4:20 the sad thing is that this is mostly true unlike in canon where its all bullshit. since sonic is a menace here though robotnik isnt necessarily good either, he still left little planet chained to mobius/earth and left amy to clean up his mess. beautiful story, by the way
Imagine how devastated Sonic would feel like if he got a peek into this reality to see how he could have turned out. Watching himself intentionally hurt the people that grew on him overtime. Poor Tails. Hopefully Amy comes back and looks after him. Funny how Sonic is still the reason she might become her own hero though. But hey, he can't complain about getting stalked this time 😀.
Poor tails... Hes so naive to his dear "Hero". Hopefully he realizes soon- heck, maybe the resourceful fox could take the info to heart by following sonics lead in a way- by harnessing the master emerald for HEROIC deeds!
Dang, poor Tails, dude's being tricked by Sonic's "Talks", not that I blame him. Welp, Sonic needs to be stop and put down a peg on his ego, his ego's so high even Eggman's couldn't match. Also, here's another what if idea: What If Sonic becomes serious?
Sonic’s need to keep tails believing him to keep his “imagine” in tact make a me wonder if Tails in some way is affecting Sonic. Like his presence could possibly help redeem Sonic, even if it seems impossible.
From eggmans arc heres an idea what if over the course of the story eggman becomes the hero and sonic becomes the villain. Kinda like the reverse universe from the comics
@@MikeJoe-jy5kpisn't it already in A AU since its timeline isn't the same As cannon? And beside if it makes good logical sense to have a good villain and a evil hero then it would make it more fun I feel
I'd probably assume it wouldn't but I'm all for sharing predictions: I'll get through the most likely ones and work from there - Knuckles dies There's no point for jerk sonic to let Knuckles live or keep him around considering knuckles wouldn't help sonic to boost his ego and leaving the master emerald to him would basically be a liability waiting to happen so knuckles will likely be obliterated and sink with the island below. - Eggman has to set up shop elsewhere With angel island presumably underwater and knuckles likely gone. Egg-man will have to start looking around for a place to set up shop on a new island. Probably the Northstar islands (Veg-o-fortress a close second) where the main change will be the absence of Fang that is it's own can of worms. Though wherever he sets up shop, Sonic is gonna arrive a bit late as eggman's databases won't be able to instantly guide him to the next area. - Jerk Sonic keeps the master emerald With the current situation, Sonic will likely have the master emerald on west-side island where he'll likely hide it in the sonic 2 hidden palace zone or someplace similar for his own emergency use. Sonic then will likely stay on west-side island as a base of operations to continue chasing down egg-man and also sometimes to bring the master emerald along if he's really in a tight spot. Sonic would also be able to use it as a excuse to go solo and give tails the duty to guard the master emerald, which'll kill two birds with one stone. - Scratch, Grounder & Coconuts are built This is mostly a joke prediction but the basic idea here is with Egg-man looking to establish a new base, He'd need to set up a chain of command that'll be able to give him the time to execute his schemes. The super sonic search and smash squad may be formed or something similar just for this purpose and if so may be the method where jerk sonic finds out about egg-man's schemes from here on out. Which'll sonic will likely beat em up and then shake em for intel regarding egg-man. Though these predictions are mostly what i'd figure would occur in the immediate future and would help to set up for the future mainline titles.
At this point I hope ether Amy comes back up and takes Tails away from Sonic or Knuckles takes Tails away from Sonic because poor Tails doesn’t deserve to be manipulated like that ;(
I think what if Sonic was a jerk series in SA2 Sonic will see the shadow of he should be And then he sins come He sacrifices himself for everyone And lost his memories Become idw sonic that lost he memories / Mr. needlemouse With his confidence and sin of pride But he is good but confident Something can Sonic : So you need help, huh I am the great Mr. needlemouse! And he loves tea 🍵 And Mr. needlemouse is British He is truly a good guy He is in blaze the cat world 🌎
Dark Multiverse AU where Whisper basically becomes R63 Infinite and joins Black Doom after killing Eggman. Her new name is Silent Wolf, she gets Eclipse’s corrupt Wisp thingies and her Wispon starts to look like a Bloodborne weapon.
considering the green did come from the master Emerald, it would make sense Eggman tell knuckles that he can’t let him use the power knuckles: Stay away from the master Emerald transformation gets disrupted and now he’s green
Sonic’s so mean Robotnik doesn’t even have to lie when talking to Knuckles!
True
Anything he might say might actually be an understatement
@tlst94 would it be a true moral change or more a pragmatic alliance?
4:20 the sad thing is that this is mostly true unlike in canon where its all bullshit. since sonic is a menace here though robotnik isnt necessarily good either, he still left little planet chained to mobius/earth and left amy to clean up his mess. beautiful story, by the way
The crazy part's that Eggman wasn't even half lying to Knuckles!
kind of understanding it actually
Funny enough, Eggman is slowly becoming a bit like a good guy.
True
And it’s even funnier the fact that he wasn’t even lying he was just telling the truth with a bit of bias. He just happens to have ulterior motives.
Imagine how devastated Sonic would feel like if he got a peek into this reality to see how he could have turned out. Watching himself intentionally hurt the people that grew on him overtime. Poor Tails. Hopefully Amy comes back and looks after him. Funny how Sonic is still the reason she might become her own hero though. But hey, he can't complain about getting stalked this time 😀.
5:12 eggman’s story in this timeline is 90% true as sonic is way more of a menace here but eggman isn’t exactly good as well
It’s more like the rival rate between two villains
PEAK HAS RETURNEDD
Also pretty cool to see Eggman slowly becoming more like a good guy by actually beginning to care about knuckles.
Eggman’s redemption arc
True
sonic in this world will probably have a redemption arc in sonic adventure 1. (probably not 100%)
Great to see another part of this story
"What If sonic was a jerk?,,
What what if? He was already, for like 10 years since 2010
Could you imagine knuckles, and Amy’s character arc?
Poor tails... Hes so naive to his dear "Hero". Hopefully he realizes soon- heck, maybe the resourceful fox could take the info to heart by following sonics lead in a way- by harnessing the master emerald for HEROIC deeds!
Dang, poor Tails, dude's being tricked by Sonic's "Talks", not that I blame him.
Welp, Sonic needs to be stop and put down a peg on his ego, his ego's so high even Eggman's couldn't match.
Also, here's another what if idea: What If Sonic becomes serious?
I can only imagine shadow's reaction, seeing the cheerful blue blur become his blue mirror.
Sonic is looking like me when I'm trying to get a midnight snack 😋💎
😂
Relateable comment
Sonic’s need to keep tails believing him to keep his “imagine” in tact make a me wonder if Tails in some way is affecting Sonic. Like his presence could possibly help redeem Sonic, even if it seems impossible.
Maybe
I Hope so!
WOOOO!!! FINALLY!!! PEAK RETURNS!!!!
Imagine if surge ended up being a thing bug as a hero because that would definitely be an antithesis to this sonic.
surge would probably put this sonic in his place
Surge in this Au would be so cool 👀
It looks like the master emerald disabled sonic's swear filter!
Could we get a full story compilation of the old version of Silver went back too far?
Awesome Video With Sonic,Tails And Knuckles 🖤💙💛❤️
From eggmans arc heres an idea what if over the course of the story eggman becomes the hero and sonic becomes the villain. Kinda like the reverse universe from the comics
But this would be an alternate timeline instead of an alternate universe
@@MikeJoe-jy5kpisn't it already in A AU since its timeline isn't the same As cannon? And beside if it makes good logical sense to have a good villain and a evil hero then it would make it more fun I feel
ITZ TIMEE!!!, my boi Knuckles about to teach some common sense!!
You weren't kidding when you said you had something cooking in the kitchen!
This world gonna be dark as fuck
Can sonic have hyper fleetway sonic
i hope to see that
So basically a version of Scourge.
Yes cool
No, it's Fleetway Sonic but if what his haters think of him
@@Hi_Tobby Either way, it's not good.
I LOVE THIS SERIES SO MUCH!!!
I can't wait until Sonic's ego gets shattered
I'd probably assume it wouldn't but I'm all for sharing predictions:
I'll get through the most likely ones and work from there
- Knuckles dies
There's no point for jerk sonic to let Knuckles live or keep him around considering knuckles wouldn't help sonic to boost his ego and leaving the master emerald to him would basically be a liability waiting to happen so knuckles will likely be obliterated and sink with the island below.
- Eggman has to set up shop elsewhere
With angel island presumably underwater and knuckles likely gone. Egg-man will have to start looking around for a place to set up shop on a new island. Probably the Northstar islands (Veg-o-fortress a close second) where the main change will be the absence of Fang that is it's own can of worms. Though wherever he sets up shop, Sonic is gonna arrive a bit late as eggman's databases won't be able to instantly guide him to the next area.
- Jerk Sonic keeps the master emerald
With the current situation, Sonic will likely have the master emerald on west-side island where he'll likely hide it in the sonic 2 hidden palace zone or someplace similar for his own emergency use. Sonic then will likely stay on west-side island as a base of operations to continue chasing down egg-man and also sometimes to bring the master emerald along if he's really in a tight spot. Sonic would also be able to use it as a excuse to go solo and give tails the duty to guard the master emerald, which'll kill two birds with one stone.
- Scratch, Grounder & Coconuts are built
This is mostly a joke prediction but the basic idea here is with Egg-man looking to establish a new base, He'd need to set up a chain of command that'll be able to give him the time to execute his schemes. The super sonic search and smash squad may be formed or something similar just for this purpose and if so may be the method where jerk sonic finds out about egg-man's schemes from here on out. Which'll sonic will likely beat em up and then shake em for intel regarding egg-man.
Though these predictions are mostly what i'd figure would occur in the immediate future and would help to set up for the future mainline titles.
I have a bad feeling about Tails. He is ether going to get hurt or killed. Which will cause Sonic to become a better person.
part 5 when?
Are you going to make what if Srcouge was a Hero
For once Eggman was telling the truth 😂
by 90% this time
Time for Sonic to get a knuckle sandwich
Yes
At this point I hope ether Amy comes back up and takes Tails away from Sonic or Knuckles takes Tails away from Sonic because poor Tails doesn’t deserve to be manipulated like that ;(
But at least tails has a bodyguard.
Will this be taking the turn that I think it will I'm looking forward to where ever this goes
I hope Knuckles takes care of Tails after this.
I love this series
can you write a story what if amy rose was a anti hero and redesign her as a bad girl and give her super form too please
I think what if Sonic was a jerk series in SA2
Sonic will see the shadow of he should be
And then he sins come
He sacrifices himself for everyone
And lost his memories
Become idw sonic that lost he memories / Mr. needlemouse
With his confidence and sin of pride
But he is good but confident
Something can
Sonic : So you need help, huh
I am the great Mr. needlemouse!
And he loves tea 🍵
And Mr. needlemouse is British
He is truly a good guy
He is in blaze the cat world 🌎
Ok that will cool
.....God damn it. I thought he would grow more heroic as he faces adversity.
BUT NOOOOOO! He grows snarkier and less heroic by the episode.
Stop whining 🤨
I can't wait for the part where Tails learns colorful language if you know what I mean. 😮
Scourge The Hedgehog 1 2 CD and 3
Feels like eggman is the good guy compared to sonic
Sheesh sonic is such a narcist I'd like to seem him go off the deep end at some point though
Dark Multiverse AU where Whisper basically becomes R63 Infinite and joins Black Doom after killing Eggman. Her new name is Silent Wolf, she gets Eclipse’s corrupt Wisp thingies and her Wispon starts to look like a Bloodborne weapon.
Algorithm fuel⛽
Prediction, Sonic will green.
considering the green did come from the master Emerald, it would make sense Eggman tell knuckles that he can’t let him use the power
knuckles: Stay away from the master Emerald
transformation gets disrupted and now he’s green
Sonic still a jerk
Fleetway Sonic/Scourge
My favorite what if from you
eggman in control is clearly a better alternative to sonic in this universe.
What if Sonic meets Fiona Fox in Sonic CD? I think Fiona and Tails they will become brother and sister?
W vid
Cool😊
Wow
Is this just going to be what if sonic was the bad guy?
Always has been
@@Megamank-ns3yy The mission, the nightmares are finally over…….
There's still the rest of sonic 3 and knuckles (and maybe more)
@@Megamank-ns3yy yeah maybe SA2 will change him
Just NO
Algorithm fuel⛽