Arabic in Indian Pakistani madrasas are taught at PhD level, yes fluency is needed but when it comes to understanding the classical Arabic books, they are kings.... Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi and Maulana hussain ahmad madani were the person with whom when Arabs spoke they used to get nervous
@@stonerosesuk it's a practical, just come and check out books, just read a book written by sheikh Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi, don't you ever underestimate scholars of Subcontinent who played big role to preserve is lam and it's science and scholarship, you can find Madani and Azhari scholars but can't find any Madani or Azhari madrasas, alhamdulillah our deobandi madrasas present everywhere, I am not talking about whole Subcontinent, just one madrasa board in Pakistan called wifaq ul madaris that produces 100,000 huffaz a year, scholars of maktab of Deoband alone has published 250 books in tafsirs, many books on commentary of siha sitta... Don't you ever underestimate us, Mujaddid of second millenium period was born here in India, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi is from India whom Prophet (saws) declared imam of coming centuries when his soul met him, don't you ever underestimate us
It's amazing what people people you meet..and just having the privilege to learn from them is a great gift just like our sweet shaykh hamza yusuf and his family ❤❤
Before criticising any well-renowned scholar, i must recommend that listen to that scholar at least for 200 hours. Then you understand, when he explains something, from where he is from.
Hanfi malyoons are always lost and they will make you astray...Islam is not complicated...it is so simple but it is hard to follow that straight path of simplicity, which is the test in this dunya....These Malyoons are fabricated 100%...
Shaykh Explained betautifully. I think its a must watch video for every Muslim parent who wants their children to pursue Islamic education. The title doesn't do justice with the video - only talked about South Asia at the end, this video is more than that.
The majority of Indian and Pakistani Ulama do know Arabic very well " Ulama" "Teachers". You cannot expect all students to be well verse in the Arabic language. There are million students in any giving year. And most of them have basic knowledge of Arabic. Not all the students become scholars. As like in past only handful of people become scholars and teachers.
@Jenni-dx1yb first bring forth a seminary like Darul uloom Deoband whose publishing house published tafsirs whose number is more than 250 whose volumes are 2 volumes, 5 volumes 10 volumes and 20 volumes, who wrote commentaries on Bukhari Mus lim Abu Dawood, nasai, ibn majah, muwatta imam malik in 10-20 volumes, whose madrasas are all over the western hemisphere and subsaharan and southern Africa and all over the world, whose missionary organization is world's largest i.e Tablighi jamaat, whose 1 board in Pax stan produces 100,000 huffaz per year, excluding other madrasas in Subcontinent, West and Africa... Achieve this milestone and then come talk to us... Also Google who is Sheikh Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi and fear Allah to speak against such friends of All ah who are so respected that even Rashid Al makhtoum sent private jet to Lucknow to pick up Sheikh and give him award in Dubai, who i respected by almost all scholars in Arab world and mus lim world
I do not disrespect the people who disrespect Shaykh Hamza Yusuf because his speech is too deep to understand. Someone must have vast knowledge to understand him. He is the only one for this century. Allahu-aAlam.
We feel sad for your poor understanding of respecting the scholars. May Allah grant you the ability to understand ilm that is in the simplest form and grant you hidayah to be around the greatest of Scholars like Shaykh Hamza Yusuf and the ability to humble the people who eats the flesh of the scholars
But when it comes to understanding a classical Arabic book, they are kings... Those who speak Arabic makes Arabs shattered, among them were Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi
@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn You're wrong if they know Arabic they still very narrow minded in their Hanafi concept, knowing Arabic for the subcontinent, it makes it easy to read Quran other than they are very limited in religious knowledge
@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muhammad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived ji haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget ji haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Pak that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year.... You talk about religious knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mullah Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
@@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muhammad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived ji haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget ji haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Pak that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year, i just mentioned madrasas affiliated to wifaq, Bangladesh and India has many other madrasas as well so we are producing more huffaz than all.... You talk about religious knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mullah Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
@@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muham mad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived j haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget j haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Paxtan that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year.... You talk about religi ous knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mulla Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
Zakaat isn't a tax , its helping others to self develop , and its a function to detach yourself from your wealth and knowledge , and help others Salaat is your own personal development to receive from Allah directly Hence salaat and zakaat are frequently together in the same verses Nowhere in Quran is zakaat given as a percentage that's made up by the tax men
@faruqfouzia, you don't have to pay Zakaat on the value of the house that you live in. But otherwise, you do have to pay Zakaat as per the Islamic requirement InshAllah. May all of our wealth be purified via paying Zakaat and be accept by Our Creator Almighty Allah SubhanahuwaTa'ala and to follow Our Beloved Prophet AlaiheSalatoWassalamWa'AlaAali perfect methods ❤❤❤❤❤
@@faruqfouzia Zakaat isn't a tax , they are lying to you, i.e if you buy a person a fishing rod he can catch their own food instead of begging others for sustenance which nobody likes doing, similarly if your a person with knowledge and teach others it without expecting anything in return, that is the essence of zakaat
They are not understanding the Qur'an Arabic of the Qur'an, Quran defines it's own words and what they mean i.e zakharia and his son Yahya was referred to as zakhiya , from the etymology and root you can clearly understand that zakharia and Yahya helped others to self develop, this action is called zakaat
What are the good materials to teach Arabic in English? So far what I've seen it's just horrible. It's as if the writers are showing off using words that aren't easy to understand, ie modern standard American English. That's why we have such low quality translations of the Quran and Sunnah, confusion is rampant, especially for the average person.
Arabic in Indian Pakistani madrasas are taught at PhD level, yes fluency is needed but when it comes to understanding the classical Arabic books, they are kings.... Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi and Maulana hussain ahmad madani were the person with whom when Arabs spoke they used to get nervous
This is the major issue, doing Arabic should be in primary school, at least in Afghanistan 🇦🇫 we used to study Arabic in primary school.
Sounds like another story from a Pakistani Madrassah.
@@stonerosesuk it's a practical, just come and check out books, just read a book written by sheikh Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi, don't you ever underestimate scholars of Subcontinent who played big role to preserve is lam and it's science and scholarship, you can find Madani and Azhari scholars but can't find any Madani or Azhari madrasas, alhamdulillah our deobandi madrasas present everywhere, I am not talking about whole Subcontinent, just one madrasa board in Pakistan called wifaq ul madaris that produces 100,000 huffaz a year, scholars of maktab of Deoband alone has published 250 books in tafsirs, many books on commentary of siha sitta... Don't you ever underestimate us, Mujaddid of second millenium period was born here in India, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi is from India whom Prophet (saws) declared imam of coming centuries when his soul met him, don't you ever underestimate us
Fraudsters brainwashing to keep their people from using their brains. Open ur brain kid.
😂 Wth is this guy even saying? Which English dialect is he speaking
Omgggg
It's amazing what people people you meet..and just having the privilege to learn from them is a great gift just like our sweet shaykh hamza yusuf and his family ❤❤
Sheikh is always on top of his job. Mash Allah
@@zainullahjan9661 🫀❤️
Before criticising any well-renowned scholar, i must recommend that listen to that scholar at least for 200 hours. Then you understand, when he explains something, from where he is from.
You spoke in the language of the wise ❤️🫀
Hanfi malyoons are always lost and they will make you astray...Islam is not complicated...it is so simple but it is hard to follow that straight path of simplicity, which is the test in this dunya....These Malyoons are fabricated 100%...
Absolutely true
Imagine 200 with Qur’an
Please Pray For MUSLIMS UNITY
🤲🏻
آمييين يا رب العالمين❤️🤲🤲🤲
I love ❤️ shaykh hamza walahii the seek of Allah and I understand every word ❤️ 🙏 he said it changes my self 🎉❤❤❤❤❤❤
❤😊
Thanks for distinguishing the tasuwuf of ihlaaq from tasawuf of azwaaq
Shaykh Explained betautifully. I think its a must watch video for every Muslim parent who wants their children to pursue Islamic education. The title doesn't do justice with the video - only talked about South Asia at the end, this video is more than that.
The majority of Indian and Pakistani Ulama do know Arabic very well " Ulama" "Teachers". You cannot expect all students to be well verse in the Arabic language. There are million students in any giving year. And most of them have basic knowledge of Arabic. Not all the students become scholars. As like in past only handful of people become scholars and teachers.
These people don't know who is Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi and Maulana Hussain Ahmad Madani, Arabs used to get nervous when they speak to them...
QamruddinKhan-hf4dn😂cmon does that even make sense? What kind of foolish words is this?
@Jenni-dx1yb first bring forth a seminary like Darul uloom Deoband whose publishing house published tafsirs whose number is more than 250 whose volumes are 2 volumes, 5 volumes 10 volumes and 20 volumes, who wrote commentaries on Bukhari Mus lim Abu Dawood, nasai, ibn majah, muwatta imam malik in 10-20 volumes, whose madrasas are all over the western hemisphere and subsaharan and southern Africa and all over the world, whose missionary organization is world's largest i.e Tablighi jamaat, whose 1 board in Pax stan produces 100,000 huffaz per year, excluding other madrasas in Subcontinent, West and Africa... Achieve this milestone and then come talk to us... Also Google who is Sheikh Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi and fear Allah to speak against such friends of All ah who are so respected that even Rashid Al makhtoum sent private jet to Lucknow to pick up Sheikh and give him award in Dubai, who i respected by almost all scholars in Arab world and mus lim world
❤
❤️🤲🏻
I do not disrespect the people who disrespect Shaykh Hamza Yusuf because his speech is too deep to understand. Someone must have vast knowledge to understand him. He is the only one for this century. Allahu-aAlam.
😂😂
We feel sad for your poor understanding of respecting the scholars. May Allah grant you the ability to understand ilm that is in the simplest form and grant you hidayah to be around the greatest of Scholars like Shaykh Hamza Yusuf and the ability to humble the people who eats the flesh of the scholars
I agree with his statement on indian , pakistani Bangladeshi ulma are not fluent in Arabic.
But when it comes to understanding a classical Arabic book, they are kings... Those who speak Arabic makes Arabs shattered, among them were Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi
@QamruddinKhan-hf4dn
You're wrong if they know Arabic they still very narrow minded in their Hanafi concept, knowing Arabic for the subcontinent, it makes it easy to read Quran other than they are very limited in religious knowledge
@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muhammad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived ji haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget ji haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Pak that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year.... You talk about religious knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mullah Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
@@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muhammad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived ji haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget ji haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Pak that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year, i just mentioned madrasas affiliated to wifaq, Bangladesh and India has many other madrasas as well so we are producing more huffaz than all.... You talk about religious knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mullah Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
@@Mu5tyLaghmani I can understand you are narrow minded Ghair Muqallid who are against taqlid of four imams, show me single scholar like Sheikh Ashraf Ali Thanvi who wrote 1400 books all alone, for the last 400 years show me scholars outside of the Subcontinent who are like Mujaddid alfasani Sheikh Ahmad Sirhindi who is a Mujaddid of second millenium period, Shah Waliullah Dehlvi who himself met with the soul of prophet Muham mad (saws) show me single person like Syed Ahmad Barelvi who revived j haad and because of his movement people in Afghanistan and Subcontinent didn't forget j haad... Show me single University publishing house like Maktaba Darul uloom Deoband whose ulama wrote and published Tafsir of Qur'an that is more than 250 in 20 volumes, 10 volumes 5 volumes etc, show me single madrasa board like wifaq ul madaris in Paxtan that produces hundred thousand huffaz every year.... You talk about religi ous knowledge? Well why whole Arab world study the work of Maulana Abul Hasan Ali Nadvi then? If you think hanafi fiqh is against Qur'an and Sunnah then Deoband has given the book called Ila as sunan by Zafar Ahmad Usmani that showed proof from hadees, if you cry about ji haad, then Mulla Omar is from same Deobandi madrasa that produced t@li baan, when you speak about hadees sheikh zakariya kandhlavi has wrote commentaries on Bukhari Muslim and muwatta, our scholars even wrote commentaries of siha sitta, First think before you say
If you have a mortgage on your only 1 home, do you pay zakat??
Yes
Zakaat isn't a tax , its helping others to self develop , and its a function to detach yourself from your wealth and knowledge , and help others
Salaat is your own personal development to receive from Allah directly
Hence salaat and zakaat are frequently together in the same verses
Nowhere in Quran is zakaat given as a percentage that's made up by the tax men
@faruqfouzia, you don't have to pay Zakaat on the value of the house that you live in.
But otherwise, you do have to pay Zakaat as per the Islamic requirement InshAllah. May all of our wealth be purified via paying Zakaat and be accept by Our Creator Almighty Allah SubhanahuwaTa'ala and to follow Our Beloved Prophet AlaiheSalatoWassalamWa'AlaAali perfect methods ❤❤❤❤❤
@@faruqfouzia
Zakaat isn't a tax , they are lying to you, i.e if you buy a person a fishing rod he can catch their own food instead of begging others for sustenance which nobody likes doing, similarly if your a person with knowledge and teach others it without expecting anything in return, that is the essence of zakaat
They are not understanding the Qur'an Arabic of the Qur'an, Quran defines it's own words and what they mean i.e zakharia and his son Yahya was referred to as zakhiya , from the etymology and root you can clearly understand that zakharia and Yahya helped others to self develop, this action is called zakaat
💕👍
🫀
What are the good materials to teach Arabic in English? So far what I've seen it's just horrible. It's as if the writers are showing off using words that aren't easy to understand, ie modern standard American English. That's why we have such low quality translations of the Quran and Sunnah, confusion is rampant, especially for the average person.
The Madinah Arabic Reader Books 1-8. But you would benefit a lot from having a teacher taking you through it inshAllahu Ta Ala
@@meditationschmeditation5157 can u provide a link for these please?
X
Sects by any other name.