Yall know that u could do a cover of a cover right? they never claimed that they "own" the song/cover, which means that it's okay that they made a COVER of a cover of a song(toxic). I'm a die-hard fan of Mel, and I'm sure that even Mel could agree that it's ok. There's nothing wrong with what they did. Also, this was like 10 years ago- why yall complaining now when this was aired 10 YEARS AGO? I've seen comments saying "I hope the judges kicked them out". First of all, that's not a good reason to kick them out, secondly, judges don't have the power to do that- it's their manager who has the power to do that. I honestly think that they did amazing, though this was 10 years ago. Another thing, yall know that we have our own minds? A LOT of people could have thought of a version similar to Mel's that they didn't even know that Mel's version existed. Just because Melanie is famous/known, that doesn't mean that yall could attack innocent people who didn't mean any harm, just because yall "think" they copied Mel. Yall need to chill. THEY NEVER COPIED MEL. THE TWO POSSIBLE WAYS THEY DID IS DOING A COVER OR JUST SO HAPPENS THAT THEIR VERSION IS SIMILAR TO MEL'S.(never copied Mel, just did a cover/discovered a similar version) If yall come at me, then yall just don't accept the fact that covers can have covers. Yall could look up on youtube if yall don't believe me.
I think Alex was singing great but you could just tell that Sierra was trying too hard. It was just really cringe the lip biting, weird “sultry” looks, and straining of her voice to make it sound something it’s not.I really wish they would’ve credited credited Melanie Martinez since honestly her version was way better than the original even. I love me some Brittany spears but the vibe that Melanie Martinez gave to the song was something sooo beautiful to the ears. In the end Melanie soared above despite not winning the voice while Alex & Sierra won X Factor but I haven’t heard them and I heard they broke up like years ago.
Pretty sure the judges knew they were copying because Simon literally said "Why that song" and people and the audience looked shocked and confused and most of the judges stopped when she said toxic
Nobody! Will sing it like mealine bc shes the one who made it znd tbh she acculy does sing it the Best why would someone copy a talented woman!?like mealine or enyone bc they should mzke their own song atleast give the credit to mealine
I can feel.. I can sense the hate in sierras mind
Yall I’m a Mel fan and they didn’t copy like if u like Mel and someone else likes Mel that isn’t copying so Ermm
MEL DID SO MUCH BETTER. ❤
Zero credit given 🤦🏻♂
MEL IS WAYY BETTER LIKE
Wow. They really did copy melanie. Melanies is way better
i didnt like their singing anyways mel is so real and like amazing
That girl looks like it hurts her to sing it 💀
naw she was just jealous she sang it better
The fact that she tried to make the same facial expressions- 💀 It's just looks so cringe on her! Melanie is a goddess, Sierra is juste a f*cking copy!
lmao yes 😂
Wow so they just stole Mel’s cover
Yeah no copying someone else’s cover is not cool. Melanie’s cover was untoppable
Why do you steal songs, why are you, what about you, tell me you crazy You don't even have talent, so you steal songs
They make me wanna barf
Please dont spread hate for those in the comments
Alex and Sierra don’t even sound that bad 😭 but I still prefer Melanie cuz she’s the queen
Yall know that u could do a cover of a cover right? they never claimed that they "own" the song/cover, which means that it's okay that they made a COVER of a cover of a song(toxic). I'm a die-hard fan of Mel, and I'm sure that even Mel could agree that it's ok. There's nothing wrong with what they did. Also, this was like 10 years ago- why yall complaining now when this was aired 10 YEARS AGO? I've seen comments saying "I hope the judges kicked them out". First of all, that's not a good reason to kick them out, secondly, judges don't have the power to do that- it's their manager who has the power to do that. I honestly think that they did amazing, though this was 10 years ago. Another thing, yall know that we have our own minds? A LOT of people could have thought of a version similar to Mel's that they didn't even know that Mel's version existed. Just because Melanie is famous/known, that doesn't mean that yall could attack innocent people who didn't mean any harm, just because yall "think" they copied Mel. Yall need to chill. THEY NEVER COPIED MEL. THE TWO POSSIBLE WAYS THEY DID IS DOING A COVER OR JUST SO HAPPENS THAT THEIR VERSION IS SIMILAR TO MEL'S.(never copied Mel, just did a cover/discovered a similar version) If yall come at me, then yall just don't accept the fact that covers can have covers. Yall could look up on youtube if yall don't believe me.
Mel did amazing
Melanie put her own cover on the song and these notes she made up are hers I mean this other girl didn’t even copy it well
Melanie did a better job
Melanie’s is way better than the original!!!!
Mel did it way way wayyyy better
The fact that they copied off of her and all the judges didn't even turn around for melanie ✋🏽
They sound like sh*t and I hope the Judges kicked them out!!!!!!!!!
I think Alex was singing great but you could just tell that Sierra was trying too hard. It was just really cringe the lip biting, weird “sultry” looks, and straining of her voice to make it sound something it’s not.I really wish they would’ve credited credited Melanie Martinez since honestly her version was way better than the original even. I love me some Brittany spears but the vibe that Melanie Martinez gave to the song was something sooo beautiful to the ears. In the end Melanie soared above despite not winning the voice while Alex & Sierra won X Factor but I haven’t heard them and I heard they broke up like years ago.
I like the style and I wanted to do a cover of the same style of the song to melanie’s but idk-
WTF
this is so anoying. they clearly copied her and i think mel did it way better. love her. and happy easter everyone
I just wanna🤜👫 and the way she moves and smiles pisses me off😑😑😑😑
@roomieoffical Sierra in here is a LiTtLe BiT pItChY at some of these note don't ya think?🧐
They're copying Britney Spears not Melanie Martinez 😂
They are copying Melanie version of the version, so really both
the fact that simon said that it‘s a incedible version of the song is what makes me mad because, he probaly didnt know but, mel made that cover
Melanie is just a qween
Alex and Sierra just sound like they had a sore throat and were coughing up boogers and had the boogers in their throats
I think they did great if mel isnt upset over this yall shouldnt either smh
ERRRRRRRRRRR THAT IT
if you wanna do a different version then dont do toxic, its resevered for melanie
The fact she was trying to copy her facial expressions too tho 🤢
Little did Melanie know she'd become bigger than the hosts of the show that rejected her
I literally never heard of her before people were whining about Alex & Sierra just now
“Kinda different” Hmm yeah of course
Melanie martinez is much better and the creator the other people🤢
Y e s
Melanie WAYYY more better like SO MUCH better,shes the best!!!!!!🍼💦 💗
Melanies version is so much better
Sierra was only singing yeah Melanie is winning
This is why melanie release her song copy cat
Melanie Martinez sang it A LOT BUT MUCH BETTER than she is here, she just copied it, and to me without offense, but it sucks
Pretty sure the judges knew they were copying because Simon literally said "Why that song" and people and the audience looked shocked and confused and most of the judges stopped when she said toxic
1:28 LOL HER "CoMe dOwN"
YEAH🤣
Melaine sounds way better no offense to those people
Nobody! Will sing it like mealine bc shes the one who made it znd tbh she acculy does sing it the Best why would someone copy a talented woman!?like mealine or enyone bc they should mzke their own song atleast give the credit to mealine
Y’all do know that’s a type of singing tho...
Ye but she copied mels song
@@alirezakhodai7189 it’s not mels song it’s Britney Spears
What