thanks, great job , I wish once more these people colaborate , and work together to revive this great culture , I am proud of all persian people ,and their litrature. that would be great translating more poems , dorood va sepase from Iran
Growing up in Afghanistan, I recall that the books by Persian poems Sadi and Hafiz was in every home honered and loved second to Quran. The peomes are timeless. I never get tired of listoning to them.
For us, in Iran, the Quran is nowhere to be seen compared to Hafez and Shahname, and Golestan,. Hafez is like Zarathustra for us. Sufism itself is an underground (personal) Zoroastrianism.
@@nomesa7374 Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez, a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an. About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage forget Hafiz. Sufism is nowhere Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy which modern Iranians follow. Sufis are missionary group 90% muslims are converted by Sufi missionaries. Nice try.
@@arabianinferno6918 1. "Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez": Its a free world. You are nobody to tell me what to say. So Sad for you. Lol 2. "Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy": That is why, I said "Personal Zoroastrian". 3. "About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage": Because they are organized religion. Do you understand "Personal Religion"? Sufism is that. 4, "Sufis are missionary group": Maybe in your village. Sufis created Baghdad and named it a Zoroastrian name. Muslim Rulers throughout the entire period, hated the Sufis and especially their grand teachers. 5. "[Hafiz was ]a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an": Are you kidding? He has dedicated himself to Pire-Moghan (the Old Magi or Zarathustra), Mogh-Bachegan (the Magi's students), Wine, Music, Dance, Love, and stories of Shahnameh. He repeatedly and badly ridiculed Fasting, Haj, and Jihad (as holy war). Muslim Clergies hated (and still hate) him. He never went to Haj and didn't like to go there. He even said repeatedly that he is not Muslim (directly or esotericly). Hahahaha, I doubt if you even can read Persian poetry.
1. "Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez": Its a free world. You are nobody to tell me what to say. So Sad for you. Lol 2. "Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy": That is why, I said "Personal Zoroastrian". 3. "About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage": Because they are organized religion. Do you understand "Personal Religion"? Sufism is that. 4, "Sufis are missionary group": Maybe in your village. Sufis created Baghdad and named it a Zoroastrian name. Muslim Rulers throughout the entire period, hated the Sufis and especially their grand teachers. 5. "[Hafiz was ]a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an": Are you kidding? He has dedicated himself to Pire-Moghan (the Old Magi or Zarathustra), Mogh-Bachegan (the Magi's students), Wine, Music, Dance, Love, and stories of Shahnameh. He repeatedly and badly ridiculed Fasting, Haj, and Jihad (as holy war). Muslim Clergies hated (and still hate) him. He never went to Haj and didn't like to go there. He even said repeatedly that he is not Muslim (directly or esotericly). Hahahaha, I doubt if you even can read Persian poetry.
Great job. The video is prepared carefully and detailed explanation is provided for each poet. As a Persian (Iranian) who have read most of these works (except sanaee and roudaki), I confess that "Fiction Beast" has reviewed Persian poetry and its influence in literature in a short time (just 27 min). As a Persian, I am really grateful for introducing Persian culture to the world. Well done Sir!!!
Thanks for the introduction. I am from Bangladesh. My father was Madrasah educated person with good comand on urdu and reasonable farsi. I learned about these names during childhood. Not beyond names and their main books... Now in my 50s I am curious about persian culture.... Want to visit Shiraj and bukhara....
@@Fiction_Beast Rābi'a bint Ka'b (arabisch رابعة بنت كعب, DMG Rābi‘a bint Ka‘b, auch persisch رابعهٔ بلخى, DMG Rābi‘a-i Balḫī) war eine persische Samanidenfürstentochter und Dichterin der persischen Literatur des 10. Jahrhunderts. Rabia Balchi thematisierte ihre verbotene Liebe zu einem Sklaven. Vor allem in Afghanistan ranken sich Legenden um ihre Person. Ihr Mausoleum befindet sich in der nordafghanischen Stadt Balch im zentralen Park unweit des Schreins von Khwaja Abu Nasr Parsa.
What a delight, outweighs Turkish delight (ha ha). I love Persian food but never tasted Persian poems now I am sold. Thank you so much for this comprehensive review. You have done an amazing work.
As soon as you mentioned Turkish delight, i could smell it :) Persian poetry has been very underappreciated outside the language. partly because poetry translation is hard, partly becuase only narrative poetry gets read these days.
Sharon, you have won the free giveaway. It's a copy of Omar Khayyam's Rubaiyat (penguin classic version). If you want to recieve it, please send me your home address by email, or private message on instagram or twitter. Please don't write your address here.
@@Fiction_Beast What a surprise as it is not often that I get such a message. Since I am not on instagram or twitter I will have to wait for my daughter to help me. Thank you so much.
I like Khayyam. When I was a child, I wasn't very interested in poetry and I only read illustrated stories of Shahnameh. I'd read some of Khayyam's poems before, but Sadegh Hedayat made me more interested in Khayyam.
What a great overview. Growing up Iranian-American, I always felt drawn to Persian poetry as a way for me to connect to my roots. I have read works in English so far. Although I can speak Farsi, my next step is to learn how to read and write so I can read the poems in the original language! Thank you for sharing this video!
Great rundown - Persia was one of the defining civilizations of the Silk Road, alongside India, China, and Rome - could you possibly do a video on Rumi's magnum opus, the Masnavi? for some reason, the Masnavi as a whole work is far less known in the West than, say, Attar's Birds, despite Rumi's huge popularity - it's mystifying that this poet is mostly known in terms of scattered verses, while his monumental and visionary central life's work is overlooked - it would even be interesting to explore how that's even possible
Is it like Sanskrit/Tamil vs hindi. Sanskrit and Tamil languages have loads of poetry while hindi is more of a prose based language. We also have a type of sherjangi here in india, its called Antakshari(Sanskrit for "end of akshar(letter)"). Btw, persian heavily influenced hindi. I hope to learn this language soon.
@@FBlindia was ruled by persian speaking dynasties for around 1000 years. Starting with the ghaznavids and ending with the mughals right before british colonization. Persian has had lots of influence on all Indian languages. It is very easy for linguistic to tell the difference between cognates and borrowed words. Even a persian speaker can look at hindu or/and urdu and see the influence for themselves.
@@Alborzhakimi7010heaviest influence is on Urdu rather than Hindi, but yes Hindi also has lots of influence from the Persian language but over the last 100 years there has been a Hindu led movement to get rid of Persian, Arabic and Turkic origin words. So the linkages have become much weaker.
So engaging! I loved and knew so many things!! Please continue to do the works you do❤❤ continue to introduce the different cultural and literary aspects of the world to each others.
Hello Fiction Beast, I chanced upon your presentation "Ten Persian Poets" and found it very ably put. I immediately latched on to it. This is something I had been looking for for a very long time. I have read Hafez in-depth, but wanted a short list of other greats to read their poetry properly. My immediate question is: Where can I buy the Persian Kalam of these 10 poets in Farsi? I have Ferdowsi's Shahnameh and Attar's "The Conference of Birds", and also Khayyam, but for the rest of the ten, I want to acquire their original Persian volumes [ in Farsi, with or without translations]. Best wishes
Plz more on Persian literature! And I know it’s a lot to ask but a whole series on Shahnameh could be great! Or maybe on other modern ones like Nima, Forough, Moshiri.
Poetry is that popular among Iranians that the tomb of poets such as hafez and saadi, Shahriyar, ferdowsi etc are the most visited historical tourist sites in the nation.
I have a huge problem with the end part of your video. "Iran have not been arabised due to Mongolian attack!". Actually all thanks to Iranian poets like Ferdowsi not some savage army which destroyed all the books and cause curcial gap in writing history of Persia due this attack. Next generation of Mongolian kings were under influence of Persian and they changed their attitude and their religious.
@@Fiction_Beast ты глуп как и многие. Вы понятия не имеете о монголах они ничего общего не имеют с современной монголией. Монголы это те же тюрки. Я Казах из рода Кереит и мы были всю историю тюрками так же как и найманы и борджигины и все остальные рода которые поддержали Чингисхана. Если ты считаешь наш дикой ордой то запомни дикая орда никогда не смогла бы завоевать пол мира и держать в страхе даже вас европейцев которые пройграли все сражения с монголами потому что отстали как в развитии так и военном деле. У нас была своя письменность, литература и культура тактже она и осталась и арабизация это ни что то страшное , а наоборот привнесла и объединила тюркскую,иранскую и многие другие культуры. Так что почитай умных книжек и не пиши всякой ереси
Thank you great video❤❤❤. By the way we don't use Arabic script because the Arabic script itself is a branch of Avestan and pahlavid script. The earliest Arabic script is kufi which is very similar to Avesta script one can easily understand the similarities si in conclusion Arab people adopted our way of writing and changed it over time.
It’s fascinating the effort you’ve put behind this informative clip. Just one correction that Rumi was not from Iran, he was from Balkh which is located in Afghanistan. The original language was called Dari which started getting changed in the last 200 years in Iran. If not then what language was Hafez and Sa’adi’s poetries were said? Then what would you call this poem of Hafez : ز شعر دلکش حافظ کسی بود آگاه _ گه لطف طبع و سخن گفتن دری داند. Thanks.
Rumi was a Persian from Balkh. Afghanistan didn't exist back then, it was just another province of Iran. The language is called Parsi/Farsi (Persian) and originated in Iran. It spread from Iran to the rest of the Persianate World, Dari is just a dialect of Persian. Hafez and Sa'adi were from Shiraz, that is in Iran. 😂
I loved the video! It is funny that I met your channel because I was looking for someone who talked about Shahnameh and now you come with a video which opens up a whole world of literature i had ignored! A question: do you speak farsi? Is it difficult to learn?
That's great to hear. At least someone is learning from my videos. Thanks. Some. I think Farsi writing can be challenging to those unfamiliar to Arabic script. the language itself has no genders and its verb conjugation is somewhat similiar to Russian, changes based on the tense and person.
As a Blit, and a lifetime reader of Persian poetry, I can say that "almost" sixty precent of it is prosaic! and has a highly articulated classification. For instance with Molavi (or name which he is famous with in the west "Rumi) Three gigantic books (of his five gigantic books) is prosaic. Or the same story goes with Nezami, Sa'adi. and also better having in mind that what works are we categorizing as Persian literature? since the overall manner and essence of "Iranian Philosophy'' is actually poetic. as if they had sensed where has the "truth" concealed! (please forgive my English)
I recommend you read more modern Persian poems as well,they are great there are many greats poets in the kinda modern area to from Parvin Etesami,to Akhavsn Sales,Nima Yoshij and Forogh Farokhzad
Thank you for sharing! I love Rumi and Hafiz’s the most. I must say that China’s early literature had a very strong poetry presence, so much so that even in its prose there were many couplets. Every scholar, every government officials, many emperors, generals and merchants, women … wrote poetry. Even today, it is not unusual for young children to recite dozens of poems from ancient times. The famous Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai (701-762 AD) had a poem “Amidst the Flowers with a Jug of Wine”, about the moon, the flowers, wine, solitude and friendship - I find it interesting to read this together with Khayyam’s famous poem “… beneath the bough, a flask of wine … and thou beside me singing…” Today, we find Khayyam’s portrait on the Egyptian wine bottle, and Li Bai’s name on the traditional Japanese wine (sake) bottle. They are immortalized by their poems that have traveled to so many lands.
This also applies to Persia, where the very strong presence of ancient Persian shapes everyday life. It is very usual and common for Iranian youth to recite dozen of poems and legends dating back to ancient times.
I really like your content. But one mistake is to call the Persian alphabet the Arabic alphabet. The Perso-Arabic alphabet was a direct evolution of the Aramaic and Pahlavi Alphabets (generated in Sasanids Ctesiphon). Besides innovations of dots and vowels by Iranians, almost all calligraphic styles are the innovations of Iranians. So it is a Persian Alphabet. Some historians and etymologists also argue that the Arabic language itself was generated by Mathematicians of Ctesiphon (look at Arabic's mathematical structure) to compete with the scientific supremacy of Greek and Roman languages. For example, ferdows, Al-ard (the earth), Zamzam, and so many other fundamental words have Iranian origins (Pardis, or erd). That is why, The oldest found Arabic text is in Syria and Iraq.
Regarding the rhythm and rhythm, you are very right. Persian Poetry is considered the first attempt of humans to "write down" (not just to hear) the music. Gatha (the short book of Zarathustra) is also poetic.
As a Farsi/Dari speaking Afghan American who left Afghanistan at age 14, I can read and write Dari. Farsi a most beautiful language imaginable, of course I am biased. Unfortunately, these poems lose their beauty and essence when translated into English. It’s like taking a masterpiece of art, say a Van Gough or a Rembrandt and just letting a toddler brush paint all over it. The ONLY way to truly appreciate the immense and blinding beauty of Farsi/Dari poetry is to learn the language and learn it very well!
Awesome work. brilliant. but as you yourself said: the Persian poems do not translate and should be read in Farsi to understand the depth and beauty of it.
good luck for you, as an Afghanistanian I admire your efforts. but it were the Persian scientists and linguistics who modified both Arabic and Persian languages, otherwise Arabs were brutal men and knew nothing about literature
Oh man. Great video, tho I’d like to add that Coleman barks is not a good translator. If you want a better translation I recommend Nicholson or I recommend you buying the Oxford classics version of Mathnavi.
One big mistake at the begining, Persian does not contain 20 -40 percent arabic loan words, I studied persian literature and only islamic/religious books contain arabic. This is a major mistake in your introduction. Farsi contains approximately 5 to 7 percent arabic loan words also,arabic contains a lot of persian loan words, for instance iraqi arabic contains a lot of farsi loan words approximate 15-20 percent. Also ferdowsi's Shahnameh is 100 percent written in farsi with no arabic loanwords.
English language is based on Sanskrit language and in Arabic. Also there are a lot of Persian words which is borrowed from Persian into Arabic language.
My dear, English in poetry and literature versus Persian is like a drop in the ocean. In English, the elements that exist in Persian poetry and literature do not exist in English, not only in English, but also in other languages. I am reciting a poem by Ferdowsi the Great. Now you can translate it into English. See if it is beautiful in Persian or in English. هوشنگ با رای و داد به جای پدر تاج بر سر نهاد
If you agree with the logic that Ghandi was not a white Englishman just because he lived in the British Empire which included India at the time, then you also must agree that a lot of these people were Tajiks and not "Persians".
Σε αυτήν τη γεωγραφία της Περσικής ποίησης ιδιαίτερα με εντυπωσιάζει η πόλη Balkh (Βάκτρια των Ελλήνων). Ποιά είναι αυτή η πόλη των ΕλληνοΜακεδόνων, των ΠερσοΖωροαστρών, των ΙνδοΒουδιστών, των ΑραβοΜουσουλμάνων, που βρίσκεται στο βόρειο Αφγανιστάν; Ποιά είναι αυτή η πόλη όπου πέθαναν προφήτες όπως ο Ζαρατούστρα και γεννήθηκαν ποιητές όπως η Rabia Balkhi και ο Mevlana Jalaladdin Rumi Balkhi; Η ιστορία της με γοητεύει και η φαντασία μου προσπαθεί να την αναστυλώσει στην πρότερή της δόξα
🤡🤡🤡 joker -- read the Samanids dynasty, Saman Khuda from Balkh was the founder of it. The capital of the dynasty was based in Bukhara. Rabia Balkhi was a princess of Samanids. She wrote in Farsi and what that has anything to do with Baloch or Balochistan?
Great video. Western society are inconceivable without Iranian deep ancient knowledge due to mongol then arabs tried to destroy this amazing culture which bring love and poetry and again you see today the Islamic regime trying to destroy it but still not capable due to the zorvanisim and mythraic love still remain in Iranian people in Iranian pelato.
I ilke Persian poetry. And proud of a Turkish poet and philosopher; Mevlana Celalettin-i Rumi having an important place in it. He wrote all his poems in Iranian because of great cultural influence of Persia. His “Mesnevi “ is a masterpiece…🙏🏻
Rumi was Persian and belonged to Iran and Iranian culture. And in the course of his life, he lived in IRAN. Try not to confiscate what does not belong to you. He was not Turkish, and there was no Turkey since 1924, and it was created by Britain. Before that, it was Ottoman which was nothing but inhumanity. It is not lovely behaving like this, Mr. Koglu.
Many of these poets were Tajiks. Not Persians. The concept of Persian has changed to mean people of Iran only these days. It excludes the Tajiks of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Afghanistan who in the time of Rumi (born in Balkh, Afghanistan) may have been considered Persian but are not considered that anymore. Therefor Its wrong to call these ancient Tajik poets "Persian" just because they spoke Persian. Its like calling an English speaking Nigerian an Englishman just because he only speaks English and published his works in a more dominant language of the time. If Rumi and the other Tajiks in this list lived forever and didnt die, they would be considered Tajik today, not Persian. Iranians love to claim everyone under the sun that lived in the past as "Persian" even if they are Tajiks in reality.
@@antidweller6373 actually if we are being correct now that you mention it, "Persian" as an identity didnt exist back then and neither does now. The term "Persian" is an English word and doesnt exist in the "Persian" language. Nobody calls themselves "Farsi" in Iran or anywhere else. Only westernized Iranians like to call themselves "Persian".
@@antidweller6373 "Persian" is an English word and nobody calls themselves "Farsi" people lol. Specially not 1000 years ago when people didnt have a concept of ethnicity.
*SOME CORRECTIONS OF WRONG INFORMATION IN THIS VIDEO:* Persian doesn't use the "Arabic" alphabet. It uses the *Persian alphabet.* Arabic speakers can't read Persian since they don't know how the letters are pronounced in Persian. Persian is an Indo-Euopean language, meaning it is just as close to English as English is close to Hindi. Persian hasn't adapted "too many" Arabic vocabulary. Only 5% of Persian words trace an Arabic origin. Your false and unscientific research ridiculously suggests that Persian uses 20%-40% of Arabic words. Persian is a very rich language and can easily create new words out of native word stems. Persian is correctly called Parsi.
Just because Tajiks were conquered by Persians doesnt mean Tajiks' accomplishments and heritage belongs to Iranians. Otherwise we can say whole of Iran belongs to Mongolians since Iran was another Khanate of Mongolia at one point. Also another point, you wouldn't claim Ghandi was a white Englishman just because he lived in the British Empire which at the time included India. Also Tajiks were only part of Persian Empire 100-200 years. Rest of history there were other empires whose rulers were not Persians, but Turks, Arabs, Mongols and Tajiks themselves (Samanid Empire)
@@Fiction_Beast if you mean that nobody is infallible, yeah I agree obviously we’re all flawed but there’s a difference between having the capacity to do immoral things and actively and continuously doing immoral things (and I’m using my moral doctrine as the criteria here so there’s no confusion) without repentance, regret or shame all the while revelling in what you’ve been doing do you get what I’m saying brother?
I think this guy was some Persian person from Iran because he didn’t put a lot of great poetry of Afghanistan who were way better than Iran even I didn’t see any Tajikistan best poetry in this video
The presenter is not Iranian; he doesn't sound like an Iranian at all. But these poets are Persian poets; they belong to Persian speaking peoples all over the world. The idea of modern countries is a new concept, only 3 or 4 hundred years old. So one shouldn't talk of these poets as Afghanistani or Iranian. Rumi was a Persian from Balkh; Hafez was a Persian from Shiraz. They weren't Afghanistani or Iranian; they were Persians. At those times, people in this area only identified themselves with their names, ethnicity, town and religion; eg, a person would say, "I am Ali, son of Mohammad; I am Persian, and I am a Muslim from Herat." That's it. Modern countries came later. That is why one only hears of tribal/family names for periods of history- Safavids or Samanids, eg. For Safavids or Samanids, the most important thing was to conquer as much territory as they could, and also the ruler should have been from their families. They didn't care about Afghanistan, Iran, or Tajikistan. So we should leave our current nationalistic pride aside and just celebrate our shared history and literature. Two poets who talked specifically about Iran in their works were Ferdowsi and Nezami, but you can be certain that by Iran, they meant the lands of Persian peoples (today's Afghanistan, Iran, Tajikistan, and many other lands occupied by Persians); they were not talking about modern-day Iran, because there was no modern-day Iran.
@@piruz3243Wrong, Iran is not a modern country. Iran is the oldest country on earth. The notion and borders of modern Iran already existed in the works and maps of Persian poets and scholars in antiquity. Today's Iran is the ancient Persian land that Ferdowsi and Nizami extensively write about in their poetry. Iran's historical territories and provinces throughout Asia have been stolen and made into various artificial states.
@@texmexexpress Every country today is a modern country, my friend. You are confusing the concept of a modern country with a new country, which are not the same thing. The concept of a modern country is probably only about 300 years old; before that, all the world was based on tribal or feudal systems. This does not mean that countries didn't exist before; it just means that they were defined by the territories of tribal chiefs or feudal lords. As an example, when the Zand dynasty (capital Shiraz) came to power in 1751 after the Afsharids, the Afsharids (capital Mashhad) were still ruling the eastern part of Iran. The interesting thing is that the Afsharids were in power until 1796, while the Zand dynasty fell in 1794. Both were defeated by the Qajars. So which one was Iran? As for Iran being the oldest country, different scholars have different lists of the oldest countries in the world; they differ because each uses different criteria. Iran definitely is one of the oldest. But one cannot make an absolute assertion that it is the oldest; it depends on the criteria that is being used. Also, you speak of old maps and borders. Until the 19th century, every single dynasty in Iran, without exception, had different borders. Not only that, but the borders of each dynasty changed as it gained or lost territory. So, tell me, which of these hundreds of borders are the 'real' borders of Iran? It is absurd to claim that every territory that was once ruled by Iran belongs to Iran. If we go by this claim, many other countries can have overlapping claims because they once ruled the same territories. The only time that borders didn't change was when the Pahlavi dynasty replaced the Qajars, because by that time, Iran was already a modern country with distinct borders. So unlike the old times, rulers can change, but borders stay the same.
@S U I dont think you really understand what shi’ism is. 1. The Hadith you mentioned is about twelve caliphs whom all are from Quryash tribe. And it is stated clearly this way without the need for (interpretation) 2. The difference come from pillars of Islam. Shia believe that you are not really a muslim until you believe in Imamah and that the 12 Imams are Infallible. 3. Shia believe Fatimah is more like a goddess than just a normal human being. 4. Shia consider the prophet as a secondary character of Islam and thus it is very hard to say we split after the death of the prophet since you don’t really take anything away from the teachings of the prophet because it was transmitted to us by people like Abu hurayrah, Aisha, and Ibn-Abbas...etc (Shia consider them infidels)
@@husnaasadi infact, mahmud ghazni looted somnath temple from my country, india and paid ferdousi gold coins for each verse he wrote. Ghaznavid dynasty was itself turkish.
@@husnaasadi Do you really believe your shits? There is no place name as Afghanistan in medival and ancient time. Afghan is the name Pashtun tribe and nothing to do with Persian . Secondly Iran as political and identity meaning mentioned by Sassanid king Ardeshir I in his inscription as "IranShahr" this inscription located in "Kaba Zartosht" of Fars province . Instead of repeating nonsense claim, research about name of Iran . Before Reza Shah all Iranian call their land as Iran . The name Persia was traditional name by westerners since Ancient Greece. When you don't have enough knowledge no need to repeat nonsense claims
Persian poet's? You mean Afghanistan's poet's jalaludin Mohammed balkhi, Rabia balkhi , if you don't know about balkh please check Google , do not creat wrong video with wrong information maybe Iranian paid you to do this
All the poems have been written in Persian. Then you say why they are called Persian poets? Ferdowsi has mentioned the name of Iran many times in his poetry. In general, all these poets belong to a single culture that is common between Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan. Wars and borders later separated this single culture. Afghanistan and Tajikistan They were also part of Iran at the time of these poets.
@@husnaasadi What you are saying is influenced by emerging nationalist ideologies based on prejudice and hatred of others. Iran has an ancient and clear history, the cultural geography of Iran and the Persian language including present-day Iran, Tajikistan and the Persian-speaking parts of Afghanistan.
As a Tajik I thank you for warm feelings towards our wonderful literature 🧡🙏🏻
Our pleasure!
thanks, great job , I wish once more these people colaborate , and work together to revive this great culture , I am proud of all persian people ,and their litrature.
that would be great translating more poems , dorood va sepase from Iran
This is a really wonderful introduction to Persian literature. Well done!
Awesome. Thanks.
Growing up in Afghanistan, I recall that the books by Persian poems Sadi and Hafiz was in every home honered and loved second to Quran. The peomes are timeless. I never get tired of listoning to them.
Thank you for sharing. They are really great poets.
For us, in Iran, the Quran is nowhere to be seen compared to Hafez and Shahname, and Golestan,. Hafez is like Zarathustra for us. Sufism itself is an underground (personal) Zoroastrianism.
@@nomesa7374 Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez, a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an.
About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage forget Hafiz.
Sufism is nowhere Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy which modern Iranians follow. Sufis are missionary group 90% muslims are converted by Sufi missionaries.
Nice try.
@@arabianinferno6918
1. "Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez": Its a free world. You are nobody to tell me what to say. So Sad for you. Lol
2. "Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy": That is why, I said "Personal Zoroastrian".
3. "About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage": Because they are organized religion. Do you understand "Personal Religion"? Sufism is that.
4, "Sufis are missionary group": Maybe in your village. Sufis created Baghdad and named it a Zoroastrian name. Muslim Rulers throughout the entire period, hated the Sufis and especially their grand teachers.
5. "[Hafiz was ]a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an": Are you kidding? He has dedicated himself to Pire-Moghan (the Old Magi or Zarathustra), Mogh-Bachegan (the Magi's students), Wine, Music, Dance, Love, and stories of Shahnameh. He repeatedly and badly ridiculed Fasting, Haj, and Jihad (as holy war). Muslim Clergies hated (and still hate) him. He never went to Haj and didn't like to go there. He even said repeatedly that he is not Muslim (directly or esotericly).
Hahahaha, I doubt if you even can read Persian poetry.
1. "Non Islamic should not talk about Hafez": Its a free world. You are nobody to tell me what to say. So Sad for you. Lol
2. "Zoroastrianism a Priestly based clergy more like Shia clergy": That is why, I said "Personal Zoroastrian".
3. "About zoroastrian they don't even claim Modern Persian (Farsi)as Persian heritage": Because they are organized religion. Do you understand "Personal Religion"? Sufism is that.
4, "Sufis are missionary group": Maybe in your village. Sufis created Baghdad and named it a Zoroastrian name. Muslim Rulers throughout the entire period, hated the Sufis and especially their grand teachers.
5. "[Hafiz was ]a person who dedicated entire life for Qur'an": Are you kidding? He has dedicated himself to Pire-Moghan (the Old Magi or Zarathustra), Mogh-Bachegan (the Magi's students), Wine, Music, Dance, Love, and stories of Shahnameh. He repeatedly and badly ridiculed Fasting, Haj, and Jihad (as holy war). Muslim Clergies hated (and still hate) him. He never went to Haj and didn't like to go there. He even said repeatedly that he is not Muslim (directly or esotericly).
Hahahaha, I doubt if you even can read Persian poetry.
Great job. The video is prepared carefully and detailed explanation is provided for each poet. As a Persian (Iranian) who have read most of these works (except sanaee and roudaki), I confess that "Fiction Beast" has reviewed Persian poetry and its influence in literature in a short time (just 27 min). As a Persian, I am really grateful for introducing Persian culture to the world. Well done Sir!!!
Thanks so much! It means a lot.
As an irainan i love all of them but hafez is unbelievable i can't compare him with anyone
Thank you for video ❤
You made me want to explore Persian literature with urgency. Thank you!
Thanks for the introduction. I am from Bangladesh. My father was Madrasah educated person with good comand on urdu and reasonable farsi. I learned about these names during childhood. Not beyond names and their main books... Now in my 50s I am curious about persian culture.... Want to visit Shiraj and bukhara....
Thanks for sharing. I am glad you enjoyed it.
As an Iranian, I am so glad you like and attention to Persian literature.
You're very welcome. Thank you for watching.
@@Fiction_Beast have you forgotten something, rabia balkhi was legendary in love with baktash and brother of kills rabya
@@Fiction_Beast Rābi'a bint Ka'b (arabisch رابعة بنت كعب, DMG Rābi‘a bint Ka‘b, auch persisch رابعهٔ بلخى, DMG Rābi‘a-i Balḫī) war eine persische Samanidenfürstentochter und Dichterin der persischen Literatur des 10. Jahrhunderts. Rabia Balchi thematisierte ihre verbotene Liebe zu einem Sklaven. Vor allem in Afghanistan ranken sich Legenden um ihre Person.
Ihr Mausoleum befindet sich in der nordafghanischen Stadt Balch im zentralen Park unweit des Schreins von Khwaja Abu Nasr Parsa.
Great introducing to amazing Persian literature , Thank you
Thank you too!
What a delight, outweighs Turkish delight (ha ha). I love Persian food but never tasted Persian poems now I am sold. Thank you so much for this comprehensive review. You have done an amazing work.
As soon as you mentioned Turkish delight, i could smell it :)
Persian poetry has been very underappreciated outside the language. partly because poetry translation is hard, partly becuase only narrative poetry gets read these days.
Sharon, you have won the free giveaway. It's a copy of Omar Khayyam's Rubaiyat (penguin classic version). If you want to recieve it, please send me your home address by email, or private message on instagram or twitter. Please don't write your address here.
@@Fiction_Beast What a surprise as it is not often that I get such a message. Since I am not on instagram or twitter I will have to wait for my daughter to help me. Thank you so much.
@@sharontheodore8216 My email is in this channel's "about" page. Yes please take your time. There is no rush.
Did you know that Turkish delight was invented by Persians? 😂
Incredible introduction to Persian poets thank you. I have only read Hafiz. Many hours of enjoyment ahead of me, deeper senses opened by honest words.
Glad you enjoyed it!
I like Khayyam. When I was a child, I wasn't very interested in poetry and I only read illustrated stories of Shahnameh. I'd read some of Khayyam's poems before, but Sadegh Hedayat made me more interested in Khayyam.
i really loved the blind owl. He was a great writer.
khayyam is the best 😍
I can say first time I have listen an explanation about Persian literature like this, thanks for making, Great respect from India Sir
Glad you liked it!
What a great overview. Growing up Iranian-American, I always felt drawn to Persian poetry as a way for me to connect to my roots. I have read works in English so far. Although I can speak Farsi, my next step is to learn how to read and write so I can read the poems in the original language! Thank you for sharing this video!
That's really cool to be able to read in Farsi. Translatability is a an issue in Persian poetry. Saadi might be an easy place to start.
What an enlightening video! Thank you very much. Would love in-depth videos on each poet.
Great rundown - Persia was one of the defining civilizations of the Silk Road, alongside India, China, and Rome - could you possibly do a video on Rumi's magnum opus, the Masnavi? for some reason, the Masnavi as a whole work is far less known in the West than, say, Attar's Birds, despite Rumi's huge popularity - it's mystifying that this poet is mostly known in terms of scattered verses, while his monumental and visionary central life's work is overlooked - it would even be interesting to explore how that's even possible
Is it like Sanskrit/Tamil vs hindi.
Sanskrit and Tamil languages have loads of poetry while hindi is more of a prose based language.
We also have a type of sherjangi here in india, its called Antakshari(Sanskrit for "end of akshar(letter)").
Btw, persian heavily influenced hindi. I hope to learn this language soon.
Thanks for sharing.
I doubt Persian influenced Hindi that much. They both have the same roots so it makes sense that they have lots of similarities.
@@FBlindia was ruled by persian speaking dynasties for around 1000 years. Starting with the ghaznavids and ending with the mughals right before british colonization. Persian has had lots of influence on all Indian languages. It is very easy for linguistic to tell the difference between cognates and borrowed words. Even a persian speaker can look at hindu or/and urdu and see the influence for themselves.
@@Alborzhakimi7010heaviest influence is on Urdu rather than Hindi, but yes Hindi also has lots of influence from the Persian language but over the last 100 years there has been a Hindu led movement to get rid of Persian, Arabic and Turkic origin words. So the linkages have become much weaker.
Well that was quite uplifting, thank you very much good sir.
Glad you enjoyed it
Motashakeram I love them all but Hafez& Khayyam have a special place in my heart when I read them it give me of comfort & belonging.
So engaging! I loved and knew so many things!! Please continue to do the works you do❤❤ continue to introduce the different cultural and literary aspects of the world to each others.
Regardless of the person being from Afghanistan, Iran, Tajikistan, Samarqand, Bukhara- Persian poetry runs in our veins like our blood.
Well done, this was a thorough and informative work. Also let's mention Naser Khosrow with perhaps his most famouse poem: The Eagle
we definitely could use more insight from Persian literature
Hello Fiction Beast, I chanced upon your presentation "Ten Persian Poets" and found it very ably put. I immediately latched on to it. This is something I had been looking for for a very long time. I have read Hafez in-depth, but wanted a short list of other greats to read their poetry properly. My immediate question is: Where can I buy the Persian Kalam of these 10 poets in Farsi? I have Ferdowsi's Shahnameh and Attar's "The Conference of Birds", and also Khayyam, but for the rest of the ten, I want to acquire their original Persian volumes [ in Farsi, with or without translations]. Best wishes
I would love to dive deeper. Thank you so much 🙌
You're welcome! Let
Plz more on Persian literature! And I know it’s a lot to ask but a whole series on Shahnameh could be great! Or maybe on other modern ones like Nima, Forough, Moshiri.
Poetry is that popular among Iranians that the tomb of poets such as hafez and saadi, Shahriyar, ferdowsi etc are the most visited historical tourist sites in the nation.
Watching and learning from your presentation was wonderful. Thank you so much.
You are very welcome
After having read Shahnameh, I definitely want to read more Persian poetry.
Rumi is populat but I say read some Khayyam.
I have a huge problem with the end part of your video. "Iran have not been arabised due to Mongolian attack!". Actually all thanks to Iranian poets like Ferdowsi not some savage army which destroyed all the books and cause curcial gap in writing history of Persia due this attack. Next generation of Mongolian kings were under influence of Persian and they changed their attitude and their religious.
The mongols destroyed a lot including the arabization process of Iran.
@@Fiction_BeastIlliterate 😂
@@Fiction_Beast ты глуп как и многие. Вы понятия не имеете о монголах они ничего общего не имеют с современной монголией. Монголы это те же тюрки. Я Казах из рода Кереит и мы были всю историю тюрками так же как и найманы и борджигины и все остальные рода которые поддержали Чингисхана. Если ты считаешь наш дикой ордой то запомни дикая орда никогда не смогла бы завоевать пол мира и держать в страхе даже вас европейцев которые пройграли все сражения с монголами потому что отстали как в развитии так и военном деле. У нас была своя письменность, литература и культура тактже она и осталась и арабизация это ни что то страшное , а наоборот привнесла и объединила тюркскую,иранскую и многие другие культуры. Так что почитай умных книжек и не пиши всякой ереси
@@madinahaminteresting
@@Fiction_Beast This has to be the weirdest thing i've heard
Thank you great video❤❤❤. By the way we don't use Arabic script because the Arabic script itself is a branch of Avestan and pahlavid script. The earliest Arabic script is kufi which is very similar to Avesta script one can easily understand the similarities si in conclusion Arab people adopted our way of writing and changed it over time.
It was great . I love hafez ferdowsi and rumi a lot 😊 you can search about new peots too
Thank you, I will
It was amazing! Thank you so much 👌🏻👌🏻
It’s fascinating the effort you’ve put behind this informative clip. Just one correction that Rumi was not from Iran, he was from Balkh which is located in Afghanistan. The original language was called Dari which started getting changed in the last 200 years in Iran. If not then what language was Hafez and Sa’adi’s poetries were said? Then what would you call this poem of Hafez :
ز شعر دلکش حافظ کسی بود آگاه _ گه لطف طبع و سخن گفتن دری داند.
Thanks.
But he said that… 16:48
Rumi was a Persian from Balkh. Afghanistan didn't exist back then, it was just another province of Iran. The language is called Parsi/Farsi (Persian) and originated in Iran. It spread from Iran to the rest of the Persianate World, Dari is just a dialect of Persian. Hafez and Sa'adi were from Shiraz, that is in Iran. 😂
@@texmexexpressWell said.
I loved the video! It is funny that I met your channel because I was looking for someone who talked about Shahnameh and now you come with a video which opens up a whole world of literature i had ignored!
A question: do you speak farsi? Is it difficult to learn?
That's great to hear. At least someone is learning from my videos. Thanks.
Some. I think Farsi writing can be challenging to those unfamiliar to Arabic script. the language itself has no genders and its verb conjugation is somewhat similiar to Russian, changes based on the tense and person.
@@Fiction_BeastIt's the Persian script!
As a Blit, and a lifetime reader of Persian poetry, I can say that "almost" sixty precent of it is prosaic! and has a highly articulated classification. For instance with Molavi (or name which he is famous with in the west "Rumi) Three gigantic books (of his five gigantic books) is prosaic. Or the same story goes with Nezami, Sa'adi. and also better having in mind that what works are we categorizing as Persian literature? since the overall manner and essence of "Iranian Philosophy'' is actually poetic. as if they had sensed where has the "truth" concealed! (please forgive my English)
I recommend you read more modern Persian poems as well,they are great there are many greats poets in the kinda modern area to from Parvin Etesami,to Akhavsn Sales,Nima Yoshij and Forogh Farokhzad
Thank you for the great video :) in grace
Thank you for sharing! I love Rumi and Hafiz’s the most. I must say that China’s early literature had a very strong poetry presence, so much so that even in its prose there were many couplets. Every scholar, every government officials, many emperors, generals and merchants, women … wrote poetry. Even today, it is not unusual for young children to recite dozens of poems from ancient times. The famous Tang Dynasty poet Li Bai (701-762 AD) had a poem “Amidst the Flowers with a Jug of Wine”, about the moon, the flowers, wine, solitude and friendship - I find it interesting to read this together with Khayyam’s famous poem “… beneath the bough, a flask of wine … and thou beside me singing…” Today, we find Khayyam’s portrait on the Egyptian wine bottle, and Li Bai’s name on the traditional Japanese wine (sake) bottle. They are immortalized by their poems that have traveled to so many lands.
This also applies to Persia, where the very strong presence of ancient Persian shapes everyday life. It is very usual and common for Iranian youth to recite dozen of poems and legends dating back to ancient times.
But for every Arabic word that is in Persian we have Persian counter pets and pure Persian or almost pure does exists
I really like your content. But one mistake is to call the Persian alphabet the Arabic alphabet.
The Perso-Arabic alphabet was a direct evolution of the Aramaic and Pahlavi Alphabets (generated in Sasanids Ctesiphon). Besides innovations of dots and vowels by Iranians, almost all calligraphic styles are the innovations of Iranians. So it is a Persian Alphabet.
Some historians and etymologists also argue that the Arabic language itself was generated by Mathematicians of Ctesiphon (look at Arabic's mathematical structure) to compete with the scientific supremacy of Greek and Roman languages. For example, ferdows, Al-ard (the earth), Zamzam, and so many other fundamental words have Iranian origins (Pardis, or erd). That is why, The oldest found Arabic text is in Syria and Iraq.
Regarding the rhythm and rhythm, you are very right. Persian Poetry is considered the first attempt of humans to "write down" (not just to hear) the music. Gatha (the short book of Zarathustra) is also poetic.
As a Farsi/Dari speaking Afghan American who left Afghanistan at age 14, I can read and write Dari. Farsi a most beautiful language imaginable, of course I am biased. Unfortunately, these poems lose their beauty and essence when translated into English. It’s like taking a masterpiece of art, say a Van Gough or a Rembrandt and just letting a toddler brush paint all over it. The ONLY way to truly appreciate the immense and blinding beauty of Farsi/Dari poetry is to learn the language and learn it very well!
Persian literature, very rich culture.
I agree
Thank you for the video! Have you done a video about Sohrab Sepehri?
I'll recommend you all the Ghazal Number 441 of Divan e Shams by Rumi! It's magical!
If possible can you send me a link if it is available online. Thanks so much.
You left out, one of the great Persian poet Mirza Ghalib dehlvi, though he also wrote poetry in Urdu and another one Bedil dehlvi
Amir khosrow dehlawi
M.ikbal lahouri
the original version of Khosrow o Shirin by Nezami is available in the market???
Awesome work. brilliant. but as you yourself said: the Persian poems do not translate and should be read in Farsi to understand the depth and beauty of it.
1.Ferdowsi Tusi
2.Molana balkhi (rumi)
3.Saadi Shirazi
4.Hafez shirazi
5.Attar Neyshaburi
6.Sanai ghaznavi
7.Nizami ganjavi
8.khaghani Shervani
9.Farrukhi Sistani
10.khayam Neyshaburi
11.Manuchehri Damghani
12.Vahshi bafghi
13.abdulrahman Jami
14.Saeb tabrizi
15.Ghatran Tabrizi
All of them are Iranian persian🇮🇷❤️
if the persian poetry almost in-transtable, how you read them?
سپاس از اینکه به بررسی شعر فارسی پرداختید.🙏❤️
good luck for you, as an Afghanistanian I admire your efforts.
but it were the Persian scientists and linguistics who modified both Arabic and Persian languages, otherwise Arabs were brutal men and knew nothing about literature
Thanks a bunch! Thanks for the informations.
Glad it was helpful!
Keep up the great 👍 work 👍
Thank you sir to explain us this thinks
It's very useful for me... Thanks a lot
Oh man. Great video, tho I’d like to add that Coleman barks is not a good translator. If you want a better translation I recommend Nicholson or I recommend you buying the Oxford classics version of Mathnavi.
Thanks for the tip!
very well made 👏👏
One big mistake at the begining, Persian does not contain 20 -40 percent arabic loan words, I studied persian literature and only islamic/religious books contain arabic. This is a major mistake in your introduction. Farsi contains approximately 5 to 7 percent arabic loan words also,arabic contains a lot of persian loan words, for instance iraqi arabic contains a lot of farsi loan words approximate 15-20 percent. Also ferdowsi's Shahnameh is 100 percent written in farsi with no arabic loanwords.
You.forgot to mention the name of Asad Ullah Khan Ghalib, his 90% poetry was in Farsi and just on 10% in Urdu..
Great
Persian 🇮🇷🔥
Nasir Khusraw Bulki around 1050 is a major classical poet but ignored here
English language is based on Sanskrit language and in Arabic. Also there are a lot of Persian words which is borrowed from Persian into Arabic language.
Do you have pdf format of poetry
Yes I’m trying to find a good place so viewers have access to my scripts.
Please talk about nezami more
Super content.
Thanks!
Nizami türkdu gəncədən atabey dövlətin şairi idi ..
Nizami fars idi. O, savadsız türklərə nifrət edib, sizi monqol vəhşiləri adlandırıb ... 🤣
🙃
😂😂😂😂😂😂
The funny part of this subject is to put Shamloo among these famous poets.
Parvin Etesami also has the best poets of conversation
its mersy like this مرسی
Excellent really excellent
Thank you so much 😀
My dear, English in poetry and literature versus Persian is like a drop in the ocean. In English, the elements that exist in Persian poetry and literature do not exist in English, not only in English, but also in other languages. I am reciting a poem by Ferdowsi the Great. Now you can translate it into English. See if it is beautiful in Persian or in English.
هوشنگ با رای و داد
به جای پدر تاج بر سر نهاد
Giveaway will help to know more about the topic so thank you very much
Thank you! I hope you win. 🤞
If you agree with the logic that Ghandi was not a white Englishman just because he lived in the British Empire which included India at the time, then you also must agree that a lot of these people were Tajiks and not "Persians".
Σε αυτήν τη γεωγραφία της Περσικής ποίησης ιδιαίτερα με εντυπωσιάζει η πόλη Balkh (Βάκτρια των Ελλήνων). Ποιά είναι αυτή η πόλη των ΕλληνοΜακεδόνων, των ΠερσοΖωροαστρών, των ΙνδοΒουδιστών, των ΑραβοΜουσουλμάνων, που βρίσκεται στο βόρειο Αφγανιστάν; Ποιά είναι αυτή η πόλη όπου πέθαναν προφήτες όπως ο Ζαρατούστρα και γεννήθηκαν ποιητές όπως η Rabia Balkhi και ο Mevlana Jalaladdin Rumi Balkhi; Η ιστορία της με γοητεύει και η φαντασία μου προσπαθεί να την αναστυλώσει στην πρότερή της δόξα
Rabia is from Khuzdar Balochistan Pakistan not Afghanistan!
Or may I am Wrong. Please check it!
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
🤡🤡🤡 joker -- read the Samanids dynasty, Saman Khuda from Balkh was the founder of it. The capital of the dynasty was based in Bukhara. Rabia Balkhi was a princess of Samanids. She wrote in Farsi and what that has anything to do with Baloch or Balochistan?
Great video. Western society are inconceivable without Iranian deep ancient knowledge due to mongol then arabs tried to destroy this amazing culture which bring love and poetry and again you see today the Islamic regime trying to destroy it but still not capable due to the zorvanisim and mythraic love still remain in Iranian people in Iranian pelato.
it is very nice
Salaam for all... If any have persian please help and teach me
What do you mean of "have Persian" exactly?
I ilke Persian poetry. And proud of a Turkish poet and philosopher; Mevlana Celalettin-i Rumi having an important place in it. He wrote all his poems in Iranian because of great cultural influence of Persia. His “Mesnevi “ is a masterpiece…🙏🏻
Rumi was great. he belonged to no people and to all people.
Yes his work is universal. But it doesn’t change the reality of his Turkish identity.
Rumi wasn't Turkish
Rumi was Persian and belonged to Iran and Iranian culture.
And in the course of his life, he lived in IRAN.
Try not to confiscate what does not belong to you.
He was not Turkish, and there was no Turkey since 1924, and it was created by Britain. Before that, it was Ottoman which was nothing but inhumanity.
It is not lovely behaving like this, Mr. Koglu.
@@leventkoglu7107 They called him Rumi because he passed away in konya, modern-day Turkey, but he was 100% Iranic
👏👏👏👏👏🙏❤️❤️❤️❤️thank you
You are so welcome
Many of these poets were Tajiks. Not Persians. The concept of Persian has changed to mean people of Iran only these days. It excludes the Tajiks of Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Afghanistan who in the time of Rumi (born in Balkh, Afghanistan) may have been considered Persian but are not considered that anymore. Therefor Its wrong to call these ancient Tajik poets "Persian" just because they spoke Persian. Its like calling an English speaking Nigerian an Englishman just because he only speaks English and published his works in a more dominant language of the time.
If Rumi and the other Tajiks in this list lived forever and didnt die, they would be considered Tajik today, not Persian.
Iranians love to claim everyone under the sun that lived in the past as "Persian" even if they are Tajiks in reality.
They WERE Persian. This statement is correct. Tajikistan didn't exist back then. They didn't identify as Iranian or Tajik. They identified as Persian.
@@antidweller6373 actually if we are being correct now that you mention it, "Persian" as an identity didnt exist back then and neither does now. The term "Persian" is an English word and doesnt exist in the "Persian" language. Nobody calls themselves "Farsi" in Iran or anywhere else. Only westernized Iranians like to call themselves "Persian".
@@antidweller6373 "Persian" is an English word and nobody calls themselves "Farsi" people lol. Specially not 1000 years ago when people didnt have a concept of ethnicity.
0:45
tus is mashhad now
*SOME CORRECTIONS OF WRONG INFORMATION IN THIS VIDEO:* Persian doesn't use the "Arabic" alphabet. It uses the *Persian alphabet.* Arabic speakers can't read Persian since they don't know how the letters are pronounced in Persian. Persian is an Indo-Euopean language, meaning it is just as close to English as English is close to Hindi. Persian hasn't adapted "too many" Arabic vocabulary. Only 5% of Persian words trace an Arabic origin. Your false and unscientific research ridiculously suggests that Persian uses 20%-40% of Arabic words. Persian is a very rich language and can easily create new words out of native word stems. Persian is correctly called Parsi.
Just because Tajiks were conquered by Persians doesnt mean Tajiks' accomplishments and heritage belongs to Iranians. Otherwise we can say whole of Iran belongs to Mongolians since Iran was another Khanate of Mongolia at one point.
Also another point, you wouldn't claim Ghandi was a white Englishman just because he lived in the British Empire which at the time included India.
Also Tajiks were only part of Persian Empire 100-200 years. Rest of history there were other empires whose rulers were not Persians, but Turks, Arabs, Mongols and Tajiks themselves (Samanid Empire)
was he a sufi?
Who?
@@Fiction_Beast
Firdowsi
I am not sure about his Sufi connection.
No, ferdowsi wasn't suffi.
Rumi, sanai, Atar were suffi only in this video.
🤗🤗
im irany that means im persian
You are wrong with shamloo. He is not a great persian poet.
💕✔️
They were great writers but it’s a shame that most of these people were very degenerative and immoral in their personal lives
Who isn’t?
@@Fiction_Beast are you brother? Lol
Everyone has a demon.
@@Fiction_Beast if you mean that nobody is infallible, yeah I agree obviously we’re all flawed but there’s a difference between having the capacity to do immoral things and actively and continuously doing immoral things (and I’m using my moral doctrine as the criteria here so there’s no confusion) without repentance, regret or shame all the while revelling in what you’ve been doing do you get what I’m saying brother?
I think this guy was some Persian person from Iran because he didn’t put a lot of great poetry of Afghanistan who were way better than Iran even I didn’t see any Tajikistan best poetry in this video
Maybe in future videos.
The presenter is not Iranian; he doesn't sound like an Iranian at all. But these poets are Persian poets; they belong to Persian speaking peoples all over the world. The idea of modern countries is a new concept, only 3 or 4 hundred years old. So one shouldn't talk of these poets as Afghanistani or Iranian. Rumi was a Persian from Balkh; Hafez was a Persian from Shiraz. They weren't Afghanistani or Iranian; they were Persians. At those times, people in this area only identified themselves with their names, ethnicity, town and religion; eg, a person would say, "I am Ali, son of Mohammad; I am Persian, and I am a Muslim from Herat." That's it.
Modern countries came later. That is why one only hears of tribal/family names for periods of history- Safavids or Samanids, eg. For Safavids or Samanids, the most important thing was to conquer as much territory as they could, and also the ruler should have been from their families. They didn't care about Afghanistan, Iran, or Tajikistan. So we should leave our current nationalistic pride aside and just celebrate our shared history and literature.
Two poets who talked specifically about Iran in their works were Ferdowsi and Nezami, but you can be certain that by Iran, they meant the lands of Persian peoples (today's Afghanistan, Iran, Tajikistan, and many other lands occupied by Persians); they were not talking about modern-day Iran, because there was no modern-day Iran.
@@piruz3243Wrong, Iran is not a modern country. Iran is the oldest country on earth. The notion and borders of modern Iran already existed in the works and maps of Persian poets and scholars in antiquity. Today's Iran is the ancient Persian land that Ferdowsi and Nizami extensively write about in their poetry. Iran's historical territories and provinces throughout Asia have been stolen and made into various artificial states.
@@texmexexpress
Every country today is a modern country, my friend. You are confusing the concept of a modern country with a new country, which are not the same thing. The concept of a modern country is probably only about 300 years old; before that, all the world was based on tribal or feudal systems. This does not mean that countries didn't exist before; it just means that they were defined by the territories of tribal chiefs or feudal lords.
As an example, when the Zand dynasty (capital Shiraz) came to power in 1751 after the Afsharids, the Afsharids (capital Mashhad) were still ruling the eastern part of Iran. The interesting thing is that the Afsharids were in power until 1796, while the Zand dynasty fell in 1794. Both were defeated by the Qajars. So which one was Iran?
As for Iran being the oldest country, different scholars have different lists of the oldest countries in the world; they differ because each uses different criteria. Iran definitely is one of the oldest. But one cannot make an absolute assertion that it is the oldest; it depends on the criteria that is being used.
Also, you speak of old maps and borders. Until the 19th century, every single dynasty in Iran, without exception, had different borders. Not only that, but the borders of each dynasty changed as it gained or lost territory. So, tell me, which of these hundreds of borders are the 'real' borders of Iran? It is absurd to claim that every territory that was once ruled by Iran belongs to Iran. If we go by this claim, many other countries can have overlapping claims because they once ruled the same territories.
The only time that borders didn't change was when the Pahlavi dynasty replaced the Qajars, because by that time, Iran was already a modern country with distinct borders. So unlike the old times, rulers can change, but borders stay the same.
@@piruz3243 Thanks for proving my point.
Hafez looks like shia Alhussein haha
it's an artist's impression so you're right, he does look like a Shia imam.
@@Fiction_Beast more like the Shia God lol, but I think this is a true impression of Poet Hafez
@S U I dont think you really understand what shi’ism is.
1. The Hadith you mentioned is about twelve caliphs whom all are from Quryash tribe. And it is stated clearly this way without the need for (interpretation)
2. The difference come from pillars of Islam. Shia believe that you are not really a muslim until you believe in Imamah and that the 12 Imams are Infallible.
3. Shia believe Fatimah is more like a goddess than just a normal human being.
4. Shia consider the prophet as a secondary character of Islam and thus it is very hard to say we split after the death of the prophet since you don’t really take anything away from the teachings of the prophet because it was transmitted to us by people like Abu hurayrah, Aisha, and Ibn-Abbas...etc (Shia consider them infidels)
Ferdowsi was Ghaznavi poet Ghaznavi Afghanistan Ghazni .
Ferdowsi was from Tus.
@@husnaasadi infact, mahmud ghazni looted somnath temple from my country, india and paid ferdousi gold coins for each verse he wrote. Ghaznavid dynasty was itself turkish.
@@Aman-qr6wi no Mahmoud Ghazni Ghaznavid was an afghan warrior , from Ghazni province Afghanistan
@@husnaasadi oh, I get it. He was from afghanistan.
@@husnaasadi Do you really believe your shits?
There is no place name as Afghanistan in medival and ancient time.
Afghan is the name Pashtun tribe and nothing to do with Persian .
Secondly Iran as political and identity meaning mentioned by Sassanid king Ardeshir I in his inscription as "IranShahr" this inscription located in "Kaba Zartosht" of Fars province .
Instead of repeating nonsense claim, research about name of Iran .
Before Reza Shah all Iranian call their land as Iran . The name Persia was traditional name by westerners since Ancient Greece.
When you don't have enough knowledge no need to repeat nonsense claims
Persian poet's? You mean Afghanistan's poet's jalaludin Mohammed balkhi, Rabia balkhi , if you don't know about balkh please check Google , do not creat wrong video with wrong information maybe Iranian paid you to do this
Yes, I am very rich, and that's why the Iranian economy is struggling right now.
All the poems have been written in Persian. Then you say why they are called Persian poets? Ferdowsi has mentioned the name of Iran many times in his poetry. In general, all these poets belong to a single culture that is common between Iran, Afghanistan and Tajikistan. Wars and borders later separated this single culture. Afghanistan and Tajikistan They were also part of Iran at the time of these poets.
@@masoud7036 Afghanistan's official language is farsi (Persian) , shut ur mouth before talking shi*t
@@masoud7036 Ferdowsi mentioned Iran Ghazni Ghaznavid Ariana Afghanistan, not the Iran handmade 70 years old Reza Shah.
@@husnaasadi What you are saying is influenced by emerging nationalist ideologies based on prejudice and hatred of others. Iran has an ancient and clear history, the cultural geography of Iran and the Persian language including present-day Iran, Tajikistan and the Persian-speaking parts of Afghanistan.