Mr. Tahir is continuously telling that BJP is making India a hindu country. Can he site one instance or policy which is exclusively for hindus made by Modi? Secondly India has tried several times to normalise relationship with Pakistan but everytime she has been backstabbed by Pakistani establishment.
India that is Bharat is Hindu civilization nation for the last 5,0000 years. Why Islamic fools living islamic hell countries crying about Bharat being Hindu country? Arey katuwo do Kodi ke converted musalmano Bharat to Hindu Desh hai sada se jaha Vedas aaye, jaha bhagwano Avtarit hue , jaha Vedic Rishis hue wo desh Hindu rashtra nahi hoga to kya Saudi barbia ko kabja ke Mecca ko udda ke Hindu rashtra banaye?
@Dan Levi Ek ek ko pakad pakad ke maar dalna chahiye... It's only hindus who r having patience since thousands years. Now it's time to get rid of them. Gazwa E Mulla
Not only muslims but all nations in india has problem with RSS. Therefore the policy of BJP has put in india in trouble . The GDP of India has gone into negative for the first time in history and your country is occupied by China and all your neighbours are annoyed with zindia.
Arvind bhai ne jo ye bate boli. ye unke under ka dard hain. as a indain Hum jab 20 karore upne muslim bhiyo ke sath pyar se rah sakte hain. too hum kisi ke sath bhi rah sakte. Hindo ka Dharm kbhi khatre main nahi padta. Hum open minded hote hain. aapki purii takrir suni. very nice. main vasani ji ko sunta hun.it is true person. we love u. ek Hindustani delhi se. thanks
Think about reason thats why B J P has grown it is because of Muslims attitude. Sri Lanka Bangladesh nepal burma bhutaan also small country but they have not security threat.
BJP dont need a muslim attitude to grow. Your age seems to be between 25 to 35. U dont know history of Muslim here n out side. GAZWA ehind is beyond your imagination. So pl think n study history
ये इन लोगों का mindset है, इन्हें बस भारत से IPL में कुछ लाख-करोड़ रूपए चाहिए, जहन से ही पैदायशी भिखारी मानसिकता के ही होते हैं। इनकी क़ौम में Hamid Bashani साहब जैसे rare category के बहुत थोड़े से लोग ही पुरी दुनिया में पाते जाते हैं। अगर कुछ मिलेंगे तो भारत में ही मिलेंगे ... Anyway ! पर क्या कर सकते हैं ...?
Itne Dialogue kya fayad jab hame hugna or chodpatti karni hai to,,, Tarik ki baat shi haj milne do londo ko India or pakistan k jab communication hoga to sab patri par aayega...
problem quaran me hai inke chikne chinke baton me ab Hindu nhi wale h ager us masjid bna di Jaye toh thik hai aur Hinduo ki Astha bhand me Jaye.... Pakistan se hme kuch Lena Dena nhi h
Mr Tahir Malik, app ko bhi maloom hai aur mujhe bhi humarey yahaan election establishment ke hisab se hota hai.India mei aysa nahi hota hai aur aap jaise daanishmand establishment ko support kartey hai isiliye humaree ye halat hai. Shame on you Tahir.
4 wars inflicted on India. Proxy war for the last 35 years .whenever India tried to give a chance of peace it got stabbed in the back. So the onus is on Pakistan.
अरविंद जी आपका आशावाद अच्छा है परंतु इनके जहन इतने कंडिशन्ड है और ये पास्ट के झूठे ग्लोरियस सपनो में भटके लोग है ,जो कभी नही जग सकते और आपका ह्रदय हिन्दू करुणा से भरा ह्रदय है ।इंसान तो ये भी है परंतु इनकी कंडीशनिंग ही ऐसी है सचाई को ये कभी नही देख सकते ।असम्भव ,नामुमकिन
इस एपिसोड वीडियो में तो आप छा गए। ऐसे लीड रोल में मैंने पहले नहीं देखा। हैं ये अलग बात है कि ये dec19 का वीडियो है और आज 22april ko du raha hun। आपका ये प्रोग्राम अरविंद जी में लगभग रोज़ सुनने की कोशिश करता हूं। आपका prog मुझे बहुत अच्छा लगता है। मैं करुणेश सहारनपुर से। धन्यवाद।
Mr Arvind Saharan,well done.You have conducted this debate very intelligently, particularly the part dealing with Abdali,Ghaznavi&Ghori etc and also about shared heritage and ancestry.
I request everyone to see the faces and expression of all these three people their faces explain them more than their words .....Their expression and gesture are telling whole story 😊
I consider my self a Hindu Nationalist and patriot, but I don't understand ur assessment of Tahir Malik. He has a different opinion and that OK. My honest review is that he doesn't have any low or negative opinion - he just has a different opinion. Just respect it.
Arvindaji bahut badhiya programme /discussion aapne kiya hai.aapki namrata se argument karneki kala jo hai woh dil ko chhu leti hai. Main asha karta jitne bhi Pakistani ish episod ko dekhenge toh to unke Dilo dimaag me aapke dwara rakhe huye sundar vicharo ki khuhsboo ki ameet chhap kayam rahegi.Educated and uneducated ka fark aapne unko samjaya drudhtase makkam hokar parantu vinamra bhasha mei. Yahito basic fark hai hum mein aur unme. I hearty appreciates your thouts. Love you sir. Chandresh Virani. From Dombivli/Mumbai Maharashtra
Tahir Malik is far away from the facts. He does not read or understand the current thought process of Indian people. Average Indian hardly give any value to what is happening in Pakistan. His conclusions are naive. Arvindji bang on the facts. He took good Class of Tahir Malik. He kept on dodging the questions. He must be saving himself from any backlash back home. Surprisingly Nobody from Pakistan watches these vlogs? OR react on them? Mr TAHIR at least must have spoken in PUNJABI. That's sad. It's true that one can not speak PUNJABI in (Pakistan's) PUNJAB assembly. Those who forget their mother tongue has a dim future. P.S. Those who forget their history, their geography will change often.
Don't insult him, he is defending his country, like every good citizen should. He is also aware of the problem, but he loves his country, he is grateful to it for providing him life, food and job, just like you are towards your country. Don't hate the person, hate the ideology which has put the country to shame.
I am a sikh from Tehran and my parents come from zahedan.Most of my relatives were born in either of two cities.Iranians although being a muslim country but they do not let you feel that you are a sikh.This pakistani s mentality is the same as the other fundamentalists..their thinking can not change.
I support CAA and NRC. Though Mr Bashani and Mr Malik are quite balanced in their mindset, approach and opinion, Mr Malik has a mindset quite common among Pakistanis. They want to score point over us by trying to teach us secularism. If secularism is important for Pakistan then they must adopt secularism. We are not going to appease Pakistanis atall. Jai Shriram. If any lesson is to be learnt by anyone it is Pakistan.
Mr. Vinod Kumarji I fully agree with you honest trust rises out of sincere trustworthy experiences and reliability. In that regard one has to be extremely cautious and alert thanks ❤
ये भाई कह रहा है भारत नही हिंदू ये सही रहेगा कहना अपना दिल धर्मशाला बना ले और पाकिस्तानी नही मुस्लिम कहना सही रहेगा अपना दिल तो अपना है मै( मुस्लिम) क्यू भारत से(हिंदू) के साथ क्यू रहु
Bhai ye surrendered people hi.... Hum hai asli Malik... These are converted jats... Kya apko pta hi ... Aapke yha kinne Jats hi ... Wo bhi Malik.... Jatworld.com dekh lo ek bar
Hello Sirs. Im from Pakista. It has not very logn been since I started watching and listening you here. Honestly I liked it. After watching a number of your programes in previous, I watched today's episod and found myself convinced by Mr. Tahir Malik. It is very well said. Thank you Mr. Malik. You spoke my mind. However, to my beliefs, its just one element of few more that need attention of you all i.e. the proxies of others in the reagion, the media influences of both sides where almost all looks for their rating and God knows what n what. However i like n appreciate your intentions and the efforts. May Allah help you all and guid you all in a correct and right direction. Aameem. Khalid.
Basani sahab.. We always get educated by you... the perspective that u bring it deepens our understanding of this area.. We in India usually do not pay attention in what's happening in Pakistan...
@@viking7769 ....Any one who make law based on religion that if hindu do not found any documents its ok but if muslim do not found documents its ghupsithiya
Tahir Malik Sir, hum Indians or khas taur par Hindus, Pakistan se bahut taklif uthaye hai. Ab or nehi hai. Ab toh tit for tat hi hogi. Koi chance nehi rahegi Pakistan ke liye.
Kashmir issue is resolved now and only pending issue remaining is getting back POK. India has moved away from trying to normal relations with Pakistan. We don’t give a damm about them anymore and they can do their worst! Good luck!
Tahir ji, india has given "most favoured nation" status to pakistan in 1998. Pakistan cannot do same to india in 20 years. You never put control on proxy war against india. You never said to hand hafez sayed, dawood to india. You were involved in parliament attack, mumbai attack and many more terrorist activities against india. And you are saying "Galti dono taraf se hai" Tell me why India is not having problems with any other neighbouring countries only with pakistan. On the other hand pakistan has bad relations with all his neighbours. (Not China bcoz master slave relationship). It means something is wrong with pakistan not india. You cannot hide behind excuse that we are not democratic. The problem is your biased mindset. In the show for peace you were carrying Pakistan agenda, unknowingly. That's the mindset problem I am talking about. I forecast now that few years later you will be starting jihad against chinese also. If you want good relations with india you have to show sincerety on ground. This is two way road.
Hamid Bhashani sb spoke well about the facts which Tahir Malik sb cant discribbed easily while living here and representing Pakistan , anyway it was a good show to close both countries for better future
We gave a face-saving to Bhutto by releasing 90,000 prisoners of war in 1971. What did we get? He went back after Shimla agreement and announced a 100-year war with India by giving her a thousand cuts.
Better we are separated otherwise what if 40 crores more Muslims from both neighbouring countries with us? I say give them kashmir along with all muslims from India.
Hello Arvind, I like your programmes because your style brings out the reality truth !! If Pak is insecure of India because of its size, then this is for infinity!! The real reason and it is self evident, Pak wants to get as much and more and wants to live in the past + dominate the non+momin ! Your man from Pak continues to deny the truth and his country will definitely have to reap what they have been sowing for 70 years. It is dominated by a toxic punjabi military regime who are doing great crimes against the Baloch, Pashtuns and the rest. May I suggest you invite a pashtun or a Baloch on your discussion to get the balanced view. I am a Koshure from the J/K valley and for me, no resolution is more important than the justice delivered to the KPs who were genocided against + whether the World agrees with it or not. Modiji is on track to deliver this and we suport him. This fobia in Pak about BJP is another excuse for the Pak Govt to fool its own poor .....
Every time I watch your show I feel proud of your initiative ....... Great people are not born great sometimes, it's their courage to take the first step toward wisdom that makes them great ..... & Happy to say u r one among those people 🙏
Everything is fine now, everyone in my country has accepted CAA / NRC / NRP. All the country accepted 4 days of exemptions except for minor incidents. Long live Mother India
When Tahir Sahib talks about people meeting each other then he is thinking about Punjabi meeting Punjabi. They are 28 more states in India who are least connected culturally with Pakistan.
Arvind Sir ye program maine Char bar dekha, fir bhi ye aaur ek bar dekhana chahenge. Isme bahot acchi bate huvi aaur aakharika share bhi Dil ke karib raha
Nice and exceptionally good programme. Thank you very much Arvind Saharan ji. Aa usual Barrister Hamid Bashani Sahab's views are unbiased and transparent. Unfortunately. Tahir Malik Sahab's views are shying away from the reality, though the essence of his views are OK. I thank all of you three persons.
Arvind bhai, apki waah waah. Jo apne itni siddat se inn Pakistanis ki baat suni Koi farq nhi pdta ki Pakistani toranto me rhe yaa khi bhi. Wo hmesha aisa hi rhega.
Arvindji, though timing wise this video was long but I can understand how tight steps you are walking the rope. Mazaa Aa gaya. Kudos! 👍 Appreciate the thoughts, thoroughly enjoyed. And Bashani Sir, as always cool and rational.
Separate Islamic state was given on 14 August 1947 in the shape of East Pakistan (Now Bangala Desh ) & West Pakistan . Don't be afraid No another Islamic state . They have to beleave on Indian Constitution and follow the Indian law ammended time to time according in interest of Nation otherwise leave india and take citizen ship of any other country Which they like.
Pakistan da bura haal hai Karan hai Jhooth, nafrat, dokha saazish, darpok, fukrian,badkan doglapan hai. Pakistan ne jo 47 vich hazaro Gurudware, mandir kithe gaye. 23 % Hindus, Sikhs si hun 2 % rah gaya baki kithe gaye. Pak army di tanashahi hai. Awaam bol nai sakde j bole o gayab ho janda fer vaapas nai aanda. Democracy, secular Pak waat a stupid joke.
bhai wo 23% including east pakistan (bangladesh) tha jo 1971 main alag ho gya mostly hindus wahan thy ap facts check kro .aur hmare masjid b gurudware aur mandir ban gye hain jo chor aye hum east punjab main ap history read kro aur jhot ka sahara nahi lo
Mein jb Delhi gia hoon, poone gia hoon, rajasthan gia hoon, punjabi hote hue meri hindu v bhaut hi ashi hai, hindu bhai dhaba meine nashta order kia, jb mein nashta kr rha tha, us dhabe ka Malik mere pass aia aur much se preshen kia, bhai sahib aap punjabi ho naa, meine poosha aap ko kaise malcom ? Usne bola jitny Mirchi tum, tiny mirchy toh koi punjabi hi kha skta hai,
जी ताहिर जी चालाक नहीं है उनकी मजबूरी है कि वह खुलकर नहीं बोल सकते हैं जो बोलने की आजादी भारत में है ,वह पूरे विश्व को पता है की वैसी आजादी दूसरे किसी देश में नहीं है,भारत माता की जय!
Arvindji your intention of bringing People in both countries to understand eachother, but political Aspect not in favour. Our foreign Office has given plenty of visas for Pak people for treatment in india When sushmaji passed away you Could have seen the tweets of Pak People ,no media there condemn Such remarks.
Arvindji ji I think you still in the domain of superiority. You picking and choosing the weakness of Pakistani state.there is many lot of bests and India has also lot of weaknesses. But you showing perfect Indian society. Come out from the so called perfectionism. Check your weaknesses rather picking of other wrongs
@@ranaakram2955 don't worry you Have Washington Post newyork Alzajeera , above that BBC they Employ indians to show or support stories of genocides. Surprisingly no other minorities Claim issues. Gaddars plenty in Form of media, renowned authors , sold themselves to Foreign neighbours, best cream Owaisi brothers.
I thought Tahir Malick is intellectual, but is on the same old mind set. We have given enough chance to Pakistan. Now it is time for India to go forward and do what is right.
Arvind ji aapse request hai ki aapke programme me koi indian expert specially koi Nationalist penalist ko bhi include karo, jo aapke programme me miss hota hai. Next time also include some indian also.
😂😂😂, I really liked saying Barrister sahib fasad ki jar. I think he is very true in his opinions mostly except one or two issues where I felt that he was biased. Arvind Ji your program is really great. Keep it up. 👍
Wow what a program 👌 Rahit Malik started belligerent on being Islamic but then Arvind u melted him by your counter views. I hope he still is melted, will be good for him 😊. Badhani Saab as always.....love to listen to him 🤲
Brother Abdali, Ghazhanvi Ghori had brought all his army. And the army never brings its women with them. And yet the children of Abdali, Ghaznavi and Ghauri were born in today's Pakistan and Hindusthan ... !! Now understand what their relationship is. ??
ur pt is valid...this invaders never brought women with thm...thy raped picked women frm india...all were hindus,jain n buddhist....this jihadis r born to this invaders or converted forcefully....let thm check their dn..
Mr. Tahir is continuously telling that BJP is making India a hindu country. Can he site one instance or policy which is exclusively for hindus made by Modi? Secondly India has tried several times to normalise relationship with Pakistan but everytime she has been backstabbed by Pakistani establishment.
Because at the end he is ??
He is Pakistani. Inki kabhi soch nahi badlegi.. Anpadh hai saale madrassa chhap
Raman Kumar these idiots survive on lies! Nobody believes in them any more. Only thing left is to let them implode! Good luck suckers!
Sab Indian hi Karenge yah Pakistan bhi kuch Karega bhenchod
India that is Bharat is Hindu civilization nation for the last 5,0000 years.
Why Islamic fools living islamic hell countries crying about Bharat being Hindu country?
Arey katuwo do Kodi ke converted musalmano Bharat to Hindu Desh hai sada se jaha Vedas aaye, jaha bhagwano Avtarit hue , jaha Vedic Rishis hue wo desh Hindu rashtra nahi hoga to kya Saudi barbia ko kabja ke Mecca ko udda ke Hindu rashtra banaye?
India wasted 70 yrs for convincing Pakistan, now Mr. Modi is on right path.
lakh lanat on you and pagal modi
Yeah bro
@@gffpak lakh na lat too you ur country
@@gffpak Beta tere abbu ke bare me aisa nahi bilte
@Dan Levi Ek ek ko pakad pakad ke maar dalna chahiye... It's only hindus who r having patience since thousands years. Now it's time to get rid of them. Gazwa E Mulla
You love Islam no problem,Others love hinduism that becomes problem for you.
Not only muslims but all nations in india has problem with RSS. Therefore the policy of BJP has put in india in trouble . The GDP of India has gone into negative for the first time in history and your country is occupied by China and all your neighbours are annoyed with zindia.
@Mad Max cy.
@@abdulrauf9070 All the nations in India have problem with RSS ??? O ' Results of Madrasa education 😂😂😂🤣
@@abdulrauf9070 ha be lakbadchide
@@abdulrauf9070 We are talking about our religious beliefs not GDP.How many nations do you see in one India ,First of all you read what you writing.
Arvind bhai ne jo ye bate boli. ye unke under ka dard hain.
as a indain Hum jab 20 karore upne muslim bhiyo ke sath pyar se rah sakte hain. too hum kisi ke sath bhi rah sakte.
Hindo ka Dharm kbhi khatre main nahi padta. Hum open minded hote hain.
aapki purii takrir suni. very nice.
main vasani ji ko sunta hun.it is true person. we love u.
ek Hindustani delhi se.
thanks
Love barrister Bishani’s smile... should be the signature advert of the show ... it’s absolutely ace
Think about reason thats why B J P has grown it is because of Muslims attitude. Sri Lanka Bangladesh nepal burma bhutaan also small country but they have not security threat.
BJP dont need a muslim attitude to grow. Your age seems to be between 25 to 35. U dont know history of Muslim here n out side. GAZWA ehind is beyond your imagination. So pl think n study history
Srilanka does not have security threats..🙄 what about the serial bomb blasts at the churches that happened few months ago..
ये इन लोगों का mindset है, इन्हें बस भारत से IPL में कुछ लाख-करोड़ रूपए चाहिए, जहन से ही पैदायशी भिखारी मानसिकता के ही होते हैं।
इनकी क़ौम में Hamid Bashani साहब जैसे rare category के बहुत थोड़े से लोग ही पुरी दुनिया में पाते जाते हैं।
अगर कुछ मिलेंगे तो भारत में ही मिलेंगे ... Anyway !
पर क्या कर सकते हैं ...?
Rakesh aap pagla gaye ho... Go to the countries u mentioned here and stay there for a month and then u know
Itne Dialogue kya fayad jab hame hugna or chodpatti karni hai to,,, Tarik ki baat shi haj milne do londo ko India or pakistan k jab communication hoga to sab patri par aayega...
Problem ये है कि ये मुसलमान है
बाकी लोग दुनियां में इंसान हैं
Yes☝️😄
True
😂😂😂😂
problem quaran me hai inke chikne chinke baton me ab Hindu nhi wale h ager us masjid bna di Jaye toh thik hai aur Hinduo ki Astha bhand me Jaye.... Pakistan se hme kuch Lena Dena nhi h
P M Godiyal very true
Mr Tahir Malik, app ko bhi maloom hai aur mujhe bhi humarey yahaan election establishment ke hisab se hota hai.India mei aysa nahi hota hai aur aap jaise daanishmand establishment ko support kartey hai isiliye humaree ye halat hai.
Shame on you Tahir.
Musalle lawalo ki maa bahan.ko chodana na hai hame hinduvoko
Excellent discussion! 💐🌷🌹🇧🇩
Tahir Malik is giving free advice to India and Indians, Mr. Malik give it to Pakistan they needed it much more.
Bashani sahab you are great Mai aap jaise kuchh Muslims ke Karan hi Islam par 1% ok manta hu
4 wars inflicted on India. Proxy war for the last 35 years .whenever India tried to give a chance of peace it got stabbed in the back. So the onus is on Pakistan.
अरविंद जी आपका आशावाद अच्छा है परंतु इनके जहन इतने कंडिशन्ड है और ये पास्ट के झूठे ग्लोरियस सपनो में भटके लोग है ,जो कभी नही जग सकते और आपका ह्रदय हिन्दू करुणा से भरा ह्रदय है ।इंसान तो ये भी है परंतु इनकी कंडीशनिंग ही ऐसी है सचाई को ये कभी नही देख सकते ।असम्भव ,नामुमकिन
I am Pakistani and totally agree with Arvind!
इस एपिसोड वीडियो में तो आप छा गए। ऐसे लीड रोल में मैंने पहले नहीं देखा। हैं ये अलग बात है कि ये dec19 का वीडियो है और आज 22april ko du raha hun। आपका ये प्रोग्राम अरविंद जी में लगभग रोज़ सुनने की कोशिश करता हूं। आपका prog मुझे बहुत अच्छा लगता है। मैं करुणेश सहारनपुर से। धन्यवाद।
Arvind ji. U r a real positive, effective compassionate analysts. God bless you.
अरविंदजी ये कभी ये नहीं मानेंगे की अपने किताबों में परिवर्तन करें कारण इनकी आसमानी किताब जिसमे इनको ऐसा करने से रोकती है
"Dharti Chapti Hai" kitaab ki ye line to change nhi KR skte Jo ki scientifically disproven h..Baki Kya change kreinge.!!
Mr Arvind Saharan,well done.You have conducted this debate very intelligently, particularly the part dealing with Abdali,Ghaznavi&Ghori etc and also about shared heritage and ancestry.
मैं अभी तक इतना सार्थक बहस नही सुना अरबिंद भाई इसकेलिए आपको धन्यवाद।
It's impossible that Pakistan say we r wrong
I request everyone to see the faces and expression of all these three people their faces explain them more than their words .....Their expression and gesture are telling whole story 😊
I had high opinion about Tahir Mallik as liberal progressive. After panel discussion, l concluded a very low or negative opinion about him.
I consider my self a Hindu Nationalist and patriot, but I don't understand ur assessment of Tahir Malik. He has a different opinion and that OK. My honest review is that he doesn't have any low or negative opinion - he just has a different opinion. Just respect it.
I love you Arvind Bhai I like your programs 🙏🙏🙏
Love you so much From Pakistan 🇵🇰☪🕉🇮🇳
Arvindaji bahut badhiya programme /discussion aapne kiya hai.aapki namrata se argument karneki kala jo hai woh dil ko chhu leti hai. Main asha karta jitne bhi Pakistani ish episod ko dekhenge toh to unke Dilo dimaag me aapke dwara rakhe huye sundar vicharo ki khuhsboo ki ameet chhap kayam rahegi.Educated and uneducated ka fark aapne unko samjaya drudhtase makkam hokar parantu vinamra bhasha mei. Yahito basic fark hai hum mein aur unme. I hearty appreciates your thouts. Love you sir.
Chandresh Virani. From Dombivli/Mumbai Maharashtra
अरविंद शरण साहब आप बहुत अच्छी पत्रकारिता करते हैं । As an Indian I often watch your program . Thank you very much .
Tahir malik is a student of madrassa who can only blame Hindus !and still on the otherside saying proud Muslim
Tahir Malik sorry for khan
@Gulrez Rana aby tere ancestor kab convert hue thy .. Rana caste Musalman Ki Nahi ho sakti
@@reenasachdev4019
He will not reply now
@@Scorpionking_2024 u are also Rajput bro why are u keeping arbi name
@@rajniparihar5298
Because I don’t care about names
Tahir Malik is far away from the facts. He does not read or understand the current thought process of Indian people. Average Indian hardly give any value to what is happening in Pakistan. His conclusions are naive. Arvindji bang on the facts. He took good Class of Tahir Malik.
He kept on dodging the questions. He must be saving himself from any backlash back home. Surprisingly Nobody from Pakistan watches these vlogs? OR react on them?
Mr TAHIR at least must have spoken in PUNJABI. That's sad. It's true that one can not speak PUNJABI in (Pakistan's) PUNJAB assembly.
Those who forget their mother tongue has a dim future.
P.S.
Those who forget their history, their geography will change often.
Dr. Chetan nich he hai ye malik
Dr. Chetan meetha zehar bc malik
He cleverly showing his hatred against india he think he is smart and we believe what he is saying
Don't insult him, he is defending his country, like every good citizen should. He is also aware of the problem, but he loves his country, he is grateful to it for providing him life, food and job, just like you are towards your country. Don't hate the person, hate the ideology which has put the country to shame.
Very smarty he is trying to escape from the questions
I completely agree with bashhani saheb. Kashmir are not only problem among them. There are so many things to discuss.
I am a sikh from Tehran and my parents come from zahedan.Most of my relatives were born in either of two cities.Iranians although being a muslim country but they do not let you feel that you are a sikh.This
pakistani s mentality is the same as the other fundamentalists..their
thinking can not change.
अरविंद भाई, आपने एक पेचीदा मसले पर सार्थक वार्तालाप किया...शुक्रिया।
That is why the present government of India is trying to solve these outstanding issues, which is unresolved for the last 70 years.
One has to resolve issues so we can live together unworried.
I support CAA and NRC. Though Mr Bashani and Mr Malik are quite balanced in their mindset, approach and opinion, Mr Malik has a mindset quite common among Pakistanis. They want to score point over us by trying to teach us secularism. If secularism is important for Pakistan then they must adopt secularism. We are not going to appease Pakistanis atall. Jai Shriram. If any lesson is to be learnt by anyone it is Pakistan.
Mr. Vinod Kumarji I fully agree with you honest trust rises out of sincere trustworthy experiences and reliability. In that regard one has to be extremely cautious and alert thanks ❤
ये भाई कह रहा है भारत नही हिंदू ये सही रहेगा कहना अपना दिल धर्मशाला बना ले और पाकिस्तानी नही मुस्लिम कहना सही रहेगा अपना दिल तो अपना है मै( मुस्लिम) क्यू भारत से(हिंदू) के साथ क्यू रहु
Aravinda Saharan I am at the age of 66. I respect you as well as Hamid Bashani jee.
To day l heard Tahir Malik Sub ,my respect is for hjm also.
Tahir malik himself shown his hindu hatred, his argument is so swallow and shabby
Bhai ye surrendered people hi.... Hum hai asli Malik... These are converted jats... Kya apko pta hi ... Aapke yha kinne Jats hi ... Wo bhi Malik.... Jatworld.com dekh lo ek bar
@@robinmalik1040 India is great and Indians are the greatest...
Converted fattu jat h yh
Absolutely
I support cab NRC
Pakistan has to show good faith in dealing with India.
India will not talk with a gun at its temple.
Hello Sirs. Im from Pakista. It has not very logn been since I started watching and listening you here. Honestly I liked it. After watching a number of your programes in previous, I watched today's episod and found myself convinced by Mr. Tahir Malik. It is very well said. Thank you Mr. Malik. You spoke my mind. However, to my beliefs, its just one element of few more that need attention of you all i.e. the proxies of others in the reagion, the media influences of both sides where almost all looks for their rating and God knows what n what. However i like n appreciate your intentions and the efforts. May Allah help you all and guid you all in a correct and right direction. Aameem.
Khalid.
Basani sahab.. We always get educated by you... the perspective that u bring it deepens our understanding of this area.. We in India usually do not pay attention in what's happening in Pakistan...
My family supports CAA. We are proud of P. M.
Why because u r family hate muslims
@@iqbalumarnatkar1835
No we hate illegal ghuspaithiye
@@viking7769 ...amit shah and brahmans are from iran illigal ghuspaithiya
@@iqbalumarnatkar1835
Anyone who says that we won't show documents is ghuspaithiya rest are OK regardless Hindu or Muslim by the way are you Indian?
@@viking7769 ....Any one who make law based on religion that if hindu do not found any documents its ok but if muslim do not found documents its ghupsithiya
arvind ji again what a lovely host u r....hamare hosts ap se bahot kuchhsikh sakte hain...thanx hamid basani sir..thanx tahir malik sir..
Ye sab logon ka waqt barbad kar rahe hain pakhandi
Hindustan m Anchor k samne kathmulle ukaat dekhate hai . esliye Anchor Ko chup karwana padhta hai
Pura video dekhne ke baad, main point bashani sir ne last me bola ki museum band hi na ho jaye...
This is painful but true .....
Tahir Malik Sb very intelligently spoke reality of indo Pakistan relations. We all should learn from him.
Thanks Arvind for bringing Tahir sir and Hamid sir in program. Both they are great people whom people love to listen..
प्रिय बन्घु ,
बशानी साहब शुर्किया,
आपके आखरी जुम्ले ने पूरी बहस(पाकिस्तान) की पोल ही खोल दी।( कुछ भी हो जाये पतनाला यही गिरेगा।)
ताहिर! अहमदियों की शरण में जाओ, और मानो नये विद्वान जन्म ले सकते है। तेरे कल्याण का यही एक रास्ता है।
Sare lecture India ke liye hi hai
15 lakh bangladeshiyon se fark nahi padta
10ooo ,20000 Hinduon se Pakistan ko fark padta hai
Hellow Arvind bhahi. Kia hal ha apka? Bhot acha kam kartay hain Love you from Pakistan
Arvind Ji thanks for your journalism.
Tahir Malik Sir, hum Indians or khas taur par Hindus, Pakistan se bahut taklif uthaye hai. Ab or nehi hai. Ab toh tit for tat hi hogi. Koi chance nehi rahegi Pakistan ke liye.
😀😀😂😂
Just live you life according to your stance of not living with Hindus.
Kashmir issue is resolved now and only pending issue remaining is getting back POK. India has moved away from trying to normal relations with Pakistan. We don’t give a damm about them anymore and they can do their worst! Good luck!
And what about China occupied Ladakh Sir?
Tahir ji, india has given "most favoured nation" status to pakistan in 1998. Pakistan cannot do same to india in 20 years. You never put control on proxy war against india. You never said to hand hafez sayed, dawood to india. You were involved in parliament attack, mumbai attack and many more terrorist activities against india. And you are saying "Galti dono taraf se hai"
Tell me why India is not having problems with any other neighbouring countries only with pakistan. On the other hand pakistan has bad relations with all his neighbours. (Not China bcoz master slave relationship). It means something is wrong with pakistan not india. You cannot hide behind excuse that we are not democratic. The problem is your biased mindset. In the show for peace you were carrying Pakistan agenda, unknowingly. That's the mindset problem I am talking about. I forecast now that few years later you will be starting jihad against chinese also.
If you want good relations with india you have to show sincerety on ground. This is two way road.
Nepal china sri lanka Afghanistan now bangladesh.....all hate india
@@ekthapakistan7587 tum log btao indians black kyun hn
Hamid Bhashani sb spoke well about the facts which Tahir Malik sb cant discribbed easily while living here and representing Pakistan , anyway it was a good show to close both countries for better future
We gave a face-saving to Bhutto by releasing 90,000 prisoners of war in 1971. What did we get? He went back after Shimla agreement and announced a 100-year war with India by giving her a thousand cuts.
Kya shandar discussion, bhasani sahab is great scholar, arvind organized shandar discussion,
Who asked for separate country on the basis of religion...?
Another point is... u r not discussing CAA...?
Better we are separated otherwise what if 40 crores more Muslims from both neighbouring countries with us? I say give them kashmir along with all muslims from India.
Hello Arvind, I like your programmes because your style brings out the reality truth !! If Pak is insecure of India because of its size, then this is for infinity!! The real reason and it is self evident, Pak wants to get as much and more and wants to live in the past + dominate the non+momin ! Your man from Pak continues to deny the truth and his country will definitely have to reap what they have been sowing for 70 years. It is dominated by a toxic punjabi military regime who are doing great crimes against the Baloch, Pashtuns and the rest. May I suggest you invite a pashtun or a Baloch on your discussion to get the balanced view.
I am a Koshure from the J/K valley and for me, no resolution is more important than the justice delivered to the KPs who were genocided against + whether the World agrees with it or not. Modiji is on track to deliver this and we suport him. This fobia in Pak about BJP is another excuse for the Pak Govt to fool its own poor .....
Boht hi jada suljhe huye smjhdhar or point pe baat krne wale ye teeno 🙏
Boht boht shukriya boht kuch smjhne ko sikhne ko mila 🙏
Every time I watch your show I feel proud of your initiative ....... Great people are not born great sometimes, it's their courage to take the first step toward wisdom that makes them great ..... & Happy to say u r one among those people 🙏
Mr. Bhashani sahab is quite deep thinking and coolly philosophical and mature thinking., which is quite interesting and unusual.
Whenever India thinks good of Pakistans,history tells me that India cannot count on good will of sincere goodwill.
10:00
Everything is fine now, everyone in my country has accepted CAA / NRC / NRP. All the country accepted 4 days of exemptions except for minor incidents.
Long live Mother India
Even I am from South india, I become emotional after listening this video.
Tahir sahib .... Both countries have thought ,which is in Punjabi ," Thale Nahin Lagnaa" 😁😁😁👍👍🤘 great . We have be a world citizen.
When Tahir Sahib talks about people meeting each other then he is thinking about Punjabi meeting Punjabi. They are 28 more states in India who are least connected culturally with Pakistan.
Arvind Sir ye program maine Char bar dekha, fir bhi ye aaur ek bar dekhana chahenge. Isme bahot acchi bate huvi aaur aakharika share bhi Dil ke karib raha
हमीद बसानी साहब मै आपको सलाम करता हूँ सही बोलने के लिए
पाकिस्तान की उम्र बस अब 25 साल ओर है उसके बाद अखंड भारत होगा जय श्री राम।
Nice and exceptionally good programme. Thank you very much Arvind Saharan ji.
Aa usual Barrister Hamid Bashani Sahab's views are unbiased and transparent. Unfortunately. Tahir Malik Sahab's views are shying away from the reality, though the essence of his views are OK. I thank all of you three persons.
ताहिरा मलिक तुम बड़े बेशर्म हो ।वन्देमातरम भारत माता की जय ।
Tahir lives in a well.
He cannot think beyond his boundaries.
Arvind bhai, apki waah waah.
Jo apne itni siddat se inn Pakistanis ki baat suni
Koi farq nhi pdta ki Pakistani toranto me rhe yaa khi bhi.
Wo hmesha aisa hi rhega.
U can’t expect a journalist from Pakistan to speak anything that will land him in trouble like Najam Sethi Hamid Mir and others ?
Arvindji, though timing wise this video was long but I can understand how tight steps you are walking the rope. Mazaa Aa gaya. Kudos! 👍
Appreciate the thoughts, thoroughly enjoyed. And Bashani Sir, as always cool and rational.
We hindus are in fear when mulla increased then demand seprate Islamic state.
Don't warry this will never happen
Separate Islamic state was given on 14 August 1947 in the shape of East Pakistan (Now Bangala Desh ) & West Pakistan .
Don't be afraid No another Islamic state .
They have to beleave on Indian Constitution and follow the Indian law ammended time to time according in interest of Nation otherwise leave india and take citizen ship of any other country Which they like.
Mr.Arvind sharan your every word is like a bullet based on true facts, god bless you and your family a long healthy lifestyle.
Thanks Ganesan Ji.
Wow...this is what happens when brothers meet after long time.
सीधी बात - ये दुनिया में कहीं रहने लायक नहीं है; पाकिस्तान में भी नहीं।
Pakistan da bura haal hai Karan hai
Jhooth, nafrat, dokha saazish, darpok, fukrian,badkan doglapan hai.
Pakistan ne jo 47 vich hazaro Gurudware, mandir kithe gaye.
23 % Hindus, Sikhs si hun 2 % rah gaya baki kithe gaye. Pak army di tanashahi hai. Awaam bol nai sakde j bole o gayab ho janda fer vaapas nai aanda.
Democracy, secular Pak waat a stupid joke.
KIYA HAHAHHAHAH HAM NAHI MANTAY
bhai wo 23% including east pakistan (bangladesh) tha jo 1971 main alag ho gya mostly hindus wahan thy ap facts check kro .aur hmare masjid b gurudware aur mandir ban gye hain jo chor aye hum east punjab main ap history read kro aur jhot ka sahara nahi lo
@@muhammadsherazisherazi8714 बेशर्म लोग ।
Tahir malik ka logic ek school kid ki tarah hai. Hansi aa gayee 😂
Mein jb Delhi gia hoon, poone gia hoon, rajasthan gia hoon, punjabi hote hue meri hindu v bhaut hi ashi hai, hindu bhai dhaba meine nashta order kia, jb mein nashta kr rha tha, us dhabe ka Malik mere pass aia aur much se preshen kia, bhai sahib aap punjabi ho naa, meine poosha aap ko kaise malcom ? Usne bola jitny Mirchi tum, tiny mirchy toh koi punjabi hi kha skta hai,
I completely agree with Mr Tahir Malik
Excellent I think he is talking very true & believable .
Thank u sir for making peace video for us , luv from India.
ताहिर मलिक बहुत चालाक है वही चला कि इस समय पाकिस्तान दिखा रहा है
जी ताहिर जी चालाक नहीं है उनकी मजबूरी है कि वह खुलकर नहीं बोल सकते हैं जो बोलने की आजादी भारत में है ,वह पूरे विश्व को पता है की वैसी आजादी दूसरे किसी देश में नहीं है,भारत माता की जय!
Arvindji your intention of bringing
People in both countries to understand eachother, but political
Aspect not in favour. Our foreign
Office has given plenty of visas for
Pak people for treatment in india
When sushmaji passed away you
Could have seen the tweets of Pak
People ,no media there condemn
Such remarks.
Arvindji ji
I think you still in the domain of superiority.
You picking and choosing the weakness of Pakistani state.there is many lot of bests and India has also lot of weaknesses. But you showing perfect Indian society.
Come out from the so called perfectionism.
Check your weaknesses rather picking of other wrongs
@@ranaakram2955 don't worry you
Have Washington Post newyork
Alzajeera , above that BBC they
Employ indians to show or support stories of genocides.
Surprisingly no other minorities
Claim issues. Gaddars plenty in
Form of media, renowned authors , sold themselves to
Foreign neighbours, best cream
Owaisi brothers.
I thought Tahir Malick is intellectual, but is on the same old mind set. We have given enough chance to Pakistan. Now it is time for India to go forward and do what is right.
Barrister Bashani Sir Totally Exposed Tahir Malik & Pakistan
Congress had kept Bangladeshis as sons-in-law, NRC will soon be applicable in the whole country:
Arvind ji aapse request hai ki aapke programme me koi indian expert specially koi Nationalist penalist ko bhi include karo, jo aapke programme me miss hota hai. Next time also include some indian also.
Arvind ji hi kaafi hain.😅
@39:00 😂 🙏 Tahir Malik , world knows your country by their deeds , not by Economy. citizens of Bhutan has more respect than citizen of Pakistan.
Arvind Saharan sir ap ka channel main dekha or suna hoon Meri taraf se ap ko Dua hai ap jug jug jiye ap k mafik insan desh k liye bht jaruri hain.
Arvind sir u r a great generalist ,true indian ,u hv a high vision ,and patriotic person
15 Nahi Abhi 15 Karod death ho to bhi CAA wapas nahi hoga... this is clean India..
True.
😂😂😂, I really liked saying Barrister sahib fasad ki jar. I think he is very true in his opinions mostly except one or two issues where I felt that he was biased. Arvind Ji your program is really great. Keep it up. 👍
ताहिर जी हिंदू तो समझ जाएगा पर मुस्लिम को केसे समझाओगे जो कुरान से बाहर ही नहीं निकला
वो कुराण के बाहर निकाल ना नही चाहता
Wow what a program 👌
Rahit Malik started belligerent on being Islamic but then Arvind u melted him by your counter views. I hope he still is melted, will be good for him 😊. Badhani Saab as always.....love to listen to him 🤲
G^8, talk and ending music. Thanks a lot Arvind ji
if want to ask this if pakistani are so secular then why they dont oppose Kashmiri padits carnation in Kashmir?.
thanks
If Pakistan have become Secular , there would have been better Relations between India & Pakistan .
Abey waha 100% muslim. Secular declare karke bHi kya farak padta hai
@sikander haroon And What is Secular in your eyes ? Why Pakistan is not Secular like India.
@sikander haroon what you mean by Secular ? Do you think God is Secular ?
Nahi imran Khan declare ki wo risayite madena banana chachte hai
Brother Abdali, Ghazhanvi Ghori had brought all his army.
And the army never brings its women with them.
And yet the children of Abdali, Ghaznavi and Ghauri were born in today's Pakistan and Hindusthan ... !! Now understand what their relationship is. ??
ur pt is valid...this invaders never brought women with thm...thy raped picked women frm india...all were hindus,jain n buddhist....this jihadis r born to this invaders or converted forcefully....let thm check their dn..
Me Tahir Malik ki soch Ko Salam krta hoon....I really appreciate it
Arvind bro when ever u will come Pakistan I will like to meet you cos I have lot of respect for u .You r doing good.
You have all party and your constitution is islamist
Do not forget you have notorious blashfamy law
Why 27%hindu become three percent dear