Clear, symmetrical, and analytical thinking that explains beautifully, still conforms to the tradition----but does not advance what is *MISTAKENLY* thought of as the tradition. I have plenty of reasons why I follow your stuff, Vic, and this video is one of the best reasons yet.
i like how saturns signs are opposite the sun and moons signs. i have alot of respect for saturn thank you for your awesome take on this subject and for presenting so much information i have never heard or considered!! especially the age of the ruling planets. i fell like that knowledge is going to assist me greatly
I genuinely feel sorry for people who’ve not yet found your channel Vic! I have been sharing your name to all that will listen. I adore and value the numerical systems you use to explain concepts. I’m confident that you’re one of the stepping stones we’ve so desperately needed to pull the practice of astrology out of its woo-woo reputation of the past and into its rightful, credible place in the future.
thank goodness, I was the most feminine sign until Mars showed up 💪💪 and yes, I would say this is really what it feels like as a Scorpio, like two different energies at war with each other but I also have Aries rising so maybe that's it.
awesome and very in depth analysis. i love specially the explanations about gemini, virgo and scorpio... it helps me to understand a lot of stuff experienced personally right now
I always felt this, and I can't believe someone saying it the way is see it... I'm transgender /gender nonconforming and my ascendant is in Libra. I literally feel like you described Libra. And my other friends who are Scorpios or Geminis or Leo's etc etc you literally described them... I guess we're in tune with our inner feelings
Vic, truly Vedas belong to the entire universe. I salute you for your enduring persistence in Vedic astrology. 🙏👏🙏 If you are into it, pl discuss directions of house parts for ensuring auspiciousness, I mean, Vaastu shastra...
These gender dynamics are so interesting! The details and nuances are fascinating. Thank you for making another clear, in-depth video🙏 It’s definitely one to watch more than once 😊✨
♥️ liking sharing and commenting ♥️ because this is one of the best channels on astrology on UA-cam. Cant wait to get all your books in hard copy once I’ve moved into my own apartment 😣! 😁😁
Thanks a bunch for this! I'm a practicing apprentice astrologer of about two years having arrived at astrology through other personality systems which hold extroversion/introversion as a trait metric. No one else I've studied has explained WHY certain gender was assigned to the elements when there seems to be exceptions like Libra, Scorpio, Capricorn, and Aquarius, although it was very subtly obvious. I abandoned those loaded terms in favor of extroversion (air and fire) and introversion (earth and water), but under the condition that I'd eventually learn more about the reason behind all the gender talk... so here it is! I ordered your book on the philosophy of astrology and look forward to reading it as that is my primary area of interest which for most astrologers is mistakenly taken for granted. Cheers!
@@VicDiCaraAstrology I ordered the philosophy book, and thought it was awesome. But I would love another book that uses the above analytical approach with visual diagrams, for all the things you cover. I'd love to learn in the same visual manner.....how signs in different houses alter the masculine and feminine natures as well. Visual charts/descriptions/algorithms, describing exaltation and debilitation of traits, for signs in houses, and planets in signs. Do you have such a book?? Im working on an app right now, that is combing astrology with the kabbalistic tree of life, and I need to understand how houses, and exaltation/debilitation are working in a more mathematical way.... (as shown in this video). I understand how it works on an intuitive level for sure.....but for my software....I need a similar mathematical breakdown so I can code it. This way of calculating the "true" gender of a sign, has already helped me immensely in my app. Thanks!
I love your explanation of scorpio and virgo and why having the same score, one sign has a lot of "drama" in itself and the other is simply balanced. And thank you for clarifying the elements as well. 😎
this new series is right up my alley. thank you for explaining in a clear and comprehensible way. thanks to you, I'm finally beginning to get a handle on some of this stuff. 🙏
I would kind of think of fixed signs as being at least both male and female considering the strong willed, stubborn and even rebellious in doing things their own way. They are patient and enduring like you said but I wouldn't quite say that fixed just means feminine. Anyway, I do love your channel.
They showed me about the DM/DF(or as they called it to me divine masculine/feminine) as far as why I don't know. I didn't ask I just accepted the concept. I will listen to what was given to you to learn even more. Thank you for the hard work you have worked for in order to feed us with knowledge.
Excellent breakdown. Learned a lot of golden nuggets. Very insightful which opened up that rabbit hole of other things that connects to numerology and those number associated with ruling planets.
This is beautifully explained! Thanks for sharing. I have your books in ereader format. Do you have the descriptions in this series in the book which is not offered in ereader format?
Fascinating thesis and great explanation! You drew an interesting parallel between the Zodiac and the spectrum of gender. I find the video's content to be interesting, although difficult to concentrate on the changing context in this video format. I was wondering if you possibly throw up some text with name of the sign being mentioned? This would help me better understand what you're presenting by reclaiming my attention. E.g., 19:27 - "♒Saturn's Aquarius"
THIS! 👏🏼 Why don’t other astrologers talk about this? I have always seen each sign with its own unique balance of feminine and masculine. Until I saw this video I thought that was only my personal ideas. I have heard of planets being talked about as having feminine, masculine, and androgynous characteristics, but never the signs especially in this way. Thank you for sharing this knowledge with us! You are a treasure in the astrological community.
Also could be likened to the commonly used *blood types.* Interesting perspective, though I love math the numbers throw me a little but if it works for you👍🏽. Visually observed naturally is relevant as well as the "male" & "female" foundation blended with planet, element and modality and placement/age. Example..Aries Mars = beginning = our birth as a baby = seperated sentient bodies which is masculine which is leaving feminine(womb of mother of Pisces) to be in another feminine(womb of mother nature of Taurus). Scorpio Mars is going within, hidden or down under ..so the feminine quality of leaving the 'of age' bodies that connected in a masculine sense in Libra. What leaves our bodies? Woman's cycle, conception, semen, bowel and urine. Also life leaving the body so death. Awareness leaves the bodies so passion. Emotions leaving the body etc. Going to the masculine of exploration of dharma? By using words like push and pull, leave and go into, led and supported.. I'm sure creates a beautiful story. The child bearing mother is told to push while the child may feel pulled into the next chapter in life. Or how the support of the Leo with inspiring legacy and self creation is great for the calculating and perfecting competition in virgo that's led with the standards and compromises in Libra.
no its a lifelong tendency. lol ;) but thanks. Just sometimes my idea of "fantabulous" aligns with other's concept of "fantabulous" and sometimes my idea of "fantabulous" is something from a different universe, lol
Vic, there is a singer that has all his planets in feminine signs and is known for soprano voice, is Dimash Kudeibergen 5/24/1994 at 7:30pm in Aktoba...he has a very interesting chart. Born in lunar eclipse, 3 planets in ascendant Scorpio...and is titled the best singer in the world.
For some crazy reason, the gender of the planets would just make more sense if jupiter was feminine. It looses symetry somewhere for it to be masculine.
i think then there would be too many females. I think we would have symmetry if jupiter were in the middle of the two genders with mercury and saturn. And honestly, that is prettttttty close to what it is. Its just that Jupiter has the male quality of being bossy, telling people whats what. The symmetry shows when you include the 2 nodes. Females: Venus (young), Moon (mature), Rahu (atypical) Males: Mars (young), Sun (mature), Jupiter (atypical) Trans: Mercury (young), Saturn (old), Ketu (atypical)
So I'm pretty new to Astrology and I'm mostly here for personality traits and making some sort of sense of what we do and why do we do it. Don't really understand spirituality so these things are kinda hard to understand. So my question is what do you mean by masculine and feminine zodiac signs ? I'm a Taurus Sun, Aquarius moon and Leo Rising male and I have a pretty masculine personality or so people say. So how does the masculinity or femininity of the zodiac signs correlates with the person?
if you are clear on what masculine and feminine means, you can proceed. but not many people are. basically masculine goes out, feminine goes in - and that explains 90% of everything more complex about the two. M/Fm in astrology will be used in many ways. We use it to see how comfy or uncomfy a planet is in a sign, for example. A simple way you can use it is to see if your male planets are in male signs, and visa versa. The more they are, the more gender-clear or gender-simple you are.
Nice video. Thank you. Would have loved to see it 10 years ago though. The cynic in me thinks you're trying to appeal to the "Abominable Insanity" (quoting Prabhupada) of the LGBTQRSTUVWXYZ community.
How strange and wonderful it is that not many people like such a wonderful and deep knowledge.. While the world bows its head to the filth and rubbish..
Clear, symmetrical, and analytical thinking that explains beautifully, still conforms to the tradition----but does not advance what is *MISTAKENLY* thought of as the tradition. I have plenty of reasons why I follow your stuff, Vic, and this video is one of the best reasons yet.
thank you so much
incredibly insightful in beauty & power coming together to express in so many different ways 🏵
I'm glad that an astrologer finally covered this topic! 🙌 ty
i like how saturns signs are opposite the sun and moons signs. i have alot of respect for saturn thank you for your awesome take on this subject and for presenting so much information i have never heard or considered!!
especially the age of the ruling planets. i fell like that knowledge is going to assist me greatly
I genuinely feel sorry for people who’ve not yet found your channel Vic! I have been sharing your name to all that will listen. I adore and value the numerical systems you use to explain concepts. I’m confident that you’re one of the stepping stones we’ve so desperately needed to pull the practice of astrology out of its woo-woo reputation of the past and into its rightful, credible place in the future.
Thank you so much!
👌
thank goodness, I was the most feminine sign until Mars showed up 💪💪 and yes, I would say this is really what it feels like as a Scorpio, like two different energies at war with each other but I also have Aries rising so maybe that's it.
awesome and very in depth analysis. i love specially the explanations about gemini, virgo and scorpio... it helps me to understand a lot of stuff experienced personally right now
We need more on this topic, you're so sharp
I always felt this, and I can't believe someone saying it the way is see it... I'm transgender /gender nonconforming and my ascendant is in Libra. I literally feel like you described Libra. And my other friends who are Scorpios or Geminis or Leo's etc etc you literally described them... I guess we're in tune with our inner feelings
This is so amazing & never done before in such a detailed way 👏 answered many of my questions 🙌
Great presentation! Clear message... Thank You so much!!
Thank you so much 🙏🙏🙏🎩🎩🎩
Thanks!! I'm learning pretty much with you!
Thank You 🌬❣️
incredibe explanation. thank you.
Vic, truly Vedas belong to the entire universe. I salute you for your enduring persistence in Vedic astrology. 🙏👏🙏 If you are into it, pl discuss directions of house parts for ensuring auspiciousness, I mean, Vaastu shastra...
Thank you 🙏🙏🙏
Beautiful explanation ❤
Great explanation..🙏🙏
These gender dynamics are so interesting! The details and nuances are fascinating. Thank you for making another clear, in-depth video🙏 It’s definitely one to watch more than once 😊✨
♥️ liking sharing and commenting ♥️ because this is one of the best channels on astrology on UA-cam. Cant wait to get all your books in hard copy once I’ve moved into my own apartment 😣! 😁😁
Thanks a bunch for this! I'm a practicing apprentice astrologer of about two years having arrived at astrology through other personality systems which hold extroversion/introversion as a trait metric. No one else I've studied has explained WHY certain gender was assigned to the elements when there seems to be exceptions like Libra, Scorpio, Capricorn, and Aquarius, although it was very subtly obvious. I abandoned those loaded terms in favor of extroversion (air and fire) and introversion (earth and water), but under the condition that I'd eventually learn more about the reason behind all the gender talk... so here it is! I ordered your book on the philosophy of astrology and look forward to reading it as that is my primary area of interest which for most astrologers is mistakenly taken for granted. Cheers!
thank you
@@VicDiCaraAstrology I ordered the philosophy book, and thought it was awesome. But I would love another book that uses the above analytical approach with visual diagrams, for all the things you cover. I'd love to learn in the same visual manner.....how signs in different houses alter the masculine and feminine natures as well. Visual charts/descriptions/algorithms, describing exaltation and debilitation of traits, for signs in houses, and planets in signs. Do you have such a book??
Im working on an app right now, that is combing astrology with the kabbalistic tree of life, and I need to understand how houses, and exaltation/debilitation are working in a more mathematical way.... (as shown in this video). I understand how it works on an intuitive level for sure.....but for my software....I need a similar mathematical breakdown so I can code it.
This way of calculating the "true" gender of a sign, has already helped me immensely in my app. Thanks!
Ty
Very interesting and helpful.
Wonder what to make of Scorpio/Libra relationships given the gender complexities of both?
I love your explanation of scorpio and virgo and why having the same score, one sign has a lot of "drama" in itself and the other is simply balanced.
And thank you for clarifying the elements as well. 😎
Hi.. could you provide me the background music (in the beginning and end of video).."Hare rama hare rama...." it's just awesome!
Thank you fr the beautiful explanation ❤️
Hi can I help
Magical as always
Wow, this is so validating as a trans masculine person.
My entire chart is air and fire, with Aquarius and Sagittarius having the most placements.
This the best and the most enlightening explanation of gender I've heard in my life so far. It's complicated but I get it. Thank you.
this new series is right up my alley. thank you for explaining in a clear and comprehensible way. thanks to you, I'm finally beginning to get a handle on some of this stuff. 🙏
Hey when are you starting over with the next canto translation.. eagerly waiting
Very interestingly and logically detailed and explained. Great work !
I would kind of think of fixed signs as being at least both male and female considering the strong willed, stubborn and even rebellious in doing things their own way. They are patient and enduring like you said but I wouldn't quite say that fixed just means feminine. Anyway, I do love your channel.
Love it Guru
Great video Vic
Hope all is well,
Taurus Sun Aries moon
thank you vic
They showed me about the DM/DF(or as they called it to me divine masculine/feminine) as far as why I don't know. I didn't ask I just accepted the concept. I will listen to what was given to you to learn even more. Thank you for the hard work you have worked for in order to feed us with knowledge.
Sir i wanna learn vedic astrology do you have any video in for beginners
I just ordered 4 x of your books from Amazon. Some for me and for my friend who’s all brand new to astrology :) can’t wait!
Excellent breakdown. Learned a lot of golden nuggets. Very insightful which opened up that rabbit hole of other things that connects to numerology and those number associated with ruling planets.
this was good.
This is beautifully explained! Thanks for sharing. I have your books in ereader format. Do you have the descriptions in this series in the book which is not offered in ereader format?
Thank you so much for making this!
Hi Vic, I really liked your video, If I may ask you a question:
Which sign is the best for Aries in a relationship way?
Fascinating thesis and great explanation! You drew an interesting parallel between the Zodiac and the spectrum of gender. I find the video's content to be interesting, although difficult to concentrate on the changing context in this video format. I was wondering if you possibly throw up some text with name of the sign being mentioned? This would help me better understand what you're presenting by reclaiming my attention.
E.g., 19:27 - "♒Saturn's Aquarius"
Thanks for a great video. :)
What combinations give success in foreign lands? Can you make a video on this or give general houses and dasha timings? Thankyou!
Thanks Vic for making such a wonderful video. You are truly amazing. Your work for Astrology really much much appreciated.
loved this video, thank you
Hope the video does well, love your videos Vic 😊 thank you for all your work 🙏
Hi can I help you
This was great, connections being made. I could watch these again and again and glean more each time. Potent!
Incredible series, amazing video 👏 thank you Vic 🙏
great video
THIS! 👏🏼 Why don’t other astrologers talk about this? I have always seen each sign with its own unique balance of feminine and masculine. Until I saw this video I thought that was only my personal ideas. I have heard of planets being talked about as having feminine, masculine, and androgynous characteristics, but never the signs especially in this way. Thank you for sharing this knowledge with us! You are a treasure in the astrological community.
Hi can I help
Very very happy to hear and listen to this video.
And I understood it clearly because of all your Effort sir ✌🤗...
Very thankful for you.....
I wish I had this video when I started learning about astrology! 👏
This information made so many things I've experienced click in a rational way. Thank you!
Very insightful 🌞
Thank you so much for sharing this 🙏
Wow 👍 brilliant video 🌹 thank you 🙏
Truely awesome, much Love from the other side; both masculine and feminine ❤ - expressed, affected and experienced
Also could be likened to the commonly used *blood types.* Interesting perspective, though I love math the numbers throw me a little but if it works for you👍🏽. Visually observed naturally is relevant as well as the "male" & "female" foundation blended with planet, element and modality and placement/age.
Example..Aries Mars = beginning = our birth as a baby = seperated sentient bodies which is masculine which is leaving feminine(womb of mother of Pisces) to be in another feminine(womb of mother nature of Taurus).
Scorpio Mars is going within, hidden or down under ..so the feminine quality of leaving the 'of age' bodies that connected in a masculine sense in Libra. What leaves our bodies? Woman's cycle, conception, semen, bowel and urine. Also life leaving the body so death. Awareness leaves the bodies so passion. Emotions leaving the body etc. Going to the masculine of exploration of dharma?
By using words like push and pull, leave and go into, led and supported.. I'm sure creates a beautiful story. The child bearing mother is told to push while the child may feel pulled into the next chapter in life. Or how the support of the Leo with inspiring legacy and self creation is great for the calculating and perfecting competition in virgo that's led with the standards and compromises in Libra.
Love your comment!!
@@thealignedlover Really?? Thank you
Great stuff. I'm glad I just discovered your channel. Thanks
Absolutely appreciate the gender explanation. Ty!
In relation to age, that is. ❤
Wonderful video, Vic! Thank you.
Just watched it again. Such juicy information.
Another amazing series, thank you very much
Hi can I help you
Really great video Vic
I have 4 placements in Cancer so in total I am -12 which is very feminine! I'm a man and straight..... Help!
Is it that Venus in ur lagna transit or what making you dress fantabulous ❤️😂💯. You looking like a groom master 💡😳
no its a lifelong tendency. lol ;) but thanks. Just sometimes my idea of "fantabulous" aligns with other's concept of "fantabulous" and sometimes my idea of "fantabulous" is something from a different universe, lol
Although sun is a male planet but once sun is in 5th house it will give daughter for sure..
Thanks a lot, sir)
So as per that, scorpio=libra. Which means, if a man's venus is in libra, a scorpio would also do... Just in case.
Vic, there is a singer that has all his planets in feminine signs and is known for soprano voice, is Dimash Kudeibergen 5/24/1994 at 7:30pm in Aktoba...he has a very interesting chart. Born in lunar eclipse, 3 planets in ascendant Scorpio...and is titled the best singer in the world.
Hi can I help you
This was an amazing explanation this kinda makes me think that sexuality is fluid
hey Vic a off topic question, am I banned from your channel or blacklisted? I don't get updates?
did you "ring the bell" on the subscription button? idk. ringing the bell turns on notifications, i believe.
JaiHoPrabhu🙏🏼
Do you mean male and female, or did you mean masculine and feminine? There's so much confusion between sex and gender these days.
🥰🥰🥰👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
For some crazy reason, the gender of the planets would just make more sense if jupiter was feminine. It looses symetry somewhere for it to be masculine.
i think then there would be too many females.
I think we would have symmetry if jupiter were in the middle of the two genders with mercury and saturn.
And honestly, that is prettttttty close to what it is. Its just that Jupiter has the male quality of being bossy, telling people whats what.
The symmetry shows when you include the 2 nodes.
Females: Venus (young), Moon (mature), Rahu (atypical)
Males: Mars (young), Sun (mature), Jupiter (atypical)
Trans: Mercury (young), Saturn (old), Ketu (atypical)
So I'm pretty new to Astrology and I'm mostly here for personality traits and making some sort of sense of what we do and why do we do it. Don't really understand spirituality so these things are kinda hard to understand. So my question is what do you mean by masculine and feminine zodiac signs ? I'm a Taurus Sun, Aquarius moon and Leo Rising male and I have a pretty masculine personality or so people say. So how does the masculinity or femininity of the zodiac signs correlates with the person?
if you are clear on what masculine and feminine means, you can proceed. but not many people are. basically masculine goes out, feminine goes in - and that explains 90% of everything more complex about the two.
M/Fm in astrology will be used in many ways. We use it to see how comfy or uncomfy a planet is in a sign, for example. A simple way you can use it is to see if your male planets are in male signs, and visa versa. The more they are, the more gender-clear or gender-simple you are.
Nice video. Thank you. Would have loved to see it 10 years ago though. The cynic in me thinks you're trying to appeal to the "Abominable Insanity" (quoting Prabhupada) of the LGBTQRSTUVWXYZ community.
How strange and wonderful it is that not many people like such a wonderful and deep knowledge.. While the world bows its head to the filth and rubbish..
NO. totally disagree. Cardinal is female, Fixed is male ,Mutable is fluid .
Not moving an inch from this ,dear sir.
pls listen to me ,thank me later.
Smh