This issue is not about safety of Drs. This is about sadist mind of some powerful people.How to make our society which cares for women, how to be helpful to others.Morality is in question. How to make people more Human.
What the hell is wrong with the Lawyers......the dumbness with which they're speaking is unbelievable. It's not about just doctors or just work.... it's about SAFETY EVERYWHERE....I just wish if anything happens with their family will they say the same thing????????
Don't you understand law.... their cases would be taken seperately (if filed in supreme court), you can't take decision legally on a case which is not even filed yet.. ofcourse don't doubt CJI, i remember when he was taking the case of NEET SCAM recently...if the proofs are there, then he is gonna give justice... But if the proofs are removed by government.. even he can't do it, the court doesn't run on emotion, the cases must be taken seperately cuz the case is not about what to do in future but rather about specifically that female resident dr... That's why they are not talking much about women safety in general
society and mindset need to change. we have enough laws. Even police, doctors and everyone in society are not sensitised enough towards these things. people are like that in India. We are still a very backward society.
Basic infrastructure is missing in government offices and institutions. Why? Women's needs are ignored. Bathrooms, restrooms, baby changing rooms in public areas are totally missing. Safety and Security measures are not in place. With modern technology this should not be difficult to provide citizens. Why do we have to ask for something so basic?
This guy sibal is gone out of his mind and talking nonsense, he just want to save all the accused and the kolkata police and the CM anyhow, and the civil worker is not the culprit they are just hiding the big names
So now protection should be given based on what a girls profession in this country . Thank u for this wonderful thought. So every common girl, lady or women will be unsafe forever and will be struggling for safety .
I dont get it. Unless there is a national uproar, nobody who is in power wanted to give justice to any victim. This is not the first time a gruesome rape and murder has happened in our country. When rapes happen in UP, Haryana and Gujarat, everything is just brushed off. I understand this rape is not just rape and there is a lot of racket behind it, but why is it that only this rape is politicized?
NCRB annual reports of 2022 shows that 4.45 lakh cases of crimes against women were registered, which is equivalent to nearly 51 FIRs every hour. We are human but not humane 😢
Surprise is that, entire hospital was aware of the rape and murder, handed over the body to the police, police was present in crematorium to ensure its cremated at 8.30 pm and only at 11.45 pm on victim's father complaint the FIR was registered. Kapil says, the state was persuading the father and doing whatever he was asking? but very little reaction from bench. shocking. and the level with which Kapil is given weightage show his power.
Our Lord CJI, must continue his honerable services as long as he is healthy. Sir don't take retirement, if anyone ask your resignation , please don't leave your service. You continue your work we are supporting you sir. God will bless you with good health and happiness. 🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
Whats wrong with the lawyers? It’s not just about the safety of doctors or the workplace it’s about the safety of every human being, both alive and deceased, and the safety of this country, Bharat Ma. ‘Ma’ means ‘Mother,’ right? Then where is the safety of this Ma?”
seems like the HC judge was much better with his words and judgement, i did not see much of the backlash from the Supreme court on such a heinous crime, it seemed to me like the he was too polite with his words for this incident, which was unnecessary, the aggrieved population of Bengal is not satisfied with this proceeding
There must be a committee involving management and the students trainee a part committee to check periodically if they are facing and threat sexual harassment by any one right to file complaint if any suppression for them to reach to a government body attached to the court
Violent clashes between police and protesters in Badlapur, Thane, Maharashtra as protesters demand strict action against the accused who sexually abused two 4-year-old girls in a school toilet. The accused has been identified as AkshayShinde. (No no don't look at his name or surname) BJP and RSS that is aggressive & outraged in Kolkata is maintaining pin drop silence in Badlapur sexual assault case Maharashtra, as it's their own govt. It clearly shows that Kolkata protest manufactured by BJP is to grab power, not about women safety. Nadda was visiting Bengal , wonder when is he visiting Maharashtra
Yes chief Justice sir also the doctors and nurses and paramedics claims they have been manhandled even murdered including men do not have protection against patients and their attendants and outside mob there should be a security wing for protection of all working in the institution
Just go and watch , the kolkata case , the mumbai sion case , uttrakhand nurse case , UP nurse case ... too many cases in india , india is just not safe for women . & it's a shame for a man .
few things i noticed in this proceedings. If u dont have the patience to do so. 1)The reason i watched this whole thing is to filter what is false news and what is not, but such details was never clarified such as the allegations if the principal called it a sucide. it was disputed but never clarified. There are other aspects also which was not clarified. The case was discussed less but more emphasis was given on what should be done to protect the individuals on ground. 2)between the bench, prosecutor and defendant. The bench is well versed with the case and the prosecutor seems to fumble with the details such as who logged the FIR and the timing. The defendant feels more prepared in the case. They were more prepared with the complains on scene. if there was an AI to analyzed who between the 3 spoke in this court. pretty sure the prosecutor will be like 10%. 3) The bench is more focused on maintaining the safety of the medical professional. Which is rightly so. prevention is better than cure but i believe forming a task force will delegate the responsibly to other. By doing so in a case of failure who is held accountable in a case like this? point is the institution should be accountable for ensuring their safety IMO. 4)The prosecutor is trying to rope in others state bodies to be held accountable but the delivery was poor. Even the aspect of sharing the Details with the investing body (CBI) is disputed saying it will be leaked to the media by the defendant. I hope the prosecutors were more prepared and stern. I will give them credit to refer past cases and verdicts relevant to this case and complains from the doctors on ground. 5)all parties do agree with a digital app and a helpline to help medical professionals in destress. But in the Kolkata doctors case It would not have helped in my humble opinion. proper screening and security personals would be more helpful as long as they dont run away. 6)around 1:19:00 was productive when the vandalism was address and the allegations when the cops ran away hiding allegedly. I am satisfied by decisive action taken.
Why don't kapil let the CJI speak...such a notorious advocate he is.... I don't know how he appears in front of his wife and daughters.... Such a shame... Defending the criminal always...
I don't get it why the hech would a senior lawyer would say such nonsense just for some money????? In All his experience has he never learnt what's wrong and right????
Justice For Dr Moumata and protect all the girls in India and across the globe. This is not about Her Alone. This is about all the women Your wife,sisters,mother,aunts,nieces,daughters This is Matter to All. Why you covering the culprits???
I don’t understand.. what is making the state defend the accused. Why is Mamta government so hell bent to protect the accused party? What is wrong with this people .. why are they arguing.. all this are facts .. this has happened.. oh my God.. we are not safe in our own country
There is no absolute solution to this issue, as it fundamentally revolves around the concept of mens rea-the intent and mindset of individuals. Crimes can occur even in the safest of safe environments, including within our own homes. To address this, I believe the establishment of a stronger deterrent effect, rooted in a heightened fear of legal consequences, is crucial. Even this may only address 40-50% of the issue.
Wah chadhme baddoor,there are many issues to be adressed in india,ur interest matters?,this is the result for SC is not at all for public from before,but now scenerio changed by CJI sir,SC should concentrate in country interest cases rather than unnecessary things.
Kapil sibal sir all we can see with nacked eyes why you are with currept people and Money not getting being such a strong carrier name fame you have and your team and you are protecting high profile person
Indian laws are strictly made of thick walls with large loops. People don't have any confidence in this law system and in this governments, politicians want to politicize the issue and lawyers want to highlight the issue in detail to protect the culprits, but the criminals in the society were happily roaming the streets. Who will give safety and security to our country's women? after seeing all these judgments and arguments people lose confidence in our governments still pm saabh was not even gives a single statement bengal ka corrupted mamatha was so dramatically acting on the incident she will surely get a oscar foe her performance and high drama whole country is watching its a very ashameful to the bengal government while hiding the truths to save the culprints.
Stfu, the number women who are raped, beaten by their husband, groped, catcalled on streets, and sexually harassed are way more than innocent men going to jail in this country. You bringing this issue here undermines women’s safety in this country. It obviously is a problem, but a completely inappropriate time to talk about it
What the hell is going on … kapil sibbal hate button … whats wrong with him … he didnt even understand the intensity of the crime … saddest reality of our country…
Why on earth are you just focusing on safety for doctors, this is not just about doctors, it's about each and every female in India irrespective of her occupation. It is a gender matter, the Females gender in India is not safe, their dignity and life is at stake.
If kapil siebel only representative of indian medical association then why is supreme court judges bending backwards to listen to onky what kapil siebel wants to say infact kapil siebel is speaks without facts contradictory statements what is already recorded in high court throw kapil siebel out of supreme court he is neither representing police or principle or kolkats govt hebis in indian medical association lawyer throw him out
His Lordship is retiring in November 24. Who will monitor the long list of directions contained in the order. With great respect the CJI has enlarged the scope and ambit of the directions to all the HCs & and States in India. No disrespect intended but the West Bengal HC was doing an outstanding job of pulling up the West Bengal government from its failure to prevent such a heinous crime and keep law and order when the docs were protesting outside the hospital. Will the HC continue to monitor the case or the CBI investigation
This issue is not about safety of Drs. This is about sadist mind of some powerful people.How to make our society which cares for women, how to be helpful to others.Morality is in question. How to make people more Human.
What the hell is wrong with the Lawyers......the dumbness with which they're speaking is unbelievable. It's not about just doctors or just work.... it's about SAFETY EVERYWHERE....I just wish if anything happens with their family will they say the same thing????????
This is our new india sad we really need some one like INDIAN
Indian 2 is trending on Netflix
Don't you understand law.... their cases would be taken seperately (if filed in supreme court), you can't take decision legally on a case which is not even filed yet.. ofcourse don't doubt CJI, i remember when he was taking the case of NEET SCAM recently...if the proofs are there, then he is gonna give justice... But if the proofs are removed by government.. even he can't do it, the court doesn't run on emotion, the cases must be taken seperately cuz the case is not about what to do in future but rather about specifically that female resident dr... That's why they are not talking much about women safety in general
I want be surprised if mr Kapil sibal argues that there is no eyewitness so it' is case of suiside.. CJI may say yes it' is possible
It is not just about the safety of doctors, it is about the safety of all working or not working girls and women across the country.
So kapil sibal says as if they did a favor by doing port mortem and allowing parents to file FIR !!!!
My salute to CJI. 🙏🏼 Such a proactive initiative will make the judiciary more and more respectful.
If you hate Kapil sibal
We are already friends 😉
This guy literally fought for terrorist
society and mindset need to change. we have enough laws. Even police, doctors and everyone in society are not sensitised enough towards these things. people are like that in India. We are still a very backward society.
Lady lawyers backing Mr Kapil....Shame on you people
This is the worst judgement world is looking
Kapil Sibal always defends rap!sts?
Basic infrastructure is missing in government offices and institutions. Why? Women's needs are ignored. Bathrooms, restrooms, baby changing rooms in public areas are totally missing. Safety and Security measures are not in place. With modern technology this should not be difficult to provide citizens. Why do we have to ask for something so basic?
This guy sibal is gone out of his mind and talking nonsense, he just want to save all the accused and the kolkata police and the CM anyhow, and the civil worker is not the culprit they are just hiding the big names
First CM must punished.
She is very arrogant lady.
She is not taken immediately actions. She is screard of her chair.
SIBAL is SHAMELESS
So now protection should be given based on what a girls profession in this country . Thank u for this wonderful thought.
So every common girl, lady or women will be unsafe forever and will be struggling for safety .
We don't want to wait even for a single day to get the justice done for our lady doctor, we want justice for any cost
I dont get it. Unless there is a national uproar, nobody who is in power wanted to give justice to any victim. This is not the first time a gruesome rape and murder has happened in our country. When rapes happen in UP, Haryana and Gujarat, everything is just brushed off. I understand this rape is not just rape and there is a lot of racket behind it, but why is it that only this rape is politicized?
So sibal is also want save the CM and accused
He is always side of accused
When no one stands by us SC stands for us
Kolkata hc too
Like they did fot neet students ???
@subhashkurni5056 in few cases they do stand and in few cases they don't
Kapil sibal crook of the first order
Honorable court should meet the victims parents in private and how could renovation work start a few metres from the crime scene
I am happy SC has taken this matter. 🙏
NCRB annual reports of 2022 shows that 4.45 lakh
cases of crimes against women were registered, which is equivalent to nearly 51 FIRs every hour.
We are human but not humane 😢
Surprise is that, entire hospital was aware of the rape and murder, handed over the body to the police, police was present in crematorium to ensure its cremated at 8.30 pm and only at 11.45 pm on victim's father complaint the FIR was registered. Kapil says, the state was persuading the father and doing whatever he was asking? but very little reaction from bench. shocking. and the level with which Kapil is given weightage show his power.
Our Lord CJI, must continue his honerable services as long as he is healthy. Sir don't take retirement, if anyone ask your resignation , please don't leave your service. You continue your work we are supporting you sir. God will bless you with good health and happiness.
🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
.... CJI MUST REOPEN JUDGE LOYA's CASE FOR REINVESTIGATION AND REEXAMINE TO FIND OUT THE TRUTH .....
Imagine how many hundreds of crores was paid to Kapil Sibal and his team by TMC
JUSTICE IS NEEDED.JAI HIND
Sibbal show, CJI has given all rights to Sibbal to run the court.
Kapil sibal nonsense he is talking
Whats wrong with the lawyers? It’s not just about the safety of doctors or the workplace it’s about the safety of every human being, both alive and deceased, and the safety of this country, Bharat Ma. ‘Ma’ means ‘Mother,’ right? Then where is the safety of this Ma?”
seems like the HC judge was much better with his words and judgement, i did not see much of the backlash from the Supreme court on such a heinous crime, it seemed to me like the he was too polite with his words for this incident, which was unnecessary, the aggrieved population of Bengal is not satisfied with this proceeding
Judiciary is fucked up in India.. I'm suffering for the past 16 years..Shame on the Judiciary
There must be a committee involving management and the students trainee a part committee to check periodically if they are facing and threat sexual harassment by any one right to file complaint if any suppression for them to reach to a government body attached to the court
Make IHSF ( Indian Hospital/Medical Security Force). Immediately, depute from CRPF, Industrial Security Service, ....
Violent clashes between police and protesters in Badlapur, Thane, Maharashtra as protesters demand strict action against the accused who sexually abused two 4-year-old girls in a school toilet. The accused has been identified as AkshayShinde. (No no don't look at his name or surname)
BJP and RSS that is aggressive & outraged in Kolkata is maintaining pin drop silence in Badlapur sexual assault case Maharashtra, as it's their own govt.
It clearly shows that Kolkata protest manufactured by BJP is to grab power, not about women safety. Nadda was visiting Bengal , wonder when is he visiting Maharashtra
How come sibals Mike is louder than Chief justices !
what kind of circus is this ???? i am totally disappointed seeing this. Time to switch country.
Yes chief Justice sir also the doctors and nurses and paramedics claims they have been manhandled even murdered including men do not have protection against patients and their attendants and outside mob there should be a security wing for protection of all working in the institution
Uncivilised Indian society… after millions of years nothing much can change is expected..
Sibal paid heavily?
Of course
Sibal sir please we want justice
Please be a judicious lawyer, the entire world is watching
Just go and watch , the kolkata case , the mumbai sion case , uttrakhand nurse case , UP nurse case ... too many cases in india , india is just not safe for women . & it's a shame for a man .
Body was not handed to the parents . It was cremated hurriedly . Parents arrived Only to receive the ashes
Its brutal to report line by line and word to word of the post-mortem report
I hope thye SC takes nte of this
few things i noticed in this proceedings. If u dont have the patience to do so.
1)The reason i watched this whole thing is to filter what is false news and what is not, but such details was never clarified such as the allegations if the principal called it a sucide. it was disputed but never clarified. There are other aspects also which was not clarified. The case was discussed less but more emphasis was given on what should be done to protect the individuals on ground.
2)between the bench, prosecutor and defendant. The bench is well versed with the case and the prosecutor seems to fumble with the details such as who logged the FIR and the timing. The defendant feels more prepared in the case. They were more prepared with the complains on scene.
if there was an AI to analyzed who between the 3 spoke in this court. pretty sure the prosecutor will be like 10%.
3) The bench is more focused on maintaining the safety of the medical professional. Which is rightly so. prevention is better than cure but i believe forming a task force will delegate the responsibly to other. By doing so in a case of failure who is held accountable in a case like this? point is the institution should be accountable for ensuring their safety IMO.
4)The prosecutor is trying to rope in others state bodies to be held accountable but the delivery was poor. Even the aspect of sharing the Details with the investing body (CBI) is disputed saying it will be leaked to the media by the defendant. I hope the prosecutors were more prepared and stern. I will give them credit to refer past cases and verdicts relevant to this case and complains from the doctors on ground.
5)all parties do agree with a digital app and a helpline to help medical professionals in destress. But in the Kolkata doctors case It would not have helped in my humble opinion. proper screening and security personals would be more helpful as long as they dont run away.
6)around 1:19:00 was productive when the vandalism was address and the allegations when the cops ran away hiding allegedly. I am satisfied by decisive action taken.
Who is that lady advocate behind sibal sir, shame to you lady advocate
Task force, status report etc etc but the situation in reality won’t change
Why don't kapil let the CJI speak...such a notorious advocate he is.... I don't know how he appears in front of his wife and daughters.... Such a shame... Defending the criminal always...
Sibal dominates or seeks to dominate Chief justice , and ofcource gives no chance to the other lawyer to be heard .Disgusting man
Sibal is politician in lawyer's dress!
I don't get it why the hech would a senior lawyer would say such nonsense just for some money?????
In All his experience has he never learnt what's wrong and right????
Please take case of Manipur issue on sou motto also SEBI and hindernberg
sai deepak should take this case......
CM should resign
Kapil Sibal.. pure Congress mindset.. This shows how they respect woman 😢😢
We have total faith in CJI snd honble judges
Justice For Dr Moumata and protect all the girls in India and across the globe.
This is not about Her Alone.
This is about all the women
Your wife,sisters,mother,aunts,nieces,daughters
This is Matter to All.
Why you covering the culprits???
🙏🙏🙏 CJI
Sibal sir please don't do politics in this case
Kapil sibal is dominating in SC
I don’t understand.. what is making the state defend the accused. Why is Mamta government so hell bent to protect the accused party? What is wrong with this people .. why are they arguing.. all this are facts .. this has happened.. oh my God.. we are not safe in our own country
There is no absolute solution to this issue, as it fundamentally revolves around the concept of mens rea-the intent and mindset of individuals. Crimes can occur even in the safest of safe environments, including within our own homes. To address this, I believe the establishment of a stronger deterrent effect, rooted in a heightened fear of legal consequences, is crucial. Even this may only address 40-50% of the issue.
Sibal is dominating SC
Wah chadhme baddoor,there are many issues to be adressed in india,ur interest matters?,this is the result for SC is not at all for public from before,but now scenerio changed by CJI sir,SC should concentrate in country interest cases rather than unnecessary things.
I dont trust supreme court from the court hearing today
Please ban pronography first
Can anyone tell me whom adv Peter Pettygrew is representing is it west bengal Mamta bano gvt?
Kapil sibal sir all we can see with nacked eyes why you are with currept people and Money not getting being such a strong carrier name fame you have and your team and you are protecting high profile person
such shameless people these kapil sibal and his minion lawers
Why sibal sir is angry
Kapil sibal arguing for every point on CJI
Indian laws are strictly made of thick walls with large loops. People don't have any confidence in this law system and in this governments, politicians want to politicize the issue and lawyers want to highlight the issue in detail to protect the culprits, but the criminals in the society were happily roaming the streets. Who will give safety and security to our country's women? after seeing all these judgments and arguments people lose confidence in our governments still pm saabh was not even gives a single statement bengal ka corrupted mamatha was so dramatically acting on the incident she will surely get a oscar foe her performance and high drama whole country is watching its a very ashameful to the bengal government while hiding the truths to save the culprints.
G S T WHY SILENCE
My God ! Looks like Sibal records on his person and passes on yo Brut ! Shameful his volume is most prominant
Sibal and his group shameless
What do u expect from sibal? This guy literally defended terrorists
Onky kapil siebel is being allowed to speak when he is only IMA representative
Its Women everywhere
TMC goons in Bengal...... bengal failed state.... CM should resign.. ..put presidents rule...
imagine if women misuse the law in favor and innocent men are sent to jail
What's their to imagine it's already been happening for decades now mate
Stfu, the number women who are raped, beaten by their husband, groped, catcalled on streets, and sexually harassed are way more than innocent men going to jail in this country. You bringing this issue here undermines women’s safety in this country. It obviously is a problem, but a completely inappropriate time to talk about it
😢😢😢 Really
But remember a lot of real rapist men are not in jail . What about that ?
Don't imagine. Stand up for the victims, but do not try to disrespect the victim right now by bringing whataboutism.
What the hell is going on … kapil sibbal hate button … whats wrong with him … he didnt even understand the intensity of the crime … saddest reality of our country…
Please go live your proceedings
Sibal sir is highly paid
Why on earth are you just focusing on safety for doctors, this is not just about doctors, it's about each and every female in India irrespective of her occupation. It is a gender matter, the Females gender in India is not safe, their dignity and life is at stake.
this kapil sibal guy spews only nonsense
Apply China rule in India
Kapil sibal is a shameless person.
Sibal is shibal
Arrow waali aunty
bastard sibal is back
哇，太可怕了！
Kabil sibbal is a blot on this country
If kapil siebel only representative of indian medical association then why is supreme court judges bending backwards to listen to onky what kapil siebel wants to say infact kapil siebel is speaks without facts contradictory statements what is already recorded in high court throw kapil siebel out of supreme court he is neither representing police or principle or kolkats govt hebis in indian medical association lawyer throw him out
Lo gaya case pani me
His Lordship is retiring in November 24. Who will monitor the long list of directions contained in the order. With great respect the CJI has enlarged the scope and ambit of the directions to all the HCs & and States in India. No disrespect intended but the West Bengal HC was doing an outstanding job of pulling up the West Bengal government from its failure to prevent such a heinous crime and keep law and order when the docs were protesting outside the hospital. Will the HC continue to monitor the case or the CBI investigation
Sibal sir please don't do politics in this case
Kapil sibal is dominating in SC