Full interview: Levin says Idaho suspect Kohberger murder narrative is 'weird' | Banfield
Вставка
- Опубліковано 2 сер 2024
- TMZ executive producer Harvey Levin joins NewsNation's Ashleigh Banfield to discuss Bryan Kohberger, the man accused of killing four college students in Idaho. Harvey says he's not doubting the evidence but he's also not convinced by the prosecutor's theories. "I'm not saying he didn't do it," Levin said on "Banfield." "I'm saying the circumstances are boldly weird here."
#idahofour #byrankohberger #banfield
Ashleigh Banfield is the definitive authority on the nation’s biggest true crime stories. A veteran award-winning journalist, Ashleigh brings a sharp focus to the crime stories gripping America, distilling facts and analyzing context in a way which captures viewers’ interests and imaginations. No one knows the prosecution and the defendants’ cases better than BANFIELD, all the while keeping the victim at the heart of every story we tell - just another reason NewsNation is truly News for All America.
Weeknights at 10pm/9C. #Banfield
NewsNation is your source for fact-based, unbiased news for all America.
More from NewsNation: www.newsnationnow.com/
Get our app: trib.al/TBXgYpp
Find us on cable: trib.al/YDOpGyG
How to watch on TV or streaming: trib.al/Vu0Ikij
Just because he was never caught for a crime doesn’t mean he never committed one.
The same can be said about the roommates.
After watching a zillion true crime cases I can assure you people, he did not commit this brutal crime! It was too personal for it to be BK. It had to be someone else a lot more comfortable with the house and also connected to the victims. There are many other people who it could have been. LE needs to start looking into the other people immediately once BK is cleared due to insufficient evidence and no connection at all to the house nor any of the people.
@@ManiCUREdwhat state do you practice law enforcement in? Or which government do you work for with all your knowledge of BK if he did this or not? Just odd for LE to focus on bk and weird he bought a k-bar an Dickies jumper but neither was found during the searches or his apartment or parents house!
So true!!! I always am surprised when people consider people good, just because they don’t have a criminal record! Because, that never means that someone hasn’t committed crimes! It just means they haven’t been caught committing crimes.
I agree
He was never caught before
Harvey is a gossip, not a homicide investigator.
Playing telephone with the evidence Is investigator like?
4 intoxicated people who wer on the verge of sleep an would NEVER EVER think wat was about to happen would happen an so far as never done any crime before he was a weirdo who has slowly turned him to madness
@@amberf8952 I was just saying he's a gossip guy. His new business is true crime
This is ridiculous. Have these people not been following the case? How stupid these people are. One more time, PROSECUTION SAID THERE WAS NO, AGAIn NOOOOO STALKING THAT HAPPENED!!!!!!!!!!!
@@avjam these people? You mean the ones who think he couldn't have done this right?
"Somebody who has never committed a murder before"
Like every killer in history who had never killed anyone before until they did?
So you find the results the police claims to be factual?
@@CelticRuneSingerabsolutely
No I really don't believe it was him. There are so many other people with motives.
Exactly! This would not be the first crime either if he was not caught
@@ManiCUREdSame. House was a known drug house in the area.
The whole thing is wierd. Always has been. Multiple reasons why many people are not buying the BK did it alone for no reason.
The only people who kill for no reason a crazy people and serial killers. Maybe it wasn't just him. In the movie scream there was more than one killer.
The people who say this usually have a ridiculous theory that a 100 pound roommate did it and never left any evidence on their phone or anywhere else. And, of course, there’s also no reason in that scenario. There’s no reason anyone would do it so it would be impossible to find someone who had a reason to do it
Weird MRS Berger hasn't showed her face.
When a crime is solved correctly, it is very simple. What makes this seem complex and complicated, is that people are combining false news reports, true facts, and fiction from the internet. That makes a giant mess.
@@JeffSherlock I think this whole thing is a source of entertainment to people. I’m fascinated by what actually happened which is why I read the PCA like 10 times but I’m not interested in anything else that people say until the trial..then the whole truth will come out. A lot of people seem to be much more entertained by speculating. They threw all these wild theories out there before Bryan’s arrest and they kept going after his arrest..I think they’ll keep going after he’s convicted too. The actual facts and evidence don’t really matter…
How do we know that he hasn't done anything like this before?
IKR? It may not be 0-60. He may have had practice elsewhere.
He had taken several steps before the murders and graduated to a killer, he had been stalking that house and fantasizing about the murders for 6 months.
Because they already looked into it and could find nothing pinning him to it.
He would have a record?
@@Jmango9988lies
There actually isnt a lot of evidence (what has been revealed to the public) that attaches BK to the crime. There is no evidence that he stalked the house, in fact the prosecution has said that he did not stalk (Idaho def of stalk) the victims. His cell phone pinged in the area 12 times. Moscow Idaho and Pullman Washigton are only 15 minutes from each other, it is relativly normal for him or anyone to go between the 2 cities. especially being a college student, WA has legal WEED and ID does not. He was not nearby to look at the sky, his alibi was that he was at wawai park which is in Washington NOT that he was nearby looking at stars, the DNA is touch(transferrable) DNA not regular DNA (bodily fluids). Experts got the car year wrong, Experts say that the cell data that is present does not necessarily put him in the area, if there was a clear phot /video of the car we would have had him right away because the plates were PA plates. and only a back plate. there are plenty of other people who had more motive than BK did.
Lol you're so off it's ridiculous
@@el34glo59 how so? courtroom discussions from prosecution have said he did not stalk them. touch DNA is not widely used because it is often wrong. and he never pinged on their wifi (That we know of) so his being in Moscow 12 times doesnt mean anything. cell tower data can not say where he was in location to the house. so maybe you need to adjust your way of thinking... and there is a possibility it is him.. i can say that.. i have a brain that can comprehend a bigger picture.. but the evidence provided does not by any means prove he is the killer.
People not familiar with the case or can’t hear well the prosecutor himself said that he did not stalk the house, look it up his name is Bill Thompson. I can’t believe they are still saying this knowing it’s not factual, damn
None of the victims were stalked. The house was not stalked. Kohberger did not stalk anyone.
Yep that is exactly what ole Bill stated
Bill Thompson said he was not stalking the house or victims because he cannot prove the legal definition of stalking. But he never said that Bryan was not watching those girls and/or that house for weeks before he killed them!
Stalking has a very specific legal definition. The victim(s) must be aware of the actions a person is taking in order for it to constitute stalking. He could still have been watching the house and/or victim(s) without their knowledge. So no stalking is correct, but it doesn't mean he wasn't watching.
@@kirsty916 except there’s no connection between Bryan kohberger and that house or anybody associated with that house period end of story. Come to find out Steve Goncalves is stating the prosecution is have trouble connecting him to any of the victims, but your saying it’s a technicality and it’s the definition of the word and they got the right guy. Make sure you get ahold of the prosecution and show them your evidence
61 yrs old. I've never ever seen or heard of anyone, accused of such heinous crimes, not say anything and just sit there stone faced.
If I didn't do this, and someone was calling me guilty, I wouldn't be able to contain or control myself. I would be publicly and privately lashing out my innocence.
Jus say'n
You’ve obviously never been to court with a lawyer 🤦🏼
The only evidence is the touch DNA that is all. Also the prosecutor admitted that he DID NOT STALK THEM. His info is all wrong.
Can somebody please inform Harvey & Ashleigh that neither law enforcement nor the prosecution (or any other official) has ever said that Bryan went to the house numerous times and just watched. The PCA simply states that his phone pinged off the same tower that the house uses 12 times. Cell towers have a range of up to 45 miles, and Bryan only lived 10 miles from 1122 King Rd. The PCA even states that at the time of one of the pings, police do not believe he was in Moscow. That just proves that his phone can ping off that tower when he is not in the area. Not sure why they would include that in their own PCA. Kind of stupid.
Didn’t his phone try and connect to the Wi-Fi inside the home while he was nearby on occasions?
Msm pushing msm narrative.
Such an important point. All of the pings were from when Kobgerger was in Pullman. The Wawawai Park, is some 25 miles or more to the West of Pullman, not the east. These TV boneheads just do not get that.
@JeffSherlock well, we don't know where he was when his phone pinged off that tower, but this stalking narrative has to be put to an end. There is no proof of it, and Bill Thompson (the prosecutor) said in court that Bryan was NOT stalking them. We do know that he was in Moscow for other things, such as the pool party he attended. I'm sure his phone pinged off that tower then.
@loislane9826 Kaylee's dad said Bryan's phone "touched their wifi." We don't know exactly what he meant. Was he just referring to the phone pings? Maybe confused on what a ping was? Or is there something else. We have no idea at this point. And, even if his phone did try to connect to the wifi in the house, that does not prove he committed m*rder.
There is NOT a lot of evidence in this case !!!!!!
Because the Feds. They arrested Xana’s mother and Maddie’s stepmother. Both snitched on the Aryan Brotherhood leading to multiple significant arrests. This was retaliation
There isn’t a lot that has been divulged to the public. You have no clue how much evidence they have or don’t have.
That we know of. There is no way we know all the details
Exactly, scene messed with for too many hours....before reporting@@tammymorgan9870
How do you know? Lol There has been a gag order from the beginning. They hadn't even done the investigation.
A lot of people do not believe that Brian did it at all, and I am one of those people
Same. I think they wrote off those surviving roommates as suspects too quickly.
Wow! What are yall smoking?
@nikkibobby17 if you follow the court proceedings you learn a lot of things which cast enormous doubt on the states case. These guys aren't following it closely at all and are speculating on things that have already been demonstrated to be false
@@nikkibobby17what are you smoking!? You should really know what you’re talking about before showing the world you have no clue about this case 🤦🏼
What evidence❓
Exactly. All the evidence they have is circumstantial. In the PCA it was stated that Bryan did NOT stalk the roommates. The BIG QUESTION is.... Why did Dylan and Bethany take 8+ HOURS to eventually call 911 from a house drenched in blood everywhere, a house that smelt of death and blood and bodies? The police smelt the stench the second they entered the house via the first floor though the bodies were on second floor. Why didn't the surviving roommates smell anything. Why didn't they see any blood? SMH. There's more but I've wasted enough time for now.
Prosecutor says none of the victims were stalked.
on social media but that is the opposite of what the gps on his car says including the night of morning of and all around the time of the murders. along with 12 other times in the 9 days prior. he's guilty
@@djohny-ne3ggthe cast report hasn’t been finalized…all that was a generalization based on a wide range…not near the house…highly inaccurate…they didn’t even know how to open the reports…look at the last couple hearings with mowry was a joke and sy ray showing he’s in opposite direction
officer Payne admitted out of the thousand hours of video footage they don’t have Bryan’s car on video once, not once so I’m not sure where your information is coming from. We do know three out of the 12 times his phone pinged the tower that covered 1122 Queen Rd., He wasn’t there, but it doesn’t matter because the prosecution said he wasnt stalking them, there’s no connection between Bryan and that house and anybody who lived there
But he surveiled the house. Its not the same s stalking. Especially when its stated in a courtroom from a prosecutor with a law degree.
@@user-si7ch4mh2mor no evidence connecting him other than the planted sheath..
No stalking!!!! They’ve said it themselves!!!! Wake up!
Bingo!!!
BT said the PCA is no longer relevant
Let that sink in
Brian Goldberger has never released any statements
So when the TMZ guy says Brian said he was near the crime scene
Is total BS
@@user-wn3cs5tg9p It is in trial paperwork He Said to fbi or LE investigator
I can’t count how many times I’ve seen this comment. It’s you who are slumbering. According to Idaho law, stalking requires that those being stalked be aware of the situation. In this case, the one(s) being stalked-iMO, Maddie and perhaps Kaylee-didn’t know what BK was up to, which was illegal surveillance, what Peeping Tom’s do to gaze upon their targets with lust and to learn their habits. BK was creeping and peeping, probably drooling at the luscious fruit he could never get to even date, let alone to f**k. How do you pro-burghers explain the 12 times his phone pinged off the nearest cell tower to the house, all but one late a night? What was he doing in the Moscow area so many times at night? Shopping? Show us at least one receipt. Dining out? Again how about a receipt or a witness? Was no one else in the restaurant? How about the server? Wake up! You don’t have a clue! 😎😎😎
Does he not know that bill Thompson already said there was no evidence that Bryan stalked the victims ?
Thompson only said that because he cannot prove stalking by its legal definition. It does not mean that BK was not doing surveillance on those girls on the regular!
@@hotpinkthreadSteve Goncalves recently sent email to attorney Andrew D Meyers, who featured Howard Blum on his YT channel. In the email. Steve G writes: "WE HAVE ONE PRIMARY QUESTION, REGARDING BLUM'S BOOK. WHAT EVIDENCE SUPPORTS THE THEORY, THAT BK WAS FOCUSED ON MADDIE MAY?"..."IN OUR RECENT MEETING WITH THE PROSECUTION TEAM, THEY EXPRESSED DIFFICULTY IN ESTABLISHING DIRECT CONNECTIONS BETWEEN BK AND THE VICTIMS."
"Stalking" involves threats or multiple unwanted advances. He didn't do that, he surveilled them. More than likely, they never knew who he was.
@@adamkail4449 I'm sorry but there is absolutely no evidence that he surveilled them. The phone pinging from the same tower with a 45 mile reach when he lives only 10 miles away is not evidence .
@@hotpinkthread Thompson cannot prove anything .
How did he kill that many people and not get one drop of blood in his car?
Exactly... The trail of blood that is non existent from incredibly bloody crime scene
His sister reported he cleaned it with bleach in PA right after his arrest.
@@matildagreene1744🤦🏼😆😂
He was stalking the victims if you believe the prosecution? 🤣🤣 the prosecutor made it clear that there was no stalking and no connection!
Known at that time …
The prosecutor never said there was no connection. The defense team said that, the prosecutor did say no stalking. The gag order was put into place long before the investigation was wrapped up. They haven't even hit the entire discovery dead line.
Why are you so-called professional journalists repeating debunked rumors? He DID NOT stalk the victims.
One person goes through a 3 story house and kills 4 people without a scratch on himself or forensic evidence? A top military man couldn't do that.
Why doesn't the news include the other oddities about the case. Some of the parents of the victims are heavy drug addicts. One of Kohberger's lawyers represented a drug case of one of the parents recently. There's a few weird debt/drug problems in that scene.
That town could have some kind of weird drug/cult problem.
Right! I think the crime was committed by someone they knew very well and trusted. The layout is known and moving freely in the dark at a fast pace. The dog not attacking at the sight of an unknown person in the middle of the night with a face mask comitting assault then murder?!
Did you see the interview with the neighbor that said 30 minutes before the murders took place she saw 4 guys on the back porch smoking. @@Vrin137
@@Vrin137 maybe a group of people. Maybe they were drugged first?
More weirdness...the delay in reporting, the demolition of the crime scene/ house, 4 people felled in 14 minutes etc.
Dylan’s hinky tale....
I have to agree with this man’s statement
One barely in-shape person goes through a 3 story house and cleanly killing 4 people without a scratch on himself? A marine couldn't do that.
Less than 14
@@smallwang7maybe it was Brent Kopacka?
Confirmation bias isn’t a good look. No connection, nothing in his car or office or apartment. Not stalking out of the mouth of Bill Thompson. Sy Ray’s expert opinion. Touch DNA on a moveable object. Justice for these victims is not the firing squad for a defendant with this much reasonable doubt.
True, and what happened to the other 3 male DNA
bunny thinks like rabbit 😂
Same car as his on victim’s street, DNA on part of weapon left at house, cell phone pings going to and from Moscow, Bryan admitting that he wasn’t home at 4:00am that Sunday, Dylan’s description of a tall but athletically lean male, Bryan wearing latex gloves out and about afterwards, and much more evidence to come. Allegedly proof of Bryan purchasing the weapon that was used etc etc.
Also Sy was paid for his “expert opinion”. There’s a division of the FBI dedicated to cellular analysis that disagrees and they have no reason to be biased like Sy does.
@@curtf9813 I hear ya, I do, but he is actually working pro bono. Thank you for discussing respectfully!
Something seems off
For sure. A lot seems off! I also notice most media go with narratives and some persons on here don’t really care for Levins POV but what he’s saying doesn’t seem far fetched either.
No many things seem off.
Something stinks in this investigation for sure.
The one very interesting thing in this case is the estrangement of Kaylee and her bf and the fact that she made an exception to come back on this particular night. One last time ever but that couldn’t mean anything right
@@MrShane82 An even more interesting thing is she was given a stern warning on the same night the murders took place and it was on camera. Jack S said they're going to get you for this!!! and that's what prompted her to say to her friend "what did you say to adam?" I told him everything.
There's no way in hell that this dialogue has nothing at all to do with what happened. BK was never involved in this shit and he should be released.
Harvey your imagination has run away with you.
How so? Explain
@@CelticRuneSinger it's what he does. It's his new angle true crime. He'spromoting his latest endevor. True Crime is all over especially on UA-cam. Who cares about celebritie gossiping like they use to. You must be under 40
@@SHARON.I has anyone ever questioned his “knowledge” of the Oj case? He was friends,& that’s how he got the TMZ 😉
@@tracyhicks8441 knowledge?
He just likes to insert himself into everything for attention. He is annoying AF.
Prosecutor said he didnt stalk, and he supposedly did all this in 12 minutes? Cmon!
Now you’re an expert on murderers. 😂
He used to be a lawyer, fool 😂
Even more WEIRD...NO EVIDENCE AT ALL AGAINST HIM. Has noone watched the hearings???
no, people are in denial, they want bk to be guilty for the "told you so"
Yeah because his dna being on the knife sheath is no evidence 🤯🤣
@@katelynhernandez7998 Ian’s 2 other profiles and it’s touch DNA 🧬 if you knew the difference then you would not have made the comment, and it was on the metal clasp DNA degrades w/in a few hours they didn’t find it until they moved the bodies and it was a soup of makecDNA in that sorority house didn’t you see the body cam off 100’s of guys a week before in the house not knowing who or what lived their 🤦🏻
@@katelynhernandez7998you obviously know Nothing about touch dna 🤦🏼
@@Otis5115 that's literally how they changed him Jesus Christ y'all are a joke. DNA a shoe print and his car. Not to mention eye witnesses. Bffr 🤣😭🤦
How did the killer know no one in the house owned a gun?
The PCA would have mentioned Bryan DNA under the victim's fingernails rather than a few molecules on a sheath if they really had evidence against him.
The investigation was weeks old at that point. The gag order has been in affect from the beginning. None of us know what evidence there is but we know one thing, the DP is still on the table so they have evidence.
@@kristenpino4635we do know that they have no video of Brian’s car and no evidence of him stalking or being at the house so there’s that
@@Otis5115 I am very well aware there is no evidence of stalking. I was responding to the inquiry of why things were not known right away.
You to stop telling lies in this case
What about the cops? Have they done anything wrong in this case? No actually Payne admitted in court that it wasn't Bryan's car and the prosecutor Bill Thompson admitted that Bryan wasn't stalking them. So the people that pride themselves on facts are ignoring the facts.
The pca is full of lies.
Thank you!! People just ignoring the facts.
Payne never said that the car they have on camera on the the victim’s street isn’t Bryan’s car. Quit spreading misinformation to help Bryan. The car they labeled as “suspect vehicle 1” is the same make, model, approximate year, and color as Bryan’s..that hasn’t changed and won’t change. That’s all they know.
@@curtf9813 Doesn’t mean it’s his car. And they never confirmed it WAS his car. Just because it looks like his car doesn’t mean it is definitively his car. Unless they have his specific license plate on camera with him driving the car, can’t say it was absolutely BK.
@@Basbhat Yeah they can’t say that it wasn’t his car for the same reason they can’t say it was his car. But that’s pretty much all a person can do with video footage…even if they had a video of someone who looks like Bryan all they can say is that it looks like Bryan…not that it’s certainly him
How was he not covered in blood?
I saw and heard(that doesn’t say much aha obviously, I know) that he wore the dickies coveralls, and then disposed of them. They said they recovered the tag, but who knows. I just want the person/s who did this to be brought to justice.
He was never there
He had PLENTY of time to wash up and dispose of items. Just like he was doing putting his trash in The neighbors trash can. Who does that????
How do you know he wasn't?
@@Kay-fv7cw spot on. We don’t know.
America loves a conspiracy theory.
Because they usually wind up being true.
@@bulldaggerwatkins190 in the bigger scheme overall thats not true do some have some truth at times , yes, but thats not factually true
@@orlawalsh926 because the CIA totally didn’t kill JFK or sell cocaine and heroin to Americans to fund clandestine wars in SE Asia and South and Central America.
Uhhh...what?! He was no where near King Rd looking at the stars. He was in Wawaiwai Park which is in Washington, SW of Pullman. Can you people PLEASE get your facts straight and stop spreading lies! For God's sake. So frustrating.
I love that you brought Harvey on as a guest.I never knew that he was a lawyer. But Ashley, you are journalist.I feel like you're supposed to be neutral.And you're incredibly biased when it comes to Bryan Kohburger
Harvey was the guy outside on the “people’s court!” Sadly, my nana made me watch it everyday during the summer as a kid aha.
Plus he use to end every show with the outro of his mock mug shot and voice over saying “I’m a lawyer!”
Not sure if he still does, I haven’t watched TMZ for years!🤷🏻♀️
She is a joke!
Ashley’s always biased it is so funny. 😅
HAHAH HARVEY AINT THE FBI!!! GET real....
The first thing you got to figure out is how kohberger got to 1122 queen rd that morning and how did he leave. That’s not his car circling the house that morning, officer Payne admitted on the stand the don’t have Bryan car on any of the 1000 hours of footage period end of story, they don’t have him entering or leaving Moscow on video and if you point this out, you get called Bryan’s boyfriend, FN clowns, do you really think the FBI expert was wrong that it was a 2011 to 13 Hyundai ELANTRA at the crime scene that morning? GTFOH!! so you’re telling me Bryan picked out this house by random, and it has to be random because there’s no ties linking Bryan to that house or any of the victims in the house, there was no stalking the prosecution even said that, so after running from Pullman to Moscow he just picked this house and went in and killed four people at random and left with nobody’s DNA on himself in the house, so in 8 minutes he not only killed Ethan, xana, and Maddie, but he also stabbed Kaylee 57 times and caved her face in so bad that she was unrecognizable, so he did that and didn’t take any DNA from the crime scene, supposedly he left transfer DNA on a knife sheath that we’re not even sure held the murder weapon, that’s the only thing they have left. That will be exposed at some point too, That whole thing is shady. Where is the FBI? Where are they? I’ll tell you where , they said well boys, good luck to you and we’re out of here. I hope they have a smoking gun on this guy because to all the idiots out there saying were Bryan’s boyfriend, that’s not true, I want the person or persons guilty of this to have to face justice? Luckily they have an expert that will prove Bryan wasn’t anywhere near there, this is the first time he’s ever worked with a defense, he’s helped put lots of people away for the prosecution and has worked with the FBI before numerous times. Do you really think if Bryan did this he would say he’s nowhere near that house, of course not, he’d be thinking up a reason why his car is there and try to explain it away. But that’s not what he did. He’s claiming he’s not even in the same fucking state hahaha idiots. If you believe 100% that Bryan did this all by himself please stay the hell away from me cause you guys are dangerous, oh and just because you hear something on TV but they don’t give their sources then you can’t say its true
These people claim there aren't many differences between Elantras and that it's common for experts to make mistakes. Are we supposed to believe that an FBI expert with over 30 years of experience randomly guessed the car's model year? Without clear indicators, there would be no reason to specify a year. The expert likely identified clear evidence for that model year. The model year was adjusted twice by investigators, not the expert.
We know BK had at least one interview with the MPD and one with the FBI before his arrest. It would be helpful to know what was discussed, who initiated these interviews, and if there's a timeline connection between the interviews and the model year adjustment.
It's possible BK contacted the police to make a good impression. He wanted a police internship, though it's unclear if he got it. He might have tried to ingratiate himself by mentioning he knew a white Elantra was being sought and that he often drove around the general area at night, including the park on that particular night, not out of fear of suspicion but to appear helpful, interested, and honest. If so, he not only put himself in the spotlight but also told them which footage should not be requested and which cell tower data should be omitted from the official records.
Ain't nobody reading that.
@@Romina1907. you just described exactly what many murderers and serial killers do lol
@@enderthexenocide760 so kohberger did talk to the FBI and MPD before he left Moscow to head back home to Pennsylvania? I wanna see the proof of that
None of us are convinced!
Because there’s no proof.
NO...MANY are TOTALLY convinced. If you have been listening at all, you would be as well. Start listening more closely.
I don't think a jury will be convinced either....
Who knows whether he done it or not...most likely... but demolishing the residence that the crime took place in is absolutely insane, especially where there is still investigation and trial going on. In favour of both sides there could be evidence missed in the house that either helps the prosecutors case or the defendants...human error is common. You get rid of that you can no longer go back.
So with how long they've been kicking in the can you're claiming this as human error Coupled with wanta, shoulda, and coulda With the things that were allowed to be destroyed You do understand the bodies were deliberately cremated
@@CelticRuneSinger No im stating human error is always possible so you should leave the option to go back...no ones perfect...
Who is saying he's never committed a crime and not been caught?
His father turned him for "stealing his sisters phone" 16 years ago which is a Juvenile record.
@@denasewell Wow stealing a cell phone the gateway of murder
Duh!! But how does one kill of he didn’t stalk the victims as said by prosecutors
@@denasewellhis sister’s phone ? How much could he get from a phone? Especially his sister and he was 15, come on
You are so right. Never say never. I thought this was a very strange case but so was the highjackers on 911 with box cutters used to take over a plane full of people.
Ashley
Get the fact correct, prosecutor stated BK never stalked the home or the girls
Steve Goncalves recently sent email to attorney Andrew D Meyers, who featured Howard Blum on his YT channel. In the email. Steve G writes: "WE HAVE ONE PRIMARY QUESTION, REGARDING BLUM'S BOOK. WHAT EVIDENCE SUPPORTS THE THEORY, THAT BK WAS FOCUSED ON MADDIE MAY?"..."IN OUR RECENT MEETING WITH THE PROSECUTION TEAM, THEY EXPRESSED DIFFICULTY IN ESTABLISHING DIRECT CONNECTIONS BETWEEN BK AND THE VICTIMS."
The prosecution has stated in court that he didn’t stalk them.
Maybe not overtly
@@JuliusSqueezer110 he did not it was part of the jury questionarre and what do you believe is the legal term for stalking? The prosecution said not even on media and obviously you don’t know law
There’s A L O T weird about this case. Too numerous to mention.
Lots of YT channels have investigated much more than Harvey & police have.🙄
SUPER sketchy cops.
See Brent Kopacker for starters.
Fistly, watching the 'TMZ' video of this, it was absolute garbage. Disgusting to see 'NewsNation' continuing to use the orange jumpsuit picture.
This guy Levin is horrific. What a pile of absolute manure.
There is almost no evidence at all. And, Ashley Banfield invented more fiction right there, during this video. Ethan was taken-down immediately. One swift swing of the weapon.There was no 'battle' at all. None. Nobody had beem stalked. No one had stalked. Kohberger had not stalked anyone. The prosecution has been very, very clear that there had been no stalking at all.
Bryan Kohberger is a student of pasychology. He has also--at WSU--studied computer forensics. He is not a student of crime, crimescense, crime techniques.
@@JeffSherlock at least they don’t have Coffindaffer spewing misinformation anymore
What happened to the story about the other Frat house in walking distance? The mysterious texts of someone waiting for lights to go out at the house? ... and people walking up and back down.
Tearing down the house was a crime and it should have remained at least until the butcher is dead. Too bad if it makes people uncomfortable. What is wrong with feeling bad about this? We should all be very concerned.
These institutions of learning are failing our kids. We are all failing our kids. What a mess.
He thought Maddie was alone and also thought everyone was asleep. He killed one and just kept killing as he moved through the house. Kaylee's mom said it best, "He came in to kill one and ended up killing four."
Do you have a crystal ball or are you a mind reader?
No disrespect to Kaylees mum at all, but she is not an investigator or expert in crime and how it's committed .
Hearings....watch the hearings...
He could see 6 cars in the front lot, he probably watched the DoorDash delivery so he knew at least 1 person was up.
Where's your evidence for him thinking Maddie being alone Also you cannot use stalking since the prosecution has said that's bogus Also you cannot use stalking since the prosecution has said its bogus
He may be a lawyer , but he's not an investigator or a victim.
My reply was deleted in less than three minutes. This is why I can't ever write in on your channel. I work in communities as a civil rights Activist and work with police officers every day. I have a lot to inform you I am Deleted. Go ahead take this down.
Mine was as well.
Do you think he did it?
Odd that Harvey is so aggressively defending BK
@@516Mel If you are looking for attention ,you say something controversial, then promote your new venture.
There was a lot of police that night over there and a lot of people drinking and a lot of people partying young kids. There’s no way Brian did it with all that activity outside of that house. No way it was somebody. They knew . And they actually don’t have proof.
He is NOT the GUY in my opinion. there are waaaay more people with MOTIVE in this town. and Money may be one of them ... imo.
What knife❓
Levin said BK had a lot of evidence against him. Please explain
I agree - how is it possible for 1 person to overcome 4 people with just a knife? And why was there no blood trail? How could someone clean up all that blood in just a few minutes?
Levin Is incorrect about him stalking the house because in one of the hearings, Thompson said he never stalked them! Kaylee had over 50 stab wounds! Ethan had many too on his legs so there must’ve been more than one person doing everything and maybe more than one knife! Get your facts straight because Kohberger May not be the person who did this!
Also the middle of the night, they were out partying before. He was in shape. How do we know he hasn’t killed before .
They have searched. LE/FBI -- they have no evidence suggesting he is anymore than an ass when it comes to women.
His phone was out of range, not turned off. Have any of you actually followed the case? 1, no stalking. 2, no video of his car turned over to the defense yet, 3 no connections to any of the victims yet. 4, cell phone data presented to the grand jury innacurate. 5 dna is suspect with timing and amount-touch dna (not enough for a scientifically accurate sample) on a movable object. 6, No victim dna in his car, home or office. 7, video of the girls with JS walking where he says "They're going to get you for that" after Maddie says she told Adam everything.(a few hours later the girls are dead) 8, 4 people seen running away from the scene of the crime in the bandfield video. 9, The FBI expert had a different year of car initially. 10, Elantra matching the FBI experts report found crashed in Oregon tied to rhe owner of the home not processed for dna evidence. And the list goes on. Only 1 persons dna found in a party house. Police chief moves evidence from an active crime scene in a uhaul. Crime scene destroyed. Coroner not allowed on scene for 12 hours and changed timeline 3x. Prosecution witholding discovery, saying it doesn't exist, then magically finding it the day before the hearing. The way it was investigated produced so much reasonable doubt, no one should put him to death with this amount of wtf going on.
You are exactly correct plus much, much more- I’m amazed by the people that actually believe the garbage that MSM spreads! It only takes 1/2 of a brain to research legal documents and listen to the hearings! Pay attention and research this case and this corrupt town of Moscow! It’s super easy to find out truth and not just be brainwashed like 95% of people are! It’s super sad that anyone could be in a situation like this and yes it happens every day- corruption!
Santa said he was not stalking in an open hearing Didn't you see that?Bill Thompson!!!
The crime scene was contaminated before investigators could begin. How do people not understand the evidence is weak?
Most of this case is weird! Logically, it is hard to believe Kohberger did this.
Meanwhile the real killer is thinking that he is one lucky killer.
Yep that's what it is
The prosecutor literally confirmed he didn’t stalk them. Those idiots need to pay attention
Lmao nice try. The OG PR account was made in December of 2017.
@@ozzibear there is no OG PR account. The account you mention simply changed their username. It has been around posting under various lives since the arrest.
@@pappa_rodgeractually no it hasn't it's PappaRodger_1121
@@pappa_rodgerthe account has been inactive for awhile
@@pappa_rodger no one has seen that specific account on any chat. It's been inactive for awhile.
Were all the injuries from the same knife? If so then he must’ve been the only one. I don’t believe he’s too smart, but I believe he thinks he is.
You believe what ever you see on TV but in real life you don't know a single thing really about the guy.
@@ManiCUREd DNA doesn’t lie.. I don’t want to know anymore about “the guy”.
@@ManiCUREd I know a few things about “the guy” And? DNA doesn’t lie.
@@RC-no3dr Are you aware of the nuances between touch DNA that was found on the sheath and Actual DNA which was absent in the suspect's apartment and car? And are you aware that touch DNA isn't even admissible in certain parts of the world?
@@ManiCUREd isn’t that a little odd for your own dna to not be found in your own car or apartment? I don’t even see how that’s even relevant. The guy forgot the sheath or didn’t have time to look around for it in the dark, it’s as simple as that.
How did he know no one in that house had a gun?.......tremendous risk
What restaurant delivers at 4 am?
Yes weird. Multiple weapons used. Wounds were different. Kaylee beaten and assaulted. No way was this all done in 10 minutes. No way the two roommates didn’t hear more. Prosecutor says he wasn’t stalking. Those kids were not sleeping. They were up. We need to wake up and question everything. Nothing makes sense in this case. Also Levin is incorrect. His alibi wasn’t that he was out looking at stars. They just said he was driving. They said he liked to look at Stars. No proof yet he was turning his phone off. Also regarding Ashleigh’s statement, there is no proof that sheath belongs to Bryan nor do we know it held the murder weapon. Please don’t present it that it was.
You are SO wrong about everything you said
No he's not you have no idea what your talking about go read the PCA... or better yet go watch the lead detective take the stand and answer no to weather or not they could place his car at the crime scene and that theu didn't find his DNA...
@@gamerelated8985what stand? It’s not on trial yet?
So Brian's fathers dna that was on the knife sheath was blown there by the wind?
@edstar83 💯💯 and what everyone is NOT talking about is how when BK was arrested his DNA was taken, it matched (a direct match)
Let's not forget to consider, or underestimate, Kohberger's hubris.
Don't you find it on the girl that saw the guy coming in and out she never called the cops and I don't care how scared you are when you hear someone getting killed you call 911
I bet that’s a backdrop/green screen behind Harvey and he’s just sitting at his house.. 😝 😂
It is weird. But Kohberger is weird....
…maybe your weird…😂😂😂 not a reason to convict some of a horrible crime…
No stalking…no car at crime scene…CPA they aren’t even going to use! Touch DNA …corruption in every level…they are being exposed..,LE covering up for the university…
This sums up the entire case - The guy is weird so lets pin it on him.
Meanwhile the killer is some FBI agent or something.
@@nealm6764 are you serious? 🐑
#1) we don't know he never killed before.
#2) it was a party house and people likely to be sleeping under some intoxicating substance...
He did not stalk the victims-Bill Thompson the prosecutor
The house was also a known drug house.
How do you assume that all the residents were asleep? According to the PCA, Xana received a food delivery shortly before the alleged time of the incident and was active on TikTok. Dylan reportedly opened her door several times because she heard loud noises and voices. The PCA states she could understand what was being said and saw a man dressed in black with bushy eyebrows and a mask before entering a frozen shock phase. It's also known that the police heavily relied on the phone data of the surviving roommates to create the timeline.
If you accept these statements as accurate, you cannot simultaneously claim, without any evidence, that the residents were under the influence of substances and sleeping soundly to make it fit what you want to be true. Additionally, there was no party at the house that evening.
No party is needed for substance use.
@@Romina1907. Just because there wasn’t evidence of a full blown party that night doesn’t mean people weren’t doing drugs. And not all drugs make people knock out.
Yes weird. Multiple weapons used. Wounds were different. Kaylee beaten and assaulted. No way was this all done in 10 minutes. No way the two roommates didn’t hear more. Prosecutor says he wasn’t stalking. Those kids were not sleeping. They were up. We need to wake up and question everything. Nothing makes sense in this case. He’s saying tons of evidence but the sheath isn’t a weapon and the dna wasn’t direct fingerprint, the phone pings aren’t reliable, his alibi didn’t prove anything. The prosecution said he wasn’t stalking. This is why we need fair reporting.
Maybe the 2 left were tired of roommates and hired Kohberger to help them. (sarc)🤔
He practiced law AND was a law professor.
@@nhmooytis7058and that means what?
@@Otis5115 reado Englisho?
Harvey doesn't know if he hasn't killed before. He's just never been convicted of killing before. His whole focus has been domination over others and has had numerous problems, so he's not the angel that Harvey is making him out to be.
Angel? Did you listen to this?
@sallyvella7012. You haven't watched any of the hearings have you....
Also "Somebody who has never committed a murder before"
Like every killer in history who had never killed anyone before until they did?
@@edstar83 So ed can you tell me why the FBI doesn't want to be linked to this anymore Since you're so Adamant about murder
@CelticRuneSinger I don't work for the FBI I couldn't tell you. I have a question for you, how did his father's DNA get on the knife sheave left at the murder scene? Was it simply blown there by the wind?
I still think that that kid, that rich kid,
the one creeping on the victims at the food truck earlier that night,
the one who fled the country pretty much right after it,
the one who way way too into hunting and seemed pretty adept with knives,
That kid is involved somehow and should've been checked out further.
Harvey is dead wrong he acted alone.The home was a party house i am sure the murderer had been in the house before and knew the layout.
You cannot dismiss and disregard the eye witness statement of man with bushy eyebrows…..
He also knew they drank a lot at that house.
He knew this! He knew that! What else did he know? Since you’re a mind reader and apparently Bryan Koghberger!!!
Always has seemed weird to me. Something definitely off about it.
I think he's killed people before; they just haven't definitively discovered which cold cases he's tied to. But someone in his physical condition - and with that kind of knife (which was originally designed as a military knife for the express purpose of killing people rapidly and QUIETLY) - could definitely commit this kind of crime. He allegedly used to go hunting and fishing with his father (for all his OCD virtue signaling about vegetarianism) - and he once had a job gutting fish. I'm sure they hired him, too, because he had some hunting/fishing/knife experience, to begin with. "Weird?" Well, sure it's "weird" - not to mention, horrific. But you know the phrase and the song about how much can happen in "a NY minute" ?? And crime victims who survive will tell you how quickly everything happened "all of a sudden." You cannot look at this through the mindset of a normal person. Whoever did this (I believe it's the accused) - got a perverse predatory thrill out of the high risk of the situation - things like criss-crossing with the door dash, or Xana being awake on the 2nd floor, while he slipped upstairs to the third floor, first -- this was part of the sadistic and arrogant enjoyment of "the hunt," so to speak, is my guess, as far as his psychology is concerned. He may also be schizoid - and perhaps committed these crimes in a highly depersonalized state of mind.
There is a serial killer in walker county alabama to. Summer buzbee jasper alabama vanished walking and found dismembered on railroad tracks in a wooded area. Third girl found in the same manner. Multiple guys have gone missing and never heard from again. And yet nobody covers their stories
What?? I have family in Alabama....that's scary 😓
Somebody was arrested for this?
@martinwhite418 yes but it goes beyond what the sherrifs department have posted in a way alot of people around here feel as if the department is covering it up to not frighten the public. There are several people involved. They are investigating a cult of people if that makes sense. This girls murder is one of the most awful thing a person could go through and my family has nothing but facts surrounding her case and it is truly sad what has been said went on during that day for that girl. No family should have to hear something like that
@martinwhite418 an he was held for questioning that's as far as that went. He was the last to be seen with her on Two different occasions he will never not be a person of interest but he will never not be the only suspect
I think Kohberger confronted circumstances he didn't plan for like the two girls sleeping in the bed together and running into other roommates in the home. Adrenaline can enable a person to do things physically they normally couldn't do
Then where's the injuries or scars on his body
@@CelticRuneSinger Four days after the incident, BK attended a pre-scheduled doctor's appointment. It was reportedly a general check-up related to his PhD studies. While protective gloves might have prevented cuts, it's implausible that his hand wouldn't have been visibly bruised after repeatedly stabbing four people. The knife allegedly used has a guard to prevent slipping, but stabbing through human muscles and hitting bones again and again in a short time would cause his hand to hit the guard with significant force with each stab. There is no way that the person who did this walked out of the house without any injury.
I agreee with the concept. I do not at all agree that Kohberger had anything to do with this.
*Just because Harvey doesn't think he could do it...doesn't mean BK didn't do it.* 🙄 I believe that Kohberger wanted to know if he could get away with murder. I don't think he expected the other 3. So are we going with speculations like mine and Harvey's or are we going with what the investigation says! *I'm disappointed in your having this man on!* Booooooo
Ted Bundy went into a building with 8 women, two or three in every room armed with a log, killed or severly injured everyone in that house in a matter of minutes. Not one scream from anyone.
So there is that, Harvey the lawyer.
I think that is what Kohberger is banking on. Thanks Ashleigh and Harvey. Hopefully the families of the Idaho 4 will all see justice soon
You think none of this would have ever been considered or brought up during the trial?
Said it from the beginning friends are involved
Wait, from the TV show?
@@aisle_of_viewyes!😂
Yes, “friends” from Greek row!
Sigh, the house was actually not "Big" it's teeny tiny. You need to research this more and get the facts straight
He could easily get methed up and do this on his own.
He figured they were drunk passed out. Maybe.
The dude was in shape and trained for this. He ran a 6 minute mile for Pete's sake. But Mr tmz wants to stir the pot. Whatever
That's merely speculation.
K. wanted to commit a crime that outdid the other serial killers. He wanted to be a Nietzsche Super Man. He studied this stuff. He absolutely fits the profile.
Weird not improbable...if everyone was partying and drinking it would definitely hinder self defense.
Exactly, BK is more credible than the other people that were there at scene including two surviving Frozen shock sleeping housemates 🥶🥶 BK is not guilty
How is he "more" credible? Whether or not he did it, I'm just waiting to hear the evidence before I declare him guilty or not guilty. To me that is the correct approach.
Forget the cops' "Frozen shock" wording. It means nothing.
@@Doris1888 well he wasn't there? Others were there trampling the crime scene, someone had already checked out before cops got there? Where's the 911 call? I would say that BKs alibi is more believable compared to those people!
@@ruthcarter1360 Just because others were trampling the crime scene (which I agree) doesn't mean he wasn't there. His DNA on the knife sheath. But I am willing to listen to all the evidence before I would convict him or say not guilty. I'll agree they goofed with the crime scene but that doesn't mean he wasn't there.
@@JeffSherlock I don't think it was frozen shock. Considering it was COVID, she probably thought whomever was leaving the party and went back to bed.
It doesn't take a rocket scientist to see that ain't Koberger first time at the rodeo. Its just the first time he got caught.
Also "Somebody who has never committed a murder before"
Like every killer in history who had never killed anyone before until they did?
I wouldnt hire this guy.
It actually does take a scientist and your clearly not it!!
@@deannaleejackson5777 Your boyfriend is going to prison for multiple homicide.
No I strongly disagree. It had to be somebody else.
It's ridiculous to read the comments of those desperately trying to make BK Bundy 2.0. They insist it could still be true whenever something comes to light that doesn't support their narrative. These same people naively believe in a mountain of evidence that Santa is supposedly hiding for strategic reasons, ready to dump on the defense during the trial.
Hint: It doesn't work this way, and the last hearings were quite sobering. There is no mountain of evidence. Over 1.5 years after the crime, they can't even prove the story they put in the PCA.
It's not about your fantasies but justice for the victims and BK's rights. Both are closely linked and depend on the work of the investigators and the prosecution. Anyone claiming to want justice for the victims and their families should hold the prosecution to the highest standards.
But how do you know he didn’t have a gun for back up? Just because he didn’t use it, doesn’t mean he didn’t have it….If it wasn’t him, you could say the same thing about whoever did it. Unless you’re implying that multiple people did it for which I would then think that there would be nobody left alive if there were multiple people there to commit the crime..
He did not stalk the victims. Judge judge clearly states this as fact in one of the hearings regarding the survey. Link below of court hearing judge judge confirming he did not stalk the victims.
ua-cam.com/video/LSZZOFhnAno/v-deo.htmlsi=RbmtQQSEM4xiWGiV
I think he went there that night to kill one person (he probably thought he was slick enough to pull that off without anyone else knowing) & he killed the three others because he had too (things didn’t go to plan) cause his target was not alone in the room (remember, the one girl had already moved out & came back to visit & show them her new car) the couple were still up & probably heard him & Ethan probably confronted him, so that led to their deaths, but we won’t know anything for sure till the trial
I think that is exactly what happened too. He kept running into people on the way out so he had to kill them to get out. I also think the reason he didn’t kill the last girl was he was exhausted and thought he may get caught if he didn’t get out quickly.
Thank you! Yes, wait till trial. I too think this guy didn’t plan 4 kills. If there were multiple killers, there hasn’t been solid evidence of there being so or they were ruled out.
@@skiarytn6744there was 3 other male dna found in the house
BK is innocent until proven.
So how does a murderer kill his first victim, Harvey? Every one has a first and that first is violent and it ain't pretty. Harvey's own Liquor Store example is a logic fail: Just because we don't KNOW of previous violence/killing does not mean he didn't commit any. If he was ever CAUGHT having done them, then he wouldn't have GRADUATED to more complex crime ala the liquor store example. Pretty amateur mistake coming from an attorney...
I have always loved Harvey. He's so logical in his theories. I think he should write a book.
Too bad he's repeating gossip and slander here instead of facts.
He has no idea what he’s talking about in this case
Harvey, Harvey, Harvey
This dodo didn't know there would be 6 pax in the house. Come on now…😅
So he didn't see all the cars parked out front? He must have just missed that during his several drive bys that night
Harvey is using common sense! Perhaps people should read through all the facts for themselves and not base opinions on bias in the media!!! We can’t all be sheep!
@@johannawigg6921 I just don't know but, it kind of looked like other neighboring residents could have been parking there. Remember, this neighborhood is full of kids.
@@deannaleejackson5777 oh honey, I've been on it. Harvey has a lot of tentacles out in his 30 mile zone. I question if he even cares about this case.
@@TheRealHellrazor but there was also a parking area up behind the house too