YouTube Rewind 2018: What Went Wrong?
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 чер 2024
- UA-cam released its annual Rewind video and the audience voted... pretty badly. But why? SUBSCRIBE NOW: goo.gl/bPrSLZ
Watch the Rewind Here: • UA-cam Rewind 2018: E...
Could the most disliked video on UA-cam be one of its own videos?
There was a time when UA-cam Rewind was celebrated and loved but something has changed in the matrix. In this video we study how the video was released and some interesting analytics from the video's first day of life.
▶Install the vidIQ Chrome Extension for free today: bit.ly/1zNglHx
▶What is vidIQ?
vidIQ is a chrome extension that provides on-the-spot analytical video data as well as tools to help you research the best topics and manage your UA-cam channel.
▶Where can I find out more about what vidIQ can do?
Watch this video that covers 100 different ways we can help in just 15 minutes:
• 100 UA-cam Tools For ...
▶How about general tips to help grow my channel?
That's part of what we do on this channel so make sure to subscribe: bit.ly/2hj8zYU
▶English is not my first language, do you create content in other languages?
Yes. Check out vidIQ En Español here: goo.gl/3uPuKj
▶I have a problem with vidIQ
We will try our best to help you in the comments but for dedicated support contact: support@vidIQ.com
▶Join us on these social media platforms
Facebook: vidIQapp
Twitter: vidIQ
Instagram: vidIQ
Direct UA-cam messaging: youtu.be/addme/qbm8A_eDnXTabT...
#youtuberewind - Навчання та стиль
QOTD: Why do you think UA-cam Rewind has so many dislikes?
Obviously no pewdiepie and MrBeast
Because it doesn’t address what’s actually going on in the UA-cam community and it has an overtly political message right in the middle of it.
They sacrificed real connections with their UA-cam audience by giving us what really made UA-cam great this year, for their political correct nonsense.
NO PEWDIEPIE
Also it was worse than last year
1: No Pewdiepie (chair don't count)
2: No Stefan Karl
3: Included Politics
4: Included people who no one knows.
5: Boring
6: No T-Series vs Pewdiepie, which is the biggest thing on YT right now. Even UA-cam is getting free advertisement in Europe, US and India because of this.
Binoy J S 7. Ninja
8. No Mr Beast
9. K-pop
What politics?
@@orseonovakovic8521 IMPOSTER!!! To gulag you go!
Hi Stalin. How you doin?
@@randomotaku4289 well im dead, so............
They didn't include Stefan Karl, that's what went wrong
Investing Book Summaries he’s sadly ded
He doesn't deserve to be in some cancerous vid he deserves better
Yes, but there could at least be a moment of silence for our fallen brotheren.
FireWaffles He deserves a video of his own
Investing Book Summaries dark
-Everyone Controls Rewind-
*_UA-cam Controls Rewind_*
Everyone controls dislike
Thank you
ua-cam.com/video/nLuRNN_WDRM/v-deo.html
UA-cam rewind 2018 with pewdiepie
Brainwashing us.😂
Dj Pyromania 100% agree!
UA-cam Rewind 2018: What Went Wrong?
Well, everything...
What went wrong. UA-cam yet again showed they don’t understand the trends on their own platform. They showed people who were relevant 3-5 years ago. No one knew who 90% of the people were. Rewind has turned into a political statement. Take it back to its roots next year. The dislikes are warranted.
iChase i knew ninja
10001subs no videos ninja should even be in the video.... he’s a twitch streamer
Well to be fair they tried to get in youtubers from many different countries who might not be well known worldwide but certainly have a lot of followers. But overall you are right. Lots of things missing. UA-cam Rewind should be a proper Year review including all big things/controversies that were interesting this year. Instead they decided to do a cringy video with nothing really in it. 99% of the time i had no idea whats going and what the point of the whole thing is.
MrSteamedchicken shouldn’t* learn the difference
What political statement though? Mental health discussion, education, single mother empowerment, how is that political stuff??
The video was cringy and it didn't do a good job a representing the year in review. They are so out of touch with their own platform it's ridiculous. Think of the top 3 events on UA-cam in 2018.
The Boxing Match
The Shane Dawson Docs
T-Series vs PewDiePie
None of those were in the rewind. As UA-cam gets bigger and better, the rewind gets worse.
When I read the first line I thought you were talking about THIS video...
...I read the rest of the comment and my faith was, once again, restored.
If UA-cam were to put Tseries and Pewdiepie is would just mean more support towards Pewdiepie.. I don’t support Tseries and I don’t really want a corporation to dominate either however Pewdiepie had some offensive content that was terrible. On the bright side, he is a very good person bcz he contributed to India in the fight against Child labor
Also WWE sucks in 2018 because Raw got so many low viewers and the PPVs have become more bored and so bad that 2018 was worse for the both of them
@@VedangKevlani and Logan Paul literally showed a dead body and laughed about it... And his red show was given back and he got back his premier ads....mmmmm
@@VedangKevlani t series has been feeding poor and homeless people of katra region of jammu & kashmir for past 25 years. I'm not saying that pewd's step of raising fund for CRY was wrong, but many people blindly believe that t series is just a selfish company, which is absolutely false.
How to dislike UA-cam Rewind 2018 without watching it?
Bruh this ain't google
Adblock? If you have a PC.
Just watch it, by current statistics if people watch it, they will dislike it so it makes sense to introduce more people to dislike it.
I don't think it has ads, except youtube patting itself on the back and links to bunch of youtubers who don't really matter.
Just click on it and dislike, you don't need to watch any of the ads or the video since you can instantly pause, dislike and go back
Ikr! Its like 70m viewers! I was like, i am not going to donate more views, but I REALLY want youtube rewind to have the most disliked video in youtube
People dont dislike it because they are "haters". People dislike it because it's bad. Let's look at thia year's rewind: starts and ends with will smith, which last time I checked wasnt a youtuber, has an open spot for talk show hosts (also 2017) and has ninja be a big part of the start, even though he is not a youtuber. It also has a full minute or 2 about people talking about supporting things like mental health, which ironicly, mental health videos get demonitized all the time. But the biggest problem is not featuring actual events from this year, the biggest being youtube's own biggest creator, Pewdiepie vs T series. The fact that Jaiden had to sneak in his chair to even have a refernce of him is outrageous. It, 2017 and 2016 (and maybe 2015, im not sure) were all heavily disliked because they did not feature many of the big events of the year, and the ones they do feature are either not that big or makes youtube looks good or at least does not affect them. If they started making rewinds which actually represent the year, they will not get disliked, its funny that Jaiden's 3 seconds animation was more 2018 than the whole rewind. Oh and one more thing: it does not help that they started removing dislikes :)
2016's dislikes were mainly out of a protest because of UA-cam's adpocalypse. Your point still stands
2015 was fine too
@@lovreb3872 People wanted youtubers they know, not celebrities who have nothing to do with YT. I haven't seen one person who wanted will smith in rewind
in will smith's defense, from the videos of his that I've seen, he seems to genuinely want to get a look into what vloggers do. sure, he has editors and will always been known as an actor/celebrity first, but he seems to be genuinely trying and it lets us see him as an everyday guy with a camera, rather than this huge celebrity. so imo I'm glad that they included him, it was one of the VERY few parts of rewind I liked
Ninja is a UA-camr. His channel has over 20 millions.
UA-cam: post youtube rewind
UA-cam rewind: gets 1.5 million dislike
UA-cam: suprised pikachu
😯
correct that 5 million+ dislikes
this comment banned in the EU. lol
_K o w a l s k i a n a l y s i s_
I saw this meme XD
Personally I think there's just a lot more people upset with YT as it's become more and more focused on promoting corporations and les about being a platform for the people to express their creativity like it use to be.
Hi
Because the UA-cam executives don't actually use youtube
Nice profile pic now that's an actual PICTURES OF THE YEAR
that moment when youtube can’t make a good video on its own platform
@@Sacioales i don't know either
@@ratio9636 So what?? its just likes lol
Hey gamer
Didn't expect to find musty here lol
It's pretty simple. They try to avoid all controversy, but by doing that they have to exclude 90% of the content on UA-cam. This leaves the viewers unsatisfied.
Also, the grudging hate against UA-cam has been growing as they keep restricting their creators, making the content on UA-cam less and less inventive as creators are often afraid to try new things.
UA-cam tried to show how inclusive they are in this rewind, but everyone who has actually been following what's happening on UA-cam knows this is just a way for them to cover up all their controversies.
All in all, the feeling I got after watching UA-cam rewind 2018 was "what is this?" I barely knew anyone, and the references they made was mostly to content I don't care about at all. This apparently is how most of UA-cam felt too.
I support your opinion. I watched three times that video and I didn't feel anything. After this, UA-cam must change the concept for t he next Rewind.
@Cristian Babencu I haven't played Fornite yet but it's annoying that mention it everywhere because they ignored other videogames on this year.
Yeah, I get why they left out alot of youtubers even though I liked them still. Just because some things are causing actual real political tension in some places, where it shouldn't be. It touches on sensitivities from those things
Agreed, couldn’t have been explained any better.
*It will be 1 milion Dislikes today!*
Yup. updating the thumbnail in... 20 minutes!
Joni Multiple Solutions first video to 1 million dislikes in a day
Riot Success
1.3 mil
1.4 mil now
2 million dislikes time to update thumbanil (u have to update it many times)
Edit: Just update it to 10 millions and you never have to do it again (probably)
Edit2: Well UA-cam did it
Done!
@@vidIQ well done m8
vidIQ bro it’s 2,000,000 lol
2000 thousand?
@@michaelalvarez1139 Same thing...... He said 2,000*K*
I think the people disliked the video, because it was pure garbage. It represented like 1 percent of youtube 2018.
Not 1%. Its 0.1 percent.
@@k-star9794 I disagree. They got 1% right like Fortnite and... Know what, you're right. 0.1%. Could be even less.
@@leopoldskozowski9538 yup...strongly agreed.
0,000001% Nearly the whole Video was a cringe party! The only part that was ok was with the animators. They put so much irrelevent stuff in it that it could be a UA-cam Rewind 2003!
@Con ne Why does that fortnite trash even exists...i wouldnt call it a game as it would be a disrespect to other games.
where is suicide forest
Tiktok
ksi vs Logan Paul
tanacon
Shane Dawson
mind of Jake Paul
You want that? Nah heres some sjw bs
Article 13
Defy Media Lawsuits
All the charity live streams that happened
2018 was full of memes where are they
Pew die pie vs T Series
Jake paul from Walmart the suicide forest was in the fortnight dancing scene
the only person who deserved to be in the video was the guy at the end, the primitive guy has actual talent.
The only dude who deserves to be in the video is pewdiepie
@@Gamer4LifeOfficialChannelPewdiepie Fanboy I see
I’m glad the animators made it in
Also Yes Theory they have amazing content
only person deserve is ninja cuz hes pro master fortnite player and hes good at fortnite and kind
Like if u agreih
The video sucked. Why the actual hell would they put baby shark? And come on, Yodelling Kid is more irrelevant than LeafyIsHere (just saying).
They also used a BTS song without crediting them, whilst the 'Kiki do you love me' thing had the animators look cringy as hell. No offense Domics and Odd1IsOut.
They didn't put Pewdiepie in there, however not crediting him for the reference they used with his 399 meme. Where was KSI and Logan Paul?
99% was Fortnite. The only person who should've featured is Ninja because he blew up to 9th most subscribed gamer.
I can agree in every point except two:
1. I think Jaiden did the chair meme without telling anybody so there is at least SOMEKIND of Pewdiepie in this video.
2. I think Ninja shouldn´t have been featured either because he is a STREAMER on Twitch.
FlopGamer I found out that in the background it had a SUBmarine, peace (to) and a bro fist.
I already knew about it because everybody wrote it
UA-cam rewind dont know de wae
Baby shark was popular in 2018, also Johnny Johnny
Its not because of the haters, its because it doesnt really represent 2018...... 2017 lacks many things but 2018 lacks too much......
Can you tell me what it lacks
David S *Everything*
also, it's cringe
@@slimytoilet7735 what's the everything?
David S Ah, glad you asked. The rewind was too stuffed like youtube tried to put everything together making it hard to watch, youtube also included the normie youtubers which most people dont know. The existence of ninja also caused a bit of chaos since he is a twitch streamer and only post twitch clips on youtube. The kpop and fortnite craze that they emphasize is also pretty cringe which made people hate it even more, I reccommend you watching this video for more-
David S ua-cam.com/video/dQw4w9WgXcQ/v-deo.html heres the link, this talks about everything the rewind lacks and the rewind producers opinion on the hate.
Popular spngs like this is America was missing.
Creators like Pewdiepie and Mrbeast and more were missing.
Memes like Ugandam Knuckles was missi and the list goes on.
This one was by far the worst rewind ever.
Ugandan knuckles was still going strong till march despite people claiming it's a dead meme so it's fair to say that it deserves a spot, this is america was such a hit that it started a trend of people making their own version for their country, mr beast was a big name this year so he also deserves a spot.
@Cristian Babencu Uganda Knucles was a thing until 2018, were you living under a rock or something? And this is america deserves its place in UA-cam Rewind because, who didn't hear of that song when it came out? Even Latino countries heard of it lol
If they included Ugandan Knuckles the Rewind would be even more criticized. Ugandan Knuckles is an anti-meme at this point. I would say to feature the most impactful creators, Pewds, T-Series, and Mr. Beast should have definitely been there. But UA-cam had to make a mockery of itself.
i don't see how ugandan knuckles was a anti-meme.. Irritating for some people? yes but that's how every meme works, one could also say that t series vs pewds was also controversial cause pewds made fun of india by saying u india u loose and you language sounds like mumble etc u get the point. Ugandan knuckles was a popular meme.
Matrix Programmer, it was a popular meme, no longer is. If I were to go to a meme chat room at this moment and starting saying Ugandan knuckles references, I would either be kicked or muted. I’ve seen this happen before. The only time I ever hear Ugandan Knuckles mentioned is in an ironic context, like, “haha epic meme, it’s like Ugandan Knuckles epic!” Sorry my guy, but no one likes Ugandan Knuckles anymore. It died in January.
Ninja isn't even technically a youtube creator if you only uploads twitch highlights
Not to say he's bad to be there I like the guy, but people who uploaded fortnite videos directly for youtube should've been......
Plus a little too much fortnite...and don't even get me started on ki ki and baby shark
Baby shark was pretty good lol but the Kiki was not my damn cup of tea
@@coydog7902 Not your damn cup of tea tea
Yes my disappointment is immeasurable and our rewind is ruined
Thought he had UA-cam channel?
(speech inbound)
It wasn't made for the viewers. It was made fir advertisers and corporations. They ignored much of the year's important events, such as the boxing matches, the Shane Dawson docs, and the Pewdiepie vs. T-Series battle. They pushed their "core values" and diversity that it became stifling. It's not like I don't agree with them, it's just that it went on forever. Instead of highlighting creators like Markiplier and Jacksepticeye who pushed for positivity, they went for clickbait, controversy, and money. Honestly, this was only to be expected, as when the platform got big enough to make money off of, the corporations moved in to corrupt it.
I’m surprised there wasn’t a bunch of Audible ads...
Their are so many reasons why this flopped:
Celebrities, 90% fortnite themed, 80% people noone knows, that stupid political speech in the middle, only one or two good memes, handpicking comments to be featured, Kpop, mukbang, asmr, bad music, and lying about giving everyone what they want (and I think this is the biggest reason)
NinjaPenguin77664 it was so stupid like as soon as I clicked on the video I see will smith and was like this is going to be horrible
The music that they chose for the video IMO was random, they should've picked songs that were famous but went together. Like "This is America" and "God's Plan"
I wasn't surprised Keke got in, but "Happier", Cardi B's song(forgot name sorry), "High Hopes" and that Kpop song (I don't know all the names sorry) seemed like such a random bunch. They may have been at the top of the charts for a while but not as long as Gambino and Drake.
nah, that kpop song was one of the most viral things when it came out
Gods plan and this is America? lmao trash songs
@@perk8601 those songs represent 2018 better than some random Kpop songs that are only popular for its audience
Their choice of songs was pretty justifiable, though their mix was terrible.
Idol- (the K-pop one)- Set records this year on UA-cam and K pop has exploded in general this year.
Cardi B- This was her year. She came out of nowhere and appeared on everything as a guest rapper to dethrone Nicki Minaj.
High Hopes--was a suprise for me I'll grant you that.
Happier- took off because, like Cardi B, this was Marshmallows year. And that really sad video got alot of views. Plus Bastille is great.
There is no way "this is America" would be used given its imagery that UA-cam doesn't want to show, it's also only about America....
I think the song they used was the only good thing except they made idol (kpop song) look like a joke they had Asian creator there they could have used them but they made it look like a whole joke that to me it was disrespectful
Can we get 5 million dislike to show that we want pewdiepie to say year review on yt rewind plz that would be EPIC!
That is going to happen in the next hour!
@@vidIQ oooh this is going to hert bad for yt soon >:3
And it happened
@@vidIQ it's over one million now! 2x the like ratio😂
2M is coming soon
it hit 7.2m dislike as of right now lol
Thumbnail updated!
alex g. 7.3 now.. yikes
alex g. 7.7 M dislikes :v
7.9 now
8.9 Million XD
Thank you vidIQ, I just found out about your UA-cam plugin yesterday and it's amazing.
It tried something new but became something horrible... There was no song and no rythm in this... There was no MOOD in this... This felt like I was reading some boring book... Also, Nigahiga made a better Fortnite world than them... that tells something...
It was like reading Twilight, which I committed to and it was awful
Honestly I feel like it’s because a lot of individual creators are starting to feel thrown under the bus by youtube. It’s hard to get anywhere amazing on youtube right now. Especially since youtube is more worried about their Hollywood/big company creators. As an individual creator with not enough subscribers to even be monetized youtube makes it hard to be seen even if you rank well in tags.
You mean thrown under the fortnite spawn bus????
@@coydog7902 I was just gonna say it
I like how you change the thumbnail everytime it reaches a dislike milestone
Ikr it's so funny 😂😂
I am so glad that you talked about the live conversation. No one is talking about it.
The videos dislike gain has been so quick that if Justin Bieber Baby, the most disliked video of all time, had been consistently gaining dislikes at that rate, it would have more dislikes than the world population. But the number of dislikes that video has is less than 0.15% of the world population.
Of course, the dislike growth of UA-cam Rewind 2018 will slow down pretty soon as it's pretty much impossible to maintain high growth rates of anything.
@@StarTheTripleDevil almost 2 million dislike at this point
Yeah, but the dislike gain is already slower than 10 hours ago. It's still probably the only video to get 2 million dislikes in one day.
The 2018 Rewind has almost overtaken the 2017 one in dislikes.
@@StarTheTripleDevil 2 mil>1.9 mil
It was just a bad video, and bad representation of what has gone on over the year. Cringe as well too much fortnite too. Always big UA-camrs where’s some of the small creators. In all like we have seen in the past UA-cam isn’t in touch with its users. But thanks Rob for the quick video enjoyed buddy
DD WW auto correct lol
That's not true. It's because they politicized rewind. It used to be a fun mashup and then they turned it PC
There were absolutely NO TRIBUTES to those who passed this year
STAN LEE WHYYY
It's over 1mil dislikes already only 592k likes
Thumbnail update!
Grimm Hades it has like 3 million dislikes now
@@jayce6162 lmao I know and it's just going to get more
Grimm Hades ha yeah
3.1 now
Rewind should've been a whole 10 minutes of Rob from VidIQ looks at the analytics of thr biggest youtube videos and disstracks, not saying it would of been the best but it would be 100x better.
Next year... next year.
Fingers crossed....fingers crossed
4.4million dislikes now it's time to update your thumbnail.
Vivek Sharma now it’s 5 million
7 million now!!!
now its 7M
Almost 8 now, 7.9!
11 m LOL
Congratulations bro, really great video👍🏻
Half of it was about fortnite, and a quarter of it was about exclusivity. I'm just glad about 2% of it was about yodel kid, he reminds me of what UA-cam is about for me, random ass videos taking off and giving you a really good laugh.
Has never seen your channel before but i saw your comment and now your video recomended for me. keep up the Good work you deserve a Sub
Goddd it is sooo obvious as u can see rewind was a hit till 2016 where pewdiepie was still in rewind but 2017 and 2018 didnt include pewdiepie...and pewdiepie has a big audience.... We nine year olds support our lord.... So they had so many dislikes for putting fortnite bullshit instead of pewdiepie...that is all
Please us nine-year-olds
I disliked because no big UA-camrs and it was basically all fortnite
Ya where's pewdiepie
Ninja has 20 million subs
Ninja
Why are people saying too much fortnite it was only there part of the beginning and very very little part in the end.
@@thelightningash one time is more than enough
They could put another things that happen this year
It didn't start with meme review.
Year review
Year* review
Look back at earlier years and check who/what they featured VS who/what was popular that year on UA-cam, then check the newer ones and check for that number
Change the thumbnail to 5 million, you knows it's happening 😂
It had no PewDiePie.
Need to say more?
My comments were deleted on rewind and all I said was his terrible it was.l and I will make an updated edited version. And yes I believe the invite only was so they could get positive msgs
Are you sure it got deleted? One of ours has gone missing too but feel like it might be to do with how flooded it's getting right now.
@@vidIQ I can't find it still but it's possible for that also.
@@GrimmHades Did you try looking at your comment history?
@@hibroXD where would that be on my app I have never seen a place for tht
@@GrimmHades It's in the same place for UA-cam watch history but on the right side, only have "Comments" selected. I believe this is only exclusive for PC and not on mobile.
Short answer:
*E v e r y t h i n g*
Every year youtube is farther away from all their creators and viewers
*What went wrong?*
They didn't have PewDiePie
Everything
Is that all?
@@vidIQ YEAP BURN IT TO THE GROUND
I love this channel dude
Lmao you keep editing the thumbnail very nice
Ps: was here before the thumbnail says 2 mill
Pretty much everything went wrong.
👏👏 YEAR REVIEW
Main reason,
No Pewdiepie, again.
We got his chair tho
I like how the thumbnail of this vid gets updated everyday ~
This is simply because people are unhappy with the platform. Persobally i think their "strategy" with the invitation only was smart. They knew they were foing to be bombarded with negative comments specially about pewd and tseries, so, by having the invited viewers commenting on it, their fans would more likely thumbs up their comments which in turn would make said comments be in top, in order to disguise the negative one. Because UA-cam doesn't want to be called out for for deleting negative comments
They forgot Thanos,Stan Lee,Stefan Karl,and pyrocynical. UA-cam is just so cruel! UA-cam will just dig its own grave along with the SJW’s and liberals who brought the wrong image to UA-cam. My favorite rewinds are the 2012,2013,and 2017. I’m saddened at the downfall of UA-cam’s relevance and creativity. When I first started using UA-cam back in 2009-2011ish I loved seeing all of the creativity and now SJW’s are destroying creativity on this site and it’s integrity! All gamers and pewds rise!
How TF do you like the 2017 one?
Because memes it’s my opinion. I thought the 2016 one was cringe because it was really inconsistent
no they are hating the rewind 2018 since the famous events that happened in youtube (pewdiepie vs t-series, logan paul vs ksi, etc...) did not appear in the video
WolfDogFilms 2017 was bad too, and y’all hated it even more than this year, i ain’t forget. best ones were 2015 and 2014. 2012/2013 i was 9 or 10 so i wasn’t really emerged in the memes or youtube culture
I’ve watched one video on YTR 2018, never seen a single video of yours before, yet UA-cam gave me a NOTIFICATION for this video...what...?
i would love to see Ryan Higa and Amit Bhadana in next rewind !! NICE VID vidIQ !! ENJOYED
Ikr. At least put big RECOGNIZABLE UA-camrs in it.
UA-cam should look at Ariana Grande's premiere before doing it.
Their was no pewds...
*commits thanos snap*
I'll like your video. I've already done my service on the rewind video.
What would make the rewind better is if theres EVERY popular , gaming, science, biologist, asmr , mukbang, vlog, animations, space, art,drawing,tourist,story teller, clans, for clans its faze and optic and others,singers,rappers,hip hop,jazz,and other type of songs.
What went wrong?
*everything except animations*
This is it. This sums it up.
Well since youtube rewind was shite, any youtubers want to support each other?
Hahaha your thumbnail figure keeps on changing. I expect it will change later to 6M.
I never dislike a video, but this was the first one.
It was just the total opposite of what everyone expected it to be, and way too “normal”.
I think the biggest problem with this year's rewind (excluding missing a lot of events that happened and didn't make it into the video) is that it's just all over the place. I liked watching previous ones because of the music remixes and montage, scenes were smoothly blended with each other and it just looked good in overall. This year random people just appear in random places, random music plays occasionally, it literally looks like a teenage director wannabe took the camera for the first time. I know I say "random" a lot, but this whole vid was completely random and wild, and not in a good meaning. It's very clear for me they didn't even have any good idea to begin with.
And this awful forced message. I know they had UA-cam had good intentions trying to say that people who help various charities and those who support creators are important, but was it really needed? Don't we know that already? Don't youtubers say that in many of their videos, when no one is writing these "i'm thankful" lines for them?
Well, I just hope that seeing how much criticism the rewind got, UA-cam will learn on their mistakes and create better video next year.
QOTD answer: It's because there's ALOT Fortnite haters (for example: me) and like half of the video was about fortnite. Also it's because of the demonetized content creators who are showing off their anger. That's just my opinion, no hate, please.
SAME FORNITE SUCKS!!
money over actual viewers.. thats good..
not just fortnite, everything else is cringey
Thank you for dissecting yt rewind 2018
Or maybe people genuinely disliked it? I hate how people say "you dislike the video- time to make you a villan, and brand you as a 'hater'". The dislike button is there for creators to know whether their content is something that they and their audience is happy with. You can't please everyone, but you can try to please the majority.
cuz pewdiepie was not included
lol the UA-cam Rewind had Baby Shark in it
This video was recommended to me by youtube, even tho I wasn't subscribed to this channel.
Simply, everything
The Emoji Movie: The most hated movie.
UA-cam Rewind 2018: The most hated video.
Conspiracy
We didn't needed k-pop and this was basically fortnite rewind
Rohan Tripathi we didn’t need them to do k pop like this. 2018 was a big year for k pop but they didn’t do it right just like everything else
@@TheDCbiz no we didn't need kpop at all
Straight Melon bts was nearly if not the largest viewed music video and outside of America k pop is as trump would say, “HUGE”. So k pop was as necessary as cardi b but UA-cam screwed a lot of k pop fans earlier on and then made it cringey in Rewind how dare they do that to casy
Straight Melon if you don’t like k pop that’s fine but let’s not be racist and it’s hugh in places not America and even has a following in America just fyi
@@TheDCbiz if its not popular in america then we dont need it
I love this content.
amazing video! lots went wrong, quite a bad rewind video.
I know us the ARMY (BTS Fandom) are angry because they used their song 'Idol' without even giving credit to them. Also, UA-cam has deleted views off of BTS videos and ones that would have beaten records so us ARMY are pretty mad about it. We are glad K-Pop is getting some recongition but Youtude isn't giving the credit where it is needed.
Well you better update the thumbnail then it had reached 7 million dislikes now
Done!
This year is getting hate especially because it’s advertising itself as the people’s rewind, while UA-cam simultaneously ignores the people
Who would want Baby Shark in rewind? Who wanted Fortnite? Half of this year's rewind is about sending a positive message. The other half is Fortnite, Baby Shark, Will Smith and random things that the rewind "needs". The only thing they knew we wanted was the animators, but they only get like 2.5 seconds each, sometimes reappearing for another 2.5 up to 4 seconds.
It needed PewDiePie and Stefan Karl
"its VSauce"
At least we got pewd's chair
what if it’s just Australians liking the video?
We need to have a talk with Slazo and his army.
I'm happy cause 2 big UA-camr from my country are in rewind video 2018..
There's one thing this video needed:
An emotional tribute. But not to creators like Stan Lee or Stefan Karl Steffanson. But vague mentions of sad people.
*I wanna be TRaCer*
I dont like the youtube rewind 2018 cuz they didn't show what was trending on youtube... They only show the one that is years ago! What about the Pewdiepie vs T-series?! They could have created a sub count between Pewdiepie vs T-series with the people who vote them! Instead they make cringy old things... This is why i dislike the video!
I’m still confused as to what was happening in UA-cam rewind
I was gunna dislike this as it seems like the in thing to do, but it was nicely done. and i love vidiq so you know. but! IS VIDIQ going to work with the creator studio update?
I don't like to complain but I will showcase all I felt went wrong. Too much talking, Rewind isn't for that, felt like some sketch. There wasn't enough music and It wasn't really a remix, each one sounded by itself. Many trends were left out, many people were left out, there was no creativity after the Battle Bus thing, it was just saying this and oh the reference, it was way more entertaining searching for them. Also, the campfire had some irrelevant youtubers. The "comment setion" part was really unnecesary, Rewind is supposedly just that, giving what "they want" and here they just threw it on your face. Really slow-paced, it's supposed to be a celebration of the year. Animators mixed with people felt really out of place. The political/emotional message was really bad executed and out of place, it's not for the rewind. Isn't youtube affiliated with Google?? Because "Year in Search" mostly covers the tributes and all of the emotional messages in a really nice way. Also, no tribute to death people, in 2016 they did nice nods without making them feel out of place, here they just forgot.
Well, try to appeal to everyone and you won't please anyone, but they REALLY screwed up this year
As the saying goes
"Baby" is bad
"Despashit" is bad
"Fortnite" is bad (hello hate)
"Dame tu cosita" is bad
But UA-cam Rewind is even worse
LOW ELO TV uM fOrTnItE iS tHe BeSt GaMe Of AlL tImE
Man, I thought this was gonna answer “what went wrong?”
I find it interesting that they doped dj earworm who was remixing the music for the loved old rewinds.
I didn't want to watch some new content.
I watch rewind to REWIND THE YEAR, im even fully happy with just clips from those big moments on UA-cam with some good music from that same year.