Elac Debut B5.2 B6.2 speakers simple mods

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 81

  • @NeilBaker-r9s
    @NeilBaker-r9s Рік тому +10

    Many thanks for this, very useful. I thought my Debut's had been lacking something. Tweeter grille now removed, but what has really made a difference is the dampening of the steel speaker basket. I used dense rubber foam fixed with extra strong double sided tape, on every bit of the steel, not just the 4 brackets. Bass is easily noticeable to be lower & tighter. Very happy already & still have caps to consider.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      That's great! I'm happy that you enjoy them more now! Do consider caps - this is the final touch (or maybe almost final, as there are also resistors that can be upgraded ;) )

    • @patrickmiller4987
      @patrickmiller4987 6 місяців тому +1

      Wow! If only Andrew had this awesome knowledge to add 5 dollars worth of dampening! Someone should show him this video ASAP and the before and after measurements that prove the bass is better so he can us this in future projects !!!

    • @robertgartner6072
      @robertgartner6072 6 місяців тому +1

      @@patrickmiller4987 I don't disgree, however speaker manufacturing is all about cost and meeting a consumer price point. Andrew has MUCHO trainig and years of experience so I'm confident he knows these things. It's just not in the budget for this model. Just FYI, Andrew no longer works at ELAC.

    • @patrickmiller4987
      @patrickmiller4987 6 місяців тому

      @@robertgartner6072I dont believe he decided against a few dollars of dampening when it could of made them sooo much better!? He's showing off his MoFi towers at the moment. People tend to like changing things and are biased towards hearing an improved response because they want to and made an effort when in reality they cant remember what they heard initially and could of moved the speakers around the room for a different response. Id bet Andrew would hear it and say " thats not an improvement IMO"! Would love to see two sets of same speakers with and without changes measured in same spot volume matched to 1dB and a double blind test done. To each their own though! Take care!

  • @1960ianparker
    @1960ianparker 9 місяців тому +2

    Hi there, just wanted to say thank you for posting this tutorial. I've upgraded my debut 2.0 6.2 using your guide and good speakers are now great speakers. Cheers🎉

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  9 місяців тому

      Thank you! Enjoy them :)

  • @Rock-Pirate
    @Rock-Pirate 6 місяців тому +2

    I have the 6.2 and there is no need to modify anything!
    😎☠️🏴‍☠️🤘

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  6 місяців тому

      Well modding (anything) never is about the need, right? :)
      These are great and can be even better!

  • @MikeK6046
    @MikeK6046 6 місяців тому +2

    Many reviewers say that these Elacs (even in stock form) are great candidates & "really benefit" from high/higher quality ($2K to $5Kish amps). BTW, I'm just using a "well-reviewed" $500 integrated with mine and I'm pretty satisfied but would love to hear them with these mods and a better integrated amp.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  6 місяців тому +1

      Yes they are amazing out of the box and can be easily further upgraded. Great little speakers!

    • @patrickmiller4987
      @patrickmiller4987 6 місяців тому +1

      The price of an amp does not represent its sound quality. A lot of high end products add distortion and or change the freq. response slightly to add warmth etc to stand out from others. Which means we are paying a high price for a not so accurate product.

  • @thomasdiyaudio5353
    @thomasdiyaudio5353 6 місяців тому +1

    Changing the yellow capacitor will make a lot of difference. Other than Jantzen, you can try GAD, Solen (good value for money) or Mundorf Oil (if you can willing to spend more). Another upgrade is changing all the internal wiring. I prefer to use Gotham speaker wire, the same type you can use for connecting the speaker to your power amplifier.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  6 місяців тому

      Yes, you're right, however by then the price of the new components gets comparable to the speakers price;)
      Where I can I am using a combination of Jantzen silver or red and Mundorf Silver in oil - best of both worlds

  • @markhanson1273
    @markhanson1273 6 місяців тому +3

    It looks like the capacitor you added is soldered right into the same spots as the "yellow" capacitor. Am I understanding correctly? I know very little about electronics but I can operate a soldering iron. I'd like to give it a shot. Thanks!

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  6 місяців тому

      Yes exactly, same spots as the original yellow one :) Go for it, it's simple job and enjoy the results!

  • @stewvox4797
    @stewvox4797 4 місяці тому

    I added the cap as you suggested and it worked very well. Thank you.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  4 місяці тому

      @@stewvox4797 Thank you!

    • @stewvox4797
      @stewvox4797 4 місяці тому

      @@k4syx I have listened for a while now and they do exactly what you said they would. They add “air” and smooth (balance) the highs. Really great mod dude. I salute you.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  4 місяці тому

      @@stewvox4797 Thanks!

    • @stewvox4797
      @stewvox4797 3 місяці тому

      I want to do the woofer upgrade but how did you get the plastic ring off without causing damage? I bought the butyl tape but I can’t get the ring off.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  3 місяці тому +1

      @@stewvox4797 it should just go away with the driver after the screws had been removed. If it doesn't, try to pry it with something thin and flat (like butter knife) from the inside of the ring, slowly work your way around step by step. Sometimes it can be a tight fit there

  • @DarylSawatzky
    @DarylSawatzky 9 місяців тому

    I did these changes plus I rebuilt the whole crossover with high quality parts and lined each box with dampening material. It's a completely different speaker now and worth $400 more.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  9 місяців тому

      Kudos!

  • @eugenefudge3685
    @eugenefudge3685 Рік тому +1

    Great tips. I made the mod and I believe it sounds better. I also use this matt on all the case work for my cd transport. My amp and dac and my rega turntable. It works. I might change the capacitors to the jantsen

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      I'm glad you like it. This matt is great for damping all unwanted vibrations as long as there is enough space for it.
      Sometimes I'm using it to dampen the whole speaker boxes in case of very cheap stereo sets with very light and thin cases.

    • @eugenefudge3685
      @eugenefudge3685 Рік тому +1

      I also used it on the elac 3010 Sub woofer. I think it tightens everything up. And by the way the matt in Canada is $20. A SQ. Ft.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      @@eugenefudge3685 That's a lot! I guess that depends on the thickness, but still - quite pricey compared to EU.

  • @mkuzm
    @mkuzm 8 місяців тому +2

    I did only dampening of the speaker basket ( all 4 parts with butyl matt) and it really works - bass is much more stronger. I do not need to buy subwoofer now.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  8 місяців тому +1

      Stronger and much better controlled, it's more precise

    • @patrickmiller4987
      @patrickmiller4987 6 місяців тому

      I hope this is sarcasm.

  • @mikecrotser3631
    @mikecrotser3631 8 місяців тому +2

    Can someone post a picture of where and how to install the janzen cap? Is this on the coil or the electronic assembly? Thank you.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  8 місяців тому

      It's in the video, 6:18 and later. Look for big red capacitor with gold lettering on the underside of crossover board

    • @mikecrotser3631
      @mikecrotser3631 8 місяців тому +1

      Sweet. Thank you!

    • @mikecrotser3631
      @mikecrotser3631 8 місяців тому

      Thanks. I did get the capacitor in too. Sounds great less analytical.

  • @christopherspiro9857
    @christopherspiro9857 5 місяців тому +2

    Hello, could you put up the complete part number of the jansen capacitor. Also, was it hard to put in? Thanks

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  5 місяців тому

      It's easy job, capacitors like that do not have part numbers: you need only voltage and capacity, it should be in the video description and it's visible in the video as fast as I remember

    • @christopherspiro9857
      @christopherspiro9857 5 місяців тому

      @@k4syx Ok, thanks for replying.

    • @christopherspiro9857
      @christopherspiro9857 4 місяці тому +1

      Hello< I just bought the elac debut B6.2? I am wondering about the capacitor - I believed you said you bridged them? How will I know which Janzen to buy to bridge them? Is bridging just Soldering to the stock capacitor connectors? I really would like to do this upgrade. Thanks.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  4 місяці тому

      @@christopherspiro9857 Yes bridging is just soldering to the same contacts as you may see in my video. you may use the same capacitor as I did as this is just a bridge. Go for it, its easy!

    • @christopherspiro9857
      @christopherspiro9857 4 місяці тому +1

      @@k4syx thank you. I’m going to open the back when I have time (very busy now) so I guess the tweeter cap is the same size for the 6.2 ? And can just use the same cap as you did. I see someone just completed the modification on their 6.2 so I’m guessing it’s the same cap as you used. Thanks again! Sorry very new to this. Ha!

  • @ivandjdocrodriguez
    @ivandjdocrodriguez 11 місяців тому +1

    Hi,
    What if these Elacs are connected using an active 2 way crossover biamped to the 2 drivers, will that bypass any need for mods?

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  11 місяців тому +1

      Only if you'll connect that directly to drivers, bypassing internal crossover completely. And then I would still recommend doing two other mods, that is removing treble grille and dampening mid driver basket. Won't using the active crossover on these be too expensive?

    • @ivandjdocrodriguez
      @ivandjdocrodriguez 11 місяців тому +1

      Thanks for the reply, yes, I will definitely use the 2 mods. I am able to use an active Xover because I own it from previous PA work otherwise I would not want to invest that type of money to biamping the Elacs. Appreciate your response, I'm looking for data on the Xover point that Andrew Jones uses for these drivers.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  11 місяців тому +1

      @@ivandjdocrodriguez you may try to look for frequency measurements, xover point should be somewhat visible. Also gr mods (I think that's what they are called) would have these graphs for upgraded xover, these could be even better for you if you're looking just for the specific frequency

    • @ivandjdocrodriguez
      @ivandjdocrodriguez 11 місяців тому +1

      I just found the number, 2.2Khz is the Xover point used by ELAC, I will try with that as a starting point, thank you again.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  11 місяців тому +1

      @@ivandjdocrodriguez you're welcome, good luck!

  • @omaraody2538
    @omaraody2538 Рік тому +2

    Is it jantzen superior z-cap 0,1uF 1200v capacitor 2%?

  • @chinmeysway
    @chinmeysway 10 місяців тому +1

    wait what exactly did you stick on to the speaker frames ? thanks !

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  10 місяців тому

      Butyl dampening mat, like Dynamat Extreme, same as used for dampening car doors when upgrading speakers. Dampens vibrations on metal, improving sound.

  • @sonhouse9636
    @sonhouse9636 Рік тому +2

    Hi and thanks for the video. Why did you keep the original capacitor in place ? By adding a new one you've changed the filter's cutting frequency. What was the value of the original capacitor ? Thanks again

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      Hi! Replacing stock one would be more expensive, the effect would be better, but still: these are not expensive speakers so I try to stay on cheap. As for the filter freq original cap is +/-10%, so as long as bypass is below 10% of the nominal stock value (like 5%) it doesnt affect filter more than production error. But bypass is way cheaper and 70-80% effective compared to direct replacement. As for the stock value, Im sorry - I just dont remember. If its not visible in video, or you cant hear me saying aloud the value in the video, you may try to ask here in the comments, maybe someone else will remember.

  • @M-ski
    @M-ski Місяць тому +1

    Personally, with all due respect, I don't think we should fiddle with Andrew Jones's design however I wonder if this kind of modes is maybe something he introduced in Uni-fi's and Reference series? Question to those who follow his work.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Місяць тому +1

      I admire his work, but you still need to remember that these are still being build to the price point. Like "what can you do with xxUSD? Amaze me" job.
      So you can do a little improvement here and there that was not possible within price limits (and lets be honest here, these are CHEAP and AMAZING at the same time)

  • @nikolaygeorgiev147
    @nikolaygeorgiev147 9 місяців тому +3

    Removing the tweeter grilles makes the speakers too harsh, bright, forward upper mid and really fatiguing after an hour of listening.. Of course this is a matter of taste, but Andrew Johnes wouldn't put this grill with that strange shape if it would be better without it.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  9 місяців тому +1

      I guess that's a matter of taste and pairing with amp and source. But for this particular mod there are measurements (freq response) that show the highs actually get flatter and even. I guess that grille is also for protection (as anyone who had B&W 60x series can confirm :D )

  • @jeremymerry7967
    @jeremymerry7967 Рік тому +2

    Will this mod work on.the 6.2s?

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      Yes, it will. Those are also great !

  • @SomeGuy-xq3kv
    @SomeGuy-xq3kv Рік тому +1

    Hi, thanks for posting this video. Do you think it would sound better if we add some resistor to lower the treble around 1 db? I am considering to build a brand new crossover but cant find spec list of original components nor any FRD data for those drivers. How do you come up with that z-cap?

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      Hi! I don't find them bright, so adding R to treble would be just for your sound preference (which is fine).
      As for the bypass this is standard technique for getting better result with better cap without replacing original, which would be quite expensive. As for the value the standard is to use 1/100 of the original value. This way you are also staying (more or less) within original value - they are usually +/-5% anyway - so there should be no real effect on the crossover points.

    • @SomeGuy-xq3kv
      @SomeGuy-xq3kv Рік тому +2

      @@k4syx Alright, thank you for your response. I just ordered the tape and those exact z-caps, cant wait to hear the improvements :D Thanks again!

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      @@SomeGuy-xq3kv give them some time to burn and enjoy!!

    • @SomeGuy-xq3kv
      @SomeGuy-xq3kv Рік тому +2

      I've tried it and listened to it for a month now, pretty decent upgrade. The top end is clearer, i use 10inch sub to add some oomph for low end and the result is great.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      @@SomeGuy-xq3kv Thanks for sharing, I'm happy that you like it!

  • @tweakradje
    @tweakradje Рік тому

    I prefer the 3d soundtage and bass extension of my original debut 5. Also modded for a few dollars. The debut v2 might have better imaging. Pick what you prefer.

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      Yes I've also heard that .2 are more "reference" flat, as opposed to originals being more fun and musical.

  • @edwardsidel6862
    @edwardsidel6862 Рік тому +1

    Great video! I do have a question. Would it be ok to stabilize the Jantzen cap against the woofer coil using Blu Tack? I think I would find it easier to solder if the new cap were stable. Can the Blu Tack be left in place permanently or would I be better to use a hot glue gun?

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      Yes, actually blue tack would be a good idea to dampen some vibrations on the capacitor so you may leave it there. It won't do anything bad to cap. Hot glue on the other hand may be too hot for capacitor, and it will be difficult to remove. It will also not help with vibrations.

  • @martinlaforest
    @martinlaforest Рік тому +1

    Ils sont ok

  • @fernandoleitao382
    @fernandoleitao382 Рік тому +2

    Do you have a reference for the damping material? Can you make a video for the crossover setup?

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +1

      For the dampening look for "Dynamat" or "STP" butyl mats (or any butyl car audio mat that you can buy close to you). As for the crossover its just soldering additional cap in parallel to the one thats already there: the vid would be about soldering 2 points ;)

    • @wyup
      @wyup Рік тому +1

      Why did you add another capacitor in parallel instead of replacing the original one with a Jantzen of the same value? I have Elac DBR62 and am considering this aswell. Thanks for the tip!@@k4syx

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому

      @@wyup Hi! Check my full reply to the same question in comments below. Short answer: keeping the costs low.
      6.2 are also great speakers and the same mods can be applied with great results - go for it :)

  • @intheknow3431
    @intheknow3431 Рік тому +2

    Why don't you get a tripod for your camera? It's a pain watching!

    • @k4syx
      @k4syx  Рік тому +2

      I got one! Finally :)
      So my newer vids are losing that shaky flavour ;)