The Most Legendary Rye Ever vs $75 Shelfer | Booker's Rye vs Jack Daniel's Barrel Proof Rye

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 29 жов 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 82

  • @gknepper01
    @gknepper01 2 місяці тому +10

    "I do this all the time and don't appreciate you questioning my methods" said no social sipper ever. :)

  • @joewinckowski
    @joewinckowski 2 місяці тому +9

    I’m in the suburbs of Chicago and Jack Daniels Barrel Proof Rye is typically $62.99-$65.99 which makes it a super awesome value!

    • @motohead077
      @motohead077 2 місяці тому +1

      It just dropped to $60 here in S. NV recently, but always get 5-10% off, so really $54-57.
      Found a store that did a pick of the BP Rye last month, at JD in TN. Don't know if they will up charge for that (like ECBP), but guessing they will, since had to goto TN & also never seen 1 of those in town.

    • @100puremustard5
      @100puremustard5 2 місяці тому

      ​@@motohead077Yup, $59.99 on the shelf in NoCal

  • @jamesfenton147
    @jamesfenton147 2 місяці тому +7

    I got excited when I saw this thumbnail. I have a JDSBBPR that is so good that it beats out Handy imo. Never had the Bookers Rye, though. The JDs are the best available whiskey on the market.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +2

      We’ve had JD ryes that have easily been better than any Thomas H Handy that we’ve ever tried so we’re right there with you!

  • @ChrisJaubert
    @ChrisJaubert Місяць тому +1

    I absolutely LOVE how little shit Erin takes from Josh....LOL...Feels very familiar to my situation at home.

  • @chrishughes9202
    @chrishughes9202 Місяць тому

    That Crazy Special Whiskey Thing on a t-shirt.

  • @travisrobeson306
    @travisrobeson306 2 місяці тому +4

    Josh, don't get her to bring out the Bro!! LOL!

  • @T_Nastie
    @T_Nastie 2 місяці тому +3

    The jack is awesome, one of my special pours. Mine is 138.5 proof

  • @WhiskeyFan
    @WhiskeyFan 2 місяці тому +2

    CREAM! Cash Rules Everything Around Me

  • @justinwilliams7637
    @justinwilliams7637 2 місяці тому

    This video makes me so happy! Glad you guys got to experience the Bookers Rye in a blind. And Josh…I’ve got more where that came from! 👊🥃

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +1

      Thank you for making the video happen brother! Such a fun one!

  • @MrRockingRilo
    @MrRockingRilo Місяць тому +1

    Last I saw the Booker's it was $3K. I'll take the Jack. From Bonded to SBBP to 10/12yr. to Coy Hill they have it all across the price and proof spectrum. I do love the Booker's 2023-04 Storyteller. Great bottle for $100. Never been able to touch the rye however.

  • @BuckMcAntlerson
    @BuckMcAntlerson Місяць тому +1

    Love the (eye)glasses 👓

  • @arbeckWA
    @arbeckWA 2 місяці тому +11

    I have the Booker's Rye as one of the top 10 whiskies I've ever had. It's not necessary because the flavor of it is the greatest thing in the world. But it is one of the most unique whiskies I've had. The Jack Daniels is delicious, but I can probably pull a half dozen things off my shelf that have a similar profile. But if I wanted the Booker's Rye, I don't have anything that is really similar.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому

      It’s definitely something else. Unique in and of itself and even more unique in the realm of ryes. It’s pretty firmly in my Top 10 as well.

  • @JimMatthews-nr6xc
    @JimMatthews-nr6xc 2 місяці тому +5

    If I could find Bookers rye for $300 a bottle, I would buy a few cases.

  • @kamahhl
    @kamahhl Місяць тому

    I agree with Josh, these can easily influence each other with the long finish and the high proof. Dont take it personal Erin 😂

  • @drgallup
    @drgallup 2 місяці тому +1

    JD BP rye was very hard to find for awhile but now I'm seeing them on the shelf at reasonable prices. I have one but haven't opened it yet. I'll never see the Booker's. But the best bottle I ever bought was Kentucky Owl 11 yr rye Batch 01. I paid about $130 for it and it was worth 3 times that.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому

      Those Kentucky Owl ryes were phenomenal for sure!

  • @johng5710
    @johng5710 2 місяці тому +1

    JDSBBP one of the best, if not the best, values in whiskey. I actually just found a 139 proofer recently

  • @dbealby
    @dbealby 2 місяці тому +2

    Don't question my methods -- oof!

  • @TheWhiskeyRambler
    @TheWhiskeyRambler Місяць тому

    If looks could kill “Bro”! You in trouble 😂

  • @Nole1992
    @Nole1992 2 місяці тому +1

    Erin at a Wu-Tang show would be classic 😂😂

  • @brettheiner7125
    @brettheiner7125 29 днів тому

    It’s pretty rare I like a Booker’s anything, but I love JDSBBPs including the rye. Very rare to get a sub-par bottle.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  28 днів тому +1

      We’re with you on Booker’s bourbons. Not our jam. This one-time release rye is a whole different animal though.

  • @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice
    @tommysimpsonandtheloadeddice 2 місяці тому

    Oh man that look Josh gave the camera! Hilarious

  • @Urban-Explorer365
    @Urban-Explorer365 Місяць тому +1

    Part of Booker’s pricing model is the story they have. I doubt the pure juice worth much of the price.

  • @tylerboggs612
    @tylerboggs612 2 місяці тому

    Hell yeah! I love these videos!

  • @Tranzekno
    @Tranzekno 2 місяці тому +2

    Erin is spicy like a rye

  • @edwardrice146
    @edwardrice146 2 місяці тому

    I love the JD SBBS Rye....need the bigboy pants for that stuff....Going through a bottle of the WT Rare Breed Rye which is another great rye about 16 proof points lower.

  • @enotrilogy
    @enotrilogy Місяць тому

    Hopefully there will be a Booker's Rye II someday

  • @showenough
    @showenough 2 місяці тому

    Bookers LE Rye is the best whiskey I have ever had too date. Hard to do it in a blind as I don’t have a bottle but it was and always will be stellar!

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому

      Tell ‘em! That bottle is something else!

  • @noworldforeric
    @noworldforeric 2 місяці тому

    Not "I don't know this music" lmaoooo
    It's actually HILARIOUS how opposite you two are.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому

      They say opposites attract, and it’s definitely true with us. Cheers!

  • @thomashardy1851
    @thomashardy1851 Місяць тому +1

    Just got a JDSBBP for $40 for labor day. It's so tasty.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Місяць тому +1

      That’s a steal! Congrats!

    • @motohead077
      @motohead077 Місяць тому

      Nice, the lowest I've seen those is $47.59, but it's a shitty barrel & not even worth it, at that price. They still haven't sold them all & got them in May or before. The 1792 Full Proof SiB Pick I have is much better & paid $45 total.
      Have not given up though. Want to get a good JD BP that everyone talks about.
      Had 2 barrels of the BP Rye & both of those are much better. The BP bourbon seems very young. There is zero spice, zero oak/wood & tons of alcohol burn on finish. It's just a flat sweet palate. It's likey just a JD Black barrel at Brl Prf, but 1 of the upper floor barrels.

  • @justinvandee9428
    @justinvandee9428 2 місяці тому

    I have a Jack Daniel's Rye store pick that is outstanding. Glad I snagged 3 before sold out. Cheers 🥃

  • @geno816
    @geno816 Місяць тому

    I should grab a bookers rye

  • @nickp5511
    @nickp5511 2 місяці тому

    Great pours! Local store has the Booker’s for 5,000.00

  • @JackBass9
    @JackBass9 Місяць тому +1

    Josh you must have a big wallet. I do not understand spending 300 on a bottle let alone 1700. My channel would be the frugal sipper 😂.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Місяць тому +1

      It’s all in what you prioritize. There are a select few bottles I’d spend that on, not because I value the whiskey that much, but because I value sharing that whiskey with special company to make special memories. Not too dissimilar to splurging on a nice meal with special company from time to time.

  • @WhiskyForBeginners
    @WhiskyForBeginners 2 місяці тому

    If the JD SBBP rye is half as good as the bourbon, then it's gotta be fine whisky. I'm a bourbon guy, and only want rye whisky now and again, but that Jack Single Barrel Barrel Proof rye is on my wish list. And right now I'm drinking Hard Truth Sweet Mash Rye, so proof and rye don't scare me. 🥃🙂

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +2

      Funnily enough we both think the JDSBBP rye is twice as good as the JDSBBP Tennessee whiskey. And I’m a bourbon guy.

  • @gimmebbq
    @gimmebbq Місяць тому +1

    Ha!! Need one more zero....Bookers Rye is 3000.00

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  Місяць тому +1

      It’s actually fallen down to the mid teens with the softening whiskey market, but was $300 when it released. It’s funny to think so many of us passed it by at that price given how rare it ultimately would be.

  • @Brad_Boersma
    @Brad_Boersma 2 місяці тому

    Make sure you diversify ya’ll’s bonds!
    - WuTang Financial

  • @LP23D6
    @LP23D6 2 місяці тому

    Rye Now you got my attention!

  • @dbealby
    @dbealby 2 місяці тому

    That Bookers goes for $1.8-$2k. Amazing just to blind it to JD Rye

  • @SmokedTamaleAlan
    @SmokedTamaleAlan 2 місяці тому

    Yikes, this one had Erin felling some kinda way huh?😂😂😂

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +1

      😂😂 all in good fun. Cheers and thanks for watching!

  • @877-MASH-NOW
    @877-MASH-NOW 2 місяці тому

    WHISKEY CHEERS 😎

  • @sweetsinnndy5201
    @sweetsinnndy5201 2 місяці тому

    There is no chance I would spend $300 for any liquor, I can afford it, but it's principal. Have not had any kind of Jack since I was 18.

    • @brettheiner7125
      @brettheiner7125 29 днів тому

      Go back and try the while Jack line-up above 07 - it is amazing and tremendous value. Not your daddy’s Jack!

  • @eymerichinquisitore9022
    @eymerichinquisitore9022 27 днів тому

    I dared to buy the JD single barrel barrel strength with 64.5 ABV, without diluting it is only fire on the palate and compressed aromas on the nose. I really don't understand the obsessive mania for certain cask strengths. 🤔

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  27 днів тому

      Could just be that single barrel or could be a palate preference (or personal acclimation) thing. Some folks enjoy hot sauce and others think ketchup is too spicy. Whiskey isn’t much different.

  • @Slowthefunkdown
    @Slowthefunkdown Місяць тому

    $ $ BOOKERS YALLLLLLL

  • @dneuens
    @dneuens 2 місяці тому +5

    Jeez, Josh makes a reasonable point @14:40 and Erin is all daggers. Yikes.

    • @Nole1992
      @Nole1992 2 місяці тому +1

      Don’t tell Erin how to drink 😂😂

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +2

      😂😂 had to rewatch to see what you were referencing as we’d forgotten. We got a kick out of that part!

    • @tomhalstead8935
      @tomhalstead8935 2 місяці тому +1

      I’m surprised it survived editing. Erin and Josh are a lot more honest than I am.

  • @dylanroskop5134
    @dylanroskop5134 2 місяці тому +3

    I think Josh knew what this match up was prior to the reveal. No doubt. Cheers y'all!!

  • @kyliejohn3813
    @kyliejohn3813 2 місяці тому

    😂

  • @johng6350
    @johng6350 2 місяці тому

    I'm about to lay down some (hopefully constructive) criticism, so either brace yourselves, or delete this comment now. Erin, your point about not questioning your method is valid. Heck, it's the whole point of having you both on the channel, different methods, different opinions. However, Josh's comment about long finishes and possible cross-contamination is also extremely valid. Especially in the wake of your comment about the whiskeys starting to taste the same. Your casual dismissal of it caused me to disregard your final judgment on these whiskeys.
    *Most importantly*, while I don't actually know what is going on in your guys' heads, so maybe (hopefully) this is a nothingburger for you...I found that whole exchange (and the following one about opinions) to be very awkward and uncomfortable to watch. To the point that I started skipping ahead through the video. Because while this may be part of the 'Stuff' in your channel title, I can't help but recommend that any kind of personal drama, whether real or perceived, should just be edited out.

    • @stuffandwhiskey
      @stuffandwhiskey  2 місяці тому +2

      That’s fair if that’s how you feel. We laughed about that exchange afterwards, and if it were serious it wouldn’t have been on the video at all, but at the end of the day this is just whiskey. Erin has her processes, I have mine, and it’s okay if we disagree in our book. It happens more often on our livestreams and you can clearly tell it’s something we’re having fun with and neither of us take it too seriously.

  • @jameslenaburg4378
    @jameslenaburg4378 2 місяці тому

    No way Bookers is worth 300 😮 JDBP Rye is excellent and under $70 here.