Emilee Walker Same, I don't know why. OH WAIT! It's because they copied how she sung it. They should have sung it they way they would sing it. Not how Melanie would.
@@stantwice1490 Yes, she does, Melanie voice is superior to this rat🐀. Now Melanie and Britney that is different, they both have different styles, I see Britney as a good artist, but she is too commercial and common for my taste, but I see and hear Melanie's voice, and I hear a very unique voice that is neither commercial nor common.
Lauren Morfi exactly, that's why i said the meaning of "inspired" is far off from "copying" because sierra and alex said "inspired by Melanie Martinez" but they basically just copied her rendition
Neiko Essönë No it isn't because if someone said that I doubt they'd be on national television. Not to mention they gave Melanie no credit whatsoever. They even put it on an album. That's clearly unfair.
THANK YOU! Finally I read a decent, mature comment after all these people easily offended for Melanie. Jesus Christ she rly does have one of the worst fan bases
ur opinion is very rude lol. they’re both very talented, but of course it isn’t right to copy someone else. i know ur comment was posted a year ago so i hope u became more mature 🤗
Honestly, they weren't bad, but I just love Melanie's voice. Being raspy and smooth at the same time! I really do prefer Melanie's version because of her beautiful voice and ability to play the guitar.
jimmy martinez If you don't like copy cats... than you should not like Melanie because she copied Yael Naim who did the cover first in this exact style.
bitch can you actually sing better? do you think your the best? nigga idk about you but dont hate on someone just because someone is better. you do realize smeone is better than you?
Emmer They never gave Melanie any credit whatsoever, I doubt that's fair considering they won the show and Melanie don't win the voice. Not to mention they put it on an album. *_sigh_*
Oh my god. No one copied anyone. They just both happened to do an ACOUSTIC cover of toxic. People cover the same songs in the same fashion ALL THE TIME.
I saw some people in comment section say that Naim did it first. Sorry but it wasn't, neither the key, notes, and beat are the same. Melanie has real talent. She actually auditioned on 2012, while they audition on 2013. Melanie's audition was uploaded on YT on 2014 though.
I'm sorry, here's an example of a random teenage commenter who is trying to be "rebellious" and "different" from everyone in the comment section. But seriously, they did not "copy" Melanie. They decided to do an acoustic version of the song, as did Melanie. Not everyone wants to sing it in the original style, like come the fuck on.
But they did the same tones and tempo as her. They could’ve chosen any tempo and shit but they decided to do it Melanie’s way. If they said they were doing a cover of Melanie doing a cover of Brittany, it would’ve went fine, but they kept it hidden.
Im sorry but just because someone sings the same song someone else does-- a song that is over a decade old-- does not mean theyre "stealing" from melanie. You guys make me so disappointed. So if I cover toxic, I'll be stealing from Melanie?
They didn't steal Melanie's song because it wasn't hers, but they stole the tone Mel used to cover the song. So, they copied her style but didn't steal the song. I just wanted to state it... (=ﾟωﾟ)ﾉ
well i mean just because one person used a deep tone doesn't mean someone else can't. It's not as a serious crime as people make it out to be. It isn't about where you got the song, its about how well you sing it lol
Rockeyboa i did actually, multiple times. watching talent show videos like this one brought me to melanies audition. i wouldnt say they copied anything. they may have been inspired by the way she sang it sultry, but they didnt "steal" anything like these cringy crybabies say.
They didn’t copy the song from Melanie because it wasn’t hers to begin with but the style that Melanie sang in was unique and the style Alex and Sierra sang in was almost identical to Melanie’s
You guys are over exaggerating. The guitar vocals weren't close to Melanie's. They sound similar, but they aren't. And what does it matter? They were just making a cover for the song, they were singing a COVER. You guys need to chill. And I know I am going to get a lot of hate for this, but I am also a Melanie fan, and I simply don't agree with everybody bashing everybody who "copies" Melanie.
Person 1: Hey can I copy your homewok?
Person 2: Sure. Just change it a bit so they won't think you copied mine.
Person 1: Ok, thanks!
Azusa Shimazaki Illumanati:Stay right there
Lmaoooo HAHHAHAHAHAH
True
I too saw that insta post for sure
So true but they didn't ask lol! I loved this comment
They honestly should've just sang one of Melanies song instead of copying
Yeah cause they can't just copy
She hadn’t released any songs yet
Faith The Potato she had unreleased ones
222likes dont ruin it
it's just a simple acoustic change and i bet people have done it way before melanie
"I mean we do it kinda diferent"
mmhhmm...
lmao
MEL DID WAYYY BETTER
Jxca YESSSS
i thought that same cover of toxic was on glee
Jxca true
Jxca I know Mel will always with #Crybaby
I agree fully
Do the judges know that girls version is Melanies?
sadly no
They obviously don’t lmao. Which is stupid.
No
probably
uh
Melanie did a better job. Alex and Sierra just sound like a Walmart copy, knock-off version of her. Wait, aren't even close to sounding like her.
I agree not because im a fan but mel has the voice and they dont
Yeah I agree as well
+Ana Avila exactly
Tru that they sound like they're trying too hard to copy her
Listen to Yaël Naïm - Toxic that came before Melanie.
at least Mel has talent
Blurryfrøøtbaby ~oh shit, the shade
i know right!!
Blurryfrøøtbaby Burn tho
Madaratt z
Those two weren't that bad...
Like they even skipped the “with the” like Melanie
Melanie's version is even better than the original one lol
She looked horrified
AoibheRoblox Supple Ikr!
Weirqueen who?
Jayla Graham huh? What do you mean by “who” sorry I didn’t quite get it
Weirqueen you said ikr to that girl so I asked who..
why is that dude on the stage for moral support because I mean he can’t sing :p
Ruby Williams wtf have you seen his voice ?? in the ACTUAL song ? it’s really good.
Be quiet nobody Asked for your opinion keep it to yourself.
Copying talent doesn't make you talented lol
i thought that same cover of toxic was on glee
Unless you know, they sang really well? Which they did :)
Anuhea812
FACTS
Anuhea812 they are not coping if u look at the video where they sing it and u look at the date they sang it it was before Melanie even sang it
YOU CANNOT COPY TALENT! WTF hahahaha
The smug look on that woman's face... she knows that she copied Melanie but others don't
cindy for real tho i like your profile
IKR
cindy - ikr
Yeah:
Ikr. That toxic smile. Ugh.
LEAVE MY LIL MELANIE ALONE.
RIGHT.
IKR
for fuck sake kiddos the song is Toxic is made by and israel-french singer Yael Naim. Get your shit right
alex and sierra preformed it before melanie lol....
Toidleboy Gaming no, they didn't.
*2:06*
That girl is *TRIGGERED* she knows
That is just such a copyright. We all know Melanie sang it better. I can't believe someone would do such a thing 😠😕
No it NOT, It's a simple acoustic change you can't copyright a style of music.
I agree
I think the girl at 0:01 knew what they were doing
Nadine yeah.
Yeah ikr
Omg yes
Of course she know..
If you mean they know that they are doing a better version then Melanie and they know she doesn’t own that version or the song as a whole then I agree
I like Melanie better :'(
same
+Erika Correa yeah
same
she gave me chills
Same
I hope you see my middle finger rise cause you're bullies in the school yard!
True Mel Fans know what I mean (;
jerryparas41434 YASSSSS
I love dear porcupine ⭐️⭐️
Dear Porcupine! My fav unreleased.
dear porcupine
panic!forthecrybabies toppityparty dear porcupine!
yo this is kinda cringy
LiLY how?
@@fann.9874 cause of Alex and Sierra
wth do you mean kinda
alex and sierra are always cringey
Are you jealous of them.
"I think we do it kinda different"
this honestly pisses me off xD
I know right
omg same
true that
alex and sierra preformed it before melanie lol....
well there both copying Brittany and hers was the best and original so.
And on the expressions, she sang horrible and Mel sings beautiful
sing to me and I can judge you thas 4 having bad attitude so stop plz thats rude
Paula Flores Army army
typical.asian Girl it's called having an opinion. :)
Kagome, Kagome It’s called facts, she/he can’t do better than them.
It's mean but its true
I'm kinda mad at this
Emilee Walker Same, I don't know why. OH WAIT! It's because they copied how she sung it. They should have sung it they way they would sing it. Not how Melanie would.
Emilee Walker same
Emilee Walker me too
Emilee Walker Same.
Melanie martinez is the BEST!
Yuno Gasai you and I are literally twins. MEL AND YUNO IS A HEAVENLY MATCH
CORRUPTED CHAN
Yeah she is melanie
melanie is NOT the best. She is the meaning of LIFEEE
Duh
YASSS
The parts sierra sings, mel does them better
Nothing Matters yeah. She has no talent.
Yeah agreed
Yup
Well you’re obviously def because Sierra has beautiful voice
xArianatorx She does have talent.
I honestly disliked Alex's and Sierra's SO much .
SavannahGracee Me too.
Ikr
SavannahGracee you're the one who song I hate you and I love you and it's the most annoying song I've ever heard
same
People are going to dislike you if you keep this up so I suggest you not type this.
Melanie is better and always will be
Melanie's cover is more beautiful than original.
Love Eugeniac Yeah it's more clean and better quality
Love Eugeniac Lol thats what I thought
i thought that same cover of toxic was on glee
Nah original is so iconic nothing can beat that hit
*LEAVE THE CRYBABY ALONE* 😡😡
Emely Hernandez
Yeah
Be quiet they wanted to sing the song.
@@jaylaboss677 be quiet it's the whole point of the damn video
None of the notes or rhythms were original. They just plain up copied it, and didn't even bother to try and make it different.
yEs
Melanie rules over that girl and Britney 👌👌👌
No she doesn't
Britney and Melanie are both queens
Don’t compare a queen against a queen
Forget about those peasants who copied Melanie
@@stantwice1490
Yes, she does, Melanie voice is superior to this rat🐀. Now Melanie and Britney that is different, they both have different styles, I see Britney as a good artist, but she is too commercial and common for my taste, but I see and hear Melanie's voice, and I hear a very unique voice that is neither commercial nor common.
@@stantwice1490 mmm k
Any day
that other girls face expressions kept making me giggle lol and her eyes. I liked Melanie's better.
I'm so triggered. They even had the fricken guitar effect in the background. Melanie was savage compared to them.
And she had her little tambourine between her feet. Melanie is ACTUALLY talented.
They sang the same thing but Melanie Martinez did it way better!!!😁❤️😄🤔😂😆
Them: Y’know we do it kinda different
Me: *Rly?*
The word INSPIRED is far different from COPYING ffs
Lauren Morfi exactly, that's why i said the meaning of "inspired" is far off from "copying" because sierra and alex said "inspired by Melanie Martinez" but they basically just copied her rendition
Nicky Lim but they say they did that because they do it "different" (well not too much if Melanie created that version)
Neiko Essönë
No it isn't because if someone said that I doubt they'd be on national television. Not to mention they gave Melanie no credit whatsoever. They even put it on an album. That's clearly unfair.
THANK YOU! Finally I read a decent, mature comment after all these people easily offended for Melanie. Jesus Christ she rly does have one of the worst fan bases
I don't blame them - Melanie is just awesome!
you right
Maya Ka noooo
axolotl Lover lol yeah
axolotl Lover lol true
axolotl Lover they said that it was their own version
They obviously saw how Melanie did it so they liked it and wanted to copy it. I loved the way you edited it though
Pink Love like how Yael Naim did it, not Melanie. You should look her up they all got their style for this song from her.
I'm not mad because the other version is just called shit😝😝😝 and melanie's was called a masterpiece😇😇😇😇😇😇😇😇
ur opinion is very rude lol. they’re both very talented, but of course it isn’t right to copy someone else. i know ur comment was posted a year ago so i hope u became more mature 🤗
surgetasic ! She was giving her opinion just like you are
Ik it's rude but true😂
I think melanie is better than those two
they could have at least said sponsored by Melanie Martinez
Cry Baby I would of said that
Melanie martinez did not pay them to sing that version so they couldnt have said it was sponsored. They should have said it was inspired by her
this two guys is just a photocopy of Melanie. 😂🙄
do you sing better version ??? you can start now and see if you have copy.
Listen to Yaël Naïm - Toxic that came before Melanie.
Sierra isn't a guy and u should know that by now🤔
*ew i can feel the unoriginal vibes*
*TOO STRONG TOO STRONG*
Alex will never live up to melanie
monster the sdit actually he will not like you.
@@jaylaboss677 lmao I posted that 2 years ago going on three. You're very late
monster the sdit okay and?
@@jaylaboss677 unlike you I don't have time for your childish games
Guys we know who has the talent here 🍼
User Us Yess
User Us Yes alex and sierra
i'm joking Melanie of course #ImACrybaby
User Us yesss mel
User Us YEEEEE MEL
User Us YES MEL
Melanie's is better there just copying her in a bad version
Alexa Dondiego SOOO TRUEEE
Probably got inspired maybe stop being a salty fuck they're actually good
Yeah they’re singing was kinda sucky..
i love Melanie, but this seems a little far fetched, i dont think they copied her, their style is more country than anything.
Oddrae K yh
Oddrae K they did it
Honestly, they weren't bad, but I just love Melanie's voice. Being raspy and smooth at the same time! I really do prefer Melanie's version because of her beautiful voice and ability to play the guitar.
Thank you thank you ! I Rember this his couple and I was furious I can’t believe ppl voted for these cheaters!
Blue Panda be quiet they wanted to do this song let them be.
melanie martinez #1 Brittany #2 and the duet #3 they were so bad
Did you just say britney is seconds jfc
And mel wasn't even the first person to do it like this
Pedro Henrique who was then
OMG they copy melanie martinez the best in this world omg!!!
BOI LAY OFF MY LIL BEAN MELANIE AND GET YOUR OWN STYLE FFS
2:17 BUDDY THATS EXACTLY THE SAME
Melanie’s version of this will always be my favorite 💕
I do not like copies caters I like melanie Martinez better
no style at all they suck😈😈😈
I'm just so mad
jimmy martinez If you don't like copy cats... than you should not like Melanie because she copied Yael Naim who did the cover first in this exact style.
How old are you 9?
jimmy martinez Are you 5?
For some reason im fuckin pissed
Melanie Martinez DID IT BETTER SHE IS A CORRUPTED VERSION
Now i know why Melanie Martinez did the song copycat 😂.
She’s getting credit for how they sung aka the version not bc they sung it good!
im shook thats why alexa and sierra mist haven't been relevant since 2013 and mel is #6 on trending right now
but they cant sing
Xxlovly lady lumpsxX but they won
JustBecauseImHelen
HOW TF?!
Xxlovly lady lumpsxX They sound fine to me. Not good but average.
bitch can you actually sing better? do you think your the best? nigga idk about you but dont hate on someone just because someone is better. you do realize smeone is better than you?
Didn't realize this was Melanie's song .-. If Alex and Sierra want to sing it like that, why can't they?
Your icon!!!!!! 😍
It isn't Melanie's song but they completely copied Melanie's unique way of covering the song.
DalekGirl because they were trying to sound like Melanie when they were singing it
Emmer They never gave Melanie any credit whatsoever, I doubt that's fair considering they won the show and Melanie don't win the voice. Not to mention they put it on an album. *_sigh_*
karkki daim "unique" she literally just slowed down the beat and the chords.
Melanie did it way better
Do the judges even know that Melanie did the changes to the song
Omg my anger is BOILING
Oh my god. No one copied anyone.
They just both happened to do an ACOUSTIC cover of toxic. People cover the same songs in the same fashion ALL THE TIME.
I think everyone who is going off about his need to calm down. I think Melanie would be so happy about this, knowing she inspired them.
I’m glad I’m not the only one who thought that!
WTF IS THAT 1:42 IS SOUNDED LIKE A GOAT OR COW .
Beautiful Day101 agree
The title seems so immature to me really??? "Copy"
Could have put "Alex and Sieraa cover of Toxic (version by Melanie Martinez )"
FĄŇŇĮÀ they did copy it bcos they said they made it. But they didn’t
Anii LaCute she said they do it different not that they made it as an original
FĄŇŇĮÀ she didn't put that in the title because she did come Melanie
But they never said it was a cover and you can't do a cover of something that's a cover of something else
except they actually claimed it was their own twist on the song, with no inspiration. I feel "copy" was an appropriate use of words for this matter
HOW DID I NOT NOTICE THIS???
They should've gave the credit to Mel
Listen up Melanie did not invent slowing down a song quit hating on them they didn't a great job and so did Melanie idk what the big deal is here
I love Shiloh Seaton FREAKING FINALLY... SOMEONE WHO ACTUALLY HAS COMMON SENSE
Yes but the notes mel hits are unique and not just slowed down
I saw some people in comment section say that Naim did it first. Sorry but it wasn't, neither the key, notes, and beat are the same. Melanie has real talent. She actually auditioned on 2012, while they audition on 2013. Melanie's audition was uploaded on YT on 2014 though.
I'm sorry, here's an example of a random teenage commenter who is trying to be "rebellious" and "different" from everyone in the comment section. But seriously, they did not "copy" Melanie. They decided to do an acoustic version of the song, as did Melanie. Not everyone wants to sing it in the original style, like come the fuck on.
Dead . . . Finally someone in the comments that's saying that these too copied and being immature
You don’t know how notes work... You can’t just sing an acoustic version of the song and all the note sounds exactly the same... like seriously 😒
Kierra lmao I love the first part of your comment.
Totally agree,but the problem is that they did it exactly the same! And they did'nt even told them that wasn't their version,it was melanie's...
But they did the same tones and tempo as her. They could’ve chosen any tempo and shit but they decided to do it Melanie’s way. If they said they were doing a cover of Melanie doing a cover of Brittany, it would’ve went fine, but they kept it hidden.
the fact that simon said that it‘s a incedible version of the song is what makes me mad because, he probaly didnt know but, mel made that cover
Mel was better.
+Hugo Cortez yes she was
+Hugo Cortez yes she was haha
+Hugo Cortez I think marline was better but it's ur opinion
@@hugocortez8681 ik i'm late but frick u🖕
Good job!
thank you. Still bothers me that no one called them out on it in person.
GlitterGift They've mentioned it on twitter before that they did give credit but it wasn't aired on the show..
J Vera hey, no way! link me? That would be incredibly disrespectful of x-factor to do that.
+GlitterGift true
GlitterGift yeah!!
I'm triggered
1: 13 that guy knows 😂
Ali Alvarez That look on his face-
Thats the face of "wtf is this rip-off????"
I am offended
this is really pissing me off wow.
jeez.
Sorry but no lmao
Pretty. Odd. Right!?
You can copy Melanie, but b*tch you can't copy her talent❤❤
if i was in that crowd, i would throw my shoes to both of them and yell "YOU GOT NO CREATIVITY SO DAT MEANS NO TALENT M8!!!!!!"
Do you all not know what an acoustic cover is
Dystirium nope they don't they're to hardheaded and salty to comprehend and call this a copy
It's so alike wth 😂 . Melanie soundss wayy better thoughh(:💓
Melanie did absolutely amazing she’s so talented
Little did Melanie know she'd become bigger than the hosts of the show that rejected her
I literally never heard of her before people were whining about Alex & Sierra just now
Melanie did much. Better
Sorry but you said it's inspired by Melanie Martinez
I am not death
That's the exact same way as she sang it
Phandom at the disco death?
I a huge fan of Melanie and not so much of the other two but they were only similar not completely copying!!
dammit this makes me angry af! you can litteraly see on there faces thats its not their own version jezus!
I have a Melanie Martinez song for them “your a copy cat you take it then you leave it honey just like that”
I would be so mad before all the stuff has been said/ done but right now I’m kinda just weirded out just listening to this.
Im sorry but just because someone sings the same song someone else does-- a song that is over a decade old-- does not mean theyre "stealing" from melanie. You guys make me so disappointed. So if I cover toxic, I'll be stealing from Melanie?
They didn't steal Melanie's song because it wasn't hers, but they stole the tone Mel used to cover the song. So, they copied her style but didn't steal the song. I just wanted to state it... (=ﾟωﾟ)ﾉ
well i mean just because one person used a deep tone doesn't mean someone else can't. It's not as a serious crime as people make it out to be. It isn't about where you got the song, its about how well you sing it lol
Kawaii Neko Did you not watch the video? They clearly copied her style
Rockeyboa i did actually, multiple times. watching talent show videos like this one brought me to melanies audition. i wouldnt say they copied anything. they may have been inspired by the way she sang it sultry, but they didnt "steal" anything like these cringy crybabies say.
They didn’t copy the song from Melanie because it wasn’t hers to begin with but the style that Melanie sang in was unique and the style Alex and Sierra sang in was almost identical to Melanie’s
so true omg
I like how Britney is worst out of all of them
XD
WHY WOULD YOU PEOPLE DO THIS
To be honest, I prefer Melanie’s version and also the version from Pitch Perfect three.
I'm not annoyed by the fact that they used Mel's own Style, but they just can't sing, they sound so bad, i don't like them
alex and sierra preformed it before melanie lol.... and they won x factor so i would say they can sing nice try tho
It is actually Yael Naim's style... So, they all kind of copied her.
You guys are over exaggerating. The guitar vocals weren't close to Melanie's. They sound similar, but they aren't. And what does it matter? They were just making a cover for the song, they were singing a COVER. You guys need to chill. And I know I am going to get a lot of hate for this, but I am also a Melanie fan, and I simply don't agree with everybody bashing everybody who "copies" Melanie.
No, it is literally Mel's amp feed.