Its so much more than the economy We are tired of woke We are tired of the censorship We are tired of the condescension We are tired of the dislike for our country We are tired of open borders We are tired of the victim mentality …… oh and she was the worst candidate ever
@@pauldempsey1214 i wish I knew how to go about reminding DOGE, just in case, to take a hard look at the NPR financing and the rules applying to their public solicitation of funds.
Democrats use that phrase exactly the same way Chairman Mao did in 1957. “A threat to our Democracy”. The question is who encompasses “our”. Hint: Mao eliminated 55,000,000 threats after his 1957 speech on The Correct Handling of Conditions Among the People.
It's national security. It's border policy. It's energy policy. It's the corruption and lack of transparency and gaslighting. And it's the economy. But more specifically, all the policies that negatively impacted the economy. Let's not generalize.
He's relevant because he is the only remaining Democrat with an iota of common sense and doesn't care about the woke coming after him for getting real about what went wrong.
For me, I agree with 90% of his criticism, but I'm a boomer . Millennial, the X's could see it different. In so many ways the country is becoming effeminate. Carvel doubts that's a good strategy for campaigns.
Exactly. That arrogance and holier than thou, smarter than you attitude is a big reason they lost. They drove people away by deriding them and treating people like complete idiots.
They have lost me for a long time to come. Any party that wants to make me call a man a woman and allow men to infiltrate women's spots is not the party for me.
Carville couldn't care less about the effectiveness of policies, he only cares about what dishonest messaging could win. On both counts that makes him a true Democrat.
@@johnhanson1st Are you new to politics? Trump ran on bringing down price of groceries- good thing to run on- and now he is elected he is backing off this. Remember no tax on tips? Good way to win the votes of people in the service industry. But it isn't ever gonna happen. Back in the first term Trump said republicans would be the party of healthcare. Lol. What even is the republican health care plan? How is draining the swamp working out?
Carville said he would have fired the "snot-nosed" staffers who suggested Kamala appear on Rogan. I guess the Turtle thought she would have been better off on Johnny Carson.
Ironically, James was just as complicit in promoting the hate rhetoric towards Trump that ultimately got the democrats in the unfavorable condition they are in
@@Mkrake2024 Hey comrade, no one is saying Public TV/Radio shouldn't exist. They simply shouldn't be funded by the government when for decades it has been ovewhelmingly obvious that they are clearly surrogates for the Democrat Party. Why should the entire tax paying public have their tax dollars used to fund a network that despises half, if not more than half the country??
No one is calling for communism. Saying dumb sh*t like that is partly what turns off young people and independents from listening to conservatives. Not everything you dislike is communism. Get over it.
@Cam-vz2zk Lol no don't. You want it to reflect your views. If NPR was conservative you wouldn't care. Funny how people only see bias when hearing what the person doesn't like.
"She was a pretty good candidate.. " The Democrats' ongoing and paralyzing fear of criticizing a very weak black female candidate is funny to watch. They will happily blame everyone and anything for her loss...EXCEPT HER. 😂
It seems that with James, it's always about how we are going to spin it rather how we are going to deliver on anything. How are we going come up with something that resonates with people as opposed to what will actually work.
It's interesting that this is the exact same criticism Canadians have with the folks running and advising Trudeau up north-everything is a communications problem, not an "our policy is wrong" problem.
2:10 "We didn't offer people what they were looking for and that's something different." But they did offer something that was _cosmetically_ different and, for the Democrats, that's the most important thing.
There is a guy named Chad who works at the Chevron Station in Vail Arizona. I would take his political opinion over anything James Carville has to say.
Carville says of NPR "Its their company. They can do what they want." Well, no. Its not their company when they get billion dolar subsidies from the tax payer. They should pay their own way, completely. THEN they can say whatever they want.
no, when news was subsidized and not for profit, they could say what they want. Once they went for profit, and started taking money from political parties, then they started saying what they were told to say. News should not be for profit.
Immediately after the election all I heard was talk about the need to improve messaging. Kamala and the Democrat party were out of touch with common people's reality.
She was sooo great that she never won a presidential primary, never had to compete with better ideas from within her own party. She was chosen by her party but not by voters
@billmoretz8718 that's the unspoken truth they never seem to mention: we wouldn't be talking about tariffs if places like China and Canada weren't cheating
During McKinley’s presidency, tariffs along with a massive increase in the gold supply created inflation which helped because the country was in the middle of a depression and had deflation for decades before that. Also tariffs were needed back then because it was the government’s source of revenue. More often than not though if you actually study US history you’ll see that tariffs hurt the American consumer more than it ever helps industry by creating inflation which people hate as you can see by the result of the 2024 election. Tariffs are definitely not needed now that we are already in a period of highly inflated prices. Ironically the people who used to hate tariffs the most were farmers who voted overwhelmingly for Trump. I think this is because in recent history the US hasn’t had many tariffs as part of the neoliberal consensus so people aren’t aware of what they mean. If Trump really does across the board tariffs which are as high as he is promising, I guarantee you Republicans will lose a lot of support in 2028 even in reliably Republican areas. That’s a pretty big if though, I think he’s probably just bluffing about most of the tariffs he’s proposed because he’d have to be insane to really put a 60% tax on everything from China.
@@dodobirdfisher4697 A wonderful reply. You show a great knowledge of U.S. history. As a history teacher for 15 years I am greatly impressed. A few things to reply to. First, tariffs are not the culprit for inflation in the McKinley Years. The reason inflation was high from 1898-1899 was the Klondike Gold Rush. This flooded more gold into the market than McKinley had anticipated. One needs to remember that the country saw a recovery from the Panic of 1893 and the five year depression due to increased gold and the tariff protections that the Dingley Tariff of 1898 gave American companies. This increased inflation due to expanded gold for money and economic recovery (which initially leads to inflation. We saw this from 2021-2022 as the country emerged from COVID Lockdowns). Second, the statement that anyone who knows US history knows that tariffs hurt the economy is also debatable. The first tariffs introduced by Hamilton in the Tariff of 1789 proved to be successful in protecting America's infant industries from British dumping of cheap goods. Throughout the Civil War the Morill Tariff flooded America's newest national banking system with gold and silver. This period saw significant advancements in infrastructure, such as railroads and factories, which were essential for economic expansion. The protective tariffs contributed to transforming the U.S. into one of the world’s leading industrial powers by fostering a favorable environment for domestic manufacturers. Third, tariffs have been used effectively for trade reciprocity. During the 1980s, President Ronald Reagan played a crucial role in the revival of Harley-Davidson, which was struggling against fierce competition from Japanese motorcycle manufacturers. In response to the dire situation facing the company, Reagan imposed a 45 percent tariff on large motorcycles imported from Japan in 1983. This protective measure was intended to give Harley-Davidson the breathing room it needed to restructure and improve its product quality. By the time Reagan visited the Harley plant in York, Pennsylvania, in 1987, he noted that the company had successfully turned around its fortunes and no longer required tariff protection. This intervention not only helped save an iconic American brand but also highlighted the impact of trade policies on domestic industries. This tariff would also lead to a evening of trade between Korea and the USA in terms of automobiles. Finally, the "American Carnage", to quote President Trump, from free trade is something one can easily see when they tour the Midwest. resulted in a decline in U.S. manufacturing employment, with estimates suggesting a loss of around 700,000 jobs due to trade deficits exacerbated by the agreement. Allowing China to join the WTO had also empowered a vicious enemy of he USA and has made a lot of employers of child labor a lot of money. American communities were also hollowed out. Are somewhat higher prices worse than this? I want to once again say you made excellent arguments, but I will always be, as President McKinley said, "a tariff man!"
Carvel is as deluded as the rest of his party. If Comme Kammy had had more time as the nominee she would have lost by a larger margin. She was inept and incompetent.
Carville is completely oblivious as evidenced by his conclusory statement that Harris won the debate. She only won the debate in the eyes of her supporters, who were the only people she was speaking to in the debate. The debate was her opportunity to speak to independent voters and she declined to do so. The real time meters used by one pollster based upon Republican Independent and Democratic voters illustrated that when Harris was speaking only her base was receptive to her comments, whereas both Republicans and Independents tracked not being receptive. Conversely only the Democrat voters tracked non-receptively when Trump spoke, while both Republicans and Independents tracked receptively. If you only cater to your party base, you'll never win as you must speak to the largest component of the American electorate, which is the independent voters.
And ubsound delusional trump literally said they are eating the cats and dogs at the only debate he had and couldnt answer one question and lets not forget he had a concept of a plan,racism and misogyny was the deciding factor
He didn't exactly "blast Democrats" as the title suggests. I don't think he really understands how unlikable Harris and Waltz are. Of course, he is right about NPR language. There is nothing weirder about announcing your pronouns when when meeting someone....
I've always been a conservative, therefore not incline to pay his rantings much heed. He didn't even follow his own advice about the economy this past election, so why would I (or anyone else, for that matter) be inclined to consider his judgment at this point? Hating on Trump while admitting that he bested them with far fewer resources is just classic Dem thinking; guess the orange man is still bad...
Watching the videos of Democrat talking heads trying to figure out why they lost is the most fun I have had watching disaster coverage since the videos about the end of Game of Thrones.
The reason KH lost the election is that she was a horrible cannidate and the campaign was very badly run. Who thought it was a good idea to get rich millionaire Hollywood actors to endorse her? Like they have nothing to do with the average middle class person. Also KH didn't seem to be able to answer even the most easy softball questions. She would start all her answers by saying how she grew up in a middle class family, she worked at McDonalds, and that she loves america. All the while laughing like the question was funny and never actually answering the question. Is this somebody you want making deals with foreign leaders? And saying that she wouldnt have done anything different than Biden was not a answer anybody wanted to hear.
So Ukraine has borders but the US doesn't...!? Lie about increasing wages whilst making that an impossibility due to an abundance of cheap labour... Just endless lies.
He is still clueless about why they lost on main street. Hopefully, they stay as clueless and out of touch as they have been and they continue to loose.
Carville thinks that if they had a primary it would have given them a better candidate but that candidate still had to defend the indefensible: inflation and the DEMs' open border policies. Those two issues were #1 or #2 in the minds of 59% independent voters. Mother Teresa (RIP) would have lost vs Trump with such atrocious policies.
I love his pained look before starting to once again face just how wrong he was. Must be tough being so blind to reality while ragin' about sensibility.
What is funny James would take a job in Trumps cabinet in a heartbeat if offered . I have known this man for 40 yrs he speaks out of both sides of his mouth,
James the point of tariffs is to penalize countries that tariff our goods which is basically everyone, from China to the neighboring country of Canada. If they would like those tariffs lifted then they need only to lift the ones they have against us.
Carville is just so out of touch with reality, just about like that guy that predicted harris would win based on his 13 keys. Both him and Carville allowed their demoncrap bias to affect their ability to come to a rational conclusion.
Note the priority - he's not in the slightest concerned that the country might have a leader mentally unfit for the job, only about whether his side keeps winning. This is consistent with e ery Democrat opinion I've seen regardless of how they view Biden's mental state
He’s right about the first part. The Democrats sound like Marie Antoinette arguing about decorum while the revolution rolls them. He’s just too embedded in the establishment to understand the revolution part.
I think Carville is spot on. In 1992 Clinton said that he felt our pain. In 2024 Biden/Harris said that we are imagining our pain. Trump won convincingly, but not in a landslide. Yes, he won the popular vote, but he did not win a majority of the popular vote. If Trump was half as likeable as Reagan Trump would have won in a landslide.
James Carville has been "celebrity bartender" at Molly's On The Market on Decatur Street in New Orleans. He mixed drinks, pulled beers, and cracked wise for a very packed house of locals and tourists. I hate his politics, but he's a fine fellow.
Is anybody else watching his head sway back-and-forth. His eyes wandering all over. He doesn’t even believe himself. Interviewing Carville, no one‘s learned yet. There’s rarely one reason for anything. Multiple reasons, not the least of which were our children being molested. Find somebody relevant.
Its so much more than the economy
We are tired of woke
We are tired of the censorship
We are tired of the condescension
We are tired of the dislike for our country
We are tired of open borders
We are tired of the victim mentality
…… oh and she was the worst candidate ever
And the phony moralistic hectoring while they are all stuffing their pockets and feathering their own nests. Oh the decency !
Nailed it!!
Absolutely right.
Right on the money. The left does not get those things. They want to steer away from them. The left has learned nothing from their loss.
He doesn't have a clue either 😂 nobody in that communist party could have beat trump! Good for nothing canidate 😂
Yes, James. You had more money, more people, more endorsements....and you still got your clock cleaned.
James was recently diagnosed with HVIV. You heard it here FIRST.
Also TDS. 😂
@@komicsreviewer8505 Tf does that stand for ? I googled it first and no clarification.
Non sequitur.
He's talking about Dem strategy, not what you mentioned.
@@liuj88Yes, it follows. His strategy failed.
Why is NPR democrat propaganda still paid for by Tax
I'm sure it's on the DOGE chopping block
Good question
This just goes to shows you, that Kamala Harris wasn't too bright in the actual brain department. In the actual frist place, for sure. 😂
@@pauldempsey1214 i wish I knew how to go about reminding DOGE, just in case, to take a hard look at the NPR financing and the rules applying to their public solicitation of funds.
If you ever watch one of their shows you'll notice that they get a fair amount of private funding too, for example from the Koch brothers
Anyone who says "Trump is a threat to Democracy" is a total nut job to me.
Or a liar
Democrats use that phrase exactly the same way Chairman Mao did in 1957. “A threat to our Democracy”. The question is who encompasses “our”. Hint: Mao eliminated 55,000,000 threats after his 1957 speech on The Correct Handling of Conditions Among the People.
Yep, along with dictator, authoritarian, racist, etc.
I like intelligent debate, but if you mention those the words the convo is over.
Carville is delusional
@@marcespinoza5901 Couldn't agree more, but even delusional people can be spot on once in a blue moon.
Anyone who thought Kamala was going to win should be ignored
More like examined
Yes!
@@The_Homie_Khaya😂😂😂exactly
Carville is out of touch, and saying we are out of touch
Saw her on TV the other day and it really hit me that WHAT WERE THEY THINKING?? They may as well have just put Brittny Spears on the ballot.
Its not idiotic "language". It's idiotic ideology.
Bingo
Carville is completely out of touch
@jacobzindel987 Idiotic ideology couched in idiotic language and they keep at it.
There's stages. We havent manage to get past "Denial" in the kubler/ross model.
@@kevin6293 I watched him on Bill Maher's show and was thoroughly unimpressed. He just didn't seem to know the details of issues. Chok full of TDS.
"The border crossings are very modest"? Why are you interviewing him? He is out of touch and uninformed.
Yeah Amber should’ve asked why it was 5 senators… and Biden keeping the border open for 3.5 years
No...he is lying. Just more gaslighting.
Goes to show how pitiful our standards have become vis a vis border security after 4 years of Brandon.
[Source: U.S. Customs and Border Protection website]
2019 Southern Border Encounters 851,508 (Remain in Mexico Policy initiated by Trump)
2020 Southern Border Encounters 400,651
2021 Southern Border Encounters 1.73 million (Remain in Mexico Policy terminated by Biden)
2022 Southern Border Encounters 2.37 million
2023 Southern Border Encounters 2.47 million
2024 Southern Border Encounters 1.73 million (as of September)
@@davidmc8475 Yeah. They're down maybe 20-25ish percent once the year end numbers come in. After climbing over 600%. Great job brando. Great job.
Pro-choice party didn't give them a primary
"Defend Democracy" party skipped the democratic process.
They're only in favor of democracy and choice if they win.
plagiarizing Whitney, eh?
@@rustyoak8860 She's definitely not the first to say something to this effect...
But she's obviously great
@@monkeeseemonkeedoo3745 it's funny, because she just said it on CNN and it's been on Rising this morning.
It's national security.
It's border policy.
It's energy policy.
It's the corruption and lack of transparency and gaslighting.
And it's the economy. But more specifically, all the policies that negatively impacted the economy. Let's not generalize.
why is Carville relevant? A: he’s not.
Carville never was relevant. If it weren't for Ross Perot nobody would even know who he is.
we just like to laugh at him.
He's relevant because he is the only remaining Democrat with an iota of common sense and doesn't care about the woke coming after him for getting real about what went wrong.
For me, I agree with 90% of his criticism, but I'm a boomer . Millennial, the X's could see it different.
In so many ways the country is becoming effeminate. Carvel doubts that's a good strategy for campaigns.
He's an artifact of the Clinton era, its like he got unfrozen and doesn't understand what has happened since then.
"We had more of everything?" Yeah- you had more ARROGANCE. I cannot stand the Democrat party anymore.
They didn't have more votes
Exactly. That arrogance and holier than thou, smarter than you attitude is a big reason they lost. They drove people away by deriding them and treating people like complete idiots.
They had more money, more crooked establishment support, more fake news coverage, more misinformation
You lost the debate 🐶🐱
They have lost me for a long time to come. Any party that wants to make me call a man a woman and allow men to infiltrate women's spots is not the party for me.
Carville couldn't care less about the effectiveness of policies, he only cares about what dishonest messaging could win. On both counts that makes him a true Democrat.
Yeah, because republicans don't play the same game😂😂😂😂😂😂
@@Mkrake2024Provide an example to support your statement rather than a bunch of emojis. Saying “Yeah but they do it too” is a nothing response.
@@johnhanson1st Are you new to politics? Trump ran on bringing down price of groceries- good thing to run on- and now he is elected he is backing off this.
Remember no tax on tips? Good way to win the votes of people in the service industry.
But it isn't ever gonna happen.
Back in the first term Trump said republicans would be the party of healthcare. Lol. What even is the republican health care plan?
How is draining the swamp working out?
Very true
"We won a debate" 😂 that's the biggest lie he said here
This dude is still what is wrong with the Democratic party and establishment
Carville said he would have fired the "snot-nosed" staffers who suggested Kamala appear on Rogan.
I guess the Turtle thought she would have been better off on Johnny Carson.
He almost got a heart attack watching Trump sweep the states
No, that was just Greg Popovich the head coach of the Spurs.
And we enjoyed every moment of it.
Ironically, James was just as complicit in promoting the hate rhetoric towards Trump that ultimately got the democrats in the unfavorable condition they are in
The CEO of NPR needs to be fired also for her open woke ideology.
Sounds like cancel culture. If you don't like it then don't listen.
@@HBrown-pu2hb And make sure that also includes PBS as well.
Why would they do that when taxpayers are on the hook for their paychecks???
@@clubmogambo3214 Yeah, and any thing else that has book learning people and education.
@@Mkrake2024 Hey comrade, no one is saying Public TV/Radio shouldn't exist. They simply shouldn't be funded by the government when for decades it has been ovewhelmingly obvious that they are clearly surrogates for the Democrat Party. Why should the entire tax paying public have their tax dollars used to fund a network that despises half, if not more than half the country??
No James, the answer still isn’t communism.
yeah, don't act like stalin
Who's talking about big bad communism? Is it in the room with you now?
Hail Kamala!😂
OR socialism......
No one is calling for communism. Saying dumb sh*t like that is partly what turns off young people and independents from listening to conservatives. Not everything you dislike is communism. Get over it.
Kamala was an awful candidate full stop.
The Democrats are an awful party full stop. The Republican Party isn't that much better and that's why we forced Trump on them.
A cackling word salad who could not think of ONE THING should would have done differently than Biden.
Can we finally defund NPR?
And fund what you agree with?
Sure. Yipppeeee.
To steal a phrase "Yes we can"
@Mkrake2024 If I pay for a news outlet I want it to be unbiased. If you don't that proves my point.
@Cam-vz2zk Lol no don't. You want it to reflect your views.
If NPR was conservative you wouldn't care. Funny how people only see bias when hearing what the person doesn't like.
@Mkrake2024 they don't need the $_ Sesame Street merch makes millions
Defenders of democracy. Cancel the primary in 2024 and give one candidate the debate questions in 2016 primary , thanks for protecting democracy 🤣🤣🤣
Also insist every election you lose was stolen or unfair, see also Stacey Abrams & Hillary Clinton
They haven’t run a real primary since 2000
And try to kick police opponents off the election ballots.
You forgot silencing free speach
"She was a pretty good candidate.. "
The Democrats' ongoing and paralyzing fear of criticizing a very weak black female candidate is funny to watch. They will happily blame everyone and anything for her loss...EXCEPT HER. 😂
And she wasn't a real black woman. Voters caught on to that.
@aaroncostello8812
A South Indian woman.
It seems that with James, it's always about how we are going to spin it rather how we are going to deliver on anything. How are we going come up with something that resonates with people as opposed to what will actually work.
That would require abandoning Leftist policies and dogma
@ wathairston Most true statement comment here....... It was "the way it was said" not so much as being wrong.
It's interesting that this is the exact same criticism Canadians have with the folks running and advising Trudeau up north-everything is a communications problem, not an "our policy is wrong" problem.
He epitomizes his party, politicking vs governance.
Because democrats platform is a weaker USA but can't make it too obvious.
2:10 "We didn't offer people what they were looking for and that's something different."
But they did offer something that was _cosmetically_ different and, for the Democrats, that's the most important thing.
Running on abortion was never going to get it done
Such a desperate move on the Dems' part.
THAT was a joke
It got them close. They have abandoned everything else so it’s all they have
@ scary they got that close, Trump should have won by a lot more than he did
Most people need to just face the facts....abortion is m...rder......period.
You lost because you couldn't cheat.
Now and moving forward it Will be Hard to cheat in federal election since voter ID Will be mandatory before President Trump leaves office.
Go MAGA
There is a guy named Chad who works at the Chevron Station in Vail Arizona. I would take his political opinion over anything James Carville has to say.
Sure Carville, the redistribution of wealth is always going to be popular to those who receive other people’s money.
They just can’t stand other people being successful. They have to take your money and redistribute it to their political allies. It is a sickness.
@@mstaley34it’s about skimming off the top. It’s more federal money they can steal
THEY dock their 7 million dollar handmade sailboat out of state to save a hundred bucks.
Carville says of NPR "Its their company. They can do what they want." Well, no. Its not their company when they get billion dolar subsidies from the tax payer. They should pay their own way, completely. THEN they can say whatever they want.
The Hill says it is $90 million of NPR’s $279 million dollar budget.
no, when news was subsidized and not for profit, they could say what they want. Once they went for profit, and started taking money from political parties, then they started saying what they were told to say. News should not be for profit.
Not billions but bloated. They could fire a third tomorrow and never see an on air hiccup.
@@rustyoak8860 NPR sucks either way.
This guy is a joke
Geez he was having heart attacks 25 yrs ago. Can't believe he's still around.. talking...& Talking ...
Kamal lost lulzz
Of. Course. James. Carville. Is. A joke. He. Being. On. The wrong. Career. Business. All. His. Live
Takeaway, we needed more time to craft our lie!
Immediately after the election all I heard was talk about the need to improve messaging. Kamala and the Democrat party were out of touch with common people's reality.
Carville does not live in the real world.
Carville’s opening statement demonstrates how well he can put his foot in his mouth.
Carvel has a serious case of TDS.
Keep being who you are. Don’t change it to win an election. If we like your ideology and policy you will win. County is done with this bs
He does a pretty good job of diagnosing democrats but then shows his laughable unhinged side on Trump.
He contracted an early strain of TDS... Very difficult to get rid of.
He can't understand their vile hatefillled speech and actions are a huge part of their problem.
She was sooo great that she never won a presidential primary, never had to compete with better ideas from within her own party. She was chosen by her party but not by voters
Tariffs worked well in Lincoln's presidency and McKinley's presidency. Tariffs make the country money. They also protect industries. Tariffs work.
Everyone who is anti US tariffs are strangely quit about other countries tariffs aimed at US.
@billmoretz8718 that's the unspoken truth they never seem to mention: we wouldn't be talking about tariffs if places like China and Canada weren't cheating
Lincoln and McKinley? Ah, tariffs worked 150+ years ago and nothing has changed so they will work now. 🙄
During McKinley’s presidency, tariffs along with a massive increase in the gold supply created inflation which helped because the country was in the middle of a depression and had deflation for decades before that. Also tariffs were needed back then because it was the government’s source of revenue. More often than not though if you actually study US history you’ll see that tariffs hurt the American consumer more than it ever helps industry by creating inflation which people hate as you can see by the result of the 2024 election. Tariffs are definitely not needed now that we are already in a period of highly inflated prices. Ironically the people who used to hate tariffs the most were farmers who voted overwhelmingly for Trump. I think this is because in recent history the US hasn’t had many tariffs as part of the neoliberal consensus so people aren’t aware of what they mean. If Trump really does across the board tariffs which are as high as he is promising, I guarantee you Republicans will lose a lot of support in 2028 even in reliably Republican areas. That’s a pretty big if though, I think he’s probably just bluffing about most of the tariffs he’s proposed because he’d have to be insane to really put a 60% tax on everything from China.
@@dodobirdfisher4697 A wonderful reply. You show a great knowledge of U.S. history. As a history teacher for 15 years I am greatly impressed.
A few things to reply to. First, tariffs are not the culprit for inflation in the McKinley Years. The reason inflation was high from 1898-1899 was the Klondike Gold Rush. This flooded more gold into the market than McKinley had anticipated. One needs to remember that the country saw a recovery from the Panic of 1893 and the five year depression due to increased gold and the tariff protections that the Dingley Tariff of 1898 gave American companies. This increased inflation due to expanded gold for money and economic recovery (which initially leads to inflation. We saw this from 2021-2022 as the country emerged from COVID Lockdowns).
Second, the statement that anyone who knows US history knows that tariffs hurt the economy is also debatable. The first tariffs introduced by Hamilton in the Tariff of 1789 proved to be successful in protecting America's infant industries from British dumping of cheap goods. Throughout the Civil War the Morill Tariff flooded America's newest national banking system with gold and silver. This period saw significant advancements in infrastructure, such as railroads and factories, which were essential for economic expansion. The protective tariffs contributed to transforming the U.S. into one of the world’s leading industrial powers by fostering a favorable environment for domestic manufacturers.
Third, tariffs have been used effectively for trade reciprocity. During the 1980s, President Ronald Reagan played a crucial role in the revival of Harley-Davidson, which was struggling against fierce competition from Japanese motorcycle manufacturers. In response to the dire situation facing the company, Reagan imposed a 45 percent tariff on large motorcycles imported from Japan in 1983. This protective measure was intended to give Harley-Davidson the breathing room it needed to restructure and improve its product quality. By the time Reagan visited the Harley plant in York, Pennsylvania, in 1987, he noted that the company had successfully turned around its fortunes and no longer required tariff protection. This intervention not only helped save an iconic American brand but also highlighted the impact of trade policies on domestic industries. This tariff would also lead to a evening of trade between Korea and the USA in terms of automobiles.
Finally, the "American Carnage", to quote President Trump, from free trade is something one can easily see when they tour the Midwest. resulted in a decline in U.S. manufacturing employment, with estimates suggesting a loss of around 700,000 jobs due to trade deficits exacerbated by the agreement. Allowing China to join the WTO had also empowered a vicious enemy of he USA and has made a lot of employers of child labor a lot of money. American communities were also hollowed out. Are somewhat higher prices worse than this?
I want to once again say you made excellent arguments, but I will always be, as President McKinley said, "a tariff man!"
You can't rub the stench of the rotting dem party.
Well DIMs have said they got the message wrong from 2000, ,2004, 2010, 2016.
Carvel is as deluded as the rest of his party. If Comme Kammy had had more time as the nominee she would have lost by a larger margin. She was inept and incompetent.
Carville is completely oblivious as evidenced by his conclusory statement that Harris won the debate. She only won the debate in the eyes of her supporters, who were the only people she was speaking to in the debate. The debate was her opportunity to speak to independent voters and she declined to do so. The real time meters used by one pollster based upon Republican Independent and Democratic voters illustrated that when Harris was speaking only her base was receptive to her comments, whereas both Republicans and Independents tracked not being receptive. Conversely only the Democrat voters tracked non-receptively when Trump spoke, while both Republicans and Independents tracked receptively. If you only cater to your party base, you'll never win as you must speak to the largest component of the American electorate, which is the independent voters.
They think they won the debate because Democrat journalists and Leftist pundits told them so. They never talk to normal people.
And ubsound delusional trump literally said they are eating the cats and dogs at the only debate he had and couldnt answer one question and lets not forget he had a concept of a plan,racism and misogyny was the deciding factor
Last month James told us Trumps MSG rally was mimicking a N@zi rally.
He has lost all credibility with this absurd comparison.
James can pound sand.
Sometimes he makes sense but his reasoning is that of Elmer Fudd.
Excuse me, he's a hippie from Mississippi.
He didn't exactly "blast Democrats" as the title suggests. I don't think he really understands how unlikable Harris and Waltz are. Of course, he is right about NPR language. There is nothing weirder about announcing your pronouns when when meeting someone....
And nobody wants to hand Walz a potentialy unearned presidency! From the cornfield to the Oval Office in one leap and no votes - no way!
She did push that she was the "change" candidate, but Americans were sick of the Democratic Party lies.
She was the "change" candidate who stated that she would not have done anything differently than Biden. 😆
I've always been a conservative, therefore not incline to pay his rantings much heed. He didn't even follow his own advice about the economy this past election, so why would I (or anyone else, for that matter) be inclined to consider his judgment at this point? Hating on Trump while admitting that he bested them with far fewer resources is just classic Dem thinking; guess the orange man is still bad...
Watching the videos of Democrat talking heads trying to figure out why they lost is the most fun I have had watching disaster coverage since the videos about the end of Game of Thrones.
The reason KH lost the election is that she was a horrible cannidate and the campaign was very badly run. Who thought it was a good idea to get rich millionaire Hollywood actors to endorse her? Like they have nothing to do with the average middle class person. Also KH didn't seem to be able to answer even the most easy softball questions. She would start all her answers by saying how she grew up in a middle class family, she worked at McDonalds, and that she loves america. All the while laughing like the question was funny and never actually answering the question. Is this somebody you want making deals with foreign leaders? And saying that she wouldnt have done anything different than Biden was not a answer anybody wanted to hear.
Oh please he called literally everything wrong. Just retire James.
Clinton only received 43% of the vote in '92, proving Carville was never an intelligent strategist.
So Ukraine has borders but the US doesn't...!? Lie about increasing wages whilst making that an impossibility due to an abundance of cheap labour... Just endless lies.
I am not a Carville fan, but I appreciate the Hill bringing in a wide range of political perspectives.
The language is idiotic because the thinking behind it is idiotic. It goes deep.
Why should we believe him when he said he was certain Kamala was going to win?
BeCause he thought they still had the 2020 vote manufacturing operation up and running...but they fell 15 million short.....
He thought they could cheat again.
"Came as close as we did". The man is delusional, they got wrecked!
No one cares about what he thinks
Who listen to these TDS liars anymore 😂
Is this guy literally drooling out of the right side of his mouth?
Yes. Tobacco juice.
You lost and your team is still drinking woke coffee.
He's saying woke is bad
@@billywilson1368 You're both right. He said it's bad and the dems are still drinking that coffee.
Right James yall had more everything democrats just forgot 1 thing they needed “THE PEOPLE” that what democrats & celebrities forgot 🤷🏽♂️
He is still clueless about why they lost on main street. Hopefully, they stay as clueless and out of touch as they have been and they continue to loose.
She won the debate? No, no she did not
Id like to know why he thought she was a good candidate.
She-It had the Right Diversity Quotient.
This guy does realize that whenever they raise corporate taxes the corporation is just raised the prices right?
Anyone who lists a "feeling" as a reason his candidate would win, should not part of diagnosing what went wrong.
Carville thinks that if they had a primary it would have given them a better candidate but that candidate still had to defend the indefensible: inflation and the DEMs' open border policies. Those two issues were #1 or #2 in the minds of 59% independent voters. Mother Teresa (RIP) would have lost vs Trump with such atrocious policies.
Dear Elon and Vivek,
Please remove all funding for NPR. My tax dollars should not be spent on democrat propaganda.
I love his pained look before starting to once again face just how wrong he was. Must be tough being so blind to reality while ragin' about sensibility.
I would love to his Wife's opinion. Kamala changed all her postions! How much more change can she give? Leadership and vision was sorely missing
It's a long road for the DEMs to improve the economy, first they have to understand the meaning of the word economics, that will be a long time.
Amber went easy on him, bless.
That is an unexpected guest. Good on y’all for having him on.
George Carnival is a 🤡
Who?
Carnival about sums it up.
Hey Carville, why didn't you say this BEFORE the election? Did YOU forget it was ALWAYS the economy.
Maybe Carville will tell us who will win the Super Bowl the day after the Super Bowl.
He as an expert just had the light bulb come on? Lol!!
Oh my, well God bless his little cotton socks. Little Jimmy is living in a world of his own. Best to leave him there
The more I listen to Carville the more I realize that he is indeed a demoncrat and beyond all hope!
2.5 billion and 20 million in debt.
What debate did the Democrats win?
No democratic process in choosing the candidate, endless war, “this is fine” with an economy the workers struggle in, etc.
What is funny James would take a job in Trumps cabinet in a heartbeat if offered . I have known this man for 40 yrs he speaks out of both sides of his mouth,
For me it was Liz Cheney!!
James the point of tariffs is to penalize countries that tariff our goods which is basically everyone, from China to the neighboring country of Canada. If they would like those tariffs lifted then they need only to lift the ones they have against us.
💯
To BE a democracy, you have to DO democracy.
This dude has gotten everything wrong for the past decade or so now. Why is anyone asking him anything politics related?
Sadly he's not the only one thinking campaigns are run like it's 1995.
Democrats had more of everything accept love and concern for America and its people.
Carville is just so out of touch with reality, just about like that guy that predicted harris would win based on his 13 keys. Both him and Carville allowed their demoncrap bias to affect their ability to come to a rational conclusion.
HAHAHA..."if only Biden had gotten out in 23' we would have won" ..... What a loser.
Note the priority - he's not in the slightest concerned that the country might have a leader mentally unfit for the job, only about whether his side keeps winning. This is consistent with e ery Democrat opinion I've seen regardless of how they view Biden's mental state
He’s right about the first part. The Democrats sound like Marie Antoinette arguing about decorum while the revolution rolls them. He’s just too embedded in the establishment to understand the revolution part.
Correction, at 13:45 he does the decorum thing 🤦♂️🤣
Men with balls voted for trump and woman with ballsvoted for kamala - someone. 😂
After foinbtheough 2 billion....Dems ARENT ALOWED TO TALK ABOUT A
OTHER PARTIES CONTRIBUTIONS POLITICALLY 13:42
Carvil can’t position a camera properly to save his LIFE. 😂😂😂
😂
He clearly do not understand supply and demand
I think Carville is spot on.
In 1992 Clinton said that he felt our pain. In 2024 Biden/Harris said that we are imagining our pain.
Trump won convincingly, but not in a landslide. Yes, he won the popular vote, but he did not win a majority of the popular vote.
If Trump was half as likeable as Reagan Trump would have won in a landslide.
James Carville has been "celebrity bartender" at Molly's On The Market on Decatur Street in New Orleans. He mixed drinks, pulled beers, and cracked wise for a very packed house of locals and tourists. I hate his politics, but he's a fine fellow.
The dems had more of everything except good policy ideas. lol
His delusions of grandeur with Harris deems him unbelievable going forward.
Of course Carville was wrong the whole way through. The 90's are over bro.
Hey Jimmy, if we didn't send 175 BILLION to Ukraine then we could have helped home buyers!
Is anybody else watching his head sway back-and-forth. His eyes wandering all over. He doesn’t even believe himself.
Interviewing Carville, no one‘s learned yet. There’s rarely one reason for anything. Multiple reasons, not the least of which were our children being molested.
Find somebody relevant.
Every prediction this clown made prior to the election was wrong yet somehow he still gets out of time
7:25 as soon as they came from”spirit animal “ I knew they had really
Lost the plot