some bad monsters. Shugavox ruins the song “BBBBBBBRPFTH. AHA!” Is trash, it also didn’t have epics for a while, and could be fixed with some new monsters, changing the sounds of old ones, or other changes.
It’s not A or S, you only say that for the time, but it just doesn’t hold up to today’s standards, and I think, personally, B is the highest, but it’s above E.
Magical, Wublin, Bone, Ethereal and Amber are the best ones. Earth island will always be amazing but I think those work better because Earth Island has one of the best songs but Idk if it's as good as those ones. Maybe it can go up there as well
Seasonal shanty deserve to be at least at B or C even if you hate it, it's not D for sure theres the masterpiece that is the Ffidyll verse that in my opinion puts it up a tier
Thanks friend! Usually I would turn the music down but for this video when the theme is on the music I thought it would be good to have it a bit louder
I LOVE your opinion on Magical Sanctum It’s my fav island and I’m working on getting all monsters while free playing and it’s pretty possible to get done free playing I really like it it deserves s but light, seasonal shanty, fire oasis, and amber island deserves more
dont know which one came first but i remember watching a similar video with like the exact same scripts and ratings to the point where they said the exact same thing as you
I think the reason lots of people almost despise Light Island, being someone who will say that Light Island is my least favorite Magical Island if not in the entire game, is because of how empty and slow it feels. Clearly it's not MEANT to be fast paced, but it also doesn't have too much variety through the song whatsoever until Blow't, which is just a mutated Gob if you really think about it
I muted all the vocalists, except pot belly, furcorn, and kayna, though they all had the volume turned down a bit, and I instantly liked the song better, cause I could hear the unique monster on the island
My least favorite island is probably Party Island. It just doesn’t feel like a party. Also Kayna, Furcorn and PomPom actually say words, and PomPom sounds horrifying
mythical island got a new monster 2 new islands which are magical nexus and ethereal workshop also the magical islands have quints now which is why you should do an updated version of the tier list
Can we hit 3000 likes this video?
W or L ranking?
Which other tier lists should I create?
Thanks for watching, make sure to like and subscribe ;) !
My MSM friend code: 1019492054LA
Join my discord: discord.gg/vRvZBWT2bF
ehhhhhhh W even if you put seasonal shanty in D i like it
Calamital island is here
It is almost my opinion :)
Except for seasonal shanty,i put this island in "a" tier
👍
L
W and L
Technically The Collusingum and Composer Island shouldn’t count since they’re not real songs, they just have other songs incorporated into them
Right
I included them as well since MSM decided to experiment with new types of Islands.
💀💀💀🤓🤓🤓🤓
@@Certified_Racist01wdym with 💀🤓
@@DawesyMSM 🫥
“Light Island isn’t all that great so I will chuck it into C tier”
*puts it in b tier 💀
💀💀💀💀💀💀💀💀
*System Fail*
D’oh I missed!
4:11 here
Mostly agreeable. One thing I would change is having Shugabush higher up, and Amber is #1 for me
Amber at 1 is so valid.
Yep. MSM adding the extra verse saved it from B, possible C or D imo.
I have the Shugabush
yes shugabush island is banger
yes same
"You can't make a song out of only vocalists"
Acapella: *Am I A Joke To You?*
You can’t make a GOOD song out of only vocalists.
I have a disagreement on Gold Island. It deserves at least A or S tier because it actually sounds like a goodbye song and you saying it doesn’t hit hard enough is quite the understatement because The intro part and the mid part and the last part is all great and hits like a sledgehammer and yeah sure some monster are drowned out but most of the monsters that are drowned out are pretty minor in Gold Island but yeah that’s what I just wanted to say about Gold Island.
Gold island made me cry.
Ok but fire haven is S tier with rare wubbox
YEAH! The Last Part was so fire with rare wubbox
Boutta get hella downvoted for this....but actually this is a very fair ranking video. People are saying they feel how the ratings are too harsh, but I prefer when people are honest with their thoughts, rather than chucking everything into S, A, and B tier because they feel too scared to judge the songs more objectively - to MSM fans, you can consider this an open opportunity to be more free with your unpopular opinions and be honest with which songs/monsters you don't like!
Plus I don't think you said anything that outlandish - Gobbleygourd objectively ruined the fire islands like how you said with Oasis, some songs definitely have too much clutter/empty space, the music composers for Shugabush and Seasonal Shanty robbed their potential and could've done much better etc. - but unfortunately if you say any of your honest feelings in the MSM community especially the subreddit, you just get downvoted into oblivion and replies threatening you simply because you don't prefer one song over another lol.
this aint reddit
Maybe it's just their actual opinion
That must have taken a lot of courage for an Elsen to write that, proud of you.
Although, I think it’s understandable to put most of the islands in high tiers, if you genuinely like them all
NEVER EVER LET THIS MAN COOK 🔥🔥🔥 SEASONAL SHANTY IS THE BEST! ESPECIALLY THE CASTLE BASS PART.
Definitely agree with you on the hot take with cold island rare wubbox being the best
S: Gold, Amber, Earth, Oasis, Haven, Water, Air, Cold, Bone, Psychic, Faerie, Ethereal, Sanctum, Mythical, Ethereal Workshop, Wublin, Celestial, Continent, Cloud, Starhenge, Cave, Tribal, Space
A: Light, Seasonal Shanty, Plant, Shugabush
B:
C:
D:
E:
F:
Your shugabush island rating is too harsh, it is either A or S tier. I honestly never see anyone saying anything bad about shugabush, it's always seen as an awesome island, and plus you have to keep in mind it was made in 2013 so it is an AWESOME island especially for the period of time it was made in. Of course it's not going to be the best island since it barely has had any additions other than viveine, so you still need to give it credit
I agree
Yeah but it’s his opinion in the video you didn’t record it
@@Inxy_editz78 at the end of the video he literally said "do you agree? Disagree? Comment down bellow"
So they're just commenting if they agree or disagree 💀
Yeah but it still has some bad monsters. Shugavox ruins the song “BBBBBBBRPFTH. AHA!” Is trash, it also didn’t have epics for a while, and could be fixed with some new monsters, changing the sounds of old ones, or other changes.
It’s not A or S, you only say that for the time, but it just doesn’t hold up to today’s standards, and I think, personally, B is the highest, but it’s above E.
"You can't make a song out of purely vocalists"
Accapella: AM I A JOKE TO YOU?
Magical, Wublin, Bone, Ethereal and Amber are the best ones. Earth island will always be amazing but I think those work better because Earth Island has one of the best songs but Idk if it's as good as those ones. Maybe it can go up there as well
Gold island is probably S toer for me. The quarriester part is just epic and the oaktupos too.
This will be a ride
hi blitzo it’s fizzarolli, wanna come to my house I’m making cookies
I already tell the wublin goin back to sleep after this
Seasonal shanty deserve to be at least at B or C even if you hate it, it's not D for sure theres the masterpiece that is the Ffidyll verse that in my opinion puts it up a tier
No.
@@ethanplaysroblox214your wrong
@@ethanplaysroblox214 youre wrong
@@ethanplaysroblox214 you're wrong
Okay what the algebra im confused
The gobbleygourd hate is insane
Context: Shugabush island is actually a song by Kristian Bush which is Love or Money
cold island rare wubbox hittin the thug shake
great video! just a suggestion though, maybe you should turn down the music so we can hear your voice better.
Thanks friend! Usually I would turn the music down but for this video when the theme is on the music I thought it would be good to have it a bit louder
@@DawesyMSM yeah i get that, cool video tho. seasonal shanty sucks so much 😭
1:10 “fearful we won’t sing / buffer overflow”
Make another tier video with the new islands
I LOVE your opinion on Magical Sanctum It’s my fav island and I’m working on getting all monsters while free playing and it’s pretty possible to get done free playing I really like it it deserves s but light, seasonal shanty, fire oasis, and amber island deserves more
In my opinion the 3 BEST ISLNADS would be seasonal shanty, Shugabush, and magical sanctum
same
4:11 "With that said I will chuck in C tier" *Proceeds to put in B tier*
Ahem
Havent you heard near the end of Seasonal shanty with Spurrit
0:19 B a d P i g g i e s
Everyone love bad piggies
1 year later I can assure you that the new mythical came out and a new island
I LOVE ETHEREAL ISLAND IT'S MY FAV ISLAND❤❤❤❤❤
Ethereal island team
👇🏻
👇🏻
👇🏻
Shugabush is still my favorite
¨ive yet to find someone who dislike ethereal island¨ well dawesy I'm here now
Him: nobody likes stoowarb, you fool you fell for it because I EXIST
Blud did not just say Gold doesn't hit hard enough 💀💀
4:09 With that said I will chuck it into c tier
*puts it in b tier*
Oops
i literally LOVE water island thats the only island that made me want to download this game
Quick and simple,I love it
Sessional shanty has an sick beat drop with violin
I love your videos!
Who likes rare wubbox on cold island
👇
Listening to Seasonal Shanty makes me want to light myself on fire.
w video like always brother 🔥🔥
business is booming
I’m probably the only gobbely gourd fan
the water mythical is already out, and it's called anglow. they are working on a mythical for fire haven tho
Woah every island including fanmades? edit:I just saw scenes💀 there’s no fanmades💀
Nah there is one it’s the swamp looking one
@@maplex321 What Island?
@@nocontextmobilever the lost landscapes
@@nocontextmobilever evergreen marsh
Evergreen good 👍
im sick of people shitting on seasonal shanty it goes hard when the worm dude comes in
“It’s just a promo for another game” my brother in Christ it came out first
If you put earth in S tier I will…*you continue to put earth island in S tier*
Hi
dont know which one came first but i remember watching a similar video with like the exact same scripts and ratings
to the point where they said the exact same thing as you
Yoooo bro this vid is so fire
I know it’s his opinion but I actually really like the battle area (forgot how to spell it ) and I think it deserves more love
"up next we have 'Do the earth-quake!';ÁÃÄÅÆ:" Very true, lol
Yesss dude. Rare wubbox on cold island is my favorite too
The first song is from a game called bad pigies
I think the reason lots of people almost despise Light Island, being someone who will say that Light Island is my least favorite Magical Island if not in the entire game, is because of how empty and slow it feels. Clearly it's not MEANT to be fast paced, but it also doesn't have too much variety through the song whatsoever until Blow't, which is just a mutated Gob if you really think about it
I muted all the vocalists, except pot belly, furcorn, and kayna, though they all had the volume turned down a bit, and I instantly liked the song better, cause I could hear the unique monster on the island
My least favorite island is probably Party Island. It just doesn’t feel like a party. Also Kayna, Furcorn and PomPom actually say words, and PomPom sounds horrifying
@@Fanful-v8n Isn’t that a DoF island? We’re only discussing MSM ones here
@@MutedAndReported3032 ok my least favorite msm island is probably Light Island, due to it’s repetitiveness
I agree with your cold island hot take great video keep it up
I think you could make your videos better by making sure your V/O is in the foreground. It completely drowns into the game audio here
My ranking
S: Sanctum, Mythical, Nexus, Light, Psychic, Bone, Space, Water
A: Plant, Cold, Party, Continent, Air, Haven, Starhenge, Etheral
B: Shanty, Earth, Gold
C: Oasis, Etheral workshop (Pentrumba ruins it)
D: Tribal, Celestial
F: Amber (Gnarls ruins it), Shugabush (straight (no pun) up crap), Fairie (just bad), Cave (overhated+too crowded+underhated+ratio), Wublin
not putting amber island in s tier has to be some kind of crime
It's good but not THAT good
Him: *puts water island in A tier*
Me: how dare you disrespect it
Ah yes because a tier isn’t good enough for water
Omg you are so good
yo
Finally, someone else who likes cold rare Wubbox.
Thank you for adding us to earth island
THE SCUPS ON WATER ISLAND IA THE MOSTB TRUESTNTHING IN THIS VIDEO OMG YOU MBEAUTIFUL MAN YOU MADE ME SPIT OUT MY SANDWICH
Air Island is S tier for me. Yawstrich, Quibble, and Riff carries🌫🌫🌫
I would appreciate part 2 kind sir
i like shuga bush island and all, but the original (love or money) is a good song
"Water island is under rated" THE BIGGEST HOT TAKE KNOWN TO MAN
Bro is trying so hard to not wake up his parents
mythical island got a new monster 2 new islands which are magical nexus and ethereal workshop also the magical islands have quints now which is why you should do an updated version of the tier list
Not gonna lie and I don’t care what people say but the dipsters are so underrated and overrated, I WILL DEFEND THEM WITH MY LIFE
Yessss it's sound so cool especially sol
6:40 no way you just put it in D tier my man (I know it's his opinion okay don't complain it).
You’re also right about the dipstirs because they carry along the whole song
Oh and btw the new mythical is called angglow (if I spelled right) . To breed u need soups and pummel ( I forgot the breeding guid )
You on Air Island: that also me.
4:05
"I will chuck it into C tier"
*puts into B tier*
Light island is my favorite I don’t care that it’s repetitive it sounds so good.
Seasonal shanty is overhated
I like it
I actually love Seasonal Shanty 😭
For the yawstrich you should put every other monster on half volume and keep him at full
Dawesy: with that said, i'll chuck it into C tier
Also Dawesy: *puts it into B tier*
Workshop: you forgot about me😭
Magical Nexus: you forgot about me😭
They didn't even exist when this video was made
Scups on cold island?
You know what the reason I'm never watching your channel again is cos of that shugabush island rating
Just kidding just don't do it again
@@ArnoldSchwarzeneggerGOATfire haven not being s is criminal
For some reason i love the collosingum
very accurate list
Great vid
Mythical got higher in my ratings now cus of Buzzinga and nerve but I think amber wins 1st
Just imagine just chilling in ur room and a FUCKING TOR JAMMER BREAKS IN AND LICKS UR TOES
bro u went dirty on seasonal shanty
I STRONGLY DISAGREE with Seasonal Shanty it sound is ✨PERFECT✨ HOOLA CARRIES THE ISLAND
MY FAVORITE WUBBOX IS AIR WUBBOX!!! AND MY FAVORITE WEORDO IS STOOWURB
My like were the nomber 1k, im proud of that
Up next we have DO THE EARTHQUAKE AAAAAAH LOL
Fun fact for earth island: if you slow down it, it will be better for me.
🤓👆 Uhm, boss music!!!
7:54 u put wublin island
Dawesy: I will chuck it into C tier * puts it in B tier *
What monster Do you like on The Tribal Island
The reason Yawstrich can't be heard is because everyone puts their Yawstrich at half volume because of HOW LOUD it is
also, i disagree with the seasonal shanty one for *reasons*
They actually made the Yawstrich louder in a patch, now it sounds fine
Why the fu** would you placed seasonal Shanty in d tier it's one of my favorites.
Tribal Island also contains every natural as well
L on shugabush, that song is amazing and even if its repetitve it sounds good and all of the monsters are good, not one of them are bad.