As a Hong Konger raised in Singapore and now back in my homeland, thank you Mr Mahbubani for sharing your wisdom, encouragement to Hong Kong, and contribution to the world.
This is such a prestigious guest. The professor is wise and eloquent, and he always backs up his views with solid evidence and a well-thought-out worldview.
first of all , they should learn well about china history and cultural thoughts.they should build cultural confidence again . They have no idea about China mainland so much.
Hong Kong should stand by the side China, we are the same country, Hong Kong should becoming the China Yuan exchange center for the world. Either you pick China or not picking or stay like now, Hong Kong will be suffering from the west. So either way you are going to be like that. Make a bet all in China our own country! And do more technology innovation don’t focus on Real Estate and stock markets. But technology and advance medical technology.
HK IS standing by China's side!? What makes you think it isnt? HK has no say either way..... HK IS and ALWAYS WAS just a province in China! its just a port city of Guangdong!? HK is barely the size of London!
@@antwangomost of the HK people are but the small amount of the people with more financial abilities, and the rich are not on the side of China. Because most of their money is stored in the west. Chief Executive of Hong Kong, cannot do much, with the real estate giants, and the people under him in the government, either lazy or on the west side. Hong Kong needs to have a strong leadership to change the situation, and also think about how to follow the China lead in this time. All the government people are either lazy or afraid to change. That makes Hong Kong going no where. The West will not let Hong Kong go well, so why not slowly give up the west and fully submit itself to the same direction with China. Otherwise Hong Kong will not go anywhere.
@@toniwhy8415 absolutely agree with you, it's also.not just about the leadership but it's in our mind. We need to own it, believe that there's a better wayand work hard on it. Continuing to play victim is the worst choice to make. It's really time for HKers to step up our game and it's in all of us to do so at a personal level. Tech innovation is also the best way to remain self-sufficient for the years ahead.
No doubt to standing with and by China, after all is our Motherland, admit it. De peg out of the USD? not yet, the status quo is better and the lost of being Financial Center and ranking no less than 3rd make us with system to favor with. Tilting to the West like this small nation is no brainer, after all what's in the pocket besides taxes all around and being a 'good boy' to begin with West and allies?
@@toniwhy8415 rich people in HK are against China? I'm not sure about that. I've heard other vloggers like keybros state the opposite, as alot of their money is based on China.
When you and LKY went to NYC, to confront the Western MSM, they were still independent MSM. Now they all work for the same Entity, a tiny country somewhere in the M-E.
you are right. @5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
Singaporean leaders are good at expressing themselves in English. I can't think of any similar leaders in hk. Since Cantonese is limited outside of hk, not many understand the hk story.
@5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
One People One nation. One Singapore. United we stand. Stay in one piece and not broken pieces. Show the world that you can be trusted & Relied on . HK is a great place of hard working people. HK needs to be proud of it's passed achievement. Grow together. Protect one another. Take pride of who you are to emerge as one of Asia's 10 Tigers. Prof Kishore's Sharings n advices. Take note. You are knock down but Not out. Eagle's flies high against the winds of adversities. Fly higher.
I think he's very right that HK is lacking an articulated person who can argue logically. I felt we are lacking talents in the public sector as well 😢.
@5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
@5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was Cambridge-educated in law, a well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY in Singapore or HK. HK leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, prefer their British colonial master, while those appointed by Beijing are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. In any case, debating with the sinophobic and racist media and press from the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. HK should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West daily, to change the perception of HK. For many years, the Western media & press have misled the world into believing that all Palestinians are Hamas and are terrorists, however unfiltered reporting & witnesses of the atrocities in Gaza from independent journalists & civillians onto TikTok have shifted global perceptions of the Palestinians and garnered global support to free Palestine.
I suggest HK Govt should seriously consider inviting external experts like Dr Kishore Mahbubani, Jeffrey Sachs, Martin Jacques, Richard Wolff, Eric Xun Li and the like mind as our advisor to help navigate HK over this complex geo-political issues with their great international knowlege, wisdom and open-minded.
Open minded 😂😂 Good one. Genuinely gave me a belly laugh, thanks 🙏 But be careful there little pink because you seem to be suggesting Mr Lee and his colleagues in the HK gov aren't selling this properly and we need to import these foreign paid shills to do it. That's pretty disrespectful to the HK gov, could be a breach of the NSL. So watch your step.
Change is required for hong Kong, which is taking place gradually Its the mindset of her people and people round the world to change esp the western countries to accept her new role in the world, No wars, no sanction, And this is change that all countries work hard to achieve
6:56 The man gave you the answer: Find smart and articulate leaders like Pm Yew .... hahahha very very hard to find (his son is also very good but at last he has also retired). But the anchor wants to be spoon-fed
Exactly. @5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
I disagree. No matter how hard HK try, HK is always going to be viewed as part of Greater Bay Area without independence. Don’t waste time waging PR against this reality. The ugly British Union Jack no longer flies over HK and all its allies will never return their posture to their past position. Instead leverage the huge market and technology behind you, evolve the HK identity and figure out what is the new HK story rooted in the spirit under the Lion Rock. HKers have been evolving this tiny island amazingly over a hundred years. They can do it again. Have arrogance to sing, not despair to beg.
Exactly. @5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated in law, well-articulated leader, and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY in Singapore or HK. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
Chinese are unfortunately not very good in debate, whether in English or in Chinese. Ironically, Lee Kuan Yew was an exception, not only good, but he could shot down any attack from reporters. Apart from his language skills, he had self-confidence.
Hongkong has a bigger population than Singapore. Of course it is possible. You have just to encourage the talented to go into government, rather than making big bucks in business. How will you do it?
@@keffinsg it's not about number of talents but identity politics. By nature, among these a-kissing group in HK Gov to the Central Gov in the north, none of them shares anything like Mr LKY. However, they earn much more than Mr Lee.
Yes, that is my sentiments exactly. @5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY. Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
Unfortunately, American politics is not a Darwinian struggle. Like the free market theory, a Darwinian battle needs a set of assumptions. If master groups control and determine the winners, it is not a struggle. It leads to a mediocre society. Regarding what Hong Kong can do, your opportunities are just outside your windows; China in your backyard is your future. Looking East and speaking Putonghua is a necessary step..
Very unfortunate the moderator did not push further on the many points Prof Kishore has elucidated (if one noticed, he appeared to go thru the points or the talking point) .. it would have been more remarkable if this interview is done by Assoc Prof Brian Wong who has a primordial style to extract the best of the interviewed person …. HK needs to go into the “lion’s dens” … nothing in the periphery… + above all the interviewer seems to be in a rush with his questions to Prof KM trying to go nowhere … 😂
Could have spent more time on HK. How HK should reorientate itself within China and outside China? Unlike SG,it can deal with other gov directly, you have to go thru Beijing. Like what Kishore said get some good diplomats to sell HK.
Simply put, with a population of 7 million, Hong Kong should focus on its own role and what it can and should do, rather than trying to address the issues of the entire 8 billion. Viewing things through the lens of “yellow,” “blue,” or any other color is misguided, impractical, and ultimately meaningless.
I mean as a HKer... my thought is, why are we always asking questions, relying on others to give us answers? That's why we don't have any talents in politics because we always rely on other great minds to spoonfeed us, I mean what chance do we have if we remain this way? STEP UP guys! Think for ourselves, find the answers ourselves, and STOP PLAYING VICTIM! Own it!!!
talent in politics? do you mean the atrocity riots? HK need brains for business, economy and world' stage diplomacy amid China influencing, not politics. Have you not witness the low cuss and classed politics on the street daily, ? pathetic.
@@justineesun3396 I agree with your view about those during the riots but I don't mean that, I mean proper diplomacy training especially for government reps. We need better awareness and leaders like Lee Kuan Yew who can find the balance and are not intimidated by the West. Business and economy are important and we're not short of talents in those fields, but we need to diversify e.g. in tech innovation.
He should talk with Mehdi Hassan if he dares. That would be something to watch. But seeing what happen to Victor Gao, everybody has figured out the weak point of China apologists
As if that would ever be allowed. RTHK has been completely gutted since the NSL from top to bottom. It's no better than CGTN now, only propoganda is permissable not genuine debate.
He is a goddamn class A asshole. And if you looked back into history.. you would see what has happened to HK... and their people that were sent abroad to protect themselves... And him.. being of Indian heritage... is acting so sanctimonious as well.... And it is him, that is not aware of what needs to be done? I wish I went back to hellp HK... cos it is people like him.. manipulating the English language to send those kind of perception across the world.... So, they have been plotting with the North... as part of BRICS ?... And you think that does not alienate Japan, or South Korea... who is quite close to the older chinese as well ? When you see individuals from Fuijian.. runs off into Malaysia... and also Singapore as well.. and manipulating the laws... and whatever... and forcing illegal situation to occur... Do you not think that is quite badly done ?.... What happened with Russia should NEVER have happened.. .and you can see that Singapore had a foot in this. Same as Malaysia as well. Both region had actual British investments in them. BP has oil in Malaysia... and in SG... what he is saying is actually very very sanctimonious.... absolute trash can. When you see HSBC being manipulated and dominated by many an actual Pakistani and Indian management... you know that something is wrong here... Very wrong. And all of those so called accountancy firms as well.. across Europe... as well as into Pakistan... all dominated by Mazar. While the likes of PWC falls over.. and yet, Mazar doesn't ? It isolates itself ? Why ?? So India and Pakistan is wanting a foot in the door blocking the Middle Eastern situation and indirectly forcing the UK to kowtow as well ?..... Wow indeed... And now the rise of Nazism is on the go here in Europe as well... And yet, so many ignorant HK citizens have rushed to the UK, even when Europe is at war. THIS is the indirect effect of the actions in SE Asia... forcing situations to happen in the European areas !
poor interview, tvb has wasted this great opportunity for having krishnan on their show. the host has not allowed he aswered the question in full, then hurryingly goes to next question. HK people has yet to learn the importance of details not only everything must be fast.
the interview is getting bored by this Kishore, repeating the same stance while he lauded the success of China and geopolitical what's not? after all, ain''t too brainy to talk any thing else, Bring in George Yeo!!
I just can’t stand the politically correct way to introduce the titles of a guess, maybe just few recognizable titles, too much always feel like kissing ass. In this caseI do not mean Mr. Kishore through most of his interview he is a humble guy.😅
Look at the difference between India and Hong kong which is the same under British rules. Hong Kong Chinese worked hard with Chinese ideology and characteristics which they developed well compared Indians today
Talk is cheap, in especially when one small nation is tilted to the West, amid that HK will flow to volatility , the backing of China, and the influence of value will prevail and take HK out of the wood. When One economy is dependent on 'taxes economies' let's see if the tilt to the West shall pay off after many Asian Nations are now finding footing with China growth, continually.
Hong Kong wants to do business with all countries in the world. Hong Kong is one of the very few places where the US scores a trade surplus. And a big one. It's the countries which have been imbued with overt or covert agenda, that want to take China down, using HK as a leverage.
@@WWLooi-js8rl Whether you like it or not, the fact of the matter is, "Data is combined for the 7 member countries of the G7 that accounted for 25.8% of Global GDP in 2023, and 14.2% of global GDP growth in the past 10 years (2013-2023)."
Singapore has tons of US military hardware, that include, the soon to be delivered in a few years' time, F35. Singapore allows USN to use its naval base at Changi. Singapore is situated at the choke point of the Malacca Strait. Those are the huge differences between Hong Kong and Singapore.
As a Hong Konger raised in Singapore and now back in my homeland, thank you Mr Mahbubani for sharing your wisdom, encouragement to Hong Kong, and contribution to the world.
好有國際經驗的嘉賓，非常資深，可能現世上為數不多有成熟經驗看清複雜國際形勢的学者。👏👏
This is such a prestigious guest. The professor is wise and eloquent, and he always backs up his views with solid evidence and a well-thought-out worldview.
Thank u sir, for sharing with us your wisdom,
Amazing interview, awesome guest, don’t expect to see him in TVB😂 just like him as always. And good job, TVB.
Bravo. and that is a huge guest.
Great interview with a Great man. Thank you.
One lesson for HK to learn, a deep sense of allegiance to its country.
first of all , they should learn well about china history and cultural thoughts.they should build cultural confidence again . They have no idea about China mainland so much.
馬凱碩是對東亞事務的國際地緣政治專家，絕對的知識淵博、及其出色的外交家🎉新加坡的外交正常非常理性且明智，馬凱碩在國際論壇上与美國政治人物、學者的辯論非常非常精彩，強烈建議觀看
他在Asia Society的演讲和分析很值得一听. 在油管能找到， 题目是The United States, China, and the Future of the Global Order
Excellent conversation.
真的很難得能邀請到馬凱碩上來，但只有20分鐘，主持又問咁多問題，每個問題都無法深入討論，建議觀眾可以去看馬凱碩的其它訪問，會收獲更多❤
不愧是大智慧家 一针见血的说明一切 👍
Great interview Eugene!
十分得著，這個訪問可以解開不少香港人的迷思。 👍
香港人对西方有天然的亲近感。跪舔太久了 他们也不敢硬起来了
Kishore always give fare comment. Love him.
Yes, Hong Kong should open for world's talent by providing attractive incentives
Wellcome
Kishore
Jeffrey Sachs
Martin Jacques
👍👍👍
Martin Jacques is a shit he hates China..
Cyrus Janssen is also a good commentator and UA-camr.
And George Yeo..
3:09 Kishore gave a gentle tap on the heads of some people, trying to make them wake up from their unwarranted adoration of their ex colonial master.
Powerful insight.
Applaud .
28/9/24
We need to extend this interview to at least an hour.. or 2 hours if possible
Hong Kong should stand by the side China, we are the same country, Hong Kong should becoming the China Yuan exchange center for the world. Either you pick China or not picking or stay like now, Hong Kong will be suffering from the west. So either way you are going to be like that. Make a bet all in China our own country! And do more technology innovation don’t focus on Real Estate and stock markets. But technology and advance medical technology.
HK IS standing by China's side!? What makes you think it isnt? HK has no say either way..... HK IS and ALWAYS WAS just a province in China! its just a port city of Guangdong!?
HK is barely the size of London!
@@antwangomost of the HK people are but the small amount of the people with more financial abilities, and the rich are not on the side of China. Because most of their money is stored in the west. Chief Executive of Hong Kong, cannot do much, with the real estate giants, and the people under him in the government, either lazy or on the west side. Hong Kong needs to have a strong leadership to change the situation, and also think about how to follow the China lead in this time. All the government people are either lazy or afraid to change. That makes Hong Kong going no where. The West will not let Hong Kong go well, so why not slowly give up the west and fully submit itself to the same direction with China. Otherwise Hong Kong will not go anywhere.
@@toniwhy8415 absolutely agree with you, it's also.not just about the leadership but it's in our mind. We need to own it, believe that there's a better wayand work hard on it. Continuing to play victim is the worst choice to make. It's really time for HKers to step up our game and it's in all of us to do so at a personal level. Tech innovation is also the best way to remain self-sufficient for the years ahead.
No doubt to standing with and by China, after all is our Motherland, admit it. De peg out of the USD? not yet, the status quo is better and the lost of being Financial Center and ranking no less than 3rd make us with system to favor with. Tilting to the West like this small nation is no brainer, after all what's in the pocket besides taxes all around and being a 'good boy' to begin with West and allies?
@@toniwhy8415 rich people in HK are against China? I'm not sure about that. I've heard other vloggers like keybros state the opposite, as alot of their money is based on China.
Should give more time for such a distinguished guest. Learning should not have a time limit, especially with a guest of such extraordinary knowledge.
Singapore has consistently produced men of such talents.
when there is Prof.Kishore, its a must watch video...
Great to have Mahbubani’s presence in this show!
China lackey ?
20:02 地緣政治專家：
李光耀
吳慶瑞
拉惹勒南
Kishore Mahbubani!!! 🌞🖖🏽✌🏽
When you and LKY went to NYC, to confront the Western MSM, they were still independent MSM.
Now they all work for the same Entity, a tiny country somewhere in the M-E.
you are right.
@5:05
Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
very intelligent. have our leaders read his book yet?
My Dean when I took up my MPA in 08-09. Now I've been in public service and entrepreneur through the years.
❤❤❤❤❤
Singaporean leaders are good at expressing themselves in English. I can't think of any similar leaders in hk. Since Cantonese is limited outside of hk, not many understand the hk story.
Kishor is and NEVER was a Singapore Leader.
@@paul291288he was a diplomat
@5:05
Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
One People One nation. One Singapore. United we stand. Stay in one piece and not broken pieces. Show the world that you can be trusted & Relied on .
HK is a great place of hard working people.
HK needs to be proud of it's passed achievement. Grow together. Protect one another. Take pride of who you are to emerge as one of Asia's 10 Tigers. Prof Kishore's
Sharings n advices.
Take note. You are knock down but Not out. Eagle's flies high against the winds of adversities. Fly higher.
I think he's very right that HK is lacking an articulated person who can argue logically. I felt we are lacking talents in the public sector as well 😢.
@5:05
Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
馬凱碩是當今世界為數不多的真正學識淵博且有豐富外交經驗的專家，可惜的是節目時間太短，如果能有充足的時間探討更深層次的問題就更好了
没有旗鼓相当的对手，不可能有深入的探讨，这是一个showcase节目不是学术论坛，这对主持人有点要求太高，尽管主持人已经做的很好给观众一个brief view of马凯硕
@5:05
Lee Kuan Yew was Cambridge-educated in law, a well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY in Singapore or HK.
HK leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, prefer their British colonial master, while those appointed by Beijing are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. In any case, debating with the sinophobic and racist media and press from the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. HK should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West daily, to change the perception of HK. For many years, the Western media & press have misled the world into believing that all Palestinians are Hamas and are terrorists, however unfiltered reporting & witnesses of the atrocities in Gaza from independent journalists & civillians onto TikTok have shifted global perceptions of the Palestinians and garnered global support to free Palestine.
I suggest HK Govt should seriously consider inviting external experts like Dr Kishore Mahbubani, Jeffrey Sachs, Martin Jacques, Richard Wolff, Eric Xun Li and the like mind as our advisor to help navigate HK over this complex geo-political issues with their great international knowlege, wisdom and open-minded.
Open minded 😂😂 Good one. Genuinely gave me a belly laugh, thanks 🙏
But be careful there little pink because you seem to be suggesting Mr Lee and his colleagues in the HK gov aren't selling this properly and we need to import these foreign paid shills to do it. That's pretty disrespectful to the HK gov, could be a breach of the NSL. So watch your step.
👏👏👏👏👏👍👍👍
It's better to have one country one system in order to progress and develop well.
李光耀時代的西方媒體仲有啲良心，宜家啲西方媒體直頭係宣傳機構，同佢哋講都嘥氣
人地係要寫衰你, 搞乜都多鳩餘
隨住時間推移, 香港始終都係馬照跑舞照跳
睇下英國商會班友, 攞到回鄉卡已急不及待北上
Tiktok/UA-cam都愈來愈多香港旅遊Vlog
加埋班BNOer回流潮, 踩香港謊言只會不攻自破
香港老表还系有明白人噶
宣传其实还是重要的，包括大陆在这方面做的都不足。现在是一个很合适的时候，西方传统媒体公信力已经在历史低点了，没多少人看没多少人信。就算纠正不了西方的扭曲观点，我们仍然可以争取大陆香港更好的互相理解，争取大量亚洲非洲北美国家的好感。
Change is required for hong Kong, which is taking place gradually
Its the mindset of her people and people round the world to change esp the western countries to accept her new role in the world,
No wars, no sanction,
And this is change that all countries work hard to achieve
兩位加油！💪
25.9.2024
香港总是喜欢与新加坡比较，新加坡有李光耀家族集权管理，香港只有一群相互算计商人，新加坡可以用国有资产做战略投资，香港利益集团都有自己的背景，无利不起早，大不了学李嘉诚。
点了，香港只认钱
可否加中文字幕呢？
❤🎉
Hong Kong is not Singapore. If Hong Kong cannot be more closely integrated with Chinese mainland, Hong Kong will decline.
No! Hong Kong's role is mean to integrate China to the rest of the world, inward thinking like yours is hurting Hong Kong and China
香港人根本就不和我们融合😢我看大多数香港人对大陆的排斥，至今严重😅
@@MuradAquino 有強大的祖國, 必然會融合, 不是人們的選擇, 大勢所趨, 君不見大把大把的人北上消費旅遊
6:56 The man gave you the answer: Find smart and articulate leaders like Pm Yew .... hahahha very very hard to find (his son is also very good but at last he has also retired).
But the anchor wants to be spoon-fed
Exactly.
@5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
Easy talk then Done.
If the collective west not listen,do your best and leave them in the dark corner!
I disagree. No matter how hard HK try, HK is always going to be viewed as part of Greater Bay Area without independence. Don’t waste time waging PR against this reality. The ugly British Union Jack no longer flies over HK and all its allies will never return their posture to their past position. Instead leverage the huge market and technology behind you, evolve the HK identity and figure out what is the new HK story rooted in the spirit under the Lion Rock. HKers have been evolving this tiny island amazingly over a hundred years. They can do it again. Have arrogance to sing, not despair to beg.
Exactly.
@5:05 Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated in law, well-articulated leader, and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY in Singapore or HK.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
Chinese are unfortunately not very good in debate, whether in English or in Chinese. Ironically, Lee Kuan Yew was an exception, not only good, but he could shot down any attack from reporters. Apart from his language skills, he had self-confidence.
Law training helps
It seems Kishore's main point for success is that you need someone like Mr LKY. Unfortunately, it may not be realistic for HK.
Hongkong has a bigger population than Singapore. Of course it is possible. You have just to encourage the talented to go into government, rather than making big bucks in business. How will you do it?
@@keffinsg it's not about number of talents but identity politics. By nature, among these a-kissing group in HK Gov to the Central Gov in the north, none of them shares anything like Mr LKY. However, they earn much more than Mr Lee.
Yes, that is my sentiments exactly.
@5:05
Lee Kuan Yew was a Cambridge-educated, well-articulated leader and the founding father of Singapore, who wielded tremendous power and credibility, enabling him to challenge the US press. There will never be another LKY.
Hong Kong leaders educated in the West and well-articulated, unfortunately, still in love with their old colonial master, while those appointed by China are, unfortunately, not articulate in English. Debating with the sinophobic and racist media in the US and UK is pointless-they have an agenda. Hong Kong should leverage a powerful tool like TikTok, viewed by millions of young people in the West, to change the perception of HK. TikTok has helped shift perceptions of Palestinians and garnered global support.
As of today, the stock market rebounds and there are so many funds from overseas coming in. These monies speak for themselves.
香港是中國人的驕傲
Don't make me puke.
Unfortunately, American politics is not a Darwinian struggle. Like the free market theory, a Darwinian battle needs a set of assumptions. If master groups control and determine the winners, it is not a struggle. It leads to a mediocre society.
Regarding what Hong Kong can do, your opportunities are just outside your windows; China in your backyard is your future. Looking East and speaking Putonghua is a necessary step..
Hong kong only got administrator not political leader sadly
新加坡有能人啊
Very unfortunate the moderator did not push further on the many points Prof Kishore has elucidated (if one noticed, he appeared to go thru the points or the talking point) .. it would have been more remarkable if this interview is done by Assoc Prof Brian Wong who has a primordial style to extract the best of the interviewed person …. HK needs to go into the “lion’s dens” … nothing in the periphery… + above all the interviewer seems to be in a rush with his questions to Prof KM trying to go nowhere … 😂
Dame can leaning from the number reading want horse is strong in racing about the pass.👨📖
哪三個大師？李光耀和誰？
Kishore is awesome.
Singapore and Hong Kong are fundamentally different.
Kishore basically said : "HK, stop licking the west, you'll be better off facing China and S.E Asia."
唔好意思, 馬教授對政治的觸覺未夠高度, 如果俄羅斯不對烏克蘭進行軍事行動, 現在會如何？這可以追溯到抗美援朝, 當時新中國已成立, 為何要組織“志願軍”渡鴨綠江？可以避免？
Could have spent more time on HK. How HK should reorientate itself within China and outside China? Unlike SG,it can deal with other gov directly, you have to go thru Beijing. Like what Kishore said get some good diplomats to sell HK.
國際視野離不開轉變和適應，消費券令香港高速轉戰電子支付。
但近六個月，很多商舖食店走回頭路，强制客人使用現金，大家覺得香港抗拒轉變的情況下還有未來啦？
Need a better host to explore deeper questions. Too superficial.
香港人需要重新认识中国，学习地缘政治和整个亚洲。
hey, its' kishore mahbubani
Simply put, with a population of 7 million, Hong Kong should focus on its own role and what it can and should do, rather than trying to address the issues of the entire 8 billion. Viewing things through the lens of “yellow,” “blue,” or any other color is misguided, impractical, and ultimately meaningless.
Hong Kong, look into providing HK people , public housing and HK ownership!!!
I mean as a HKer... my thought is, why are we always asking questions, relying on others to give us answers? That's why we don't have any talents in politics because we always rely on other great minds to spoonfeed us, I mean what chance do we have if we remain this way? STEP UP guys! Think for ourselves, find the answers ourselves, and STOP PLAYING VICTIM! Own it!!!
talent in politics? do you mean the atrocity riots? HK need brains for business, economy and world' stage diplomacy amid China influencing, not politics. Have you not witness the low cuss and classed politics on the street daily, ? pathetic.
@@justineesun3396 I agree with your view about those during the riots but I don't mean that, I mean proper diplomacy training especially for government reps. We need better awareness and leaders like Lee Kuan Yew who can find the balance and are not intimidated by the West. Business and economy are important and we're not short of talents in those fields, but we need to diversify e.g. in tech innovation.
HKers are only concerned about making money.
He should talk with Mehdi Hassan if he dares. That would be something to watch. But seeing what happen to Victor Gao, everybody has figured out the weak point of China apologists
As if that would ever be allowed. RTHK has been completely gutted since the NSL from top to bottom. It's no better than CGTN now, only propoganda is permissable not genuine debate.
Kishore, correction, Apple, amazon is now falling no longer world class
就算他 有一天公開 罵新加坡和馬來西亞政府 為什麼要 剷除 馬來亞共產黨。 甚至 有一天 他提倡 或 筑建新的馬來亞共產黨 推翻 現在的 體制。 也是有可能的。
Excellent assessment by professor Kishore Mahbubani. We can only hope that the West is listening.
Chris
In fact, those Americans Kishore met are the ones locked in their own cages...
if nobody want to leaning is not my problem .want im done im follow my study for long time.👨🧑🤝🧑👬let dame done,im look.
那位 新加坡 印度學者 非常支持共產黨和 共產黨 的種種行為。 就算他說 新加坡和馬來西亞 是中國的一部分。 或者他說 他支持中共 在背後 支持伊朗 也门湖賽武裝 黎巴嫩 真主黨 巴勒斯坦哈馬斯 我也不感覺意外。
Damn, I sure hope hosting a Taylor Swift concern hasn’t become a yardstick for success
竟然請到馬凱頭!! 不過佢話印度可以取代英國係咪有太多私人感情因素??
看现在英国的状况，恐怕还真有可能！
其实从理性分析，印度GDP已经是前五，人口也是世界第一，而联合国本来就是国际社会处理共同面临的问题的协商机构，印度是有成为五常的理由的。
但是现实来看，联合国并不是什么民主机构，它就是二战之后美苏瓜分势力范围，互相角力的外交战场。当初中国入五常是因为美国觉得老蒋是自己一挂的，它一拖三想排挤苏联，后来中华人民共和国取代中华民国成为合法代表，一方面是我们自己继承毛泽东农村包围城市打法，让一帮穷兄弟抬进联合国，另一方面美国也早探到口风，可以联手对付苏联。而发展到现在，美国在联合国框架下完全处于下风，则是它完全没有料到的。
总之，联合国五常不是按道理说是怎么样的地方，至少在美苏当初设计的时候就不是，当然现在也不是。而印度人认为目前形势美国需要它，它就可以靠喊话成为五常，这无疑是缘木求鱼，印度入常只能成为一个网络梗，流传在网友的笑料中。在我看来，印度真想入常，其实只有一个途径，那就是通过中国。因为只有中国是希望保留联合国框架而重塑改革联合国的五常国家，不过这样也很难，毕竟五常只要一票就干死你了，这也是印度入常被五常排着队轮流一票否决的笑点所在。
im not clever person, im share in horse racing for long team any county 👨🔑🌊🗝🌊why im never get my income im need to pay rental house nobody support me👨
呢段訪問當參考就得，唔係所有都用得著。因為佢講既野比較企係李光耀時代講，同而家有差別。
1.李光耀訪港時，有人問，港人係咪應該有民主。
當時佢答，香港“deserve",但係唔係所有應得都會有。
即是，李光耀本人都認同香港要有民主，但係現實係唔會有。不過，基本法講到明，香港向普選邁進，都算有法理證明。
2.新加坡俄烏戰爭入面都跟歐美制裁俄國，證明新加坡政治外交都企係歐美，仲講咩東升西降？
3.李光耀時期，新加坡建國已經係威權。香港就呢幾年先有國安法同23條。新加坡“一直都係咁“，香港“呢幾年先有變化”，政治上根本好難有比較。
no wonder all the Hong Kong rich and capable are running towards Singapore . too crowded already. go to China and stay there
是的，你比联合国官员更懂政治和地缘😂
@@MuradAquino 我無咁驕傲。佢講內容係10-20年前就正確。當時中國經濟成長快、李光耀仲在世、兩岸同中美關係無而家咁差。
而家，咪話李光耀，李顯龍都72，中國經濟下行、西方視中國為對手。成個世界都唔同左。
天真，表面。新加坡是左右逢源，軍事靠向美，經濟靠向中，而基本國策偏向中國。美洲、歐洲、亞洲比，亞洲經濟總量遠超美、歐，以中國為首的東盟經濟總量超歐盟接近兩倍，也超越美國(美洲），這不是東升西降嗎？
@@彪英單論“經濟”就比較親華（地理位置同本身星國華人7成），但係如果計埋外交政治，就比較親西。
Hk no longer one country systems...Dictator XJP never allow.
Mahbubani needs to be designated as a foreign agent by the Singapore government, what a tool.
He is a goddamn class A asshole. And if you looked back into history.. you would see what has happened to HK... and their people that were sent abroad to protect themselves... And him.. being of Indian heritage... is acting so sanctimonious as well.... And it is him, that is not aware of what needs to be done? I wish I went back to hellp HK... cos it is people like him.. manipulating the English language to send those kind of perception across the world.... So, they have been plotting with the North... as part of BRICS ?... And you think that does not alienate Japan, or South Korea... who is quite close to the older chinese as well ? When you see individuals from Fuijian.. runs off into Malaysia... and also Singapore as well.. and manipulating the laws... and whatever... and forcing illegal situation to occur... Do you not think that is quite badly done ?.... What happened with Russia should NEVER have happened.. .and you can see that Singapore had a foot in this. Same as Malaysia as well. Both region had actual British investments in them. BP has oil in Malaysia... and in SG... what he is saying is actually very very sanctimonious.... absolute trash can. When you see HSBC being manipulated and dominated by many an actual Pakistani and Indian management... you know that something is wrong here... Very wrong. And all of those so called accountancy firms as well.. across Europe... as well as into Pakistan... all dominated by Mazar. While the likes of PWC falls over.. and yet, Mazar doesn't ? It isolates itself ? Why ?? So India and Pakistan is wanting a foot in the door blocking the Middle Eastern situation and indirectly forcing the UK to kowtow as well ?..... Wow indeed... And now the rise of Nazism is on the go here in Europe as well... And yet, so many ignorant HK citizens have rushed to the UK, even when Europe is at war. THIS is the indirect effect of the actions in SE Asia... forcing situations to happen in the European areas !
He is.
poor interview, tvb has wasted this great opportunity for having krishnan on their show. the host has not allowed he aswered the question in full, then hurryingly goes to next question. HK people has yet to learn the importance of details not only everything must be fast.
the interview is getting bored by this Kishore, repeating the same stance while he lauded the success of China and geopolitical what's not? after all, ain''t too brainy to talk any thing else, Bring in George Yeo!!
I just can’t stand the politically correct way to introduce the titles of a guess, maybe just few recognizable titles, too much always feel like kissing ass. In this caseI do not mean Mr. Kishore through most of his interview he is a humble guy.😅
The difference is HK has no Lee Kuan Yew
nor Singapore will ever produce another LKY.
Look at the difference between India and Hong kong which is the same under British rules.
Hong Kong Chinese worked hard with Chinese ideology and characteristics which they developed well compared Indians today
I am sure mainland Chinese will work in Hongkong.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
已经死硬了
This guy is a superb bull artist.
Talk is cheap, in especially when one small nation is tilted to the West, amid that HK will flow to volatility , the backing of China, and the influence of value will prevail and take HK out of the wood. When One economy is dependent on 'taxes economies' let's see if the tilt to the West shall pay off after many Asian Nations are now finding footing with China growth, continually.
The interviewer is terrible. No charisma and engaging at all.
The longer HK is distance from the G7 Countries, the faster decline HK would.
It is the declinig G7 countries that are screwing HK to slow China down, you got it all wrong!
Hong Kong wants to do business with all countries in the world.
Hong Kong is one of the very few places where the US scores a trade surplus. And a big one.
It's the countries which have been imbued with overt or covert agenda, that want to take China down, using HK as a leverage.
The G7 itself is in decline!
G7 is slowly becoming irrelevant, stop dreaming!
@@WWLooi-js8rl Whether you like it or not, the fact of the matter is, "Data is combined for the 7 member countries of the G7 that accounted for 25.8% of Global GDP in 2023, and 14.2% of global GDP growth in the past 10 years (2013-2023)."
Free Jimmy Lai.
祝長命百二歲，終身監禁
@@michaelchow8023 Today Jimmy Lai tomorrow will be you. 今天黎智英，明天就是你。
No, tomorrow is you@@fromtheoutside37
@@walkerxin3943 Probably your right cause I don't lick balls.
mai Lai mai Lai…..
Singapore has tons of US military hardware, that include, the soon to be delivered in a few years' time, F35.
Singapore allows USN to use its naval base at Changi.
Singapore is situated at the choke point of the Malacca Strait.
Those are the huge differences between Hong Kong and Singapore.
yes. HK has no army.
@@duncankowable
HK has a brilliant police force.
HK also has the brilliant PLA for All Weather Protections.
@@duncankowable 香港有東風洲際導彈系列。