The End of Time | Sam Baron | TEDxFremantle
Вставка
- Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
- Dr. Sam Baron is a senior lecturer in philosophy at the University of Western Australia, and holds two grants from the Australian Research Council (ARC) on time. Sam introduces both the physics and philosophies which underwrite the 'end of time.' The idea that time does not exist has startling complications... If time does not exist, then a range of everyday 'realities' seem to be meaningless; notions such as morality, agency, and causation. Dr Sam Baron is Senior Lecturer in philosophy at the University of Western Australia and holds two grants from the Australian Research Council (ARC) on time. Sam will introduce both the physics and philosophy that underwrites the ‘end of time’. The idea that time does not exist has startling implications. If time does not exist, then a range of everyday notions seem to be meaningless; notions such as morality, agency and causation. This talk was given at a TEDx event using the TED conference format but independently organized by a local community. Learn more at www.ted.com/tedx
*Change will not come if we wait for some other person or some other time. We are the ones we've been waiting for. We are the change that we seek. @*
Let's see
Amen
Subbed
@@maxsargent2171 Welcome to the channel! :)
@Discover Change-makers are the problem-makers
"There's no reason to feel bad for something you did in the past because time doesn't exist." Um, time may not exist but other people's feelings do, so yeah, if you do something bad that hurts someone else then guilt is a good thing to feel!
This is nonsense. Time is not a social construction, even if seconds and minutes are. Just as space is not a social construction even if meters are. An important distinction to remember in relativity is that time always passes at a constant rate relative to the observer, and, importantly, always in a "forward" direction. Your space traveler would see earth dwellers in fast forward and himself at normal speed, and earth dwellers would see the space traveler in slow motion and themselves at normal speed. Both of them would measure light at the same speed they always have. This is not to say that there isn't more to know about time, but a social construction? Please.
Great clarification. Lucid.
Now Thanos gotta rename the Time Stone to Change Stone.
Lol, good one.
Perfect concept! I'm gonna crazy with it. Hahaha
Alan Watts explained this much more clearly
I felt he was leading up to the idea of time as a tool, but I appreciate the other analogies he uses.
Here's another point of view. Time is a psychological object.
These were first defined by Kurt Danziger, a researcher who opined that "broken legs" are not the same as "broken hearts." Yet, we study these two in the same way and more than occasionally, confuse ourselves by forgetting that there's a big difference.
Is time real? My thinking is that time is a real psychological object. So are good/bad, uptown/downtown, war/peace, happiness/depression.
He argued that you can tell a psychological object by the fact that its historical definition changes. 100 years ago, scientists were studying "melancholy." Today, the term is almost never used in a psychological context. But humans beings have not changed. However, a broken leg a million years ago remains that same today.
This remarkable distinction between physical and psychological objects can clarify debates like these.
(BTW, the invention of "digital objects" has transformed our world as well.)
No one ever made the assertion time is a present force or entity and we're fully aware that's it's a human construct that has a practical use but okay.
He's a nutball. Time is SYNONYMOUS with CHANGE.
Change-makers are the problem-makers
We don't need Time to know we should feel bad about doing someone wrong. But we could just use the present moment to make the situation better instead of pretending what happened did not happen. The future is only the continuation of Now.
I get high off of conversations like these. TIME... The illusion. (How I see it.)
Imagine if we never slept.
If we could just pull up a chair and watch, observe. Seeing the process of a person aging would be quite the experience.
Almost all scientific observations involve time.
and almost none of scientists talks that time doesn't exist.
szczsz yeah time may be relative, but it still has measurable effects, entropy for example.
@@mindseyemelodies yup, and it's grrat that in 4d spacetime everything is all right
szczsz philosophy is full of empty reasonings such as the tree falling in the forest, or even the notion that math isn’t real. It’s a waste of time in my opinion.
szczsz I hope he wasn’t paid for his time. Since it does not exist. 😁. Philosophy courses should be free, since math and time do not exist
the video description has the same paragraph twice
This one was full of contradictions. He used logical tidbits to keep a strange narrative going.
What is the contradiction here? please tell me
If you don't know, I doubt I can help you. It about simply comparing his own words. If you do know but are testing me, I got better things to do.
Time is Thought & Thought is TimeThere is no time without thought & there is no thought without timeThought & Time are the past & there is no present or the future.....so the past keeps repeating itself.I would never use this word "Change" because there is no change anywhere..........however, there is a tiny bit of modified continuity of the past(which you could call it change, but I won't). Now this modified continuity of the past "maybe" is the present, but as soon as the present is born, the past eats or converts the present into past & we are all left with the past, again.
Around 4:15... "Newton, living during the Industrial Revolution...". Umm...Newton was about 3 decades dead before the Industrial Revolution is considered to have begun.
This is what I always thought about time. It's just a way to measure progression and cycles of events. But then the theory of relatively, quantum physics etc. seemed to prove me wrong.
Philosophically - or rather practically? - he makes interesting points.
If you have a day full of activities the day seems to have been longer afterwards. Maybe we can make more time for ourselves by doing more stuff? If you live your life not doing much, isn't it like you've only had a short time on earth? Eventhough paradoxically (or is it?) at the moment not doing much, time seems to slow down, and while being busy time seems to fly.
✋🏼👊🏼😀❤️ Co-creators experiencing joy in this illusion of time.
Does time , really clocks ? 💤
one of the most interesting Talks I've listened on TED.
Time is an illusion of measurements, ergo art. Creativity allows for the shared cognition of life's view of their realities. Then, nature vs. nurture (luckily now with AI!) can aid Earth's toxic imbalances (water & air micro cleansing with several strategic bio domes) from adding to further transformations that can cascade towards another epic natural cleansing (WaterWorld, anyone?).
I see Time as one unit, a spiral understood by even the Tube worms.
Time as it pertains to earth is used to stamp the change of something in motion. Thats all I use it for.
& that recording of time is YOU & US & EVERYONE so if time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go
@@manujohn99 Time is applicable to our human needs. So, I agree with you.
@Superior Actually there is no need of applying time to our human needs, but we are inextricably forced into it, maybe for good reasons or maybe for bad reasons...........but you can be the judge of reasons....but remember whatever you judge is still in time so we are still only going to strengthen the inextricable force of time upon ourselves
Time .... It's inversly proportional to the speed of body ! The more is the speed of body the slow will the time passes !! 🙏
I love mathematics ❤️
@Prash So why does a stationary body have a slow speed of time but not faster speed of time.........tell me genius
I feel so enlightened! As if he just said somethings I was expecting for a long TIME.
Few Implications:
Goodbye AI Take Over
Welcome Parallel Universes
Goodbye Time Travel
Welcome Optimism
Etc.
0ll
Salam Even if you are enlightened, there's no point
@@manujohn99 cruel and unfortunate. The point is so huge its all over the realm. Its like taking the poor mice off the treadmill Newton once put on in his lab during the mechanical-mouse-on-the-wheel era.
@Salam Look enlightenment is just another knowledge like every other knowledge but knowledge will never make anyone free.........like it or not.......we are all living through this same knowledge
@@manujohn99 if knowledge can't (haven't), I dont know what will. We lost the point anyway.
Everything depends on the way of your thinking and what you believe
Yes, time is thinking & thoughts.
Manu John exactly
Slaughterhouse Five - Kurt Vonnegut
"Plot
The story is told in a nonlinear order, and events become clear through flashbacks (or time travel experiences) from the unreliable narrator. He describes the stories of Billy Pilgrim, who believes he was held in an alien zoo and has experienced time travel."
"Tralfamadorian philosophy...
he narrator of the story explains that the Tralfamadorians see time all at once. This concept of time is best explained by the Tralfamadorians themselves, as they speak to Billy Pilgrim on the matter stating, "I am a Tralfamadorian, seeing all time as you might see a stretch of the Rocky Mountains. All time is all time. It does not change. It does not lend itself to warnings or explanations. It simply is."[21] After this particular conversation on seeing time, Billy makes the statement that this philosophy does not seem to evoke any sense of free will. To this, the Tralfamadorian reply that free will is a concept that, out of the "visited thirty-one inhabited planets in the universe" and "studied reports on one hundred more",[21] exists solely on Earth."
Quotes from "wiki (slash) Slaughterhouse-Five"
*You are omnipresent*
Terrible presentation of time here although there are some good points Dr. Barron makes. We are each a unique path of time. Why a unique path? Because we are free to roam (have our way or "path") and have our being (life) and think for ourselves about (truth) in ALL things created or previously existing before human record. At 1:39 he mentions "each event is living in its own little universe" "The universe is fragmented into pieces and each piece lives on its own" Are we not each an "event" living on our own having our being and with our own free will with the construct of "time" in all its forms to use (employ) to help in making decisions and help keep order in our own lives as well as to assist in helping others?
Unique paths = Unique personal projections
Hence his presentation of time.
@Francisco creating a unique time or following the standard time doesn't mean anything because you are not living. Time is always gonna be there until the end of human beings but a living person need not create or worry about time.......a living person will just live life but time doesn't need to dictate a living person's life......if time has to dictate our life always, then in soo many ways we are not living life.
@@manujohn99 You are spot on Manu except for "time doesn't need to dictate how we live it". It actually does force you to think about how you are spending your time especially in the fast-paced world of America. We know the average life span is upwards of 70. Knowing this, in essence, draws out a boundary or limit of the possibilities one person can do. So in this sense this expectation or time constraint does indeed dictate your life to one extent. But I think what you are trying to say is that time does not dictate the quality of your life. I would also like to point out that what you reminded me of in the whole of your comment is why the reason Jesus Christ is "said to be" (actually declared) the Truth, The Way and The Life and I know that this is so because this is the life of Love. It recognizes that human life in the flesh is extremely short as folks approach their senior years and feel the effects of aging and we have heard it so many times from them that we know see our youth repeating and reminding us of it also. Luckily for our youth today, there is overwhelming conviction of what a good, quality life looks like but many have yet to discover The Way.
@@manujohn99 Also Manu we fundamentally indeed, are each a unique path of time, each with our own free will. Dr. Sam Barron almost mentions it but just missed it at 1:39 "each event is living in its own little universe" The universe is fragmented into pieces and each piece lives on its own". My question to all is: Are we not each an "event" living in its own little universe? A unique (Fill in the blank with the Truth)...?
@@knightchecks Yes, we are each a unique path of time, having our being on Earth with our own free will, each with our own perspective and perception as the Truth draws our soul closer to it and as we each know that we are part of the truth in flesh but have not fully understood it. In human history, the Way, The Truth and the Life has already been established yet many deny it or fail to see it.
I think you mean time is just a measurement unit of changes.
Time is a measurement of existence & not just changes
Lol .time is measure of delayness
@Shiva time is also measurement of existence in delay.........in short, time is you, me & everybody together
Time IS merely a measure of change. But this has not addressed the issue of the ontological state of the universe "prior" to remembered changes. Discounting the possibility of the existence of the universe in "anticipated" changed states, it makes no sense to describe the remembered states without reference to a conceptual framework of the "past". This creates an obvious tautology: we cannot arrive at a conclusion about these remembered states without slipping in some surreptitious reference to time, either as past states or as prior-but-now-obliterated states or whatever. We can't describe how the change constitutes a transition from one state to another without using time-laden terminology. Just sayin...
how can anything happen w/o time?
Nothing can happen without time..........anything can only happen with time......in short "Time is the happening & if there is no time there is no happening".
what if time is something like a 'thing' in the universe which *causes* change?
Time is Thought & Thought is Time. There is no time without thought & there is no thought without time. Thought & Time are the past & there is no present or the future.....so the past keeps repeating itself.I would never use this word "Change" because there is no change anywhere..........however, there is a tiny bit of modified continuity of the past(which you could call it change, but I won't). Now this modified continuity of the past "maybe" is the present, but as soon as the present is born, the past eats or converts the present into past & we are all left with the past, again.
@@manujohn99 in that context we have to define what a thought is, cause as far as I think we all are making efforts which is use of nothing. Because our science is thinking it at very basic level still portraying it like it is a complex thing. Time isn't some physical stuff, it is reality, but we still haven't found that which relm should be called real. For a human of today's world, time is just a mere perception. As far as past is concerned, I think you are viewing stuffs quite fast. Slow it down, cause this perception in which people are living has a very less chance of being real.
@raj Thought is a memory & what else are you asking? If you are asking about real reality then real reality does not exist because real reality wouldn't have time in it, which means, if time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go. I did not understand anything about your science explanation
We need to think in terms of energy, frequency and vibration
Time is an abstract concept
Actually time is detailed & deep concept but we don't care much of time other than when we are late to something
Triste não ser fluente em inglês e perder um conteúdo tão bacana 😥
Tadinha! Eu traduzo pra tu: TEMPO NÃO EXISTE!
What about time dilitation?
It's used to track moments😉
time doesn't exsist, clocks exsist
What is clocks?
@@LughSummerson what is 'is' ?
time or clock....all the same......no difference
Change is a normal part of life and being able to manage your time well os key for being productive in 2019.
*You are omnipresent.*
@@kobinsadvance I HAVE THAT TITLE
@@mayorgeneralramirez1997 So you are the admin of that channel?
Nobody is a machine to be productive..........just live the life...........not be a production in life
@@kobinsadvance No but I'm a deity
Ok, but your lecture is entirely based on the assumption that the hole universe is going to crunch at some point in "time" putting an end on it, but I don't think this is the most accepted hipotheses in phisics nowadays, so you cannot treat time as if it was an object with measures, begining and end, and I think the concept of a begining is also not fully understood, since that based on the theory, the big bang is not te begining of everything, but the begining of the/this universe
Big Crunch? We in 2019 already man
Exactly what I thought!
What do you mean ?
Time exists
@Internet If time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go
@Ken If time did not exist.........we do not too
Ok dude, time doesn’t exist 👍
@Hakostrofik If time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go
This video is 13 minutes and 19 seconds long. It is a measure of time and it is not subjective even if no one views it.
The only germaine comment I've read so far, though it's early. Your winning ;)
@Ada Vanja yes, I misplet sum wirds.
To begin with, I have hayed watches and flocks as long as I can remember. They have restrected my life enormously. In my mind, my "time" is what I do when I do it. I love from an event to event, but not by the clock. I have always been an oddball, a kind of freak. Still, with all that, I went to school, studies in the university and got my degree. With no watch. With no time, just a series of events following each other in a smooth path. As I grow older, time jaa lost its meaning completely. I am my own mistress to do what I want when I want, no time needed.
I think Einstein has some ois idea of time being just a fraction of factors in the Universe and in ota movements. I have created me a space where there is no time, no day or night, nothing that must be done at exact moments. Any action without time still causes a reaction that can have far-fetching impact in the Universe. Time is manmade. As se dare to step into these new concepts, it behind to make a lot of sence.
There are many tries who have no concept of time other than the sunrise and sunset. Everything between is not determined by hours and minutes and seconda, but by how much got done. That is my kind of timelessness. I get things done, or not, but there will be a new day to get things sorted. I am very happy in my timeless bubble, and even I get lost in it with pleasure, a real treat.
To me time is just one component in the spaces structures, but not in the sense we understand t. There is the great timelessness, also referred afterlife by some, a place standing still providing our souls to have a relief period every now and then. There are still some details I have to think over, but time is only a globule of things in the big scheme of things.
I have noticed that there are moments that time does stand still. I have had those experiences. And a lot happens in that spot without seconds ticking away. It is an awesome state of being, a lot happens in my space within a few moments, and the pollution time reåremand me of being lady and unproductive. That is so far from the truth.
Time, as I sen it, is just one part of the Universe works, but people had taken time (and money) as their leaders and they are in trouble with their waelth. Time is their mantra. Time goes fast and a lot has to be devided between issues. First let the issues simmer a while and then start to see, what time really is or isn't.
Einstein's tekes sense to me completely. Even though the are so things undeniable need of testing. I think the abstract of time is waste of though, hunters and fishermen do wake early to get in the proper mind art.
There is a lot to learn about time, even humans have their inner core.
Sublime🙏
Great just so true! Thanks :)
The big bang "Theory"
each tedtalk is timed. Wait.. time does not exist....
If time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go
If time isn't real, why are you not 60 hmmmm
Turkish subtitles should be added
I need a translate 😭
"time doesn't exist" .....
while a countdown clock is flashing in his face telling him to wrap it up.
@calholi Nobody here proved that "Time doesn't exist". The guy in the video was telling us "We the people create time on ourselves & by ourselves & for ourselves"
@@manujohn99 We didn't create it... we observe it happening. Just like we didn't create water turning to ice when it freezes. But we can time it while it's happening. The way we measure time and temperature- ect. is made up; but time passing is a thing, no matter how you try to redefine it.
@calholli if people from ancient times did not create time, then who did?.........Its the same people who observed it........created time out of it, while it's happening. So don't say "We didn't create it".........of course you didn't create time but you & me do things through time, which means we strengthen the time which is already created from the past
@@manujohn99 Again... No one created time. Not now, and not in the past. You can't create something that was already happening long before humans were even a species. That's like saying humans created rain, even though it rained on the dinosaurs long before we existed.
@calholli so you are saying that if we turn-off all of the time, clocks, watches, digital time & what not related to time in the world...........there still is time???? If there still is time...then who is running that time???? Tell me the answers
I believe he is close but not quite there. It seems to me that time is an emergent property of mass and change.The notion of emergent functions or properties is not entirely wel understood. But a common recent example is that of mind from brain. Mind does not exist without a working brain (sofar as I know). In the same way, time makes no sense without something changing.
The social construct that we live by is the units of measurement used. Currently it is primarily seconds, minutes and hours. But those are relatively recent creations, and even now are not universally used Until recently (in the human timeline) we had no fundamental, objective basis for any of this. Now we use an atomic clock. But that is only convention too A sidereal based year and lunar based month could provide a universal experience. But theyt are not generally used, leading to multiple systems for both, and confusion.
There are other significant units. Some are beyond our experience directly. Others are almost too long to experience but we do because of secondary impact. Seasons determine climate and crops so we have many elaborate ways to mark them. Cycles of our sun around the galaxy may have significnase when we pass throught the galactic plane and experience disruption of Oort cloud bodies that result in extinctions. Perhaps there are cultural cycles with their own scales like the rise and fall of countries and religions.
DI don't think the distinction I'm making affects his conclusions in a significant way. Does that mean they are constructs too? lol
In Short, time is thought..........& you just expressed your thoughts on time, through time & for time
Just as we can time travel. If we really put are minds too it ..
@WJ We already are travelling through time.........now you wanna double travel through time backwards or forwards........no way.........its like if I told you to eat an orange, & you ate it. Now I ask you to eat the same orange again, its not possible for you to eat the same orange, again because you already ate it. You could have another orange which is not eaten so that you can eat it. So you can't make an already eaten orange whole again.......so you can't time travel backwards or fast forward time travel to the future......you can only travel through time the same way we all are travelling through time.......no difference.
Time is man made!
Hello sir
Nice Doctor Who reference
Alan Watts...
"Bigbang" durp
Imagine a Namba lain!!!
Time is 4th dimension, which we can’t not see
@Arun but we can see time
This doesn’t make any sense time is time lol
Time is you, me & everyone else
I didn't watch this video or did I? 😁
Amazing 😍👏
this video doesnt last 13:19 minutes
This is amazing very inspiring I love this
Read the vedas to know more
- I'm tantalized, and very keen to understand, but I'm still confused. Please help me (and probably thousands of other viewers) figure this out...
◘ Give me three specific, practical daily-life examples that, with 12-year-old simplicity, illustrate how we could behave differently because of watching this video.
◘ By simple, I don't mean 'theory' and 'principle'. I mean practical talk about specific home activities, work activities, relationships, earning ability. Ordinary things.
Time is YOU.
there is no time or cells change.
And Jesus saves
You got it. We are each a path of time discovering the truths in matters. I left two big statements in comments on this video thread, please tell me if you can see it Inquisitor. Thank You.
Such foolishness that's unscientific
People seeing this video are expected to leave scientific knowledge behind If not they might get hurt
we are all already hurt........that's why we are all here..........genius
We are the masters of time, and Jesus the master of changing.
Believe and receive.
receive poop
@@manujohn99 no the holy spirit
Good😍😍
What a waste of time.
you even wasted your thoughts coz Time is Thought & Thought is Time
Time is manmade...
Yes time is people-made but without time, we don't even realize that we are existing.........we can only know others through time
Worst Ted ever
Rubbish
Time is just a man made construct.
Yes & if time did not exist.........we do not too........means we go with the time........anywhere time goes.....we go
First
The end of time is when the universe stops moving.
No no......end of time is end of people..........the universe will always be fineeeeeee even without us in it.
Time never existed and people are discovering it now....but it's all the knowledge they have got from our vedas ...which mentions time does not exist
Vedas represents the knowledge and the knowledge does not belong to anyone.
@Halady If time does not exist then the vedas also did not exist.........genius
@@manujohn99 give me a break from your stupidity ...OK? ??
Can you define this now in which people are discovering time does not exist?
@Alfonso Nobody here proved that "Time doesn't exist". The guy in the video was telling us "We the people create time on ourselves & by ourselves & for ourselves"
Time does exist and it always did. Genesis the first chapter of the word says
" And God made the two great lights-the greater light to rule the day and the lesser light to rule the night-and the stars." as you can see in the verse ,which by the way was the first week of creation, God made Night and day. And that's" time" simplified. Now the hours and minutes it's all manmande. But it's that simple. Bible is the greatest book , it's the living book. Thats y I love it. You atheist gonna hate that idc
uhm no, it says that god made the planets. the night and day are just results of this process. but when the bible was written, they didn't know about planets or stars - such as the sun - and so, they couldn't explain it like that
@@aabandreea hush! The scripture is right in your face quoted jus read . It said "TWO GREAT LIGHTS" last time I checked there are way more than 2 planets. this scripture is referring to the sun and the moon obviously. Not the planets. But there are other scriptures where they are mentioned . Thank u
@@waltwilliams1997 Yes, sure. In this scripture of yours it is said that he created "the lesser light to rule the night", which is false information. The moon does NOT produce light, but merely reflects the sun's light. It's called science. Search it up, you might find that you lived in lies your whole life.
@@aabandreea the moon does produce light !!! I even use the light from the moon to see when it's pitch dark outside when I'm camoing. The moon abosolutely produces a lesser light! And second of all nothing in the Bible is false information. Science is lies! That's why so many atheist like you connect with it . Every creation has a creator remember that. I'm not going back and forth with an atheist it's pointless . Have a good day. " The moon doesn't produce light" got to be kidding
Genesis 1 verse 14 says 'they will serve as signs for seasons and for days and years' that sounds like time to me, it's how the first calendars came about. Time exists in the physical plane.