Seeing this? These girls need the biggest apology of the massive hate they got when they're just 1 yr and 4 months at that time but still they serve vocals and do choreo.
@@genesishernandez1749 singing and dancing at the same time is hard, especially with those notes. If you find it so funny we’d like to see you try. Then we’ll be the ones laughing.
'but they have hard choreo so of course they can't sing well live' meanwhile aespa: literally drops to the ground at the chorus and deliver the high note bridge straight after
the aespa was w backtrack, neither too high nor too low. le serafim just needed that, anyway none of the groups that performed at coachella come close to aespa's vocals, they are on another level
하여간 쇼츠가 문제다... 풀영상 보면 라이브 잘만 하는데 음원이랑 음정 살짝 다른 부분을 폰카로 찍어서 음향 이상한 영상들만 들고 와서 열심히 하는 어린 얘들 죽어라 조리돌림한 이유가 대체 뭐야. 게다가 야외현장이라 음향기계에 따라 엄청 울리는데... 나도 속상한데 에스파는 오죽 했을까. 이러니까 이때 이후로 얘들이 신날 때도 목소리 크게 안 높이고 음원구현에만 집중해서 부르잖아... 솔직히 생라이브에 기교 쓰면서 이 정도로 할 수 있는 그룹 몇 안 되는 것 같은데... 그냥 활동 응원해주면 되는거지 굳이 영상 만들고 욕하는 사람들 심리를 모르겠다.
Can we just praise Karina too? She danced, hit the vocals in Savage and did the rap wonderfully. I see great potential in her and her Stage presence was so good.
As a person who sings onstage myself,I could recognize how difficult this performance is. Kudos to the girls for pulling it off without missing a note and forgetting the choreography.
i've watched these coachella performances back so many times, they just seriously killed this. love seeing the improvement, their live singing is great !
I'm a huge blink but loved Aespa performance and since it was their first live performance infront such a big crowd, they nailed it with hard vocals n choreo... Go Aespa girls 😃🥳🥳... I especially liked NingNing Stage presence and everything but everyone did great
You are right winter can be a main vocalist in other groups easily.al most all lead vocals in sm can main vocal in different group. Sm lead vocalist are underrated.
@@joy11311 hmm… u sure? coz jennie got the clothes with most white to see her better and she's the center(fyr only) so winter should be the center?? idk😂😂
Bc SM ain't shit. They even made Exo and SNSD lipsync. Like for what?! Why?! They're clearly talented singers. Ningning did great and Winter sounded the same as the studio version. I truly can't understand why SM gets some of the best vocalists in kpop and then DOESNT LET THEM SHINE.
Yes! They have such healthy bodies. Ningning and Giselle in particular, and Karina has a really great shape. It's so nice to see them looking so healthy especially when we compare them to how poor Red Velvet and Girls Generation were in their early days.
Yes different point But I thinking Asia people keep going asking Giselle & ning diet. That's what I see at forum. Somemore saying Karina becomes fattest than before. What they want?
As Lisa's Fan, They are on next level. Keep going Aespa. Never mind the hate. Every Girl group undergo with that thing. As time goes by, people will appreciate your talent. 💕
Do you all noticed during the second verse the back track was so low. Girls shone there the most when they sang live and ate. Giselle's rap was so stable and good
![Illusion [4k]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/zQRx5tTZsQ8/mqdefault.jpg)
Seeing this? These girls need the biggest apology of the massive hate they got when they're just 1 yr and 4 months at that time but still they serve vocals and do choreo.
for real!
Yeah!!!
Lol 😂 thanks 르세라핌
Also probably the first live big stage for them. They debuted in 2020 and promoted their music in covid era with very limited live audience
Vine aquí para verlas cantar en vivo luego del desastre de LS, y Aespa canta increíble , wao
This is a K-Pop performance. A combination of actual and live singing and dancing.
My girls finally getting the appreciation they deserve 🤧
We need Coachella to invite aespa the next year cuz THEY DESERVED IT
I hope they either reinvite Aespa or Blackpink. Or they invite Nmixx or G idle. These girls can sing and dance live.
They finally got to sing their debut song live in front of a proper crowd, so happy for them.
2:15 look at ningning omggggggggg 😭😭😭she looks so happy
Ty😭
is this insult or compliment wtf🤔
@@maiavitale8458the commenter said ningning looked happy so Ig it’s a compliment
에스파 코첼라 지금 나오면 진짜 무대 씹어먹을듯.. 이때는 급하게 잡힌 스케쥴이라 멤버들도 여러모로 아쉬웠을텐데ㅠㅠ 다음에 또 볼 수 있었으면!!
I love how Ningning enjoying this performance so much. She looks totally energetic and shows her fully potential on this stage.
OmO!!! Ningning!!!!
The way how this one is hard to sing because of the high notes and their choreography.
They sang live. 😭😭❤️❤️❤️
The choreography isn’t even hard😂
@@genesishernandez1749 then try it if u can
@@genesishernandez1749 singing and dancing at the same time is hard, especially with those notes. If you find it so funny we’d like to see you try. Then we’ll be the ones laughing.
@@kaarissm I could it isn’t even hard😂
@@genesishernandez1749 yeah, then do it with singing at the same time
'but they have hard choreo so of course they can't sing well live'
meanwhile aespa: literally drops to the ground at the chorus and deliver the high note bridge straight after
the aespa was w backtrack, neither too high nor too low. le serafim just needed that, anyway none of the groups that performed at coachella come close to aespa's vocals, they are on another level
저때 진짜 에스파 데뷔1년차였는데 저정도 실력으로 까인거 진짜 억울하다 하
민희기자회견보면 답나온거 아니겠어 역바이럴
하여간 쇼츠가 문제다... 풀영상 보면 라이브 잘만 하는데 음원이랑 음정 살짝 다른 부분을 폰카로 찍어서 음향 이상한 영상들만 들고 와서 열심히 하는 어린 얘들 죽어라 조리돌림한 이유가 대체 뭐야. 게다가 야외현장이라 음향기계에 따라 엄청 울리는데... 나도 속상한데 에스파는 오죽 했을까. 이러니까 이때 이후로 얘들이 신날 때도 목소리 크게 안 높이고 음원구현에만 집중해서 부르잖아... 솔직히 생라이브에 기교 쓰면서 이 정도로 할 수 있는 그룹 몇 안 되는 것 같은데... 그냥 활동 응원해주면 되는거지 굳이 영상 만들고 욕하는 사람들 심리를 모르겠다.
그건 우리를 이유 없이 까대는 중국애들한테 물어 보시오
Can we just praise Karina too? She danced, hit the vocals in Savage and did the rap wonderfully. I see great potential in her and her Stage presence was so good.
Respect went High after watching lesserafrim's performance 😅
They r really far better tho
YES POOR GIRL THEY BEING BASH FOR BAD VOCAL BACK THEN
LOL, dancing with 1/4 of the effort of LE SSERAFIM's performance and only singing marginally better? Your take is 😴
@@portaIwaIkeridol who cant sing and only can dance? Deserve to be back dancer maybe lol
@medythawp Your favorite singers sound just as bad while dancing that hard. Prove me wrong, lol.
에스파는 존나 선녀다... 그 그룹에 비하면 개잘하네
블랙핑크가 더 좋아
르세라핌40분
바람도 많아 불었음
르세라핌 대한민국
가장 빡센 안무
에스파 15분하고
욕 먹었음
비교할걸 하시지
@@user-tf4yt2hh1t릇저씨 폰끄세요
@@user-tf4yt2hh1t 니 때문에 르세라핌 더 욕먹을듯 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ
@@mcdonalds4192
팩트를 갖다대면 반박도
못하는 것들이 이따위 댓글이나 쓰고 있어
Winter's voice is much stable than my mental health 😭❤️
Lol😭😭😭😭😭
yooo😭😭😭
0:43 and 1:41 I still goosebump when hear those "Black Mamba" shouted out.
That's why i love singing live. No need perfection, just emotion.
for real!!! i love love LOVE it when they are hyping up the audience like this!!! its so cool
윈터는 진짜 걍 보물이네..
르세라핌이랑 비교를 떠나서도 그냥 잘하는데 왜 욕먹은거임ㅋㅋ
라이브는 잘하는데 무대가 허전하고 심심한 느낌임. 야외 무대에 맞는 구성을 안짠듯.
@@kikune03 암튼 라이브 못했다고 쳐맞을 수준이 아닌데요..
블핑이 넘사벽이여서 그랬나? 분명 그때는 못해보였는데 르세라핌 보고 왔더니 공연천재임
블핑은 걍 댄서랑 무대구성이 화려해서 무대장악을 잘해서그럼ㅋㅋ 실력으로 따지면 윈터가 한수위임
@@kikune03노래를 그냥 원곡으로 들고가서 그럼ㅋㅋㅋ
1:27 the way Karina and Giselle are smiling at eachother 🥺💕
"We can do it" said their smile
The fact that they consistently doing that since debut is very wholesome✨
Seriously why is Ningning's vocals so good ?
Dulu ada yang ngejek sampe bilang aespa gak pantes tampil di coachella tapi buktinya aespa lebih baik daripada yang maju tahun ini
As a blink I come in peace.They did so good,I'm proud and a new fan. I think I love Karina and Ning Ning but i can't help but cheer for Giselle lol
Gigi just felt like she was in her element
@@BEcauseILoveYooh who's gigi?
@@eeshalfatima2331 Giselle. Goes by Gigi
@@BEcauseILoveYooh oh thank you
Thank you for appreciating them💙 they need appreciation now cause they getting so much hate😢
윈터는 진짜 에이스 그자체
As a person who sings onstage myself,I could recognize how difficult this performance is. Kudos to the girls for pulling it off without missing a note and forgetting the choreography.
Ningning and Winter absolutely rocked the vocals!!!!! Girls can SAAAAAANG
here to cleanse my ears
they deserve an apology
Ningning is gorgeous, love her voice
Winter's voice is so stable!!
OMG. This is my favorite song from their songs.
Ningning. 😭😭❤️❤️❤️
윈터는 엄청 안정적이다
이런건 또 사람들이 안 보지,, 에스파 잘 한다고ㅜ 에스파 코첼라하면 망했다는 프레임 쓰인 게 너무 안타까움
Winter stage presence really fits their concept she is really a queen
에스파는 첫 라이브무대, 빡센 춤, 노래자체가 고음역대인거 감안하면 솔직히 윈터는 블핑이상이었다고 본다
ㅇㅈ 윈터는 신이야
Winter's stable vocals 🥰🥰🥰🥰
i've watched these coachella performances back so many times, they just seriously killed this. love seeing the improvement, their live singing is great !
역시 전통의 스엠…잘해…!
WINTER HAS SUCH STABLE VOCAL HOW???? Winter slayyed y'all
Winter's voice is exactly like in the mv
I'm a huge blink but loved Aespa performance and since it was their first live performance infront such a big crowd, they nailed it with hard vocals n choreo...
Go Aespa girls 😃🥳🥳...
I especially liked NingNing Stage presence and everything but everyone did great
Same
Ningning is beast on stage hella fire🔥
Winter is on Another LEVEL, Main Vocalist Material!
no？💀 lead vocalist
@@alicia5447 qué? Winter lo tiene todo para ser main vocal en otro grupo
She is struggling here
You are right winter can be a main vocalist in other groups easily.al most all lead vocals in sm can main vocal in different group. Sm lead vocalist are underrated.
Ningning and winter both are main vocalist.. u guys understand?
카리나 존재감은 진짜...
winter so stable her vocals 🔥🔥🔥🔥
라이브 잘하는데?!
i came from lesserafim..
aespa is the best💖
omg, they are amazing! black mamba choreography is one of my favorites in kpop, im glad the crowd appreciated them.
The blonde girl has the best stage presence
Her name is ningning
SM ent. never disappoints with their vocalists. if you can't sing, you won't debut under SM
Imagine aespa going back to Coachella next year 🔥
지금 다시 보니까 엄청 잘했다 ㅠㅠ
에스파 최고네요👍👍
Ning Ning ate and left no crumbs she carried this entire performance
Ningning!!! She really enjoy the stage i can hear her voice loudest and her adlib im so proud
에스파 졸라 잘했네 그에비해...그분들은..😮😮
aww , I’m so proud of them!! and ningning’s live vocals are no joke!💀💅✋🏻
1:42 that BLACK MAMBA gave me goosebumps 🫣🫣
NINGNING AND WINTER ATEE AND LEFT NO CRUMBS AND THEY KNOW THAT VERY WELL THEMSELVES🕶💅💥queens material
Ningning was great but winter had no expressions at all it was dull
@@jensmoonn its based on their ai concept for your info
@@kuchhekodadusupremacy5474 so ig ningning doesn't follows the concept in that case and only winter does 🗿
@@jensmoonn she carried the live vocal tho
진짜 잘했음 물론 이전에 블핑이 너무 잘해버려서 블핑과 비교했을때 무대센스나 구성이 아쉬워서 비교적 못해보여던거임
블핑이랑 르세라핌은 스테이지 규모가 크고 좋았음 규모가 다름 에스파는 코첼라 작은 스테이션이라 그런듯
Karina voice more stable in the stage but Ning Ning did too..perfect stage for Aespa 👍❤️💕
에스파 너무 잘하는데?
라이브 뭘못한단거임? 윈터랑 닝닝 쭉쭉올라가고 카리나 저음 안정적이고 지젤 랩쫀득한데?
막귀 똥귀라그럽니다
진짜 이제서야 잘 했다고 하는거 보면 멍멍 웃김. ㅠ
@@killerqueen2971ㄹㅇ 신나서 깔땐 언제고 이제와서?? ㅋㅋㅋ
Everyone, say Sorry to Aespa 🥹🙏🏻
Winter’s outfit is the best! She’s the only one with white outfit and I’m so fucking proud 😭 she’s the center!
Karina's the center 😐
Both are center. Karina is center in the first half of the song and Winter in the second half (and Karina at the end)
@@joy11311 hmm… u sure? coz jennie got the clothes with most white to see her better and she's the center(fyr only) so winter should be the center?? idk😂😂
@@luhvlys7906 cause jennie is the official center lol 💀
@@joy11311 so winter should be center this way🤡😹
Ningnings high notes were amazing 🔥
존나 잘하는고만
블맘 무대는 그냥 완벽했음 생라이브고 안무도 다 하는데 음정도 안 나가고.. 이걸 까는 건 말이 안됨
That choreo is hard! Fair play to them what they did is impressive
That's why you need to let idols sing live
Winter looks pretty!!!
에스파는 대학축제로 먼저 워밍업 한뒤에 코첼라 갔어야했다
?
해도 되는 애가 있고 안되는 애가 있고....
@@Ji-hu_ He has some reason
@@user-wm3it1wo1l It's not that I didn't understand I don't speak Korean 😅
@@Ji-hu_ He said: they should perform first at the university festival and then go to coachella
I am so proud of Aespa! Not because they are better than others but they did really well
Winter and Ningning seriously saved this stage!
No es hate a ningún grupo, pero comparado con le sserafin, esto es muy bueno(por fa no me cancelen)
Wow this is the closest fancam
Fr
Yes! Finally I found a proper one😭
Rare fotage of aespa singing live 😱 *SHOCKING*
And they did great!
you mean the only one-
Bc SM ain't shit. They even made Exo and SNSD lipsync. Like for what?! Why?! They're clearly talented singers. Ningning did great and Winter sounded the same as the studio version.
I truly can't understand why SM gets some of the best vocalists in kpop and then DOESNT LET THEM SHINE.
@@blahblahsuperanon I think it's because they want "perfection" but SM idols ARE perfection 😭
Ning Ning's high scale at the end with a live voice is not a matter of joke 👌🏻✨😭
Bring them to Coachella again its not a need its a want 🔥
imagine "DRAMA" on Coachella with the live band arrangement.... People think they lip-sync because of how good their live vocals
Aside from their performance what makes me really happy is seeing them looking healthy. Not the super skinny kpop body most agencies want
If this isn't skinny..
Yes! They have such healthy bodies. Ningning and Giselle in particular, and Karina has a really great shape. It's so nice to see them looking so healthy especially when we compare them to how poor Red Velvet and Girls Generation were in their early days.
Yes different point
But I thinking Asia people keep going asking Giselle & ning diet.
That's what I see at forum.
Somemore saying Karina becomes fattest than before.
What they want?
@@bloom6291 they definitely are skinny, but compared to some REALLY skinny idols they look much healthier
In fact there are comments that say they are fat. Hopefully the company does not see those comments and does not force her to lose weight. 😢😭
Aespa vocal is amazing
2:29 how come Ningning hit that high note then hit the beat that easily? Sis that's hard!
I like how Giselle hype the crowd and her members
Thank you for sharing this with us!!! I really love aespa!!! They are talented, gorgeous, and hardworking!!!
역시 근본있는 수만씨~
Winters voice❤
As Lisa's Fan, They are on next level. Keep going Aespa. Never mind the hate. Every Girl group undergo with that thing. As time goes by, people will appreciate your talent. 💕
Karina danced the hardest and sang so stable
Aespa vocal is amazing ❤
Giselle and Ningning’s stage presence was great :)
윈터 넘 잘한다 😢 발성이 시원시원해
winter very attractive dayum
Winter's voice is crazy. so stable and neat❤
블핑>>에스파>>>>>>>>>>>>>>르세라핌
Ning Ning heaven voice🥰
The point in the beginning when they finally figure out ningning’s mic volume is very satisfying
뭐야.. 사람들 다 닝닝 목소리 떨리는 부분만 가져와서 쇼츠에서 악플 유도한거봐…
카리나랑 지젤도 진짜 잘하고 윈터는 평소대로 찐한 발성내고 닝닝 완전 잘하는데 ㅠㅠ
그러게요 ㅠ
그러게.. 음질 정확한 영상으로 들어보니 닝닝 살짝 불안했던 부분 빼면.. 잘하는데??? 뭐지..?
외국인 댓글은 전부 닝닝 칭찬함. 저기는 축제지 평가하는 자리가 아님. 우리나라 사람들만 걍 중국인이니까 삐딱하게 보는거임;; 영어 댓글 보셈 수천개 댓글중에 단 한개도 닝닝이 노래 못부른다고 욕하는 댓글 없음; 유별나게 우리나라 사람들만 중국인이라고 욕하는거임
@@killer3936 yesyes 제가 하고싶은말... 우리나라 사람들은 무슨 한이 있다고 연예인 평가질하면서 풀고... 제발 외국인들처럼 그냥 즐기란말이야... 인종차별 티나게 하지말고^_^;;
닝닝은 못해도 15억이 응원하니 걱정않해도 됩니다. 윈터나 카리나 응원하기도 벅참 ㅁㅁ,,, 마음을 넓게 가질 여유가 없단 말이죠옵,,, 외국인에 중국인들은 없으까,,, 중국애들은 우리나라애들 뭐만 꼬뚜리 잡으면 열심히 까대는데,,, 순진한 척 우리만 착한척???
아니..저 당시엔 블핑이 너무 잘하니 에스파 못한다고 생각했는데 이건 못 하는것도 아니었다니 😑😑😑 거긴 너무 심각하네
Ningning was creating the hype and we loved it
Do you all noticed during the second verse the back track was so low. Girls shone there the most when they sang live and ate. Giselle's rap was so stable and good
Ningning has proved that she can sing high notes
관객있는 무대는 거의 처음 이라서 무대를 가득 채우는 느낌은 없구나